1
Triplet Repeat Diseases
Stephan J. Guyenet and Albert R. La Spada University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195
1 A Novel Mechanism of Genetic Mutation Emerges 3 1.1 Repeat Sequences of All Types and Sizes 3 1.2 Trinucleotide Repeat Expansion as a Cause of Disease: Unique Features Explain Unusual Genetics 4
2 Repeat Diseases and Their Classification 5 2.1 Summary of Repeat Diseases 5 2.2 Differences in Repeat Sequence Composition and Location within Gene 6 2.3 Classification Based upon Mechanism of Pathogenesis and Nature of Mutation 6
3 Type 1: The CAG/Polyglutamine Repeat Diseases 9 3.1 Spinal and Bulbar Muscular Atrophy 9 3.2 Huntington’s Disease 12 3.3 Dentatorubral Pallidoluysian Atrophy 15 3.4 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 1 16 3.5 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 2 18 3.6 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 3/Machado–Joseph Disease 19 3.7 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 6 21 3.8 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 7 22 3.9 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 17 25 3.10 Role of Aggregation in Polyglutamine Disease Pathogenesis 25 3.11 Protein Context 29 3.12 Transcriptional Dysregulation 30 3.13 Proteolytic Cleavage 30
4 Type 2: the Loss-of-function Repeat Diseases 33 4.1 Fragile X Syndrome 33
Encyclopedia of Molecular Cell Biology and Molecular Medicine, 2nd Edition. Volume 15 Edited by Robert A. Meyers. Copyright 2005 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN: 3-527-30652-8 2 Triplet Repeat Diseases
4.2 Fragile XE Mental Retardation 34 4.3 Friedreich’s Ataxia 36 4.4 Progressive Myoclonus Epilepsy Type 1 39
5 Type 3: the RNA Gain-of-function Repeat Diseases 40 5.1 Myotonic Dystrophy Type 1 40 5.2 Myotonic Dystrophy Type 2 42 5.3 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 8 43 5.4 The Fragile X Tremor – Ataxia Syndrome (FXTAS) 44
6 Type 4: The Polyalanine Diseases 46 6.1 Overview 46 6.2 Oculopharyngeal Muscular dystrophy 46 6.3 Synpolydactyly (Syndactyly Type II) 48 6.4 Cleidocranial Dysplasia 48 6.5 Holoprosencephaly 48 6.6 Hand-foot-genital Syndrome 49 6.7 Blepharophimosis-ptosis-epicanthus Inversus Syndrome 49 6.8 Syndromic and Nonsyndromic X-linked Mental Retardation 49 6.9 Congenital Central Hypoventilation Syndrome 50
7 Unclassified Repeat Diseases Lacking Mechanistic Explanations 50 7.1 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 10 50 7.2 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 12 51 7.3 Huntington’s Disease Like 2 (HDL2) 52
Bibliography 54 Books and Reviews 54 Primary Literature 54
Keywords
Aggregate Accumulation of proteinaceous and/or ribonucleic acid material into a structure that is visible in a cell at the light microscope level.
Anticipation Worsening severity of a disease phenotype as the causal (typically dominant) genetic mutation is transmitted from one generation to the next in a family segregating the disease of interest. Triplet Repeat Diseases 3
Gain of function Refers to a type of mutation that imparts a novel activity or action to the gene product containing the mutation.
Loss of function Refers to a type of mutation that eliminates the action of the gene product encoded by the gene within which the mutation resides.
Repeat Expansion An elongation of a repeat to a larger size that no longer falls within the size distribution range typically seen in the normal population; this process is now recognized as a mechanism of human genetic mutation.
Trinucleotide Three DNA base pairs of specific sequence composition (e.g. cytosine-adenine- guanine).
The repeat expansion disorders are a group of human diseases that are caused by the elongation of a DNA repeat sequence. In this chapter, we provide an overview of the discovery of repeat expansion as an important cause of human disease, and we summarize the molecular genetics and mechanistic basis of 27 microsatellite repeat disorders. Comparison of the many repeat expansion disorders reveals distinct categories of repeat diseases, allowing us to propose a classification of the repeat expansion disorders based upon mutation sequence and pathogenic mechanism. The four types of repeat expansion disorders defined by this approach are the CAG/polyglutamine repeat diseases; the loss-of-function repeat diseases; the RNA gain-of-function repeat diseases; and the polyalanine diseases. Although the genetic basis for most of these diseases was determined less than a decade or so ago, considerable advances have been made in our understanding of how ‘‘dynamic mutations’’ produce molecular pathology and human disease.
1 cleaved them, yielded a new methodology A Novel Mechanism of Genetic Mutation for differentiating individuals (‘‘molec- Emerges ular fingerprinting’’). This methodology 1.1 also found application in the mapping of Repeat Sequences of All Types and Sizes inherited genetic diseases, taking advan- tage of human variation in the form of Long before the sequencing of the human so-called restriction fragment length poly- genome was undertaken, the discovery of morphisms (RFLP’s). In the search for bacterial enzymes that recognize specific even more informative genetic markers, DNA sequences (‘‘recognition sites’’) and investigators uncovered a variety of very 4 Triplet Repeat Diseases
short repeat sequences (‘‘short tandem independently made paradigm-shifting repeats’’ – STR’s; ‘‘simple sequence length discoveries. In one case, a CAG trinu- polymorphisms’’ – SSLP’s) that were cleotide repeat expansion within the first highly dispersed throughout the human coding exon of the androgen receptor (AR) genome. These latter repeat sequences gene was found to be the cause of an came to be known as ‘‘microsatellites’’ to X-linked neuromuscular disorder known differentiate them from the ‘‘minisatel- as spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy lites’’ that were being used for molec- (SBMA or Kennedy’s disease). CAG en- ular fingerprinting. Minisatellites were codes the amino acid glutamine; thus, originally defined as tandem arrays of elongation of a polyglutamine tract within 14–100 bp repeating sequences. In the the AR protein was hypothesized to be case of minisatellites, the repeat sequence the molecular basis for the motor neu- was in essence a ‘‘consensus’’ as devi- ron degeneration in SBMA. In the other ations from the exact repeat sequence case, a disorder known as the fragile X were common. Microsatellites, however, syndrome of mental retardation (FRAXA), were typically pure perfect repeats of also X-linked but much more common, less than 13 bp, the most common mi- was reported to result from expansion of crosatellites being dinucleotide repeats, a CGG repeat. In the latter case, although trinucleotide repeats, or tetranucleotide re- originally envisioned to encode a polyargi- peats. The discovery of minisatellites and nine tract, the CGG repeat turned out microsatellites yielded a virtual bonanza to be in the 5 untranslated region of a of reagents for molecular fingerprinting novel gene, the so-called FMR-1 gene (for and genetic linkage mapping, while also ‘‘fragile X mental retardation-1’’). providing evolutionary biologists and pop- The identification of triplet repeat ex- ulation geneticists with intriguing material pansions as the cause of two inherited to attempt to reconstruct evolutionary diseases was an exciting turning point in relationships and inter- or intraspecies re- the field of human molecular genetics not lationships. Although human geneticists only because of the novel nature of these and evolutionary biologists were applying findings, but also because of the unusual microsatellites in different ways for their genetic characteristics of this new type of own studies, they shared the commonly mutation. Analysis of families segregat- held belief that such repeats were neutral ing FRAXA revealed the existence of three and therefore unlikely to be of much func- distinct allele categories defined by the tional consequence, let alone play a role in length of the pure CGG repeat: a normal causing human disease. Of course, all that size range; a disease size range; and an would soon change in the last decade of intermediate, ‘‘premutation’’ size range. the twentieth century. As discussed below, individuals carrying premutation-sized CGG repeats never de- 1.2 velop the mental retardation phenotype, Trinucleotide Repeat Expansion as a but instead are at risk for passing on even Cause of Disease: Unique Features Explain larger CGG repeats to their children or Unusual Genetics grandchildren who then display the men- tal retardation phenotype. An important In 1991, two groups working on seem- tenet that emerged from these early stud- ingly unrelated inherited genetic diseases ies was that expanded CGG repeats (larger Triplet Repeat Diseases 5 than the normal size range) displayed an defining feature of DM in 1918, a num- exceptionally high rate of further mutation. ber of leading geneticists, among them This observation reversed a commonly Penrose, L.S., dismissed its authenticity, held view of the genetic material – the claiming that it was a product of ascertain- notion that any single nucleotide in the hu- ment bias due to better clinically defining man genome displayed a mutation rate of the profound variable expressitivity in this − ∼1 × 10 5. In the case of expanded CGG disorder. This view persisted from its pro- repeats in premutation carriers, the rate mulgation in the 1950s, reinforced by approached unity (100)! Besides displaying the concept that the genetic material is this high mutation rate, there were other seldom subject to alteration or modifi- unusual features: (1) the CGG repeats cation that could be heritable. However, showed a marked tendency to further ex- with the discovery that expanded trinu- pansion, suggesting that repeat mutation cleotide repeats could further expand, and was a polar process; and (2) the sex of the that indeed the expansion process was a individual transmitting the premutation- prerequisite for the FRAXA disease pheno- sized CGG allele determined whether a type – accounting for maternal inheritance large expansion into the disease range and greater percentages of affected individ- would be possible. For FRAXA, expansion uals in more recent generations – a role into the disease range could only occur if for repeats in diseases displaying antici- the premutation allele was transmitted by a pation was entertained. Consequently, the female carrier. All of these unusual aspects third repeat mutation disorder to be iden- of FRAXA CGG repeat genetics thoroughly tified – just one year after the SBMA and accounted for the bizarre non-Mendelian FRAXA discoveries – was DM. Studies of inheritance patterns described in FRAXA the causal CTG repeat expansion in DM families as the ‘‘Sherman paradox.’’ demonstrated a strong correlation between The recognition of repeat expansion as disease severity (i.e. age of onset and rate the cause of the neurodegenerative dis- of progression) and the length of the CTG order SBMA and as an explanation for repeat. In this way, it became clear that the puzzling genetics of FRAXA set the anticipation was a genuine phenomenon stage for further discoveries in the field of and that expanded repeat mutational in- neurogenetics (the study of inherited neu- stability was its long awaited molecular rological disorders). One disorder known explanation. The mutational instability as myotonic dystrophy (DM), the most com- characteristics of expanded repeats have mon of all muscular dystrophies, had been led to their designation as so-called ‘‘dy- the center of a genetic controversy that had namic mutations.’’ gone on for nearly a century. The contro- versy involved the debate over whether the clinical phenomenon of anticipation truly 2 existed or was simply an artifact of clin- Repeat Diseases and Their Classification ical study (Anticipation may be defined as a progressively earlier age of disease 2.1 onset with increasing disease severity in Summary of Repeat Diseases successive generations of a family segre- gating an inherited disorder). Although The list of diseases caused by microsatel- anticipation was initially proposed as a lite repeat expansions (involving repeats of 6 Triplet Repeat Diseases
