Ternary Nitride Materials: Fundamentals and Emerging Device Applications Arxiv:2010.08058V1 [Cond-Mat.Mtrl-Sci] 15 Oct 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ternary Nitride Materials: Fundamentals and Emerging Device Applications Ann L. Greenaway,1 Celeste L. Melamed,2;1 M. Brooks Tellekamp,1 Rachel Woods-Robinson,3;4;1 Eric S. Toberer,2 James R. Neilson5 and Adele C. Tamboli1* 1Materials and Chemistry Science and Technology Directorate, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, Colorado, United States, 80401 email: [email protected] 2Department of Physics, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, Colorado, United States, 80401 3Applied Science and Technology Graduate Group, University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, California, United States, 97402 4Energy Technologies Area, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, United States, 94720 5Department of Chemistry, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, United States, 80523 Keywords ternary nitride, structural chemistry, metastability, nitride synthesis, optoelectronics, battery Abstract Interest in inorganic ternary nitride materials has grown rapidly over the past few decades, as their diversity of chemistries and structures make them appealing for a variety of applications. Due to synthetic challenges posed by the stability of N2, the number of predicted ni- tride compounds dwarfs those that have been synthesized, offering a breadth of opportunity for exploration. This review summarizes the fundamental properties and structural chemistry of ternary nitrides, leveraging metastability and the impact of nitrogen chemical potential. A discussion of prevalent defects, both detrimental and beneficial, is followed by a survey of synthesis techniques and their interplay with arXiv:2010.08058v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 15 Oct 2020 metastability. Throughout the review, we highlight applications (such as solid-state lighting, electrochemical energy storage, and electronic devices) in which ternary nitrides show particular promise. 1 Contents 1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................ 2 2. FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES AND STRUCTURAL CHEMISTRY ..................................... 3 2.1. Nitrogen in the Solid State ............................................................................. 4 2.2. Cation Chemistries ...................................................................................... 4 2.3. Structural Chemistries .................................................................................. 5 2.4. Metastability ............................................................................................ 6 3. DEFECTS .................................................................................................... 8 3.1. Intrinsic Defects ......................................................................................... 8 3.2. Cation disorder .......................................................................................... 11 3.3. Extrinsic Defects ........................................................................................ 11 3.4. Extended Defects ....................................................................................... 13 4. SYNTHESIS OF TERNARY NITRIDES .................................................................... 13 4.1. Controlling Nitrogen Chemical Potential, µ(N) ........................................................ 14 4.2. Bulk Synthesis and Crystal Growth ..................................................................... 14 4.3. Thin Film Synthesis ..................................................................................... 17 4.4. Integration with Binary Compounds .................................................................... 18 4.5. Challenges and Promise in Ternary Nitride Synthesis .................................................. 20 5. CONCLUSIONS .............................................................................................. 21 1. INTRODUCTION Nitride materials surged in importance over the 20th century as numerous applications were identified from light emitting diodes, lasers, and power electronics, to superconductors and hard coatings. As the utility of nitrides increased, so did the need for broader structure- property tunability, spurring the development of ternary nitride research. The nitrogen Ternary inorganic atom in the solid state presents both a promise and a challenge: its strong bonds lead nitride: A compound to compelling materials properties and long experimental lifetimes, but make synthesis consisting of two challenging due to the relative inertness of N2. Despite the prevalence of nitrogen on Earth metal cations and (1), there are few reported ternary nitrides compared to ternary oxides, making this a the nitrogen anion. This review focuses promising field for research (2, 3). on emerging Ternary nitrides were sparsely studied from the 1950s through the 1980s (see Figure compounds in this 1a,c), with early work by a handful of research groups in studies limited to synthesis and class rather than fundamental structural characterization (4{7). In the 1990s, interest in ternary nitrides heavily investigated increased as techniques such as solid state metathesis, ball milling in a nitrogen atmosphere, alloys such as microwave-generated nitrogen plasmas and novel molecular and oxide precursors were used InxGa1−xN. in exploratory syntheses (8{14). This expansion has continued into the 21st century, with progress in both the development of previously synthesized nitrides for applications varying from hydrogen storage to photovoltaic absorbers and light-emitting diodes (LEDs) (15{17), as well as the continued search for new ternary nitrides, driven by the rise of computational materials prediction and discovery (2, 3, 18). Interest in ternary nitrides has led to a commensurate increase in their elemental diversity (Figure 1b), expanding this space to an exciting array of potential chemistries. In this review, we highlight how the diversity of the nitride chemistry enables a wide breadth of structures and properties, reaching beyond established application spaces where binary nitrides have historically been used. New applications are emerging in which ternary 2 Greenaway et al. Figure 1 (a) A timeline of important events in nitride research divided between materials discovery and developments in applications. (b) A heat map of the frequency of elements in fully-ordered ternary nitrides as reported in the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD). Compounds where nitrogen was not the sole anion were removed from the list. (c) A histogram of all experimentally-synthesized binary and ternary nitride compounds (with nitrogen as the sole anion) over time, from the ICSD. Each compound refers to a unique crystal structure, and the compound's year refers to the earliest report of each compound. Additional information for all sections can be found in Section S2 of the SI. [**Note to Annual Reviews: We created this figure for this article; it is not based on any previously published image.**] nitrides can uniquely serve, such as batteries and phosphors. Many of these new potential applications are still theoretical or early stage: there is a huge opportunity space for device- oriented materials research in ternary nitrides. We highlight the unusual metastability of ternary nitrides and their ability to be integrated into hybrid devices with binary nitrides. We discuss how the particular defect chemistry of ternary nitrides plays into properties, such as cation site disorder and anion vacancies, which leads to some challenges and some opportunities for applications. 2. FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES AND STRUCTURAL CHEMISTRY Inorganic ternary nitrides span a broad range of compositions (Figure 1b) and stoichiome- tries, yielding a commensurate breadth of properties. This chemical diversity can be traced back to the unusual properties of nitrogen. In the following, we discuss the solid-state chemistry of nitrides, addressing the behavior of nitrogen as well as cation chemistries and metastability, and highlighting recent examples of compounds that continue to expand our understanding of these materials. www.annualreviews.org • Ternary Nitrides 3 Figure 2 (a) Comparison of electronegativity and hardness of common anions relative to the values for nitrogen. (b) Comparison of chemical distributions of ternary nitrides across materials databases. Only unique compounds are counted across all of the Materials Project (MP), thermodynamically \stable" compounds in MP (Ehull = 0 eV/atom) and the experimental ICSD. Further details can be found in Section S3 of the SI. [**Note to Annual Reviews: We created this figure for this article; it is not based on any previously published image.**] 2.1. Nitrogen in the Solid State Chemical hardness: Quantification of the To understand the nitrogen anion, it is illustrative to compare it to other non-metal el- soft/hard acid/base ements. Figure 2a highlights electronegativity and absolute hardness across the p-block concept, where soft elements. Nitrogen is very electronegative (comparable to Cl, but less than O and F) (19), acids are acceptor with its electronegativity arising from its poorly shielded nucleus. This also drives nitrogen atoms with large, diffuse, polarizable to be the hardest element of the anion-forming main group elements (20). This high chem- electron clouds and ical hardness and intermediate electronegativity give rise to nitrogen's unique properties, easily excited outer where it can form high-coordination ionic compounds but also form covalent bonds as a electrons; hard acids result of