Ylo-Vesse Velvelt's Life Story and Surviving the 'Czech Hell'

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ylo-Vesse Velvelt's Life Story and Surviving the 'Czech Hell' When is the War Over? Ylo-Vesse Velvelt’s Life Story and Surviving the ‘Czech Hell’ Tiina Ann Kirss 1. Introduction: Czech Hell and its Survivors For young Estonian men mobilized into the Nazi Army in 1944 and shipped off to Germany as the second Soviet occupation advanced north and west in the third week of September 1944, the war was far from over. For most, a stint at the Neuhammer military training camp in Poland preceded a long, erratic march to the eastern front, in full consciousness of being cannon fodder, and accompanied by a concentrated first-hand look at war atrocities and civilian bombings. Months later, the following spring, these and other men in Estonian units fighting in Silesia followed orders to retreat. What followed came to be referred to by the newly-minted word kablutamine, a pell-mell, disorganized fleeing westwards, as fast as pos- sible and mostly on foot. For those in the units headed by legendary figures of Paul Maitla1 and Alfons Rebane,2 who had survived one or more Red Army encirclements, the road in May 1945 led through the ‘Czech Hell’. This appalling experience, the culmination of all the harrowing experiences of the preceding months was the outcome of a gamble that the Americans would surely reach Prague before the Russians, thus guaran- teeing freedom and safe passage west. The Russians got to Prague first and Czech partisans and civilians over the ensuing days and weeks com- mitted random acts of retaliatory brutality against the occupying German army. The perpetrators of these brutal acts, including summary executions, made no allowances or acts of clemency to affect the fate of Estonians mobilized into the army that had occupied their homeland. For those marching through the ‘Czech Hell’, the meanings of confusion and helplessness became radicalized. In this paper I will focus on one narrative of remembering the Czech Hell, the life story of Ylo-Vesse Velvelt (born 1926), both in its published (edited) and unedited forms.3 Compared to other Estonian war stories, and other published Czech Hell narratives, it is a modestly told, moderately jovial tale, yet it narrates a passage through the middle of the cauldron. Czech Hell is one framed chapter of Velvelt’s war journey, which lasted exactly one year from the day he shipped off to Germany to his return home to Saaremaa; it is not, however, the story’s dramatic climax. The war is one chapter of a comprehensive account spanning an entire life, most of which was spent in the homeland; the ‘war chapter’ is both set 366 When is the War Over? apart and framed by a holistic apologia pro vita sua that weaves it into a larger pattern. Velvelt’s story allows analytical focus on the periodization and density of a life narrative, and on the perceived agency of the teller. Survival of the Czech Hell was indeed a gamble, a matter of fortunate timing, the discernment of a ‘time window’, and the strategic concealment or revelation of one’s national identity, which with luck and language competence, could be a bargaining chip for one’s life if not freedom. Vel- velt’s story allows the examination of how this agency is narrated in retro- spect. Finally, like many other war stories, and in its very modesty, Vel- velt’s survival story subordinates individual heroism to male bonding: he emerges from the Czech Hell alive because a friend knew how to speak Russian. In the larger history of World War II, the Czech Hell was one local event among many others of its kind, episodes of entrapment, escape, and local chaos which occurred against a canvas of large-scale movements of troops and front lines (Made, 2008, 225). It was a transition, an effect of timing and geography, a composite of the complicated, desperate trajecto- ries of an army in retreat, and the added chaos of an ‘interregnum’ between regimes, releasing both outbursts of euphoria greeting supposed ‘liberation’ and a spate of random as well as concerted acts of revenge. Heino Susi, a ‘Finnish Boy’ who went on to survive the Czech Hell com- pares this drastic culmination of the war journey to the interval between Soviet and Nazi occupations in the summer of 1941. As both Susi (1985) and Lauri Vaska (2004) recount in their memoirs, for Estonian men in the German army, the Czech Hell was one more case of the overall predica- ment of being caught in the middle in ‘someone else’s war’. How long the Czech Hell lasted was variable – from a few days, to some weeks, to months of work, wandering, or imprisonment. In his fictionalized memoir, Heino Taremäe (1921–2000), who was fortunate enough to have time on his side, crossed the Elbe at Melnik before the Soviet troops arrived and blocked the bridge, and moved rapidly west via Chemnitz. He reflects on this stubborn foot-march, once his protagonist has reached safety in the West: ‘There they were, in the little room of a hostel in Heidelberg. They had kept on going indefinitely, westward and westward. Had they finally arrived? What would happen next? All at once the thought seemed very foreign to Mart that tomorrow morning they would not have to get up and go anywhere. Life had proceeded according to a definite plan, consisting of three main parts: walking, obtaining food, and looking for a place to sleep.’ (Taremäe, 1996, 123.) The crucial factor of timing in the passage through the Czech Hell be- comes clearer if one sketches a more detailed chronology of events. On .
