DOCSLIB.ORG

Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry Into Child Protection Services in NSW

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry Into Child Protection Services in NSW Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Child Protection Services in NSW Volume 1 The Hon James Wood AO QC November 2008 © State of NSW through the Special Commission of Inquiry into Child Protection Services in NSW, 2008 ISBN 978-1-921301-86-5 Published November 2008 Special Commission of Inquiry into Child Protection Services in New South Wales Table of contents Volume 1 Executive Summary .......................................................................................................i Recommendations .......................................................................................................xi Acronyms................................................................................................................xxxix Part 1 DoCS structure and workforce.........................................................................1 1. Introduction........................................................................................................3 2 DoCS structure and reform...............................................................................7 Introduction .....................................................................................................................8 Pre 2002............................................................................................................................8 2002 Reform Package .....................................................................................................9 Child Protection Major Project.....................................................................................13 DoCS organisational structure and budget................................................................14 Information systems .....................................................................................................18 Research function.........................................................................................................23 Complaints system .......................................................................................................25 Issues arising ................................................................................................................28 Recommendations ........................................................................................................40 3 DoCS workforce capacity................................................................................43 DoCS workforce ............................................................................................................44 Professional standards.................................................................................................57 Issues arising ................................................................................................................66 Recommendations ........................................................................................................79 Part 2 Early intervention and child protection .........................................................81 4 Key child protection research ........................................................................83 Introduction ...................................................................................................................84 Risk, protection and resilience in children and families...........................................86 Parenting capacity ........................................................................................................90 Domestic violence.........................................................................................................91 Neglect ...........................................................................................................................92 Physical abuse ..............................................................................................................95 Carer drug and alcohol misuse ...................................................................................98 Table of Contents Psychological abuse .................................................................................................. 104 Carer mental health .................................................................................................... 105 Sexual abuse............................................................................................................... 107 Child/young person risk taking behaviour............................................................... 112 Summary...................................................................................................................... 115 5 Key child protection data ............................................................................. 117 NSW demographic data ............................................................................................. 118 Reporting trends since 2001/02................................................................................. 119 Outcome of assessment at the Helpline .................................................................. 137 Reports referred to a CSC/JIRT for further assessment ........................................ 137 Assessment path ........................................................................................................ 149 Outcome of assessment of all child protection reports ......................................... 156 Care proceedings........................................................................................................ 164 Future Demand............................................................................................................ 166 6 Risk of harm reports to DoCS ...................................................................... 169 Reporting trends......................................................................................................... 170 Substantiations........................................................................................................... 174 Reports which receive no further assessment........................................................ 174 Mandatory reporting................................................................................................... 176 Recommendations...................................................................................................... 197 7 Early intervention .......................................................................................... 199 Introduction................................................................................................................. 201 Types of early intervention services......................................................................... 207 Inter-jurisdictional models......................................................................................... 213 NSW Framework ......................................................................................................... 215 Universal service system........................................................................................... 219 Targeted service system............................................................................................ 