revised on 2010.10.16
IV. Scene of maturity
Chapter IV IV- 1
8. Soaring into chaos
(1) Ellipse and chaos formation of neo-baroque
The aim of post-modernism was to first raise objection against the monistic system brought about by modern rationalism. This negative dialectic produced many breaks and fractures. The monistic system first became dualistic and then pluralistic. New problems were brought in by this process, and opposing paths led to either expanding this pluralistic set of styles into chaos or reintegrating them into some new method. The logic of style proceeded in this way. This problem prompted the mannerism of the 16th century and was a theme that occurred during the downfall of the ideal of the monistic formal order such as the central-plan or proportions of the renaissance. Michelangelo placed a semi-circular dome on the square plan of the Medici chapel showing the posture to inherit the high renaissance in the early half of the 16th century, and then he drew an elliptical shape in the stone paving in the Piazza del Campidoglio showing the posture to move to mannerism in the middle of the 16th century. This was used as a trick that created a distortion in the field of view by matching the trapezoidal square with the aim of creating the illusionary effect of a perspective drawing method. After this, elliptical shapes became extremely popular, such as in Piazza San Pietro in the Vatican designed by Bernini in the middle of the 17th century, and elliptical shapes became a key symbol of baroque style. Arata Isozaki referred to and turned over this ellipse on the Piazza del Campidoglio in the courtyard of the “Tsukuba Center Building” as if to present a doubled method of mannerism. Although it seemed not to add intention to attach a role concerning the development of style carried by the Piazza del Campidoglio itself, there was a boom in the use of elliptical shapes after this through the 1980s and 1990s, particularly in Japan. This was not a simple fad but can be said to have symbolized the graduation of the awareness of the age from post-modern mannerism migrating toward a baroque-ish stream of thought. The “ Unoki Elementary School” (1988) of Kiko Mozuna formed an elliptical structure surrounding an elliptical courtyard as if reviving mysticism designs of the baroque church and symbolized the universe (Fig. IV-1). Toyo Ito used the ellipse in the “Tower of Wind” in Yokohama, and inserted in the competition entry for “Bibliothèque nationale de France” (1989) in Paris two elliptical shapes as if floating within a lattice-shaped plan with an orderly barcode style (Fig. IV-2). The architects group Coelacanth and associates added an elliptical shape protruding from orthogonal coordinates in “Utase Elementary School” (1995) in Japan. Rem Koolhaas gathered the main conference facilities of “Congrexpo” (1994) into a single large elliptical shape in the project for Euralille. Although Isozaki himself created the overall silhouette of the “Nara City Hall” (1992 competition) using a long, thin elliptical shape and also used ellipses in other works, the manneristic criticism was going to fade away and the feeling of the existence of the elliptical shape itself was emphasized just as in baroque age. The elliptical shapes gradually developed
Chapter IV IV- 2
into solidified objects and became a symbol of the age despite the difficulty of constructing walls. In the “Color of the Crystal” (1987) of Masaharu Takasaki, an egg shape appears in the corner of a space that expands and sways. A variety of concrete shapes gathered around the egg shape then appeared in the “Tamana City Observatory Museum” (1992), and the flow of power began to be visible on the surface (Fig. IV-3). This was not already the critical spirit of mannerism but exhibited the outpouring of the energy of baroque. In the “Naka-no-shima Project “in Osaka (in the 1980s) by Ando Tadao, the insertion of a large egg-shaped hall carved out of the interior of the former city hall of historicism architecture was proposed. Why was this flood of elliptical shapes seen particularly in Japan? Although this is probably connected to the rapid pace of the construction works in Japan, it may also be because the Japanese architectural design world is more sensitive to the stylization of shape compared to other developed countries and had strong inclination to be influenced by that. The worldwide neo-baroque trend can be said to have been superficially understood in Japan where it became a fashion. So, where can we find the extent and main themes of the neo-baroque style of the 20th century? Although elliptical shapes were initially deformed circles, their transformation into even more complex shapes continued, making it easy to wrap diverse shapes using the efficiency of this deformation. This bore the role of an integration of the group of isolated shapes which is inclined to fall into chaos. If seen from the opposite viewpoint, it is said that the architectural shapes each began to have individual power and fall into mutual conflicts forming the tendency to the chaos. Zaha Hadid proposed a new method of trompe l'oeil based on the perspective drawing method that expressed unique distorted spaces (Fig. IV-4). This was a dramatic expression drawn as a flowing space that had an overly exaggerated feeling of depth and twisting space. This neo- expressionist distortion incorporated a flowing energy rather than a clear spatial system. The flow of power began to be created in the expression of manneristic exaggeration and deviance. The jagged style that Daniel Libeskind demonstrated in the “Jewish Museum” in Berlin (1989 competition) is a form designed after understanding fully the meaning that the form has power (Fig. IV-5). The kind of inevitability that this jagged shape has cannot be understood. The reason is that it was the crystallization of the pure formal aspiration as the result of rejecting regular spatial order and further advancing the offsetting of axes. The space created internally enforced a large amount of unexpectedness brought about by offset axes and without any logic or consistency. In the interior of late baroque churches, bent and cut-up entablature can be seen as if vanishing its original shape, and in this case the broken shapes were expanded to the scale of a building. Since the pictorial book of “ Micromegas", Libeskind revived the shape motif of Constructivism of the 1920s, and progressed to more complex structures attempting to draw wriggles as if life is created from a pile of refuse. The results of this study of shape are displayed in the “Jewish Museum,” and the post-moder crushed shapes began to be infused with a new power.
