W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 1 -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 25 TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2012
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE H.G.RAMESH
WRIT PETITION Nos. 67325-67377 OF 2012 (EDN-AD)
BETWEEN
1. PRADEEP N. ACHARI AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHERUGARKERI, TQ: BHATKAL DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
2. NITHIN B. HARIKANT AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. KURIGADDE, TQ: KUMTA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
3. SACHIN RAJU HARIKANT AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. AGASUR, TQ: ANKOLA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
4. SUNIL MESTHA AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHIRUR, TQ:KUNDAPUR DIST: UDUPI
5. DURGESH P. NAIK AGE: 22 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. TATTIHAKKAL, TQ: BHATKAL DIST:UTTAR KANNADA
6. RAGHEVENDRA G. NAIK AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHIRALI, TQ: BHATKAL DIST:UTTAR KANNADA
1 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 2 -
7. VINOD MARUTI DEVADIGA AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. GURDHAGHDA MURUDESHWAR TQ: BHATKAL, DIST:UTTAR KANNADA
8. BHARATH S.A. AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. VIDYANAGAR, TQ: SHIKARIPUR DIST: SHIMOGA
9. GAJENDRA NARAYAN MUDANAGI AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. MOODANGI, TQ: KUMTA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
10. SACHIN NARAYAN NAIK AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.MURUDESHWAR, TQ: BHATKAL DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
11. FRANK ROSHAN R. FARNADES AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. KALBHAG, KUMTA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
12. KAMALAKAR ,./ BHANDARI AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. KARIKODI, HONNAVAR DIST: UTTAR KANNADA
13. SUNNI LAWRENCE FERNANDES AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. HALL BHAT, YEDTHER BYANDUR KUNDAPUR, DIST: UDUPI
14. ANNAPPA KORGA NAIK AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SARPUNKATTE, TQ: BHATKAL DIST:UTTARA KANNADA
15. SUBRAMANYA RAVINDRA SHET AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. ROYAL KERI, TQ: HONNAVAR DIST:UTTARA KANNADA
2 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 3 -
16. RAGHAVENDRA V. BHAT AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. AROLLI, MUGVA POST TQ:HONNAVAR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
17. UMESH M. POOJARI AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. POOJARI MANE KARAVALI TQ:KUNDAPUR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
18. ADARSHA KRISHNA BHAIRUMANE AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. AKSHAYA NILAYA MAVINAKATTE BENGRE TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTAR KANNADA
19. YOGESH VENKATAYYA DEVADIG AGE: 23 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. BENGAEREMAVINAKEATTE TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
20. BHASKAR NAGAPPA HARIKRANT AGE: 22 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. DHARESHWARA MATHA KUMTA TQ, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
21. SACHIN S/O KULKARNI AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.NAGAVALLI, TQ: SAGAR DIST:SHIMOGA
22. PRASAD SUDHAKAR SHAT AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. RNS HOSPITAL QUARTERS TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
23. RAGHAVENDRA T AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. MADUTHONSE TQ & DIST: UDUPI
24. SHANTIBHUSAN M. NAIK AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. GOTEGALI, KARWAR TQ & DIST: KARWAR
3 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 4 -
25. ANIL R. NAIK AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. ANILGOD, TQ:HONNAVAR DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
26. PRAVEEN M.K. AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. S. MALLAPUR TQ:HONALI, DIST: DAVANGERE
27. SHIVAKUMAR H AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. HALGER, NALLUR POST TQ: SRINGERI, DIST: CHIKKAMANGALUR
28. SUHAS B.H. S/O. HARESH B.K. AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. CHAKRANAGAR TQ: HOSANAGAR, DIST: SHIMOGA
29. VINAYAK N S/O. SIDDAPPA T AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHANTINAGAR, TQ: SHIKARIPUR DIST: SHIMOGA
30. NAIK PRAVEEN KUMAR CHANDU AGE:20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. H. NO./ B/7/5, JANATA QUARTERS BHUTE BHAT, VASCO DE GAMA GOA
31. JAMEEL SHAIKH AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. NEAR MUTTON SHOP HONNAVAR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
