<<

Montanino, Linda

From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Wednesday, Dece mber 03, 2014 4:40 PM To: Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael Subject: RE : Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430 Attachments: 20141203_163811Jpg

They are here 25 so far laying down

Sent from my Ve ri zon Wireless 4G lTE smartphor.e

------Original message------From: "Ryan, Sean" Date:12/03/2014 4:07 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Metz, Michael" Cc : "Neafsey, Daniel" Subject: Re: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I should be there around 1745 latest fyi .

Sent from my iPad

On Dec 3, 2014, at 4:04PM, Metz, Michael wrote:

Thanks Dan, lunch on me when I see ya.

Sen\ from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE

------Original message ------From: "Neafsey, Daniel" Date:12/03/2014 16:03 (GMT-05 :00) To: "Metz, Michael" ,"Ryan, Sean" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

No problem, I am here. As of right the Ch ief an d Inspector do not need anything from us right now.

Dan

fforn my Vcri2on VJi.-eless 4G l TE smnrtnhone

------Original message ------From: "Metz, Michael" Date:12/03/2014 3:59PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Ryan, Sean" , " Neafsey, Dan iel " Subject: Fwd : Twitter said a protes t is sch edu led in GCT at 430

Danny, are you able to hang out this evening? I think Joe is getting NYPD Intel since Tom P called him back.

We could use the eyes and ears.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless '1G LTE smartphone

------Original message------From: "Giulietti, Joseph" Date:12/03/2014 15:50 (GMT-05:00) To: "Fleischer, Randall" ,"Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz, Michael" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Evans, Donna" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I left holiday train and am on 340 out of Southeast. Should be there around 5 please keep me advised

Sent via the .Sc..unsung GALAXY S'· S, an AT&T ·1G I. re !lrnartphone

------Original message------From: "Fleischer, Randall" Date:12/03/2014 3:22 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz,Michael" , "Rehbein, Kim" , "Giulietti, Joseph" , "Evans, Donna" Subject: Re: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

We are aware. Am enroute to GCT. Thx

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 3, 2014, at 3:20PM, "Mannix, Mark" wrote:

FYI

Sent from my iP ad

Begin forwarded message:

From: "McCauley, Terrence" Date: De cem ber 3, 2014 3:17:56 PM EST To: "Mannix, Mark" , " Huie, Nancy" , "Mateo, George" Subject: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

2 Terrence P. McCauley Manager, Government and Community Relations MTA Metro-North Railroad 345 , 2nd Floor New York, NY 10017 http://www.mta.i nfo Telephone: 212-340-3056

3

. ·.: ·r

·- - ·-···· Montanino, Linda

From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2014 4:43 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph Cc: Kesich, John; Doering, Susan J.; Mannix, Mark; Evans, Donna; Ryan, Sean; Betries-Kendall, Katherine (MNR) Subject: Protest begins: Die In at GCT

Just started. Peaceful so far.

Randall .T . Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153 Montanino, Linda

From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2014 4:53 PM To: Metz, Michael; Ryan, Sean Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430 Attachments: 20141203_1638lljpg

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G l TE smartphone

------Original message ------From: "Metz, Michael" Date:12/03/2014 4:43 PM (GMT-05:00) To : "Neafsey, Daniel", "Ryan, Sean" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Thanks, send more pies over time

Sent from myVerizon Wireless 46 LTE smartphone

------Original message------From: "Neafsey, Daniel" Date:U/03/2014 16:40 (GMT-05:00) To: "Ryan, Sean" ,"Metz, Michael" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

They are here 25 so far laying down

Se nt from my Verizon Wireless 4G l Tf smartphone

------Original message ------From: "Ryan, Sean" Date:12/03/2014 4:07PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Metz, Michael" Cc: "Neafsey, Daniel" Subject: Re: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I should be there around 1745 latest fyi.

Sent from my iPad

On Dec 3, 2014, at 4:04 PM, Metz, Michael wrote: Thanks Dan, lunch on me when I see ya.

Sent from my Ve rizon Wireless 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message------From: "Neafsey, Daniel" Date:12/03/2014 16:03 (GMT-05:00) To: "Metz, Michael" ,"Ryan, Sean" Subject: RE : Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

No problem, 1 am here. As of the Chief and Inspector do not need anything from us right now.

Dan

Sent from myVerizon Wireless 4G LTE smartphone

------Original message------From: "Metz, Michael" Date:12/03/2014 3:59PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Ryan, Sean", "Neafsey, Daniel" Subject: Fwd: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Danny, are you able to hang out this evening? I think Joe is getting NYPD Intel since Tom P called him back.

We could use the eyes and ears.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message------From: "Giulietti, Joseph" Date:12/03/2014 15:50 (GMT-05:00) To: "Fleischer, Randall" ,"Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz, Michael" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Evans, Donna" Subject: RE : Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I left holiday train and am on 340 out of Southeast. Should be there around 5 please keep me advised

Sen t via the Samsung GALAXY s• 5, an AT&T 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message------From : "Fleischer, Randall" Date:12/03/2014 3:22 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz, Michael" , "Rehbein, Kim" , "Giulietti, Joseph"

2 , "Evans, Don na " Subjec t: Re : Tw itter said a protes t is sch ed uled in GCT at 430

We are aware. Am enroute to GCT . Th x

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 3, 2014, at 3:20PM, "Mannix, Mark" wrote:

FYI

Sent from my iPad

Begin forwarded message:

From: "McCauley, Terrence" Date: December 3, 2014 3:17:56 PM EST To: "Mannix, Mark" , " Huie, Nancy" , "Mateo, George" Subject: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Terrence P. McCauley Manager, Government and Community Relations MTA Metro-North Railroad 345 Madison Avenue, 2nd Floor New York, NY 10017 http://www.mta.info Te le phone: 212-3 40-3056

3

Montanino, Linda

From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2014 5:19PM To: Giulietti, Joseph Cc: Kesich, John; Evans, Donna; Doering, Susan J.; Ryan, Sea n; Betries-Kendall, Katherine (MNR); Mannix, Mark Subject: Die- in Protest at GCT ongoing

Joe No affect on GCT or train operations, at this time. Heavy Police and media presence. FYJ.

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro N011h Railroad 212-340-3153

------Montanino, linda

From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 20 14 5:36 PM To: Ryan, Sean Cc: Metz, Michael Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430 Attachments: 20141203_173342jpg

They seem to be leaving hmmm

Sr!nt f, orn •ny Veriz.on 4G t.TE sma11phone

------Original message------From: "Ryan, Sean" Date:12/03/2014 5:32 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Neafsey, Daniel" Cc: "Metz, Michael" Subject: Re: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Me new ETA is 1830

Sent from my iPad

On Dec 3, 2014, at 4:53 PM, Neafsey, Daniel wrote:

Same amount no increase in protesters 25

Sent horn rny Veri.zo n Wireless 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message ------• From: "Metz, Michael" Date:12/03/2014 4:43PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Neafsey, Daniel", "Ryan, Sean" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Thanks, send more pies over time

from rny Verilon \h/i rele5>s 4G l.Tf

------Original message------From: "Neafsey, Daniel" Date:12/03/2014 16:40 (GMT-05:00) To : "Ryan, Sean " ,"Metz, Michael" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430 Th ey are here 25 so far laying down

Seni f"ro;n rny Verizon WireiE>ss 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message------From: "Ryan, Sean" Date:12/03/2014 4:07 PM (GMT-05:00) To : "Metz, M ichael" Cc : "Neafsey, Daniel" Subject: Re : Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I should be there around 1745 latest fyi.

Sent from my iPad

On Dec 3, 2014, at 4:04 PM, Metz, Michael wrote:

Thanks Dan, lunch on me wheri I see ya .

Se nt from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smart phone

------Original message------From: "Neafsey, Daniel" Date:12/03/2014 16:03 (GMT-05:00) To : "Metz, Michael" ,"Ryan, Sean" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

No problem, 1 am here. As of right the Chief and Inspector do not need anything from us right now.

Dan

from my verizon VJifeless 4G l TE smar£phone

------Original message------From: "Metz, Michael" Date:12/03/2014 3:59PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Ryan, Sean", "Neafsey, Daniel" Subject: Fwd : Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Danny, are you able to hang out this evening? I think Jo e is get ting NYPD Intel sin ce Tom P called him back.

We could use the eyes and ears.

2 ------Original message------From: "Giulietti, Joseph" Date:12/03/2014 15:50 {GMT-05:00) To: "Fleischer, Randall" ,"Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz, Michael" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Evans, Donna" Subject: RE: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

I left holiday train and am on 340 out of Southeast. Should be there around 5 please keep me advised

Sent via the St:H ns ung GAI.AXY S"" 5, an AT&T 'lG I.TF. .'.. m artpho ne

------Original message ------From: "Fleischer, Randall" Date:12/03/2014 3:22PM (GMT-05:00} To: "Mannix, Mark" Cc: "Metz, Michael" , "Rehbein, Kim" , "Giulietti, Joseph" , "Evans, Donna" Subject: Re: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

We are aware. Am enroute to GCT. Thx

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 3, 2014, at 3:20PM, "Mannix, Mark" wrote:

FYI

Sent from my iPad

Begin forwarded message:

From: "McCauley, Terrence" Date: December 3, 2014 3:17:56 PM EST To: "Mannix, Mark" , "Huie, Nancy" , "Mateo, George" Subject: Twitter said a protest is scheduled in GCT at 430

Terrence P. McCauley Manager, Government and Community Relations MTA Metro-North Railroad 345 Madison Avenue, 2nd Floor New York, NY 10017

3 http://www.mta.info Telephone: 212-340-3056

4

Montanino, linda

From: Kirsch, Anne Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2014 10:00 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Evans, Donna; Fleischer, Randall; Kesich, John Subject: Protest Attachments: Attachrnent-ljpeg; A TTOOOOl.txt

In case you are not there. ATT00001 sent from my iPhone

Page 1 •' {'"!

