DOCSLIB.ORG

Decision No 540

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Decision No 540 PUBLIC VERSION ISSN NO. 0114-2720 J6822 Commerce Commission Decision No 540 Determination pursuant to the Commerce Act 1986 in the matter of an application for clearance of a business acquisition involving: VECTOR LIMITED and NGC HOLDINGS LIMITED The Commission: P R Rebstock D R Bates QC D F Curtin Summary of Application: Vector Limited or an interconnected body corporate has sought clearance to acquire, whether directly or indirectly, up to and including 100% of the shares in NGC Holdings Limited Determination: Pursuant to section 66(3) (a)/(b) of the Commerce Act 1986, the Commission determines to give clearance to the proposed acquisition. Date of Determination: 10 December 2004 CONFIDENTIAL MATERIAL IN THIS REPORT IS CONTAINED IN SQUARE BRACKETS 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS THE PROPOSAL ....................................................................................................................4 STATUTORY FRAMEWORK..............................................................................................4 ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK............................................................................................4 THE PARTIES.........................................................................................................................5 Vector....................................................................................................................................5 NGC.......................................................................................................................................5 PREVIOUS DECISIONS........................................................................................................6 THE INVESTIGATION .........................................................................................................6 MARKET DEFINITION ........................................................................................................7 Introduction..........................................................................................................................7 Relevant Trading Activities ................................................................................................8 The Markets for the Distribution of Gas...........................................................................9 Electricity Metering Markets ...........................................................................................10 Electricity Meter Product Markets ..................................................................................10 Geographic Markets ........................................................................................................12 Conclusion on Electricity Metering Market Definition ...................................................12 The Gas Transmission Market .........................................................................................12 Gas Retailing ......................................................................................................................12 Summary of Relevant Markets.........................................................................................13 COMPETITION ANALYSIS...............................................................................................13 Substantially Lessening Competition...............................................................................13 The Counterfactual............................................................................................................14 Competitive Impacts of the Acquisition...........................................................................14 COMPETITIVE IMPACTS IN METERING MARKETS ...............................................14 Introduction........................................................................................................................14 Existing Competition in the Metering Market................................................................15 Conclusion on Existing Competition ...............................................................................16 Potential Competition in the Metering Market ..............................................................16 Introduction......................................................................................................................16 Barriers to Entry in the Metering Market........................................................................17 Conclusion on Potential Competition in the Metering Market........................................18 Countervailing Power........................................................................................................18 Conclusion on Countervailing Power..............................................................................19 3 Conclusion on Metering Markets.....................................................................................19 COMPETITIVE IMPACTS IN THE GREATER AUCKLAND GAS DISTRIBUTION MARKET................................................................................................................................19 COMPETITIVE IMPACTS IN OTHER GAS DISTRIBUTION MARKETS - IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS OF THE GAS CONTROL INQUIRY .............20 The Gas Control Inquiry...................................................................................................20 