3–12 bp) now includes more than 25 disor- a gene, which applies to both CAG (glu- ders (Table 1). Certain aspects of the list of tamine) and GCG (alanine) repeats, and repeat diseases deserve emphasis. Twenty has been proposed but not yet demon- of the repeat diseases either principally strated for CTG (leucine) repeats. The rest or exclusively affect the neuraxis – that is, of the locations defined for repeats vary anywhere from the brain to the cerebel- widely, ranging from the gene’s promoter lum/brainstem, to the spinal cord, to the to its 5 untranslated region to an intron peripheral nerve or muscle – and are de- to the 3 untranslated region, and no more generative disorders. Almost all of these in- than two to three repeat expansions can herited neurological disorders are caused be placed in each of these categories at by large expanded repeats that display this time. the property of pronounced genetic insta- bility (dynamic mutation). On the other 2.3 hand, the developmental malformation Classification Based upon Mechanism syndromes for which repeat expansion of Pathogenesis and Nature of Mutation mutations have been implicated all involve modestly sized disease repeats by compar- Toallowustoreconstructhowthedif- ison, and these repeats do not exhibit such ferent repeat expansion mutations cause dynamic mutation genetic instability. molecular pathology in the various dis- orders that they cause, we have chosen 2.2 to categorize the 25 repeat disorders into Differences in Repeat Sequence four classes (Table 2). The first class of Composition and Location within Gene disorders, the Type 1 repeat diseases, are the ‘‘CAG-polyglutamine disorders.’’ When faced with the task of categorizing This class of repeat diseases includes the various repeat expansion diseases into nine inherited neurodegenerative disor- different classes, a number of approaches ders (SBMA, Huntington’s disease, den- are possible. We have found that consid- tatorubral pallidoluysian atrophy, and six eration of the sequence of the repeat and forms of spinocerebellar ataxia) that all its location within the gene are the most share the common feature of being caused useful characteristics to apply for grouping by a CAG repeat located within the coding the different repeat diseases. As shown in Table 1, there are many different types of region of a gene. Upon CAG repeat expan- repeats varying in length and sequence sion, a mutant protein with an extended composition. However, among the recur- polyglutamine tract is produced, mak- rent sequence types are CAG trinucleotide ing the protein then adopt an abnormal repeats, CTG trinucleotide repeats, and conformation and misfold to initiate the GCG trinucleotide repeats. The rest of the pathogenic cascade. The resultant pathol- repeat sequences are unique in composi- ogy is believed to primarily stem from a tion and differ widely in size, ranging from gain of function of the mutant protein 3 to 12 bp as noted above. Comparison of imparted by the expanded polyglutamine the location of a repeat within the gene tract. As discussed below, much effort has it is affecting also yields different types of gone into trying to define what the gain-of- repeats. The largest single-repeat location function effect is for each polyglutamine category is within the coding region of disease protein and into determining if Triplet Repeat Diseases 7 10 10 2000 1000 > > > > 200– a 800 ? 71– > ATTCTCAGCAGGCGCAG 10–22 7–32 25–48 9–15 ? 5–34 – – 800–4500 – – 55–78 43–66 16–29 37–70 CAGCAG 4–18 4–35 – – 19–33 37–306 GCCGAAGCGCAGCAGGCGCCCCGCCCCGCGCTG 6–40CCTG 7–38 2–3GCG 18CAG 6–35CAG 61–200 7–27 33–60 15 12–17 27–36 104–176 5–37 200–1000 – 66–1700 – 6–7 30–150 6–44 39–250 13–33 – 50–80 ? 24–27 50–60 – – 50–4000 – 175–11 000 25 8–17 39– 31– CGG 6–53 45–200 GCG 10–16 – 17–23 CAG 12–40 – 55–84 CAG 7–35 – 49–88 GCGGCGGCG 14 11–17 20 – – – 27 24 25–29 Ataxin-10 PPP2R2B TBP HOX-D13 AR CACNA1A Ataxin-7 Fmr-2 Frataxin HOX-A13 Htt/IT15 JPH3 ZIC2 Cystatin B DMPK ZNF9 PABP2 Ataxin-1 Ataxin-2 Fmr-1 ARX Ataxin-3 Atrophin-1 FOXL2 RUNX2 PHOX-2B develop the Fragile X tremor-ataxia syndrome. n atrophy (Haw River syndrome) Compilation of repeat expansion diseases in humans. Male premutation carriers of the FMR-1 CGG repeat Spinocerebellar ataxia type 10 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 12 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 17 Syndromic and nonsyndromic X-linked mentalSynpolydactyly retardation X-linked spinal & bulbar muscular atrophy Spinocerebellar ataxia type 3 (Machado-JosephSpinocerebellar disease) ataxia type 6 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 7 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 8 ? CTG 16– FRAXE mental retardation Friedreich’s ataxia Hand-foot-genital Huntington’s disease Huntington’s disease like 2 Holoprosencephaly Myoclonus epilepsy type 1 Myotonic dystrophy type 1 Myotonic dystrophy type 2 Oculopharyngeal muscular dystrophy Spinocerebellar ataxia type 1 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 2 Fragile X syndrome of mental retardation –, no premutation alleles identified,?, so existence they of may premutation not alleles exist. is unknown. Tab. 1 DiseaseBlepharophimosis-ptosis-epicanthus inversus Cleidocranial dysplasia Congenital central hypoventilation Dentatorubralpallidoluysia Gene Repeata Normal Premutation Disease 8 Triplet Repeat Diseases tal central hypoventilation epicanthus inversus dystrophy nonsyndromic) Hand-foot-genital syndrome Holoprosencephaly Oculopharyngeal muscular Synpolydactyly X-linked MR (syndromic & phy type 1 Blepharophimosis-ptosis- tremor-ataxia syndrome Congeni Spinocerebellar ataxia type 8 Cleidocranial dysplasia s RNA gain-of-function disorders Polyalanine disorders Fragile X syndrome of MR Myotonic dystro Classification of the repeat expansion diseases. mental retardation. = Spinocerebellar ataxia type 2 Huntington’s diseaseSpinal and bulbar muscular atrophySpinocerebellar ataxia type 1Spinocerebellar ataxia type 3 Spinocerebellar ataxia type Friedreich’s 6 ataxia Spinocerebellar ataxia type 7 Spinocerebellar ataxia type 17 Myoclonus FRAXE epilepsy MR type 1 Fragile X Myotonic dystrophy type 2 Tab. 2 CAG/polyglutamine disordersDentatorubral pallidoluysian atrophy Loss-of-function disorder MR Triplet Repeat Diseases 9 shared pathways of toxicity are initiated in differences. One form of spinocerebellar the different diseases. At least one, and per- ataxia (SCA8) with an unclear mechanism haps a greater number of these disorders of pathogenesis has also been provision- may principally involve a simultaneous ally placed into this category, based upon dominant-negative partial loss of the nor- current working models of how its re- mal function of the disease protein. The peat causes disease. The last class of next class of disorders, the Type 2 repeat repeat disease, the Type 4 disorders, are diseases, are a much more disparate group the ‘‘GCG-polyalanine disorders’’ that are of repeat disorders. The Type 2 repeat dis- grouped together because all involve short eases are the ‘‘Loss-of-function repeat dis- GCG repeat tracts falling within the coding orders.’’ These disorders include different regions of unrelated genes that become ex- repeats that vary in sequence composi- panded to moderately sized GCG repeats. tion and gene location, but share a final With the exception of oculopharyngeal common pathway of disease pathogene- muscular dystrophy, all are developmental sis–alossoffunctionofthediseasegene malformation syndromes, and while gain- within which they occur. This group in- of-function polyalanine toxicity has been cludes various classic trinucleotide repeat proposed for a number of these disorders, disorders such as the two fragile X syn- loss of function due to the polyalanine dromes of mental retardation (FRAXA and expansion seems more likely for others. FRAXE) and Friedreich’s ataxia – but also Finally, a number of repeat disorders, encompasses the dodecamer repeat ex- spinocerebellar ataxia type 10 (SCA10), pansion in progressive myoclonic epilepsy spinocerebellar ataxia type 12 (SCA12), type 1, and possibly the CAG repeat ex- and Huntington’s disease like 2 (HDL2), pansion in Huntington’s disease like-2 currently defy classification because very (HDL2) gene. Strong evidence for a loss-of- little is known about their molecular basis. function pathway in the form of nonrepeat These diseases will be considered in the loss-of-function mutations supports many final section of this chapter. of these classifications. The third group of repeat diseases, the Type 3 disorders, com- prise a shared class because all of them 3 have been proposed to involve the produc- Type 1: The CAG/Polyglutamine Repeat tion of a toxic RNA species. This category Diseases of repeat diseases is thus called the RNA gain-of-function disorders. Included among 3.1 these disorders are two closely related Spinal and Bulbar Muscular Atrophy forms of DM, the common and classic myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1) and its Spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy uncommon phenocopy, myotonic dystro- (SBMA; Kennedy’s disease) is a late-onset phy type 2 (DM2). Another member of neurodegenerative disease with an inher- this group is the recently described frag- itance pattern resembling X-linked reces- ile X tremor-ataxia syndrome (FXTAS) in sive. It has a prevalence of about 1 in 50 000 male premutation carriers – a fascinating males. Patients suffer a late-onset, pro- example of two different disease path- gressive degeneration of primarily lower ways operating upon the same expanded motor neurons in the anterior horn of the repeat mutation based upon size range spinal cord and in the bulbar region of the 10 Triplet Repeat Diseases
brainstem; however, variable involvement heat-shock proteins (HSPs) 70 and 90, of sensory neurons in the dorsal root gan- and resides in the cytoplasm. Upon bind- glia also occurs. SBMA typically presents ing androgen, it dissociates from these with cramps, followed by proximal mus- HSP chaperone proteins and translocates cle weakness and atrophy. Patients often to the nucleus. Once in the nucleus, AR exhibit dysarthria, dysphagia, and fascic- dimers transactivate certain genes, many ulations of the tongue and lips. Affected of which are responsible for generating individuals have symptoms of mild andro- and maintaining male characteristics. Al- gen insensitivity, such as gynecomastia, though the glutamine expansion does not reduced fertility, and testicular atrophy. affect the binding of its ligand, androgen SBMA is caused by a polymorphic (testosterone), the glutamine tract is in the (CAG)n repeat in the first exon of the AR major transactivation domain, and may af- gene, which is expressed as a glutamine fect transactivation competence. However, tract. Unaffected individuals carry 5 to 34 theeffectofthepolyglutamineexpansion triplet repeats, while affected individuals upon AR transactivation competence re- carry 37 to 70 repeats. SBMA exhibits mains controversial. a paternal expansion bias. The disease Many lines of evidence suggest that AR does not appear to involve a simple loss- must translocate to the nucleus to exert of-function mechanism, as complete loss its toxicity. Nuclear inclusions (NIs) are of AR does not result in motor neuron present in motor neurons of the spinal degeneration. cord and brainstem in SBMA patients. AR is widely expressed in males and InaDrosophilamodelofSBMA,reti- females, and is a member of the steroid re- nal expression of mutant AR only yielded ceptor–thyroid receptor superfamily with a degenerative phenotype in the pres- a highly conserved DNA binding domain, ence of ligand. As in humans, androgen ligand binding domain and transactiva- binding causes the nuclear translocation tion domain (Fig. 1). In its inactive state, of AR in mice. Transgenic male SBMA it forms an apo-receptor complex with mice produce testosterone and will only
Normal = 5–34 SBMA = 37–70
...CAGCAGCAG...
