Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line. Environmental
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PROPOSED BAOJI-LANZHOU SECOND RAILWAY LINE. Public Disclosure Authorized ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT S,UMMARY E454 Volume 1 SUBMITTEDTO: THE WORLD BANK ;-->l 1818 H STREET WASHINGTON, Public Disclosure Authorized USA .. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~: Public Disclosure Authorized FILECOPY SUBMITTED BY: THE CENTEROF ENVIRONMENTALASSESSMENT AND ENI,INEERING OF THE SCIENTIFICRESEARCH INSTITUTE Public Disclosure Authorized RAILWAYDEPARTMENT OF THE MINISTRYOF RAILWAY BEIJING, CHINA AND AMEC EARTH & ENVIRONMENTALLIMITED CALGARY, ALBERTA March, 2001 1/1}71 /4 S, CEO2169 ENVIRONMENTALASSESSMENT SUMMARY FOR THE PROPOSEDBAOJI-LANZHOU SECOND RAILWAYLINE Submittedto: The World Bank Washington,DC Submittedby: The Center of Environmental Evaluation and Engineering of the ResearchAcademy of Railway Sciences of the Ministry of Railways Beijing,China and AMEC Earth & Environmental Limited Calgary,Alberta March 2001 CE02169 The World Bank Environmental Assessment Summary for the Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line March 2001 Compilationof ReportOrganized by: The Centerof EnvironmentEvaluation and Engineeringof The ResearchAcademy of RailwaySciences of The Ministryof Railways EIA LicenseGrade A No. 1021 Compilationof Reportwith the Participationof: First Surveyand DesignInstitute of The Ministryof Railways EIA LicenseGrade A No. 3704 SA\SEC\Project\CE02169\R-Mar-HM.doc Pagei The World Bank Environmental Assessment Summary for the Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line March 2001 Team Leader: Bai Xiaojun, Engineer EIA Certificate Number: Railway 0760 Li Jia Senior Engineer EIA Certificate Number: Gansu 02315 Team Membersfor the Sub-Projects: ;virbnrnonnt Factoar ;F 00 ,0 , *eilo!T , Ecology Xia Xianfang Engineer Gansu02316 Wei Jianfang Engineer Gansu02317 Noise Li Jia Senior Engineer Gansu02315 Noise Li Yaozeng AssociateResearch Fellow BeijingOO62 Li Jia Senior Engineer Gansu02315 Water ChengZehao AssociateResearch Fellow Railway0766 Gas ChengYanfei Senior Engineer Gansu02314 Electromagnetic ZhangChen AssociateResearch Fellow Railway0767 Solid Waste Material Du Pei Engineer Gansu02318 Public Participation Bai Xiaopjun Engineer Railway0760 LandAcquisition and Bai Xiaopjun Engineer Railway0760 Resettlement EnvironmentalEconomic ZhangFenzhan AssociateResearch Fellow Railway0758 ternatescenario SongYong Engineer Beijing0024 EnvironmentalRisk ZhangFenzhan AssociateResearch Fellow Railway0758 Assessment Measurement Li Jia Senior Engineer Gansu02315 Environmental Economic.. Lai Wenhong Engineer Railway0736 Benefitand cost analysis EnvironmentalManagement Lai Wenhong Engineer Railway0736 and supervisionPlan L S:\SEC\Project\CE02169\R-Mar-HM.doc Page ii The World Bank Environmental Assessment Summary for the Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line March 2001 TABLEOF CONTENTS PAGE 1.0 INTRODUCTION.................... 1 1.1 ProjectPlanning ............................................. 3 1.2 EnvironmentalAssessment Responsibility ............................................. 3 1.3 EnvironmentalImpact Assessment Process ........................................... 3 1.3.1 Reviewof Terms of Reference............................................. 3 1.3.2 EnvironmentalAssessment Examination Process .................................. 4 1.4 EnvironmentalProtection Measures ........................................... 6 1.4.1 World BankStandards ............................................. 6 1.4.2 EnvironmentalProtection Measures ............................................. 6 1.5 RegulatoryBasis and Standards............................................. 9 2.0 PROJECTDESCRIPTION ................... 14 2.1 ConstructionSchedule ............... 14 2.1.1 RailwayLine, Rail Bed and Track.......................... 14 2.1.2 Bridgesand Culverts.......................... 16 2.1.3 Tunnels.......................... 16 2.1.4 Borrow Pits and Spoil DisposalSites .......................... 16 2.1.5 Water and Soil Conservation.......................... 23 2.2 Stations................................. 23 2.2.1 Electricaland Communications................................ 23 2.3 ConstructionCamps ................................ 24 2.4 Capacityof Passengersand Freight .. ..............................24 2.5 LocomotiveStations, Maintenance Facilities ................................ 24 2.5.1 Operationand Maintenance................................ 24 2.5.2 Rolling Stock Facility................................ 24 2.6 PowerSupply and Communications ................................ 24 2.7 Water and Sewage................................ 25 2.8 Garbage Disposal................................ 25 2.9 Roads................................. 26 2.10 Socio-EconomicAspects ................................ 