• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Noname manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Young and Intermediate-age Distance Indicators Smitha Subramanian · Massimo Marengo · Anupam Bhardwaj · Yang Huang · Laura Inno · Akiharu Nakagawa · Jesper Storm Received: date / Accepted: date Abstract Distance measurements beyond geometrical and semi-geometrical meth- ods, rely mainly on standard candles. As the name suggests, these objects have known luminosities by virtue of their intrinsic proprieties and play a major role in our understanding of modern cosmology. The main caveats associated with standard candles are their absolute calibration, contamination of the sample from other sources and systematic uncertainties. The absolute calibration mainly de- S. Subramanian Kavli Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics Peking University, Beijing, China E-mail: [email protected] M. Marengo Iowa State University Department of Physics and Astronomy, Ames, IA, USA E-mail: [email protected] A. Bhardwaj European Southern Observatory 85748, Garching, Germany E-mail: [email protected] Yang Huang Department of Astronomy, Kavli Institute for Astronomy & Astrophysics, Peking University, Beijing, China E-mail: [email protected] L. Inno Max-Planck-Institut f¨urAstronomy 69117, Heidelberg, Germany E-mail: [email protected] A. Nakagawa Kagoshima University, Faculty of Science Korimoto 1-1-35, Kagoshima 890-0065, Japan E-mail: [email protected] J. Storm Leibniz-Institut f¨urAstrophysik Potsdam (AIP) arXiv:1709.07265v1 [astro-ph.SR] 21 Sep 2017 An der Sternwarte 16, 14482 Potsdam, Germany E-mail: [email protected] 2 Smitha Subramanian et al. pends on their chemical composition and age. To understand the impact of these effects on the distance scale, it is essential to develop methods based on differ- ent sample of standard candles. Here we review the fundamental properties of young and intermediate-age distance indicators such as Cepheids, Mira variables and Red Clump stars and the recent developments in their application as distance indicators. Keywords stars: distances, stars: variables: Cepheids, stars: AGB and post-AGB, stars: horizontal branch stars, Cosmology: distance scale 1 Introduction Distance to celestial objects is one of the key astrophysical parameters. Measure- ments of many fundamental properties, such as luminosities, masses, sizes and ages, depend on distances. Moreover, distance measurements play an important role in our understanding of modern cosmology. We have various methods based on geometrical, semi-geometrical, photometric and kinematic methods, to estimate the distances to celestial objects. Each method has limited range of applicability, such as the radar techniques for solar system objects, parallax methods for stars within a few kpc, Cepheids standard candles to a few Mpc and Type Ia super- novae to several 1000 Mpc. So each method which makes each rung in the distance ladder, is used to calibrate the next most distant method. This approach enables us to determine the scale of the Universe. The parallax method of determining distance is the most direct and funda- mental to all others. As the Earth revolves around the Sun, there is an apparent change in position of nearby stars with respect to the distant stars. This apparent change in position is a measure of the distance to that object. These distances are purely based on geometrical calculation and no assumptions about the physical or chemical properties of the sources are required. Hence, parallax distances are con- sidered to be highly reliable measurements. However, the parallax measurements of giant stars which have large radius are not very precise. For distant sources, the parallax becomes smaller and this limits the application of parallax method to very nearby objects. Distance measurement using eclipsing binaries, which is based on a semi- geometrical method, can reach up to the edge of the Local Group with an accuracy of 5%. We can measure the sizes of the stars from the velocities and the eclipse durations, the luminosities from the radii and surface temperatures, and the dis- tance to the system from the magnitudes. This requires good modelling of the binary system. For early-type stars, this is a challenge due to the problems with accurate flux calibration and due to the degeneracy between stellar temperature and reddening. For late-type stars, these problems are minimal as very accurate flux calibration is available and accurate measurements of linear and angular sizes are possible. Thus, we can derive a distance which is primarily limited by the ac- curacy with which we can measure the light curve and the radial velocities. Such a distance is completely independent of the usual distance ladder. The most ac- curate distances, to date, to the Magellanic