. _,. .. -r ..... ,.. t. .. -i Montanino, linda

From: Ryan, Sean Sent: Wednesday, December 03, 2014 10:16 PM To: Metz, Michael Subject: Fwd: Protest Attachments: Attachment-1Jpeg

She is Jive blogging this to joe eta] from the west coast. She's sending updates real time.

This is a very clear shot. Js this from a protect camera?

Begin forwarded message:

From: "Kirsch, Anne" Date: December 3, 2014 at 21:59:48 EST To: "Giulietti, Joseph" , "Ryan, Sean" , "Evans, Donna" , "Fleischer, Randall" , "Kesich, John" Subject: Protest ,

Jn case you are not there.

Sent fi·om my iPhone

Montanino, linda

From:· Rehbein, Kim Sent: Thursday, December 04, 2014 7:24 PM To: Doering, Susan J. Cc: Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Kesich, John; Peloso, Matthew; Flei sc her, Randall; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; Montgomery, Sean; Santiago, Hector; Foglio, Michael; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4 Attachments: imagel.JPG

Ell.

On Dec 4, 2014, at 7:08PM, Doering, Susan J. wrote:

Sorry, they are not in New Haven, but in GCT in front of the New Haven Line Departure Boards.

Susan Doering Vice President Customer Service and Stations MTA Metro-North Railroad 914-461-0586 (office)

On Dec 4, 2014, at 7:05 PM, Doering, Susan J. wrote:

Ticket Agent in New Haven is reporting about 75 protestors in New Haven Station building in front of the departure boards. Any MTAPD in vicinity of NH STation?

Susan Doering Vice President Customer Service and Stations MTA Metro-North Railroad 914-461-0586 (office)

On Dec 4, 2014, at 6:58PM, Rehbein, Kim wrote:

We are beginning to see protestors in GCT 15 chanting, moving no issues at 125 AT THIS TIME

From: Doering, Susan J. Sent: Thursday, December 04, 2014 5:26PM To: Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Kesich, John; Peloso, Matthew; Fleischer, Randall; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Peloso, Matthew; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Rehbein, Kim; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; fv1ontgomery, Sean Cc: Santiago, Hector; Foglio, Michael; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

This is the email group to communicate the protest issues tonight. Please "Reply All" throughout the evening. Thank you!

2

Montanino, linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Monday, December 08, 2014 8:42 PM To: MTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141208_194019_resized.jpg; 20141208_193504_resized.jpg; 20141208_192722.jpg; 20141208_191334_resized.jpg; 20141208_19115S_resizedjpg; 20141208_190853 _resizedjpg; 1208141940.jpg; 20141208_20293l_resized.jpg

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From: Sent: Monday, December 08, 2014 8:39PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #4 Monday, December 08,2014

See attached photographs of Barclays vicinity and GCT (ICTF Team I GCT CO)

2035 hrs Location: Grand Central Station PBMN reports 25 orderly protesters inside of Grand Central Terminal; protestors are currently engaging Social Media to recruit more protestors to join them at location.

2031 hrs Location: Flntbush A venue nncl Atlantic A venue 1 female under arrest at location for Disorderly Conduct. 2022 hrs · , -·; ! . .. Location: SIB Flatbush Ave toward s Darclays The group of 400 protesters are now moving back SIB on Flatbush towards Barclays. "Die-In" Intersection of Atlantic & Flat bush A v

2010 hrs Location: Flatbush I Atlantic The group of 400 protesters has left the front of the Darclays Center and now in the intersection ofFiatbush and Atlantic. -

2008 hrs location: GRAND CENTRAL STATION 10 orderly protesters sitting on floor of GRAND CENTRAL Terminal chanting "I can't breathe". Not impeding pedestrian flow.

1952 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER Large.crowd of protesters that were in the street on Flat bush Ave flo BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN have moved back on the sidewalk. Traffic clear and moving at this time.

1946 hrs Location: Barclays Center Source reports potential for action after Brooklyn! Apparent plans for a Grand Central Terminal action following the Barclays actions. Awaiting group from Barclay's Center and other places.

1943 hrs Location: Atlantic Avenue & Fort Greene Place 300 protestors participating in a "die-in" in the intersection of Atlantic Avenue and Fort Green Place.

1932 hrs Location: Grand Central Station Source repo'rts 10 protesters lying down at clock inside of Grand Central Terminal.

1927 hrs Location: NIB Flat bush A venue 200 protestors walking NIB on Flatbush Avenue from 5th Avenue, in the street blocking traffic.

1925 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN 220 PROTESTERS MOVING SIB FROM BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN ON FLA TBUSH AVE BETWEEN 4TH AND 5TH AVE. PROTESTERS POSSIBLY ATTEMPTING TO GAIN ACCESS TO THE CENTER.

1923 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN Approx 220 protesters front ofBARCLA Y CENTER BROOKLYN same location on ground "die in" now up chanting; behind barrier, orderly at this time.

2 From: Sent: Mo , December 08, 2014 6:59PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE #3 Monday, December 08,2014

1842 hrs Location: STATE BUILDING 163 West I 25th Street PBMN repotis no protesters in F/0 STATE BUILDING

1841 hrs Locati.on: Barclays Center f..ppro.x.J50protestors have gathered outside the Barclays Center; ch?nting.and walkingtowards the entrance.

1823 hrs Location: BarcJays Center Approximately 30 protesters have gathered outside the Barclays Center. Orderly.

1821 hrs Location: zero (0) protestors at Columbus Circle.

1820 hrs Location: zero (0) protestors with patrol on scene at Foley Square.

1629 hrs Location: I3arclays Center Approx 50 youths at the Bm·clays Center have now dispersed.

1627 hrs Location: Union Square Protesters gathering at Union Square.

From: Sent: Monday, December 08, 2014 3:48PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE#2 Monday, December 08,2014

1546 HRS Location: BARCLA YS CENTER 150 PROTESTERS AT BARCLA YS CENTER. ORDERLY.

3 1511 hrs Location: 71-77 Clinton Ave 88 PCT Benjamin Banneker Academy ICAD REPORTS DEMONSTRATlON AT BENJAMIN BANNEKER ACADEMY (CONFINES Of 88 PCT); APPROX 60-70 STUDENTS WALKING UP MYRTLE AVENUE TOWARDS FLATBUSH AVENUE EXTENSION. MEDIA ON SCENE. ORDERLY AT THIS TIME.

From: Sent: ay, December 08, 2014 1:50PM Subject: Update # 1 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #1 Monday, December 08,2014

1303 hrs Location: Murray St & 20 City Council members walked out of City Council and are now blocking traffic along with 30 others at Murray St & Broadway.

"Hit hard, hit fast, hit often." -Lieutenant General Lewis "Chesty'' Puller, USMC

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email} including any attachments} may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient} you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review} disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error} please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer .

Please treat this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE / FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

4 NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA

!' .

5 c· .;..-.,..

Montanino, Linda

From: Foglio, Michael Sent: Friday, December OS, 2014 8:4S PM To: Ryan, Sean Cc: Montgomery, Sean; Rehbein, Kim; Fleischer, Randall; Doering, Susan J.; Kesich, John; Santiago, Hector; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4 Attachments: imageLJPG

No customers affected. Clear access to ticket windows. Regular P A announcements made throughout protest.

Sent from my iPhone

On Dec 5, 2014, at 8:37PM, Ryan, Sean wrote:

CNN reporting live form GCT

From: Montgomery, Sean Sent: Friday, December OS, 2014 19:37 To: Rehbein, Kim; Fleischer, Randall Cc: Doering, Susan J.; Foglio, Michael; Kesich, John; Santiago, Hector; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: Re: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

As info the group has turned towards Time square away fi·om GCT.

Sent from my V erizon Wireless 4G LTE Smartphone.

------Original Message ------From : Rehbein, Kim Subject : Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

Group has just finished a lay in at the Apple Store on fifth Abe. Apple in GCT has been advised.

On Dec S, 2014, at 6:19PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote: Kim MTAPD updates you're providing continue to be extremely helpful. Thanks much.

Randy

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development . MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340- 3153

On Dec 5, 2014, at 5:57PM, "Rehbein, Kim" wrote:

No Intel indicating that GCT will be a location. There is Mobile group in Columbus circle but no calls to GCT. We will continue to monitoring.

On Dec 5, 2014, at 3:25PM, Doering, Susan J. wrote:

Thank you.

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Friday, December 05, 2014 3:22 PM To: Doering, Susan J.; Foglio, Michael Cc: Kesich, John; Fleischer, Randall; Santiago, Hector; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; Montgomery, Sean; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: RE: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

Just spoke to the commander on scene, nothing going on the yet that is impacting the station ..

From: Doering, Susan J. Sent: Friday, December OS, 2014 3:19PM To: Rehbein, Kim; Foglio, Michael Cc: Kesich, John; Fleischer, Randall; Santiago, Hector; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; Montgomery, Sean; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: RE : Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

Anything in New Haven? Still 4:00 on the green? 2 From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Friday, December 05, 2014 2:55PM To: Foglio, Michael Cc: Kesich, John; Fleischer, Randall; Santiago, Hector; Doering, Susan J.; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; Montgomery, Sean; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: RE: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

A this time we have info on three possible gatherings for protests, nothing scheduled before 5 PM. No direct mention of MNR or GCT. I will keep you apprised of any developments.

