Epilepsy: an Autoimmune Disease?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2000;69:711–714 711 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.69.6.711 on 1 December 2000. Downloaded from EDITORIAL Epilepsy: an autoimmune disease? Epilepsy may present as a symptom of many neurological LANDAU-KLEFFNER SYNDROME disorders and often an aetiological explanation cannot be This childhood syndrome, first described in 1957, is char- identified. There is growing evidence that autoimmune acterised by aphasia, behavioural problems, and seizures mechanisms might have a role in some patients. This (often of partial motor in type). The EEG recorded during includes numerous reports of the detection of theoretically sleep is diagnostic and shows focal and multifocal spikes relevant serum autoantibodies, experimental data showing and spike wave discharges predominantly in the temporal that antibodies can be epileptogenic, and a response of and parietal regions. In many cases onset can be temporally some epilepsy syndromes to immunomodulation. related to a previous infection. Autoantibodies directed The evidence for immunological mechanisms in epilepsy against brain endothelial cells and neuronal nuclear can be examined within the following three main areas: the proteins have been reported.7 Case reports of successful childhood epilepsy syndromes, epilepsy associated with treatment with IVIg treatment exist,89although this is not other immunologically mediated diseases, and the more an invariable finding. common unselected groups of patients with epilepsy. copyright. WEST’S SYNDROME (INFANTILE SPASMS) AND Childhood epilepsy syndromes LENNOX-GASTAUT SYNDROME Although both West’s syndrome and Lennox-Gastaut syn- RASMUSSEN’S ENCEPHALITIS Rasmussen’s encephalitis is a rare progressive disorder of drome have very diVerent clinical phenotypes, both syndromes have been reported to respond well to IVIg unilateral brain dysfunction, focal seizures, and inflamma- 10–13 tory histopathology. It usually presents in middle child- therapy. Among the numerous unblinded studies pub- hood with intractable seizures and progressive neurological lished most have reported a positive response to treatment. deficits culminating in hemiparesis. The seizures are often Van Engelen et al have reviewed the use of IVIg treatment resistant to antiepileptic drugs. Treatment with cortico- in childhood epilepsies and concluded that although there was no formal evidence of eYcacy due to lack of controlled steroids, intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg), or plas- 13 mapheresis has been reported to be beneficial in some.12 trials, some patients benefited greatly from this treatment. http://jnnp.bmj.com/ However, no blinded placebo controlled trials have been In one series of children with West’s syndrome 33% showed a positive response, with a rapid and permanent undertaken to confirm the eYcacy of such treatments. In 11 many children with Rasmussen’s encephalitis control of resolution in 21% of those treated. One placebo control- their epilepsy may only be obtained by hemispherectomy. led (single blind crossover) study of 10 patients with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome reported a reduction in seizures The serendipitous finding that rabbits immunised with a 14 fusion protein of glutamate receptor (GluR) 3 (but not in 20% of patients. Reports of an activated but functionally impaired GluR 1, 2, 5, or 6) developed seizures and histopathologi- 15 16 cal changes that mimicked Rasmussen’s encephalitis initi- immune system, increased serum immunoglobulins and on September 28, 2021 by guest. Protected a HLA DR5 association in Lennox-Gastaut syndrome fur- ated the Rasmussen’s encephalitis autoimmune hypoth- 17 esis.3 However, mice immunised with GluR3, which ther supports immunological involvement. developed high concentrations of anti-GluR3 antibodies and brain pathology reminiscent of the disease did not go Epilepsy associated with autoimmune diseases on to develop epilepsy.4 Antibodies against GluR3 (and Seizures occur in association with some antibody mediated GluR2 at low concentrations) have been detected in the autoimmune diseases aVecting the CNS—namely, sys- serum of some patients with Rasmussen’s encephalitis3; temic lupus erythematosus, stiV man syndrome, and however, confirmatory reports from other groups and Hashimoto’s encephalopathy. studies determining the frequency of these antibodies in consecutive series of patients with the disease are notable SYSTEMIC LUPUS ERYTHEMATOSUS for their absence. Similarly, a systematic search for other The incidence of epilepsy in patients with systemic lupus autoantibodies in patients with Rasmussen’s encephalitis erythematosus is raised to between 5.4%-10%.18–21 The has not been performed. A pathogenic role for these anti- seizures