DOCSLIB.ORG

The Uncommon Virtue of Don Quixote

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Uncommon Virtue of Don Quixote The Uncommon Virtue of Don Quixote Classical virtue, prudential reason, and justice in Miguel de Cervantes’s novel Nathanael Lambert Submitted in total requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy April 2019 School of Languages and Linguistics Faculty of Arts The University of Melbourne Produced on archival quality paper Declaration: (i) This thesis comprises only my original work towards the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. (ii) Due acknowledgement has been made in the text to all other material used. SIGNED: ............................................................. I DATED: .............................................................I :l A r�..\ L 2._o °/ . Acknowledgements: This work would not have been possible without the scholarship granted by the University of Melbourne in the beginning years of the PhD. I am also indebted to the University for providing me with additional time to pursue my goals. I am grateful to all of those from whom I have had the pleasure to receive supervision, or with whom I have had the pleasure to work. I am especially indebted to Dr Vicente Pérez de León, who was my principal supervisor for much of my candidature, and who is now Head of School & Professor in Hispanic Studies at The University of Glasgow. His expertise on Don Quixote is undeniable and has many times provided the solution to apparent difficulties in methodology or knowledge. He is also unflagging in his encouragement, for which I have much to thank. Each of my supervisors has provided me extensive personal and professional guidance and taught me a great deal about both research and life in general. I would especially like to express my heartfelt gratitude to Professor Véronique Duché, A.R. Chisholm Professor of French at the University of Melbourne, who became my principal supervisor when Vicente left for Glasgow. As my teacher and mentor, she has taught me more than I could ever give her credit for here. Not only has she shown me, by her example and through her erudition, what a good scholar should be, but she has also brought a lighthearted and generous poise to her supervisory duties. Her knowledge of my period is vast and her conversation is seasoned with a wry humour that I greatly enjoy. Nobody has been more important to me in the pursuit of this project than the members of my family. I would like to thank my parents, whose love and guidance are with me in whatever I pursue. Most importantly, I wish to thank my loving and supportive wife, Celia, and my wonderful son, Tobias, who provide unending inspiration. 3 “A dry flame is the best and wisest soul.” —Fragment 46, Heraclitus 4 Abstract: This thesis investigates the influence of classical virtue on Miguel de Cervantes’s Don Quixote (1605 Part I; 1615 Part II), its particular focus being two of the virtues, prudence and justice. The thesis suggests a new reading of Cervantes’s novel which takes into account the values of these essential intellectual approaches to moral behaviour in early modern Spain. Though enthralled to chivalry and its literature, Don Quixote’s thinking and acting are motivated by Aristotle’s concept of virtue, as relayed through the tradition of Plato, Aristotle, Cicero, Aquinas and finally Cervantes, in line with most of the humanists in the Renaissance period. Although Don Quixote strives for prudence and justice, he does so to develop his reason through his actions, his habits, his memory and his eloquent rhetorical speech. In spite of his effort, the virtuous circle of his prudential reasoning, and its impact on a hostile world, is many times upset by the mental disturbance he is suffering – his ‘illusions’ (engaños). Counterpart to Don Quixote’s uncommon state of being, this thesis argues the enactment of a steady reversal of the conviction in virtue as a telos circa 1600, right before the time when DQI was written. 