·----·---·- .. ··- From: Foglio, Michael Sent: Thursday, December 04, 2014 11:38 PM To: Rehbein, Kim Cc: Kesich, John; Fleischer, Randall; Santiago, Hector; Doering, Susan J.; Mannix, Mark; Henly,James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Kirsch, Anne; Streany, Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; Montgomery, Sean; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

Protesters Exiting via 42/Park.

Sent from my iPhone

On Dec 4, 20 I4, at II :3I PM, Rehbein, Kim wrote:

Quite the chqnge. Group in the tem1inal. Chanting but orderly

On Dec 4, 2014, at 11:22 PM, Kesich, John wrote:

My thanks to All!

John E Kesich Senior Vice President Operations MT A Metro-North Railroad 3

Montanino, linda

From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 3:11 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph Cc: Kesich, John; Doering, Susan J.; Henly, James; Evan s, Donna; Ryan, Sean; Jeffrey Pertz (US); Betries-Kendall, Katherine (MNR); Kirsch, Anne; Lisberg, Adam; Donovan, Aaron Subject: GCT protest now Attachments: 20141206_150152Jpg

Die-in remains peaceful.

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President · Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

Sent !Tom my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smanphone

:- .:·- ,--- ,. "'"' Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20 PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs: . "

· From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #1

1952 hrs:

Location:34111 St & Park Ave Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34111 St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42"d and ih and will possibly head towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA - NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness •••

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Kirsch, Anne Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:28 PM To: Fleischer, Randall Cc: Giulietti, Joseph; Kesich, John; Doering, Susan J.; Henly, James; Evans, Donna; Ryan, Sean; Jeffrey Pertz (US); Betries-Kendall, Katherine (MNR); Lisberg, Adam; Donovan, Aaron; Cupelli, Steve; Rehbein, Kim Subject: Re: GCT protest now Attachments: imageOOLjpg

Sent from my iPhone

On Dec 6, 2014, at 8:23PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

Deputy General Stationmaster Houston and the Building Command Center Coordinator Moran confirm that protesters are back in GCT. They are in the main concourse and are loud. Protestors have initiated a die- in again ... about 150-200 plus people. GCT Services Dept are overriding the protestor chatter with steady PA announcements. No impact on operations. Police on scene and monitoring. Randy

Randall J. Fleische1: Vice President Grand Central Tem1inal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:46PM, "Fleischer, Randall" wrote:

A small "Die In" group (fluctuated in size from 8 to 15) has now come and left the terminal. No issues. Operations are normal at this time. Randy

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340- 3153

On Dec 6, 2014, at 3:30PM, "Fleischer, Randall" wrote:

Protestors gone now. All clear. On alert for additional protests closer to 5 pm. today. Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 6, 2014, at 3: I 0 PM, "Fleischer, Randall" wrote:

Die-in remains peaceful.

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 2-340-3153

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smartphone

<20141206_150152jpg>

2

-··---- ..

Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:38 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #5

-2023hrs: Location: Grand Central Terminal Field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to converge on Grand Central both due to inclement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I "lie-in" I similar-type events.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs: From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #1

1952 hrs:

Location: 34111 St & Park Ave Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34 111 St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42nct and i hand will po ssibly head towards GCT.

2 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

3 ·-·- '--·--. --- .,. • _.... - : .. -

Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 20 14 8:20 PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs:

· From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on. the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW : Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #1

1952 hrs:

Location: 34111 St & Park Ave 11 Approx 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34' St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sa turday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42"d and ih and will possibly head towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

2 Montanino, linda

From: Ryan, Sean Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:45 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph; Kesich, John; Fleischer, Randall; Doering, Susan J.; Evans, Donna; Kirsch, Anne; Metz, Michael; Streany, Joseph; Peloso, Matthew; Mannix, Mark Subject: FW: Protest Update #5

From MTA PD ... ·------·-··------From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 20:37 Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #5

-2023hrs: Location: Grand Central Tem1inal Field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to ,converge on Grand Central both due to inclement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I "lie-in" I similar-type events.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs: From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #1

1952 hrs:

Location: 34th St & Park Ave Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34th St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42"d and ih and will possibly head towards GCT.

2 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION ·

For your situational awareness ...

3 Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:56 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #6

Captain Esposito is on scene at GCT He advises: 1 and 5 is responding from Jamaica to GCT 1 and 5 is responding from Penn to GCT Group is getting more disorderly

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, ?014 8:38PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #5

-2023hrs: Location: Grand Central Terminal Field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to converge on Grand Central both due 1 incl ement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I "lie-in" I similar-type events.

Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Pro testors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW : Protest Update #1

1952 hrs:

1 Location: 34 h St & Park Ave 1 Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34 h St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42"d and fh and will possibly head towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

3 ..

Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sa turday, December 06, 2014 9:14 PM To: Piscitelli, Jonathan Subject: FW: Protest Update #7

Crowd is leaving through the Vanderbilt Ave exit.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:56PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #6

Captain Esposito is on scene at GCT He advises: 1 and 5 is responding from Jamaica to GCT 1 and 5 is responding from Penn to GCT Group is getting more disorderly

--- .... ·•· . ------· ··- ---·-·-· ------· --·------· From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:38PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update # 5

2023 hrs: Location: Grand Central Terminal Field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to converge on Grand Central both due to inclement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I "lie-in" I similar-type events. ..

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20 PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs:

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03PM

2 Cc: [email protected]. gov Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update # 1

1952 hrs:

Location: 34th St & Park Ave Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34th St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

Sgt Singh at 1PP advised a group is forming at 42"d and ih and will possibly head towards GCT.

' FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

3 Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 9:15 PM To: Piscitelli, Jonathan Subject: FW: Protest Update #7 correction

Vanderbilt Hall, not avenue

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 9:14PM To: Piscitelli, Jonathan Subject: FW: Protest Update #7

Crowd is leaving through the Vanderbilt Ave exit.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:56PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #6

Captain Esposito is on scene at GCT He advises: 1 and 5 is responding from Jamaica to GCT 1 and 5 is responding from Penn to GCT Group is getting more disorderly ·

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:38PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update # 5

Pe- 2023 hrs: Location: Grand Central Terminal field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to converge on Grand Central both due to inclement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I " li e-in" I similar-type events. Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update # 2

Approxi mately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #1

Per-1952 hrs:

Location: 34th St & Park Ave Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34th St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

1 Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42nd and 7 h and will possibly head towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

3 From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20 PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #4

GCT as of 2009 hrs:

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09 PM Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

A group of about 70 protestors have ente red Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 20 14 8:03 PM

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Kellman, Nzinga Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 9:28 PM To: Reimer, Peter; Piscitelli, Jonathan Cc: MTA PO 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FINAL: Protest Update #7 correction

As per Detective K. Hammamm, the protesters left GCT.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 9:15PM To: Piscitelli, Jonathan Subject: FW: Protest Update # 7 correction

Vanderbilt Hall, not avenue

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 9:14PM To: Piscitelli, Jonathan Subject: FW: Protest Update #7

Crowd is leaving through the Vanderbilt Ave exit.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:56PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #6

Captain Esposito is on scene at GCT He advises: 1 and 5 is responding from Jamaica to GCT 1 and 5 is responding from Penn to GCT Group is getting more disorderly

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sa turday, December 06, 2014 8:38PM Cc: dominick.chiumento@t roopers.ny.gov Subject: FW: Protest Update #5

Per-2023 hrs: Location: Grand Central Terminal Field Teams report hearing protesters speak of others who will be motivated to come to Grand Central Terminal. Protester event frequency I volume will be encouraged to converge on Grand Central both due to inclement weather and local policy permitting "die-in" I "lie-in" I similar-type events.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:20PM Subject: FW: Protest Update # 4

GCT as of 2009 hrs:

2 From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:09PM Subject: FW: Protest Update # 2

A group of about 70 protestors have entered Vanderbilt Hall

There is another group of about 30 huddled in a mass on the Main Concourse

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:03PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update #2

Approximately 75 Protestors have entered GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 8:00PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest Update # 1

Per-1952 hrs:

1 Location: 34 h St & Park Ave 1 Approx. 75 protestors traveling eastbound on 34 h St & Park Ave, orderly. Possibly heading to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Saturday, December 06, 2014 7:16PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest

1 Sgt Singh at lPP advised a group is forming at 42nd and 7 h and will possibly head towards GCT .

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness •..

3 Montanino, linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:45 PM Cc: dominick.chi [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #3

GCT as of 1833 hrs

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6: 33PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update # 2

Group now entering 89 Eas t doors to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:20PM Cc: [email protected]'UJQY Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises group of 150 currently at 34 & Park Ave heading nort h po ssibly towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ... Montanino, linda

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:50 PM To: Foglio, Michael Cc: Fleischer, Randall; Esposito Jr., Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Montgomery, Sean; Doering, Susan J.; Kesich, John; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Streany, Joseph; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; MitchelL Thomas; Rucano, Douglas; Taffner, Matthew; Kirsch, Anne; Santiago, Hector Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4 Attachments: image1jpeg

6:33pm

On Dec 7, 2014, at 6:45PM, Foglio, Michael wrote:

Group is currently sitting around information booth on all sides. No customer access to info booth.

Access to MetLife building closed by MTAPD.

No disruption to ticket office areas.

PA announcements being made.

Sent from my iPhone

On Dec 7, 2014, at 6:25PM, Rehbein, Kim wrote:

NOW- A group of 150 currently at 34 & Park Ave heading north possibly towards GCT.

On Dec 7, 2014, at 4:06PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

The group is now gone, without incident. Thanks Kim. Randy

Randall J. Fleischer

Vice President Grand Centra] Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 21?-340-3153 On Dec 7, 2014, at 3:43PM, "Rehbein, Kim" wrote:

25 just entered GCT. Orderly at this time

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:50PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

Thanks Kim

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:34PM, "Rehbein, Kim" wrote:

Thank you

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:33PM, Esposito Jr., Joseph wrote:

2 nd small "Die In" group (fluctua ted in size from 8 to 15) has now left the term ina I.

