Historic Preservation Law: the Metes & Bounds of a New Field

Copy Link

Pace University

DigitalCommons@Pace

Pace Law Faculty Publications

1-1-1981

School of Law

Historic Preservation Law: The Metes & Bounds of a New Field

Nicholas A. Robinson

Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University

Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.pace.edu/lawfaculty
Part of the Environmental Law Commons

Recommended Citation

Nicholas A. Robinson, Historic Preservation Law: The Metes & Bounds of a New Field, 1 Pace L. Rev. 511 (1981), http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/lawfaculty/387/.

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Law at DigitalCommons@Pace. It has been accepted for inclusion in Pace Law Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Pace. For more information, please contact [email protected].

Recommended publications

Landmarks Preservation Commission November 22, 2016, Designation List 490 LP-2579

Landmarks Preservation Commission November 22, 2016, Designation List 490 LP-2579 YALE CLUB OF NEW YORK CITY 50 Vanderbilt Avenue (aka 49-55 East 44th Street), Manhattan Built 1913-15; architect, James Gamble Rogers Landmark site: Borough of Manhattan Tax Map Block 1279, Lot 28 On September 13, 2016, the Landmarks Preservation Commission held a public hearing on the proposed designation of the Yale Club of New York City and the proposed designation of the related Landmark Site. The hearing had been duly advertised in accordance with provisions of law. Six people spoke in support of designation, including representatives of the Yale Club of New York City, Manhattan Borough President Gale A. Brewer, Historic Districts Council, New York Landmarks Conservancy, and the Municipal Art Society of New York. The Real Estate Board of New York submitted written testimony in opposition to designation. State Senator Brad Hoylman submitted written testimony in support of designation. Summary The Yale Club of New York City is a Renaissance Revival-style skyscraper at the northwest corner of Vanderbilt Avenue and East 44th Street. For more than a century it has played an important role in East Midtown, serving the Yale community and providing a handsome and complementary backdrop to Grand Central Terminal. Constructed on property that was once owned by the New York Central Railroad, it stands directly above two levels of train tracks and platforms. This was the ideal location to build the Yale Club, opposite the new terminal, which serves New Haven, where Yale University is located, and at the east end of “clubhouse row.” The architect was James Gamble Rogers, who graduated from Yale College in 1889 and attended the Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris during the 1890s.
Federal Railroad Administration Record of Decision for the East Side Access Project

Federal Railroad Administration Record of Decision For the East Side Access Project September 2012 SUMMARY OF DECISION This is a Record of Decision (ROD) of the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA), an operating administration of the U.S. Department of Transportation, regarding the East Side Access (ESA) Project. FRA has prepared this ROD in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the Council on Environmental Quality’s (CEQ) regulations implementing NEPA, and FRA’s Procedures for Considering Environmental Impacts. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) filed an application with the FRA for a loan to finance eligible elements of the ESA Project through the Railroad Rehabilitation and Improvement Financing (RRIF) Program. The ESA Project is the MTA’s largest system expansion in over 100 years. The ESA Project will expand the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) services by connecting Queens and Long Island with East Midtown Manhattan. With direct LIRR service to Midtown East, the LIRR will further increase its market share of commuters by saving up to 40 minutes per day in subway/bus/sidewalk travel time for commuters who work on Manhattan’s East Side. The ESA Project was previously considered in an environmental impact statement (EIS) prepared by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) in May 2001 and subsequent FTA reevaluations and an environmental assessment of changes in the ESA Project. Construction of the ESA Project has been ongoing since 2001. FRA has reviewed the environmental impacts for the ESA Project identified in the FTA March 2001 Final EIS, subsequent FTA Reevaluations, and the 2006 Supplemental EA/FONSI (collectively, the “2001 EIS”) for the ESA Project and adopted it pursuant to CEQ regulations (40 CFR 1506.3).
Section Date Title Box Folder Notes Daily 1962 February 19