1 919
Fig. 1 Diagram of the androgen receptor. The androgen receptor is a member of the steroid receptor-thyroid hormone receptor superfamily, and consequently displays a stereotypical architecture. The CAG repeat – polyglutamine tract (striped box) resides within the amino-terminal domain, which mediates transcription activation through an ‘‘activation function’’ domain (charcoal gray box). Additional conserved domains include the DNA binding domain (light gray box), nuclear localization signal (black box), and the ligand binding domain (checkered box). Expansion of the CAG repeat to alleles of ≥37 triplets is the cause of spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy (SBMA). Triplet Repeat Diseases 11 develop motor neuron disease if express- studies and transgenic mouse models. ing polyglutamine-expanded full-length The phosphorylation of AR is modulated AR protein, yet when castrated, such by androgen, and this posttranslational SBMA transgenic mice do not develop modification appears to enhance caspase- a phenotype. In the same study, female 3 cleavage. transgenic mice hemizygous for expanded One possible mechanism of expanded AR develop motor neuron degeneration AR toxicity is through transcription in- when exposed to exogenous androgen. Im- terference. Polyglutamine-expanded AR portantly, even rare human females who interacts with the transcription coactivator are homozygous for an AR CAG repeat ex- CREB-binding protein (CBP) in a polyg- pansion mutation do not develop SBMA, lutamine tract length-dependent manner, despite widespread expression of mutant colocalizes with CBP in spinal cord NIs AR throughout the CNS (central nervous from patients, and can interfere with system). Thus, SBMA is not a true X-linked CBP-dependent transcription. CBP is a recessive disorder, but rather is classified transcription cofactor that regulates the as a sex-limited disorder, since expres- expression of vascular endothelial growth sion of the disease phenotype is dependent factor (VEGF), among other genes. VEGF upon male levels of androgen. is important in motor neuron health, A number of studies on SBMA patients as deletion of a portion of its promoter and mouse models have characterized the called the hypoxia response element (HRE) NIs seen in this disease. While NIs are causes motor neuron degeneration even in widely distributed in lower motor neu- normoxic mice. Pathologically expanded rons of the spinal cord and brainstem, AR reduces VEGF transcript expression NIs also occur in a variety of nonneu- in males, with VEGF165 isoform ex- ronal tissues that appear to function nor- pression reduced at both the RNA and mally. NIs colocalize with components protein levels. Adding VEGF165 to a mo- of the proteasome and with molecular tor neuron-like cell line (MN-1) expressing chaperones. How this contributes to the polyglutamine-expanded AR significantly phenotype is unknown, although HSP70 rescues its cell death, again supporting overexpression attenuates toxicity in cell the role of transcription interference in culture and in transgenic mouse. The SBMA and suggesting that VEGF165 may presence of proteasome components and serve as a neurotrophic factor for mo- HSPs in NIs may thus be revealing a tor neurons. protective intervention by the cell, or al- While no effective treatment for SBMA ternatively may be deleterious due to has yet been validated in human pa- depletion of these important cellular pro- tients, the role of testosterone in SBMA teins. Interestingly, only antibodies raised disease progression has received consider- to amino-terminal fragments of AR de- able attention. Interestingly, testosterone tect NIs, indicating that proteolysis may supplementation was initially used as a play a role in the disorder. Caspase-3 has treatment for SBMA. Rather than aggra- beenshowntocleaveARinapolyglu- vating the disease as one might fear, tamine tract length-dependent manner in it was reported to attenuate the pheno- vitro, and this may have pathogenic sig- type slightly, but did not significantly nificance, as truncated AR is more toxic retard disease progression. Such a ben- than full-length protein in cell culture eficial effect of testosterone may be due 12 Triplet Repeat Diseases
to anabolic effects on muscle strength or 3.2 to a downregulation of AR in response Huntington’s Disease to elevated androgen levels. Still another possibility is that AR-mediated transcrip- Huntington’s disease (HD) is an autoso- tion in motor neurons somehow performs mal dominant disorder with a prevalence a trophic function in the face of dam- of 1 per 15 000 persons worldwide. It is age or injury. Very recent work, how- a debilitating disease that often presents ever, strongly indicates that elimination clinically in the fourth or fifth decade of of ligand by surgical or pharmacologi- life with chorea (i.e. spontaneous, invol- untary dancelike movements). Personality cal castration is a very effective treat- change and cognitive impairment may ment in SBMA transgenic mouse models, precede the clinical onset by years, and even showing efficacy when SBMA mice ultimately culminate in dementia after display an advanced phenotype. As lig- onset of the movement disorder. Chorea and binding is associated with nuclear gives way to bradykinesia and rigidity late translocation of mutant AR and aber- in the disease. CNS atrophy occurs most rant effects upon nuclear transcription prominently in the striatum, which is re- appear crucial for SBMA disease progres- duced to a fraction of its original size sion, abrogation of nuclear localization (Fig. 2). However, significant neurodegen- may account for the success of castra- eration and neuron loss in the cortex is also tion. Consistent with this hypothesis are typical, while cerebellum, brainstem, and results of studies with flutamide, a drug spinal cord are relatively spared – except in that appears to block AR-dependent trans- juvenile-onset cases. activation without preventing its nuclear HD is caused by a (CAG)n repeat ex- translocation. While pharmacological cas- pansioninthehuntingtin gene (htt), which tration with leuprolide is highly effective encodes a 350-kDa protein containing 67 therapeutically, flutamide does not ame- exons. Unaffected individuals carry 6 to 35 liorate symptoms or disease progression repeats, while affected individuals carry in an SBMA mouse model. Attempted 39 to 250 repeats. The largest repeats translation of these preclinical trial re- cause juvenile-onset HD and display a pa- sults to human SBMA patients is cur- ternal transmission bias. The htt protein rently underway. is ubiquitously expressed in brain tissue,
Fig. 2 Huntington’s disease (HD) neuropathology. Hemi-coronal sections of postmortem brains from (a) a classic, adult-onset HD patient and (b) a normal control reveal marked degeneration of the striatum (midmedial region) and considerable atrophy of cortical regions. (From Robataille et al. (1997) Brain (a) (b) pathol. 7, 901. Used with permission). Triplet Repeat Diseases 13 with highest levels in striatal interneu- emerged as an important theme at the rons and cortical pyramidal cells. Two end of the last decade. While initially it htt mRNA transcripts have been detected: was thought that the formation of large one 10 kb and the other 13 kb in length, aggregates is the basis of polyglutamine expressed most highly in CNS neurons. neurotoxicity, the weight of evidence now Ultrastructurally, the wild-type full-length suggests little correlation between visible protein is predominantly cytoplasmic and aggregate formation and disease pathol- is located in the pre- and postsynaptic ogy. However, the occurrence of aggre- regions of dendrites and axons. Htt pro- gates along with neuropathology suggests tein associates with microtubules, vesicles, that aggregation is inextricably linked to and organelles. the pathogenicity of polyglutamine disease HD appears to have a predominantly proteins. We will address the role of poly- dominant mechanism due to its inheri- glutamine aggregation in neurotoxicity in tance pattern, evidence that homozygotes detail in a separate section. are no more severely affected than het- Many theories have been proposed to erozygotes, and the observation that het- account for how polyglutamine-expanded erozygous deletion of huntingtin does not htt causes neurotoxicity. A thorough dis- cause HD. The fact that no HD-causing cussion of this literature goes beyond the loss-of-function mutations have been doc- scope of this chapter, so the reader is umented in the huge htt gene further referred to the relevant books and re- supports a gain-of-function mechanism. views in the Bibliography for a more However, postnatal elimination of htt ex- intensive treatment of this topic. Ma- pression in regions of the cortex can cause jor theories of htt neurotoxicity that will striatal degeneration in mice, so the no- be considered herein include transcrip- tion that gain of function fully accounts tion dysregulation, proteasome inhibition, for the HD phenotype is being reexam- mitochondrial dysfunction/excitotoxicity, ined. As htt is a regulator of transcription and proteolytic cleavage. As multiple inde- activation and/or mediator of vesicular pendent toxicity events may be occurring brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) concomitantly, these disease pathways are transport up and down axons, many in- not mutually exclusive. vestigators now envision the effects of Expanded htt protein may interfere expanded htt as twofold: simultaneously with transcriptional processes. Many tran- causing protein misfolding leading to gain- scription factors, such as CBP, contain of-function toxicity, and inducing partial glutamine tracts that mediate important loss of an ill-defined normal function. protein–protein interactions. CBP inter- In 1997, it was first reported that mutant acts directly with htt, and mutant htt htt forms dense amyloid-type aggregates toxicity is ameliorated in striatal neurons in in the nucleus, perikarya, and neuropil of vitro when CBP lacking the htt interaction neurons from a transgenic mouse model domain is overexpressed. CBP mediates and in human patients. The role of ag- the transcription of a number of neuronal gregation in the polyglutamine diseases survival factors, such as BDNF, and func- and in a wide range of neurodegenerative tions by acetylating histones, one aspect of disorders including Alzheimer’s disease, chromatin remodeling that permits tran- Parkinson’s disease, amyotrophic lateral scription to occur. Studies of HD fruit fly sclerosis, and the prion diseases, thus and mouse models have highlighted the 14 Triplet Repeat Diseases
