DOCSLIB.ORG

PROBLEMS in the ARGOS NARRATIVE, §§76–84 Date

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
PROBLEMS in the ARGOS NARRATIVE, §§76–84 Date APPENDIX 15 PROBLEMS IN THE ARGOS NARRATIVE, §§76–84 Date of the campaign and its motivation 1 Paus 3.4.1, perhaps drawing on Lakonika, says that Cleomenes attacked Argos immediately (aÈt¤ka) on becoming king, i.e. c520. The best argument in favour of this is that he took on a difficult task in a bravura attempt to show that he was worthy to hold the kingship, despite the rival claim of Dorieus (note to §§49.2–55 paras 4, 8). But most historians reject this late Spartan tradition1 and place it in the mid 490s,2 for several reasons: (a) it helps make sense of the double oracle, the Milesian part of which prima facie anticipates the fall of Miletus in 494.3 (b) It is easier to make sense of subse- quent events: the “slaves” taking and then losing power, §83; per- haps the Argives using their defeat as the reason (or excuse) for not officially sending troops to Aegina, §92.2; and the use of nevst¤, “recently”, attributed to them in 481–0 when they spoke of those losses (7.148) when refusing to help against Persia (for the word, see Appx 10 n. 6). (c) At §92.1 the Argives fine Sicyon and Aegina for supplying the Spartans with ships: and that reads more easily if it 1 Writers of Spartan history were late, and the value of what they recorded is pro tanto suspect. Huxley (1962) 19 suggests that Pausanias may have used Sosibios (FGrH 595, perhaps late second century). The story in Socrates of Argos that Demaratos was also there (para 6) is not persuasive, at least on the dates proposed by Forrest (1980) 21: Cleomenes succeeded c520, when Demaratos’ father Ariston was still king; Demaratos did not succeed until c515; cf on ÉAr¤stvni, §61.1. 2 E.g. BM 162; CAH IV2 497 (Hammond), so HG 196, 201; Jeffery (1976) 125, id CAH IV2 335, 364; CAH V2 101 (Lewis, with some reservations). For a defence of Pausanias’ date see Wells (1923) chap IV; he accepts the Telesilla story, infra, as true (cf Appx 6 n. 10). Stadter (1965) 52, following Jacoby, argues that Demaratos was added to the story after an incident at Argos in 271, when Pyrrhus king of Epirus was killed by a projectile thrown by a woman from above (Paus 1.13.7, Plut Pyr 34). The ransom trick does not help, since there was no Argive coinage even in 494; they start in c475–c468: Kraay (1976) 96. Ransom could have been paid in bullion or coins from elsewhere, e.g. Aegina. 3 See Appx 6, esp paras 8–10, noting the possibility that Cleomenes’ consulta- tion of Delphi (next note) was a few years before actually invading, and the double oracle was given shortly afterwards. 572 appendix 15 had happened not long before the events just described, the fighting between Athens and Aegina, which on any view probably happened in the period 493 to 484: Appx 12 paras 5–6. (d) In Herodotus’ narrative, only Cleomenes is there.4 (e) There is much merit in the point made by Jones (1967) 53, Jeffery (1976) 125, that a 50 year truce after Thyrea would expire in c496. (f ) If Telesilla was there, whatever her role, the later the date the easier it is to accommo- date her.5 2 Understanding Cleomenes’ motive and plan involves several prob- lems; when he set out, he could not have foreseen that he would be able to eliminate a substantial part of the Argive army. Did he indeed hope to capture the city, and so compel her to join the Peloponnesian league, and did he persuade the ephors that he could (cf on §§76.1 and 82.1)? Or was his aim to incorporate Argive ter- ritory into Laconia (but see para 3 ad fin)?6 That he might want to make his mark as the new king has been noted supra; but a victory over Argos would enhance his position at any time. There were probably always internal political tensions within Sparta: cf note to §§49.2–55 paras 3–4. Did he do it out of personal ambition, or was there a substantial body of Spartiate opinion behind him wanting to “nullify a major rival for hegemony of the Peloponnese” (Cartledge (1979) 149); or were both the case?7 4 In Herodotus, it was Cleomenes who had the oracle, and he alone led the expedition. This is consistent with it being after the law of 506, that only one king should lead the army. But there are cases of one king doing it before then: note to §§49.2–55 para 3. The 510 expedition was said to be in response to an oracle, but that of 508 was not. 5 It is also arguable that Herodotus’ narrative