Ada Louise Huxtable New York Times bibliography Ada Louise Huxtable papers, 1859-2013, bulk 1954-2012 The Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, accession no. 2013.M.9 For more information about the Ada Louise Huxtable papers, see the collection finding aid To access physical materials on site, go to the library catalog record for this collection and click "Request." Click here for the access policy. Section Date Title Box Folder Notes Daily 1962 February 19 Art: Wright Mythology 16 4 Daily 1962 April 29 Controversy Widens on Design of Development in Washington 16 4 Daily 1962 June 1 Kennedy Adopts Architects' Plan to Give Capital a Modern Look 16 4 Daily 1962 November 11 Federal Pavilion for New York World's Fair Is Nearing a Decision 16 4 Daily 1963 January 26 A Fair U.S. Pavilion 16 4 Daily 1963 May 28 Bold Harvard Structure 16 4 Daily 1963 June 21 Litho City: Hit or Flop? 16 4 Daily 1963 August 14 Chicago Saves Its Past 16 4 Daily 1963 August 20 Plan for Rebuilding Pennsylvania Ave. Is Near Completion 16 4 Daily 1963 October 5 Architecture: Designs for American Synagogues 16 4 Daily 1963 October 10 Upheaval at Battery 16 4 Daily 1963 October 16 Planner Defends Cars in Midtown 16 4 Daily 1963 October 24 Architecture: Virtues of Planned City 16 4 Daily 1963 November 7 Complex in Boston Is Radically Designed 16 4 Daily 1963 November 9 Yale to Dedicate 3D New Building 16 4 Daily 1963 November 24 Renewal Project Splits Cleveland 16 4 Review of Great American Mansions Daily 1963 November 26 End Papers 16 4 by Merrill Folsom.
Download Report

NEW YORK PROFITING THROUGH PRESERVATION PRESERVATION LEAGUE OF NEW YORK STATE MISSION STATEMENT By leading a statewide preservation movement, sharing information and expertise, and raising a uniﬁed voice, the Preservation League of New York State promotes historic preservation as a tool to revitalize our neighborhoods and communities, honor our heritage, and enrich our lives. Funding for this project was generously provided by The Chase Manhattan Bank. Printing was made possible with public funds from the New York State Council on the Arts. This report was prepared by Donovan D. Rypkema, Principal, Real Estate Services Group, Inc., Washington, DC, with assistance from the Preservation League of New York State. VISION OF NEW YORK STATE The Preservation League of New York State is committed to a New York where all citizens recognize the intrinsic value of historic sites and cherish them as a vital part of everyday life. We envision New Yorkers who promote careful use of our diverse historic resources and understand the economic and social beneﬁts of historic preservation. The League aspires to create a universal preservation ethic that prevents losing our past through neglect, ignorance, or momentary expediency. We will strive to remind New Yorkers in every city, hamlet, and neighborhood of the value of the past, the ways in which it enriches our lives, and the irreplaceable legacy it provides our children. Historic preservation is a daily part of life for Historic preservation is attending a City nearly every New York citizen. For some, it means Council meeting in Buffalo’s Art Deco style City a visit to one of the hundreds of museums or Hall, or serving on jury duty in the landmark historic sites throughout the state.
The Radio Urbanism of Robert C. Weinberg, 1966–71 by Christopher Neville for the New York Preservation Archive Project

“Building and Rebuilding New York:” The Radio Urbanism of Robert C. Weinberg, 1966–71 by Christopher Neville for the New York Preservation Archive Project “...This is Robert C. Weinberg, critic-at-large in architecture and planning for WNYC.” Introduction: Robert Weinberg, Department of Parks (under Robert Moses), New York City, and WNYC and at the Department of City Planning. Robert C. Weinberg was an architect and urban planner active in New York from the He taught courses in planning and related early 1930s until his death in 1974. Over four ﬁelds at New York University, the Pratt Insti- decades of vigorous engagement with preser- tute, the New School for Social Research, and vation and planning issues, he was both an ac- Yale, and published roughly 150 articles and tive participant in or astute observer of almost reviews. He was also the co-editor, with every major development in New York urban- Henry Fagin, of the important 1958 report, ism. Between 1966 and 1971, near the end of Planning and Community Appearance, jointly his career, he served as radio station WNYC’s sponsored by the New York chapters of the “critic-at-large in architecture and planning,” American Institute of Architects and the and his broadcasts are a window onto his re- American Institute of Planners. markable career and the transformations he But over his long career, Weinberg devoted witnessed in the city he loved. Weinberg’s the bulk of his considerable energies to a long personal history in the trenches and be- broad range of public-spirited efforts covering hind the scenes gave him unique perspective almost every aspect of urban development and on these changes—an insider’s overview, with city life, including historic preservation, zon- a veteran’s hindsight.
Book Review Miracle on Fourth Street: Saving an Old Merchant’S House by Lisa Ackerman, Secretary, New York Preservation Archive Project