From: Esposit o Jr., Joseph

2

Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 7:27 PM Subject: FW: Protest update #3

Crowd now at apprx 300 is moving down towards Greybar Passage Exit

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:45PM · Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #3

GCT as of 1833 hrs

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:33PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #2

Group now entering 89 East doors to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:20PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises group of 150 currently at 34 & Park Ave head ing north possibly towards GCT. FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 7:30 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #5

Protestors have exited onto Lexington Ave and are heading east on 43'd Ave.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 7:27 PM Subject: FW: Protest update #3

Crowd now at apprx 300 is moving down towards Greybar Passage Exit

------··- """· -- . .. - ---- ·- - .. ·------·- ····-· .. ------· ·---- From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:45 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #3

GCT as of 1833 hrs

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:33 PM Cc: [email protected] FW: Protest update #2

Group now entering 89 East doors to GCT From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:20PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises group of 150 currently at 34 & Park Ave heading north possibly towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness...

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Rei mer, Peter Sent: Sunday, Decem be r 07 , 2014 8:45 PM Cc: [email protected] gov Subject: FW: Protest update #6

Protestors have entered Penn Station, about 150

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 7:30PM Cc: domi nick.chiumento@troopers. ny.qov Subject: FW: Protest update #5

Protestors have exited onto Lexington Ave and are heading east on 43 'ct Ave.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 7:27PM Subject: FW: Protest update #3

Crowd now at apprx 300 is moving down towards Greybar Passage Exit ·------·-·------···-----·-··---··---·---··· From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:45PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #3

GCT as of 1833 hrs From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:33PM Cc: dominick.chiumento@troopers. ny.gov Subject: FW: Protest update /t 2

Group now entering 89 East doors to GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 6:20 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises group of 150 currently at 34 & Park Ave heading north possibly towards GCT.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - NOT FOR THE MEDIA - NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

2 Montanino, linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: tvlonday, December 08, 2014 8:42 Ptvl To: tvlTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141208_194019_resized.jpg; 20141208_193504_resizedjpg; 20141208_192722.jpg; 20141208_191334_resizedjpg; 20141208_1911SS_resizedjpg; 20141208_190853 _resizedjpg; 1208141940.jpg; 20141208_20293l_resized.jpg

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From: Sent: 08, 2014 8:39PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE #4 Monday, December 08,2014

See attached photographs of Barclays vicinity and GCT (ICTF Team I GCT CO)

2035 hrs Location: Grand Central Station PBMN reports 25 orderly protesters inside of Grand Central Terminal; protestors are cunently engaging Social Media to recruit more protestors to join them at location.

2031 hrs Location: Flatbush A venue and Atlantic A venue 1 female under arrest at location for Disorderly Conduct. 2022 hrs -· t ·. :.:.. ' Location: SIB Flatbush Ave towards Darclays The group of 400 protesters are now moving back SIB on Flatbush towards Barclays. "Die-In" Intersection of Atlantic & Flatbush A v

2010 hrs Location: Flatbush I Atlantic The group of 400 protesters has left the front of the Barclays Center and now in the intersection of Flat bush and Atlantic.

2008 hrs Location: GRAND CENTRAL STATION 10 orderly protesters sitting on floor of GRAND CENTRAL Terminal chanting "I can't breathe". Not impeding pedestrian flow.

1952 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN Large,crowd of protesters that were in the street on Flat bush Ave f/o BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN have moved back on the sidewalk. Traffic clear and moving at this time.

1946 hrs Location: Barclays Center Source reports potential for Manhattan action after Brooklyn! Apparent plans for a Grand Central Terminal action following the Barclays actions. Awaiting group from Barclay's Center and other places.

1943 hrs Location: Atlantic Avenue & Fort Greene Place 300 protestors participating in a "die-in" in the intersection of Atlantic Avenue and Fort Green Place.

1932 hrs Location: Grand Central Station Source repo"rts 10 protesters lying down at clock inside of Grand Central Terminal.

1927 hrs Location: N/B Flat bush A venue 200 protestors walking N/B on Flatbush A venue from 5th A venue, in the street blocking traffic.

1925 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN 220 PROTESTERS MOVING SIB FROM BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN ON FLATBUSH AVE BETWEEN 4TH AND 5TH AVE. PROTESTERS POSSIBLY ATTEMPTING TO GAIN ACCESS TO THE CENTER.

1923 hrs Location: BARCLAY CENTER BROOKLYN Approx 220 protesters front ofBARCLA Y CENTER BROOKLYN same location on ground "die in" now up chanting; behind barrier, orderly at thi s time.

2 From:

Sent: Mo 1 December 08 1 2014 6:59PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #3 Monday, December 08,2014

1842 hrs Location: STATE BUILDING 163 West !25th Street PBMN rep011s no protesters in F/0 STATE BUILDING

1841 hrs Location: Barclays Center have gathered outside the Barclays Center j chaJ1tiJ1g.and walking'tciwards the entrance.

1823 hrs Location: Barclays Center Approximately 30 protesters have gathered outside the Barclays Center. Orderly.

1821 hrs Location: Columbus Circle zero (0) protestors at Columbus Circle.

1820 hrs Location: Foley Square zero (0) protestors with patrol on scene at Foley Square.

1629 hrs Location: Barclays Center Approx 50 youths at the Bm·clays Center have now dispersed.

1627 hrs Location: Union Square Protesters gathering at Union Square.

From:

Sent: 1 December 081 2014 3:48PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #2 Monday, December 08, 2014

1546 HRS Location: BARCLA YS CENTER 150 PROTESTERS AT BARCLA YS CENTER. ORDERLY.

3 1511 hrs Location: 71-77 Clinton Ave 88 PCT Benjamin Banneker Academy ICAD REPORTS DEMONSTRATION AT BENJAMIN BANNEKER ACADEMY (CONFINES OF 88 PCT); APPROX 60-70 STUDENTS WALKING UP MYRTLE A VENUE TOWARDS FLATBUSH AVENUE EXTENSION. MEDIA ON SCENE. ORDERLY AT THIS TIME.

From: Sent: Monday, Dece 08, 2014 1:50PM Subject: Update # 1 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICf

UPDATE #1 Monday, December 08, 2014

1303 hrs Location: Murray St & Broadway 20 City Council members walked out of City Council and are now blocking traffic along with 30 others at MmTay St & Broadway.

"Hit hard, hit fast, hit often." -Lieutenant General Lewis "Chesty" Puller, USMC

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer.

Please treat this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE / FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

4 NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES. '" .

5

Montanino, linda

From: Montgomery, Sean Sent: Monday, December 08, 2014 11:47 PM To: Fleischer, Randall; Rehbein, Kim Cc: Esposito Jr., Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Doering, Susan J.; Kesich, John; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Streany, Joseph; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas; Foglio, Michael; Rucano, Douglas; Taffner, Matthew; Kirsch, Anne; Santiago, Hector Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight Attachments: image.jpeg

0 ..

Last protester from 7:30pm Grand Central Terminal. Other protesters coming to GCT never made the subway and were marching over the Brooklyn Bridge. Probably will arrive after the station closes. Right now condition normal.

Sean K. Montgomery, Inspector

On Dec 8, 2014, at 10:33 PM, "Montgomery, Sean" wrote:

According to NYPD intel tweets still requesting protesters to go to GCT. However, no protesters as of now.

Sean K. Montgomery, Inspector

On Dec 8, 2014, at 8:36PM, "Montgomery, Sean" wrote:

Reports from Barclay Center possible group coming to GCT (300).

Sean K. Montgomery, Inspector

2 On Dec 8, 2014, at 7:31PM, "Montgomery, Sean" wrote:

7 protesters. At GCT orderly at thi s time.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G L TE Smartphone.

------Original Message ------From : Fleischer, Randall Subject: RE: Group email chain for protest rep011s tonight 12/4

.Understood ... thanks Kim.

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Monday, December 08, 2014 4:34PM To: Fleischer, Randall Cc: Esposito Jr., Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Montgomery, Sean; Doering, Susan J.; Kesich, John; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Streany, Joseph; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas; Foglio, Michael; Rucano, Douglas; Taffner, Matthew; Kirsch, Anne; Santiago, Hector Subject: RE: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

I will not be on post tonight. Inspector Montgomery will provide updates. Chief Dunn will be on post.

From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Sunday, December 07, 2014 4:06PM To: Rehbein, Kim Cc: Esposito Jr., Joseph; Ryan, Sean; Montgomery, Sean; Doering, Susan J.; Kesich, John; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve; Peloso, Matthew; Evans, Donna; O'Connor, Kevin; O'Connor, Casey; Lagana, Joseph; Streany, Joseph; Metz, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Boyle, Neil; Grimm, Matthew; DePasquale, Matthew; Mitchell, Thomas; Foglio, Michael; Rucano, Douglas; Taffner, Matthew; Kirsch, Anne; Santiago, Hector; Rehbein, Kim Subject: Re: Group email chain for protest reports tonight 12/4

The group is now gone, without in cident. Thanks Kim. Randy

Randall J. Fleischer

Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Devel opment

3 MT A Metro North Railroad 212-340-31 53

On Dec 7, 2014, at 3:43PM, "Rehbein, Kim" wrote:

25 just entered GCT. Orderly at this lime

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:50PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

Thanks Kim

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro Nm1h Railroad 212-340-3153

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:34PM, "Rehbein, Kim" wrote:

Thank you

On Dec 6, 2014, at 5:33PM, Esposito Jr., Joseph wrote:

2"d small "Die In" group (fluctua ted in size from 8 to 15) has now left the term ina I.

