Jacques Derrida, Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology, and Grace M

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Jacques Derrida, Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology, and Grace M ONTOLOGIES OF VIOLENCE: JACQUES DERRIDA, MENNONITE PACIFIST EPISTEMOLOGY, AND GRACE M. JANTZEN’S DEATH AND THE DISPLACEMENT OF BEAUTY Ontologies of Violence: Jacques Derrida, Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology, and Grace M. Jantzen’s Death and the Displacement of Beauty By Maxwell Stephen Kennel, B.A., M.T.S. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy McMaster University © Copyright Maxwell Stephen Kennel, 2021. McMaster University DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (2021) Hamilton, Ontario, Canada (Religious Studies). TITLE: “Ontologies of Violence: Jacques Derrida, Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology, and Grace M. Jantzen’s Death and the Displacement of Beauty.” AUTHOR: Maxwell Stephen Kennel, B.A. (University of Waterloo), M.T.S. (University of Waterloo and Conrad Grebel University College). NUMBER OF PAGES: 300 pp. COMMITTEE: Dr. P. Travis Kroeker (supervisor), Dr. Dana Hollander, Dr. Morny Joy (University of Calgary), and Dr. Dawne McCance (external examiner, University of Manitoba). ii Lay Abstract This dissertation examines the early work of French philosopher Jacques Derrida (Chapter 1), debates between Mennonite philosophical theologians and John Milbank’s Radical Orthodoxy (Chapter 2), and the Death and the Displacement of Beauty trilogy by feminist philosopher of religion Grace M. Jantzen (Chapter 3). For Derrida, Jantzen, and certain Mennonite philosophical theologians the term “violence” is used to name ways of thinking, knowing, and speaking, rather than being restricted to the sphere of physical violations. This dissertation shows how these three sources each consider violence to be something that can inhere in ways of thinking about the world and our relation to it. iii Abstract This dissertation critically examines the ontological and epistemological significance of the concept of violence in French philosopher Jacques Derrida’s essay “Violence and Metaphysics” (Chapter 1), dialogues between Mennonite philosophical theologians who represent the Radical Reformation and John Milbank’s Radical Orthodoxy (Chapter 2), and the Death and the Displacement of Beauty trilogy by feminist philosopher of religion Grace Jantzen (Chapter 3). Although Derrida, Jantzen, and certain Mennonite philosophical theologians approach the problem of violence with very different concerns and frames of reference, each understand violence to have a distinctly ontological and epistemological character, while also suggesting that ontology and epistemology themselves are profoundly vulnerable to charges of violence. In Derrida’s essay “Violence and Metaphysics” language itself is imbricated in violence, and in their responses to John Milbank, Mennonite philosophical theologians Peter C. Blum and Chris K. Huebner situate their work both with and against Derrida’s supposed “ontology of violence” as they apply Christian pacifism to epistemology and seek to articulate an “ontology of peace.” In her late work in the Death and the Displacement of Beauty project, Grace Jantzen develops an epistemology that is similar to that of Blum and Huebner, while critiquing what she understands to be Derrida’s equivocation of linguistic with physical violence, all as part of her argument that the cultural habitus of the west is founded on an obsession with death that violently displaces natality with mortality. In bringing together these three sources, this dissertation uses “violence” as a diagnostic concept to assess the priorities and values of its users. Considering violence to be defined by the violation of value-laden boundaries, this study of three ontologies of violence interprets and critiques the values that Derrida’s deconstruction, philosophical Mennonite pacifism, and Jantzen’s critique of displacement seek to further and protect against violation. iv Acknowledgments I want to acknowledge the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada for funding from the Joseph-Armand Bombardier Canadian Graduate Scholarship (2018-2021) and the Ontario Graduate Fellowship (2017-2018). I would also like to express my gratitude to the Toronto Mennonite Theological Centre and Conrad Grebel University College for twice awarding me the A. James Reimer Scholarship for my Mennonite work (2016, 2020). Although words fail, I want to begin by thanking my supervisor Travis Kroeker, not only for treating my dissertation with attention and care, but for reaching out to me before I began my degree and affirming this project (which I had nearly given up on). I am so grateful that Travis showed up when he did and walked me through my degree with supportive conversations, late- night emails, and challenging seminar discussions. The various comments, suggestions, and critiques