reads better if Cleomenes had been on the throne for a good time. 6 Tomlinson (1972) 95–6, who dates the attack to 494 and after the fall of Miletus, suggested the alternative, or perhaps additional, aim of neutralising possible Argive support for Persia; Cartledge (1979) 149, infra, left it open. That is very doubtful, as few Greeks would see Persia as a threat to Hellas in the mid 490s. 7 There was probably an emotive side to the hostility between Sparta and Argos. Both probably said that Aristodemos and his brothers had shared out the Peloponnese (cf on §52.1). Sparta’s control of Messenia had already given her Cresphontes’ lot in addition to her own, and she also sought to appropriate Agamemnon (cf ibid and note to §§49.2–55 para 5). But Argos could claim that she had inherited the lot of Temenos, and was also successor to Agamemnon: see Jeffery (1976) 134–6, 164. Kelly (1976) 41–2, 44–5, questions the reliability of the “lot” references, but the story of Tegea at Plataea, 9.26–7, shows how powerful tradition could be in such matters. Although it is unclear how far Argos’ authority extended (paras 17–18), she blocked Sparta’s claim to total hegemony in the Peloponnese..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ritual Performance As Training for Daughters in Archaic Greece Author(S): Wayne B
    Classical Association of Canada Ritual Performance as Training for Daughters in Archaic Greece Author(s): Wayne B. Ingalls Reviewed work(s): Source: Phoenix, Vol. 54, No. 1/2 (Spring - Summer, 2000), pp. 1-20 Published by: Classical Association of Canada Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1089087 . Accessed: 31/03/2012 18:35 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Classical Association of Canada is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Phoenix. http://www.jstor.org RITUAL PERFORMANCE AS TRAINING FOR DAUGHTERS IN ARCHAIC GREECE WAYNEB. INGALLS INTRODUCTION THE PUBLICATION OF THE REVISION AND ENGLISH TRANSLATION of Claude Calame's Les choeursdejeunes filles en Grecearchaique (1997) has again focused attention on the participationof girls in traditionallyric choruses. One aspect of choral activitywhich Calame discusses is education (1977: 1.385-420; 1997: 221-244). In this treatment Calame deals with the chorus as the place of education, the instruction given to the chorus, the metaphoricalrepresentation of education and marriage, and the homoerotic elements
    [Show full text]
  • Bearing Razors and Swords: Paracomedy in Euripides’ Orestes
    %HDULQJ5D]RUVDQG6ZRUGV3DUDFRPHG\LQ(XULSLGHV· 2UHVWHV &UDLJ-HQG]D $PHULFDQ-RXUQDORI3KLORORJ\9ROXPH1XPEHU :KROH1XPEHU )DOOSS $UWLFOH 3XEOLVKHGE\-RKQV+RSNLQV8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV '2, KWWSVGRLRUJDMS )RUDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKLVDUWLFOH KWWSVPXVHMKXHGXDUWLFOH Access provided by University of Kansas Libraries (5 Dec 2016 18:13 GMT) BEARING RAZORS AND SWORDS: PARACOMEDY IN EURIPIDES’ ORESTES CRAIG JENDZA Abstract. In this article, I trace a nuanced interchange between Euripides’ Helen, Aristophanes’ Thesmophoriazusae, and Euripides’ Orestes that contains a previ- ously overlooked example of Aristophanic paratragedy and Euripides’ paracomic response. I argue that the escape plot from Helen, in which Menelaus and Helen flee with “sword-bearing” men ξιφηφόρος( ), was co-opted in Thesmophoriazusae, when Aristophanes staged Euripides escaping with a man described as “being a razor-bearer” (ξυροφορέω). Furthermore, I suggest that Euripides re-appropriates this parody by escalating the quantity of sword-bearing men in Orestes, suggest- ing a dynamic poetic rivalry between Aristophanes and Euripides. Additionally, I delineate a methodology for evaluating instances of paracomedy. PARATRAGEDY, COMEDY’S AppROPRIATION OF LINES, SCENES, AND DRAMATURGY FROM TRAGEDY, constitutes a source of the genre’s authority (Foley 1988; Platter 2007), a source of the genre’s identity as a literary underdog in comparison to tragedy (Rosen 2005), and a source of its humor either through subverting or ridiculing tragedy (Silk 1993; Robson 2009, 108–13) or through audience detection and identification of quotations (Wright 2012, 145–50).1 The converse relationship between 1 Rau 1967 marks the beginning of serious investigation into paratragedy by analyz- ing numerous comic scenes that are modeled on tragic ones and providing a database, with hundreds of examples, of tragic lines that Aristophanes parodies.
