Linguistic Change by Rule Generalization As Illustrated By
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
-- - National Li bcary- - E iblioth-e nationale - - - CANADIAN T-HEf ESP- TH&FS-&YAD~~S 1Je ofCanada . duCanada ON MtcRoFlcHE sua MicRoFIc \ -- J TITLE OF ThESIS/?ITRE DE LA TH~SE Linqkist ic Change by Rule General izat ion as Illustrated by Portuguese ~Ssalization i .P* IVERSITY/UNIVERSI T,! Simon Fraser University ; EAR THIS DEGREE CONFERRED/ANN,& D'OBTENTION D•’C€ GRADE 9 LAME ,OF SUPERVIStaih'OM DU DlREC TEUR DE THZSE D r . a F0 l e'~ Permission is hereby granted%to the NATIONAL LIBRARY OF L'autorisation est; par la prgsente, accdrdde 3 la 618~10~~~- t CANADA to microfilm this thesis and to lend or sell copies QUE NATIONALE DU CANADA. de microfilmer cette these et of the film. -de pr&er ou de vendre des exemplaires du film. Tne author reserves other publication rights, and neither the L'auteur se rgserve ' les autres droits de publicati~n;ni la " -_ raests nor extmsive extracts from it may be printed or other- th&seni,de longs extraits de celle-ci ne doivent stre ~mprimt+s UYISF: reproduced without the author's written permission.' w eutrement reproduit sans l'autorisation Bcrite de /'auteur. 1 , t National L~braryof CaMda &Wioth&que nationale du -,a Collections Development Branch Direction du developpement des collections NOTICE "The quality bf this microfiche is heavily dep ent La qualit6 de cette microfiche depend grandement de upon the quality of the original thesis submi for la qualit6 de la the m~miseau microfilmage. Nous microfilming. Every effort has been made to ensure ' avons tout fait pour assurer une ' qualit6 suphrieure the highest quality of reproduction possible. de reproduction. --ppp - - -- ppp-- - -- - -- -pp ---- -- If pages are missing, contact the university which S'il manque des pages, veuillez communiquer granted the degree. avec I'universitk qui a confer6 le grade. - I Some pages may Rave indistinct print especially La qualite d'impression de certaines pages peut if the original pages were typed with a poor typewriter laisser a dksirer, surtout si les pages originales ont etk ribbon or if the university sent us a poor photocopy. dactylographiees B I'aide d'un ruban us6 ou si I'univer- site nous a fait parvenir une photocopie de mauvaise qualite. Previously copyrighted materials (journal articles, Les documents qui font d6jB I'objet d'un droit pubiished_teas,-excLarenatfilmed 3-p- -p-pp--d'auteur- (articles de revue, Emens publies, etc.) nee sont pas microfilmCs. I Reproduction in full or in part of this film is gov- La reproduction, m6me partielle, de ce microfilm erned by the Canadian Copyright Act, R.S.C. 1970, est soumise a la Loi canadienne sur le droit d'auteur, c. C-30. Please read the authorization forms which SRC 1970, c. C-30. Veuillez prendre connaissance des accompany this thesis. formules d'autotkation qui accompagnent cette thkse. THIS DISSERTATION LA THESE A' ETE HAS BEEN MICROFILMED MICROFILMEE TELLE QUE EXACTLY AS RECEIVED NOUS L'AVONS RECUE * Ottawa, Canada KIA ON4 , LINGUISTIC CHANGE BY -RULE GENERALIZATION AS ILLUSTRATED BY , PORTUGUESE NASALIZATION AND RADICAL VOWEL ALTERNATIONS Paul HcFetridge a, THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUlREMEWS FOR THE DEGREE OF .'L MASTER-OF ARTS 8 in the. Department 7 I' , Languages, Literatures and L4nguist ics @ Paul McPetridge 1981 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY 1 --reproduced in whole or' in part, by photocopy P or other means, without pemssion of the author. I hereby grant to Sirpdn Fraser university the right to lend my thesis or dissertation (the title of which ahown i s below) _ to users \ - *. of :he Simcm Fraser University Library, and to make partial or single copies only for such users or in response to a request from the library I - of any other university, or other educakional inLtitution, on its own I - - - -A - - - behalf or for -one af-its users. I fu__r_ther.agree that permissi- for _ -- .- -- . t multiple copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by or the Dean of Graduate Studies. It is understood that copying - -- - - - --- -- -- - - -- -- -- -- - or publication of this- thesis for ffnancial gain shall not be allowed without my wit ten permission. Title of Tnesis/~issertation: Linguistic- Chancre by Rule Garali7lti'nn and Radical Vowel A1 ternat ions, Author : f / e / '(signature) (date) Name: Paul Gil bert McFetri dge Degree: Master of Arts Title of Thesis: LingOistic Change by Rule Generalization as Illustrated by Portuguese Nasalization - - Vowel A1 ternat ions . Chai man: Ross Saunders Thomas A. Perry , Edward Finegan External Examiner Associate Professor Depa'rtment of Linguistics University of Southern California Date approved : 3l @Wt" ", In the theory of phonoloa fondlated by J, Foley, it is, maintained that !lphonologicai change is not caused by the < addition of rules to a gramnar, but by the repetition or modif ication of rules already existing in the languagew. o ole^, , "The Latip origin of Romance rules". ) It is !maintained tha.t . ,,/ \ -- - --- linguistic chance, change inprocesses operatingin the - -- language, occurs in three ways; generalization of application to * I 5. include more elements, generalization of environment, and -- - - - repe- pfureeSses.