Recommended publications
  • London School of Economics and Political Science Department of Government
    London School of Economics and Political Science Department of Government Historical Culture, Conflicting Memories and Identities in post-Soviet Estonia Meike Wulf Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD at the University of London London 2005 UMI Number: U213073 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U213073 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 Ih c s e s . r. 3 5 o ^ . Library British Library of Political and Economic Science Abstract This study investigates the interplay of collective memories and national identity in Estonia, and uses life story interviews with members of the intellectual elite as the primary source. I view collective memory not as a monolithic homogenous unit, but as subdivided into various group memories that can be conflicting. The conflict line between ‘Estonian victims’ and ‘Russian perpetrators* figures prominently in the historical culture of post-Soviet Estonia. However, by setting an ethnic Estonian memory against a ‘Soviet Russian’ memory, the official historical narrative fails to account for the complexity of the various counter-histories and newly emerging identities activated in times of socio-political ‘transition’.
    [Show full text]
  • Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of Contents
    m o c 30 km . s p a m - 20 mi d © Maardu Tallinn Rakvere Kohtla- Sillamäe Narva Kiviõli Järve Jõhvi Keila Tapa Haapsalu Paide Jõgeva Viljandi Tartu Pärnu Kuressaare Põlva Võru Valga Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 2 One of the three Baltic States occupied by the Soviet Union from 1940 until 1991, Estonia has made impressive economic and political progress since regaining independence. Read more. History ................................................................................................................................................................ 2 Estonia, slightly smaller in area than New Hampshire and Vermont combined, is bordered by Latvia, Russia, the Baltic Sea, and the Gulf of Finland. Read more. Government and Economy.................................................................................................................................. 3 Estonia is a mature, stable parliamentary democracy with legislative, executive, and judicial branches, of which the unicameral Parliament (Riigikogu) holds the most power. Its 101 members are popularly elected every four years. Read more. Foreign Policy ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Estonia has good relations with its Baltic neighbors and is a member of the Council of Baltic
    [Show full text]
  • A Spartacist Pamphlet a $1.50 Cdn $1 £ 0.75 US $1 Trotskyism: What It Isn't and What It Lsi
    A Spartacist Pamphlet A $1.50 Cdn $1 £ 0.75 US $1 Trotskyism: What It Isn't and What It lsi L.Y. Leonidov V.1. Lenin and Leon Trotsky, leaders of the Russian Revolution, on its second anniversary in Moscow's Red Square. February 1990 ,"¢~:j~;:~X523 Spartacist Publishing Co., Box 1377 GPO, New York, NY 10116 2 Trotskyism: What It Isn't and What It Is! This article was first published in Spartacist (German We stand with those members and ex-members of the SED edition) No. 14, Winter 1989-90. There are two additions to who defend the gains the working people achieved through the English text, one dealing with the "Trotskyist" revisionists the overthrow of capitalism. We stand for the communism as the political heirs of the London Bureau and the other of Lenin and Trotsky'S Bolshevik Party. with the role played by former American Healyite leader The '''refonners'' in the bureaucracy are promising "so­ Tim Wohlforth against the struggle for authentic Trotskyism cialist renewal." But Stalinism can't deliver any kind of in the U.S. Other minor changes and corrections have also "renewal." As an ideology Stalinism is simply an apology been made. for the rule of the bureaucracy. Its slogans and "debates" are but arguments about how to put the best false face on To the workers of Germany, the policies of betrayal. Without state power, Stalinist ide­ ology is an empty shell, devoid of any relevance to the East and West, and to question of proletarian power. European and other militants The bureaucracy headed by J.