provided by my committee were also of great help to me as I developed (and continue to develop) this dissertation. I am grateful to Dana Hollander for her close attention to detail, to Morny Joy for her insights into the work of Grace M. Jantzen, and to my external examiner Dawne McCance for her important questions about the framing of the dissertation. Each contributed to an enjoyable and thought-provoking defense that continues to inspire me. Throughout my degree the Religious Studies department at McMaster provided a unique home for my interdisciplinary interests, and I am grateful that I could study Augustine, Plato, Nietzsche, Jewish philosophy, methodology, Mennonites, political theology, and the philosophy of religion, all under its generous and pluralistic auspices. I am especially grateful to Dan Machiela, Mark Rowe, and Philippa Carter for the opportunities they afforded me. I am also thankful for my colleagues Zac Klassen, Gerald Ens, Jeremy Cohen, Matthew Lee, Jonas Brandt, Anna Phipps-Burton, Rachel Matheson, and Rob Jones, who each provided humor, insight, and conversation at key moments. I want to further acknowledge and thank Kyle Gingerich Hiebert and the Toronto Mennonite Theological Centre for providing a forum for my work in 2017/2019. This dissertation was written in many places, and for the dear friends who made those places feel like home I can never be thankful enough. Tyler and Chalsi Campbell (Dayton), Jess del Rosso (Waterloo), Seija Grant, Liz and Michael Foo, Jorian van den Helm and Carlyn Hopkins (Toronto), Faith and Amos Shelley (Hanover), Jenn Neufeld and Rachael Lake (Guelph), and the members of the Niagara Anabaptist colloquium (especially Mike Driedger!) – each made my life so much better as I was reading, writing, and thinking. May there be many more conversations to come! Several people intervened at key moments to make the continuation of my degree possible by providing me with employment and material aid, most importantly Mary Lapp, Chuck Roth, and Joe Dumering. Without their help I would not have been able to finish my degree, and words cannot express my gratitude for their generosity. I am deeply thankful for the support that my parents Steve and Shirley, and my brother Reid, have shown me on the long road that led to the completion of this degree. Without our conversations around the dinner table about politics, religion, culture, and media, I would not have found or stayed with my love for this work. Thank you for supporting me and providing a home for us during our perpetual periods of interregnum. However, human beings can only do so much, and so I thank Atlas and Luna for their reassuring creaturely presence during long hours of writing. But most of all, these pages are dedicated to Amy, who – amidst many ordeals on a long and winding path – waited impatiently with me and shared so many therapeutic insights in our conversations about everything that these pages can only gesture toward. uxori omnia mea v TABLE OF CONTENTS Lay Abstract Abstract Acknowledgments INTRODUCTION pp. 1-23 Outline What is Violence? CHAPTER 1: Violence in Jacques Derrida’s “Violence and Metaphysics” pp. 24-101 The Early Derrida A Commentary on Violence in “Violence and Metaphysics” Reading “Violence and Metaphysics” with “Force of Law” and “Préjuges” Situating Violence in Derrida CHAPTER 2: Mennonite Pacifist Epistemology and Ontological Peace pp. 102-197 Radical Reformation Radical Orthodoxy Mennonites, Milbank, and Derrida John Milbank’s Ontological Peace The Philosophical Turn in Mennonite Pacifism Radical Reformation Responses Derridean Violence, Mennonite Peace CHAPTER 3: Grace Jantzen’s Critique of Violence in Death and the Displacement of Beauty pp. 199-261 The Problem of Metanarratives Jantzen and the Mennonites Jantzen’s Critique of Derrida Violence in Death and the Displacement of Beauty Violence and Displacement Violence, History, and Master Narratives History and Displacement CONCLUSION: Deconstruction, Pacifism, Displacement pp. 262-278 Bibliography pp. 279-294 vi Ph.D. Thesis – Maxwell Kennel – McMaster University – Department of Religious Studies. INTRODUCTION Outline This dissertation critically examines the ontological and epistemological significance of the concept of violence in French philosopher Jacques Derrida’s essay “Violence and Metaphysics,” in dialogues between Anglican theologian John Milbank and Mennonite philosophical theologians Chris K. Huebner and Peter C. Blum, and in the Death and the Displacement of Beauty trilogy by feminist philosopher of religion Grace M. Jantzen. Although Derrida, the Mennonites, and Jantzen use the term “violence” within different academic disciplines and with different priorities, each understands violence to refer to something that has a distinctly
Recommended publications
  • Death - the Eternal Truth of Life