223 DoCS Brighter Futures early intervention program................................................ 231 Issues arising.............................................................................................................. 238 Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 259 Recommendations...................................................................................................... 260 8 Assessment and response........................................................................... 261 NSW Assessment Framework................................................................................... 263 Introduction................................................................................................................. 263 Assessment by the Helpline ...................................................................................... 268 Case allocation............................................................................................................ 272 Case closure................................................................................................................ 277 NSW casework practice ............................................................................................. 279 Special Commission of Inquiry into Child Protection Services in New South Wales Interagency work.........................................................................................................299 Recommendations ......................................................................................................321 9 Assessment and response: issues arising .................................................323 Assessment tools........................................................................................................324 Work at the Helpline....................................................................................................334 Work at the CSC ..........................................................................................................337 Supervision and professional development ............................................................360 Inquiry’s review of four CSCs ....................................................................................361 Involving other agencies
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Builders Labourers' Federation
    Making Change Happen Black and White Activists talk to Kevin Cook about Aboriginal, Union and Liberation Politics Kevin Cook and Heather Goodall Published by ANU E Press The Australian National University Canberra ACT 0200, Australia Email: [email protected] This title is also available online at http://epress.anu.edu.au National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Author: Cook, Kevin, author. Title: Making change happen : black & white activists talk to Kevin Cook about Aboriginal, union & liberation politics / Kevin Cook and Heather Goodall. ISBN: 9781921666728 (paperback) 9781921666742 (ebook) Subjects: Social change--Australia. Political activists--Australia. Aboriginal Australians--Politics and government. Australia--Politics and government--20th century. Australia--Social conditions--20th century. Other Authors/Contributors: Goodall, Heather, author. Dewey Number: 303.484 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Cover images: Kevin Cook, 1981, by Penny Tweedie (attached) Courtesy of Wildlife agency. Aboriginal History Incorporated Aboriginal History Inc. is a part of the Australian Centre for Indigenous History, Research School of Social Sciences, The Australian National University and gratefully acknowledges the support of the School of History RSSS and the National Centre for Indigenous Studies, The Australian National
    [Show full text]
  • Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry Into Crystal Methamphetamine and Other Amphetamine-Type Stimulants 1001
    Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into crystal methamphetamine and other amphetamine-type stimulants 1001 1002 Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into crystal methamphetamine and other amphetamine-type stimulants Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into crystal methamphetamine and other amphetamine-type stimulants 1003 1004 Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into crystal methamphetamine and other amphetamine-type stimulants Table of Contents Introduction to the Inquiry’s regional hearings ......................................................... 1011 References ......................................................................................................... 1013 Chapter 23. The Lismore region ................................................................................. 1015 Introduction to the Lismore region ................................................................... 1015 Lismore’s experience with ATS ......................................................................... 1016 Use of crystal methamphetamine by people involved in the justice system ........... 1016 Presentations to health services ........................................................................... 1016 Other service providers’ observations about increases in ATS use ....................... 1017 Who is using crystal methamphetamine? ............................................................. 1017 Availability of ATS ...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Black and White Children in Welfare in New South Wales and Tasmania, 1880-1940
    ‘Such a Longing’ Black and white children in welfare in New South Wales and Tasmania, 1880-1940 Naomi Parry PhD August 2007 THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES Thesis/Dissertation Sheet Surname or Family name: Parry First name: Naomi Abbreviation for degree as given in the University calendar: PhD School: History Faculty: Arts and Social Sciences Title: ‘Such a longing’: Black and white children in welfare in New South Wales and Tasmania, 1880-1940 Abstract 350 words maximum: When the Human Rights and Equal Opportunities Commission tabled Bringing them home, its report into the separation of indigenous children from their families, it was criticised for failing to consider Indigenous child welfare within the context of contemporary standards. Non-Indigenous people who had experienced out-of-home care also questioned why their stories were not recognised. This thesis addresses those concerns, examining the origins and history of the welfare systems of NSW and Tasmania between 1880 and 1940. Tasmania, which had no specific policies on race or Indigenous children, provides fruitful ground for comparison with NSW, which had separate welfare systems for children defined as Indigenous and non-Indigenous. This thesis draws on the records of these systems to examine the gaps between ideology and policy and practice. The development of welfare systems was uneven, but there are clear trends. In the years 1880 to 1940 non-Indigenous welfare systems placed their faith in boarding-out (fostering) as the most humane method of caring for neglected and destitute children, although institutions and juvenile apprenticeship were never supplanted by fostering. Concepts of child welfare shifted from charity to welfare; that is, from simple removal to social interventions that would assist children's reform.