    [Show full text]
  • Rttter"Reuzträger Waffen-Tl
    Stiftelsen norsk Okkupasjonshistorie, 2014 ERNST-GüNTHER KRATSCHMER ~. @Y ß% U 4u!u . t/tb. )H? (~ Die Rttter"reuzträger Ocr Waffen-tl SNO VERLAG K. W. SCHüTZ KG . PREUSSISCH OLDENDORF Stiftelsen norsk Okkupasjonshistorie, 2014ZUM GELEIT Es entspricht einem -echten Bedürfnis, den zusammenhängenden Bericht vom Einsatz der Divisionen der Waffen-H durch eine Schilderung hervorragen­ der Taten -einzelner zu ergiinzcn. Verfasser und Verlag verdi-enen Dank, diese persönlichen Leistungen für die Kameraden aufgezeichnet zu haben. Umfangreiche Forschungsarbeiten erfaßten: 426 Ritterkreuzträger mit allen persönlichen Daten. 400 davon mit den Unterlagen über den Anlaß der Verleihung (2 Brillanten, 24 Schwerter, 70 Eichenlaub). 24 europäische Freiwillige - je zur Hälfte aus West und Ost - wurden /'flHA./th'?r ausgezeichnet. 1:~rrr'~-f' Nahezu die Hälfte aller mit dem Ritterkreuz ausgezeichneten Kameraden 4-7' blieb vor dem Feinde. <Y~ ,6,W? t/- /0 ~ Die verschiedenen BerichterstatDer schildern - jeder aus seinem eigenen 0. /L _I g, I') I!. ., Gesichtskreis heraus - die einzelnen Persönlichkeiten in ihrer Bewährung. J"'·rrr~r~~1 twryn;f Es ist eine alte Erkenntnis, daß Tapferkeit in der Abwehr, auf dem Rück• zug, im Kessel, ohne Aussicht auf baldigen Entsatz, unendlich vid schwerer r!, w1'egt, als im Schwung des erfolgreichen Angriffes. Wir erkennen die ver­ schiedenen soldatischen Typen: den Draufgänger, den Kämpfer mit dem kühlen Blick des ]ägens, den Führer auf der Suche nach einem Ausweg aus scheinbar hoffnungsloser Lage. Ihnen allen sind menschliche Hemmungen und Zagen nicht fremd. Doch gelang es immer wieder, si-e zu überwinden. Aus welchen Triebkräften) Welpl1Schaulicher Fanatismus war es nicht. Viel­ leicht spielte gelegentlich ein gesunder Ehrgeiz mit.
    [Show full text]
  • German Occupation of Estonia During World War II from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Create account Log in Article Talk Read Edit View history German occupation of Estonia during World War II From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Main article: Estonia in World War II Navigation After Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, Army Group North reached Estonia in July. Initially the Germans were perceived Main page by most Estonians as liberators from the USSR and its repressions, having arrived only a week after the first mass deportations from the Contents Baltics. Although hopes were raised for the restoration of the country's independence, it was soon realized that they were but another occupying Featured content power. The Germans pillaged the country for the war effort and unleashed the Holocaust. For the duration of the occupation, Estonia was Current events incorporated into the German province of Ostland. Random article Donate to Wikipedia Contents 1 Occupation Interaction 2 Political resistance 3 Estonians in German military units Help 4 German administrators About Wikipedia 4.1 Generalkommissar Community portal 4.2 S.S. und Polizeiführer Recent changes 4.3 Lagerkommandant Contact page 5 Collaboration 5.1 Estonian Self-Administration Toolbox 5.1.1 Directors 5.2 Holocaust What links here 5.3 Estonian military units' involvement in crimes against humanity Related changes 6 Controversies Upload file 7 See also Special pages 8 References Permanent link 9 External links Page information Data item Cite this page Occupation [edit] Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941. On the same day, Finland was attacked Print/export by the Soviet Union and three days later, on June 25, Finland declared herself to once again be in a Create a book state of war with the USSR, starting the Continuation War.