From: Esposit

4

....._, ....

Montanino, linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:54PM To: MT A PO 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: Update #6 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141209_194102_resized.jpg; 20141209_193903_resized.jpg; 20141209_194207 _resized.jpg; 20141209_194443_resized.jpg; 20141209_194555_resized.jpg

Importance: High

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From: Sent: , Decem Subject: Update #6 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier Importance: High

UPDATE#6 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1943 hrs

Location: Grand Centra] Terminal Approx 75 protesters in Grand Central; 20 protesters are on the floor performing a "Die-In".

Photographs - ICTF Det Hammam From: " Sent: Tuesday, 09, 2014 7:24PM Subject: Update # 5 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Importance: High

UPDATE #5 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1921 hrs Location: Grand Central Group of approx. 50 from Union Square has just arrived at Grand Central. There are now a total of approx. 70 at Grand Central.

1919 hrs Location: Brooklyn Bridge I Manhattan Bridge No activity near Brooklyn Bridge or Manhattan Bridge at this time.

From: Sent: , Decem 09, 2014 7:14PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE#4 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1906 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal 10 protestors at Grand Central Terminal at this time.

1900 hrs Location: Union Square 40-50 protesters from Union Square entered the subway entrance on 16th Stand Union Square West.

1851 hrs Location: Herald Sq There are zero (0) protesters at Herald Sq

From: Sent: , Decem 09, 2014 6:32 PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #3 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1827 hrs Location: Union Square 30 protesters at Union Square; chanting, orderly.

2 From: Sent: er 09, 2014 6:06PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #2 Tuesday, December 09,2014

1800 hrs

Location: V /0 Brooklyn Bridge- No protest activity reported at either of the following locations:

• Barclays Center

• Brooklyn-side of the Brooklyn Bridge

Location: Union Square Park 20 protesters, orderly, in Union Square Park.

From: Sent: , Decem 09, 2014 5:23PM Subject: Update ·#l NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #1 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1635 hrs

Location: Multiple locations

No activity is being reported at the following:

• Herald Square

• Penn Station

• Grand Central Terminal

• Union Square

• Cadman Plaza

• Bm·clays Center

3 Additional Tweets on Grand Central Terminal flash mob:

• 5 PM - MEET UP/PREP @ UNION SQUARE • 6 PM- GROUP TRAVEL TO GRAND CENTRAL • 7 PM- GRAND CENTRAL *MAIN CONCOURSE"

G) ;:- .. !1J suns'lr::l T:lylor ' ··- -:'' ;_, ..- ._,, ·3 . Artist led Flashmob tomoro ';ICaniBreathe :, EncGamer ·- WeekOfOu trage 'i(StopMasslncNet (i amyoreos 'd?SabeLBoo

SPM _. MEET UP/PREP ® UNION OOUARE

6PM- CROUP TRAVR TO ORJWO CENTRAl

7PM- ORANO CENTRAl .,.MAIN CONcoUR!:£ • • • WIIAT TO BRING: ••• •• ,>; 5 -- ...... •

NYC - GARNER I FERGUSON Grand Jury Decision Protests; TODAY

TUESDAY, 9 DEC 2014

Stmt at Community High School ( 420 East Students and 12th St) then Faculty from March in response MARCH to PBMS 9-Dec Tue 14:30 16:00 East Side to Eric Gamer's l Eastern District & 84 Community GJ Decision Courthouse (225 High School Cadman Plaza) via BK Bridge Footpath

4 Response Protest National Action to Eric Garner's 9-Dec Tue 16:00 Unk. 41 Bay Street, SI 120 1 Network Grand Jury Decision

Response Protest Peoples Power 9-Dec Tue 17:00 Unk. Union Square to the Ferguson, 13 1 Assembly MO decision

Flash-Mob/ Die-In Stop Mass North End of then MARCH 9-Dec Tue 17:00 Unk. Incarceration 13 1 Union Square "Through the Network City"

Stop Mass Meet-up at Union "Justice for Eric 13 & 9-Dec Tue 17:00 Unk. Incarceration Square then 1 Garner" 5 Network MARCH to 1 PP

"Hit hard, hit fa st, hit often." -Lieutenant General Lewis "Chesty" Puller, USMC

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to

5 which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer.

Please treat this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE / FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES.

6

---=---'--- .--._:..;. . __... ______.. -·-·-----·

Montanino, Linda

From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 8:39 PM To: McDonald, Edward; Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Ryan, Sean Cc: Santana, Jose; Repman, James; Joseph, Tonja; DeJesus, Saturnine; Morrella, James; Munson, Gerald; Schwarz, Frederick; Maddock, Timothy; Mullarkey, Daniel; Kudelka, James; Vinzo, Christopher; Ciaramella, Anthony; Maloney, Eugene; Ruiz, Frank; O'Brien, Thomas Subject: RE: Protesters Attachments: 20141209_203626jpg

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE sma11phone

------Original message ------From: "McDonald, Edward" Date:12/09/2014 7:46PM (GMT-05:00) To· "Abrosikov Sergey" "Lee Michael (MNR)" "Metz Michael" "Neafsey Daniel" "Ryan Sean" . ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' Cc: "Santana, Jose" , "Repman, James" , "Joseph, Tonja" , "DeJesus, Saturnino" , "Morrella, James" , "Munson, Gerald", "Schwarz, Frederick", "Maddock, Timothy", "Mullarkey, Daniel", "Kudelka, James", "Vinzo, Christopher", "Ciaramella, Anthony", "Maloney, Eugene", "Ruiz, Frank", "O'Brien, Thomas" Subject: RE: Protesters

CNN reporting live from Gcr die in.

Edward C. McDonald Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours (914)-461-0525 MTA-Metro North Railroad

From: McDonald, Edward Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:26 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Santana, Jose; Repman, James; Joseph, Tonja; DeJesus, Saturnine; Morrella, James; Munson, Gerald; Schwarz, Frederick; Maddock, Timothy; Mullarkey, Daniel; Kudelka, James; Vinzo, Christopher; Ciaramella, Anthony; Maloney, Eugene; Ruiz, Frank; McDonald, Edward; O'Brien, Thomas Subject: RE: Protesters "002.9 H- GC1 -STA-M- TKT- EAST :01 ---Selected--

Edward C. McDonald Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours (914)-461-0525 MTA-Metro North Railroad

From: McDonald, Edward Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:22PM To: Neafsey, Daniel Subject: RE: Protesters

Looks like drips and drabs Basing it on all black clothing.

Edward C. McDonald Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours (914)-461-0525 MTA-Metro North Railroad

.. ------From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:21 PM To: McDonald, Edward; Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Ryan, Sean Cc: Santana, Jose; Repman, James; Joseph, Tonja; DeJes us, Saturnine; Morrella, James; Munson, Gerald; Schwarz, Frederick; Maddock, Timothy; Mullarkey, Daniel; Kudel ka, James; Vinzo, Christopher; Ciaramella, Anthony; Maloney, Eugene; Ruiz, Frank; O'Brien, Thomas Subject: RE: Protesters

50 plus on the way 2 Sen I from my Vcrizon \V i1 e lc.ss 4G LTE sm:ll11)hone

------Original message ------From: "McDonald, Edward" Date:l2/09/2014 7:20PM (GMT-05:00) To· "Abrosikov Sergey" "Lee Michael (MNR)" "Metz Michael" "Neafsey Daniel" "Ryan Sean" ' ) ' ' ' ' Cc:0 "Santana, Jose"' , "Repman,' ' James" , "Joseph, Tonja" , "DeJesus, Saturnino" , "Morrella, James" , "Munson, Gerald", "Schwarz, Frederick", "Maddock, Timothy", "Mullarkey, Daniel", "Kudelka, James", "Vinzo, Christopher" , "Ciaramella, Anthony" , "Maloney, Eugene" , "Ruiz, Frank" , "McDonald, Edward" , "O'Brien, Thomas" Subject: RE: Protesters

Heading in from 42 nd st passage.

Edward C. McDonald Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours (91.4)-461.-0525 MTA-Metro North Railroad

From: Neafsey, Daniel Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:11PM To: Ryan, Sean; Metz, Michael; McDonald, Edward Subject: Protesters

Only 10 so far in OCT, 40-50 are inbound from Union Square

Senl from my Ycrizon Wireless 4G LTE smao1ph onc

3

,.-.: ....

Montanino, linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 8:58 PM To: MT A PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: Update #7 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141209_20244S_resizedJpg; 20141209_202429_resized.jpg

Importance: High

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From: Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 8:39PM Subject: Update #7 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Importance: High

UPDATE #7 Tuesday, December 09,2014

2028 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal

A retired Philadelphia Police Officer in uniform is one of the protesters at Grand Central Terminal. He is also known to NYPD as a protestor in OWS and has an arrest record with NYPD.

Photograph -lCTF Det. Hammam

2026 hrs Location: .. -=-· ·- There currently 4 orderly protestors at 202 Bay.

Location: West 125 Street and 7th Avenue No protest activity at the State Building at West 125 Street and 7th Avenue.

Location: Herald Square There is no activity near Herald Square.

From: Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:52PM Subject: Update #6 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Importance: High

UPDATE#6 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1943 hrs

Location: Grand Central Terminal Approx 75 protesters in Grand Central; 20 protesters are on the floor performing a "Die-In".

Photographs - ICTF Det Hammam

From: Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:24 PM Subject: Update #5 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Importance: High

UPDATE #5 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1921 hrs Location: Grand Central Group of approx. 50 from Union Square has just arrived at Grand Central. There are now a total of approx. 70 at Grand Central.

