Acta Scientific Dental Sciences Volume 2 Issue 5 May 2018 Review Article

Mental Foramen in Sex Determination

Naveen Srinivas1*, Ketki Sali2 and Sneha Khanapure3

1Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, PMNM Dental College and Hospital Bagalkot, Karnataka, India 2Private Practitioner, Amog Dental Clinic, Bagalkot, Karnataka, India 3Senior Lecturer, Department of Community Dentistry, DY Patil University, Nerul, Navi Mumbai, India

*Corresponding Author: Naveen Srinivas, Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, PMNM Dental College and Hospital Bagalkot, Karnataka, India.

Received: February 09, 2018; Published: April 16, 2018

Abstract

Identification of sex is of at most importance in forensic examination. is one of the prominent facial which is used in the determination of sex as it has many anatomical difference between the two sexes, one such structure is the mental foramen. KeywordsThis review: Mentalaims at Foramen; shedding Mandible;light at the Sex; sexual Gender dimorphism that exists between the male and the female gender.

Introduction - [5] - Forensic analysis carried out in case of mass disasters includes between the MF and the lower border of the mandible remains un sidered a stable landmark in mandible we made an attempt to re- changed . As mentioned earlier mental foramen which is con identification of anatomical features of human skeletal remains. [14]. view the importance position of mental foramen in case of gender More specifically in identification of adults, sex determination is - identification the prime focus which is followed by age and stature as these two Radiographic appearance of mental foramen features are sex determinants. is the most important and di - morphic portion for sex determination after pelvis. In certain cases when complete skull is not available mandible plays a very impor According to the authors, Yosue and Brooks the radiographic - - tant role in gender identification. Mandible is considered strongest appearance of mental foramen can be classified into four types. In - in the skull and its anatomical features will be preserved com the continuous type, the MF is uninterrupted with the mandibu dible are used by forensic specialists in determining gender. Nu- paratively for long time. Therefore, morphological features of man lar . In the separate type, the foramen is noticeably detached from the and is seen as a distinct radiolucency [1-7]. merous research on cheiloscopy, figure print analysis, palatal rugae with a well-defined border. In the diffuse type, the foramen has visible [6,7]. patterns, cuspid dimorphism in different populations of India an vague boundary while in the unidentified type, the MF is not - - Identification of a person in case of mass disasters using dental [18]: - Another classification for position of mental foramen depend characteristics such as crown, root morphology, presence of de [8-10]. ing on• its position of the tooth cayed, missing teeth, and degree of root formation aid in identifica tion of that person • Position 1: MF situated anterior to first premolar tooth - Position 2: situated in line with the long axis of first pre There are other studies where there are differences between • molar tooth genders in relation to the height of mandible, gonial angle,bigonial [11-14]. Position 3: MF situated between the apices of first and breadth, bicondylar breadth, and position of mental foramen (MF) • second premolar teeth Mental foramen: a valuable anatomical landmark Position 4: MF situated in line with long axis of second • premolar tooth -

Among many anatomical landmarks in human skull, the mental Position 5: MF situated between the apices of second pre • foramen is a stable landmark on the mandible. MF is an opening at molar and first molar teeth - the buccal side of the mandible bilaterally where the mandibular Position 6: MF situated in line with the long axis of first sels [15] nerve exits the mandible near the bicuspid area along with the ves molar tooth. . Wical and Swoope in 1974 indicated that inspite of all the relative age changes that takes place in the mandible the distance

Citation: Naveen Srinivas., et al. “Mental Foramen in Sex Determination”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences

2.5 (2018): 40-43. Mental Foramen in Sex Determination

41 Why are orthopantomograms [opg] preferred over conven- tional periapical radiographs? most point on the base of the mandible. D2: Vertical distance from - the most superior point on the mental foramen to the superior most point of the alveolar crest. D3: Vertical distance from the Radiographs are one of the important tools in forensics investi antemortem records are available. most lowest point of the to the most superior gations and its utilisation for identification is valuable if sufficient - point on the MF. D4: Vertical distance from the most lower point - of the mandibular notch to the inferior edge of the mandibular ra two-pronged location of MF, , ramus, angle, and Panoramic radiographs (orthopantomogram [OPG]) illustrate mus. Results indicated that the mean values between the two sex - es i.e male and female subjects overall values for D1, D2, D3, and mensions [19] body of the mandible. OPG allows frank position of the MF in two di D4 were significantly higher in males in comparison to females. - et al, Amorim.,et al et al, and . On the other hand conventional intro oral periapical This was coinciding with the studies by Rashid and Ali, Yousue and - et al, Al-Mufti., et al - radiographs cannot assess the MF bilaterally and due to its dimen Brooks, Freitas, Al-Khateeb., , Şahin., surements from mandibular lower border and mental foramen sions if the MF is located too apically it cannot be assessed. Pan Kilarkaje., . indicating that the verticle mea - are potent indicators for sex determination and useful in differen- oramic radiography is a widely used technique because it has the tiating male gender from female [14,16,25-28]. advantage of providing, in a single film, the image of the full man dible with relatively less exposure, time, and cost. This technique [20]. can offer information about the localization of anatomic structures - Muhammad Ajmal conducted another study in which a total of vertical and horizontal bony dimensions - lous areas. Patients aged between 30 - 70 years and were divided 500 radiographs were taken of patients having unilateral edentu - - Panoramic digital radiography can be practical in forensic medi [2,3]. tance between alveolar crest bone and superior margin of mental cine with the employment of portable unit, this allows a rapid ex into 4 groups of 30 - 39, 40 - 49, 50 - 59 and 60 - 70 yrs. The dis amination of the extra-oral structures and the dental status foramen was calculated. The results of the study indicated that - It is because of this reason we consider panoramic radiographs the distance between the superior border of mental foramen and [14,21,22]. - are much helpful and convenient to study the position of mental fo alveolar crest was comparatively more in males than in females tion [29]. ramen in such cases indicating the importance of mental foramen in gender predilec Literature showing the importance of mental foramen in et al. conducted a similar type of study but in gender identification Moni Thakur., dentulous patients and they also concluded height of the mandible - [30]. As mentioned earlier the position of mental foramen can be used and the distance from the superior margin of the mental foramen as a landmark in gender identification. The most reliable and eas to the alveolar crest can be used to determine the gender et al ily identifiable aspect of mental foramen is the distance between the superior border of foramen to lower border of mandible apart In another study Sahni., . considered another variable mandible are also considered to be reliable landmark for radiologi- from this the inferior border of mental foramen and lower border of that is distance between inferior (I-L) border of mental foramen and lower border of mandible along with superior border (S-L) - cal interpretations. Numerous studies have been conducted using of foramen and concluded that showed that the mean values of this position and vivid results have been seen. et al. 100 radio- comparison of S-L as well as I-L in males and females were signifi cantly higher in males as compared to females. The comparison A study was conducted by Akhilesh Chandra., - - of SL and IL on right and left side in the same patient was without graphs were selected for the analysis of mental foramen. Tangents et al, Catovie., et al et al any significant difference. This type of results were also in accor were drawn to the upper and lower borders of the MF and perpen - dance with Thomas., . and Akhilesh., . where diculars were drawn from the tangents to the inferior border of the [14,23,24,31]. there was a significant difference between the position of mental mandible (S-L and I-L). The data obtained were tabulated and sub foramenHowever, in both in a thestudy genders conducted by Vodanovic., et al, Enlow., et al, jected to statistical analysis. Results inferred that the average values Amorim., et al et al - of S-L and I-L were considerably higher in males than in females, whereas the distances for the right and left sides of an individual . and Akhilesh., . there was no significant differ - were almost analogous in both the sexes and the results were non- ence between the genders in relation to inferior border of mental et al et al and Catovie., et al [14,23,24]. [4,14,32]. significant. These results were in acco rdance with those foramen. This dissimilarity could have been due to the ethnic as of Thomas., , Mahima., sortment in the given inhabitants et al Conclusion - Ghouse., . conducted a study with a sample which consisted of 60 patients from both genders, (30 males and 30 females Four Panoramic radiography can be well thought-out as an supple et al - - linear vertical measurements (D1, D2, D3, and D4) were performed mentary radiographic method to identify gender from the skeletal - on all radiographic images according to Amorim., . These mea relics because it is efficient for making the proposed measure surements were done on the right and left sides of the mandible im ments which is predominantly key in mass disaster events, in age. The following measurements were taken, D1: Vertical distance which the are obtainable in fragments. Based on the grades from the most inferior point on the mental foramen to the inferior of this review there is a momentous variation in the distance from

Citation: Naveen Srinivas., et al. “Mental Foramen in Sex Determination”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences

2.5 (2018): 40-43. Mental Foramen in Sex Determination

42 14. et al. - Journal of both superior border and inferior border of MF to the lower border ForensicChandra DentalA., Sciences “Determination of sex by radiographic anal ysis of mental foramen in North Indian population”. Bibliographyof the mandible in males and females. 15. Hu KS., et al. 5.1 (2013): 5255.­ - 1. et al. “Digital analysis of linear measurements re- Journal of Forensic Sciences “Sex determination using nonmetric character - istics of the mandible in Koreans”. nation”.Ghouse N.,Journal of Medicine, Radiology, Pathology and Surgery lated to the mental and mandibular foramina in sex determi 16. 51.6 (2006): 1376-1382. Oral Sur- Yosue T and Brooks SL. “The appearance of mental foramina 2. Funayama2.3 (2016): M., 5-9. et al. gery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, and Oral Radiology 68.3 on panoramic radiographs. I. Evaluation of patients”. via computer network”. American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology “Dental identification using digital images 17. (1989): 360-364. 3. Wood RE., et al 21.2 (2000): 178-183. Oral Yosue T and Brooks SL. “The appearance of mental foramina American Jour- Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, and Oral Radiology on panoramic radiographs. II. Experimental evaluation”. nal of Forensic Medicine. “Digitized and slice Pathology interposition in forensic dental radiographic identification. An in vitro study”. 4. Amorim MM., et al. 15.1 (1994): 70-78. 18. Srinivas68.4 (1989): N., et 488-492. al. - Acta Medica Academica 46.1 “Morphological description of mandibular “The position of mental foramen in the north and south Indian populations”. Internationalcanal in panoramic Journal radiographs of Morphology of Brazilian subjects: Associa tion between anatomic characteristic and clinical procedures”. 19. Neiva(2017): RF., 44-49. et al. ‑related 5. Wical KE and Swoope CC. “Studies of 27.4 residual (2009): ridge 1243-1248. resorption. anatomy in Caucasian ”. Journal of Periodontology 75.8 “Morphometric analysis of implant - tion of mandibular resorption”. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry I. Use of panoramic radiographs for evaluation and classifica 20. (2004): 1061-1067. et al. “Evaluation of mandibular implant sites: correlation between panoramic and linear tomogra- Rockenbach MI., 6. 32.1 (1974):et al. 7-12. - Brazilian Dental Journal Clinical Oral Implants Research phy”. 14.3 (2003): 209-213. Lindh C., “Measurements‑103. of distances related to the man 21. Malik M., et al. “Mental foramen: An Indicator for Gender dibular canal in radiographs”. Journal of Health Sci- 7. 6.2Güler (1995): AU., et 96 al ences Determination- A Radiographic Study”. . “The evaluation of vertical heights of maxillary 22. Gangotri2.1 (2016):S., et al. 12-14. dentistry”.and mandibular Journal bones of Oral and theRehabilitation location of anatomic landmarks and Symmetry of Mental Foramen in Central Indian Popula- “Radiographic Determination of Position in746. panoramic radiographs of edentulous patients for implant tion”. Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine and Radiol- 32.10 (2005): 741- ogy 8. et al. 23. 23.2 (2011):et al 101-103. - India”.Suragimath Journal G., of Forensic “Gender Dental determination Sciences by radiographic dible relevant to forensic dentistry”. Journal of Dental Medi- analysis of mental foramen in the Maharashtra population of Thomascine CJ., . “A radiologic survey of the edentulous man 9. Pramod JB., et al. “Role of forensic odontologist 8.3 (2016): in post 176 mortem176.­ 3 (2004): 15-20. Dental Research Journal 24. Catovie A., et al. - 30. - person identification”. 9.5 (2012): 22­ “InfluenceActa Stomatologica of sex, age and Croatica presence of func tional units on optical density and bone height of the man 10. Giles E. “Sex determination by discriminant function analysis 327-328. dible in the elderly”. 3.6 (2002): American Journal of Physical Anthropology 22 25. - of the mandible”. - Rashid SA and Ali J. “Sex determination using linear measure 11. Vodanovic(1964): 129 M.,35.­ et al. cal positions on digital panoramic images”. Journal of Bagh- ments related to the mental and mandibular foramina verti Jour- dad College of Dentistry ‑64. nal of Archaeological “Odontometrics: Science A useful method for sex determination in an archaeological skeletal population?” 26. Al‑ et al. 23 (2011): 59 12. Vinay G., et al. 34.6 (2007): 905913.­ Surgical and Radio- Khateeb T., “Position of the mental foramen in a metrical parameters”. Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Re- logic Anatomy northern regional Jordanian population”. search “Sex determination of human mandible using 27. Şahin S., et al. 29.3 (2007): 231-237. 13. 7.12 (2013):et al 26712673.­ - “Retrospective radiographic evaluation of the Journal of interforaminal region with spiral computerized tomography: DentalGhodousi Materials A., and. “The Techniques value of panoramic radiography in gen dental status”. Gulhane Medical Journal ‑75. der specification of edentulous Iranian population”. Adequacy for dental implant placement related to age and 2.2 (2013): 4549.­ 52.2 (2010): 69

Citation: Naveen Srinivas., et al. “Mental Foramen in Sex Determination”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences

2.5 (2018): 40-43. Mental Foramen in Sex Determination

43 28. et al. maintains absolute bilateral symmetry in of differ- entKilarkaje age‑groups”. N., Hong“The Kong location Dental of Journal the mandibular foramen

29. 2.1 (2005): 35-37.- The Journal of Contemporary Den- Ajmaltal Practice M. “Evaluation of mental foramen position from pan oramic dental radiographs”. 30. 15.4et al. (2014): “Gender 399-402. Determination by Mental Foramen

Thakur M., Journal of Indian Academy of Forensic Medicineand Height of the Body of the Mandible in Dentulous Patients A Radiographic Study”. 31. et 36.1 al. (2014): 13-18. - rospectiveSahni P., study”. “Gender Medico determination Research Chronicles by pantomographic (opg) 706.analysis of mental foramen in north gujarat population- a ret 2.5 (2015): 701- 32. Vodanovic M., et al. “Determination of sex by discriminant - cal sites”. Acta stomatologica Croatica functional analysis of mandibles from two Croatian archeologi 40.3 (2006): 263-277.

Volume 2 Issue 5 May 2018 © All rights are reserved by Naveen Srinivas., et al.

Citation: Naveen Srinivas., et al. “Mental Foramen in Sex Determination”. Acta Scientific Dental Sciences

2.5 (2018): 40-43.