    [Show full text]
  • German Occupation of Estonia During World War II from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia (Redirected from Occupation of Estonia by Nazi Germany)
    Create account Log in Article Talk Read Edit View history German occupation of Estonia during World War II From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (Redirected from Occupation of Estonia by Nazi Germany) Navigation Main article: Estonia in World War II Main page After Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, Army Group North reached Estonia in July. Initially the Germans were perceived Contents by most Estonians as liberators from the USSR and its repressions, having arrived only a week after the first mass deportations from the Featured content Baltics. Although hopes were raised for the restoration of the country's independence, it was soon realized that they were but another occupying Current events power. The Germans pillaged the country for the war effort and unleashed the Holocaust. For the duration of the occupation, Estonia was Random article incorporated into the German province of Ostland. Donate to Wikipedia Contents 1 Occupation Interaction 2 Political resistance Help 3 Estonians in German military units About Wikipedia 4 German administrators Community portal 4.1 Generalkommissar Recent changes 4.2 S.S. und Polizeiführer Contact Wikipedia 4.3 Lagerkommandant 5 Collaboration 5.1 Estonian Self-Administration Toolbox 5.1.1 Directors What links here 5.2 Holocaust Related changes 5.3 Estonian military units' involvement in crimes against humanity Upload file 6 Controversies Special pages 7 See also Permanent link 8 References Page information 9 External links Data item Cite this page Occupation [edit] Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941. On the same day, Finland was attacked Print/export by the Soviet Union and three days later, on June 25, Finland declared herself to once again be in a Create a book state of war with the USSR, starting the Continuation War.
    [Show full text]
  • Vabariigi 98. Aastapäeva Tähistamine Londonis Ja Bradfordis
    ESTONIAN NEWS - eestlaste ajaleht Inglismaal. www.eestihaal.co.uk Nr. 2358 16. märts 2016 asutatud 1947 VABARIIGI 98. AASTAPÄEVA TÄHISTAMINE 1 Vabariigi aastapäeva LONDONIS JA BRADFORDIS üritused. Vabariigi 2 aastapäeva Londoni mereteemaline EV 98 aastapäev Eesti Vabariigi 98.aastapäeva tähistamine Inglismaal 27.veebruaril Bradfordi Eesti Kodus. üritused. Ligi 70 kaasmaalast koos kohalike sõpradega olid tulnud, et Vastlapäev tähistada Eesti ajaloolist sündmust 1918 aastal. Rahva seas Londonis oli nii noori, kui vanu, kümme neist olid sündinud enne sõda vabas Eestis. Kõige vanem külaline oli 92 aastane. Kohal olid 3 Eesti uudised ka lapsed koos vanematega, noorim neist vaid 11 kuune. 4 English section 5 Kommentaar Sport, Kokakunst Kirjandus 6 Eelseisvad Foto: Ly Tuubel üritused Eesti Vabariigi 98. aastapäev Variku Kooli 5. klassi õpilane, kes Teated toimus 24. veebruaril Westminster laulab Külliki Levini käe all Foto: Kirret Kanna Cathedral Hall’i saalis Londonis. laulustuudios Külliki Lauluaed. Järgmine Eesti Hääl ilmub Saalis olid kenasti kaetud lauad külma toiduga. Aga enne Kontsert algas Eesti Vabariigi Alates 5. eluaastast hakkas ta 7. aprillil 2016 hümni ühislaulmisega. Seejärel käima laulmas ja 7-aastaselt Tartu seda toimus eeskava, mis algas Bradfordi Kodu esimehe Kaastööd ja kuulutused pidas suursaadik härra Lauri Muusikakoolis viiulit õppima. avasõnaga ning millele järgnes palvus Virge (Taul) James´ilt. palume hiljemalt Bambus aastapäevakõne ja “Kristo on sündinud muusik. Ta on Rahvariietes kauaaegsed klubi liikmed Harald Luts ja Endla 28. märtsiks juhatas sisse Londoni tundlik, elegantne ja kauni Lepik teadustasid eeskava. eestlaskonna eestvedaja Tiit lauluhäälega, väga siiras ja Bradfordis sündinud Karin Blakeley ja Reet Järvik laulsid laule Eesti Hääle toimetus on Reigo mälestuseks taasesitatud hurmav esineja”, kirjeldab Levin.