    © 2018 JETIR March 2018, Volume 5, Issue 3 www.jetir.org (ISSN-2349-5162) DEATH - THE ETERNAL TRUTH OF LIFE The „DEATH‟ that comes from the German word „DEAD‟ which means tot, while the word „kill‟ is toten, which literally means to make dead. Likewise in Dutch ,‟DEAD‟ is dood and “kill” is doden. In Swedish, “DEAD” is dod and „Kill‟ is doda. In English the same process resulted in the word “DEADEN”, where the suffix “EN” means “to cause to be”. We all know that the things which has life is going to be dead in future anytime any moment. So, the sentence we know popularly that “Man is mortal”. The sources of life comes into human body when he/she is in the womb of mother. The active meeting of sperm and eggs, it create a new life in the woman‟s overy, and the woman carried the foetus with 10 months and ten days to given birth of a new born baby . When the baby comes out from the pathway of the vagina of his/her mother, then his/her first cry is depicted that the new born baby is starting to adjustment of of the newly changing environment . For that very first day, the baby‟s survivation is rairtained by his/her primary environment. But the tendency of death is started also. In any time of any space the human baby have to accept death. Not only in the case of human being, but the animals, trees, species, reptailes has also the probability of death. The above mentioned live behind are also survival for the fittest.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Evolutionary Thanatology of Grief, with Special Reference to Nonhuman Primates
    Comparative Evolutionary Thanatology of Grief, with Special Reference to Nonhuman Primates James R. Anderson Kyoto University Abstract: The impact of the dead on the living is considered from an evolutionary comparative perspective. After a brief review of young children’s developing understanding of the concept of death, the interest of looking at how other species respond to dying and dead individuals is introduced. Solutions to managing dead individuals in social insect communities are described, highlighting evolutionarily ancient, effective behavioral mechanisms that most likely function with no emotional component. I then review examples of responses to dying and dead individuals in nonhuman primates, with particular reference to continued transport and caretaking of dead infants, responses to traumatic deaths in wild populations of monkeys and apes, and a detailed case report of the peaceful death of an old female chimpanzee surrounded by members of her group. The emotional correlates of primates’ reactions to bereavement are discussed, and some suggested evolutionarily shared responses to the dead are proposed. Key words: thanatology, death, dying, emotions, social insects, nonhuman primates, chimpanzees Thanatology can be broadly defined as the study of death and dying, and researchers from a wide range of disciplines are thanatologists. Among others, studies in medicine, biology, psychology, anthropology, palaeontology, sociology and philosophy all contribute new knowledge about the antecedents, causes, and consequences of death (e.g. Exley 2004; Haldane 2007; Klarsfeld et al. 2003; Kübler-Ross 1969; Pettitt 2011; Powner et al. 1996). Concerning people’s understanding of death, psychologists generally agree that the typical human adult’s concept of death comprises at least four sub-concepts or “components” (Speece 1995).
    [Show full text]
  • Catherine A. Wright
    In the Darkness Grows the Green: The Promise of a New Cosmological Horizon of Meaning Within a Critical Inquiry of Human Suffering and the Cross by Catherine A. Wright A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Regis College and the Theology Department of the Toronto School of Theology in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Theology awarded by the University of St. Michael's College © Copyright by Catherine A. Wright 2015 In The Darkness Grows the Green: The Promise of a New Cosmological Horizon of Meaning Within a Critical Inquiry of Human Suffering and the Cross Catherine A. Wright Doctor of Philosophy in Theology Regis College and the University of St. Michael’s College 2015 Abstract Humans have been called “mud of the earth,”i organic stardust animated by the Ruah of our Creator,ii and microcosms of the macrocosm.iii Since we now understand in captivating detail how humanity has emerged from the cosmos, then we must awaken to how humanity is “of the earth” in all the magnificence and brokenness that this entails. This thesis will demonstrate that there are no easy answers nor complete theological systems to derive satisfying answers to the mystery of human suffering. Rather, this thesis will uncover aspects of sacred revelation offered in and through creation that could mould distinct biospiritual human imaginations and cultivate the Earth literacy required to construct an ecological theological anthropology (ETA). It is this ecocentric interpretive framework that could serve as vital sustenance and a vision of hope for transformation when suffering befalls us.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychopathology-Madjirova.Pdf