BOARD OF DIRECTORS Anthony C. Wood, Chair Elizabeth R. Jeffe, Vice-Chair Bradley J. Vogel, Vice-Chair Stephen Facey, Treasurer Lisa Ackerman, Secretary Daniel J. Allen Michele H. Bogart Susan De Vries Kent Diebolt Amy Freitag Shirley Ferguson Jenks Richard J. Moylan Otis Pratt Pearsall Gina Pollara John T. Reddick Anthony W. Robins NEWSLETTER FALL 2016 Welcome to the 25th edition of the newsletter of the New York Preservation Archive Project. The mission of the New York Preservation Archive Project is to protect and raise awareness of the narratives of historic preservation in New York. Through public programs, outreach, celebration, and the creation of public access to information, the Archive Project hopes to bring these stories to light. From left to right: Denise Brown-Puryear, Yvonne Taylor, and Mandingo Tshaka, interviewees in the first phase of Saving Preservation Stories, Courtesy of Liz Strong and Leyla Vural Diversity Project Expanding! Oral History Project Focused on Diverse Preservation Stories Receives Additional Funding The New York Preservation Archive Project Archive Project’s oral history collection so is pleased to announce the expansion of that it reflects a more complete and diverse 2016 Bard Birthday the oral history project Saving Preservation narrative of preservation in New York City. Breakfast Benefit Stories: Diversity & the Outer Boroughs. Over the past year interviewers visited every Honoring Robert A.M. Stern Made possible through a grant from the borough in the City to interview community with our Preservation Award LuEsther T. Mertz Fund of the New York members who have worked tirelessly to and featuring a Community Trust, this expansion will allow preserve the history and architecture of Conversation on Preservation with the Archive Project to record additional sites and neighborhoods important to them Robert A.M.
West End-Collegiate Historic District Extension Designation Report

Addendum to the West End-Collegiate Historic District Extension Designation Report On October 30, 2013, the City Council of the City of New York modified the designation of the West End-Collegiate Historic District Extension, Designation List No. 465, LP-2462 (L.U. No. 918), City Council Resolution No. 1998, by deleting the following properties: 214 West 72nd Street Borough of Manhattan Tax Map Block 1163, Lot 42 232 West 73rd Street [Display Address: 236 West 73rd Street] Borough of Manhattan Tax Map Block 1164, Lot 42 In addition, the areas of the street beds of West 72nd Street and West 73rd Street that are directly in front of these buildings are also deleted from the district. West End-Collegiate Historic District Extension Landmarks Preservation Commission W 79 St 6 West End-Collegiate 320 3 7 250 9 3 9 0 9 1 3 2 Historic District Extension 2 1 9 3 Borough of Manhattan, NY [LP-2462] Calendared: November 16, 2010 339 317 257 251 340 324 262 W 78 St 250 Public Hearing: June 28, 2011 Designated: June 25, 2013 Boundary of District Extension 2 1 3 5 6 8 0 Tax Map Lots, District Extension 1 0 343 323 233 273 W 77 St Boundaries of Existing Districts Tax Map Lots, Existing Districts West End-Collegiate 2 1 6 Deleted by City Council Historic District 9 October 30, 2013 241 235 3 260 W 76 St 230 3 Existing Historic Districts 6 Historic District Extension Bronx 2 1 3 9 259 235 H W 75 St e 304 228 A 5 W n 1 R m 3 r e y i B s v s r t H e e t o est Side/ r Upper W r E u a s d d d i n d a w s d Central Park West e m o a A n D y Manhattan A ric District v Histo r P v y 301 W 74 St 231 Queens 1 320 232 5 Brooklyn 319 251 234 232 (Display 320 W 73 St Address 236) 1 311 233 W 72 St 216 214 344 West 71st Street Historic District 357 353 303 213 352 342 308 W 71 St 212 2 1 2 2 250 0 2 Feet 303 211 ¯ W 70 St Graphic Source: MapPLUTO, Edition 09v1, 2009.
Welcome to New York (Midtown's Publishing Landmarks)

