Sympathy and Postwar American Poetry
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Western University Scholarship@Western Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository 8-13-2013 12:00 AM Feeling With Imagination: Sympathy and Postwar American Poetry Timothy A. DeJong The University of Western Ontario Supervisor Dr. Stephen Adams The University of Western Ontario Graduate Program in English A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree in Doctor of Philosophy © Timothy A. DeJong 2013 Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd Part of the Literature in English, North America Commons Recommended Citation DeJong, Timothy A., "Feeling With Imagination: Sympathy and Postwar American Poetry" (2013). Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository. 1491. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd/1491 This Dissertation/Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected]. FEELING WITH IMAGINATION: SYMPATHY AND POSTWAR AMERICAN POETRY (Thesis Format: Monograph) by Timothy A. DeJong Graduate Program in English A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The School of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario, Canada © Timothy A. DeJong 2013 Abstract This dissertation examines how sympathy, defined as the act of “feeling with” another, develops within American poetics from 1950-1965 both as aesthetic strategy and as political response to Cold War culture. Re-examining the social aims of postwar poets typically either thought of as apolitical or yoked to political positions not in fact evidenced by their poems, I argue that these poets, by developing forms of sympathy that negotiate the middle space between the aesthetic conventions of late modernist poetry and the social concerns of postwar American culture, instantiate a self-questioning, often implicit form of “soft politics” that both prefigures and creates the conditions for the more openly political aesthetic of the 1960s. The dissertation is divided into three parts, each of which examines two poets. The first section focuses on Robert Lowell and Elizabeth Bishop, analyzing their work in light of the affect theory first developed by the psychologist Silvan Tomkins to show how their poems invite and deconstruct the sharing of various forms of feeling between reader, speaker, and subject. I then examine the work of John Ashbery and Frank O’Hara, who use sympathy to fashion a radically unfinished model of selfhood that both anticipates and interrogates poststructuralist conceptions of subjectivity. The final section of my dissertation reads the work of the late modernist African American poets Robert Hayden and Melvin Tolson in the context of theorists including Frantz Fanon and Mikhail Bakhtin, demonstrating that their poems embody, by their global and sympathetic perspective, the attempt to forge of ties of sympathy between individuals separated by distance, race, gender, and history. Using an interdisciplinary methodology that combines affect theory with historicist and formalist critique, I provide an original and important reading of mid-century U.S. poetics as defined by a radical ethics rooted in forms of shared feeling. Illuminating the soft politics of late modernist poetry, this thesis complicates the current picture of the postwar arts by arguing that it is attuned not only to the psychology of the solitary or alienated self, but to the ways in which bonds of sympathy between disparate persons can transform conceptual models of individual, community, and nation. ii Key Words Sympathy; poetry; postwar; United States; affect; 1950s; Lowell; Bishop; O’Hara; Ashbery; Hayden; Tolson. iii Acknowledgements I would like to thank the several individuals who contributed, directly and indirectly, to the writing of this dissertation and whose presence made my time at Western a pleasant one: Stephen Adams, my supervisor, for his unfailing encouragement and generous advice; my readers, Tom Carmichael and Josh Schuster, who enthusiastically supported this project from its beginning stages and offered helpful guidance at every step of the way; the Western graduate students and faculty – in particular, Brad Bannon, Zeinab McHeimech, Thy Phu, Rasmus Simonsen, Michael Sloane, Bryce Traister, and Andrew Wenaus – who read and commented on the draft of this thesis in its various iterations, and whose support, intellectual and otherwise, has been greatly beneficial to me in writing this thesis; Steven Bruhm, Mary Helen McMurran, Jan Plug, and Bryce Traister, for vetting grant proposals and helping me in various other academic matters; the wonderful staff of Western’s English Department, Anne McFarland, Vivian Foglton, Beth McIntosh, and Leanne Trask, for their assistance in matters ranging from the mundane to the critical; and all my friends at Western, for their friendship, collegiality, and support. I am grateful to the province of Ontario for providing me with two Ontario Graduate Scholarships during my time at Western – financial assistance that proved greatly beneficial in enabling me to complete my dissertation on time and with a minimum of stress. I wish to thank my family, especially my parents, who fostered my early love of reading and literature and whose everyday demonstration of virtues such as commitment, love, and sacrifice it is my continued goal to emulate. Finally, to my wife, Biz: thank you for your unwavering love and support and for your daily example to me of what friendship and sympathy truly mean. iv Table of Contents Title Page……………………………………………………………………………………i Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………….. ii Key Words…………………………………………………………………………………. iii Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………… iv Introduction Narrating Fellow-Feeling: Postwar American Poetics and the Politics of Identification….. 1 I. Theorizing the “Intimate Community”…………………………………….. 1 II. The Roots of Sympathy……………………………………………………. 6 III. Contemporary Critical Interventions………………………………………. 13 IV. Feeling With Imagination: An Overview………………………………….. 17 V. Sympathy’s Ethical Injunction…………………………………………….. 21 PART ONE SYMPATHY AND AFFECT IN LOWELL AND BISHOP Chapter One The Politics of Affect: Lowell, Bishop, Tomkins………………………………………….. 24 VI. Mass Culture and the “Middle Generation” Poets…………………………. 24 VII. Lowell, Bishop, and the Politics of Poetry………………………………… 28 VIII. Merging Politics and Aesthetics: The Function of Sympathy……………... 32 IX. Sympathy and Affect Theory………………………………………………. 34 X. The Socialization of Affect in Tomkins…………………………………….36 XI. “National Sentimentalism” and the Poetics of Sympathy…………………..40 Chapter Two A Heart Grown Tense: Robert Lowell’s Affective Identifications………………………… 43 I. Lowell, Life, and Art………………………………………………………. 43 II. Life Studies and Sympathy…………………………………………………. 46 v III. “My mind’s not right”: “Skunk Hour”…………………………………….. 48 IV. Isolation and Identification in “Waking in the Blue”……………………… 52 V. Clearing the Surface: “Night Sweat”………………………………………. 57 Chapter Three “Untidy Feelings”: Elizabeth Bishop’s Soft Politics of Sympathy………………………… 61 I. Bishop’s Sympathetic Tone………………………………………………... 61 II. Gendered Affect and Sympathy in “Roosters”…………………………….. 64 III. Identifying with the Other: “Filling Station”………………………………. 70 IV. “At the Fishhouses” and the Limits of Knowledge………………………... 73 V. Loneliness and Shared Affect in “Crusoe in England”…………………….. 77 PART TWO SYMPATHY AND SELFHOOD IN O’HARA AND ASHBERY Chapter Four O’Hara, Ashbery, and the Post-Romantic Self…………………………………………….. 85 I. Avant-Garde Politics and the New York School…………………………... 85 II. Gestures of Invitation……………………………………………………… 92 III. Affect and the Shaping of the Subject……………………………………... 96 IV. Performativity and the Postmodern Poem…………………………………. 100 V. “Pity me . gentle reader”: Rousseau and the Romantic Subject………… 104 VI. Retaining the Romantic Ideal……………………………………………… 109 Chapter Five Meditations in an Emergency: Frank O’Hara and the Self as Process…………………….. 112 I. Emergence and Selfhood…………………………………………………... 112 II. O’Hara and the Reader…………………………………………………….. 116 III. Despondency and Recovery in “Joe’s Jacket”……………………………... 118 IV. Self and Society in “Adieu to Norman, Bon Jour to Joan and Jean-Paul”….123 V. Politics, Selfhood, and the Post-Romantic…………………………………. 130 vi Chapter Six “A Backward Way of Becoming”: John Ashbery’s Mystical Kingdoms………………….. 134 I. Sympathy, Memory, and Subjectivity in Ashbery…………………………. 134 II. Ashbery and the Desire to Communicate…………………………………...138 III. “Together at last, though far apart”: “The Picture of Little J.A. in a Prospect of Flowers” and “The Ecclesiast”…………………………….143 IV. “Borne on Shoulders, at Last”……………………………………………... 151 V. Moving On, Standing Still…………………………………………………. 156 PART THREE SYMPATHY AND TRANSNATIONAL OPTIMISM IN HAYDEN AND TOLSON Chapter Seven Racial Politics Reconsidered: Forms of Recognition in Hayden and Tolson……………… 160 I. The Fisk Conference and the Black Aesthetic……………………………... 160 II. Authorial Ambitions: The Situational Politics of Hayden and Tolson…….. 164 III. Responding to Racial Melancholia………………………………………… 169 IV. Navigating Sympathy’s Preconditions…………………………………….. 171 V. Recognition in Fanon and Hegel……………………………………………174 VI. Language, Idiom, Ethnicity……………………………………....................177 Chapter Eight “You keep going on now or die”: The Will to Freedom in Robert Hayden’s