potential importance of histone acetylation transport chain, such as 3-nitropropionic by demonstrating that histone deacety- acid (3-NPA), can cause a selective degen- lase inhibitors (HDAC Is) can successfully eration of the striatum in rat and primate rescue degenerative phenotypes in these models when injected systemically, since model organisms. Htt can affect transcrip- the striatum has among the highest energy tion mediated by p53, Sp1, and REST demands of all neuronal regions. 3-NPA interaction, thereby potentially altering the reduces levels of ATP, resulting in mito- expression of a large number of genes. chondrial and cellular depolarization with Differential expression of survival factors, activation of voltage-dependent NMDA re- neurotransmitter receptors, and a number ceptors. Excitotoxic damage may act in of other genes may thus contribute to HD concert with increased production of free pathogenesis. radicals to cause selective striatal degener- The ubiquitin-proteasome protein degra- ation in HD. Some of the earliest animal dation pathway has also been implicated models of HD were thus generated by ex- in HD. Nuclear inclusions of htt colocalize posing the striatum or entire brain of rats with ubiquitin, which indicates that the ex- or primates to metabolic or excitotoxic in- panded protein has been identified as mis- sults. In 1976, the first such model of HD folded and thus targeted for proteasomal was created by injection of the glutamate degradation. However, polyQ sequences analog and excitotoxin kainic acid into the longer than 9 glutamines are impossi- striatum of rats. Such lesioned rats exhib- ble for eukaryotic proteasomes to cleave. ited a selective degeneration of neurons The proteasomes of htt-transfected cells in the striatum reminiscent of HD. Re- are consequently less capable of degrading cent studies have suggested that impaired proteins other than htt, as demonstrated Ca++ flux due to aberrant interaction of by the reduced degradation of GFP-tagged htt with the inositol phosphate-3 receptor proteins in culture. If proteasome com- (IP3-R) may underlie excitotoxic pathology. ponents are clogged with mutant protein Studies of mitochondria from HD patients and/or sequestered into inclusions, they reveal abnormal mitochondrial Ca++ han- maybeunabletodegradeothermisfolded dling and decreased mitochondrial depo- or damaged proteins that carry out impor- larization thresholds, in support of this hy- tant functions. Alternatively, accumulation pothesis. One very recent study has found of improperly degraded proteins may inter- that deletion of peroxisome proliferator- fere with other normal cellular processes, activated receptor (PPAR) gamma coacti- such as autophagy or mitochondrial oxida- vator 1 alpha (PGC-1α), a key mediator tive phosphorylation. of mitochondrial biogenesis, yields HD- Perhaps the longest and most thor- like striatal degeneration in mice. Thus, oughly studied htt toxicity pathway in- metabolic insults and excitotoxicity may volves metabolic disturbances and excito- be key steps in HD disease pathogenesis. toxicity. Glucose metabolism and oxygen Another important theory of htt neuro- consumption are reduced in HD brains toxicity posits that proteolytic cleavage of as measured by PET. Severe deficits in htt is a required step in neuronal dys- the activity of complexes II/III and IV of function and the degeneration process. the mitochondrial electron transport chain As noted above, the htt protein is enor- (ETC) are evident in HD brains. Inhibitors mous, with full-length product consisting of complex II of the mitochondrial electron of >3100 amino acids. Analysis of human Triplet Repeat Diseases 15
HD material has indicated an absence of expansions can occur in a single gener- midprotein and C-terminal epitopes in htt ation, typically via paternal transmission. aggregates. Careful biochemical studies of The DRPLA disease protein, atrophin- htt have characterized a variety of putative 1, is widely expressed and appears to caspase and calpain cleavage sites. Various be predominantly cytoplasmic. Atrophin-1 studies suggest that the more truncated contains both a putative nuclear localiza- the polyglutamine-expanded htt protein, tion signal (NLS) and nuclear export signal the more toxic it is in cell culture and in (NES), and nuclear localization of normal animal models, and the more likely it is atrophin-1 is observed. Nuclear localiza- to enter the nucleus and produce toxicity tion of polyglutamine-expanded atrophin- there. In the case of htt, a series of pro- 1 has been linked to increased toxicity teolytic cleavage steps culminating with in cell culture models. Ubiquitinated NIs cleavage to an ∼100 amino acid peptide are present in neurons and glia from pa- fragment by an aspartyl protease has been tient brains, and are also immunoreactive for small ubiquitinlike modifier (SUMO) proposed to yield a final ‘‘toxic fragment.’’ protein. Atrophin-1 is a substrate for c- As it turns out, the ‘‘toxic fragment hypoth- Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), with JNK’s esis’’ (as it has also been called) may be affinity for atrophin-1 inversely propor- applicable to a number of polyQ diseases, tional to the size of the polyglutamine which will be reviewed later in this section. tract expansion. Although the relevance of JNK phos- 3.3 Dentatorubral Pallidoluysian Atrophy phorylation to atrophin-1 function is un- known, other insights into the function Dentatorubral pallidoluysian atrophy (DR- of atrophin-1 have been reported. Using Drosophila melanogaster as a model sys- PLA) is a rare, autosomal dominant tem, Zhang et al. took advantage of the neurodegenerative disorder most preva- existence of a fly ortholog of atrophin-1 lent in Japan. Adult-onset DRPLA typi- (Atro) and created lines of flies carry- cally involves progressive cerebellar ataxia, ing mutations in the Atro gene. These choreoatheosis, epilepsy, and dementia, flies demonstrated severe developmental while juvenile-onset cases also display abnormalities due to complex pattern- myoclonus, epilepsy, and mental retar- ing defects, and subsequent experiments dation. Neuropathological abnormalities revealed that Atro is a transcription core- include degeneration of the dentate nu- pressor whose activity diminishes with cleus of the cerebellum, rubral nucleus, increasing polyglutamine tract length. In- and globus pallidus, as well as a more dependent studies of human atrophin-1 in generalized degeneration and gliosis in- cell culture studies found evidence for tran- volving the brainstem, cerebellum, cortex, scription interference of polyglutamine- and pons. DRPLA is caused by a polymor- expanded atrophin-1 with CREB-mediated phic (CAG)n repeat in the carboxy-terminal gene activation. Transcription dysregula- coding region of the atrophin-1 gene on tion may thus play a prominent role chromosome 12. Normal individuals carry in DRPLA. Another study suggests that 6–35 repeats, while affected individuals disturbed carbohydrate metabolism may carry 49–88 repeats. Anticipation is promi- contribute to the DRPLA neurodegenera- nent in DRPLA, as very large repeat tive phenotype. 16 Triplet Repeat Diseases
3.4 there is strong evidence supporting a gain- Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 1 of-function mechanism in SCA1. Ataxin-1 is widely expressed in the CNS Spinocerebellar ataxia type 1 (SCA1) is an and throughout the periphery, although autosomal dominant disorder character- expression levels are several-fold higher in ized primarily by a progressive cerebel- nervous system tissues. The protein is pre- lar ataxia. It accounts for about 6% of dominantly nuclear in the CNS, however, all autosomal dominant cerebellar ataxias some cytoplasmic staining is apparent in (ADCAs) worldwide. SCA1 patients suf- Purkinje cells of the cerebellum and in fer from coordination difficulties including brainstem nuclei. Ataxin-1 knockout mice dysarthria, dysphagia, and ophthalmople- do not develop SCA1, although they do gia. The cerebellum undergoes atrophy, exhibit impairments in motor and spatial gliosis, and severe loss of Purkinje cells, ac- learning. These mice also have decreased companied by degeneration of the dentate paired-pulse facilitation in the CA1 re- nucleus, inferior olive, and some brain- gion of the hippocampus, suggesting that stem nuclei. Disease onset typically occurs ataxin-1 may normally function in synaptic in the third or fourth decade of life, but plasticity and learning. presentation in childhood or adolescence Large ataxin-1 containing NI’s occur to late life may be seen. SCA1 is caused by in the brainstem of affected individuals, the expansion of a coding (CAG)n repeat and are immunoreactive for ubiquitin, in the amino-terminal coding region of the the 20 S proteasome subunit, and HSPs ataxin-1 gene. The ataxin-1 CAG repeat is HDJ2 and Hsc70. Work done on SCA1 in highly polymorphic, ranging in size from transgenic mice by the Orr and Zoghbi lab- 6to44tripletsinunaffectedindividuals. oratories has been crucial in formulating The repeat length associated with disease models of not only SCA1 disease patho- ranges from 39 to more than 100 CAGs. genesis but also for influencing views Unaffected individuals with more than of the molecular basis of all polyglu- 20 repeats have CAT triplet interruptions tamine diseases. Indeed, the first mouse within their (CAG)n repeat tracts. Such in- model for a polyglutamine disease was terruptions stabilize the repeat expansion, generated by transgenic overexpression of while absence of the CAT repeat intersper- polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-1 in Purk- sion is noted in SCA1 patient alleles. As inje cells (Fig. 3). This SCA1 transgenic in many other polyglutamine disorders, mouse model has laid the foundation for
Fig. 3 The original spinocerebellar ataxia type 1 (SCA1) mouse model. (a) Diagram of the Pcp2-SCA1 transgene construct. A Purkinje cell-specific expression cassette based upon inclusion of the promoter (straight line), first two noncoding exons (black boxes), and first intron (bent line) of the Purkinje cell protein 2 (Pcp2) gene and a SV40 polyadenylation sequence (open box) was the basis for this landmark work. Ataxin-1 cDNAs (gray box) containing either 30 CAGs (control) or 82 CAGs (expanded) were inserted into the Pcp2 expression cassette. Sites of various PCR primer sets are also shown. (b) Pcp2-SCA1 CAG-82 mice display ataxia. Still photographs of a 30-week-old Pcp2-SCA1 CAG-82 mouse from a transgenic line that greatly overexpresses the mutant ataxin-1 transgene illustrates the inability of this mouse to maintain its balance when ambulating. Loss of balance when walking is consistent with the gait ataxia seen in human SCA1 patients. (From Burright et al. (1995) Cell 82, 937, used with permission). Triplet Repeat Diseases 17 numerous follow-up studies of polyglu- required for SCA1 in mice. In a later study, tamine disease pathogenesis. For example, crossing of SCA1 transgenic mice with expression of mutant ataxin-1 lacking an mice lacking a ubiquitin ligase enzyme intact self-association domain precluded yielded SCA1 mice incapable of aggregate aggregate formation, but permitted neu- formation. These mice were more severely rotoxicity, demonstrating that NIs are not affected than their transgenic counterparts
(a)
(b) 18 Triplet Repeat Diseases
duetoabsenceoftheubiquitinligase. of mutant ataxin-1 on neuronal function, This work supported the view that visible however, remain undefined. aggregate formation may represent a pro- Transcriptional dysregulation is also a tective cellular response for neutralizing reasonable hypothesis for SCA1 patho- misfolded polyglutamine-containing pep- genesis. One study has demonstrated that tides. In another study, mice expressing ataxin-1 interacts with polyglutamine bind- ataxin-1 with a mutated NLS were found ing protein 1 (PQBP-1), and that this not to develop SCA1, suggesting that nu- interaction results in interference with clear localization is absolutely required for RNA polymerase-dependent transcription. SCA1 molecular pathology. Although tar- Independent studies have supported a role geting ataxin-1 to Purkinje cells appears for ataxin-1 as a transcription corepressor. sufficient to recapitulate a dramatic SCA1- In pull-down assays and in Drosophila, like disease in mice, a subsequent knockin ataxin-1 interacts with the proteins SMRT mouse model of SCA1 indicated that ex- (silencing mediator of retinoid and thyroid pression in other regions of the CNS yields hormone receptors) and HDAC3 (his- a more representative disease phenotype. tone deacetylase 3), both transcriptional Over the past few years, numerous repressors. Aggregates of polyglutamine- leads have emerged in the search for the expanded ataxin-1 sequester SMRTER, the pathogenic basis of SCA1. In one line Drosophila ortholog of SMRT. Transcrip- of investigation, phosphorylation of ser- tion repressors and histone deacetylases ine 776 of the ataxin-1 protein was shown also appeared in an earlier screen for mod- to affect pathogenesis, highlighting the ulators of the Ataxin-1 phenotype in the fly. importance of this posttranslational mod- In addition, two separate studies of gene ification. SCA1 transgenic mice in which expression alterations in presymptomatic serine 776 had been mutated to an ala- SCA1 transgenic mice have uncovered nine, exhibited a dramatically attenuated changes in the levels of transcripts en- phenotype and a complete lack of NI’s. coding proteins involved in Ca++ flux In an accompanying study, interaction of and metabolism. It thus appears that tran- polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-1, but not scription dysregulation may be a key step wild-type ataxin-1, with several isoforms of in SCA1 disease pathogenesis. the phosphoserine/threonine binding pro- tein 14-3-3 was reported. This extremely 3.5 abundant