Conference Keynote Molly O’Neill • Social Networking • Market Report: Entrepreneur The Monthly The Official Publication of the American Society of Journalists and Authors, Inc. Volume 58 • Number 4 • April 2009 welcome to NEW YORKby tony robins ‘‘WE WRITE WHAT YOU READ’’ Grand Central Terminal: Threatened in the late ‘70s with demolition, the city’s secular cathedral was rescued by welcome to a Supreme Court decision upholding the local landmarks law, and then by a $150-millon restoration. Today, the Grand Central Partnership sponsors a free tour of the Terminal every Friday at 12:30 (no reservations required; meet at the NEW sculpture court of the Whitney Museum, across 42nd Street from the Terminal). Visit the lower Concourse (the “Dining Concourse”) for inexpensive ethnic/fast-food stands—or the much more expensive, but very romantic, Oyster Bar. YORK From here, you can walk to three of Gotham’s major attractions—and on your way, pass some of the city’s jour- nalistic landmarks. To Times Square: Walk westward along 42nd Street, and at Fifth Avenue you’ll find the vast New York Public Library. Its many treasures include the DeWitt Wallace Periodicals Room—restored thanks to grants from the eponymous founder of Readers Digest (who started digesting articles in this very room), and adorned with Richard Haas’s wonderful murals of old New York newspaper headquarters (if you need to scan back issues before pitching a new market, this is the place to come). Turn right (north) up Fifth Avenue, then left on West 44th Street, and you’ll pass by No.
1885-1915 Urbanism & the Search for Order

History of New York City Architecture: 1885-1915 Urbanism & the Search for Order 1885-1915 Urbanism & the Search for Order A period of “creative eclecticism” – buildings were carefully designed to accommodate historic styles with modern functions. Historical association brought a sense of continuity and security in a time of great change. Multiple period revival styles: Beaux-Arts, neo-classical, neo-Gothic, neo-Federal Characteristics of Beaux-Arts style Classical based on Greek & Roman structures Symmetrical (generally) Heavy stone bases (rustification) Use of light colored materials Grand stairways Paired columns with plinths Monumental attics Grand opening/ entrances Extensive ornamentation (cartouch, festoon, sculpture, rustification, horror vacui, etc) The Lotos Club, originally Margaret Vanderbilt Shepard residence/ later Mr. & Mrs. William Schiefflin residence, Richard Howland Hunt, 1900. New India House/ originally Marshall Orme Wilson residence, Warren & Wetmore, 1903. Monumental attics (usually used mansard roofs) Grand opening/ entrances Heavy stone base using rustification stone masonry with the joints between the blocks deeply cut back Extensive ornamentation Cartouches- an ornamental panel in the form of a scroll, circle or oval, often bearing an inscription Festoon a decorative garland suspended in a curve between 2 points carved in stone Grand entrance Light colored limestone Extensive ornamentation (cartouch, festoons, foliated carving) Extensive ornamentation Plinths (square or rectangular base for a column, pilaster or a solid monumental base, often ornamented to support a statue Residences and Hotels The Lotos Club, originally Margaret Vanderbilt Shepard residence/ later Mr. & Mrs. William Schiefflin residence, Richard Howland Hunt, 1900. New India House/ originally Marshall Orme Wilson residence, Warren & Wetmore, 1903. St. Regis-Sheraton Hotel, Trowbridge & Livingston, 1904.
SHELTON HOTEL, 525 Lexington Avenue

