Synthesis and Antifungal Properties of Compounds Which Target the Α-Aminoadipate Pathway ORIGINAL ARTICLES
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ORIGINAL ARTICLES Department of Chemistry 1 and Department of Biology2, University of Saskatchewan, Canada Synthesis and antifungal properties of compounds which target the a-aminoadipate pathway D. R. J. Palmer,1 H. Balogh,1 G. Ma,1 X. Zhou,1 M. Marko,1 S. G. W. Kaminskyj 2 Received June 20, 2003, accepted July 22, 2003 Susan G. W. Kaminskyj, Department of Biology, University of Saskatchewan, 112 Science Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan Canada S7N 5E2. [email protected] Pharmazie 59: 93–98 (2004) Fungi synthesize lysine via the a-aminoadipate pathway, which is not found in plants or animals. This pathway has been proposed as a target for antifungal agents, but until now no reports have appeared to test this proposal. Hampering studies on the susceptibility of filamentous fungi such as those of the clinically important genus Aspergillus is the fact that growth quantitation is notoriously difficult. We have used the recently-reported XTT-based method of biomass quantitation to measure the suscept- ibility of Aspergillus nidulans strain A28 to growth suppression by novel compounds designed to target early steps in the a-aminoadipate lysine biosynthesis pathway, specifically those steps involving (R)- homocitrate and (2R,3S)-homoisocitrate. Three compounds show moderate inhibition of fungal growth, which can be partially restored by the presence of lysine in the growth medium. 1. Introduction All higher fungi synthesize lysine via the a-aminoadipate pathway (Zabriskie and Jackson 2000), which is not found Invasive fungal infections are a severe threat to human in plants or animals. This pathway could therefore serve health: untreated, mortality rates from systemic fungal infections typically exceed 98%. Fungal spores are ubi- as a target for antifungal compounds since its disruption quitous; for example, there are 1–100 pathogenic Asper- should not affect the metabolism of host organisms gillus fumigatus spores per m3, worldwide (Latge´ 2001). (Suvarna et al. 1998). However, no studies have appeared Our main defense against systemic fungal infections is a reporting the use of this target for the design of anti- healthy immune response; thus it is not surprising that fungal compounds. We now report the synthesis of a series these are the primary AIDS-defining infections in HIV-po- of compounds that target enzymes from the a-amino- sitive people (Walsh and Groll 1999), and that they are adipate pathway, and an investigation of their antifungal the scourge of other immunocompromised individuals behavior. including transplant patients and those with autoimmune The early steps of the a-aminoadipate pathway are shown disease. in Scheme 1. While all the metabolites are known, not all The treatment for systemic fungal infections can be toxic of the enzymes responsible for these transformations have in its own right (Ugur et al. 2002), because most of these been identified (Zabriskie and Jackson 2000). Specifically, drugs target ergosterol or its biosynthesis, and so also af- the conversion of (R)-homocitrate to cis-homoaconitate fect cholesterol, which is an essential component of mam- has not been assigned to a gene product. It may be that malian membranes. These treatments are expensive, aver- (R)-homocitrate is converted to (2R,3S)-homoisocitrate by aging in excess of US$30,000 per patient per incident a single enzyme, in simile with the reaction catalyzed by (Wilson et al. 2002). Despite intensive treatment with cur- aconitase shown in Scheme 2. Indeed, homoaconitate rently-available antifungal agents, permanent cures are un- hydratase, or homoaconitase, is clearly related to aconitase common, such that survival/cure rates after systemic fun- in sequence, and most likely in structure (Irvin and gal infection are often expressed only for the following Bhattacharjee 1998). However, neither the homoaconitate six-month period, and many patients remain on long-term hydratase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (LYS4) nor prophylactic antifungal therapy. In addition, fungi are also Aspergillus nidulans (LysF) has been reported to catalyze severe agricultural pests, causing damage to all crops (e. g. the dehydration of (R)-homocitrate (Gamonet and Laquin Barnes 1979, Howlett et al. 2001) and stored agricultural 1998, Weidner et al. 1997). This somewhat counter- products. These facts, coupled with increasing incidence intuitive phenomenon is a subject of interest in our labora- of antibiotic (Alexander and Perfect 1997) and antifungal tory. (Loeffler and Stevens 2003; Vanden Bossche et al. 2003) Regardless of the identity of the catalyst that dehydrates resistance indicate that new antimicrobial strategies should (R)-homocitrate, a rational approach to the inhibition of steps be pursued