Issues Raised by the Conclusions Reached in the Gas Inquiry .....................................21 Limitations on Constraints Which Might be Considered ..............................................23 Consideration of Behaviour ..............................................................................................23 COMPETITIVE IMPACTS OF VERTICAL INTEGRATION.......................................24 Introduction........................................................................................................................24 The Ability of Vector to Foreclose Competition Post-Acquisition................................25 Industry Concerns............................................................................................................25 Vector’s Response to These Specific Concerns ...............................................................26 Gas Governance and Regulatory Regime........................................................................27 Analysis............................................................................................................................28 Incentives to Foreclose.......................................................................................................28 Constraints on Foreclosure...............................................................................................28 Evidence from Other Vertically Integrated Gas Supply Situations..............................29 Impact on Bypass Competition.........................................................................................29 Conclusion on Vertical Integration..................................................................................30 OVERALL CONCLUSION..................................................................................................30 DETERMINATION ON NOTICE OF CLEARANCE......................................................31 4 THE PROPOSAL 1. A Notice under s 66(1) of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act) was registered on 11 August 2004. The notice was an application for clearance (the Application) for Vector Limited (Vector) to acquire up to and including 100% of the shares in NGC Holdings Limited (NGC). 2. Section 66(3) of the Act requires the Commission either to give clearance or to decline to give clearance in respect of a notice under s 66(1) within 10 working days, unless the Commission and the person who gave notice agree to a longer period. Two extensions of time were agreed between the Commission and Vector. Accordingly, a decision on the Application was required by 10 December 2004. 3. The Applicant sought confidentiality for specific aspects of the Application. A confidentiality order was made in respect of the information for up to 20 working days from the Commission’s Notice of Determination. When that order expires, the provisions of the Official Information Act 1982 will apply. 4. The Commission’s approach to analysing this proposed Acquisition is based on principles set out in the Commission’s Merger and Acquisition Guidelines.1 STATUTORY FRAMEWORK 5. Under s 66 of the Act, the Commission may grant clearances for acquisitions where it is satisfied that the proposed acquisition would not have, or would not be likely to have, the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market. The standard of proof that the Commission must apply in making its determination is the civil standard of the balance of probabilities.2 6. The Commission considers that, to find a substantial lessening of competition, it is necessary to identify a real lessening of competition that is not minimal.3 Competition must be lessened in a considerable and sustainable way. For the purposes of its analysis, the Commission is of the view that a lessening of competition and creation, enhancement or facilitation of the exercise of market power may be taken as being equivalent. 7. When the impact of market power is expected to be predominantly upon price, for the lessening, or likely lessening, of competition to be regarded as substantial, the anticipated price increase relative to what would otherwise have occurred in the market has to be both material, and able to be sustained for a period of at least two years.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Country's Biggest Warehouse Stationery Store
    group executive GREG MUIR DAVID WILSON ROBERT SMITH PAUL HUTCHINSON BRUCE GORDON GRAHAM CHAD NEVILLE BROWN KEITH SMITH HAMISH McKENZIE BRENT WALDRON JOAN WITHERS STEPHEN TINDALL DAVE RICKARDS ROBERT CHALLINOR GLEN INGER NEIL PLUMMER JOHN AVERY JOHN DAHLSEN GRAHAM EVEVANSANS directors contents Chief Executive Officer’s Review ..........................................................................................................3 Triple Bottom Line Summary Report ....................................................................................................11 Corporate Governance ......................................................................................................................14 Founder’s Report ..............................................................................................................................22 Ten Year Review ..............................................................................................................................24 Financials ........................................................................................................................................26 highlights of the year Between 1 August 2000 and 31 July 2001 The Warehouse Group achieved an audited net surplus after tax of $60.8 million The Warehouse Group achieved sales of $1.665 billion The Warehouse New Zealand opened nine new stores - six in new locations and three replacement stores Warehouse Stationery opened nine new stores The Warehouse Australia opened ten new stores - eight in new locations