peptide is thought to serve a Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 2 regulatory function by binding proteins and determining their subcellular localiza- Spinocerebellar ataxia type 2 (SCA2) is an tion, among other things. The interaction autosomal dominant, progressive cerebel- between ataxin-1 and 14-3-3 was shown lar ataxia that accounts for about 13% of to be dependent upon the Akt-mediated all ADCA cases. Although patients dis- phosphorylation of serine 776. A novel play problems with voluntary coordinated mechanism for ataxin-1 toxicity was thus movements as in the rest of the SCAs, proposed: upon Akt phosphorylation of its main distinguishing clinical feature is polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-1, ataxin-1 extremely slow saccadic eye movements. binds 14-3-3, is stabilized, and ultimately Other symptoms may include hypore- accumulates in the nucleus. The down- flexia, myoclonus, and action tremor. Pa- stream effects of the nuclear accumulation tients suffer a gradual degeneration of Triplet Repeat Diseases 19 the cerebellum, inferior olive, pons, and Thus, a complex including ataxin-2 and spinal cord. Both Purkinje and granule A2BP1 may be involved in RNA processing cells degenerate in the cerebellum, and or metabolism. CNS atrophy in some patients can be The ataxin-2 gene is evolutionarily con- widespread. Interestingly, in certain cases, served. The murine ortholog of ataxin-2 there is involvement of the substantia does not contain a polyglutamine repeat nigra, with such patients displaying a tract, however, but instead possesses a sin- prominent degree of parkinsonism. The gle glutamine residue at the analogous lo- disorder is caused by a coding (CAG)n cation. (Absence of a substantial glutamine expansion in a novel gene of unknown repeat tract is typical for mouse orthologs function, named ataxin-2. The SCA2 CAG of polyglutamine disease proteins.) In the repeat displays little polymorphism in the case of ataxin-2, study of the Drosophila normal population, with 95% of the popu- ortholog (Datx2), which does show two lation possessing 22 or 23 repeats in each regions of marked amino acid similar- allele. The remaining 5% of alleles in un- ity and does contain polyglutamine repeat affected individuals do nonetheless range regions, has yielded some potentially im- from 15–31 CAG repeats. Such unaffected portant insights into ataxin-2s normal individuals typically have two CAA inter- function. Modulation of Datx2 dosage re- ruptions in their CAG repeat tract. Affected sulted in mutant phenotypes whose cause SCA2 patients typically display CAG re- could be traced to aberrant actin filament peats numbering from 32–63 triplets, and formation (Fig. 4). This work suggests such disease alleles are always uninter- that alteration of ataxin-2-mediated regu- rupted CAG tracts. There is a nonlinear lation of cytoskeletal structure could affect inverse correlation between expansion size dendrite formation or other aspects of neu- and age of onset in SCA2, with some stud- ronal function in SCA2. As SCA2 is one ies documenting a paternal transmission ofthefewpolyglutaminedisorderstodis- bias for larger expansions. play prominent cytosolic aggregates, such Both wild-type and expanded ataxin-2 a model of SCA2 pathogenesis seems plau- mRNA is widely expressed, with high- sible. In other experiments, eliminating est levels in the substantia nigra and the C. elegans ortholog of ataxin-2 (ATX- Purkinje cells of the cerebellum. The 2) yielded a lethal phenotype, indicating 140-kDa protein is cytoplasmic and its that ATX-2 is required for early embryonic function remains uncertain. Since it con- development of this nematode worm. It tains Sm1 and Sm2 motifs common in remains to be seen how these observations proteins involved in RNA splicing and in worms and flies will apply to ataxin- protein–protein interactions, involvement 2 function in mammals, especially since in RNA processing has been proposed. no simple or conditional knockout of the A yeast two-hybrid screen indicated that mouse ataxin-2 gene has been performed. ataxin-2 has a binding partner, ataxin- 2 binding protein-1 (A2BP1). A2BP1 is 3.6 highly conserved throughout the animal Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type kingdom and its expression pattern corre- 3/Machado–Joseph Disease sponds well with that of ataxin-2. A2BP1 contains a domain that is also conserved Spinocerebellar ataxia type 3 (SCA3) is in RNA-binding proteins, the RNP motif. the most common inherited dominant 20 Triplet Repeat Diseases
Fig. 4 Studies of the ataxin-2 ortholog in Drosophila melanogaster reveals a role for Drosophila ataxin-2 (Datx2) in actin filament formation during oogenesis. Egg chambers from normal (Wild-Type (WT)) and mutant flies with reduced expression (a) (b) (Datx2) of Drosophila ataxin-2 were stained with DAPI (blue) and phalloidin (red) to indicate nuclei and filamentous actin respectively (a–d). The egg chambers of WT flies prior to cytoplasmic transport (a) display well demarcated, separated but (c) (d) interconnected cells (blue) as expected, while the egg chambers of Datx2 flies (b) contain irregularly arranged cells. After cytoplasmic transport, the egg chambers of WT flies (c) show one greatly enlarged oocyte (dashed line) with only a small section of compressed cells, while the egg chambers of Datx2 flies (d) have failed to yield an enlarged oocyte, instead retaining dispersed and large adjacent cells. Confocal images of egg chambers prior to (e) (f) cytoplasmic transport stage reveal a prominent actin filament network in WT flies (e), but a remarkably transparent actin filament network in Datx2 flies (f). The decreased density of the actin filament network underlies the cytoplasmic ‘‘dumping’’ defect in the Datx2 flies. (From Satterfield, T.F., Jackson, S.M., Pallanck, L.J. (2002) A Drosophila homolog of the polyglutamine disease gene SCA2 is a dosage-sensitive regulator of actin filament formation, Genetics 162, 1687–1702, used with permission of Genetics.) (See color plate p. xxiii).
spinocerebellar ataxia worldwide. SCA3 is repeat allele. Some researchers have pro- also known as Machado–Joseph disease posed that this could be due to a SCA3 (MJD) because of its initial description in founder effect. The presence of SCA3 in a group of Portuguese residents of the every major racial population worldwide, Azores islands. It is a progressive, auto- however, would require the founder to be somal dominant cerebellar ataxia whose truly ancient. There is the typical inverse clinical features include ophthalmoplegia, correlation between repeat number and dystonia, dysarthria, and signs of lower age of onset in SCA3, and in this disease, motor neuron disease, such as tongue paternal expansion bias is characteristic, and facial fasciculations. Degeneration oc- as documented by repeat sizing of sperm. curs in the spinocerebellar tracts, dentate Ataxin-3 is a ubiquitously expressed 42- nuclei, red nuclei, substantia nigra, and kDa protein, making it the smallest of the spinal cord. This disease is unique among polyglutamine proteins. Ataxin-3 is highly the SCAs because the cerebellar cortex conserved in eukaryotes, with homology and inferior olive are largely spared. SCA3 to ENTH and VHS domain proteins is caused by a (CAG)n repeat near the involved in regulatory adaptor functions 3 end of the coding region of a novel and membrane trafficking. Ataxin-3 has gene (ataxin-3). Normal alleles range from several splice variants which reside in 12–40 CAG repeats while affected indi- the nucleus and the cytoplasm, and it viduals carry 55–84 repeats. Unlike many appears developmentally regulated. The other triplet repeat disorders, there is a sub- existence of NIs was first documented in stantial gap between the largest normal re- the brains of patients with SCA3, and peat allele and the smallest disease-causing this feature of polyglutamine-expanded Triplet Repeat Diseases 21 ataxin-3 remains evident in SCA3 cell 3.7 culture and mouse models. Ataxin-3 NIs Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 6 are ubiquitinated and contain numerous transcription factors. Spinocerebellar ataxia type 6 (SCA6) is A number of recent discoveries regard- an autosomal dominant, slowly progress- ing the domain structure and normal ing cerebellar ataxia that accounts for ∼ function of ataxin-3 suggest pathways 10–20% of ADCA worldwide. It is by which polyglutamine repeat expan- characterized predominantly by cerebel- sion could result in disease pathogenesis. lar dysfunction that may have an episodic Comparison of ataxin-3 amino acid se- component. Other common features may quences across a wide range of eukaryotic include dysarthria, nystagmus, loss of vi- species revealed the presence of an ex- bration sense and proprioception, and tremely highly conserved amino-terminal imbalance. Histopathological changes in- clude loss of Purkinje cells, cerebellar sequence that was named the josephin do- granule neurons, and neurons in the den- main. Study of this region indicates that it tate nucleus and inferior olive. SCA6 is may play a role in aggregate formation caused by a coding (CAG)n expansion in in concert with the expanded polyglu- exon 47 of the gene CACNA1A,which tamine tract. A rather intriguing feature encodes the α subunit of the P/Q-type of ataxin-3 that was discovered indepen- 1A voltage-gated calcium channel. This gene dently is the presence of multiple ubiquitin is located on chromosome 19 at band interaction motifs (UIMs), and the demon- p13. The SCA6 CAG repeat is small com- stration that ataxin-3 is a polyubiquitin pared to other polyglutamine disorders, binding protein. This suggests a role for with a pathogenic range of only 19–33 ataxin-3 in mediating protein refolding and triplets. Unaffected individuals carry alle- degradation. les of 4–18 repeats. There is an inverse In addition to a possible normal role correlation between repeat length and age in protein surveillance, other studies of disease onset, and minimal intergen- have found ataxin-3 directly interacts with erational and somatic instability has been the histone acetyltransferases CBP and reported for the SCA6 repeat expansion in p300, and can block histone acetyltrans- affected patients. ferase activity by inhibiting access of The 9.8 kb CACNA1A transcript impli- such coactivators to their histone sub- cated in SCA6 is expressed throughout strates. This appears to be mediated the CNS, and most highly in cerebellar by the interaction of ataxin-3 with hi- Purkinje cells and granule neurons. The stones. In vitro and in vivo studies of α1A subunit is the pore-forming compo- ataxin-3 further revealed an interaction nent of the channel, which is important with histones and the chromatin remod- in neurotransmitter release at the synapse. eling machinery that led to a repres- Polyglutamine expansions in this subunit sion of transcription activation. Thus, cause variable changes in calcium trans- polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-3 may also mission rates, depending on the system affect transcriptional processes once it and the β subunit coexpressed. Expansions begins to accumulate in the nuclear com- do not cause a reduction in membrane partments of the cell types where it is channel density in HEK293 cells, sug- expressed. gesting that aggregation does not occur 22 Triplet Repeat Diseases
