PSYCHIATRIC ASPECTS OF WICKEDNESS

The Psychology of Wickedness: and Sadism by J. REID MELOY, PhD 19th century German psychiatry. In that con­ text, such a patient would have been labeled a "constitutional psychopathic inferior": a phrase ecause I come from a long line of that itself interweaves both the Lombrosian Presbyterian ministers and have notion of a bad seed and the common moral judg­ • myself earned a graduate degree in ment that such people are less than human.3 A theology, I approach the question of century later, a substantial and growing body of mwickedness in psychology with an abundance of research argues that habitual criminality does, curiosity, but perhaps an insufficient humility. in fact, have a herit.able genetic loading.4 For wickedness, or evil, is outside the paradigm Following the classic and resurrective work of science, and, I think, should remain so. It is, of Cleckley,5 psychopathy has been carefully instead, the default of morality, or moral choice, and empirically defined by Hare6 as a constel­ and occupies the paradoxic position of being lation of traits and behaviors characterized by known to the science of psychology, yet not of it. two factors: (1) a callous and remorseless disre­ In the clinical practices of psychiatry and gard for the rights and feelings of others, and psychology, moreover, we cannot avoid occa· (2) a pattern of chronic antisocial behavior. This sionally coming face to face with patients who two·factor loading can be reliably assessed stimulate in us the thought that they are using the 20-item Psychopathy Checklist­ mean, wicked, or in some cases ra (Hebrew for Revised. 7 Such an assessment requires both a evil). Such patients live, in Oscar Wilde's clinical interview and scrutiny of independent words, "to give rebellion its fascination, and historical data, because of the mendacity of disobedience its charm," and they may truly such patients. At a certain quantitative thresh­ frighten us as clinicians. Fortunately, their old, the severe. psychopath can be clinically numbers appear to be few, because we have identified, and predictive validity studies indi­ now entered the diagnostic and psychodynam­ cate that the construct is not useless psycho­ ic landscape of the evil-doers, the wicked babble. Psychopaths are not amenable to treat­ ones-in psychology: psychopaths and sadists. ment,S and in one study were found to be more If we think about the psychology of wicked­ violent 10 years after immersion in a therapeu­ ness, these are the people we must study and tic community before release 9 They are also understand, yet fear. more dangerous than other criminals, and habitually engage in predatory, rather than THE PSYCHOPATH affective, violence. lO The former refers to The construct psychopathy was disavowed planned, purposeful, and emotionless violence, with the publication of the Diagnostic and usually toward strangers. The latter describes Statistical Manual, 2nd edition (DSM-Il),l but the reactive, emotional, and defensive violence has regained a tenuous foothold in DSM·rv.2 that could be described as the garden-variety Subsumed by the psychodiagnosis of antisocial hurtful aggression that mostly male members personality disorder, it is a much older and more of our species do, on occasion. Usually the vic­ clinically complex term that originated in late tims and perpetrators of affective violence are bonded to some degree. 1l In maximum security prisons, approximately three fourths of individ­ Dr, Meloy is Associate Clinical Professor of Psychiatry, uals will meet criteria for antisocial personality University of California, San Diego, and Chief, Court Services, Forensic Mental Health Division, San Diego County. disorder (according to DSM-IV), but only one Address reprint requests to J. Reid Meloy, PhD, 964 Fifth third of these individuals, at most, will be Ave" Ste.409, San Diego, CA 92101. psychopaths. 12

630 Psychiatric Annals 27:9/September 1997 Some of the psychodynamics of the psy­ The third psychodynamic of the psychopath chopath bring us closer to what we see as their that is often a facet of "wickedness" is his or her evil, or their wish to destroy goodness. Psycho­ of others. Psychopaths are chronic paths are aggressively narcissistic, and this liars, and research indicates that clinicians are aspect of their character pathology is often most likely to be misled by the special skill we expressed behaviorally by the repetitive deval­ think we possess to detect lying. 