    [Show full text]
  • Attorney Generals Answers to Questions on Notice 06/07 Budget
    SENATE LEGAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL LEGISLATION COMMITTEE ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S DEPARTMENT Output 1.7 Question No. 34 Senator Evans asked the following question at the hearing on 24 May 2006: Please provide a list of the locations of the existing Family Violence Prevention Centres. The answer to the honourable senator’s question is as follows: A list of existing Family Violence Prevention Legal Services units is attached. Family Violence Prevention Legal Services Units State Unit Unit location Postcode Service Area Nambucca Valley (Bowraville, Macksville & Nambucca Heads), West Bellbrook, South West Rocks/ Cresent New South Wales Many Rivers Violence Prevention Unit Kempsey 2440 Head, Port Macquarie and Wauchope Kamilaroi Family Violence Prevention Service Moree 2400 Mungindi, Boggabilla, Toomelah Parkes, Lake Cargelligo, Murrin Bridge, Condobolin, Peak Hill, West Forbes Family Violence Healing Centre Forbes 2871 Wyalong, Griffith, Cowra, Leeton Bourke Family Violence Prevention Service Lidcome 1825 Bourke and Brewarina LGA Lightening Ridge, Goodooga (via Walanbaa Yinnar Wahroo - Walgett Family Violence Lightening Ridge), Collerenibri, Prevention Unit Walgett 2832 Grawin Warndu Watlhilli - Carri Ngura Aboriginal Family Violence South Australia Legal Service Port Augusta 5700 Port Augusta LGA Ceduna Aboriginal Family Violence Prevention Legal Service Ceduna 5690 Ceduna LGA Barunga (Includes Beswick and Maranboy area), Borroloola (includes McArthur river/Gulf area),Timber Creek (Includes Victoria River area and local communities such as Bulla
    [Show full text]
  • THE TOOMELAH REVIEW March 1989
    • THE TOOMELAH REVIEW March 1989 1 r Table of Contents Page Introduction 1 Inter-governmental Conflict 2 Housing 3 Water and Sewerage 5 Roads 6 Legal Status of Toomelah 8 Zoning 9 Rates 10 Education 11 Health 14 Employment 18 Euraba Shop 20 Aboriginal Heritage 21 Inter-racial Activities 23 Recommendations 24 Notes 28 Acknowledgments 29 List of Abbreviations ADC Aboriginal Development Commission (Federal) CDEP Community Development Employment Project CDP Community Development Plan CES Commonwealth Employment Service DAA Department of Aboriginal Affairs (Federal) DMR Department of Main Roads (NSW) MPSC Moree Plains Shire Council OAA Office of Aboriginal Affairs (NSW) TAFE Department of Technical and Further Education (NSW) Introduction On 15 June 1988 the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission released the Toomelah Report, containing the results of its inquiry into the social and material needs of Aborigines in the New South Wales/Queensland border towns of Toomelah and Boggabilla. The Commission undertook at the time to review progress on the implementation of the Recommendations 1 six months after its release. On 15 and 16 December 1988, the President of the Commission, the Hon. Justice Marcus Einfeld, accompanied by Inquiry member Ms Kaye Mundine and two members of staff, visited Toomelah, Boggabilla and Goondiwindi to conduct this review. They found that substantial improvements in the living conditions of the residents had occurred and more changes were in progress or planned. This report comprises its findings. Page 1 1. Inter-Governmental Conflicts The Toomelah Report recommended the establishment of a mechanism for the co-ordination of Federal, State and Local Government activity in relation to Toornelah.
    [Show full text]
  • Toomelah.Pdf
    Human Rights Australia TOOMELAH REPORT REPORT ON THE PROBLEMS AND NEEDS OF ABORIGINES LIVING ON THE NEW SOUTH WALES-QUEENSLAND BORDER JUNE 1988 ISBN 0 642 13568 1 Printed in Australia Human Rights Australia 2 June 1988 The Hon. Lionel Bowen MP Deputy Prime Minister & Attorney-General Parliament House CANBERRA ACT 2600 Dear Attorney-General We have pleasure in presenting the report of our Inquiry into the social and material needs of the residents of the New South Wales - Queensland Border Towns of Goondiwindi, Boggabilla and Toomelah, conducted pursuant to s.11(1) (f) and (k) of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 and s.20(1) (a) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975. We commend our findings and recommendations to you. The Hon. Sir James Killen Kaye Mundine Human Flights and Equal Opportunity Commission Level 24 American Express Building 388 George Street Sydney NSW 2000 GPO Box 5218 Sydney NSW 2001 Telephone 229 7600 Eacsimile: 229 7611 Telex AA 778000 DX 869 Sydney ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The members of the Inquiry wish to acknowledge the contributions of many people to the success of the Inquiry and to the completion of this Report. Commission staff involved were: Megan Chalmers, Legal Officer: Counsel assisting the Inquiry, writing sections of the Report. Murray Chapman, Senior Conciliator Research, community liaison, assistance in and Aboriginal Policy Advisor: preparation of the Report. Kim Monnox, Research Officer: Research, writing sections of the Report. Meredith Wilkie, Senior Research Officer: Research, writing and editing of the Report. Bill Chapman, Assistant Secretary, Administrative support, assistance in preparation Management: of the Report.