constantly. of the pathway involving (R)-homocitrate and (2R,3S)- Pharmazie 59 (2004) 2 93 ORIGINAL ARTICLES Scheme 1 O CO - CO - - 2 - 2 + NADH CO2 CO2 NAD SCoA H H H OH +CO2 O -CoASH -H O CO - + - 2 2 +H2O CO2 -O2C OH -O2C H H H O H H H H H H i ii iii iv H H H H H H H H H H CO - CO - CO - - - 2 2 2 CO2 CO2 The first steps of the a-aminoadipate pathway: i.) homocitrate synthase; ii.) unidentified enzyme; iii.) homoaconitate hydratase (or homoaconitase); iv.) homoisocitrate dehydrogenase Scheme 2 CO - CO - 2 CO - 2 -H O+H2 O H H 2 - 2 H OH CO2 -O2C OH -O2C H H H H H H H - - - CO2 CO2 CO2 The reaction sequence catalyzed by aconitase homoisocitrate can be taken. Specifically, compounds de- been developed by Meletiadis et al. (2001) that they report signed to mimic the structure of the metabolites of interest correlates well with visible mycelial growth in several could inhibit homoaconitase and/or homoisocitrate dehydro- Aspergillus species. genase, resulting in an impairment in lysine biosynthesis. A variety of carboxyalkyl- and carboxyaryl-substituted d- One of the considerations in the design is that the com- malic acids and their corresponding methyl esters were de- pounds not be effective aconitase inhibitors: such com- signed as analogues of (R)-homocitrate and (2R,3S)-homoi- pounds are extremely toxic (Peters and Shorthouse 1971, socitrate. Syntheses of these compounds rely on a diastereo- Lauble et al. 1996). Therefore the difference between sub- selective alkylation to give an optically active product. strates for aconitase and homoaconitase, namely the pre- These compounds were tested for their ability to impair the sence of a propionate rather than an acetate moiety, growth of Aspergillus nidulans A28 in minimal media (i.e. should be retained or even exaggerated in any putative in the absence of exogenous lysine) and in rich media sup- antifungal. plemented with excess lysine. Of these, only methyl esters Fungal species employ two major growth morphologies: 1b–3b showed inhibitory effects on fungal growth. they form colonies of single cells called yeasts, or pro- duce multicellular filamentous mycelia. Some human fun- 2. Investigations and results gal pathogens, such as Candida albicans, are dimorphic, 2.1. Chemistry invading as filamentous hyphae but proliferating as yeasts (Gale et al. 1998), whereas others like the molds, Asper- As described previously, we have applied the Self-Regen- gillus, are exclusively filamentous (Latge´ 2001). Fungi erating Stereocentre (SRS) approach (Seebach et al. 1996) like Aspergillus grow by tip growth and form basal cell- to the synthesis of (R)-homocitrate (Ma and Palmer 2000). like compartments by crosswall insertion (Hamer et al. This approach uses the steric hindrance of the tert-butyl 1999) creating multicellular colonies. Basal cells in these group of 4 to control the face of alkylation of the planar colonies are quiescent for growth but metabolically active, enolate intermediate. In this approach, the electrophile and reinitiate growth for normal branching or in response added was eventually modified to form the propionate to mechanical damage to the mycelium. This leads to a moiety of homocitrate, thus substitution of other electro- considerable difficulty in accurately estimating viability philes was an obvious extension of the technique, as illu- after anti-fungal treatments because tip growth assays do strated in Scheme 3. Because an equally large or larger not accurately reflect the number of potentially viable moiety was desired in this position, substituted methyl cells. A colorimetric assay to quantify fungal growth has ortho-, meta-, and para-(bromomethyl)benzoates were chosen as electrophiles. The presence of the electron-with- drawing methyl carboxylate substituent would be pre- CO2R CO2R CO2R dicted to result in a less reactive electrophile relative to H H H OH H OH benzyl bromide, and this was observed in our work. The RO2C OH RO2C H RO2C H para-substituted compound gave the desired product 5 in H H H H H H moderate yield (36%), about half that obtained when ben- zyl bromide was used (Seebach et al. 1984). The ortho- substituted compound gave the desired product in very CO2R low yield (ca. 1%), and reaction with the meta-substituted CO2R CO2R compound resulted in no product in our hands. As re- 1a:R=H 2a:R=H 3a:R=H ported by Seebach et al. (1984), high stereoselectivity was 1b:R=Me 2b:R=Me 3b:R=Me obtained; the presence of the undesired diastereomer could 94 Pharmazie 59 (2004) 2 ORIGINAL ARTICLES Scheme 3 OR O O O O O O H C OH i, ii H2C iii 2 O CO H CO2R H 36% 2 95% CO2H RO C MeO2C 2 45 1a:R=H iv 1b:R=Me i.) LiHMDS/THF, methyl para-(bromomethyl)benzoate, À78 C, 3 hr. ii.) 1 N HCl. iii) 50% aqueous TFA, rt, 6 hr. iv.) CH2N2 /DMF, 10 min Scheme 4 CO2Me CO2Me CO2H H OH i, ii H OH iii H OH CO Me CO H H H 35% H CH2 2 92% H CH2 2 CO2Me CO2Me CO2H 2b 2a i.) LDA/THF, methyl para-(bromomethyl)benzoate, À78 C, overnight.