Chapter IV IV- 3
Coop Himmelb(l)au expressed motion like crawling insects by remodeling the rooftops on the historical town streets of Vienna using a complex structural framework and glass (Fig. IV-6). The structural elements have been put together freely, at worst like a garbage collector of skeletal elements. It has a protruding forward edge as if displaying a yearning for the freedom of romanticism. However, it is not merely eccentric and displays a collectivity as if the life force inside it were about to burst out. As can be seen in the case of Libeskind, the group of elements mutually cooperate and begin to hold power greater than a simple collection of matter. On the other hand, in Vienna, which gave birth to the mannerist and picturesque emotions of Hollein, there was the baroque emotion of Günther Domenig. He had created the curving design of the “Zentralsparkasse Bank” (1979) that was like a can that had been torn open, and in the “Steinhaus” in Steindorf (1986), he combined a complex set of seemingly random solid elements to create a structure like a bird’s nest. He also began to destroy shapes that had order with all of his strength and reached the stage of expressing a collision with a flow of power bursting out from the inside. Frank Gehry who had started from partial destruction of existing building shapes also surpassed post-modern criticism and dualism and shifted from focusing on the main shape that was destroyed to focusing on the complex shape of the destroyer. In the “Vitra Design Museum ” (1989), the modern shape that should have been destroyed had already disappeared, and a wriggling accumulation remained as if individual distorted shapes had collided. This created the feeling of the motion of great power like an explosion (Fig. IV-7). The shape has no place to relax and seems to be heading toward chaos. This was a replacement for the valiantly complex set of decorations of the neo-baroque period that appeared at the end of the 19th century, and here the 20th century basic elements were transfigured, turning the structure overall into a decoration of complex shapes. In this way, the neo-mannerism of post-modernism turned into a neo-baroque stage. The chaotic shape itself became its own purpose, and all that stimulate the sensibility which have been set free by post-modernism are further accumulated into the figure of building. The neo-baroque of the late 19th century left behind monuments that were luxurious yet overpoweringly over-decorated like the Opéra de Paris, the Palais de Justice in Brussels, and the Berlin Cathedral. These had the mission of decorating the capital in an age of imperialism and came to symbolize the wealth of the nation. The social background of the 20th century neo- baroque was completely different, and through globalization, the themes of the pride of the nation, etc. became outdated. However, apart from the expression of the trend displayed by the leading design, anyone could guess that the buildings that took this kind of expression of power as their theme were set to reach the stage of buildings that captured the attention of the public. The expression of power seems to be displayed not by production power and societal wealth but by an expression of the power of life as per today’s meaning. The expression of the power of neo-baroque could be established as an extension of an object that resists systemic society such as solids like the foreign body of Rossi or the fire ball of Starck. That, even among elliptical shapes, not just simple elliptical domes but egg-shapes like the objects of Takasaki were used,
Chapter IV IV- 4
suggests that the shapes which symbolize the power of life are sought surpassing the world of geometrical shapes. On the other hand, it is teaching that even a metaphor of a delicate and faint vitality such as a simple swimming ellipse form like a paramecium designed by Ito has a bud which reclaims the new time.