    [Show full text]
  • Greek Religious Thought from Homer to the Age of Alexander
    'The Library of Greek Thought GREEK RELIGIOUS THOUGHT FROM HOMER TO THE AGE OF ALEXANDER Edited by ERNEST BARKER, M.A., D.Litt., LL.D. Principal of King's College, University of London tl<s } prop Lt=. GREEK RELIGIOUS THOUGHT FROM HOMER TO THE AGE OF ALEXANDER BY F. M. CORNFORD, M.A. Fellow and Lecturer of Trinity College, Cambridge MCMXXIII LONDON AND TORONTO J. M. DENT & SONS LTD. NEW YORK: E. P. DUTTON tf CO. HOTTO (E f- k> ) loUr\ P. DOTTO/U TALKS ) f^op Lt=. 7 yt All rights reserved f PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN TO WALTER DE LA MARE INTRODUCTION The purpose of this book is to let the English reader see for himself what the Greeks, from Homer to Aristotle, thought about the world, the gods and their relations to man, the nature and destiny of the soul, and the significance of human life. The form of presentation is prescribed by the plan of the series. The book is to be a compilation of extracts from the Greek authors, selected, so far as possible, without prejudice and translated with such honesty as a translation may have. This plan has the merit of isolating the actual thought of the Greeks in this period from all the constructions put upon it by later ages, except in so far as the choice of extracts must be governed by some scheme in the compiler's mind, which is itself determined by the limits of his knowledge and by other personal factors. In the book itself it is clearly his business to reduce the influence of these factors to the lowest point; but in the introduction it is no less his business to forewarn the reader against some of the consequences.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Lyric Messene
    1 Lyric Messene: Collaborative Ethnogenesis and Historical Narrative1 Luke Nathaniel Madson Classical Studies Introduction: In the ancient world, Messenia is the case study par excellence of competing historical- political narratives and notions of revival. The wholesale creation of the late classical polis of Messene illustrates the variety of ways in which new political realities look to the past to establish precedent and stability in the face of seismic change.2 Many Messenian traditions map well onto what Jan Bremmer has called “Myth as Argument,”3 namely, a particular construction of the past to justify present political views, (sometimes) with an argument for a certain direction in the future. This idea is exemplified in the fragmentary lyric tradition of Eumelus known as the Delian Prosodion, of which we have only two attributed lines. As my analysis of this poetic tradition will show, it is inadequate to dismiss such evidence as mere political propaganda orchestrated by the Thebans and Messenians as they founded a new polis. The Delian Prosodion, when contextualized and queried against other emerging Messenian poetic traditions, historical narratives, and archaeological evidence, reveals the compelling traditions which are put forward in the process of ethnogenesis. Such expressions serve to establish legitimacy, not just in a broader external panhellenic political community, but also internally in the micro-narrative of Messene and the identity of its citizens. The poetry attributed to Eumelus shows the development of lyric memory, which functions much like the physical manifestation of civic memory, as seen in the city of Messene; both facilitate the emergence of a certain historical consciousness as well as the embodiment of a present contemporary community.