    [Show full text]
  • Download PDF
    Table of Contents Executive summary ............................................................................................... 2 What Auckland consumers have to say about electricity retail issues ........................... 3 The EAP has not fully met the requirements of the terms of reference ......................... 4 The big-5 incumbent retailers are to blame for residential price increases .................... 5 Sweet-heart deals with Tiwai Smelter are keeping prices artificially high ...................... 6 Stronger wholesale and retail competition needed to make electricity more affordable ... 8 Saves & Winbacks is making the two-tier retail market problem worse ...................... 11 Late payment penalties disadvantage vulnerable Kiwis unable to pay on time ............. 14 Prepayment arrangements exploit vulnerable consumers ......................................... 18 There are questions about compliance with the Vulnerable Consumer Guidelines and the objectives of the Guidelines .................................................................................. 19 Concluding remarks and recommendations ............................................................. 20 Appendix 1: Price increases over the last 18-years largely driven by retail (energy) .... 22 Appendix 2: Manipulation of pricing data can make it look like lines are to blame ........ 27 Appendix 3: The electricity retail and generation markets are highly “concentrated” .... 30 Appendix 4: Retail competition improvements driven by the last inquiry reforms
    [Show full text]
  • Westpac Online Investment Loan Acceptable Securities List - Effective 3 September2021
    Westpac Online Investment Loan Acceptable Securities List - Effective 3 September2021 ASX listed securities ASX Code Security Name LVR ASX Code Security Name LVR A2M The a2 Milk Company Limited 50% CIN Carlton Investments Limited 60% ABC Adelaide Brighton Limited 60% CIP Centuria Industrial REIT 50% ABP Abacus Property Group 60% CKF Collins Foods Limited 50% ADI APN Industria REIT 40% CL1 Class Limited 45% AEF Australian Ethical Investment Limited 40% CLW Charter Hall Long Wale Reit 60% AFG Australian Finance Group Limited 40% CMW Cromwell Group 60% AFI Australian Foundation Investment Co. Ltd 75% CNI Centuria Capital Group 50% AGG AngloGold Ashanti Limited 50% CNU Chorus Limited 60% AGL AGL Energy Limited 75% COF Centuria Office REIT 50% AIA Auckland International Airport Limited 60% COH Cochlear Limited 65% ALD Ampol Limited 70% COL Coles Group Limited 75% ALI Argo Global Listed Infrastructure Limited 60% CPU Computershare Limited 70% ALL Aristocrat Leisure Limited 60% CQE Charter Hall Education Trust 50% ALQ Als Limited 65% CQR Charter Hall Retail Reit 60% ALU Altium Limited 50% CSL CSL Limited 75% ALX Atlas Arteria 60% CSR CSR Limited 60% AMC Amcor Limited 75% CTD Corporate Travel Management Limited ** 40% AMH Amcil Limited 50% CUV Clinuvel Pharmaceuticals Limited 40% AMI Aurelia Metals Limited 35% CWN Crown Limited 60% AMP AMP Limited 60% CWNHB Crown Resorts Ltd Subordinated Notes II 60% AMPPA AMP Limited Cap Note Deferred Settlement 60% CWP Cedar Woods Properties Limited 45% AMPPB AMP Limited Capital Notes 2 60% CWY Cleanaway Waste
    [Show full text]
  • FTSE New Zealand Index
    FTSE Russell Factsheet FTSE New Zealand Index (USD) Data as at: 31 August 2021 bmkTitle1 The FTSE New Zealand Index is a market-capitalization weighted index representing the FEATURES performance of large and mid-cap New Zealand companies that are constituents of the FTSE All- World Index. Coverage Derived from the FTSE Global Equity Index The index is derived from the FTSE Global Equity Index Series (GEIS), which covers 99% of the Series (GEIS), which covers 99% of the world’s investable market capitalization. world’s investable market capitalisation. 10-Year Performance - Total Return Objective (USD) The index is designed for use in the creation 300 of index tracking funds, derivatives and as a 250 performance benchmark. 200 Investability 150 Stocks are selected and weighted to ensure 100 that the index is investable. 50 Liquidity Aug-2011 Aug-2012 Aug-2013 Aug-2014 Aug-2015 Aug-2016 Aug-2017 Aug-2018 Aug-2019 Aug-2020 Aug-2021 Data as at month end Stocks are screened to ensure that the index is tradable. FTSE New Zealand FTSE New Zealand USD Net Tax Transparency The index uses a transparent, rules-based Performance and Volatility - Total Return construction process. Index methodologies Index (USD) Return % Return pa %* Volatility %** are freely available on the FTSE Russell 3M 6M YTD 12M 3YR 5YR 3YR 5YR 1YR 3YR 5YR website. FTSE New Zealand 1.7 0.9 -8.1 2.8 41.6 54.6 12.3 9.1 18.4 21.4 17.8 Availability FTSE New Zealand USD Net Tax 1.5 0.5 -8.5 2.2 38.4 48.1 11.4 8.2 18.4 21.5 17.9 The index is calculated based on price and * Compound annual returns measured over 3 and 5 years respectively total return methodologies, both real time ** Volatility – 1YR based on 12 months daily data.
