2011 Volume of Additional Information
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Legal Affairs, Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Committee Estimates - 2011 Volume of Additional Information Contents Correspondence from the Leader of the House Copy of correspondence from Hon Judy Spence MP, Leader of the House to Hon John Mickel MP, Speaker, dated 17 June 2011. Copy of correspondence from Hon Judy Spence MP, Leader of the House to Hon John Mickel MP, Speaker, dated 24 June 2011. Copy of correspondence from Hon Judy Spence MP, Leader of the House to Hon John Mickel MP, Speaker, dated 25 July 2011. Minutes of meetings 17 June 2011 19 July 2011 19 July 2011 26 July 2011 Minister for Justice and Attorney-General Questions on notice and the Minister’s answers Documents tabled at the hearing Answers to questions taken on notice at the hearing Minister for Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Questions on notice and the Minister’s answers Documents tabled at the hearing Answers to questions taken on notice at the hearing Correspondence from the Minister dated 25 July 2011 Correspondence from the Leader of the House 17 June 2011 24 June 2011 25 July 2011 Minutes of meetings 17 June 2011 19 July 2011 19 July 2011 26 July 2011 - M I N U T E S - Minutes of a meeting of the Legal Affairs, Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Committee on Friday 17 June 2011 at 1.28pm Present: Hon Dean Wells MP (Chair) Mr John-Paul Langbroek MP (Deputy Chair) Mrs Julie Attwood MP Mr Jarrod Bleijie MP Mr Chris Foley MP Mrs Betty Kiernan MP (until 1.59pm) Apologies: In attendance: Ms Barbara Stone MP Mr Stephen Finnimore, Research Director Ms Amanda Honeyman, Principal Research Officer Hearing schedule: At the meeting, members were provided with two draft hearing schedule options, and copies of all departmental structures, statutory authorities and senior officers of the departments. The Chair stressed that the draft hearing schedules were offered as a basis for discussion only. Discussion ensued. On the motion of Mrs Kiernan, seconded by Mr Langbroek, the committee resolved to adopt the following hearing schedule for the hearing on 19 July 2011 and to authorise its release: PORTFOLIO: TIME: MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL Department of Justice and Attorney- 9.30am – 11.30am General Morning tea 11.30am – 11.45am Department of Justice and Attorney- 11.45am – 1.15pm General Lunch 1.15pm – 2.15pm Department of Justice and Attorney- 2.15pm – 3.45pm General Afternoon tea 3.45pm – 4.00pm MINISTER FOR POLICE AND MINISTER FOR CORRECTIVE SERVICES AND EMERGENCY SERVICES Police 4.00pm – 6.30pm Dinner 6.30pm – 7.00pm Corrective Services 7.00pm – 9.30pm Emergency Services 2 Mrs Kiernan left the meeting at 1.59pm. Ministers’ opening speeches The committee agreed that Ministers should be allowed 5 minutes for an opening speech at the commencement of each portfolio. Timetable Prior to the meeting members were provided with a draft timetable for the Estimates process. Discussion ensued. The timetable was amended to reflect the committee’s pre-hearing meeting on 19 July commencing at 9:00am. On the motion of Mr Foley, seconded by Mr Bleijie, the committee adopted the draft timetable, as amended. Attendance of non-committee members Discussion ensued. On the motion of Mr Langbroek, seconded by Mr Foley, the committee resolved to grant leave for non-committee members to attend and ask questions at the committee’s public hearing on 19 July 2011. Broadcasting of hearing The research director informed members that a meeting of the chairs and deputy chairs held prior to the committee’s meeting had been advised that the broadcasting rules were under consideration and future advices would be provided with a view to a standard, more open approach to broadcasting rules being adopted. The Committee agreed to consider this matter at a future meeting. The Chair requested that the secretariat establish whether computers and internet access will be available to members during the hearing. Adjournment: The meeting adjourned to allow the Committee to consider the Estimates timetable and other issues. Close: The meeting closed at 2:15pm Confirmed this 19th day of July 2011 Hon Dean Wells MP Chair - M I N U T E S - Minutes of a meeting of the Legal Affairs, Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Committee on Tuesday 19 July 2011 at 9.07am Room A.35 Parliament House Present: Hon Dean Wells MP (Chair) Mr John-Paul Langbroek MP (Deputy Chair) Mrs Julie Attwood MP Mr Jarrod Bleijie MP Mr Chris Foley MP Mrs Betty Kiernan MP Apologies: In attendance: Mr Stephen Finnimore, Committee Office Manager Ms Amanda Powell, Research Director Ms Amanda Honeyman, Principal Research Officer Mrs Gail Easton, Executive Assistant Minutes: Prior to the meeting, members were provided with the draft minutes of the meeting held on Friday 17 June 2011, starting at 1.28pm. On the motion of Mr