1919 hrs Location: Brooklyn Bridge I Manhattan Bridge No activity near Brooklyn Bridge or Manhattan Bridge at this time.

From: Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 7:14PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #4 Tuesday, December 09,2014

2 1906 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal 10 protestors at Grand Central Terminal at this time.

1900 hrs Location: Union Square 40-50 protesters from Union Square entered the subway entrance on 16th Stand Union Square West.

1851 hrs Location: Herald Sq There are zero (0) protesters at Herald Sq

From: Sent: Tuesday, December 09, 2014 6:32PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE#3 Tuesday, December 09,2014

1827 hrs Location: Union Square 30 protesters at Union Square; chanting, orderly.

From: Sent: , Dece 09, 2014 6:06PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #2 Tuesday, December 09, 2014

1800 hrs

Location: V/0 Brooklyn Bridge- Cadman Plaza No protest activity reported at either of the following locations:

• Bm·clays Center

• Brook Iyn-side of the Brooklyn Bridge

Location: Union Square Park 20 protesters, orderly, in Union Square Park.

3 From: Sent: Tuesday, Decem r 09, 2014 5:23PM Subject: Update # 1 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #I Tuesday, December 09,2014

1635 hrs

Location: Multiple locations

No activity is being reported at the following:

• Herald Square

• Penn Station

• Grand Central Terminal

• Times Square

• Union Square

• Cadman Plaza

• Barclays Center

Additional Tweets on Grand Central termin.al. flash mob:

• 5 PM- MEET UP/PREP@ UNION SQUARE 6 PM - GROUP TRAVEL TO GRAND CENTRAL • 7 PM- GRAND CENTRAL *MAIN CONCOURSE"

Q.1 .. ' i i ','. •' !.fl sunsara Taylor r,;•::.•. · ... :.'"'':, Artist led Flaslunob tomom · ICrmiBreaUw : EricGarnor -'·WeekOiOutrago · f'h.!t -. :,·· Sabei_Boo

5PM- MEET UP/PREP ® UNION !!OUARE

6PM- GROUP TRAVU TO GRAND CENTRAl.

7PM ... GRANO CENTRAl. *MAIN CONCOURSE WJ.IAT TO BRING: ••••••_ .a A • NYC- GARNER I FERGUSON Grand Jury Dec isi on Protests; TOD;\ Y

TU ESDAY , 9 DEC 2014

Date Day Start Reason :;- ·

Start at East Side Community High School ( 420 East Students and 12th St) then Faculty from March in response MARCH to PBMS East Side to Eric Garner's 1 9-Dec Tue 14:30 16:00 Eastern District & 84 Community GJ Decision Courthouse (225 High School Cadman Plaza) via- BK Bridge Footpath

Response Protest National Action to Eric Gamer's 16:00 Unk. 41 Bay Street, SI 120 l 9-Dec Tue Network Grand Jury Decision

Response Protest Peoples Power 9-Dec Tue 17:00 Unk. Union Square to the Ferguson, 13 1 .. ·Assembly MO decision

Flash-Mob/ Die-In Stop Mass North End of then MARCH Unk. Incarceration 13 l 9-Dec Tue 17:00 Union Square "Through the Network City"

1\!lass Meet-up at Union Stop "Justice for Eric 13 & Incarceration Square then l 9-Dec Tue ] 7:00 Unk. Garner" 5 Network MARCH to 1 PP

5 "Hit hard, hit fast, hit often." -lieutenant General Lewis "Chesty" Puller, USMC

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer.

Please treat this and ail other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE / FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES.

6

Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 9:02 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #4

Det Cheung provided the below photo at 2057 hrs.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 8:14PM Subject: FW: Protest update #3

ICTF advises 20 protestors now at GCT and they have begun chanting.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:47 PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #2 ICTF advises 17 protes ters in GCT, all orderly.

From: Takacs, Stephen Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:22 PM Cc: '[email protected]' Subject: Protest updeate #1

As per ICTF:

1747 hrs Location: PSNY Approx 25 protesters in Penn Station (Amtrak Level) staging a "Die-In"

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 12:19 AM Subject: FW: Protest update #S

All protestors have left GCT

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 9:02PM Cc: dominick.chiumento@troopers. ny.qov Subject: FW: Protest update #4

Det Cheung provided the below photo at 2057 hrs.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 8:14PM Subject: FW: Protest update #3

ICTF advises 20 protestors now at GCT and they have begun chanting. From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:47PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #2

ICTF advises 17 protesters in GCT, all orderly.

From: Takacs, Stephen Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:22 PM Cc: '[email protected]' Subject: Protest updeate # 1

As per ICTF:

1747 hrs Location: PSNY Approx 25 protesters in Penn Station {Amtrak Level) staging a "Die-In"

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 8:30 PM Cc: [email protected]; Zaino, Francis Subject: FW: Protest update #4

GCT at 2028 hrs

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 7:55 PM Cc: [email protected]; Zaino, Francis Subject: FW: Protest update #3

50 protesters at Saks 5th Ave currently heading to get as per nypd Intelligence sergeant

1 Protestor at 125 Station are leaving the property and heading West on 125 h Street

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 7:21PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #2

50 protestors at 125'h Street. Two K9 and 6DP and SV units on scene.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 6:43PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises - Approx 15 protestors doing a "die in" at this time at GCT FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness ...

2 Montanino, Linda

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 9:17 PM Cc: [email protected]; Zaino, Francis Subject: FW: Protest update #5

Protestors have exited GCT and are headed west on . No protestors at 125 st. Station

from: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 8:30 PM Cc: [email protected]; Zaino, Francis Subject: FW: Protest update #4

GCT at 2028 hrs

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 7:55PM Cc: [email protected]; Zaino, Francis Subject: FW: Protest update #3

50 protesters at Saks 5th Ave currently heading to get as per nypd Intelligence sergeant

111 Protestor at 125 Station are le aving the property and heading West on 125 Street

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 7:21PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Protest update #2 1 50 protestors at 125 h Street. Two K9 and 6DP and SV units on scene.

From: Reimer, Peter Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2014 6:43PM Cc: [email protected] Subject: Protest update # 1

ICTF advises - Approx 15 protestors doing a "die in" at this time at GCT

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - NOT FOR THE MEDIA- NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION

For your situational awareness...

2 - - ···-·-· --- ·

Montanino, Linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2014 7:34 PM To: MTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141214_191016_resized.jpg

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From: Sent: Sunday, Decem 14, 2 14 7 1 PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE#4 Sunday, December 14, 2014

1915 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal There are five (5) protesters in Grand Central Terminal sitting on the main concourse floor.

See attached photograph (MTAP D ICTF Field Team)

1909 hrs Location: Union Square Zero (0) protesters at Union Square.

1901 hrs Location: Times Square There are no protesters in Times Square. From:··· Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2014 6:34PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE #3 Sunday, December 14,2014

1832 hrs Zero (0) protesters reported at the following locations:

1. Location: Columbus Circle

2. Location:

3. Location: Grand Army Plaza (Brooklyn)

4. Location: Foley Square

5. Location:

6. Location: 1 Police Plaza

---.------From: Sent: 14, 2014 6:02PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE#2 Sunday, December 14, 2014

1752 hrs Zero (0) protesters reported at the following locations:

1) Location: Foley Square

2) Location: Zuccotti Park

3) Location: Grand Central Terminal

1749 hrs Zero (0) protesters reported at the following locations:

1) Location: Times Square

2) Location: Union Square

From Sent: Sunday, Decem r 14, 2014 5:22PM Subject: Update #1 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE #1

2 Sunday, December 14,2014

1708 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal Zero (0) protesters at Grand Central Tem1inal.

1647 hrs Location: Grand Army Plaza (Brooklyn) 30-35 protesters are still present at this time; peaceful.

1640 hrs Location: Times Square Zero (0) protesters at Times Square at this time.

1624 hrs Location: Zuccotti Park, Foley Square Park Zero (0) protesters at Zuccotti Park and Foley Square Park.

1557 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal Zero (0) protesters at Grand Central Terminal.

1550 hrs Location: Union' Square Zero (0) protesters at Union Square.

Location: Times Square Zero (0) protesters at Times Square.

1524 hrs Location: Foley Square Zero (0) protesters at Foley Square & Zuccotti Park.

1508 hrs Location: Union Square Zero (0) protesters at Union Square.

1350 hrs Location: Grand Army Plaza in Brooklyn 20 protesters at Grand Army Plaza in Brooklyn. NYPD patrol RMP across the street, monitoring.

1334 hrs Location: Grand Army Plaza in Brooklyn Approximately 11 protesters at Grand Army Plaza in Brooklyn, orderly.

3 .. ·.

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which irlnten,ded for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intt:i'ri'dedFecipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this . .· "'"'--'--;•_ in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer. ,L-Y_ __.··. ;_·-. ,'-:·· Please this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE/ FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY . . ... ;;_··t NO REPORTOR'SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES.

· .. .·

. .--: .

:_

4

···

Montanino, Linda

From: Dominici, Anthony Sent: Monday, December 15, 2014 7:46 PM To: MTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Cc: [email protected] Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT Attachments: 20141215_185208_resized.jpg

ICTF reports approximately 60 protestors at GCT. MTA EOC is monitoring via live video- all appear orderly.

From: Sent: , December 15, 2014 7:38PM Subject: Update #4 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE#4 Monday, December 15,2014

1936 h.rs Location: Grand Central Terminal inteJ reports there are 60 protesters at Grand Central TerminaL

1932 h.rs Location: Union Square ***UPDATE*** There are now 30 protesters at Union Square doing a "Die-In" on the perimeter of the park.

1927 h.rs Location: Union Square 25 orderly protesters at Union Square, on 17th Street and Union Square West

1913 hrs Location: Zero (0) protesters.