    [Show full text]
  • RETAIL BOND Investor Presentation
    RETAIL BOND Investor Presentation VECTOR May 2019 1 DISCLAIMER This presentation has been prepared by Vector Limited (“Vector”) in relation to the offer of unsecured, unsubordinated fixed rate bonds described in this presentation (“Bonds”). Vector has lodged a Product Disclosure Statement dated 1 May 2019 (“PDS”) with the Registrar of Financial Service Providers in New Zealand (“Registrar”) and made available the information on the register of offers of financial products administered by the Registrar (“Register Entry”) (the PDS and the Register Entry, together the “Offer Materials’) in respect of the offer of Bonds (“Offer”). The Offer Materials should be read before any investment decision is made. A copy of the PDS is available through www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/disclose (OFR 12633) or by contacting the Joint Lead Managers (defined below). This presentation does not constitute a recommendation by Vector or ANZ Bank New Zealand Limited, Deutsche Craigs Limited, Forsyth Barr Limited and Westpac Banking Corporation (ABN 33 007 457 141) (acting through its New Zealand Branch), (together, the “Joint Lead Managers”), or Craigs Investment Partners Limited acting as Organising Participant (together with the Joint Lead Managers, the “Syndicate”) nor any of their respective directors, officers, employees or agents to sell, purchase or retain the Bonds. None of the Syndicate nor any of their respective directors, officers, employees and agents: (a) accept any responsibility or liability whatsoever for any loss arising from this presentation or
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2013 ANNUAL REPORT Contact 2013
    here Annual Report 2013 ANNUAL REPORT Contact 2013 ...is where we do our best work. CONTENTS Contact 2013 At Contact… We keep the lights burning, We are one of New Zealand’s largest listed companies but we operate with the same genuine concern for our the hot water flowing and the customers and communities as the smallest. We are BBQ fired up for around 566,000 integral to our customers’ lives – and our customers customers across the country. are integral to us. OUR BEST WORK 4 CASE STUDIES 30 CONTACT AT A GLANCE 12 HOW WE OPERATE 40 OUR BUSINESS MODEL 14 GOVERNANCE 56 WHERE WE OPERATE 16 REMUNERATION REPORT 62 KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS 18 STATUTORY DISCLOSURES 65 CHAIRMAN & CEO’S REVIEW 20 FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 69 OUR BOARD 26 INDEPENDENT AUDITOR’S REPORT 99 OUR LEADERSHIP TEAM 28 CORPORATE DIRECTORY 100 This Annual Report is dated 5 September 2013 and is signed on behalf of the Board by: Grant King Sue Sheldon Follow us at facebook.com/contactenergy Chairman Director OUR BEST WORK Contact 2013 “The kids think there’s always money on the card – they think nothing of a 30 minute shower.” Contact customer research Everyone in the family has unique habits when it comes to energy use. That can make it tough for households to manage their energy costs. We’ve created an easy-to-use online tool, called HEAT, to help our customers manage their energy and identify practical ways to save money on their energy bills. 4 Contact Energy LIMITED Annual Report 2013 Contact Energy LIMITED Annual Report 2013 5 OUR BEST WORK Contact 2013 “I’ll come home on a sunny day and she’ll have the dryer on for half an hour to do her bra and knickers.” Contact customer research Household energy costs vary from month to month as energy use fluctuates.
    [Show full text]
  • Laura Ogorman CV Short Form&Nbsp;
    Laura O'Gorman B a r r i s t e r , B a n k s i d e C h a m b e r s e: [email protected] p: 09-200 1501 w: logorman.com O V E R V I E W Barrister with over 23 years of legal experience in a broad range of commercial litigation. Leading Lawyer SPECIALIST AREAS Skills recognised by directory rankings Lender and Insolvency Highly experienced Judicial review and statutory appeals Over 23 years of Contract and company law disputes experience with broad Problem solver expertise Conflict of laws (private international law) Innovative, efficient, tenacious IP and media Intellectual Competition and fair trading LLM from Cambridge, Land law enjoys complex and Commercial challenging matters Pragmatic, BCom in See website for details. accounting and finance Integrity Committed to professional values S E L E C T H I G H L I G H T S Zespri Group Limited v Gao [2020] NZHC 109 (HC) Milk New Zealand (Shanghai) Co Ltd v Miraka Limited [2019] NZHC 2713; [2020] NZHC 697 (HC) Vector Limited v The Electricity Authority [2019] 3 NZLR 19; [2019] NZAR 60 (CA) Sky Network Television Ltd v My Box NZ Ltd (2018) 136 IPR 341 (HC) Cargill International S.A. v Solid Energy New Zealand Ltd [2016] NZHC 1817 (HC) Planet Kids Limited v Auckland Council [2014] 1 NZLR 149; (2013) 14 NZCPR 694 (SC) Fortes v Bank of New Zealand [2014] NZCA 346 (CA) Turners & Growers Ltd v Zespri Group Ltd (2011) 13 TCLR 286 (HC) New Zealand Bus Ltd v Commerce Commission [2008] 3 NZLR 433 (CA) W O R K E X P E R I E N C E E D U C A T I O N BANKSIDE CHAMBERS 1999 MASTER'S DEGREE Barrister sole, from