    NADEJDA PETROVA MADJIROVA PSYCHOPATHOLOGY psychophysiological and clinical aspects PLOVDIV 2005 I devote this book to all my patients that shared with me their intimate problems. © Nadejda Petrova Madjirova, 2015 PSYCHOPATHOLOGY: PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGICAL AND CLINICAL ASPECTS Prof. Dr. Nadejda Petrova Madjirova, MD, PhD, DMSs Reviewer: Prof. Rumen Ivandv Stamatov, PhD, DPS Prof. Drozdstoj Stoyanov Stoyanov, PhD, MD Design: Nadejda P. Madjirova, MD, PhD, DMSc. Prepress: Galya Gerasimova Printed by ISBN I. COMMON ASPECTS IN PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGY “A wise man ought to realize that health is his most valuable possession” Hippocrates C O N T E N T S I. Common aspects in psychophysiology. ..................................................1 1. Some aspects on brain structure. ....................................................5 2. Lateralisation of the brain hemispheres. ..........................................7 II. Experimental Psychology. ..................................................................... 11 1. Ivan Petrovich Pavlov. .................................................................... 11 2. John Watson’s experiments with little Albert. .................................15 III. Psychic spheres. ...................................................................................20 1. Perception – disturbances..............................................................21 2. Disturbances of Will .......................................................................40 3. Emotions ........................................................................................49
    [Show full text]
  • Undergraduate Research Journal 2015.Indb
    ANTHROPOLOGY Deviant Burial and Fear of the Dead Zach Udell All living things end in death one day; that is the inevitable fact of living. While humans do not have the physical ability to prevent death, they tend to find incredible ways to handle it. Humans adapt to numerous obstacles and hardships that they encounter throughout their lives. Humanities ability to adapt to the numerous and diverse environments have made it possible for our species to expand and create the societies that we live in today. Despite all these achievements, one thing that humans have not yet been able to overcome is the end of life, death. Throughout human history, societies have mourned the loss of loved ones in unique ways that allows them to cope with the pain of that loss. However, some of the ways in which the dead have been laid to rest calls for for deeper investigation and analysis. In Eastern Europe, bodies have been found with their arms or legs bound, their heads and limbs removed, stones placed on top of the body or in their mouth; in so different many ways that it asks the question, why were these people buried in this way? The discovery of these bodies in unique circumstances brings about many questions surrounding the deceased and the society of that time. How the dead are handled is an important means of understanding culture and how it functions. Looking at atypical burial patterns is an effective way of seeking out the subtle nuances found in each culture. Burials that differ from the norm could be argued as having a meaning other than for mourning or respecting the dead.
    [Show full text]
  • Fear Reduction Jeanette E
    Cardinal Stritch University Stritch Shares Master's Theses, Capstones, and Projects 1-1-1979 Fear reduction Jeanette E. Coleman Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.stritch.edu/etd Part of the Special Education and Teaching Commons Recommended Citation Coleman, Jeanette E., "Fear reduction" (1979). Master's Theses, Capstones, and Projects. 553. https://digitalcommons.stritch.edu/etd/553 This Research Paper is brought to you for free and open access by Stritch Shares. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master's Theses, Capstones, and Projects by an authorized administrator of Stritch Shares. For more information, please contact [email protected]. FEAR REDUCTION by Jeanette E. Coleman A RESEARCH PAPER Submitted in PARTIAL FULFILLMENT of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Education (Education of Learning Disabled Children) at the Cardinal Stritch College Milwaukee, Wisconsin 1979 Fear Reduction This research paper has been approved for the Graduate Committee of the Cardinal Stritch College by Fear Reduction i i Table of Contents Acknowledgments i i i Chapter I Introduction A. Definitions 2 B. Scope and limitations 3 C. Summary 4 Chapter II Review of Research 4 A. I nt rod uc t ion 4 B. Anxiety 5 c. Basic elements of systematic 6 desensitization D. Hierarchies 9 E. Implementation 10 F. Examples 11 G. School phobia 14 H. Modifications 18 Chapter Ill Summary 20 References 22 Appendixes A. Relaxation technique 26 B. list of phobias 29 Fear Reduction i i i Acknowledgments My gratitude goes to: Sister Johanna Flanagan who touched my 1 ife in a very special way.