    [Show full text]
  • IN the NEWS Reinforcements from the Barracks Before Returning to Action with the Support of an Assistant Gunner
    the rays of the sun and a circle of atoms and above which a partly visible PDRY flag (Figure 16). This is encircled by the inscription on two scrolls on a red background PEOPLE’S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF YEMEN/ HIGH SUPERIORITY. Reverse: Blank (Figure 17). Size: 51mm diameter; base metal of unknown manufacture. Ribbon: There is no ribbon however the medal is suspended from a 48mm by 18mm plaque bearing the Arabic inscription meaning 10 SEPTEMBER SCIENCE DAY. Figure 17: Reverse of the 10th September Suspension: By a ring and a loop affixed to the top of Science Day Medal. the medal, and by a brooch pin at the rear of the plaque. to conduct a reconnaissance of the battlefield and seek IN THE NEWS reinforcements from the barracks before returning to action with the support of an assistant gunner. Staff Medal of Honor to Staff Sergeant Romesha Sergeant Romesha took out an enemy machine gun team and, while engaging a second, the generator he was using for cover was struck by a rocket-propelled grenade, inflicting him with shrapnel wounds. Undeterred by his injuries, Staff Sergeant Romesha continued to fight and upon the arrival of another soldier to aid him and the assistant gunner, he again rushed through the exposed avenue to assemble additional soldiers. Staff Sergeant Romesha then mobilized a five-man team and returned to the fight equipped with a sniper rifle. With complete disregard for his own safety, Staff Sergeant Romesha continually exposed himself to heavy enemy fire, as he moved confidently about the battlefield engaging and destroying multiple enemy targets, including three Taliban fighters who had breached the combat outpost’s perimeter.
    [Show full text]
  • Olla Eestlased Edasi! Paul Maitla
    Eestlane ära unusta oma langenud sõdureid, kes on andnud oma elu Eesti maa ja rahva eest. Nende kalmukünkad olgu pühad igavesti, ükskõik kus need paiknevad! “Võitleja” toimetus ja talitus Nr. 1 (503) 61. aastakäik ÜLEMAAILMNE EESTI SÕJAMEESTE JA VABADUSVÕITLEJATE HÄÄLEKANDJA aprill/veebruar/märts 2013 Paul Maitla 100 Olla eestlased edasi! Meie, eesti sõdurite peamine mõte oli vähemalt püüda teha kõik, et vaenlane tagasi ei tuleks. Me olime vabatahtlikud ja panime oma au mängu. Minul oli sõ- jas kaitseingel, sest kaks korda on mind müüri äärde viidud mahalaskmiseks, aga Paul Maitla olen pääsenud. tütar Kai “Võitlejat” olen lugenud üsna algusest Tartus Peetri peale, kohe kui Venemaalt tagasi jõud- kirikus isa sin. Postiga ta mulle tuli, väga palju lehti mälestus- läks kaduma, sest postiühendus oli räbal. tahvli all. Kui mina olin Eestis viletsas olukorras, siis aitasid mind mu relvavennad vabast maailmast. Minu lapselapselapse Mari Süda kirjutatud raamat minust sai hiljuti ilmuda samuti tänu toetusele Kanadast. Mu sõbrad välismaal ütlevad, et Eestil pole õiget valitsust. Mis minul lisada: Harald Nugiseks mitmekordsetele ettepanekutele vaata- mata ei ole ükski president minu sõjalisi teeneid millekski pidanud. Lennart Meri andis Eesti Kaitseväe erukapteni ausatme, teistel pole aga mingit julgust olnud. Luurele ei läheks ma neist kellegagi. Minu peale vaatavad meie võimukandjad vil- Lugemissoovitus: Kaks tu. Aga kõige tublim meist neljast rüütliristikandjast, Rebane, on sattunud päris uut raamatut Paul põlu alla... Maitlast. Mina ei ole ka ise väga aktiivne olnud, mis ma, vana mees, torgin ennast sinna, kuhu pole vaja. Olen ennast kümme korda välja vihastanud, aga see ei tähenda ju 27. märtsil möödus 100 aastat rüütliristikavaler Paul Maitla sünnist.