Landmarks Preservation Commission November 22, 2016, Designation List 490 LP-2557 SHELTON HOTEL, 525 Lexington Avenue (aka 523-527 Lexington Avenue, 137-139 East 48th Street, 136-140 East 49th Street), Manhattan Built: 1922-23; architect, Arthur Loomis Harmon Landmark Site: Borough of Manhattan, Tax Map Block 1303, Lot 53 On July 19, 2016 the Landmarks Preservation Commission held a public hearing on the proposed designation as a Landmark of the Shelton Hotel and the proposed designation of the related Landmark Site (Item No. 4). The hearing had been duly advertised in accordance with the provisions of the law. A representative of the owner spoke in favor of the designation acknowledging the building’s architectural and cultural importance. There were five other speakers in support of the designation including representatives of Borough President Gale Brewer, Community Board 6, the New York Landmarks Conservancy, the Historic Districts Council, and the Municipal Arts Society. A representative of the Real Estate Board of New York spoke in opposition to the designation. A representative of Council Member Daniel Garodnick submitted written testimony in support of the designation. Two other individuals have also submitted emails in support of the designation. Summary Designed by architect Arthur Loomis Harmon and completed in 1923, the Shelton Hotel was one of the first “skyscraper” residential hotels. With its powerful massing it played an important role in the development of the skyscraper in New York City. Located on the east side of Lexington Avenue between 48th and 49th Streets, it is one of the premiere hotels constructed along the noted “hotel alley” stretch of Lexington Avenue, which was built as part of the redevelopment of this section of East Midtown that followed the opening of Grand Central Terminal and the Lexington Avenue subway line.
OSBORNE APARTMENTS 205 West 57Th Street, Borough of Manhattan

Landmarks Preservation Commission August 13, 1991; Designation List 238 LP-1770 OSBORNE APARTMENTS 205 West 57th Street, Borough of Manhattan. Built 1883-1885, 1889; architect, James Edward Ware; 1906, architect, Alfred S.G. Taylor. Landmark Site: Borough of Manhattan, Tax Map Block 1029, Lot 27. On December 12, 1989, the Landmarks Preservation Commission held a public hearing on the proposed designation as a Landmark of the Osborne Apartments and the proposed designation of the related Landmark Site (Item No. 34). The hearing was continued to April 3, 1990 (Item No. 25), and then to July 10, 1990 (Item No. 5). All three hearings had been duly advertised in accordance with the provisions of law. A total of seven witnesses at the three hearings spoke in favor of designation. Two witnesses were opposed to designation. The Commission received numerous letters both in support of and in opposition to designation. The Board of Directors of the Osborne Apartments has expressed support for the designation.1 DESCRIPTION AND ANALYSIS Summary The Osborne Apartments, built in 1883-85 and designed by the talented and prolific architect James E. Ware, was one of the earliest luxury apartment buildings in New York City. Constructed in what by 1890 had become New York's first apartment house district, near Central Park, this architecturally-impressive building is a rare surviving example of the original development in this city of multi-family dwellings for well-to-do residents, an increasingly important building type in the 1880s. The Osborne's design draws elements from the popular Romanesque Revival style, such as the heavy, rusticated stone exterior with deeply set windows, for a sense of solidity; these are combined in a bold and original manner with the refinement, proportions, and strong horizontality of the emerging Renaissance Revival style.
INDIVIDUAL INTERVIEW the Reminiscences of Mosette

INDIVIDUAL INTERVIEW The Reminiscences of Mosette Broderick © 2010, New York Preservation Archive Project PREFACE The following oral history is the result of a recorded interview with Mosette Broderick conducted by Interviewer Megan Ricks on March 18, 2010. This interview is part of the New York Preservation Archive Project’s collection of individual interviews. The reader is asked to bear in mind that s/he is reading a verbatim transcript of the spoken word, rather than written prose. The views expressed in this oral history interview do not necessarily reflect the views of the New York Preservation Archive Project. Mosette Broderick’s interest in preservation was spurred by the efforts to save the Villard Houses. She worked as an assistant for the architectural historian and champion of preservation Henry-Russell Hitchcock for many years. An architectural historian herself, Broderick frequently provided expert opinions to the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission on behalf of landmark designation proposals. She speaks about her work with as a historian and the evolution of New York’s preservation movement over her career, including the renovation of the Villard Houses, the battle to preserve St. Bartholomew’s Episcopal Church, the Schinasi Mansion, and designation of the Coogan Building, which was eventually demolished. Broderick also comments on the evolution of the role of architectural historians in the preservation movement. Architectural historian Mosette Broderick received her Ph.D from Columbia University in 1972. She began her career working for notable architectural historian Henry Russell-Hitchcock. An active preservationist, she often testified before the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission.