Low-Power RFED Wake-Up Receiver Design for Low-Cost Wireless Sensor Network Applications
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
sensors Article Low-Power RFED Wake-Up Receiver Design for Low-Cost Wireless Sensor Network Applications David Galante-Sempere , Dailos Ramos-Valido, Sunil Lalchand Khemchandani and Javier del Pino * Institute for Applied Microelectronics (IUMA), University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria (ULPGC), 35017 Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain; [email protected] (D.G.-S.); [email protected] (D.R.-V.); [email protected] (S.L.K.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 28 September 2020; Accepted: 6 November 2020; Published: 10 November 2020 Abstract: The development of wake-up receivers (WuR) has recently received a lot of interest from both academia and industry researchers, primarily because of their major impact on the improvement of the performance of wireless sensor networks (WSNs). In this paper, we present the development of three different radiofrequency envelope detection (RFED) based WuRs operating at the 868 MHz industrial, scientific and medical (ISM) band. These circuits can find application in densely populated WSNs, which are fundamental components of Internet-of-Things (IoT) or Internet-of-Everything (IoE) applications. The aim of this work is to provide circuits with high integrability and a low cost-per-node, so as to facilitate the implementation of sensor nodes in low-cost IoT applications. In order to demonstrate the feasibility of implementing a WuR with commercially available off-chip components, the design of an RFED WuR in a PCB mount is presented. The circuit is validated in a real scenario by testing the WuR in a system with a pattern recognizer (AS3933), an MCU (MSP430G2553 from TI), a transceiver (CC1101 from TI) and a T/R switch (ADG918). The WuR has no active components and features a sensitivity of about 50 dBm, with a total size of 22.5 51.8 mm2. − × To facilitate the integration of the WuR in compact systems and low-cost applications, two designs in a commercial UMC 65 nm CMOS process are also explored. Firstly, an RFED WuR with integrated transformer providing a passive voltage gain of 18 dB is demonstrated. The circuit achieves a sensitivity as low as 62 dBm and a power consumption of only 528 nW, with a total area of 634 391 µm2. − × Secondly, so as to reduce the area of the circuit, a design of a tuned-RF WuR with integrated current-reuse active inductor is presented. In this case, the WuR features a sensitivity of 55 dBm − with a power consumption of 43.5 µW and a total area of 272 464 µm2, obtaining a significant area × reduction at the expense of higher power consumption. The alternatives presented show a very low die footprint with a performance in line with most of the state-of-the-art contributions, making the topologies attractive in scenarios where high integrability and low cost-per-node are necessary. Keywords: wake-up receiver (WUR); radiofrequency envelope detector (RFED); tuned-radiofrequency (tuned-RF); low power; energy efficient; wireless sensor network (WSN); complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS); active inductor; integrated transformer 1. Introduction The development of circuits and systems for wireless communications and their applications have been under extensive research during the last decades. More precisely, the applications of wireless sensor networks (WSN) have received a lot of attention since they are one of the enabling technologies promoting the Internet-of-Things (IoT) or Internet-of-Everything (IoE) [1]. WSNs are composed of battery-powered devices operating with very low-power consumptions so as to ensure a long Sensors 2020, 20, 6406; doi:10.3390/s20226406 www.mdpi.com/journal/sensors Sensors 2020, 20, 6406 2 of 16 Sensors 2020, 20, x FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 16 lifespana long lifespan of the network. of the network. This requirement This requirement is crucial is in crucial many in application many application scenarios scenarios since the since batteries the ofbatteries the sensor of the nodes sensor are replaceablenodes are replaceable at a very significant at a very cost significant because ofcost the because harsh environmental of the harsh conditions.environmental The conditions. conventional The radio conventional interface or radio transceiver interface is frequentlyor transceiver the most is frequently power-consuming the most elementpower-consuming in a WSN node, element dominating in a WSN both thenode, static domi andnating dynamic both power the consumptionstatic and dynamic of the sensor power [2]. Forconsumption this reason, of variousthe sensor strategies [2]. For this have reason, beenexplored various strategies to minimize have the been activity explored of the to conventionalminimize the transceiver,activity of the and conventional can result intransceiver, significant and energy can re savings,sult in significant thus, increasing energy thesavings, sensor’s thus, battery increasing life. Onethe sensor’s well-known battery solution life. One to drasticallywell-known reduce solution power to drastically consumption reduce is to power aggressively consumption duty-cycle is to theaggressively transceiver duty-cycle in order tothe save transceiver power, butin order this may to save leave power, the sensor but this node may unreachable leave the sensor and unable node tounreachable communicate and withunable other to communica nodes forte a with short other time nodes period for [3 a]. short Therefore, time period this decrease [3]. Therefore, in power this consumptiondecrease in power when consumption the sensor node’s when radio the sensor is in sleep-mode node’s radio results is in sleep-mode in a higher latency.results in Generally, a higher twolatency. types Generally, of applications two types can of beapplications distinguished can be in distinguished terms of the in network’s terms of activity:the network’s low-average activity: throughputlow-average applications, throughput where applications, the activity where rate the is low activity and powerrate is consumption low and power and consumption sensitivity are and key metrics;sensitivity and are high-average key metrics; throughput and high-average applications throughput in which applications the network in is verywhich active the network and data is rate very is crucial.active and Considering data rate theis crucial. two scenarios, Considering the delay the tw associatedo scenarios, with the duty-cycled delay associated transceivers with canduty-cycled severely degradetransceivers the performancecan severely ofdegrade the whole theWSN performa in thence context of the of whole high-throughput WSN in the applications context of with high- a highthroughput level of applications activity, and manywith a real-time high level applications of activity, may and not many tolerate real-time such delays. applications may not tolerateThe such implementation delays. of a wake-up receiver (WuR) apart from the main radio interface can ensure a lowThe latency implementation along with of a a very wake-up low power receiver consumption. (WuR) apart from With the this main solution, radio interface the WuR can is alwaysensure listeninga low latency to the along communication with a very channel low power while theconsum mainption. transceiver With this remains solution, in sleep-mode. the WuR Theis always WuR mustlistening be constantlyto the communication listening to channel the communication while the main channel transceiver to be remains able to in detect sleep-mode. wake-up The signals WuR comingmust be fromconstantly other WSNlistening nodes to the in ordercommunication to maintain channel a reasonable to be able latency. to detect A duty-cycled wake-up signals WuR cancoming also from be used other to WSN further nodes reduce in order the power to maintain consumption, a reasonable at the latency. expense A of duty-cycled a higher latency WuR can [4]. Thealso nodesbe used can to be further individually reduce addressed the power with consum the exchangeption, at ofthe wake-up expense signals of a higher or packets, latency employing [4]. The distinctivenodes can be identifiers individually to avoid addressed waking with up otherthe exch sensorange nodes.of wake-up To be signals able to or identify packets, the employing wake-up signaldistinctive unambiguously identifiers andto avoid avoid waking the generation up other of falsesensor wake-ups, nodes. To a WuRbe able usually to identify implements the wake-up a digital basebandsignal unambiguously (DBB) with a patternand avoid recognizer. the generation One of theof false most wake-ups, frequent modulation a WuR usually schemes implements employed a fordigital WuR baseband signals is (DBB) the On with/Off keyinga pattern (OOK) recognizer scheme,. One mainly of duethe most to the freque simplent architecture modulation it schemes requires foremployed demodulation for WuR [5 signals]. Only is after the receptionOn/Off keying of the (OOK wake-up) scheme, signal mainly with the due right to the identifier simple arearchitecture the main microcontrollerit requires for demodulation (MCU) andthe [5].conventional Only after recept radioion interface of the wake-up awakened signal to begin with datathe right exchange identifier via conventionalare the main radiomicrocontroller communications. (MCU) and A common the conven integrationtional radio of a interface WuR ina awakened WSN node to is begin shown data in Figureexchange1. via conventional radio communications. A common integration of a WuR in a WSN node is shown in Figure 1. Figure 1. Figure 1. Block diagram of a sensor node integratingintegrating a wake-up receiver (WuR). The most significant power consumption savings are observed when WuRs are used in low-traffic The most significant power consumption savings are observed when WuRs are used in low- and less-dense WSNs, mainly because the main transceiver is in sleep-mode most of the time [1]. traffic and less-dense WSNs, mainly because the main transceiver is in sleep-mode most of the time When designing a WuR, it is hard to meet high performance requirements due to the simple architecture [1]. When designing a WuR, it is hard to meet high performance requirements due to the simple used.