42011-013: Wuhan Urban Environmental Improvement Project
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Resettlement Monitoring Report Project Number: 42011-013 January 2018 PRC: Wuhan Urban Environmental Improvement Project Prepared by Tongji University This resettlement monitoring and evaluation report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB’s Board of Director, Management or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA WUHAN URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK LOAN (NO.2647-PRC) RESETTLEMENT MONITORING REPORT (NO.10, AS OF 31 JANUARY 2018) SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT TONGJI UNIVERSITY FEBRUARY 2018 External Independent Monitoring Agency: School of Economics and Management Tongji University Address: Siping Road 1239, Shanghai Postcode: 200092 Team Leader: Wu Zongfa Team Member: Wu Zongfa,Xu Ting,Chen Ping,Liu Zhen,Hu Fang Report Compilers: Wu Zongfa,Xu Ting,Chen Ping,Liu Zhen,Hu Fang TABLE OF CONTENTS 0. Replies to Resettlement Questions in the Memorandum .......................................................... 1 1. PREFACE ................................................................................................................................... 3 2. RESETTLEMENT ........................................................................................................................ 3 2.1 The projects that implemented by the Wuhan New Zone Construction Development Investment co., LTD ............................................................................................................................................. 3 2.2 The projects that implemented by the Wuhan Water Resources Development Investment Group co., LTD ............................................................................................................................................. 4 2.3 The projects that implemented by the Wuhan Jianxing Infrastructure Construction co., LTD ........... 4 2.4 The projects that implemented by the Wuhan Urban Drainage Development Co., Ltd. ................... 5 3. PROJECT IMPACT .................................................................................................................... 10 3.1 New Zone Project ................................................................................................................. 10 3.2 Yangchun Lake Project .......................................................................................................... 10 3.3 Sludge Subcomponent .......................................................................................................... 10 4. RESETTLEMENT PROCESS AND PROGRESS ........................................................................... 11 4.1 Resettlement Process ........................................................................................................... 11 4.2 Resettlement Progress .......................................................................................................... 14 5. LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT POLICIES ............................................................... 18 6. IMMIGRANT REVENUE RECOVERY .......................................................................................... 18 7. THE RESET AND RECONSTRUCTION OF BUILDINGS ............................................................... 21 7.1 Resettlement Progress .......................................................................................................... 21 7.2 Sample Households .............................................................................................................. 24 8. INFRASTRUCTURE RECOVERY ............................................................................................... 29 9. RESETTLEMENT COMPENSATION FUNDS ............................................................................... 29 10. PARTICIPATION AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE ........................................................... 30 11. ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT ................................................................................ 30 12. MONITORING AND EVALUATION ....................................................................................... 31 13. CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION .................................................................................... 31 13.1 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................... 31 13.2 Suggestion ......................................................................................................................... 32 14. APPENDIX ........................................................................................................................ 32 14.1 Interview Record ................................................................................................................. 32 14.2 Compensation and Resettlement Policies for House Demolition on Collectively-owned Houses of Yangchun Lake Community (Changqian village) of the Donghu New City project .............................. 39 14.2.1 Identification of Housing Area and Legitimacy ............................................................. 39 14.2.2 Monetary Compensation ........................................................................................... 39 14.2.3 Physical Compensation ............................................................................................ 40 14.2.4 Rules of House Choosing .......................................................................................... 40 14.2.5 Bonus ..................................................................................................................... 41 14.3 Compensation and Resettlement Policies for House Demolition on Collectively-owned Land of “Village-in-city” Reconstruction in Laoguan Village, Jiangdi Street, Hanyang District, Wuhan City ...... 41 i 14.3.1 Identification of House Legitimacy .............................................................................. 41 14.3.2 The compensation for relocation ................................................................................ 43 14.3.3 The compensation for attachments and other compensation ........................................ 43 14.3.4 Rebuilding placement ............................................................................................... 44 14.4 Resettlement method for Beiyangqiao viillage of Yangchun Lake ............................................. 46 14.5 Resettlement method for Baimazhou viillage of Yangchun Lake .............................................. 49 0. Replies to Resettlement Questions in the Memorandum LOAN 2647-PRC: WUHAN URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT REVIEW MISSION (19–23 September 2016) Replies to Related Resettlement Questions 13. The mission visited project sites and discussed with EA and IAs regarding the implementation issues of land acquisition and resettlement. So far, all permanent land acquisition and house relocation have been completed except house construction in two resettlement sites which are ongoing. A total of 1,795 mu lands were permanently acquired or transferred and 57,009 m2 houses/buildings were demolished, which affected 183 households or 542 persons. The mission was advised that so far a total of CNY1.37 billion of land acquisition and resettlement fund has been disbursed. Given the inconsistencies of resettlement costs in the latest resettlement monitoring report, the EA should double check each item of land acquisition and resettlement costs and provide more accurate land acquisition and resettlement costs in next project progress report. Reply: Land acquisition and resettlement costs is 1.4712 billion yuan. 14. Component 1: Integrated sludge treatment and disposal. Given the proposed locations for the new sludge treatment plants in Sanjintan WWTP and Huangjiahu WWTP will be constructed inside the existing WWTPs, the EA prepared and submitted a due diligence report on land acquisition and resettlement for the proposed changes to ADB in early 2016. For Huangjiahu WWTP, 800 m2 buildings within the environment buffer zone of sludge treatment plant were relocated as indicated in the resettlement due diligence report. The mission visited the sites of two new sludge treatment plants respectively in Sanjintan WWTP and Huangjiahu WWTP, and noted that both sites are ready for construction. Reply: Land acquisition and resettlement work of component 1 has be completed. 15. Component 2: Wuhan New Zone lakes and channels rehabilitation and pumping station. According to the approved changes in scope and updated resettlement plan, Longkou, Longxin and, Zhujiaxin Channel rehabilitation subprojects are dropped out of ADB financed project, The ecosystem rehabilitation project for Longyang Lake, Moshui Lake and Nantaizi Lake only affects state-owned land of one state-owned fishing farm and no people or livelihoods were affected. A total of 43 households in Laoguang village were demolished in September 2014 due to construction of Sixin pumping station. The mission was advised the resettlement site of Laoguang village is located at the intersection of Sixinzhong Road and the 3rd Ring Road, the construction site 1 and resettlement apartments commenced construction in July 2015 and