5 Table of Contents Chapter One: Literature Review & General Introduction Chapter Two: Reason is integral to virtue Section I Towards an end, or ‘prudence’ or ‘cuerdo’ (sanity) in Cervantes’s DQII: LXII Integral knowledge at work in Greek and Aristotelian definitions of virtue Towards an end, or Aristotle’s Book VI of the Ethics and its impact in coining ‘prudence’ Knowledge and ‘unity of virtue’ The discourse of virtue: the assumption of knowledge & a correct desire No ‘form world’ in prudence, Aristotle’s proofs for knowledge: experience and data Know-nothings ‘know’ how to treat matters of significance Section II Virtuous societies recognise the good and the laws at the same time Discussion: impact of other traditions Don Quixote’s ‘magnanimity’ indicates his ‘unity of virtue’ He fails ‘unity of virtue’: the failure which looks like virtue Prologue, again; Choleric dilemmas, excessive imagination, period in crisis Chapter Three: Unreason integral to Don Quixote’s ‘virtue’ – paradox, choleric action, melancholic retreats, virtuous memory and glamorous eloquence Section I Imagination’s reach: how Don Alonso became Don Quixote; questions of temperament Paraphrase of Chapter I of Don Quixote Wilfred Bion’s ‘Theory of Thinking’ Applying Bion’s theory to Chapter I of Don Quixote Don Quixote and ‘madness’: Aristotle’s Problem XXX, I; nature in charge of sad age (the ‘Senectus Dolori’ emblem) Huarte’s genius theory – ‘adustion’ (humour combining) i. Huarte’s mental power: the imagination in Chapter I; ‘the guise of the good’ ii. Don Quixote’s excuse of enchantment for his ‘bad humour’ Omnipotent thinking: enemy enchanters Blamed star: stars, seasons, Saturn and melancholy Section II Thomas Aquinas and a Scholasticized mind: Cicero and prudence trebled Titian’s ‘Allegory of Prudence’ – the melancholic skills of prudence and memory ‘Habit’: Aquinas, physical discipline and training memory Self-disciplined habits in Don Quixote Medieval didactic thought in Chapter I, Feliciano de Silva and a note on copiae Such copiae! Feliciano de Silva’s ‘woody’ style in Don Quixote’s thinking Eloquence: Cicero’s legacy to humanism Conclusion Drawing together Conclusions to the Theoretical Discussions in Chapters Two and Three Chapter Four: Doing Prudence Section I: Andres and the Cruel Master Section II: Don Quixote frees the Galley Slaves 6 Chapter Five: Thinking Prudence Section I: Don Quixote’s Advice to Sancho. Section II: Quixote’s Discourse on Arms and Letters. Rhetorical argumentation (in utramque partem) as consensus (scientia civilis) DQI:XXXVII-XXXVIII Section III: The Cave of Montesinos. Allegory as Truth and Platonic Wisdom DQII: XXII-XXIV Chapter Six: Communicating Prudence Section I: Don Quixote’s Discourse on the Golden Age Section II: Sancho Panza as Governor of Barataria Chapter Seven; & Conclusion Revisiting aims of Literature Review The emergent modern prototype of Roque Guinart 7 Chapter One: Literature Review & General Introduction Literature Review Plan 1. General literature review Merging of philosophical schools Political models of Greco- Roman antiquity Classical political values become aristocratic values Theme of ‘appearance and reality’ Scepticism Escape to the past Recent interest in ‘justice’ and contemporary law 2. Thesis Statement and Summarised Main Body Chapter Subsections “And that must be how my history is: a commentary will be necessary in order to understand it (478; DQII: III).” —Y así debe de ser de mi historia, que tendrá necesidad de comento para entenderla (566; DQII: III). —Don Quixote Miguel de Cervantes’s Don Quixote (1605/1615) has left a marvellous imprint in the collective psyche of Western literature and culture that is evidently felt in each new epoch. Every age seeks its image in the adventures of the hapless knight, Don Quixote, and his ‘common man’ squire, Sancho Panza. Written by Cervantes four centuries ago, the novel is divided into two parts. The 1615 publication of the second part is the outcome of the tremendous popularity of the first, which came out itself in four sections, thus emulating the chivalric novel Amadís de Gaula. Regarding the unplanned nature of the two parts, Ian Watt wrote that The first part of Don Quixote was an instant and enormous success: there were four authorized and three pirated editions in its first year alone; further editions followed, including two in Brussels and one in Milan; very soon there were translations into French and English. In 1613 Cervantes announced that he was bringing out a sequel, a possibility which had been hinted at in the last chapter of Part I (67).1 Don Quixote is a work that achieves simple and more complex aims—largely it encompasses a fulfilment as the first novel tout court, yet there is also its claim to anathematize books of chivalry, a hackneyed genre even in Cervantes’s day. With its high repute as a satire or criticism piece against various human follies, Don Quixote will not remain merely a satire against the idealizations of chivalric life and reactionaries the world over. It achieves so much more. Of Cervantes’s knowing 1 Ian Watt, Myths of Modern Individualism: Faust, Don Quixote, Don Juan, Robinson Crusoe (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996). 