    [Show full text]
  • The Stromata, Or Miscellanies Book 1
    584 THE STROMATA, OR MISCELLANIES BOOK 1 CHAPTER 1 PREFACE THE AUTHOR’S OBJECT THE UTILITY OF WRITTEN COMPOSITIONS [Wants the beginning ]..........that you may read them under your hand, and may be able to preserve them. Whether written compositions are not to be left behind at all; or if they are, by whom? And if the former, what need there is for written compositions? and if the latter, is the composition of them to be assigned to earnest men, or the opposite? It were certainly ridiculous for one to disapprove of the writing of earnest men, and approve of those, who are not such, engaging in the work of composition. Theopompus and Timaeus, who composed fables and slanders, and Epicurus the leader of atheism, and Hipponax and Archilochus, are to be allowed to write in their own shameful manner. But he who proclaims the truth is to be prevented from leaving behind him what is to benefit posterity. It is a good thing, I reckon, to leave to posterity good children. This is the case with children of our bodies. But words are the progeny of the soul. Hence we call those who have instructed us, fathers. Wisdom is a communicative and philanthropic thing. Accordingly, Solomon says, “My son, if thou receive the saying of my commandment, and hide it with thee, thine ear shall hear wisdom.” He points out that the word that is sown is hidden in the soul of the learner, as in the earth, and this is spiritual planting. Wherefore also he adds, “And thou shalt apply thine heart to understanding, and apply it for the admonition of thy son.” For soul, me thinks, joined with soul, and spirit with spirit, in the sowing of the word, will make that which is sown grow and germinate.
    [Show full text]
  • Greek Mythology / Apollodorus; Translated by Robin Hard
    Great Clarendon Street, Oxford 0X2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Athens Auckland Bangkok Bogotá Buenos Aires Calcutta Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi Paris São Paulo Shanghai Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto Warsaw with associated companies in Berlin Ibadan Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Robin Hard 1997 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published as a World’s Classics paperback 1997 Reissued as an Oxford World’s Classics paperback 1998 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organizations. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Apollodorus. [Bibliotheca. English] The library of Greek mythology / Apollodorus; translated by Robin Hard.
    [Show full text]
  • Maintaining Peace and Interstate Stability in Archaic and Classical Greece
    Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Ge Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Edited by Julia Wilker Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschi Studien Maintaining Peace and Interstate Stability in Archaic and Classical Greece Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten schichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte Studien zur Alten Geschichte
    [Show full text]
  • Wandering Poets and the Dissemination of Greek Tragedy in the Fifth
    Wandering Poets and the Dissemination of Greek Tragedy in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries BC Edmund Stewart Abstract This work is the first full-length study of the dissemination of Greek tragedy in the earliest period of the history of drama. In recent years, especially with the growth of reception studies, scholars have become increasingly interested in studying drama outside its fifth century Athenian performance context. As a result, it has become all the more important to establish both when and how tragedy first became popular across the Greek world. This study aims to provide detailed answers to these questions. In doing so, the thesis challenges the prevailing assumption that tragedy was, in its origins, an exclusively Athenian cultural product, and that its ‘export’ outside Attica only occurred at a later period. Instead, I argue that the dissemination of tragedy took place simultaneously with its development and growth at Athens. We will see, through an examination of both the material and literary evidence, that non-Athenian Greeks were aware of the works of Athenian tragedians from at least the first half of the fifth century. In order to explain how this came about, I suggest that tragic playwrights should be seen in the context of the ancient tradition of wandering poets, and that travel was a usual and even necessary part of a poet’s work. I consider the evidence for the travels of Athenian and non-Athenian poets, as well as actors, and examine their motives for travelling and their activities on the road. In doing so, I attempt to reconstruct, as far as possible, the circuit of festivals and patrons, on which both tragedians and other poetic professionals moved.
    [Show full text]
  • Durham E-Theses
    Durham E-Theses The dorian dilemma: Problems and interpretations of social change in late Helladic iii c and dark age Greece with reference to the archaeological and literary evidence Dierckx, Heidi How to cite: Dierckx, Heidi (1986) The dorian dilemma: Problems and interpretations of social change in late Helladic iii c and dark age Greece with reference to the archaeological and literary evidence, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/6880/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 l ABSTRACT Early Greek history, i.e. Greek history prior to about the mid-sixth century B.C., is as obscure to modern historians as it was to the ancient ones. One of the events which has been mentioned and described by ancient sources and is supposed to have happened during this period is the "Dorian Invasion".