(2) Complexity as logic
The mathematician Mandelbrot proposed a fractal geometry that focused on the relationship of the similarity between parts and the whole called self-similarity and shocked the world with its epoch-making mathematical theory. In the world of architectural design that is not very far removed from Euclidean geometry, this existed as a shape with a completely different principle from conventional architectural shapes. And furthermore because it was able to be simulated by computer graphics, this was welcomed expecting to lead to new design methods. It was felt that the complex shapes of mountain ranges and coast lines created naturally were actually the logical result following some rules, and these could be recreated by the hand of man, and new design possibilities came into view. Architectural design is a synthesis of shapes created from Euclidean geometry and freehand artistic processes such as decorations. The existence of that scientific aspect of reason and this artistic aspect of sensibility became the foundation for the wide development of architecture. Architects could be scientists while being artists and produced a diversity of expressive styles by combining the two. Fractal geometry is therefore thought to have enabled sections that were viewed as freehand decorations to be incorporated into the realm of geometry and handled theoretically. At the very least, fractal shapes, in other words the unintended and irregular shapes as if fragments were collected, were not necessarily unattractive, and the value of architectural formal beauty was reviewed. Eisenman quickly caught onto these conditions and rapidly attempted to incorporate complex shapes and unexpected shapes from computers into architectural design. In the proposal for the “Max Reinhardt House” (1993), the large standing arch-shaped building was designed by using the method called “folding” (Fig. IV-8). This form could be interpreted upon the extension of post-modernism as such that the method of offset axes was repeated and having reached a shape that is a tangle of a multitude of axes. At the same time, it can be seen as such that the self-organization of shape by self-power and logic was able to present an expression of self-power and can be interpreted as a baroque formation as an expression of life force. In a proposed plan for the Rebstockburg apartments in Frankfurt (1992), the individual buildings were defined from the overbearing overall shape, starting with the folded-up ground surface and complex silhouette of wrinkles. The street arrangement created by this has resu lted in an arrangement of buildings covered by irregularly leaning walls as if within a reef on the coast (Fig. IV-9). Even if attractive irregular shapes can be produced, the folding method restricts the freedom of the architect and forces him to follow a constant logic. Therefore, although the shapes have
Chapter IV IV- 5
the same distortion, for example freehand formations such as the organicist structures of Aalto, they differ from the starting point. However, the aspiration to the same organic structures functions and comparison is useful. Eisenman started from Constructivism and continued to experiment with offset axes while attempting to escape from inorganic forms and was gradually led to complex forms that did not highlight any homogeneity. Just same as Aalto had a will to exceed the geometrical tendency of modernism from the romantic mind in the 20th century, Eisenman is graduating from monotonous geometry. Whereas Aalto found his outlet in the free-form which is released by intuition from the organic brains of human beings, Eisenman found his outlet in the complex shape appearing logically as an extension of scientific theory. Eisenman wanted not to be a poet surrounded by the natural environment but a Dadaist poet supported by scientific devices. Architectural historian and critic Charles Jencks attempted to interpret modern architecture as per the motif of scientific vision grouped with recent complex systems of science in “The Architecture of the Jumping Universe (*1)” (1995). He supported the idea that a metaphor of scientific vision was expressed in architectural structure, and the interpretation was open from Eisenman to Gehry and Zaha Hadid to Calatrava and Correa. The architecture historian Sigfried Giedion theorized architecture as a space-time design by applying Einstein’s theory of relativity, demonstrating the belief that there was a shared base between the transitions of modern scientific advancement and architectural style. Certainly, as Jencks said, it is clear that there is a relationship that cannot overestimate the gap between the rapid appearance of complex systems of science and structural theory in architectural design. Hiroshi Hara designed buildings with complex skylines, such as “Yamato International” (1987), and showed examples of a formal system of fractal nature that as the parts were fragments and acted free the total form has not an overall tidy silhouette and become the jagged style (Fig. IV-10). He portrayed buildings as mica with stacks of thin plates and expressed the disordered forms of detached silhouettes as architectural shapes. The glass walls of the internal corridors were covered with small paintings representing the complex shape structure, and this mixed with the fractal nature of the clouds in the sky and trees in the forest that could be viewed through multiple panes of glass to foment a multilayered space lacking homogeneity in depth. Hiroshi Hara applied mathematical theory to architectural design, and in his book “Space
Chapter IV IV- 6
village from the field work of structural analysis on villages described earlier and adopted the construction of delicate and complex spaces as a theme by studying the entanglement of the depth, density variations, and scenery of diverse elements in a village space within nature. Thus it seems that, in spite of his critique on the monotonic logic, he continues the challenge of modern reason to propose an even more sophisticated logic. Operations that had been undertaken by the artistic intuition of the right brain were replaced by the logic of the left brain. Natural spaces which experienced a lot of evolutions and historic spaces which experienced civilizations do not have any homogeneity but have infinite complexity and changes, which Hara grasped with the word “modality”, and aimed to assemble architecture as a device for artificial reproduction of it. Here the subject of design is the interior space or the air covering the buildings itself, but the things that an architect can work are only the walls and roofs that frame the space, and therefore some intelligent contrivances were incorporated. The forms of the late-baroque churches consisting of curving and intersecting ceilings, and variously assorted intertwined groups of decorations creates diffuse reflections, shadows by the transparent sunlight penetrating through the windows. Furthermore, the delicate structure and complex decorations of late gothic churches had an interior space with differences in density due to light penetrating into a dark space through stained glass. These contrasted with the homogeneous space created by the clear shapes of the renaissance formed from orderly proportions and member structures. The complexity of mixing a variety of structures was a means for presenting the depth of the space. When spaces with floating objects and particles like mist that cannot be grasped by hands became the subject of design, architects are forced to embark upon an endless process of creation impossible to reach the goal of making shapes. This was originally a comprehensive art that included the works of many artists, engravers, musicians, etc., as in the case of gothic cathedrals. There was also the idea that architects should not intervene to that extent. However, as in the late-baroque small churches of southern Germany, it was acceptable for the architects themselves to undertake all of the presentation and creation as if carried out by a person who was simultaneously an architect, engraver, and artist. The theme of the age of chaos becomes the integration of pluralistic values. The science of complex systems has taught that complexity can be presented using simple devices, and this indicates that the presentation of chaos by a single architect is not impossible. In the mathematics of chaos, even phenomena that are considered to be complex at first glance can be understood as a repetitive phenomenon that occurs by taking something called an attractor as the axis and introducing a constant fluctuation in its vicinity. Thus, it was confirmed that a phenomenon that had disorder could be reproduced by simple equations alone. The contrivance of this kind of device is an issue for the architects of the time when complexity is the theme. The thing Eisenman had attempted to produce through the simple logic of folding was not only the complexity of the architectural form itself but the complexity of the space and scenery produced by it. At the beginning of the 20th century, to be scientific and theoretical meant to simplify the
Chapter IV IV- 7
spatial form and therefore to reconstruct architecture as an effective residential machine using simple logic was attempted. Now, the idea has reversed and complexity has become the goal, and we are beginning to walk on the path toward the other extreme, the impossible complexity. This is the so-called Karma that man has borne since starting to resist God as homo faber (man the creator) and is the infinite path of continuous creation as long as man’s desire last. In the same way as baroque had continued to seek that ultimate expression up to the end of the late-baroque, now architects who are aware of complexity in design can do nothing but to adopt as their theme unending supreme complexity.
(*1) Charles Jencks: "The Architecture of the jumping universe", London/ New York, 1995. (*2) Hiroshi Hara, “Space 〈From Function to Modality〉”, (Japanese) Iwanami-Shoten, 1987.
Chapter IV IV- 8
9. New paradigms in embryo
(1) Ecological naturalism
When it has become understood that man-made objects posed a menace to the nature, changes even the atmosphere and could turn the earth into a place uninhabitable by life, the contemporary arguments on ecology were taken on with a sense of urgency. Freon gas is destroying the ozone layer and allowing ultraviolet rays to reach the ground. The imbalanced emissions of carbon dioxide gas leads to global warming, the polar ice caps melt, the cities along the coast are flooded due to the rising sea levels and the climatic become disordered. To face this huge crisis, man could mealy review modern civilization and change his lifestyle. In this regard, it seemed like there were nothing that architectural design could do. In every age throughout history, people have come to reflect the problems of their time in architectural style. Even the choice of temples, cathedrals, or palaces has become a means of symbolically resolving the dominant themes and problems of each age. Even in modern ages, the ideas of modern rationalism could be said to have led to the current architectural styles. The architectural styles produced by modernism were examples of such 20th century. The fact that new architectural styles will again be created in this way in the 21st century cannot be denied, and it is strongly predicted that it will be closely related to the theme of ecology. What ecology aims for includes a thrifty lifestyle with a reduction in the consumption of resources as much as possible, and also a change from a civilization that completely dominates animals and plants to one that coexists with them. At the end of the 19th century, while society progressed toward the wastefulness of the neo-baroque period after the industrial revolution, there also appeared a trend toward naturalism and socialism that resisted this. The psychological structures of today’s society can also be said to resemble this age in some respects. Although there is no argument that ecology is a contemporary naturalism, it needs moreover to be confirmed that this bears the same motives as the naïve socialism before the Russian Revolution. Therefore, we should focus on William Morris who wrote “News from Nowhere” (1890, 1893) and is known as an artist of the arts and crafts movement. “News from Nowhere” is a novel about a place where people with a high level of crafts live happily on a fictional island far removed from civil society. His ideal was that the traditional crafts should be maintained and developed, and therefore he criticized the bland mass-produced goods manufactured by the mechanical production of those days. This was summarized in the categories of utopian socialism and artistic socialism, and he was viewed as a dreamer, while there was the radical socialism of Marx that concluded that social revolution is needed to transform the economic system. Morris, who thought that traditional values were important, formed the “Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings” to start an active movement to preserve historical buildings, in that was included not a simple nostalgia but a vision for a future society with craft as the intermediary. The thesis of the art historian Nikolaus Pevsner regarding the mechanisms of the occurrence
Chapter IV IV- 9
of modern design is widely known, that the movement which rejected mechanized civilization and promoted hand work was eventually adopted by the Bauhaus school opened in Weimar with Gropius as the director in 1919 and was transformed to the applied art in 20th century of mechanical production based on hand work. By taking that in thought, envisioning a Morris of the age of ecology, we can conceive of the direction of modern craft and architecture. Morris was the image leader of the arts and crafts movement. Among the artists who gathered around him was an architect Philip Webb, who designed the Morris’ residence“Red House” whose interior design Morris himself had worked on. His standpoint is remarkable and helpful to think about today’s world of architecture. Webb mainly designed houses, and these were modest, relatively inconspicuous structures. While they were based on a traditional rural residence style, they utilized modern geometry, as can be seen even in the circular windows of “Red House.” That is acknowledged also in a geometrical design of connected small triangular gables in other houses. Thus, a return to tradition and budding modernism existed simultaneously. Thus, the key themes were the rejection of the aspiration for an abundance brought by the industrial society and the rehabilitation of the handwork of man. The idea of today’s ecology that is recognizing the limits of a consumerist society is thought to apparently highlight things corresponding to hand work. This does not refer to the simple revival of some traditional work of craftsmen but indicates that the human body action of present days has the direct contribution to the design in the meaning that the Bauhaus started from handwork and shifted to the industrial design. Tadao Ando limits his design vocabulary to the flat walls made of exposed concrete, exposes the structural substance against the human body, and constructs it with natural elements directly provided by nature in the form of light, wind, and water , removing artificial designs from spaces (Fig. IV-11). In such method can be seen the composition which could expanded to the idea of contemporary ecology. The second half of the 20th century could be said to have created a mainstream trend to change architectural shapes into something complex as is known in the move toward post-modern diversity and complexity. Thus, the style of Ando resists the flow of time as if pulled out and left behind by 20th century technology and the industrial civilization. However, the antithesis of this is the formation of the kind of architects who design low-cost public housing and gradually developed a different flow from the mainstream industrial and consumerist society. Although this aspiration for simplicity was also highlighted in the geometric designs of Louis Kahn, for Kahn design started from a kind of heroism like a temple and there was the theme of the projection of divine shapes that were in the ideal of neo-Platonism of the Renaissance. On the other hand, for Ando design started with tenements that were a place of people’s living and widened the small space touching the flesh as if expanding the model, and that differed from the things of divine structures at the beginning at all. While, as is previously noted, the style of Kahn included the logic of spatial structure theory of those days, he took besides a direction that transcended from the flow of the age toward complexity and settled on simplicity to the point of clumsiness. This became deeply popular with people who criticized the industrial civilization and
Chapter IV IV- 10
consumerist society of the 20th century, and it was also hailed by leading post-modernists. Ando studied the space designs of the purism of Le Corbusier and absorbed the simplicity of Kahn and incorporated these into a unique ascetic and frugal psyche comparable to the Order of Cistercians. In order to understand the state of current designs, one must delve further in the comparison between the arts and crafts movement and Ando. Just as there is a mutually complementary relationship between the fashion designers of clothing accessories and the bare concrete architecture of Ando, it is possible to envision a similar dichotomy between Webb and Morris. If we consider Issey Miyake’s designs of pleats that aim at clothe design for the ordinary people, the shadow of the arts and crafts movement can be seen in current fashion. One type of design that rejects complexity and abundance is the architectural style called Minimalism. The architecture of Herzog & de Meuron cut back on so many elements that one might think the structure wasn’t complete. After everything that could be removed was removed and the shape was simplified as much as possible, only box-shaped buildings remained like a thin wrapping (Fig. IV-12). The structural game of post-modernism of aiming for complexity was seemingly completely unrelated to them. While in post-war Germany, after reflecting on too excessive cultural policies of the Nazis, architecture came to be viewed as a technical work giving distance to an extreme from artistic contemplation, the effects of this rational aesthetic probably also extended to the Switzerland. In a series of works of the Minimalist architects, the barely remaining skin of the building was not merely a facade but was transformed into a device that incorporated high technology. Differed from Ando’s plain concrete walls as if expanded from crafts work model, the remaining wall becomes a minimal mechanical device that represented the final stage of the machine model age of the 20th century. Compared with the fact that the same Swiss architect Hannes Meyer’s had sought an architectural image like the manufacturing mechanism of factories, in this case the mechanical thing had changed into a small device that combined information machines. The cube of Purism that was the origin for Le Corbusier, who also originated from Switzerland, was recreated as Minimalism, using completely different materials. It was as if the ages had transpired in a loop. By the way, contemporary naturalism has rediscovered the globe. From the ideas of geometrical typology, platonic solids that are simple geometrical shapes were preferred and the architecture of spherical form by Boullee and Ledoux during the French Revolution came to be reevaluated. This could be seen in spheres such as the mirrored ball in the Parc de la Villet in Paris as well as the “Shonandai Cultural Center” (1989) in Japan by Itsuko Hasegawa, which also symbolizes the globe (Fig. IV-13). The globe was not only used as a visible symbol, but also people began to be aware of the earth as being embedded in the globe. Emilio Ambasz proposed architectural spaces buried in the green ground from an early time, and against the background of the changing global awareness that led to a review of the world’s environment, he brought to life buildings such as the “ Fukuoka Acros” (1995) (Fig. IV-14). Peter Cook who had viewed cities as mechanical devices as
Chapter IV IV- 11
a member of Archigram became noticeably romanticist since the “Urban Mark” project of the 1970s, where he has covered mechanical devices with green and transformed them to an organic landform like a hilly district. This displayed an awe of the natural power of the globe that far exceeded the wisdom and knowledge of humans. This growing interest in the planet Earth caused the appearance of new types of landscape designers, like Peter Walker who sought new methods for designing ground surfaces. He fused the tradition of the geometrical gardens of continental Europe with the American method of urban park design that incorporated the wild nature and perfected a design style to display like a garden and also like an urban plaza (Fig. IV-15). Even genres that emerged in the post- modern age of the “Park” of the Parc de la Villet that merged eclecticism and picturesque exploited a theme that can also be called the architectural version of land art through geometrical segmentation of the ground and buildings that grew from within the earth. The awe of the Earth that was the subject of art while preserving the ground surface was fostered here, and the age of the global environment was crystallized into one style of architectural and urban design.
(2) Technological architecture and information space
A criticism of the mechanical civilization of the 20th century germinates the idea of ecology on the one hand and searches for a leap toward a relatively advanced technological civilization on the other. The latter is brought about by information technology, and this leads to a deep paradigm shift that did not merely stop at the production and utilization of simple computer devices. Compared to the machines of the 20th century that were nothing more than moving devices that replaced the human body such as the railways and machine guns exalted by futurists, information devices later began to replace the human mind and robots became a reality. Although the clumsiness of buildings of modernism architecture and functionalist architecture was criticized during the post-modernist period, one aspect of that unfulfilled expectation appeared solvable with the appearance of relatively superior architectural technology and planning methods. The architectural image that modeled machines progressed step by step in this way. The progress of technology was not complex like the advancement of culture that followed fluctuation phenomena, and overall this was also not affected by the games of the spectacular formal styles of post-modernism. Renzo Piano and Richard Rodgers accepted the assistance of the structural engineer office of Ove Arup and Partners in the “Pompidou Centre” (Beaubourg) and inherited the ideas of device-like structures of Archigram. Although the idea of surrounding a pillar-less main space with devices as a secondary space was that from the age of spatial structural theory, this experiences the technical development as a more effective mechanical device (Fig. IV-16). In the “ Lloyds of London ” (1986) by Rodgers himself, many see-through elevators surrounded an office space, presenting an architectural image that got more closer to a
Chapter IV IV- 12
mechanical device. The ducts were incorporated with the proportional design of the walls, and the roof was equipped with a colorful gondola crane for cleaning the wall surfaces (Fig. IV-17). Norman Foster also presented a new style of a high-rise office building where a mega-structure is sandwiched with elevator shafts in the same way in “Hon Kong Shanghai Bank” (Hong Kong, 1986) (Fig. IV-18). Those called as “high-tech style” architects who took an independent route from the post- modernistic trend toward sensibility, gave effort on its extension combining information devices into the building to meet the technical progress. They combined also to that an interest in ecology, and merged the seemingly contradictory directions of information technology and ecology, i.e. future technology and criticism against modernism. Although they continued to use reason as more of a foundation than sensibility and steadily inherited modern rationalism, they were already far removed from the heavy industrial mechanical models of the Italian Futurists and Russian Constructivists. They made even high-rise buildings more light-weight changing from iron to aluminum and gave flexibility allowing wind to blow past large glass surfaces and thin columns. Piano presented an architectural image like a thin long vessel turn over on water surface and designed cross-sectional shapes that followed the flow of internal waving winds in the “Kansai International Airport” (Osaka, 1994) (Fig. IV-19). Trees were even planted beneath glass in the void space excluding demonstration of the rustic structural beauty in buildings. The old heroic architectural image was hidden in the shadows and the silhouette was not determined purely by structural dynamics. At other occasions also, the interests of their technology-oriented architects demonstrated the clear move toward an ecological age, creating a natural flow in the interior room, actively introducing energy-saving technology, etc. Computers are useful for environmental control and can operate air conditioning devices that create an optimal environment based on changes in sensor temperatures. Jean Nouvel proposed a glass wall that employed the aperture technology of cameras in order to adjust the amount of heat in the incident sunlight in the “Institut du Monde Arabe ” (Paris, 1987) (Fig. IV-20). This was a monumental work in terms of the transformation of the walls into an elaborate mechanical device controlled by information equipment, which are no more merely thick stone, brick chunks or clear glass. Architecture was increasingly becoming something other than just buildings. In recent times, the common definition of architecture has progressively changed. The architectural image changed in the 19th century to light structures based on the structural theory of steel skeletons, to moving mechanical devices in the 20th century and has now begun to be transformed to robots. The ideal of Greek temples where columns stand neatly in line and supported heroically is already becoming a thing of the distant past. Furthermore, information technology is changing the common perception of the architectural image inside the computer display. The appearance of two-dimensional computer graphics (CG) has enabled computer-aided design (CAD), the drawing board continues to be expelled from design offices, and the further
Chapter IV IV- 13
appearance of 3D CG (three-dimensional computer graphics) is bringing about an age of formal design in the depth of display. Architectural shapes created in virtual space have no relation to the gravity any longer, colors are so clear without knowing the shadowing, and assemblages of platonic solids called primitives are placed as if dancing in space. A real feeling of distance has been lost and the economic concept of space has also faded with the architectural figure beginning to slide in an unexpected direction. This kind of idea was displayed in a series of architectural works by Rem Koolhaas. This was based on the Constructivism of the De Stijl style that could be called the Netherlands’ tradition, and put into three dimension, with walls and object elements combined as if suspended in air and framing space (Fig. IV-21). In his competition entry for the “Bibliothèque nationale de France” in Paris (1989), there was a large void that resembles a cube, and several masses of curved objects were suspended in it. Cubes have become nothing more than transparent boxes any longer, and the shapes have lost the feeling gravity and no longer supported stably by the ground or floors. The similar idea of a group of objects in three-dimensional CG space was even displayed in the “Kunibiki Messe(Shimane Prefectural Convention Center)” (1993) in Matsue city by Shin Takamatsu. The method making buildings’ frames flat, purifying the surface using metal, and making transparent with glass on the one hand, and scattering small rooms and devices in the interior space as if separated from building on the other, was employed by many architects of the new generation. A building can be said to have become a production of shared and institutionalized method rather than a profound art that creates personal masterpieces. Buildings are made into membranes on the one hand and turned into interior design on the other. The theme of “membrane” of architecture is reminiscent of the theorization in “Der Stil” written by Gottfried Semper in the 1870s. This sublimated into something that should be called texture mapping architecture, like attaching floral wallpaper to a building facade as in the “ Majolika Haus ” by Otto Wagner at the end of the 19th century. The phenomenon of transformation to membranes is also recognized to occupy a fixed position within the cyclical changes of architecture. In the late 20th century, display devices corresponded to buildings transformed to membranes and images represented in three dimensions are interior design. If we envision this model of the display device being expanded to the scale of a building, the effect of three-dimensional CG on architectural design can be understood. The space within the display has come to replace the work of creating an image processed within the mind of the architect. A computer works instead of the brain and is considered literally as electrical brain. The things imagined by the mind are immediately made concrete within its display and come together as a transformed shape. This has led to the need for a third medium occupying the space between the mind and actual space, such as the new concept of virtual reality. The method of perspective drawing led to a paradigm shift in architectural shapes during the early renaissance. This method came to be ignored during the drawing method revolution of Cubism and mechanical axonometric drawing method in the early 20th century, and furthermore
Chapter IV IV- 14
it was revived as the digital perspective in the form of three-dimensional CG. Three-dimensional CG in wide meaning utilizes also the ideas of cubism and can be said to have been integrated by combining this with the ideas of the perspective drawing method. It is hard to say that this new perspective drawing technology does not lead to a strong paradigm shift as influential as the renaissance. It is also difficult to predict how far this will develop the unknown architectural image. One possible direction is the special ability of CG to draw mysterious curved solids using spline curves besides platonic solids. The free curving membrane design that follows the flow of the wind as realized by Piano in the Kansai International Airport was similar to this. It is indeed enough when plenty of parts with the same dimensions were produced if the roof is made as a neat, plain surface. But for a gently curving surface, multiple parts with various dimensions are need to be produced, because there is no difference that it is assembled with many steel members. However, factories that have been robotized by mechatronics can implement such intricate requirements. Here the mind sticking to common sense on design and producing cannot follow the rapid development of the age. The “Sendai Mediatheque” (1994) by Toyo Ito destroyed the conventional knowledge of columns (Fig. IV-22). It only had a scattering of pouch-shaped nets freely expanding and contracting, without a neat row of columns or pillars. Columns escaped from their typical form in the 20th century as symbolized by the pilotis of Le Corbusier and dissolved to become tubes which can be drawn from spline curves. In the age of Art Nouveau, Guimard turned columns into objects with elegantly curved surfaces appearing as if melted in a solvent. Art Nouveau completely destroyed the common sense of the 19th century at this point. Also, the common sense of the 20th century that started with Cubism seems to be collapsed, while leaving the same mark of these melted columns. Spline curves, by nature, are drawn joining gradually multiple points. Therefore, unlike the minimal amount of information determined only by the radius of a circle and the length of a column such as the columns of Purism, many three-dimensional coordinates need to be provided in case of spline curves, and the amount of information required is large as a result. This should be called as complex shape, and that can be considered the antecedent of the aspiration for complexity that was prominent at the end of the 20th century. On the other hand, the silhouettes of Ito’s architecture displayed a simplicity common with the Minimalism of glass cubes. The aspiration for simplicity and that for complexity are dissected within a single building’s shape, and the age of the 20th century is summarized. In any case, during the early 21st century, it is expected to be a confrontation between complex shapes and simple shapes just as Behrens showed once upon a time with two streams of Art Nouveau and neoclassicism.
Chapter IV IV- 15
Figures of Chapter IV
Fig.IV-1 Kiko Mozuna, Fig.IV-2 Toyo Ito, the Fig.IV-3 Masaharu Fig.IV-4 Zaha Hadid, the Fig.IV-5 Daniel “Unoki Elementary competition entry for Takasaki, “Tamana City competition winning Libeskind, “Jewish School”, Akita Pref., 1988. “French National Library Observatory”, Kumamoto proposal for “The Peak”, Museum”, Berlin, 1989. in Paris”, 1989. Pref., 1992. Hong Kong, 1983.
Fig.IV-6 Coop Fig.IV-7 Frank Gehry, Fig.IV-8 Peter Eisenman, Fig.IV-9 Peter Eisenman, Fig.IV-10 Hiroshi Hara, Himmelblau ， ”Office “Vitra Design Museum”, a proposal for the “Max a proposal plan for the “Yamato International”, Extension in Vienna”, Weil am Rhein, 1989. Reinhardt House”, 199. “Rebstockburg Tokyo, 1987. Falkestrasse, 1989. Apartments” in Frankfurt, 1992.
Fig.IV-11 Tadao Ando, Fig.IV-12 Herzog & de Fig.IV-13 Itsuko Fig.IV-14 Emilio Ambasz Fig.IV-15 Peter Walker, “Church on the Water”, Meuron, “Signal Box”, Hasegawa ， ”Shonandai (early design), “Fukuoka The square design in Hokkaido, 1988. Basel, 1995. Cultural Center”, Acros” (1995)，Fukuoka, front of “Marugame Fujisawa, 1989. 1995. Station”, Kagawa Pref., 1991.
Fig.IV-16 Renzo Piano & Fig.IV-17 Richard Fig.IV-18 Norman Foster, Fig.IV-19 Renzo Piano, Fig.IV-20 Jean Nouvel, Richard Rogers, Rogers, “Lloyds of “Hong Kong and “Kansai New Airport”, “Institut du Monde Arabe “Pompidou Centre London”, 1986 年. Shanghai Bank”, Hong Osaka, 1994. “, Paris, 1987. (Beaubourg)” ， Paris, Kong, 1986. 1977.
Fig.IV-21 Rem Koolhaas, Fig.IV-22 Toyo Ito, the “Kunsthal”, Rotterdam, competition winning 1992. proposal for “Sendai Mediatheque”, Sendai, 1994.
Chapter IV IV- 16