    [Show full text]
  • Attendee Conference Pack
    Wind Energy Conference 2021 Rising to the Challenge 12 May 2021, InterContinental Hotel, Wellington, New Zealand Programme Joseph, aged 9 We would like to thank our sponsors for their support 2021 Wind Energy Conference – 12th May 2021 Wind Energy Conference Programme 12 May 2021 InterContinental, Wellington Rising to the Challenge Welcome and Minister’s The energy sector and renewables Presentation ▪ Hon Dr Megan Woods, Minister of Energy and Resources 8.30 – 9.00 Session 1 Facilitator: Dr Christina Hood, Compass Climate Decarbonising the New Zealand’s journey to net zero carbon energy sector ▪ Hon James Shaw, Minister of Climate Change 9.00 to 10.45 Infrastructure implications of decarbonisation ▪ Ross Copland, New Zealand Infrastructure Commission The industrial heat opportunity ▪ Linda Mulvihill, Fonterra Panel and Audience Discussion – testing our key opportunities and level of ambition ▪ Ross Copland, New Zealand Infrastructure Commission ▪ Linda Mulvihill, Fonterra ▪ Briony Bennett (she/her), Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment ▪ Matt Burgess, The New Zealand Initiative ▪ Liz Yeaman, Retyna Ltd Morning Tea Sponsored by Ara Ake 10.45 to 11.15 Session 2 Waipipi, Delivering a wind farm during a global pandemic Jim Pearson, Tilt Renewables Building new wind Australian renewables and wind development update 11.15 -1.00 ▪ Kane Thornton, Clean Energy Council DNV’s Energy Transition Outlook what it means for wind energy ▪ Graham Slack, DNV A changing regulatory landscape and implications for wind and other renewables ▪ Amelia
    [Show full text]
  • Notice of Special Meeting Vector Limited
    PLEASE READ Notice of Special Meeting Vector Limited Notice is given that a special meeting of the shareholders of Vector Limited will be held in the Guineas Ballroom, Ellerslie Event Centre, Ellerslie Racecourse, 80 Ascot Avenue, Remuera, Auckland, New Zealand, on 16 December 2015, commencing at 11am AGENDA ORDINARY RESOLUTION; TO CONSIDER, AND IF THOUGHT FIT, PASS THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION: To approve the sale by NGC Holdings Limited of all of the shares in Vector Gas Limited to Odysseus Investments Limited under an Agreement for the Sale and Purchase of shares in Vector Gas Limited dated 9 November 2015 between Vector Limited, NGC Holdings Limited, Odysseus Investments Limited and Colonial First State Infrastructure Managers (Australia) Pty Limited as manager and agent for Colonial First State Managed Infrastructure Limited as trustee for the Global Diversified Infrastructure Fund (Active), as required by clause 34.1 of Vector Limited’s constitution. By Order of the Board Diane Green Company Secretary 30 November 2015 ORDINARY RESOLUTIONS: Ordinary resolutions are required to be approved by a simple majority of more than 50% of votes validly cast at the Special Meeting. SHAREHOLDERS ENTITLED TO ATTEND AND VOTE: Pursuant to section 125 of the Companies Act 1993, the Board has determined that, for the purposes of voting at the Special Meeting, only those registered shareholders of the Company as at 5.00pm on 10 December 2015, being a day not more than 20 working days before the meeting, shall be entitled to exercise the right to vote at the meeting. PROXIES: Any person entitled to attend and vote at the meeting may appoint another person as his/her proxy (or representative in the case of a corporate shareholder) to attend and vote instead of him/her.
    [Show full text]
  • A Bold Vision
    Creating a new energy future – a bold vision ANNUAL REPORT 2021 Our vision Creating a new energy future – a bold vision isn’t linear. In pursuing our vision over the past few years, we’ve had to be flexible and adaptable. We haven’t been afraid to challenge the status quo. As leaders of the transformation of the energy sector, we know the ‘same old’ just won’t cut it. We have the confidence to forge new solutions and for our people to work differently, to think differently. We have collaborated with global technology companies and thought leaders who share our view that innovation and digitalisation are key to meeting the future needs of energy systems and fast-evolving customer demands. As governments, businesses and consumers urgently take action to decarbonise, at Vector we are clear on our vision – creating a new energy future. It’s bold. 1 VECTOR ANNUAL REPORT 2021 / 2 Creating a new energy future – a bold vision Contents Performance snapshot 4 Chair and Group Chief Executive report 6 Chief Financial Officer report 12 Our people and safety 14 Regulated networks 16 Gas trading 20 Metering 21 Our climate and sustainability 22 Our Board 26 Our management team 28 Governance report 30 Entrust, majority shareholder of Vector 39 Joint ventures and investments 40 Operating statistics 41 Financial performance trends 42 Non-GAAP financial information 44 Financials 45 Independent auditor’s report 90 Statutory information 96 Financial calendar and directory 106 About this report This report, dated 23 August 2021, is a review of Vector’s financial and operational performance for the year ended 30 June 2021.