8 irony Manuel Durán wrote, ‘the arrow that seemed to aim at the heavens turns around and comes down at our feet.’2 Part One commences with the knight’s reading of multiple chivalric works of literature. His obsession is so overwhelming that he considers he is a knight of justice and that he must pursue his cause in the world to prove his worth. The first part of the novel sees the knight leave home twice and return back again twice. In Part Two, he leaves home for the third and final time, returning only at the end of the novel for his death. As much committed to external activity as he is driven by his introspective regard, the unseasonal knight meets with challenges and obstructions from daily life. His crucible is his ideal carried against the hard fact of the dry Spanish tableland and life there circa 1600, where the inhabitants of Don Quixote’s inns, villages and landscapes are striving to lead quotidian lives.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Don Quixote and Legacy of a Caricaturist/Artistic Discourse
    Don Quixote and the Legacy of a Caricaturist I Artistic Discourse Rupendra Guha Majumdar University of Delhi In Miguel de Cervantes' last book, The Tria/s Of Persiles and Sigismunda, a Byzantine romance published posthumously a year after his death in 1616 but declared as being dedicated to the Count of Lemos in the second part of Don Quixote, a basic aesthetie principIe conjoining literature and art was underscored: "Fiction, poetry and painting, in their fundamental conceptions, are in such accord, are so close to each other, that to write a tale is to create pietoríal work, and to paint a pieture is likewise to create poetic work." 1 In focusing on a primal harmony within man's complex potential of literary and artistic expression in tandem, Cervantes was projecting a philosophy that relied less on esoteric, classical ideas of excellence and truth, and more on down-to-earth, unpredictable, starkly naturalistic and incongruous elements of life. "But fiction does not", he said, "maintain an even pace, painting does not confine itself to sublime subjects, nor does poetry devote itself to none but epie themes; for the baseness of lífe has its part in fiction, grass and weeds come into pietures, and poetry sometimes concems itself with humble things.,,2 1 Quoted in Hans Rosenkranz, El Greco and Cervantes (London: Peter Davies, 1932), p.179 2 Ibid.pp.179-180 Run'endra Guha It is, perhaps, not difficult to read in these lines Cervantes' intuitive vindication of the essence of Don Quixote and of it's potential to generate a plural discourse of literature and art in the years to come, at multiple levels of authenticity.
    [Show full text]
  • Is There a Hidden Jewish Meaning in Don Quixote?
    From: Cervantes: Bulletin of the Cervantes Society of America , 24.1 (2004): 173-88. Copyright © 2004, The Cervantes Society of America. Is There a Hidden Jewish Meaning in Don Quixote? MICHAEL MCGAHA t will probably never be possible to prove that Cervantes was a cristiano nuevo, but the circumstantial evidence seems compelling. The Instrucción written by Fernán Díaz de Toledo in the mid-fifteenth century lists the Cervantes family as among the many noble clans in Spain that were of converso origin (Roth 95). The involvement of Miguel’s an- cestors in the cloth business, and his own father Rodrigo’s profes- sion of barber-surgeon—both businesses that in Spain were al- most exclusively in the hand of Jews and conversos—are highly suggestive; his grandfather’s itinerant career as licenciado is so as well (Eisenberg and Sliwa). As Américo Castro often pointed out, if Cervantes were not a cristiano nuevo, it is hard to explain the marginalization he suffered throughout his life (34). He was not rewarded for his courageous service to the Spanish crown as a soldier or for his exemplary behavior during his captivity in Al- giers. Two applications for jobs in the New World—in 1582 and in 1590—were denied. Even his patron the Count of Lemos turn- 173 174 MICHAEL MCGAHA Cervantes ed down his request for a secretarial appointment in the Viceroy- alty of Naples.1 For me, however, the most convincing evidence of Cervantes’ converso background is the attitudes he displays in his work. I find it unbelievable that anyone other than a cristiano nuevo could have written the “Entremés del retablo de las maravi- llas,” for example.