18 The psy­ uation of others, not predominantly in , chopath for many reasons, the most common as we see in narcissistic personality disorder of which is to experience the feeling of contemp­ but in reality. Psychopaths generally do this fo; tuous delight when a deception is successfully two reasons: first, to maintain , or carried out. 19 This motive sharply contrasts with their sense of being larger than life, and second, normal lying, which is usually done to reduce to repair perceived or emotional wounds the anxiety surrounding possible rejection by an by retaliating against those they hold responsi­ angry person to whom one is bonded. ble. This repetitive devaluation of others, which Without conscience, there is no . With· may range from verbal insults to serial homi­ out guilt, the positive feeling aroused by decep­ cide, also serves to diminish , an emotion 13 tion both fuels the psychopath's grandiosity­ highlighted by Klein and recently explored by the belief, for example, that he or she is smarter 14 Berke. Envy is the wish to possess the "good­ than most-and acts as an intermittent positive ness" perceived in others. If the "good object" . The psychopath is therefore cannot be possessed, it must be destroyed or more likely to again. The mendacity of the damaged until it is not worth having. This idea psychopath can be enormous and is usually best of envy may, at first blush, seem quite theoreti­ uncovered through scrutiny ofthe known details cal, but is not if we imagine a very empathic of his or her behavior and history independent of and loving psychotherapist who extends his or his or her self-report. The best psychometric her caring-and perhaps violates his or her own assessment of deception concerning psychiatric professional boundaries-to help a psychopath­ disorder, what we normally diagnose as malin­ ic patient. The perceived goodness may, in fact, gering, is a combination of the validity scales stimulate the patient's envy and place the ther­ of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality apist in great danger, both emotionally and Inventory (MMPI-2) and the Structured Inter­ physically. Psychotherapists particularly at risk view of Reported Symptoms, a relatively new are those who narcissistically invest (take great clinical interview.20 pride) in their capacity to heal others or love These three aspects of the psychopathic per­ others unconditionally and who may conse­ sonality-behavioral devaluation of others, quently engage in counterphobic of real chronic emotional detachment, and mendacity­ danger15 (eg, seeing the psychopathic patient in are the catalyzing agents of his or her wicked· his or her home office or at unusually late ness. The historical trail ofthe psychopath's life is hours, when no other staffare around, to accom­ often marked by the wounded and angry people modate the patient's schedule). he or she leaves behind, sometimes unwittingly Another psychodynamic that contributes to stripped of their own capacity for goodness. the psychopath's propensity to commit evil acts is chronic emotional detachment from others. 16 THE SADIST For the psychopath, relationships are defined by The term sadism was coined by Krafft­ power gradients, not affectional ties. This biolog­ Ebing21 and is based on the life and writings of ically based deficit in bonding capacity, which the Marquis de Sade, who surprisingly lived to may be acquired or inherited or both, was first the respectable age of 74.22 Because the term noted by Bowlby17 in his study of delinquent has multiple meanings and a confusing and adolescents, some of whom he labeled "affection­ speculative literature,23 I will clarify: I am using less." Instead of seeking proximity to others as a the term to describe individuals who derive way to feel affection and closeness and to ward ple"asure from the control, domination, and suf­ off loneliness, the psychopath appears most con­ fering of others. I will treat sexual sadism as a cerned with dominating his or her objects to con­ more channeled variant,24 characterized by sex­ trol them. This pattern reduces threats to the ual arousal stimulated by the psychologic or psychopath and stimulates his or her grandiosi­ physical suffering of another. The DSM-IV has ty, but also diminishes the probability of tried to simplify things by eliminating sadistic and inhibition of aggressive impulse. It personality disorder, but burning the map does is phylogenetically a prey-predator dynamic,3 not eliminate the territory. As Michael Stone often viscerally or tactilely felt by the psychia. said, "sadistic personality disorder: not in the trist as an acute autonomic fear response in the DSM, but still in the USA" (personal communi­ presence of the patient without an overt behav­ cation, March 1996). The most comprehensive ioral threat: the hair standing up on the neck, analysis of the sadistic personality has been con­ goosebumps, or the more inexplicable "creepy" or ducted by Millon.25 "uneasy" feeling. These are atavistic reactions The derivation of pleasure through the sub­ that may signal real danger and should never jugation, control, and consequent pain of others be ignored; they necessitate a more careful and is an impulse-affect that has received very little thorough psychodiagnostic work-up and treat­ empiric and far more theoretical spec­ ment plan. ulation. A review of the 1967-1992 extant Psychiatric Annals 27:9/September 1997 631 researchll yielded 70 citations, of which only one passed by the extraordinary cruelty of their in four were empiric studies. There was a offenses. The majority of the subjects carefully virtual absence of any measurable treatment planned their offense, took the bound, blindfold­ studies; only three uncontrolled case studies ed, or gagged victim to a pre-selected