at pathogenic repeat lengths. Ubiquitin- calcium channel due to association of the negative neuronal inclusions are visible in mutant α1A subunit with other subunits the cytoplasm of SCA6 patient Purkinje causes SCA6. The coincidence that this dis- cells, however. order is caused by a polyQ tract expansion In addition to displaying a disease al- and causes a progressive cerebellar ataxia lele range that does not overlap with the cannot be ignored, however, more data will other polyQ diseases, there are several be required to soundly refute a possible other reasons to suspect that SCA6 is dif- concomitant toxic gain-of-function effect. ferent from the rest of the polyglutamine repeat group. The first difference is the 3.8 existence of two disorders, episodic ataxia Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 7 type 2 (EA2) and familial hemiplegic mi- graine (FMH), that are both allelic to SCA6, Spinocerebellar ataxia type 7 (SCA7) is an as both are caused by point mutations in autosomal dominant, progressive cerebel- the CACNA1A gene. EA2 resembles SCA6 lar ataxia. It is unique among autosomal as affected EA2 individuals suffer from a dominant SCAs, as patients typically de- slowly progressive form of episodic ataxia, velop visual impairment in addition to accompanied by nystagmus, dysarthria, their cerebellar ataxia. The visual impair- loss of balance and sometimes cerebellar ment is due to a cone-rod dystrophy that atrophy. EA2 is usually caused by trun- results in retinal degeneration. Patients cation mutations in CACNA1A,resulting first develop problems distinguishing col- in loss-of-function of the calcium chan- ors, but ultimately go blind in this type nel. CACNA1A knockout mice similarly of retinal degeneration. SCA7 patients develop ataxia and late-onset cerebellar may present either with cerebellar ataxia atrophy, characteristic of SCA6 and EA2 or visual impairment. The likelihood of patient phenotypes. Another reason SCA6 their presentation is dictated by the size is different from other polyQ disorders is of their CAG repeat disease allele, with that the CACNA1A protein probably does not undergo a structural change that con- larger repeats typically favoring presen- verts it into an aggregate-prone, beta-sheet tation with visual impairment. Affected adopting, amyloid-like conformer. Indeed, individuals display prominent dysarthria, even the largest SCA6 polyglutamine tract and can develop increased reflexes, de- is below the threshold required for stable creased vibration sense, and oculomotor β-pleated sheet formation in other polyg- disturbances. Neuronal degeneration and lutamine disorders. Consistent with this reactive gliosis occur in the cerebellar cor- prediction, channel localization of mutant tex, dentate nucleus, inferior olive, pontine polyglutamine-expanded CACNA1A pro- nuclei, and occasionally in the basal gan- tein is not affected in cell culture models, glia. NIs are widespread. Infantile-onset and its channel function is not com- SCA7 has been documented, and in this pletely abolished. Cytoplasmic aggregates fatal form of the disease, nonneuronal tis- in patient material are ubiquitin-negative, sues such as the heart and the kidney suggesting that the protein may not be are severely affected. SCA7 is caused by grossly misfolded. This evidence supports a highly polymorphic (CAG)n repeat in a model whereby a dominant-negative loss the 5 coding region of the ataxin-7 gene. of function of the P/Q-type voltage-gated Unaffected individuals carry 4–35 repeats, Triplet Repeat Diseases 23 while affected individuals carry 37–306 re- presence of the polyglutamine-expanded peats. The SCA7 trinucleotide repeat is one ataxin-7 has a dominant-negative effect of the most unstable of all polyglutamine upon the GCN5 histone acetyltrans- disease genes, sometimes expanding by as ferase activity of the STAGA complex, much as 250 repeats in a single generation. resulting in transcription dysregulation. There is a pronounced paternal expansion The transcription dysregulation caused bias, with large expansions occurring in by polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-7 likely male germ cells, frequently causing em- causes a disease phenotype by altering the bryonic lethality that results in reduced ability of certain transcription factors to transmission. Marked repeat instability activate expression of their target genes. can occur in the brain, and produce large The best characterized example of tran- somatic expansions on occasion. scription dysregulation by polyglutamine- Ataxin-7 is a ubiquitously expressed expanded ataxin-7 is its interference with protein of 892 amino acids. It is expressed the cone-rod homeobox protein (CRX), a most highly in heart, skeletal muscle, glutamine domain containing transcrip- and pancreas. Expression levels within the tion factor expressed only in the retina CNS are highest in the cerebellum and and the pineal gland. Ataxin-7 interacts brainstem. One splice variant, ataxin-7b, is directly and functionally with CRX, ac- expressed predominantly in the CNS (32). cording to studies performed in vitro Ataxin-7 contains a functional arrestin and in a mouse model of SCA7. Impor- domain, a protein interaction domain tantly, the interaction between ataxin-7 that is highly selective for phosphorylated and CRX appears to involve the glu- forms of its interacting protein(s). This tamine tract regions found in both pro- suggests that it interacts with specific teins. Autosomal dominant mutations in phospho-proteins, although none have CRX can cause a cone-rod dystrophy been discovered to date. It also contains in humans, further supporting a model two SH3 domains, which are protein interaction domains that bind proline-rich in which CRX’s diminished transactiva- sequences and mediate a number of cell tion competence is central to the SCA7 signaling processes. Ataxin-7 also contains retinal degeneration phenotype. Several threeputativeNLSsandoneNES. transcription factors, including CBP, can Ataxin-7 is conserved throughout eu- be found in SCA7. CRX may be but karyotes, and its yeast ortholog SGF73 is one of a number of transcription factors part of a multisubunit histone acetyltrans- whose function is diminished by polyQ- ferase complex called SAGA (Spt/Ada/ expanded ataxin-7 interaction and dys- Gcn5 acetyltransferase). The human or- regulation of STAGA complex-mediated thologs of SAGA comprise the so-called gene expression. STAGA (SPT3/TAF9/ADA2/GCN5 acetyl- One intriguing feature of SCA7 was transferase) complex, and are essen- discovered upon generation of transgenic tial transcription coactivators required mice expressing ataxin-7 with the mouse for the transcription of certain genes. prion protein promoter. This promoter STAGA components immunoprecipitate drives expression in every tissue, with the with ataxin-7. Although pathogenic expan- occasional notable exception of the Purk- sion of ataxin-7 does not alter its ability to inje cells of the cerebellum. Despite lack of be integrated into the STAGA complex, the Purkinje cell expression of ataxin-7, mice 24 Triplet Repeat Diseases
Fig. 5 Noncell autonomous Purkinje cell degeneration in a mouse model of spinocerebellar ataxia type 7 (SCA7). Confocal microscopy analysis of cerebellar sections from a SCA7 transgenic mouse (SCA7) created with an ataxin-7 CAG-92 containing murine prion protein expression vector and from an age- and sex-matched nontransgenic littermate (Control). Staining with an anti-ataxin-7 antibody (magenta), a calbindin antibody (green), and DAPI (blue) reveals a healthy, normal- appearing cerebellum characterized by properly oriented Purkinje cells with extensive dendritic arborization in the ‘‘Control’’ mice. However, SCA7 transgenic mice display pronounced Purkinje cell degeneration as evidenced by decreased dendritic arborization and displacement of Purkinje cell bodies. Interestingly, although numerous neurons in the granule cell layer (GCL) and the molecular layer (ML) display aggregates of ataxin-7, there is no accumulation of mutant ataxin-7 in the degenerating Purkinje cells due to lack of appreciable expression there. As the Purkinje cells degenerate without expressing the mutant protein, the degeneration is described as noncell autonomous. (Adapted from Garden, G.A., Libby, R.T., Fu, Y.H., Kinoshita, Y., Huang, J., Possin, D.E., Smith, A.C., Martinez, R.A., Fine, G.C., Grote, S.K., et al. (2002) Polyglutamine-expanded ataxin-7 promotes noncell-autonomous Purkinje cell degeneration and displays proteolytic cleavage in ataxic transgenic mice, J. Neurosci. 22, 4897–4905, used with permission of the Journal of Neuroscience.) (See color plate p. xxiv).
developed a cerebellar ataxia accompa- by a membrane-bound autophagosome nied by degeneration of the Purkinje cells and is accelerated by a number of cellular (Fig. 5). This noncell-autonomous degen- insults.) Caspase-3, a proteolytic enzyme eration may point to a disease mechanism classically associated with apoptosis, is ac- involving withdrawal of trophic support tivated at abnormally high levels in SCA7 by communicating neurons (olivary, deep patient brains. This may suggest that cerebellar, brainstem, or granule neurons) caspase activation, rather than causing or dysfunction of glutamate transporters apoptosis, is contributing to a nonapop- expressed by surrounding glia. Damage to totic degenerative process. inferior olivary neurons or Bergmann glia In normal human neurons, ataxin-7 is can indeed cause the degeneration of Purk- variably located in the nucleus or the inje cells, lending credence to this theory. cytoplasm. In SCA7 patients, ataxin-7 grad- Another interesting feature of SCA7 that ually undergoes a shift in localization into is common to other neurodegenerative NIs. This process has been replicated in disorders is the prominence of morpholog- SCA7 transgenic mice, in which ataxin-7 ical and functional degeneration without immunoreactivity shifts from the cyto- pronounced apoptosis. Some neurons in plasm to the nucleus, and ultimately forms SCA7 humans and mouse models ex- foci there. In patient’s brains, these NIs hibit indentations in the nuclear enve- colocalize with promyelocytic leukemia lope, reduced arborization, ectopy, and (PML) protein, which is an integral part increased autophagy. (Autophagy is the of nuclear bodies (NBs). NBs are associ- bulk degradation of cellular components ated with transcription regulation and the Triplet Repeat Diseases 25 ubiquitin-proteasome pathway; thus, accu- Given TBP’s central role in transcription mulation of ataxin-7 in NBs may represent regulation, the basis of SCA17 disease an attempt by the cell to degrade misfolded pathogenesis is proposed to involve tran- protein. scription dysregulation, but this is yet to be proven. 3.9 Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 17 3.10 Role of Aggregation in Polyglutamine Spinocerebellar ataxia type 17 (SCA17) Disease Pathogenesis is the most recently discovered polyglu- tamine repeat disease. It is an autosomal In most polyglutamine disorders and in dominant, progressive disorder character- many neurodegenerative diseases in gen- ized by dementia as well as cerebellar ataxia eral, protein aggregation is a prominent and involuntary movement abnormalities. feature. It occurs in almost all polyglu- Its symptoms are diverse and heteroge- tamine diseases, despite the lack of domain neous, but typically begin with behavioral or structural similarity between the dif- disturbances and cognitive impairment. ferent disease proteins. Aggregates have This is followed by ataxia, rigidity, dysto- long been considered reliable indicators nia, hyperreflexia, and rarely parkinson- of disease, although their pattern and on- ism. Neuropathologically, patients may setoftendonotcorrespondwellwiththe suffer degeneration of the cortex, cere- cell-type specificity of disease pathology. bellum (including Purkinje cells), inferior As the role of aggregation in pathogenesis olive, caudate nucleus, and medial tha- has been one of the most hotly debated lamic nuclei. SCA17 is caused by the issues in the field of neurodegeneration, expansion of a coding (CAG)n repeat in it may have implications for Alzheimer’s the TATA-binding protein (TBP) gene on disease, Parkinson’s disease, and amy- chromosome 6q27. Unaffected individuals otrophic lateral sclerosis. Why? There are carry 25–48 repeats, while affected individ- several characteristics of polyglutamine- uals carry 43–66 repeats. The area of over- mediated aggregation that are presumably lap between affected and unaffected alleles common to all of the disorders that show indicates incomplete penetrance at inter- aggregation. First of all, aggregates are mediate repeat lengths. The pathogenic rich in β-pleated sheets and have many threshold is higher than for most other of the properties of amyloid. This is sup- polyglutamine disorders, yet there is an ported by Congo red birefringence and inverse correlation between repeat length immunoreactivity with antiamyloid anti- and age of onset. bodies. Various studies have shown that TBP is a ubiquitously expressed tran- the conformational change is associated scription initiation factor that is a core with the production of visible aggregates component of the RNA polymerase II rather than in the soluble nonaggre- transcription factor D (TFIID) complex. gated phase, where polyglutamine tracts TBP possesses DNA binding activity in the are thought to remain in a random coil TFIID complex, and is therefore required conformation. for the transcription of numerous genes. In vitro, the kinetics of aggregation are SCA17 patients have NIs immunoreactive consistent with nucleated-growth polymer- for TBP, polyglutamine, and ubiquitin. ization, in which the rate-limiting step is 26 Triplet Repeat Diseases