    [Show full text]
  • Fiction Excerpt 2: from the Adventures of Don Quixote
    Fiction Excerpt 2: From The Adventures of Don Quixote (retold with excerpts from the novel by Miguel de Cervantes) Once upon a time, in a village in La Mancha, there lived a lean, thin-faced old gentleman whose favorite pastime was to read books about knights in armor. He loved to read about their daring exploits, strange adventures, bold rescues of damsels in distress, and intense devotion to their ladies. In fact, he became so caught up in the subject of chivalry that he neglected every other interest and even sold many acres of good farmland so that he might buy all the books he could get on the subject. He would lie awake at night, absorbed in every detail of these fantastic adventures. He would often engage in arguments with the village priest or the barber over who was the greatest knight of all time. Was it Amadis of Gaul or Palmerin of England? Or was it perhaps the Knight of the Sun? As time went on, the old gentleman crammed his head so full of these stories and lost so much sleep from reading through the night that he lost his wits completely. He began to believe that all the fantastic and romantic tales he read about enchantments, challenges, battles, wounds, and wooings were true histories. At last he fell into the strangest fancy that any madman has ever had: he resolved to become himself a knight errant, to travel through the world with horse and armor in search of adventures. First he got out some rust-eaten armor that had belonged to his ancestors, then cleaned and repaired it as best he could.
    [Show full text]
  • Religious Nonconformism: Methodism As Quixotism in His 1905 Talk
    CHAPTER 7 A TALE OF FAITH AND LOVE: RELIGIOUS ENTHUSIASM AND NATURAL AFFECTION IN RICHARD GRAVES’ THE SPIRITUAL QUIXOTE Religious Nonconformism: Methodism as Quixotism In his 1905 talk, “Tercentenary of Don Quixote: Cervantes in England”, delivered at the British Academy, Fitzmaurice-Kelly affirms that “The Spiritual Quixote of Graves, published in 1773, and similar productions of this period have lost whatever interest that they may once have had”.1 Labelled by the literature as an anti-Methodist satire, a minor novel like The Spiritual Quixote is of interest, I argue, because, like other previous canonical eighteenth-century texts, it takes Quixotism as a critique of Methodism. A Nonconformist Christian confession born within the Church of England, Methodism was, spiritually and politically, a cultural institution “with the sovereign at its head”.2 Graves’ novel fills yet another gap in the Enlightenment cultural critique filtered through the lens of Quixotism, in that it draws attention to the hazardous practice encouraged by a sectarian movement driven by religious enthusiasm as true faith in God. My intention is not to probe the historical and political factors underlying this issue, but to look at Graves’ not wholly satirical treatment of Methodism as religious practice and spiritual reform in an “orthodox Quixotic narrative”,3 as Scott Paul Gordon points out. The Spiritual Quixote is a comic romp born of an incident that took place when Graves was a rector at Claverton. An itinerant preacher, who was a shoemaker by trade, settled in his parish for a while and 1 Fitzmaurice-Kelly, “Tercentenary of Don Quixote: Cervantes in England”, 16-17 (emphasis added).