    [Show full text]
  • Frankston Mornington Peninsula Local Drug Action Team Presenter
    Frankston Mornington Peninsula Local Drug Action Team Presenter: Lisa Abbott ACTIVATE Lead Agencies: • Frankston Mornington Peninsula Primary Care Partnership, Brotherhood of St Laurence Partner organisations: • Peninsula Health, Frankston Business Network, Chisolm Institute of TAFE, Department of Education & Training, Department of Health & Human Services, Frankston City Council, Monash University, Mornington Peninsula Shire, SalvoCare Eastern, Stepping-Up Consortium, University of Melbourne, Victoria Police. • Location: City of Frankston and Shire of Mornington Peninsula Local challenge • Population of approximately 72,000 young people between the ages of 5 – 25 (ABS, 2017) • 15,000 young people are estimated to be at-risk or highly vulnerable (SFYS, 2016) • Emerging trends and issues include: increased family violence incidents, alcohol and other drug use, family breakdown/stress, youth crime, suicide, bullying, teenage pregnancy, and sexually transmitted infections. • Pockets of extreme disadvantage, including high rates of disengaged young people and high rates of families from low socio-economic backgrounds. Compared to the general population: • Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders people experience higher rates of disadvantage • LGBTIQ+ young people experience poorer mental health outcomes and more likely to experience homophobia in sport (Denison & Kitchen, 2015). Solution • Sport and recreation activities for young people can lead to improvements in self-esteem, better relationships with family and increased academic performance
    [Show full text]
  • Artstate (Day 1) – Friday 1St November 2019 Plenary Session
    ArtState (Day 1) – Friday 1st November 2019 Plenary Session Un-edited Transcript (may contain errors and omissions) ELIZABETH ROGERS (MC): Good morning everybody, and welcome to the first day of Artstate 2019. I like to welcome Aunty Yvonne Kent to provide the Welcome to Country. AUNTY YVONNE KENT - KAMILAROI ELDER: Can you hear me at the back? Welcome to the wonderful land of the Kamilaroi people, and pay our respect to the elders and the youth. I'll like you to stand and have a moment's silence, and I notice that was missed last night. I always like to pay our respects to our past Elders, because without them, we would not be here today and have what we have. So, thank you. Thank you. So, let us be informed. Find out what is going on throughout these next four days. Also be involved. Go to as many things as you can. Most of all, be inspired by it and our country. Thank you, and welcome. (Applause) ELIZABETH ROGERS – CEO REGIONAL ARTS NSW (MC): Thank you, Auntie Yvonne. I would also like to acknowledge we are meeting on Kamilaroi country, and pay my respects. I like to acknowledge all of the Elders that have travelled from other parts of the state, and all Aboriginal and other first nations people that are with us here today. I would also like to knowledge the chair of Regional Arts NSW, Julie Briggs, and the directors of our boards. The chair of Arts Northwest Anna Watt, and Caroline Downer, and the chair executive directors from the other organisations that make up our unique regional arts network.