    [Show full text]
  • A CATHOLIC CRITICISM of E. E. CUMMINGS a Study of Form
    UNIVERSITY D-OTTAWA ~ ECOLE DES GRADUES A CATHOLIC CRITICISM OF E. E. CUMMINGS c ', i- •J. f » ifX. • A Study of Form, Technique and Content in one of the Controversial Poets of Our Time from the Traditional Christian Viewpoint* By Stephen Breen Thesis presented to the Faculty of Arts of the University of Ottawa through the Department of English as partial fulfill­ ment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. 6. fWf Ottawa, Canada, 1958 AjU*A^&->w( \J \ 5 «• Q~\^- UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA - SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES UMI Number: DC53307 INFORMATION TO USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleed-through, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. UMI® UMI Microform DC53307 Copyright 2011 by ProQuest LLC All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 UNIVERSITE D-OTTAWA ~ ECOLE DES GRADUES ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis topic was selected under the guidance of the Chairman of the English Department, Professor Emmett 0'Grady, and executed under the guidance of Dr. Paul Marcotte in its initial stages, with Dr. Brian Robinson directing its organization and conclusion.
    [Show full text]
  • Kaznakov, Vladimir (2013) Treatment of the "Special" Dead in the Early Middle Ages: Anglo-Saxon and Slavic Perspectives
    Kaznakov, Vladimir (2013) Treatment of the "special" dead in the early middle ages: Anglo-Saxon and Slavic perspectives. PhD thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/4368/ Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Treatment of the "special" dead in the Early Middle Ages: Anglo-Saxon and Slavic Perspectives By Vladimir Kaznakov A dissertation submitted in part requirement for the degree of PhD in History. May 2013 Contents: Acknowledgement page ii Abstract iii List of figures v Introduction 2 1. "Unusual" burials among the Anglo-Saxons 55 2. “Unusual” burials among the Slavs 124 3. The Restless Dead in the Primary Sources 175 Conclusion 205 Appendix: Catalog of the graves 234 Bibliography 255 Acknowledgments In the first place I want to thank to all staff of the Glasgow University, especially to the members of the Department of Medieval History - especially Julia Smith, Stuart Airlie, Matthew Strickland, Andrew Roach and Graeme Small. I have a particular debt of gratitude to Marilyn Dunn, who read the first drafts of my dissertation and gave advice and also criticism when needed.
    [Show full text]
  • On Neolithic Funerary Practices: Were There “Necrophobic” Manipulations in 5Th-4Th Millennium BC Arabia?
    On Neolithic funerary practices: were there “necrophobic” manipulations in 5th-4th millennium BC Arabia? Vincent Charpentier and Sophie Méry Summary This paper reviews the evidence for Neolithic burial practices in SE Arabia, focusing in particular on sites in the Ja’alan region of eastern Oman. Attention is given to the nature of material buried with human remains, including jewellery and, most interestingly, the bones and shells of green turtles in the burials of Ra’s al-Hamra 5 and 10. The paper concludes with a discussion of the possible evidence for “necrophobia” at the 5th millennium BC Neolithic necropolis of Suwayh 1. Introduction work in Arabia today tends to demonstrate that beyond their sepulchral role, these tombs are above all the In the Persian Gulf, archaeological research of the past affirmation of the living and the marker of a new social fifty years has concentrated on the Bronze Age, on the order (Cleuziou 2006). We know less whether the Dilmun and Magan cultures, and their relations with the preferred location of necropolises on high points predates regions located between Mesopotamia and the Indus the early Bronze Age. However, beginning in the 5th Valley. Archaeologists have paid less attention to the late millennium, they occupy knolls or promontories, as at prehistory of the Gulf, except in relation to exchange Ra’s al-Khabbah, Ruwayz, Suwayh, Ra’s al-Hamra and between this region and the Ubaid culture of lower Wadi Shab in Oman and UAQ-2 in the United Arab Mesopotamia. Emirates. They are also sometimes found at the foot of jebels and near springs, as at Buhais-18 or Faye NE-15, Excavations concerning the Neolithic period in Arabia two necropolises which are, with that of Suwayh 1, the are rare; twenty sites at most have been excavated oldest in the Oman peninsula.