Bleijie, seconded by Mr Foley, the committee confirmed those minutes. Public hearing The Chair reminded members of the following matters relating to the procedures: hearing: • The Chair has the same powers as the Speaker regarding questions – SO 182(5). • As per the committee’s agreement, each Minister may make an opening statement of up to 5 minutes, per portfolio. • Questions may be put to the Minister, a Director-General or a CEO (only those set out in Schedule 7) – SO 181(d). Questions to D-Gs and CEOs should focus on facts and not seek comment on government policy. • Advisors may answer questions referred to them by the Minister, Director-General or CEO – SO 181(f). • Questions may be taken on notice by the Minister only – SO183(1). • Documents may only be tabled by a Minister or witness with the leave of the committee – SO 184(2). • Committee members may table documents without leave of the committee, provided the tabling does not offend the Standing Orders. • Documents tabled at the hearing are deemed to be released by the committee upon tabling unless the Committee expressly directs otherwise – SO 184(3). • Committee deliberations are to be held in private. • The committee had, at its previous meeting, given leave for 2 non-committee members to attend and ask questions, however no members had subsequently indicated that they wished to attend. • A quorum of the Committee is 4 members – s. 91 Parliament of Queensland Act 2001. Broadcast of hearing: Prior to the hearing the members were provided with a copy of the conditions for Broadcasters of Proceedings and Guidelines for Camera Operators in Estimates Hearings. The Chair advised members that since the last meeting of the committee, the Committee of the Legislative Assembly had developed the attached conditions relating to the broadcast of Estimates hearings. On the motion of Mrs Kiernan, seconded by Mr Langbroek, the committee resolved to authorise the broadcast of the hearing and to adopt the attached conditions for Broadcasters of Proceedings and Guidelines for Camera Operators in Estimates Hearings for the hearing. Answers to questions on The Principal Research Officer informed the committee that, under notice: Standing Order 182(8), the Ministers’ answers to the committee’s questions on notice are deemed to be authorised for release by the committee and published upon the commencement of the committee’s hearing, unless the committee expressly orders otherwise. The committee endorsed the full release and disclosure of the Ministers’ answers to the questions on notice. Release of inquiry On the motion of Mr Bleijie, seconded by Mrs Attwood, the documents: committee authorised, pursuant to s. 50 (2) Parliament of Queensland Act 2001, the publication of all documents so far presented to it in the course of its Estimates inquiry and letters from the committee Chair to Ministers. Other business: Members discussed procedural matters relating to the conduct of the hearing. The Chair indicated that he intended to give the call so as to enable a free-flowing line of questioning. Close: 9.19am Confirmed this 26th day of July 2011 Mrs Betty Kiernan MP Chair - M I N U T E S - Minutes of a meeting of the Legal Affairs, Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Committee on Tuesday 19 July 2011 at 3.50pm Room A.35 Parliament House Present: Hon Dean Wells MP (Chair) Mr John-Paul Langbroek MP (Deputy Chair) Mrs Julie Attwood MP Mr Jarrod Bleijie MP Mr Chris Foley MP Mrs Betty Kiernan MP In attendance: Mr Neil Laurie, Clerk of the Parliament Mr Stephen Finnimore, Committee Office Manager Ms Amanda Powell, Research Director Ms Amanda Honeyman, Principal Research Officer Procedural matter Mr Bleijie raised a matter pertaining to the line of questioning of the pertaining to line of Chairperson of the Crime and Misconduct Commission. questioning: The Clerk provided advice on the options available to the committee. Discussion ensued. Close: 3.53pm Confirmed this 25th day of July 2011 Mrs Betty Kiernan MP Chair - M I N U T E S - Minutes of a meeting of the Legal Affairs, Police, Corrective Services and Emergency Services Committee on Tuesday 26 July 2011 at 10.31am Room 5.04a Parliament House Present: Mrs Betty Kiernan MP (Chair) - via teleconference Mr John-Paul Langbroek MP (Deputy Chair) Mrs Julie Attwood MP - via teleconference Mr Jarrod Bleijie MP - via teleconference (from 10.40am) Mr Chris Foley MP - via teleconference (until 10.50am) Ms Carolyn Male MP - via teleconference Apologies: In attendance: Ms Amanda Powell, Research Director Ms Amanda Honeyman, Principal Research Officer Mrs Gail Easton, Executive Assistant Committee membership: Prior to the meeting members were provided with a copy of a letter from the Leader of the House, dated 25 July 2011, advising that Hon. Wells had stepped down as Chair of the committee and that Mrs Kiernan had been appointed as Chair, and Ms Male had been appointed as a member until close of business on 1 August 2011.