Clouds are estimated using eclipsing binaries (Pietrzy´nskiet al. 2013, Graczyk et al. 2014). Beyond the distances which can be reached using the geometrical and semi- geometrical methods, objects with known luminosity are adopted. They are called Young and Intermediate-age Distance Indicators 3 standard candles and they include Cepheids, RR Lyrae stars, Mira stars and Red Clump (RC) stars. Whereas, Type Ia supernovae are standardisable candle as their luminosities are not known. What we know from nearby Type Ia supernovae is that there is a specific relation between their peak brightness and the time it takes for them to decay (Phillips, 1993). Intrinsically bright supernovae shine longer than faint supernovae. From the ratio of peak to width of their light curve, we can determine their absolute magnitude. Here, we restrict our review to distance indicators whose luminosities are known, which are standard candles. The main problems associated with standard candles are their calibration, selection and other systematic uncertainties. To mitigate these issues, several detailed studies are going on. In this chapter we review the fundamental properties of young and intermediate- age stellar populations such as, Cepheids (15 { 300 Myr), Mira variables (1 { 7 Gyr) and RC stars (2 { 9 Gyr) and the recent developments in their application as distance indicators. 2 Cepheids Since Henrietta Leavitt discovered their Period-Luminosity (PL) relation (Leavitt law, Leavitt & Pickering 1912), Classical Cepheid variables have assumed a funda- mental role as primary distance indicators. The Leavitt law was indeed the crucial ingredient allowing Edwin Hubble to determine the first reliable distance to M31 (Hubble, 1929a). In doing so he established the technique that in short order would lead to the discovery of the eponymous Hubble law (Hubble, 1929b), and modern cosmology. Almost a century later, Cepheids PL relations are still the cornerstone of the cosmological distance ladder. Cepheids in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) and other Local Group galaxies, provide the link between the local universe, distant standard candles (e.g. Supernovae Type Ia) and the Hubble Flow. The Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Key Project on the Extragalactic Distance (Freedman et al., 2001), in particular, tied all this together by delivering the first precise (10% accuracy) determination for the value of the Hubble constant. Despite their importance, Cepheid distances are still challenged by several factors. On the observational side, in addition to the statistical photometric un- certainties related to the measurement of Cepheid's mean magnitudes, the main errors in Cepheid distances are due to interstellar extinction and the systematic errors in the chosen PL relation. These systematic errors are related to the uncer- tainty in the PL slope and zero point, as well as its intrinsic scatter σIS, which in turn is the consequence of PL relations not taking into account the width in temperature of the Cepheid Instability Strip (IS). Due to this intrinsic scatter, PL relations should be really considered as statistical relations that can be correctly applied only to a statistical ensemble of stars, and not to individual Cepheids. As such, when Cepheids are used as galactic tracers to derive the three-dimensional structure of an underlying stellar population, the PL relation σIS becomes the dominant source of error. Instead when we measure the distance of a group of Cepheid stars (such as when using Cepheids to derive the distance of a galaxy used to calibrate the next step in the cosmological distance ladder) interstellar 4 Smitha Subramanian et al. extinction and the empirical calibration of the PL zero point remain the largest uncertainties. The last decade has seen great progress to overcome these limitations, with observations moving towards infrared wavelengths (where extinction is reduced) and the adoption of HST parallaxes for a number of Cepheid calibrators. Great progress has also been made in bringing under control issues regarding the lin- earity of the PL relation, and its dependence on metallicity. This has allowed a new determination of the Hubble constant, anchored on Cepheids, with accuracy better than 3% (Freedman et al., 2012). The adoption of Period-Wesenheit (PW) relations has reduced the uncertainties related to the σIS and to extinction at optical and near-infrared wavelengths, while templates have been produced to al- low greater photometric accuracy even for sparsely sampled Cepheids light-curves. These developments were crucial for allowing Cepheids to assume the important role as galactic tracers described above. In the theoretical arena the outstanding issue directly affecting the accuracy of Cepheid distances is the

Load more

  63

Copy Link