    [Show full text]
  • Masterpiece: Don Quixote, 1955 by Pablo Picasso
    Masterpiece: Don Quixote, 1955 By Pablo Picasso Keywords: line, shape, pen & ink Grade: 5th Month: May Activity: The Mighty Pen (and Ink) Meet the Artist: Picasso was born in Spain in 1881. His father was an artist who taught at a local university and he encouraged Pablo at an early age to pursue his artistic talents. At the age of 11, Pablo and was sent to art. Picasso’s artworks changed significantly through his career and he created hundreds of paintings and sculptures. He married and had 4 children. When they were younger, he was a fantastically fun dad. He would draw on tablecloths, did magic tricks and would prepare birthday dinner celebrations made up entirely of chocolate. He became most well known for his Cubist paintings. Cubism emphasized line, shape and color. It was a modern art style that is not realistic in nature, but based geometric shapes. It started out with neutral colors, but eventually became a very colorful style. Picasso was very outspoken, opinionated and eccentric. He never threw anything out, hated the telephone, and refused to dust his studio. He loved keeping an odd assortment of pets, including goats, reptiles, a monkey and always some Afghan Hounds. He loved any publicity and made sure he was always reading something about himself. He was a prolific painter, and even in his 90th year, he painted 200 paintings. He was still working on the day he died, at 92, of heart failure. Don Quixote is a 1955 sketch by Pablo Picasso of the Spanish literary hero and his sidekick, Sancho Panza.
    [Show full text]
  • Unamuno's “Quixotism”
    The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of the Liberal Arts FLESH AND BONE: UNAMUNO’S “QUIXOTISM” AS AN INCARNATION OF KIERKEGAARD’S “RELIGIOUSNESS A” A Dissertation in Philosophy By Mary Ann Alessandri © 2010 Mary Ann Alessandri Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy May 2010 ii The dissertation of Mary Ann Alessandri was reviewed and approved* by the following: Shannon Sullivan Professor of Philosophy, Women’s Studies and African and African American Studies Head of the Department of Philosophy Dissertation Adviser Co-Chair of Committee Daniel Conway, Professor and Department Head Philosophy Department, Texas A&M University Co-Chair of Committee Special Member Brady Bowman Assistant Professor of Philosophy John P. Christman Associate Professor of Philosophy and Political Science Nicolás Fernández-Medina Assistant Professor of Spanish Literature, Department of Spanish, Italian and Portuguese *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. iii ABSTRACT My dissertation explores the philosophical kinship between the existentialist thinkers Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855) and Miguel de Unamuno (1864-1936) in an attempt to resurrect an ethically religious way of life. In Kierkegaard’s writings one can find a description of a passionately committed way of life that is distinguishable from both his conception of ethics and his version of Christianity. He calls this form of ethical religion or religious ethics “Religiousness A,” but he fails to give a vivid illustration of it that definitively distinguishes it from ethics and Christianity. As a result, the scholarship on Religiousness A is impoverished, and what would otherwise amount to a promising new way of being religious in a secular world has been largely regarded as unimportant or simply a watered-down version of Christianity.
    [Show full text]
  • Texto Completo (Pdf)
    Los nombres de los personajes de la novela de Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quijote de la Mancha DOMINIQUE REYRE* l propio Miguel de Cervantes nos brindó el tema del presente curso in- E vitándonos a investigar el significado de los nombres de personajes de su genial novela Don Quijote de la Mancha, al decir en la última frase de su pri- mer capítulo, a propósito de la dama del héroe: Don Quijote vino a llamarla Dulcinea del Toboso, porque era natu- ral del Toboso; nombre a su parecer, músico y peregrino, y significativo, como a todos los demás que a él y a sus cosas había puesto1. Esta frase nos autoriza a preguntarnos lo que Cervantes entendía por “sig- nificativo” y, una vez aclarado este concepto clave, nos convida a emprender el desciframiento de los nombres de sus personajes. Dicho concepto tan só- lo puede aprehenderse resituándolo en el marco general de la teoría del len- guaje que seguía vigente entre los hombres de principios del Seiscientos. De esta teoría nos da una idea Sebastián de Covarrubias, quien en el prólogo de su Tesoro de la lengua castellana (1611) afirmó que: El lenguaje no [era] adquirido ni inventado por ellos, sino infundido del Señor, y con tanta propiedad que los nombres que Adán puso a los animales terrestres y a las aves fueron los propios que les competían; por- * LEMSO, Universidad de Toulouse-Le Mirail. 1 Citamos por la edición de Diego Clemencín, El ingenioso hidalgo don Quijote de la Mancha, Edi- ción IV Centenario, Madrid, Ediciones Castilla, 1967. Daré las indicaciones de la parte, del capítulo y de la página de dicha edición.