~rconcept- XrIlnguis tic change is t applied to the analysis of two aspects of Portuguese phonology: nasalization and radical vowel a1,ternations. Chapter I presents a brief outline of the conception of linguistic change as generalization of rules which exist in the language. It is demonstrated that denial of the traditional -- +-- - - -- -- -- - synchronic/diachronic distinction permits analyses which simultaneously explain data traditionally classified as synchronic as well as the linguistic change from historically earlier stages of the language by reference to the same set of - - - 1) - processes and principles, I * In Chapter 11, nasal diphthongs and the retention of preconsonantal nasals are examined. The latter is theoretically preconsonantaloef fare. Tt is nrvu- d retention is only apparent, the result of generalization of - -- Latin vocalization which causes a glide to remain after nasal effacempt. This glide either fqrms a nasal diphthong withuthe preceding vowel or,consonantalizes before a stop. This is further related to the vocalization of -1 and the palatalization of -s. 1 a - - -- In Chapter 3, the radical vowel aTternations of the t-----. Portuguese verb are examined. Analyses by Williams and Harris, which propose rules of assfmilat ion, are considered, but F because it uses morphologically sensitive-and language particular rules. It iB argued that the alternations are caused by the generalization of Latin contraction. c he contract ion of .-' - dissimilar vowels causes weakening of the radical vowel in proportion to tJre strength required for contraction. ~vidence from Old Portuguese is ad,duced in support of this claim., It is concluded that Portuguese rules are the result of continuing linguistic change generalizing Latin rules. TABLE OF CONTENTS Approval .............................................,........ii Abstract ....................................................... a I. Introduction :.,..............................l 11. Nasalization ...............................,.9 Summary ............................................25 . - - - 111. Radical Vowel Alternations in the - - - Portuguese Verb ....................................28 , Sumnafl ............................................55 . t Bibliography ..............,..'..........................:.....65 - 1 a f - I. Znt roduct ion Wrfting in 1906, Meillet argued that linguistic change is , -I neither a&aberr?tion nor a collectipn of arbitrary unrelated * -. .- f events,, but a, continuing coherent pfoce*ss.' He maintained that -- 4 ' i_ k explanation .of &his must refer to universal "t imeless,-'linguistic laws".. i * It - -- I 13~-UC~e%ontinlti6-~~&volut is= -- -- Lnguistiqu=, et cette continuit6 r&v&lela - constance des causes qui dgterminent les i modalit& du changement. -"---- Les changements linguistiques ne prennent leur sens que si l'on consid6re tout l'ensemble du # diiveloppement dont ils font. partie; un &me changement a une signification absolutkment differente suivant le proces dont il relave, et il n'est jamafs lggitime d'essayer d'expliquer un d6tail en dehors de la -- -- ;- -- - - - -- --- consid6ration du syst&me g6n6ral de la langue oh il apparait. D;?S lors la nCcessit6 stimposer%e chercher 2 formuler les lois suivant lesquelles sont susceptibles de s'opsrer les changements linguistiques. On determinera alnsi, -non plus ' Y des lois historiques,. telles que sont les <<lois ph6n6tWiques>>ou les formules analogiques qui emplissent les manuels actuels de linguistique, mais des lois gsnlrales qui ne valent par pour une seul moment du d6veloppement d'une langue, qui au contraire '-, sont de tous les temps; qui ne s70nt pas ., , limit+es une langue donnse, qui au contraire - --- - -- - -- - - - - --- rt sr6tendent egalement a toutes les langue~.Et, k qu'on le remarque, ce ne seront ni des lois ioloeques nf des lois psycniques, mais . Since de Saussure, .it has been generally assumed that the , study of linguistic change and the study of a particular synchronic stage on a language are separate fields of inquiry. Ontological and methodological priority has been placed on m synchrony and diachrony has becdme the coAPpariaon of synchronic continuing trends in language, their explanation, nor the - discovery of universal phonological. processes. The - --- --- - - ----- - - -- - synchronic/diachronic distinction legitimizes the ahlysis of a