    [Show full text]
  • The History and Antiquities of the Doric Race, Vol. 1 of 2 by Karl Otfried Müller
    The Project Gutenberg EBook of The History and Antiquities of the Doric Race, Vol. 1 of 2 by Karl Otfried Müller This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at http://www.gutenberg.org/license Title: The History and Antiquities of the Doric Race, Vol. 1 of 2 Author: Karl Otfried Müller Release Date: September 17, 2010 [Ebook 33743] Language: English ***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE HISTORY AND ANTIQUITIES OF THE DORIC RACE, VOL. 1 OF 2*** The History and Antiquities Of The Doric Race by Karl Otfried Müller Professor in the University of Göttingen Translated From the German by Henry Tufnell, Esq. And George Cornewall Lewis, Esq., A.M. Student of Christ Church. Second Edition, Revised. Vol. I London: John Murray, Albemarle Street. 1839. Contents Extract From The Translators' Preface To The First Edition.2 Advertisement To The Second Edition. .5 Introduction. .6 Book I. History Of The Doric Race, From The Earliest Times To The End Of The Peloponnesian War. 22 Chapter I. 22 Chapter II. 39 Chapter III. 50 Chapter IV. 70 Chapter V. 83 Chapter VI. 105 Chapter VII. 132 Chapter VIII. 163 Chapter IX. 181 Book II. Religion And Mythology Of The Dorians. 202 Chapter I. 202 Chapter II. 216 Chapter III. 244 Chapter IV. 261 Chapter V. 270 Chapter VI. 278 Chapter VII. 292 Chapter VIII. 302 Chapter IX.
    [Show full text]
  • The Chronology of Ancient Kingdoms Amended
    THE CHRONOLOGY OF ANCIENT KINGDOMS AMENDED. To which is Prefix'd, A SHORT CHRONICLE from the First Memory of Things in Europe, to the Conquest of Persia by Alexander the Great. By Sir ISAAC NEWTON. LONDON: Printed for J. TONSON in the Strand, and J. OSBORN and T. LONGMAN in Pater-noster Row. MDCCXXVIII. TO THE QUEEN. MADAM, As I could never hope to write any thing my self, worthy to be laid before YOUR MAJESTY; I think it a very great happiness, that it should be my lot to usher into the world, under Your Sacred Name, the last work of as great a Genius as any Age ever produced: an Offering of such value in its self, as to be in no danger of suffering from the meanness of the hand that presents it. The impartial and universal encouragement which YOUR MAJESTY has always given to Arts and Sciences, entitles You to the best returns the learned world is able to make: And the many extraordinary Honours YOUR MAJESTY vouchsafed the Author of the following sheets, give You a just right to his Productions. These, above the rest, lay the most particular claim to Your Royal Protection; For the Chronology had never appeared in its present Form without YOUR MAJESTY's Influence; and the Short Chronicle, which precedes it, is entirely owing to the Commands with which You were pleased to honour him, out of your singular Care for the education of the Royal Issue, and earnest desire to form their minds betimes, and lead them early into the knowledge of Truth.
    [Show full text]
  • Greek Mythology Link (Complete Collection)
    Document belonging to the Greek Mythology Link, a web site created by Carlos Parada, author of Genealogical Guide to Greek Mythology Characters • Places • Topics • Images • Bibliography • Español • PDF Editions About • Copyright © 1997 Carlos Parada and Maicar Förlag. This PDF contains portions of the Greek Mythology Link COMPLETE COLLECTION, version 0906. In this sample most links will not work. THE COMPLETE GREEK MYTHOLOGY LINK COLLECTION (digital edition) includes: 1. Two fully linked, bookmarked, and easy to print PDF files (1809 A4 pages), including: a. The full version of the Genealogical Guide (not on line) and every page-numbered docu- ment detailed in the Contents. b. 119 Charts (genealogical and contextual) and 5 Maps. 2. Thousands of images organized in albums are included in this package. The contents of this sample is copyright © 1997 Carlos Parada and Maicar Förlag. To buy this collection, visit Editions. Greek Mythology Link Contents The Greek Mythology Link is a collection of myths retold by Carlos Parada, author of Genealogical Guide to Greek Mythology, published in 1993 (available at Amazon). The mythical accounts are based exclusively on ancient sources. Address: www.maicar.com About, Email. Copyright © 1997 Carlos Parada and Maicar Förlag. ISBN 978-91-976473-9-7 Contents VIII Divinities 1476 Major Divinities 1477 Page Immortals 1480 I Abbreviations 2 Other deities 1486 II Dictionaries 4 IX Miscellanea Genealogical Guide (6520 entries) 5 Three Main Ancestors 1489 Geographical Reference (1184) 500 Robe & Necklace of
    [Show full text]