    [Show full text]
  • The Search for Dog in Cervantes
    humanities Article Article The Search for Dog in Cervantes ID Ivan Schneider Seattle, WA 98104,98104, USA; [email protected] Received: 20 20 March March 2017 2017;; Accepted: 11 11 July July 2017 2017;; Published: 14 14 July July 2017 2017 Abstract: This paper reconsiders the missing galgo from the first line in Don Quixote with a set of Abstract: This paper reconsiders the missing galgo from the first line in Don Quixote with a set of interlocking claims: first, that Cervantes initially established the groundwork for including a talking interlocking claims: first, that Cervantes initially established the groundwork for including a talking dog in Don Quixote; second, through improvisation Cervantes created a better Don Quixote by dog in Don Quixote; second, through improvisation Cervantes created a better Don Quixote by transplanting the idea for a talking dog to the Coloquio; and third, that Cervantes made oblique transplanting the idea for a talking dog to the Coloquio; and third, that Cervantes made oblique references to the concept of dogs having human intelligence within the novel. references to the concept of dogs having human intelligence within the novel. Keywords: Cervantes; talking dogs; narratology; animal studies Keywords: Cervantes; talking dogs; narratology; animal studies 1. Introduction 1. Introduction “[Cervantes] saw his scenes and the actors in them as pictures in his mind before he put “[Cervantes]them on paper, saw much his scenes as El Greco and the [see actors Figure in1] madethem as little pictures clay models in his ofmind his figuresbefore beforehe put thempainting on paper, them.” much (Bell as1947 El ,Greco p.
    [Show full text]
  • Don Quijote in English
    Tilting at Windmills: Don Quijote in English _________________________________________ Michael J. McGrath rinted on the inside jacket of Edith Grossman’s 2003 transla- tion of Don Quijote is the following statement: “Unless you read PSpanish, you have never read Don Quixote.” For many people, the belief that a novel should be read in its original language is not contro- vertible. The Russian writer Dostoevsky learned Spanish just to be able to read Don Quijote. Lord Byron described his reading of the novel in Spanish as “a pleasure before which all others vanish” (Don Juan 14.98). Unfortunately, there are many readers who are unable to read the novel in its original language, and those who depend upon an English transla- tion may read a version that is linguistically and culturally quite different from the original. In his article “Traduttori Traditori: Don Quixote in English,” John Jay Allen cites the number of errors he encountered in different translations as a reason for writing the article. In addition, ac- cording to Allen, literary scholarship runs the risk of being skewed as a result of the translator’s inability to capture the text’s original meaning: I think that we Hispanists tend to forget that the overwhelming ma- jority of comments on Don Quixote by non-Spaniards—novelists, theoreticians of literature, even comparatists—are based upon read- ings in translation, and I, for one, had never considered just what this might mean for interpretation. The notorious difficulty in es- tablishing the locus of value in Don Quixote should alert us to the tremendous influence a translator may have in tipping the balance in what is obviously a delicate equilibrium of ambiguity and multi- valence.
    [Show full text]
  • The Female Gothic Connoisseur: Reading, Subjectivity, and the Feminist Uses of Gothic Fiction
    The Female Gothic Connoisseur: Reading, Subjectivity, and the Feminist Uses of Gothic Fiction By Monica Cristina Soare A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Ian Duncan, Chair Professor Julia Bader Professor Michael Iarocci Spring 2013 1 Abstract The Female Gothic Connoisseur: Reading, Subjectivity, and the Feminist Uses of Gothic Fiction by Monica Cristina Soare Doctor or Philosophy in English University of California, Berkeley Professor Ian Duncan, Chair In my dissertation I argue for a new history of female Romanticism in which the romance – and particularly the Gothic romance – comes to represent the transformative power of the aesthetic for the female reader. The literary figure in which this formulation inheres is the Female Quixote – an eighteenth-century amalgamation of Cervantes's reading idealist and the satirized figure of the learned woman – who embodies both aesthetic enthusiasm and a feminist claim on the world of knowledge. While the Female Quixote has generally been understood as a satirical figure, I show that she is actually at the forefront of a development in British aesthetics in which art comes to be newly valued as a bulwark against worldliness. Such a development arises as part of mid-eighteenth-century sensibility culture and changes the meaning of an aesthetic practice that had been to that point criticized and satirized – that of over-investment in the arts, associated, as I show, with both the figure of the connoisseur and of the Female Quixote.