location, that focused on sexual sadism. One study used kept the victim in captivity for at least a day, cyproterone acetate,26 one an olfactory aversion and proceeded to anally , force fellatio, beat, procedure,27 and the third employed self"admin­ and vaginally rape her (in descending order istered covert desensitization.28 All three of frequency) before murdering her and conceal­ showed positive treatment outcomes. ing the corpse. Most of the sexual sadists also We clinically know characterologic sadism, recorded their offenses, presumably to memori­ however, when we see it. The antisocial inpa­ alize their victims' suffering and to use for mas­ tient incessantly teases others and derives plea­ turbatory stimulation between offenses. There sure from their discomfort. The spousal batterer were sufficient data to conclude that virtually smiles broadly when shamelessly recounting his all the subjects remained unemotional and . The most disturbing example, though, is detached during the torturing and murdering. the child who does not angrily kick a pet, but Gratzer and Bradford,35 mindful of the instead animals with detached plea­ risks of uncontrolled research, conducted a com­ sure. We also know that this behavior in chil­ parative study of the Dietz sample, their own dren, cruelty toward animals, correlates with sample of criminal sexual sadists (n=28) from adult violence,29 but the causative factors of the Royal Ottawa Hospital, and a sample of sadism, whether biogenic or psychogenic, are nonsadistic sexual murderers (n=29). The sadis­ unknown. tic murderers, as a combined group, had a sig­ There is a growing body of empiric work on nificantly greater frequency of , both consensual and criminal sexual sadism. cross-dressing, voyeurism, exhibitionism, and The subculture of consensual heterosexual and homosexual experiences in their history than homosexual sadomasochism has been explored the nonsadistic sexual murderers. They were through surveys. Spengler conducted the first also significantly more likely to plan their study of male sadomasochists in Germany.30 In offense, pre-select a location, and beat, anally another study, sadomasochistic women appear rape, bind, and force fellatio on the victim. to be more extroverted, less neurotic, more psy­ Emotional detachment and sexual dysfunction chopathic, and more sexually active than control also distinguished them. Eighty-six percent of subjects.31 Self-defined sadomasochists are pre­ the sexually sadistic murderers (Royal Ottawa dominantly heterosexual, well-educated, rela­ Hospital sample only) were antisocial personal­ tively affluent, and interested in both domina­ ity disordered, and the majority had measur­ tion and submission, and they engage in a wide able neurologic impairments. range of sexual activities.32 Breslow33 conducted Neither study34.35 measured psychopathy, the largest survey study to date in the United but the convergence with sexual sadism is States and found that consensual sadomaso­ strongly suggestive and expectable: both the chists included both men and women who were psychopath and the sexual sadist share a desire predominantly white, had a wide range of edu­ to control and dominate their objects, a chronic cation, did not hide their proclivities from their emotional detachment that dehumanizes their significant other, had an average of six partners objects, an aggressive that makes during the past year, mostly engaged in oral sex them feel entitled to do what they want to their and spanking, and were remarkably free of self­ objects, and a mendacity that both delights them reported depressive and negative feelings about and facilitates the abduction of their victims. We their sexual interests. have recently empirically found that psychopa­ It appears that this abnormal sexual behav­ thy and sadism are significantly and positively ior does not evoke wickedness or evil, and in this correlated, with a sufficient magnitude (effect report I will instead focus on criminal sexual 'size) to warrant further study.36 sadism. By definition (DSM-IV), criminal sexual sadism requires the paraphilia, a nonconsensu­ CONCLUSIONS al object, usually an abducted or captured vic­ If we are to clinically manage the wicked­ tim, and psychological or physical . Here ness of psychopathy and sadism, we must first the paths of sadism and psychopathy cross and accept its reality. Regardless of the biogenic and our species' capacity for evil is most apparent. psychogenic roots of these human disorders, we Two recent studies have scrutinized the must look upon them with a scientific objectivi­ offender and offense characteristics of the crim­ ty unfettered by a naive optimism that all psy­ inal sexual sadist for the first time. Dietz and chopathology is treatable, or, if not, will amelio­ colleagues34 conducted an exploratory, descrip­ rate in time. We must also be willing, at the tive study of a small, nonrandom sample (N=30) same time, to exercise moral choice and judg­ of criminal sexual sadists, the majority of whom ment on those who act in such nefarious ways. murdered three or more victims. Virtually all of For the most difficult decisions in life are moral. the subjects were white males, and the majority And the most difficult acts in life are those that did not experience parental infidelity or divorce, demand moral courage. physical abuse, or as children. The Ifwe lose sight of these complementary and banality of their known histories was only sur­ distinct aspirations-to seek scientific objectivi- 632 Psychiatric Annals 27:9/September 1997 ty and to also exercise moral choice and der. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1991; 179:546-552. judgment-then we risk either contaminating 17. Bowlby J. Forty-four juvenile thieves: their characters and home-life. Int J Psychoanal. 1944; 25:19-53, 107-128. our scientific advancements with bias or abdi­ 18. Ekman P. Telling Lies. New York, NY: Norton; 1985. cating moral responsibility in the service of sci­ 19. Bursten B. The manipulative personality. Arch Gen entific achievement. Without such aspirations, Psychiatry. 1972; 26:318-321­ that "morning-star of evil," in Wilde's words, 20. Rogers R. Structured Interview of Reported Symptoms. Odessa, Fla: Psychologlcal Assessment Resources; 1992. may begin to believe in us. 21. von Krafft-Ebing R. Psychopathia Sexualis: A Medico­ forensic Study. New York. NY: Putnam; 1965. REFERENCES 22. Lever M. Sadela Biography. New York, NY: Farrar. 1. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Straus and Giroux; 1993. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric 23. Mollinger R. Sadomasochism and developmental stages. Association; 1968. Psychoanal Rev. 1982; 69:379-389. 2. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 24. Shapiro D. Autonomy and Rigid Character. New York, 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric NY: Basic Books; 1981. Association; 1994. 25. Millon T. Disorders of Personality DSM-IV and Beyond. 3. Meloy JR. The Psychopathic Mind: Origins, Dynamics New York, NY: Wiley and Sons; 1996. and Treatment. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson; 1988. 26. Bradford J, Pawlak A. Sadistic homosexual pedophilia: 4. Raine A. The Psychopathology ofCrime. San Diego, Calif: treatment with cyproterone acetate: a single case study. Academic Press; 1993. Can J Psychiatry. 1987; 32:22-30. 5. Cleckley H. The Mask of Sanity. St Louis, Mo: CV Mosby; 27. Laws D, Meyer J, Holmen M. Reduction of sadistic sexual 1941. arousal by olfactory aversion: a case study. Behav Res 6. Harpur T, Hakstian AR, Hare R. Factor structure of the Ther. 1978; 16:281-285. psychopathy checklist. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1988; 28. Hayes S, Brownell K, Barlow D. The use of self­ 56:741-747. administered covert sensitization in the treatnlent of 7. Harc RD. The Hare Psychopathy Checklist-Revised exhibitionism and sadism. Behavior Therapy. 1978; 9:283­ Manual. Toronto: Multihealth Systems; 1991. 289. 8. Meloy JR. Antisocial personality disorder. In: Gabbard G, 29. Feltous A, Kellert S. Violence against animals and people: ed. Treatments ofPsychiatric Disorders. Vol 2. Washington, is aggression against living creatures generalized? Bull DC: American Psychiatric Press; 1995:2273-2290. Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1986; 14:55-69. 9. Rice M, Harris G, Cormier C. An evaluation of a maxi­ 30. Spengler A. Manifest sadomasochism of males: results of mum security therapeutic community for psychopaths an empirical study. Arch Sex Behav. 1977; 6:441-456. and other mentally disordered offenders. Law and 31. Gosselin C. Wilson G, Barrett P. The personality and sex­ Human Behavior. 1992; 16:399-412. ual preferences of sadomasochistic women. Personality 10. Serin R. Psychopathy and violence in criminals. Journal and Individual Differences. 1991; 12:11-1:::. of Interpersonal Violence. 1991; 6:423-431. 32. Moser C, Levitt E. An exploratory-descriptive study of a 11. Meloy JR. Violent Attachments. Northvale, NJ: Jason sadomasochistically oriented sample. Journal of Sex Aronson; 1992. Research. 1987; 23:322-337. 12. Hare RD, Hart SD, Harpur TJ. Psychopathy and the pro­ 33. Breslow N. Sadomasochism. A Report of a 10 Year Study posed DSM-lV criteria for antisocial personality disorder. Into Sadomasochism Among Consenting Adults. Los J Abnorm Psychol. 1991; 100:391-398. Angeles, Calif: Oceanside Press; 1992. 13. Klein M. Envy and Gratitude and Other Works 1946· 34. Dietz P, Hazelwood R, Warren J. The sexually sadistic 1963. New York, NY: The Free Press; 1975. criminal and his offenses. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 14. Berke JH. The Tyranny ofMalice. New York, NY: Summit 1990; 18:163-178. Books; 1988. 35. Gratzer T, Bradford J. Offender and offense characteris­ 15. Lion J, Leaff L. On the hazards of assessing character tics of sexual sadists: a comparative study. J Forensic Sci. pathology in an outpatient setting. Psychiatr Q. 1973; 1995; 40:450-455. 47:104-109. 36. Holt S, Meloy JR, Strack S. Sadism and psychopathy in 16. Gacono CB, Meloy JR. A Rorschach investigation of violent and sexually violent offenders. Manuscript sub­ attachment and anxiety in antisocial personality disor­ mitted for publication.

Psychiatric Annals 27:9/September 1997 633