    [Show full text]
  • Deviancy and Disability in the Human Past
    Eileen M. Murphy, ed.. Deviant Burial in the Archaeological Record. Oxford: Oxbrow Books, 2008. xviii + 244 pp. $60.00, paper, ISBN 978-1-84217-338-1. Reviewed by William Southwell-Wright Published on H-Disability (October, 2013) Commissioned by Iain C. Hutchison (University of Glasgow) The last two decades have seen scholars in‐ ment and disability for periods that offer little creasingly focus on aspects of premodern disabili‐ other evidence. ty history, with an especial focus on medieval Eu‐ The papers in this volume originate from a rope and the classical world. This work has, how‐ session held at the eleventh annual meeting of the ever, remained largely within the bounds of his‐ European Association of Archaeologists in Cork, torical rather than archaeological research. That Ireland, in 2005. The focus of that session was on archaeologists have made relatively little contri‐ atypical and deviant burial phenomena applied to bution to current debates is somewhat puzzling individuals from a wide range of past human soci‐ given the wide range of osteological examples of eties, which, as Eileen M. Murphy states in the in‐ individuals with impairments that archaeologists troduction, “can include criminals, women who and paleopathologists can draw on in the aid of died during childbirth, unbaptized infants, people disability history. Besides an edition of the Ar‐ with disabilities, and supposed revenants, to chaeological Review from Cambridge (1999) and name but a few” (p. xii). As such, several of the pa‐ Jane Hubert’s edited volume Madness, Disability pers in the volume will be of less interest to dis‐ and Social Exclusion: The Archaeology and An‐ ability historians than others.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Modern Interments from Drawsko, Poland
    Antiquity http://journals.cambridge.org/AQY Additional services for Antiquity: Email alerts: Click here Subscriptions: Click here Commercial reprints: Click here Terms of use : Click here Buried with sickles: early modern interments from Drawsko, Poland Marek Polcyn and Elżbieta Gajda Antiquity / Volume 89 / Issue 348 / December 2015, pp 1373 - 1387 DOI: 10.15184/aqy.2015.129, Published online: 07 December 2015 Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0003598X15001295 How to cite this article: Marek Polcyn and Elżbieta Gajda (2015). Buried with sickles: early modern interments from Drawsko, Poland. Antiquity, 89, pp 1373-1387 doi:10.15184/aqy.2015.129 Request Permissions : Click here Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/AQY, IP address: 129.234.252.67 on 07 Dec 2015 Buried with sickles: early modern interments from Drawsko, Poland Marek Polcyn1 &Elzbieta˙ Gajda2 Research In Central Europe, medieval and early modern burials sometimes contain iron sickles placed on the body or in direct contact with the deceased. Previous interpretations have Drawsko considered them as markers of social status Warsaw or occupation, or as magical and apotropaic. Detailed analysis of sickle burials from a cemetery at Drawsko in Poland leads to a discussion of demonology beliefs, dual faith and a resurgence in paganism following the Counter-Reformation. The results illustrate how the sickle might have served as an indicator of social identity, the nature of the N 0 km 300 individual’s death and the way the deceased was perceived within their community. Keywords: Poland, Early Modern period, funerary rites, sickle burials, demonology, folklore Introduction Iron sickles with semi-circular and elliptical blades were common agricultural tools used to harvest grasses and cereals in Central Europe from the tenth to thirteenth centuries AD; they are frequently found in archaeological contexts of this period (Niesiołowska-Wedzka˛ 1975: 173).
    [Show full text]
  • Cambridge Archaeological Journal Governing from the Grave: Vampire
    Cambridge Archaeological Journal http://journals.cambridge.org/CAJ Additional services for Cambridge Archaeological Journal: Email alerts: Click here Subscriptions: Click here Commercial reprints: Click here Terms of use : Click here Governing from the Grave: Vampire Burials and Social Order in Post- medieval Poland Tracy K. Betsinger and Amy B. Scott Cambridge Archaeological Journal / Volume 24 / Issue 03 / October 2014, pp 467 - 476 DOI: 10.1017/S0959774314000754, Published online: 03 November 2014 Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0959774314000754 How to cite this article: Tracy K. Betsinger and Amy B. Scott (2014). Governing from the Grave: Vampire Burials and Social Order in Post-medieval Poland. Cambridge Archaeological Journal, 24, pp 467-476 doi:10.1017/S0959774314000754 Request Permissions : Click here Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/CAJ, IP address: 137.141.221.89 on 07 Nov 2014 Governing from the Grave: Vampire Burials and Social Order in Post-medieval Poland Tracy K. Betsinger & Amy B. Scott Mortuary treatments are ways in which archaeologists can learn about the culture and lifestyle of past societies, in terms of how they view the dead. The dead, however, can continue to play a role in the lives of the living, which may also be reflected in funerary rites and burial treatments. This article explores the social agency of the dead, focusing on the ‘vampire burials’ of the post-medieval Polish site of Drawsko 1. These burials, identified through their grave goods, provide a unique opportunity to learn how vampire folklore and the deceased ‘vampires’ influenced the living, most notably as ways to encourage social order, as an explanation for the unknown, and as an economic commitment.
    [Show full text]