the formation of misfolded peptide as- degradation away from the soluble phase semblies, often referred to as oligomers. and into aggregates has been proposed as A mechanism involving nucleated-growth a potential cause of cell toxicity in neurons polymerization would predict that only one with aggregates. Caspase activation is (or a few) visible aggregates would appear another way in which aggregation could be in each affected cell, and this appears to linked to pathology. Caspase recruitment bethecaseformostpolyglutaminedis- into aggregates can lead to their activation, orders. In the cellular milieu however, which could result in dysfunction or cell where membranes and intermolecular in- death in neurons. Further supporting teractions compartmentalize proteins, this the role of aggregates in polyglutamine prediction may not be valid. The dis- protein toxicity, injection of preformed covery of polyglutamine microaggregates polyglutamine aggregates into the nuclei confirmsthissuspicion.Thethreshold of cultured cells causes cell death, for aggregation of polyglutamine tracts is while the injection of nonpolyglutamine similar to the disease threshold for most aggregates does not. At the same polyglutamine diseases. In vitro,longer time, there is strong evidence that polyglutamine tracts have a lower con- soluble polyglutamine protein, rather centration threshold for aggregation and than aggregates, is the primary source nucleate more quickly than shorter tracts. of toxicity. Importantly, the pattern of This is one possible explanation for the cor- aggregates observed in human patients relation between tract length and disease often does not correlate with the pattern onset and progression. of neuronal dysfunction. For example, Some data support a role for aggregation in the striatum of HD patients, large in polyglutamine disease pathogenesis. interneurons contain aggregates more Some proponents of this theory invoke frequently than medium spiny neurons, the fact that aggregates sequester many yet the former neurons are largely spared, proteins besides the disease protein. Inter- while the latter are most vulnerable. molecular interactions between transcrip- HD transgenic mice expressing full-length tion factors often involve glutamine tracts mutant htt will develop inclusions in or glutamine-rich regions. Some studies many brain regions many of which are have shown that normal proteins with glu- neuropathologically unaffected, while few tamine tracts or glutamine-rich regions inclusions are detected in the striatum, are enriched in polyglutamine aggregates the region of the brain displaying the most in cell culture and animal models. Sev- prominent pathology. eral transcription factors colocalize with Aggregation and toxicity have been di- such aggregates, including CBP, TBP, and rectly dissociated in other polyglutamine numerous TBP-associated factors (TAFs). disease model systems. Studies of the CBP is responsible for the prosurvival SCA1 knockin mouse model revealed that effects of BDNF, and its soluble concen- neurons lacking aggregates were more sus- tration is lowered in HD patient’s brains. ceptible to dysfunction and demise, while Postnatal mice lacking CREB and its ho- those neurons displaying prominent ag- molog CREM develop a progressive degen- gregates were protected. Similarly, SCA7 eration of the hippocampus and striatum. transgenic mice exhibit retinal pathology Titration of enzymes and factors before the occurrence of visible aggregates. required for protein refolding and Finally, in a very provocative study, SCA1 Triplet Repeat Diseases 27 transgenic mice lacking the ubiquitin lig- of mutant protein. To examine the role of ase E6-AP were significantly less capable aggregate formation in polyglutamine tox- of forming large and numerous aggregates icity, another group then tracked survival in neurons in comparison to SCA1 trans- time versus diffuse, soluble htt protein ex- genic mice on a wild-type background, pression levels in htt-transfected striatal but displayed earlier onset of an ataxic neurons undergoing aggregate formation. phenotype and accelerated neurodegener- Comparison of neurons that developed ag- ation. This suggests that the aggregates gregates over time versus those that did may be protective, although the toxicity not confirmed that the level of soluble of compromising the proteasome may nonaggregated mutant polyglutamine pro- have contributed to the accelerated phe- tein was the more reliable predictor of notype. Thus ensued a contentious debate cellular toxicity. Such studies have shifted over the role of aggregate formation in our attention to the role of the intermedi- polyglutamine disease – with some work- ates (oligomers, protofibrils, etc.) as the ers espousing the view that aggregates toxic species instead of the final, visi- were responsible for disease pathology, ble aggregates. others suggesting that the aggregation A reasonable model for polyglutamine process was a protective coping mecha- toxicity predicts that the process starts nism of the cell and thereby beneficial, with a protein that misfolds because of and still others insisting that aggregates the presence of an expanded polyglu- were incidental and irrelevant. This de- tamine tract. The misfolded protein is bate was complicated by the existence of initially detectable in the soluble phase ‘‘microaggregates,’’ small clumps of aggre- due to the cell’s ability to maintain the pro- gated protein visible only at the electron tein in a properly folded state and direct microscope level. it to the degradation machinery. How- Over the last few years, studies decon- ever, the refolding capacity of the cell is structing polyglutamine tract aggregation ultimately exceeded, and since the degra- into a multistep process suggest a par- dation machinery cannot turnover the simonious explanation for the divergent misfolded mutant polyglutamine protein, views. Using a variety of biophysical ap- accumulation occurs. Misfolded polyglu- proaches, including transmission electron tamine proteins can spontaneously change microscopy (TEM), Fourier transform in- their structural properties and adopt ab- frared spectroscopy (FTIR), and atomic normal conformations. These abnormally force microscopy (AFM), one study dis- folded proteins can then nucleate, forming sected the process of huntingtin (htt) oligomers. Oligomers then form protofib- exon 1 peptide aggregation and found rils that grow into fibrils. The transition evidence for a number of sequential mor- to the fibril stage is characterized by the phological and structural intermediates attainment of a β-sheet structure, so at (Fig. 6). By showing that misfolded htt this point the structures are amyloid-like. exon 1–44Q adopted intermediate struc- Fibrils then grow into fibers (also known tures, such work opened up the possibility as microaggregates), which then assemble that intermediates (not visible at the light into aggregates visible under a light micro- microscope level) are the toxic species and scope. According to such a model, blocking that the ultimate visible aggregated forms an intermediate step could be therapeu- of htt exon 1–44Q are neutralized versions tically effective. Consistent with this, one 28 Triplet Repeat Diseases
Fig. 6 Polyglutamine-expanded huntingtin protein undergoes a variety of structural alterations on its way to becoming a visible aggregate. In this experiment, transmission electron microscopy tracked the structure of huntingtin exon 1 peptide with 44 glutamines after release from a linked (a) Control (b) 2 h affinity tag. (a) Prior to affinity tag release, nothing is observed. (b-c) After affinity tag release, globular structures become apparent. (d) This is followed by formation of short fibers (4–5 nm in diameter). (e-f) Fiber formation becomes more prominent. However, during this time, large globular (c) 3 h (d) 4 h assemblies remain (arrowheads). (g-h) Eventually, only fibers are present, and the fibers begin to adopt a uniform appearance, suggesting consolidation into protofibrils. (From Poirier, M.A., Li, H., Macosko, J., Cai, S., Amzel, M., Ross, C.A. (2002) Huntingtin spheroids and protofibrils as precursors in (e) 5 h (f) 6 h polyglutamine fibrilization, J. Biol. Chem. 277, 41032–41037, used with permission of the Journal of Biological Chemistry.).
(g) 7 h(h) 8 h
group has nicely shown that Congo red can enhances their sequestration into visi- bind polyglutamine peptides once they are ble aggregates is beneficial. Finally, since amyloid-like and prevent their conversion oligomers are difficult to detect, it is of- into fibers, while an independent group ten not possible to know whether cells are has shown that Congo red delivery to an successfully sequestering the toxic precur- HD mouse model is a highly effective treat- sors into aggregates or if high levels of ment intervention. toxic intermediates are building up. So, One satisfying aspect of this model is aggregates are thus also incidental, since that it allows us to simultaneously view their presence does not provide us with aggregates as harmful, protective, and in- insight into the steady state levels of the nocuous. How? First, aggregates clearly toxic precursors. In conclusion, advances must be toxic as their creation is predicated in our understanding of the role of aggre- upon the production of earlier intermedi- gateformationinpolyglutaminedisease ate toxic forms. At the same time, the processes suggest that aggregates may be final visible aggregates are less toxic than simultaneously viewed as harmful, benefi- the earlier intermediates, so anything that cial, and incidental. Triplet Repeat Diseases 29
3.11 ataxin-1 with a mutated NLS do not develop Protein Context the SCA1 phenotype, while those without mutated NLSs do. Interaction domains Theimportanceofproteincontextinthe also affect polyglutamine protein toxic- pathogenesis of polyglutamine disorders ity. The ability of expanded polyglutamine is a subject of great interest to many proteins to interact with other molecules researchers, because it is directly related is a promising avenue in the search for to the mechanisms of toxicity in each mechanisms of cell-type specificity. Yeast disease. It is evident in the polyglutamine two-hybrid screens and other techniques disorders that protein context plays a have yielded interaction partners for a role in cell-type specificity. For example, number of polyglutamine proteins. For a polyglutamine expansion in the Htt example, Htt’s interactions with transcrip- protein causes a severe degeneration tion factors may prove to be central to its of the striatum and cortex, while the pathological effects. At the same time, it is same size glutamine tract in ataxin- 1 causes a degeneration of structures also evident that polyglutamine tracts are in the cerebellum and brainstem, while innately toxic. Pure polyglutamine tracts sparing the striatum and cortex. This cause toxicity in cell culture. Mice that cannot be attributed to gross differences express a glutamine tract of 150 amino in expression patterns, since both proteins acids in the Hprt protein, which does not are pan-neural (Fig. 7). naturally contain any such tracts, exhibit Oneeffectthatproteincontextmayhave progressive neurological deficits and NIs. on pathology is to affect subcellular local- Thus,itappearsthatpathologyineach ization. For example, the presence of a polyglutamine disease is due to a gain of functional NLS or NES dictates preferen- function of the glutamine tract that is then tial subcellular localization in the nucleus modulated by the protein context in which or cytoplasm. Mice expressing expanded it resides.