1902 h.rs Location: Grand Central Terminal Intel Team reports 40 protestors at the location, some sitting, most standing and chanting.

From: Sent: , December 15, 2014 6:57 PM Subject: Update #3 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDICT

UPDATE #3 Monday, December 15 , 2014

1855 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal Approx thirty (30) protesters in Grand Central Terminal. See attached photograph (MTAPD JCTF} 1850 hrs Location: Union Square Zero (0) protesters at Union Square.

Location: Grand Central Terminal Intel Field Team reports 20 orderly protesters at Grand Central Terminal

From: Sent: r 15, 2014 6:39 PM Subject: Update #2 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE#2 Monday, December 15,2014

1834 hrs . Location: Grand Central Terminal Approx. 18-20 protesters; continually rotating in/out of concourse in varied numbers. Some are sitting/some standing. See attached photo (MTAPD JCTF)

1828 hrs Location: SI Ferry Terminal- Whitehall Station (MN) All protestors have left the location.

1825 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal Approx. 5-10 protesters; half rotating in/out from the main concourse. See attached photo (MTAP D JCTF)

1819 hrs Location: Gracie Mansion PBMN Response Auto advises there are 25 orderly protestors, in front of Gracie Mansion on East 88th Street and East End Drive.

1802 hrs Location: Times Square Zero (0) protesters in Times Square at this time.

From: Sent: Monday, December 15, 2014 6:00 PM Subject: Update # 1 NYC Protest re GARNER VERDier

UPDATE#l Monday, December 15,2014

1758 hrs Location: Grand Central Terminal 2 protestors were present at the information booth, orderly, and now departed GCT.

1757 hrs 2 Location: SI Ferry (Manhattan) 25 orderly protestors at SI Ferry terminal (Manhattan)

1718 hrs Location: Gracie Mansion Zero (0) protesters at Gracie Mansion. Media is reporting fi·om the location. 1/8 present ( 19 Pet).

Location: 343 Malcolm X Boulevard Zero (0) protesters at 343 Malcolm X Boulevard.

1710 hrs Location: Times Square Zero (0) protesters in Times Square.

1659 Location: Grand Central Tem1inal Zero (0) protesters at Grand Central Terminal.

1620 hrs Location: 343 Malcolm X Boulevard Zero (0) protesters at 343 Malcolm X Boulevard at this time ..

1614 hrs Location: Times Square Zero (0) protesters in Times Square at this time.

Location: Gracie Mansion Zero (0) protesters at Gracie Mansion.

Location: SI Ferry- (Manhattan Tenninal) Zero (0) protesters at the SI Ferry (Manhattan)

1545 hrs Location: Union Square Zero (0) protesters in Union Square at this time.

1535 hrs Location: Grand Central Station Zero (0) protesters in Grand Central Terminal at this time.

3 ,,......

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer.

Please treat this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE/ FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES.

4 ·. Montanino, Linda

From: Morrella, James Sent: Monday, January 05, 2015 5:54 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: PROTESTER UPDATE Attachments: 20150105_174632jpg

Police report 75 protesters. This attachment from MTAPD Pro-Tect

James Morella SCC Operator Metro-North (914} 461-0525

Montanino, Linda

From: Kirsch, Anne Sent: Monday, January 05, 2015 5:59 PM To: Fleischer, Randall; Giulietti, Joseph; Lisberg, Adam; Doering, Susan J; Evans, Donna; Kesich, John; Ryan, Sean; Rehbein, Kim; Henly, James; Cupelli, Steve Subject: GCT protest - group chain Attachments: Attachment-l.jpeg; ATTOOOOl.txt

Group has grown.

i I I i i ATT00001

sent from my iPad

Page 1

--·.:. · . Montanino. Linda

From: Maddock, Timothy Sent: Tuesday, January 06, 2015 5:04 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean; Le e, Michael (MNR) Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Schwarz, Frederick; Vinzo, Christopher; Maloney, Eugene Subject: Protesters GCT Main Concourse Attachments: demo l615.bmp

Approximately 40 protesters on Main Concourse holding signs.

Timothy Maddock Operator Security Command Center 24 Hours: (914) 461-0525

MTA Metro-North Railroad

Montanino, linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Monday, January 12, 2015 6:02 PM To: MTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: GCT protest Attachments: 20150112_175246Jpg

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From:- Sent: Monday, Ja 12, 2015 5:55PM To: Boyle, Neil; Noens, Marc; Hammam, Keyla; Berlingieri, John; D' Angelis, Anthony; Rehbein, Kim; Jatindranath, Swarendra; V nte, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Farney, Thomas; Cudia, Lawrence; Lindsay Alexander; Cheung, David;- Augie Paratore; Beahan, Gary; MTA PD Communications Sergeants; MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors; Rucano, Douglas; Piscitelli, Jonathan; Takacs, Stephen; Odessa, Thomas; Martelli, Joseph; Noens, Marc; Kieran, Kevin; Ojeda, Daniel; Montgomery, Sean; Diaz, Raymond Subject: GCT protest

Approximately 50 protesters currently gathered in front of the clock.

__ .-:

Montanino, Linda

From: Pouncey, Dwayne Sent: Monday, January 12, 2015 6:09 PM To: MT A PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: UPDATE #1 Shut Down GCT PROTEST Attachments: 1755 hrs.jpg

D.M.Pouncey Sergeant

From Sent: Monday, nuary 15 6:08 PM Subject: UPDATE #1 Shut Down GCf PROTEST

MONDAY, 12 JAN 2015 UPDATE #1 Location: Grand Central Terminal

1805 hrs Group is marching on main concourse, singing "I Can't Breathe."

J754 hrs Approx. 50-60 protesters present in Grand Central Tenninal on main concourse; mic check; orderly. See attached photo

Jose LaSalle, anti-police activist present; performed mic check CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, including any attachments, may contain confidential and privileged information which is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which the transmission is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this communication in error and that any review, disclosure, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmission is strictly prohibited. If you received this communication in error, please notify me immediately by replying to this message and delete the transmission from your computer.

Please treat this and all other communications from the Intelligence Division of the New York City Police Department as LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE / FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

NO REPORT OR SEGMENT THEREOF MAY BE RELEASED TO ANY MEDIA SOURCES.

2

Montanino, linda

From: Esposito, Antonio Sent: Monday, January 12, 2015 8:33 PM To: MTA PD 24HR Incident Notification Subject: FW: GCT protest Attachments: 20150112_202455Jpg

From:- Sent: Monday, January 12, 2015 8:27 PM To: Boyle, Neil; Noens, Marc; Hammam, Keyla; Berlingieri, John; D' Angelis, Anthony; Rehbein, Kim; Jatindranath, Swarendra; Vicente, Michael; Finneran, Kathleen; Farney, Thomas; C1.1dia, Lawrence; Lindsay Alexander; Cheung, David; Augie Paratore; Beahan, Gary; MTA PO Communications Sergeants; MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors; Rucano, Douglas; Piscitelli, Jonathan; Takacs, Stephen; Odessa, Thomas; Martelli, Joseph; Noens, Marc; Kieran, Kevin; Ojeda, Daniel; Montgomery, Sean; Diaz, Raymond Subject: RE: GCT protest

Approximately 25 to 30 protesters remaining, orderly at this time.

------Original message ------From.-

To: "Boyle, Neil" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Hammam, Keyla" ,"Berlingieri, John" ,"D' Angelis, Anthony" ,"Rehbein, 1m atindranath, Swarendra" ,"Vicente, Michael" ,';Finneran, Kathleen" ,"Farney, Thomas" ,"Cudia, Lawrence" ,Lindsay Alexander ,"Cheung, David" ,Augie Paratore ,"Beahan, Gary" ,MTA PD Communications Sergeants ,MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors ,"Rucano, Douglas" ,"Piscitelli, Jonathan" ,"Takacs, Stephen" ,"Odessa, Thomas" ,"Martelli, Joseph" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Kieran, Kevin" ,"Ojeda, Daniel" ,"Montgomery, Sean" ,"Diaz, Raymond" Subject: RE: GCT protest

Approximately 30 protesters remaining at this time.

------Original message ------From:'- Date:Ol/12/2015 18:46 To: "Boyle, Neil" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Hammam, Keyla" ,"Berlingieri, John" ,"D' Angelis, Anthony" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Jatindranath, Swarendra" ,"Vicente, Michael" ,"Finneran, Kathleen" ,"Farney, Thomas" ,"Cudia, Lawrence" ,Li ndsay Alexander ,"Cheung, David" ,Augie Paratore ,"Beahan, Gary" ,MT A PD Communications Sergeants ,MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors ,"Rucano, Douglas" ,"Piscitelli, Jonathan" ,"Takacs, Stephen" ," Odessa, Thomas" ,"Mm1elli, Joseph" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Kieran, Kevin" ,"Ojeda, Daniel" ,"Montgomery, Sean" ,"Diaz, Raymond" Subject: RE: GCT protest

Group of 40 walking around the concourse chanting.