    [Show full text]
  • Eesti Üksustest Wehrmacht'i, Ssi Ja Politsei Ning Relva-Ssi Alluvuses Teise Maailmasõja Ajal
    158 Eesti üksustest Wehrmacht’i, SSi ja politsei ning Relva-SSi alluvuses Teise maailmasõja ajal Komplekteerimisest ja formeerimisest Toomas Hiio Eestikeelne akadeemilis-monograafi line üldkäsitlus Saksa relvajõudude eesti üksuste ajaloost puudub. Põhjalikumalt on vaadeldud soomepoiste ajalugu – kes õieti küll Saksa sõjaväkke mobiliseerimise eest Soome põge- nesid ja hiljem Eestisse naasnutena ikkagi Relva-SSiga liideti – ning üle- vaatlik ajalooraamat on kirjutatud ka eesti idapataljonidest.1 Ilmumas on ülevaade piirikaitserügementidest ja politseipataljonidest Narva rindel 1944. aastal ning mitmeköitelise koguteose oma mälestustega on välja andnud Narva pataljoni veteranid. Ka nende teoste puhul pole enamasti tegemist akadeemiliste uurimustega – ehkki niisuguse ambitsiooniga artikleid või peatükke sisaldab nii mõnigi neist – ja see ei olegi nende raamatute eesmärk. Kirjutamata on veel üldkäsitlus 20. eesti SS-divii- sist ja eesti kaitsepataljonidest/politseipataljonidest. Seda lünka täidavad mõnevõrra vastavad peatükid Inimsusvastaste Kuritegude Eesti Rahvus- vahelise Komisjoni raportite kogumikus „Estonia 1940–1945” (2006),2 kuid need on inglise keeles ja Eesti laiemale avalikkusele seetõttu tund- matud. Alljärgnev artikkel teeb eestikeelse kokkuvõtte selles kogumikus avaldatud eesti üksusi puudutavatest artiklitest, mida on täiendatud ka viimase viie aasta uurimistöö tulemustega. 1 Mart Laar, Peep Pillak, Hain Rebas, Meelis Saueauk, Soomepoisid: Võitlus jätkub: II maa- ilmasõjas Soome armees võidelnud Eesti vabatahtlike ajalugu 1939–2010 ( Tallinn: Grenader, 2010); Eesti idapataljonid Idarindel 1941–1944, toim Andres Adamson (Tallinn: Argo, 2004). 2 Estonia 1940–1945: Reports of the Estonian International Commission for the Investigation of Crimes Against Humanity, edited by Toomas Hiio, Meelis Maripuu, Indrek Paavle (Tallinn: Inimsusevastaste Kuritegude Uurimise Eesti Sihtasutus, 2006). Eesti üksustest Wehrmacht’i, SSi ja politsei ning Relva-SSi alluvuses… 159 Senistest eestikeelsetest üldkäsitlustest tuleb nimetada Toe Nõmme artiklit 1990.