Central nervous system:
Cerebral hemisphere Brain Brain stem
Spinal cord
Fig. 7 The conundrum of cell-type specificity in the polyglutamine diseases. Although the different polyglutamine disease proteins are Huntington's disease expressed throughout the central Spinal muscular atrophy nervous system, only select populations of neurons degenerate in the different Spinocerebellar ataxias disorders. The principal regions of selective vulnerability are shown for certain of the polyglutamine diseases. 30 Triplet Repeat Diseases
3.12 tendency for the polyglutamine dis- Transcriptional Dysregulation ease proteins to alter transcription factor/coactivator-mediated histone acetyl- Transcriptional dysregulation is one the- transferase (HAT) activity. The ability of ory of polyglutamine toxicity that has agenetobetranscribeddependsupon gained support from many lines of evi- its chromatin structure, and thus upon dence in several disorders, and it appears the degree of histone acetylation in its increasingly likely that it is one of the vicinity. This is because acetylated hi- fundamental causes of pathogenesis. Mi- stones cause chromatin to be in an croarray technology and other genomic ‘‘open,’’ transcription-friendly conforma- techniques are facilitating rapid advances tion. Acetylation status depends upon the in this area of the polyglutamine field. The balance between the activity of HATs majority of polyglutamine disorders are and their countervailing counterparts, caused by proteins that are either transcrip- the HDACs. CBP, p300, and p300/CBP- tion factors/cofactors or interact closely associated factor (PCAF) are all HATs that with transcription factors. TBP and AR are are inhibited by polyglutamine-expanded transcription factors, atrophin-1 is a tran- htt exon 1 peptide and ataxin-3. In cell cul- scriptional corepressor, ataxin-7 is part of ture, expression of a mutant htt fragment a transcriptional coactivator complex, and reduces global histone acetylation. ataxin-1, htt, and ataxin-3 all interact with Finally, according to a very recent study, various transcription factors. It is therefore ataxin-7 directly interacts with GCN5 as reasonable to suspect that an abnormally part of the STAGA complex, and upon long polyglutamine tract could interfere polyglutamine expansion, mutant ataxin- with the transcriptional activity of these 7 causes a dominant-negative effect upon proteins and/or their interactors. GCN5 HAT activity. This results in CRX CBP is one of the most studied transcrip- transcription interference that may con- tion factors in the polyglutamine field. tribute to the SCA7 retinal degeneration It is a transcription activator that me- phenotype. Inhibiting HDACs with drugs diates part of the cellular response to known as HDAC inhibitors (HDAC Is) at- cAMP, and it can interact with numer- tenuates the phenotype of HD and SBMA ous polyglutamine proteins in the soluble in mouse and fly models, presumably by or insoluble phase, including huntingtin, shifting the cells’ acetylation status. HDAC ataxin-3, ataxin-7, and AR. Expanded htt Is such as sodium butyrate and especially represses CBP-regulated genes, and over- suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA) expression of CBP causes a considerable have thus emerged as possible candidates rescue of the cell death phenotype in HD for therapeutic trials in human polyglu- and SBMA cell culture models. Postna- tamine disease patients. tal mice lacking CBP’s upstream activator CREB and its homolog CREM display a 3.13 profound degeneration of the striatum Proteolytic Cleavage and hippocampus. Thus, interference with CBP appears to be a common theme in The occurrence of proteolytic cleavage in polyglutamine pathology. polyglutamine diseases first became ap- Another common theme in the tran- parent when it was shown in HD that scription dysregulation equation is the htt can be cleaved by extracts derived Triplet Repeat Diseases 31
Fig. 8 Proteolytic cleavage in the polyglutamine (kD) nt 24Q 92Q diseases. Production of amino-terminal truncated proteins is observed in many of the polyglutamine 148 Ataxin-7 92Q diseases, as is shown here for SCA7. In this Ataxin-7 24Q experiment, nuclear fractions of retinal lysates 98 from age- and sex-matched nontransgenic (nt), ataxin-7 CAG-24 (24Q), and ataxin-7 CAG-92 (92Q) 64 mice were prepared and immunoblotted with an 55-kD fragment antibody directed against the amino-terminal 50 region of the protein ataxin-7. As shown here, in addition to soluble full-length ataxin-7 (which is 36 typically reduced in cells where it is aggregating 22 into insoluble inclusions), an ∼50–60kD fragment is detected. (Adapted from Garden, G.A., Libby, R.T., Fu, Y.H., Kinoshita, Y., Huang, J., Possin, D.E., Smith, A.C., Martinez, R.A., Fine, G.C., Grote, S.K., et al. (2002) Polyglutamine- expanded ataxin-7 promotes noncell-autonomous Purkinje cell degeneration and displays proteolytic cleavage in ataxic transgenic mice, J. Neurosci. 22, 4897–4905. Used with permission of the Journal of Neuroscience.). from apoptotic cells. Subsequent publi- proteolysis may be a normal event in pro- cations showed that only amino-terminal tein turnover and the inability to clear epitopes of htt protein are detectable in ag- cleaved protein may be the problem. gregates. SBMA, DRPLA, and SCA7 were Another possibility is that soluble polyglu- then added to the list of diseases in which tamine proteins may cause the activation aggregates are only immunoreactive for of proteases such as caspases, which then a glutamine-containing fragment of the cleave the disease protein and send the cell disease protein. Since then, evidence of on a path to degeneration and ultimately proteolytic cleavage has been published for apoptosis. As we will see, each theory has nearly all known polyglutamine disorders. support and not all are mutually exclusive. Experimental studies revealed that inhibi- Abnormal proteolysis of polyglutamine tion of caspase cleavage reduces aggregate disease proteins is one possible mecha- formation and toxicity in a cell culture nism of toxicity. Some studies have shown model of HD, underscoring the relevance that polyglutamine repeat length modu- of proteolytic cleavage in polyglutamine lates susceptibility to proteolytic cleavage, disease pathogenesis. Cleavage promotes but results have been inconclusive. Few aggregation and/or toxicity in SCA3 and studies have been performed using hu- SCA7 (Fig. 8). Polyglutamine tract con- man brain tissue, however. Considerable taining htt fragments are more toxic in cell evidence exists to show that polyglutamine culture than full-length htt, and the most tracts themselves are resistant to degrada- widely used HD mouse model expresses tion by mammalian proteasomes. The 20S only exon 1 of the htt gene. and 26S eukaryotic proteasomes are in- There are several mechanisms by which capable of cutting within polyglutamine cleavage may modulate polyglutamine tracts longer than 9 amino acids in vitro. neurotoxicity. Abnormal proteolysis of The inability of the proteasome to di- polyglutamine proteins may lead to a toxic gest glutamine tracts may contribute to species that can cause damage in the the toxicity and aggregation of expanded soluble or insoluble phase. Alternatively, polyglutamine peptide fragments. 32 Triplet Repeat Diseases
Proteolysis may be a normal part of the There are many proteases that are sus- turnover of wild-type and mutant htt. One pected to play a role in the proteolytic group published evidence that caspase-3 cleavage of polyglutamine proteins, the cleaves both mutant and wild-type htt in most studied of which are the caspases. the cytoplasm of HD brains, suggesting Caspases are cysteine- dependent aspartyl that this particular cleavage is a normal proteases that play a crucial role in apop- event in its turnover. Since this fragment tosis, but are increasingly being inves- was located exclusively in the cytoplasm, it tigated for their nonapoptotic functions. also implies that further cleavage occurs In healthy cells, caspases are present pre- before the nuclear translocation of htt. dominantly as inactive proenzymes, which Another study suggested that pepstatin- must be cleaved for full activity. Caspase-3 sensitive aspartyl endopeptidases such as is the only protease that has been shown the presenilins and cathepsins D and E to cleave htt in HD patient’s material, al- may be involved in the normal turnover though caspases 1 and 6 have also been of htt. This process, which may normally implicated in cell culture and in vivo. aid in maintaining the balance between htt Inhibiting the cleavage of htt by any of synthesis and degradation, could generate these three proteases is protective, and an a toxic, highly aggregation-prone (and HD mouse model expressing dominant- negative caspase-1 showed significantly hence intermediate oligomer/protofibril- delayed disease onset. Caspase-3 has also prone) species when it cleaves mutant htt. been implicated in the proteolytic cleavage Another possible source of toxic cleav- of atrophin-1, ataxin-3 and AR. Caspases age products is the ubiquitin-proteasome are activated in response to a number of system, which is responsible for labeling cellular insults, and in postmitotic cells anddigestingmisfoldedproteins,among such as neurons where inhibitors of apop- other things. Polyglutamine tracts beyond tosis proteins (IAPs) are highly expressed, a threshold of about 35 glutamines adopt this may cause cellular damage that does β an abnormal -pleated sheet conforma- notresultinclassicalapoptosis. tion, which may cause the host protein Calpains are another family of pro- to be ubiquitinated and thus targeted for teases implicated in the cleavage of degradation. In support of this theory, polyglutamine proteins. They are calcium- a common feature of polyglutamine dis- activated cysteine proteases that exist pre- eases is the presence of ubiquitin-positive dominantly as proenzymes. As mouse inclusions. Arguing against this idea is models of HD and material from HD pa- an experiment showing that in a cell cul- tients exhibit abnormal mitochondrial cal- ture model of SCA1, increased proteasome cium regulation, some investigators have degradation due to the introduction of proposed that altered calcium flux is the a degradation signal reduces aggregates mechanism of calpain activation. Indeed, and toxicity. Another potential source of several cell culture studies support the role toxic fragments is the autophagy pathway, of calpain proteases I, II, and ‘‘m’’ in htt which is responsible for the bulk degrada- cleavage. As mentioned previously, other tion of cellular components. According to aspartyl proteases such as the Alzheimer’s one study, degradation of htt by autophagy disease-associated presenilins and auto- and the autophagosome-associated cathep- phagy-associated cathepsins have also sin D creates toxic htt fragments. been implicated in htt cleavage. Triplet Repeat Diseases 33
4 there is a linear correlation between re- Type 2: the Loss-of-function Repeat duced protein levels and IQ test scores. Diseases Expansion of the disease allele results in hypermethylation of the (CGG)n tract, 4.1 Fragile X Syndrome which spreads to a nearby CpG island in the FMR1 promoter region. Some of the Fragile X syndrome (FRAXA) is an X- proposed secondary structures formed by linked disorder with a prevalence of 1 the FRAXA repeat contain C–C mispairs, in 4000 in males and 1 in 8000 in fe- which are good targets for human DNA males, making it the most common form methyltransferase. Another theory invokes of inherited mental retardation. Neuro- the RNAi protein Dicer’s ability to cleave logical presentation frequently includes CGG repeat RNA, postulating that the re- mild to severe mental retardation, hy- sulting siRNAs recruit DNA methyltrans- peractivity, poor eye contact, high-pitched ferases to the FMR1 locus. Affected alleles speech, and flapping or biting hand move- also display condensed chromatin, loss of ments. Physical signs in males include histone acetylation and increased histone long, prominent ears, and jaws, macro- methylation. These data support a process cephaly, postpubescent macroorchidism, whereby DNA methylation recruits tran- and occasionally, connective tissue abnor- scription silencing machinery, which sub- malities. The mutation responsible for sequently suppresses FMR1 transcription FRAXA is typically an expansion of a in the nearby promoter region. Interest- polymorphic (CGG)n repeat found in the ingly, while premutation carriers had been 5 -untranslated region of the fragile X men- viewed as perfectly normal for decades, tal retardation-1 (FMR1) gene. Expanded recent work indicates that some premuta- chromosomes have a folate-sensitive frag- tion carriers (60–200 uninterrupted CGG ile site at Xq27.3 that can be viewed under repeats) display a phenotype distinct from a light microscope under special cell cul- FRAXA. Females have a predisposition ture conditions. Normal alleles contain to premature ovarian failure (POF), and 6–53 triplets punctuated by one or more males may develop late-onset ataxia and AGGs, which are considered to have a tremor with the presence of neuronal in- stabilizing influence on the repeat. Dis- tranuclear inclusions (NIs) that consist ease alleles contain expansions beyond 200 ofRNA.(ThisnewFXTASisdiscussed and up to 2000 repeats, with no AGG in- in a separate section.) Expression stud- terruptions. Pathogenic expansions result ies have shown that premutation carriers exclusively from maternal transmission. may express up to seven times more FRAXA appears to be a loss-of-function FMR1 mRNA than normal individuals. disorder, since deletion of FMR1 and This upregulation is probably not due to loss-of-function point mutations can also compensation for loss of function, be- causeFRAXA.Thisviewisfurthersup- cause individuals with point mutations ported by the FMR1 knockout mouse, resulting in loss of function of FMRP do which reproduces certain aspects of the not have higher levels of the transcript. human disorder. Abnormal transcript levels due to premu- FRAXA patients have reduced levels tations or full mutations are thought to of the FMR1 gene product, FMRP, and be as a result of the expansion’s effect 34 Triplet Repeat Diseases