------Original message ------From:'- Date:Ol/12/2015 18:21 (GMT-05:00) To: "Boyle, Neil" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Hammam, Keyla" ,"Berlingieri,.John" ,"D' Angelis, Anthony" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Jatindranath, Swarendra" ," Vicente, Michael" ,"Finneran, Kathleen" ,"Farney, Thomas" ,"Cudia, Lawrence" ,Lindsay Alexander ,"Cheung, David" ,Augie Paratore ,"Beahan, Gary" ,MTA PD Communications Sergeants ,MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors ,"Rucano, Douglas" ,"Piscitelli, Jonathan" ,"Takacs, Stephen" ,"Odessa, Thomas" ,"Martelli, Joseph" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Kieran, Kevin" ,"Ojeda, Daniel" ,"Montgomery, Sean" ,"Diaz, Raymond" Subject: RE: GCT protest

Same group now stationary in front oftrk 26 chanting

------Original message ------From:'- Date:Ol/12/2015 17:54 To: "Boyle, Neil" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Hammam, Keyla" ,"Berlingieri, John" ,"D' Angelis, Anthony" ,"Rehbein, Kim" ,"Jatindranath, Swarendra" ,"Vicente, Michael" "Finneran, Kathleen" ,"Farney, Thomas" ,"Cudia, Lawrence" ,Lindsay Alexander ,"Cheung, David" ,Augie Paratore ,"Beahan, Gary" ,MTA PD Communications Sergeants ,MTA PD Emergency Comm Supervisors ,"Rucan6, Douglas" ,"Piscitelli, Jonathan" ,"Takacs, Stephen" ,"Odessa, Thomas" ,"Martelli, Joseph" ,"Noens, Marc" ,"Kieran, Kevin" ,"Ojeda, Daniel" ,"Montgomery, Sean" ,"Diaz, Raymond" Subject: GCT protest

Approximately 50 protesters currently gathered in front of the clock.

2

Montanino, Linda

From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Tuesday, January 13, 2015 12:41 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph; Rinaldi, Catherine Cc: Rehbein, Kim; Ryan, Sean; Greco, Anthony; Barrett, Marilyn; Lisberg, Adam Subject: Protestors returned

Joe/ Cathy, Protesters returned. Same group as last week led by Rev. Billy. He got himself arrested last time in GCT. They're displaying some placards now .. .if they place same on the floor the MTA police will be directing them to remove them. Otherwise they will be arrested for obstruct' Chief Coan is with me on the floor. Picture attached. I will

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153 Montanino, linda

From: Ryan, Sean Sent: Tuesday, January 13, 2015 12:49 PM To: Li sberg, Adam Cc: Fleischer, Randall; Giulietti, Joseph; Rinaldi, Catherine; Rehbein, Kim; Greco, Anthony; Barrett, Marilyn Subject: Re: Protestors returned Attachments: imagel.JPG

Ell;

On Jan 13,2015, at 12:42, Lisberg, Adam wrote: I

Any press?

------··-··-- ... From: Fleischer, Randall Sent: Tuesday, January 13, 2015 12:41 PM To: Giulietti, Joseph; Rinaldi, Catherine Cc: Rehbein, Kim; Ryan, Sean; Greco, Anthony; Barrett, Marilyn; Lisberg, Adam Subject: Protestors returned '

'I·· .'I Joel Cathy, Protesters returned. Same group as last week led by Rev. Billy. He got himself arrested last time in GCT. They're displaying some placards now .. .if they place same on the floor the MTA police will be directing them to remove them. Otherwise they will be arrested for obstructing. Chief Coan is with me on the floor. Picture attached. I will keep you posted. My cell : 917-679-8784. Randy

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-3 40-3153 Montanino, Linda

From: Santana, Jose Sent: Thursday, January 15, 2015 8:30 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean; Feeney, Michael; O'Brien, Thomas; Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Schwarz, Frederick; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: Protestor Update

Protestors have initiated a "Die-in."

Jose Santana Shift Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours: 914-461-0525

MTA Metro North Railroad Montanino, Linda

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Thursday, January 15, 2015 9:28 PM To: Fleischer, Randall Cc: Giulietti, Joseph; Rinaldi, Catherine; Kesich, John; Kirsch, Anne; Ryan, Sean; Mannix, Mark; Henly, James; Doering, Susan J. Subject: Re: Protesters in GCT Attachments: 20150115_184410Jpg

At one point the protestors were displaying the attached and were advise it had to come down.

On Jan 15, 2015, at 9:23 PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

Info Booth reopened ... about 6 protestors h!ft in the Terminal.

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro North Railroad 212-340-3153

On Jan 15,2015, at 9:02PM, "Doering, Susan J." wrote:

At 7:20 GCT Ticket Manager Michael Foglio reported a group of 75-100 protesters chanting while walking around lower level. At 7:30 approximately 50 of them moved to the upper level chanting and circling the concourse. At about 7:50 it appeared two protestors were removed by MTAPD, the Information Booth was closed and the MetLife escalators were turned off. Currently most of the protesters have dispersed with only 10 left on the upper level. Info Booth is still closed. Large police presence with some TV networks in the Tenninal.

Susan Doering Vice President Customer Service and Stations MTA Metro-North Railroad 914-461-0586 (office)

Montanino, linda

From: Santana, Jose Sent: Thursday, January 15, 201 5 9:37 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michae l (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean; Feeney, Michael; O'B rie n, Thomas; Ciaramella, Anthony; Co rrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Joseph, To nja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Schwarz, Frederick; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: Protestor Update

Small group still remains. All in order.

Jose Santana Shift Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours: 914-461-0525

MTA Metro North Railroad Montanino, linda

From: Morrella, Jam es Sent: Sunday, January 18, 2015 9:13 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnino; Feeney, Michael; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: PROTESTERS BACK

About 10, orderly per Police. Here GCT Main Concourse since about 2050 hours

Jim Morrella Operator Security Command Center 24 Hours: (914) 461-0525

MTA Metro-North Railroad Montanino, Linda

From: Morrella, James Sent: Sunday, January 18, 2015 -9:41 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnino; Feeney, Michael; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: Protester update

Protesters are still present in GCT. Just milling around Main Concourse at 2140hrs.

Jim Morrella Operator Security Command Center 24 Hours: (914) 461-0525

MTA Metro-North Railroad Montanino, Linda

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Monday, January 19, 2015 6:07 PM To: Fl eischer, Randal l; Giulietti, Joseph; Ryan, Sean Subject: GCT protestors Attachments: Attachment-1.jpeg; A TTOOOOl. txt

The circle and signs held up. .·

ATTOOOOl

Page 1

...... ,--•

-··· .. _:: -· Montanino, Linda

From: Morrella, James Sent: Monday, January 19, 2015 6:14 PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael {MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark;, DeJesus, Sa turnine; Feeney, Michael; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: FW: PROTESTERS Attachments: 20150119_175607 _LLS.JPG

Picture attached

James Morella SCC Operator Metro-North (914) 461-0525

From: Morrella, James Sent: Monday, January 19, 2015 6:07PM To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael {MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Sean Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Feeney, Michael; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: PROTESTERS .

There are about SO protesters GCT Main Concourse by Information booth. We will send a snapshot once we get video back. Noticed them about ten minutes ago.

James Morella SCC Operator Metro-North (914) 461-0525

... -- .-·- ;... · !:"'".. ••• .... _ -- ·- --£.. - _:___ :. --:: ---- •· .

Montanino, Linda

From: Rehbein, Kim Sent: Monday, January 19, 2015 6:20 PM To: Rinaldi, Catherine Cc: Fleischer, Randall; Giulietti, Joseph; Ryan, Sean Subject: Re: Protestors Attachments: imagel.jpeg

[Ql, EJt Estimated at 100 now

On Jan 19, 2015, at 6:15 PM, Rinaldi, Catherine wrote:

Thanks. Still the typical routine? ·

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE smar1phone

Original message ------From: "Rehbein, Kim" Date:01/19/2015 5:58PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Fleischer, Randall" Cc: "Giulietti, Joseph" ,"Rinaldi, Catherine" ,"Ryan, Sean" Subject: Re: Protestors

Group is now at 50.

On Jan 19, 2015, at 5:54PM, Fleischer, Randall wrote:

Joel Cathy, We have about 20 protestors on the main floor at this time. Just began chanting. The usual routine.

Randy

Randall J. Fleischer Vice President Grand Central Terminal and Corporate Development MTA Metro No11h Railroad 212-340- 3153

Montanino, linda

From: Morrella, James Sent: Monday, January 19, 2015 6:22 PM Sean To: Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR); Metz, Michael; Neafsey, Daniel; Ryan, Tonja; Cc: Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Feeney, Michael; Joseph, Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; Maloney, Eugene; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; O'Brien, Thomas; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Santana, Jose; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: UPDATE ON PROTESTERS Attachments: 20150119_181309Jpg

There are now about 100. Some MTA PD in area. Around Information booth.

James Morella SCC Operator Metro-North (914) 461-0525

Montanino, Linda

From: Santana, Jose Sent: Friday, January 30, 2015 9:00 PM To: Ryan, Sean; Abrosikov, Sergey; Lee, Michael (MNR) Cc: Ballard, Joshua; Braun, Molly; Budde, Gavin; Burke, Ian; Cassese, Edmund; Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Dick, Linda; Joseph, Tonja; Kalmanson, Brad; Kirsch, Anne; Kudelka, James; Kupec, Nicholas; Maddock, Timothy; McDonald, Edward; Metz, Michael; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; Neafsey, Daniel; Peloso, Matthew; Repman, James; Riordan, Linda; Ruiz, Frank; Ryan, Sean; Sammon, Clare; Santana, Jose; Schwarz, Frederick; Spafford, Melissa; Streany, Joseph; Velez, Brandee; Vinzo, Christopher; Welch, William; Maloney, Eugene; Feeney, Michael; O'Brien, Thomas; Ciaramella, Anthony; Corrigan, Mark; DeJesus, Saturnine; Joseph, Tonja; Kudelka, James; Maddock, Timothy; McDonald, Edward; Morrella, James; Mullarkey, Daniel; Munson, Gerald; Repman, James; Ruiz, Frank; Schwarz, Frederick; Vinzo, Christopher Subject: Protestors

Small protest on main concourse.

Jose Santana Shift Supervisor Security Command Center 24 Hours: 914-461-0525

MTA Metro North Railroad