    [Show full text]
  • World Notions Disorderly
    Quixote and the Logic of Exceptionalism Quixote Aaron R. Hanlon Aaron A WORLDof DISORDERLY NOTIONS A WORLD OF DISORDERLY NOTIONS A WORLD Y of DISORDERL NOTIONS h Quixote and the Logic of Exceptionalism Aaron R. Hanlon university of virginia press Charlottesville and London University of Virginia Press © 2019 by the Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America on acid- free paper First published 2019 1 3 5 7 9 8 6 4 2 Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data Names: Hanlon, Aaron R. (Aaron Raymond), 1982– author. Title: A world of disorderly notions : Quixote and the logic of exceptionalism / Aaron R. Hanlon. Description: Charlottesville : University of Virginia Press, 2019. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2018044533 | ISBN 9780813942162 (cloth : alk. paper) | ISBN 9780813942179 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: English fiction—18th century—History and criticism—Theory, etc. | Characters and characteristics in literature | American fiction—19th century—History and criticism—Theory, etc. | Exceptionalism in literature. | Cervantes Saavedra, Miguel de, 1547–1616. Don Quixote. | English fiction—Spanish influences. | American fiction—Spanish influences. Classification: LCC PR858.C47 H36 2019 | DDC 823/.50927—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018044533 Cover art: From vol. 1 of Don Quixote, Miguel de Cervantes (London: Cadell & Davies, 1818). Proof with etched letters, print by Francis Engleheart, after Robert Smirke. (Image © Trustees of the British Museum) For Nhi, crosser of boisterous oceans A world of disorderly notions, picked out of his books, crowded into his imagination. —Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote CONTENTS Introduction: Tilting at Concepts 1 Part I: The Character of Quixotism 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction: the Quixote Trope 1
    Notes Introduction: The Quixote Trope 1. As my Epilogue explores more fully, these terms stem from Nelson Goodman’s Ways of Worldmaking (Indianapolis: Hackett, 1978), 14 and passim. 2. Frederick Crews, Postmodern Pooh (New York: North Point Press, 2001), xv; Phyllis Trible, review of Leon Kass, The Beginning of Wisdom: Reading Genesis, in The New York Times Book Review (October 19, 2003): 28; Roger Kimball: The Rape of the Masters: How Political Correctness Sabotages Art (San Francisco: Encounter Books, 2004), 100, 152. 3. Surprisingly (or perhaps not), there has been little scholarly attention to “over-reading.” But see “Over-Reading, Overreading, Over Reading: Implications for Teaching and Learning,” ed. Jason Snart and Dean Swinford, a special issue of Inventio: Creative Thinking and Learning 5, 1 (2003). 4. Wendy Motooka, Age of Reasons: Quixotism, Sentimentalism and Political Economy in Eighteenth-Century Britain (London: Routledge, 1998), 27. 5. Jonathan Swift, A Tale of a Tub, ed. S. C. Guthkelch and D. Nichol Smith, second edition (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958), 52. 6. See Barbara Johnson, “Melville’s Fist: The Execution of Billy Budd,” in The Critical Difference: Essays in the Contemporary Rhetoric of Reading (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980), 79–109. 7. J. L. Austin, How to Do Things with Words, second edition (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1975), 117. 8. Bernard Mandeville, Free Thoughts on Religion, The Church and National Happiness, ed. Irwin Primer (New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 2001), 134. I am grateful to Irwin Primer for this reference. 9. John Dewey, Human Nature and Conduct (1922) in John Dewey: The Middle Works, 1899–1924, ed.
    [Show full text]