26 3.0 ANALYSISOF ALTERNATIVES............................................ 27 3.1 ComparisonBetween Existing Railway Alternatives ............................ 27 S:.SEC\Project\CE02169\R-Mar-HM.doc The World Bank Environmental Assessment Summary for the Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line March 2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS (con't) PAGE 3.2 Comparisonof Railwayand Highway.................................................. 27 3.3 Comparisonof AlternativeRouting Options along the BoalanLine .................... 27 4.0 ANALYSISOF ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTS ................................... 30 4.1 Methods........................................... 30 4.1.1 Scopeof Assessment........................................... 30 4.2 Summaryof Impacts............................................ 41 4.2.1 ImpactsAssociated with the ConstructionPhase ................................ 41 4.2.2 ImpactsAssociated with the OperationalPhase .................................. 42 4.2.3 Analysisof Impacts........................................... 43 4.3 AIR QUALITY........................................... 44 4.3.1 Construction........................................... 44 4.3.2 Operation........................................... 44 4.4 Noise........................................... 44 4.4.1 Construction........................................... 44 4.4.2 Operation........................................... 45 4.5 Vibration........................................... 51 4.5.1 Construction........................................... 51 4.5.2 Operation........................................... 51 4.6 ElectromagneticLevels ............................................ 52 4.7 Surfaceand GroundwaterResources ........................................... 52 4.7.1 Construction........................................... 52 4.7.2 Operation........................................... 54 4.8 Geology........................................... 55 4.8.1 Construction........................................... 56 4.9 Topography,Geomorphology and Soil ...................................... 56 4.9.1 Construction........................................... 56 4.9.2 ErosionControl Measures........................................... 57 4.10 Vegetation............................................ 58 4.10.1 Construction........................................... 58 4.11 Wildlife and Fisheries........................................... 58 4.12 ResourceUse ........................................... 58 4.12.1 Land Expropriation........................................... 58 4.12.2 Industryand Mining........................................... 59 4.12.3 PowerSupply ........................................... 59 4.12.4 Effects of Constructionon UrbanTransportation ................................. 60 5.0 HISTORICALAND CULTURALRESOURCES ................................... 61 S:\SEC\Project\CE02169\R-Mar-HM-doc Page ii The World Bank Environmental Assessment Summary for the Proposed Baoji-Lanzhou Second Railway Line March 2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS (con't) PAGE 6.0 SOCIALIMPACT ASSESSMENT .................................................. 62 6.1 Effectsof ClosingRailway Stations .................................................... 62 6.2 Construction.................................................... 62 6.2.1 PositiveImpacts .................................................... 62 6.2.2 NegativeImpacts .................................................... 63 6.3 Operation.................................................... 63 6.3.1 Land Requisition,Removal and Resettlement..................................... 63 7.0 PUBLICPARTICIPATION ................................................. 65 7.1 Resultsof Surveys................................................. 65 7.2 Commentsand RecommendationsFom the Public........................................... 66 8.0 ENVIRONMENTALMONITORING AND CONTROLPROGRAM .. 68 8.1 Construction................................................. 68 8.2 Operation................................................. 69 8.2.1 Monitoringof Resettlement................................................. 70 8.2.2 Monitoringof SecondaryEnvironmental Impacts ................................. 70 9.0 ENVIRONMENTALMANAGEMENT AND TRAINING ................................ 72 9.1 Management................................................. 72 9.2 EnvironmentalManagement Training Plan ................................................. 72 10.0 ENVIRONMENTALRISK ASSESSMENT .......................................... 73 10.1 DesignStage ............................................ 73 10.2 ConstructionStage ............................................ 73 10.3 OperationStage ............................................ 74 LIST OF TABLES Table 1.5-1 Standardsfor EnvironmentalImpact Assessment ........................................ 10 Table 1.5-2 Noise LimitedValues