32. ANISH A S/O. ANWAR HUSSAIN AGE: 21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. GUMMAHAKKAL, SHIRALI TQ: BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
33. SONALI S. MANGEKAR AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. TUNGA BLOCK, RAILWAY STATION QUARTERS, TQ: KARWAR
4 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 5 -
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
34. MILLAN SURESH CHANDEKAR AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. DANDEBAG TQ: KARWAR DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
35. CHODUNKAR SUMUKH SANTOSH AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.PORVRIM, TQ: BARDEZ DIST:NORTH GOA
36. DASSAI JAYAKRISHNA JAGANATH AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.PORVORIM, TQ: BARDEZ DIST:NORTH GOA
37. AMITH FARNANDIS AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. C-27/3, K.P.C. COLONY KARGAL TQ: SAGAR, DIST: SHIMOGGA
38. JAYARAM GOPAL SHETTY AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. MADDODI, TQ: BYANDUR DIST: UDUPI
39. HARISH NAGARAJ KHARVI AGE:22 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.MAVINAKONE, BUNDER BHATKAL TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
40. JITENDRA SUBRAY NAIK AGE:21 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. HEBLE TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
41. MAHESH M. NAIK AGE:20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. KEREGUDDE TQ:BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
42. GANESH PRASAD AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. UPPUNDA
5 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 6 -
TQ: KUNDAPUR, DIST: UDUPI
43. NAGARAJ SHANKAR HARIKANT AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. BASTI, NEAR ARUNODAYA HOSPITAL, TQ: BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
44. MOHAN MARUTI DEVADIGA AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHIRALI, TQ: BHATKAL DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
45. GANGADHAR RATNAKAR NAIK AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.NIRGADDE, MUNDALLI POST TQ: BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
46. GANJANAN VENKATESH GAVADI AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. VAUGEVLI, TQ: KUMTA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
47. PRITESH PANGA NAIK AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. KAVLE-GOA TQ: PONDA, SOUTH GOA
48. UMESH JAMBAPPA HONNALLI AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. V.M. SALAGAUNKAR UPPAR COLONY, MURUDESHWAR TQ: BHATKAL, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
49. AJAY MAHALE AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. MARGAO, SALUTE SOUTH GOA DISTRICT
50. KUMARI ASHWINI K.L. AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.NEHRU COLONY, 3RD CROSS SHIRALKOPPA, SHIKARIPURA TALUK DIST: SHIMOGA
6 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 7 -
51. KUMARI SONIA RANI R AGE: 18 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O.MATHADAKERI HONNAVAR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
52. KUMARI, SHWETA R. NAIK AGE: 20 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. ALVEHODI, KUMTA DIST: UTTARA KANNADA
53. VIJAYA H. HEGDE S/O. HERAMBA HEGDE AGE: 19 YEARS, DIPLOMA STUDENT R/O. SHRI MATHA COMPOUND NEAR JANATA VIDYALAYA SHRALI BHATKAL DIST: UTTARA KANNADA ... PETITIONERS
(BY SRI S G KADADAKATTI, ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION, VIDHAN SOUDHA BANGALORE
2. THE DIRECTOR OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION PALACE ROAD, BANGALORE-1
3. THE PRINCIPAL RNS RURAL POLYTECHNIC MURDESHWAR, TQ: BHATKAL DIST: UTTARA KANNADA ... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI MAESH WODEYAR, AGA FOR R1 & R2 NOTICE ISSUED TO R3 , SERVICE AWAITED)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE NOTIFICATION DATED:24/07/2012 IN NO.DTE 22
7 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 8 -
ACM (2) 2012-13 ISSUED BY THE SECOND RESPONDENT VIDE ANNEXURE-A BY ALLOWING THESE WRIT PETITIONS AND ETC.,
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
O R D E R
H.G.RAMESH, J.(Oral) :
Learned Additional Government Advocate, on instructions, submits that the Government Order dtd. 23.07.2012 is withdrawn and consequently the impugned Circular dtd. 24.07.2012 is also
withdrawn and a fresh Government Order dtd. 17.09.2012 is issued, fixing modified norms for admissions to third & fifth semester of Diploma courses. As the impugned circular has been
withdrawn, the Writ Petitions have become infructuous. The Writ Petitions are accordingly dismissed as having become infructuous with liberty to the petitioners to challenge the aforesaid
8 W.P Nos. 67325-67377/2012 - 9 -
Government Order dtd. 17.09.2012 in accordance
with law.
Petitions dismissed .
SD/- JUDGE
BNS
9