tend to respond to anticonvulsant drugs, and19 can GluR3 antibodies has been postulated with experimental take any form, with various EEG abnormalities re- data indicating their ability to activate cortical neurons and ported.18 19 22 Epilepsy is particularly common in associ- induce complement dependent and independent ation with the presence of anticardiolipin antibodies, espe- cytotoxicity.4–6 cially in high titre18 19; the lupus anticoagulant18 22; and the www.jnnp.com 712 Palace, Lang J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.69.6.711 on 1 December 2000. Downloaded from antiphospholipid syndrome.22 23 However, these findings presence of intrathecal antibodies and a response to are not universal.20 24 Brain MRI tends to be normal in corticosteroids. Within a series of seven such patients one those with epilepsy alone19 but abnormal in those with had complex partial epilepsy and recurrent status epilepti- clinical features of the antiphospholipid syndrome.23 In cus without other clinical features.36 The CSF may contain another study of patients with systemic lupus erythemato- increased protein concentrations, a pleocytosis, and oligo- sus admitted to hospital, an association of epilepsy with clonal bands, and MRI may be normal although atrophy, stroke (clinical or on imaging) was reported.22 white matter lesions, and ischaemic changes have all been The role of these antiphospholipid antibodies in causing reported.35–37 Cerebral oedema, immune complex cerebral epilepsy has been open to debate. Possible mechanisms vasculitis, acute disseminated encephalomyelitis, and a include a direct eVect of antibodies causing seizures, the direct antibody eVect possibly due to a common trapping of immune complexes within vessels resulting in “brain/thyroid” antigen are possible mechanisms to explain seizures, and antiphospholipid antibodies causing microv- the syndrome. ascular lesions. The direct eVect of antibodies in provoking epilepsy is supported by studies showing that antibrain antibodies can directly cause seizures325; that serum from Antibodies associated with unselected patients with patients with systemic lupus erythematosus with epilepsy epilepsy and anticardiolipin antibodies can inhibit Cl− currents Raised concentrations of serum antibodies, which recog- through the GABA receptor complex26; and that the pres- nise brain antigens, have been detected in groups of 38 39 ence of anticardiolipin antibodies in the CSF is longitudi- patients with isolated epilepsy. A dramatic response to nally associated with clinical symptoms.27 The finding that IVIg has been reported in a group of children with refrac- 40 antiphospholipid antibodies react directly with CNS tory seizures. In addition more specific antibodies have tissue28 does not rule out secondary damage as a been detected in such patients with epilepsy alone. mechanism for seizures. Ischaemia induced seizures secondary to a hypercoaguable state is backed by reports of ANTIPHOSPHOLIPID AND ANTINUCLEAR ANTIBODIES abnormal imaging and an association with stroke in some An increased incidence of antiphospholipid antibodies has groups of patients. Even in the presence of normal imaging been reported in consecutive patients with epilepsy of postmortem has disclosed cerebral microinfarctions.19 unexplained cause without the antiphospholipid syndrome Many patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and epi- or systemic lupus erythematosus. One series found lupus lepsy have no detectable antiphospholipid antibodies in the anticoagulant in 6% of patients with epilepsy admitted to serum or the CSF, so other processes such as infection, hospital, all of whom were men in their sixth to eighth dec- metabolic abnormalities, or as yet unidentified antibodies ade.41 In patients seen at an epilepsy centre there was an could be responsible. It is of interest that anti-GM1 increase in the incidence of anticardiolipin IgG and antibodies, reported to be epileptogenic, have been identi- antinuclear antibody positivity, a sixfold and 2.5-fold risk copyright. fied in 15.5% of patients with systemic lupus erythemato- respectively.42 All types of epilepsy were seen and the sus.29 seizures were generally well controlled with antiepileptic drugs. In a series of children with cryptogenic partial epi- STIFF MAN SYNDROME lepsy 13% had high titres of antiphospholipid antibodies, The stiV man syndrome is a rare CNS disease character- all with frontal lobe seizures and normal imaging, whereas ised by progressive rigidity and painful spasms of the mus- none were found in the control groups.43 One case had cles. Serum antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase refractory seizures, which resolved with the temporary (GAD), the cytoplasmic enzyme that catalyses the conver- addition of corticosteroids. sion of glutamate to GABA, have