    [Show full text]
  • Tõnis Ritson Toomas Hellat Ja KGB 5
    Tõnis Ritson Toomas Hellat ja KGB 5 TÕNIS RITSON (Toomas Hellati KGBle 1944/45 ülevaade pagulastest sai lõpetatud alles kirjutatud omakäeliste aruannete kahe päeva eest. Võib-olla tõesti kiirus- algus TUNA 1998 nr 1) tati tagant. Seda enam paneb imestama Toomas Hellati mälu, mis säärase hulga Järgnev ülevaade võõrvägedes võidelnud andmeid talletada suutis ja eeluurimis- Eesti ohvitseridest (ERAF, f 129, n 1, s kongi viljastavais tingimusis need kärsi- 24585, II kd, l.23-31) sai Hellatil valmis tute võimurite tarvis paberile jäädvustas. 16.02.1945 ning see on tema oma käega Muud kirjandust sirvides saab aga ikka- kirja pandud ülestunnistuste seas kõige gi selgeks, et terve rida ohvitsere, ka kõr- napisõnalisem. Vahest siis sõjaväelasli- gemaid, on nimetamata. On siin tegemist kult konkreetne, koosnedes suuremalt juhusliku unustamise või kindla suundu- jaolt vaid viidetest varemöeldule. Eks musega? Kui, siis millisega? Ja milleks? seepärast saab ka siinsed märkused teha Väidetavasti (Ülo Jõgi, vt Tuna, 1998, nr lühemad, osutada eelnevaile osadele ja 1, lk 130) püüdis Hellat järjekordselt luu- autori toimikus sisalduvatele mater- reaparaati üle mängida, kuid miks oli jalidele; lühendamise mõttes ka- seejuures vaja võidukaile vägedele veel sutan viimase juures tavakohaselt niisugune ports potentsiaalseid karistus- ainult köite ja lehekülje numbrit. aluseid ehk vaenlase ohvitsere ette söö- Täitmist vajavat nimekirja pole ta? Küsimused tahaksid vastuseid, asi autorile siin ette antud, 129 nime vääriks põhjalikumat uurimist. puhul on järgitud alluvusvahekor- di ülemused ikka kõigepealt, Kirjaviis on jäänud muutmata, ka ko- nagu kord ja kohus ja (luure)- madega pole siin eriliselt patustatud, ohvitserile sünnis. Kidakeelsuse milline pisipuudus eelnevate osade juu- põhjus on ilmne, pikk ja põhjalik res veidi arusaamist häiris.
    [Show full text]
  • Contested Histories in Public Spaces: Principles, Processes, Best Practices Contested Histories in Public Spaces Principles, Processes, Best Practices
    Contested Histories in Public Spaces: Principles, Processes, Best Practices Contested Histories in Public Spaces: Principles, Processes, Contested Histories in Public Spaces Principles, Processes, Best Practices An International Bar Association Task Force Report Contested Histories in Public Spaces Principles, Processes, Best Practices February 2021 International Bar Association 4th Floor, 10 St Bride Street London EC4A 4AD T: +44 (0)20 7842 0090 F: +44 (2)20 7842 0091 [email protected] www.ibanet.org © International Bar Association 2021 Cover image: A statue of Winston Churchill in London’s Parliament Square is defaced for a second day, amidst Black Lives Matter protests in June 2020. © Ben Thornley/Shutterstock Contents In Memoriam 6 Task force members/special advisers/researchers & writers/research assistants 7 Preface by Co-Editors 11 Introduction: What time is this statue? 13 Case Study I: Toppling Edward Colston 19 Edward Colston Statue, Bristol Case Study II: Litigating Robert E Lee 51 Robert E Lee Equestrian Statue, Charlottesville, Virginia Case Study III: Why Rhodes fell 73 Cecil Rhodes Statue, University of Cape Town, Cape Town Case Study IV: Politics of former slave ports 97 Signage and Street Names, Nantes and Bordeaux Case Study V: Colonial legacies in Senegal 125 Louis Faidherbe Statue, Saint Louis Case Study VI: Red Army as liberator or occupier? 147 Bronze Soldier Memorial, Tallinn Case Study VII: Commemorating ‘comfort women’ 175 Statue of Peace: Asia, America, Europe Case Study VIII: Contested history of a founding father 199 Langevin Block, Ottawa Case Study IX: Re-thinking Christopher Columbus 223 Monument to Cristóbal Colón, Buenos Aires Case Study X: James Cook through Indigenous eyes 249 Botany Bay Memorial, Sydney Conclusion: Principles, Processes, Best Practices 277 In Memoriam Edward Mortimer, CMG 1943-2021 The Task Force acknowledges the significant contributions of Edward Mortimer to this volume of case studies and to the broader Contested Histories in Public Spaces project.
    [Show full text]