    [Show full text]
  • Westpac NZD Account 8.36% New Zealand Local Government
    FULL PORTFOLIO HOLDINGS Offer name: Kiwi Wealth KiwiSaver Scheme Offer number: OFR10715 Fund name: Default Fund number: FND553 Periodic disclosure applies [dd/mm/yyyy] 30/06/2021 Asset Name % of fund net assets Security Code Westpac NZD Account 8.36% New Zealand Local Government Funding Agency Bond 3.5% 14 Apr 33 1.86% NZLGFDT009C0 14/4/2033 New Zealand Local Government Funding Agency Bond 4.5% 15 Apr 27 1.57% NZLGFDT007C4 15/4/2027 New Zealand Local Government Funding Agency Bond 1.5% 20 Apr 29 1.47% NZLGFDT012C4 20/4/2029 Westpac New Zealand - TD - 0.93% 05 Jul 21 5/7/2021 1.46% DU0TZ21705D8 Housing New Zealand Ltd 3.42% 18 Oct 28 18/10/2028 1.38% NZHNZD0628L7 Kommunalbanken AS 4% 20 Aug 25 20/8/2025 1.34% NZKBNDT009C6 International Bank for Reconstruction & Development 1.625% 10 1.24% NZIBDDT018C3 May 28 10/5/2028 Landwirtschaftliche Rentenbank 0.75% 09 Jun 25 9/6/2025 1.13% NZLRBDT014C1 New Zealand Government Bond 2% 15 May 32 15/5/2032 1.10% NZGOVDT532C8 Kommunalbanken AS 1.25% 02 Jul 30 2/7/2030 1.08% NZKBNDT012C0 Bank of China Ltd - TD - 0.75% 08 Sep 21 8/9/2021 1.05% DU0TZ21908A4 ANZ Bank Ltd - TD - 0.85% 13 Sep 21 13/9/2021 0.99% DU0TZ21913C0 Transpower New Zealand Ltd 1.735% 04 Sep 25 4/9/2025 0.96% NZTRPD0070L9 ANZ Bank Ltd - TD - 0.85% 20 Sep 21 20/9/2021 0.94% DU0TZ21920B7 ASB Bank - TD - 0.81% 22 Dec 21 22/12/2021 0.93% DU0TZ21D22A6 ANZ Bank Ltd - TD - 0.85% 26 Jul 21 26/7/2021 0.88% DU0TZ21726C6 ANZ Bank Ltd - TD - 0.85% 24 Aug 21 24/8/2021 0.88% DU0TZ21824A3 Westpac New Zealand - TD - 0.77% 29 Nov 21 29/11/2021 0.88% DU0TZ21N29C6
    [Show full text]
  • A: Strengthening the Consumer Voice
    A: Strengthening the consumer voice A1: Establish a consumer advisory council We support the option to establish a consumer advisory council. However, in order to be effective, this council will need to avoid industry and regulatory capture and will need to maintain a strong focus on consumer, rather than industry, needs. To do this the group will need to be underpinned by strong customer data analytics and evidence and should have a structure which is independent from undue industry or regulatory influence. It should also have strong consumer representation. We agree with the Panel and that setting up a Consumer Advisory Council to promote the interests of residential and small business consumers is a positive step to help overcome the complexity of the electricity sector and to give consumers a voice in decision-making. However, as noted by the Panel, the complexity of the electricity sector can make it difficult for consumers to engage with industry and regulatory decision making. There is therefore a risk that the proposed Council may simply rely on the views of external consultants to inform their positions and decision making, which could lead to industry and/or regulatory capture of the Council. Appointing a regulator to act as Secretariat would also raise similar concerns. A number of the options put forward in the Paper signal that the EA has not adequately accounted for consumer interests in its approach. For example, the proposed Government Policy Statement (GPS) on transmission pricing highlights the limitations of a narrow focus on pure economic efficiency at the expense of consumer experience – the impact of price shocks on consumers, and particularly those experiencing energy hardship, has been raised with some concern by the Panel.
    [Show full text]