    [Show full text]
  • Mapping the Cultural Atlas of North Queensland
    Mapping the Cultural Atlas of North Queensland: Ronald “Tonky” Logan a Case Study Abstract The ‘Cultural Atlas’ proposed by the PIP (People, Identity, Place) research cluster at James Cook University aims to contextualize cultural communities and artists in North Queensland into a comprehensive profile. Case study Ronald “Tonky” Logan is a North Queensland Aboriginal Country Western musician. The secondary theme of this article is the appropriation of Country Western music by Australian Aboriginal groups as traditional music. This article draws on research by Dunbar-Hall & Gibson (2004), who demonstrate the relevance of contemporary music within Australian Aboriginal contexts, based on location and geography, as a means of establishing people, identity and place. Dr. David Salisbury James Cook University School of Creative Arts Digital Sound Introduction In 2005 the PIP (People, Identity, and Place) research cluster of James Cook University held an annual seminar during which the concept of initiating a Cultural Atlas was proposed. In March 2006 a PIP Cultural Atlas meeting was held and basic concepts were proposed including some preliminary boundaries of latitude 18, south to Bowen and Hayman Island, west to Mt. Isa and north covering the Gulf region (the Torres Strait Islands are not included). Possible outputs could be a Website as a primary means to maintain a collection of data and resources for tourism, focusing on eco and cultural-tourism CD’s and DVD’s. Initially this article aims to establish the context in which the subject of this case study, Ronald ‘Tonky’ Logan, performs and lives by outlining a brief history of Aboriginality in North Queensland along with a brief history of Aboriginal music in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • SCREEN Nsw Andvisit FILMS Daniel CONNORS Christopher Edwards Anddean Daley-JONES “Toomelah” Mixersam Haywood Director O
    Sales Agent for Toomelah is Ryan Kampe | Visit Films 89 5th Ave #806, New York NY 10003 USA Email: [email protected] Telephone: +1.718.312.8210 Cannes 2011- Lerins S8 +33 (0)4 92 99 32 19 Toomelah (Un Certain Regard) Après le sud (Director’s Fortnight) Screening schedule <http://www.visitfilms.com/ZZZspecial/Visit2011Cannes.pdf> International Cannes Publicist for Toomelah is Mia Romley Davies 4 New Burlington Street, London, W1S 2JG Telephone: +44 (0)20 7148 3770 Mobile: +44 (0) 7791 670 465 Fax: +44 (0) 20 7148 3774 Email: [email protected] Australian Publicist for Toomelah is Tracey Mair | TM Publicity P. O. Box 2506, Byron Bay NSW 2481 Telephone: +61 (0)2 6680 7106 Fax: + 61 (0) 2 6680 7108 Mob: +61 (0) 419 221 493 Brochure Production Supported by Screen Australia SCREEN AUSTRALIA ANd BUNYA PROdUCTIONS PRESENT IN ASSOCIATION wITh ANd ANd SCREEN NSw VISIT FILMSRE-RECORdIN g dANIEL CONNORS dIRECTORChRISTOP OF hER EdwARdS dEAN dALEYwRITER-J ANONESd “TOOMELAh” COMPOSER MIxER PhOTOgRAPhY PROdUCER dIRECTOR A film by Ivan Sen IVAN SEN SAM ©hAY 2011 wSCREENOO AUdS TR ALIA, SCREEN NIVANSW, BUNYA SEN PRODUCTION S PTY LdIMITEAVID d JOwSEY IVAN SEN ThE DiReTOR Ivan Sen was raised in Inverell, New South Wales, Australia. He graduated from Inverell High School in 1989 and then undertook a degree in photography at Griffith University in Queensland. He studied filmmaking at the Australian Film Television and Radio School, where he completed a Bachelor Arts in Directing in 1997. The STory Throughout the late 1990s Sen worked on numerous short films, before making his In a remote Aboriginal community, Then a rival drug dealer Bruce, returns feature film debut with Beneath Clouds in Daniel, a sensitive, troubled 10 year old from prison, and a drug turf war erupts, 2002.
    [Show full text]
  • Toomelah Cwa Branch
    A RIGHT MOVE TOOMELAH C.W.A. BRANCH HOME FOR ABORIGJIUAL FAMILY FOURTH ANNNERSARY PARTY With the completion of the building of their new home The fourth anniversary of the formation of the Country Mr. and Mrs. Gordon Troutman, of Boggabilla, have Women’s Association Branch at Boggabilla, known as the now moved to a more central position on the Boggabilla Toomelah Branch, was held recently. Common. The branch is now functioning as an all aboriginal one The enterprise of the Troutmans was shown in an and was guided into this position by Mrs. R. F. Brown, article of an earlier edition of Dum. Gordon, a president of Boggabilla Branch of the C.W.A. when both shearer, was not content to live in a tent on the Aboriginal white officers had to resign. Mrs. J. Buchanan was Station. He and his wife Jean had, like most people, Treasurer until her husband, Headteacher of the something better in mind-they wanted a home of their Aboriginal School, was transferred. Mrs. W. E. Roberson own in better surroundings, something they could call had to resign her position as Secretary due to ill health. their own. So, through the manager and the Welfare Officer, Mr. Preston Walker, they sought the assistance Mrs. Brown has given much of her time to come out of the Aborigines’ Welfare Board who endeavour to to the Station for the monthly meetings of the branch accommodate such industrious people as well as their held by the aboriginal women of the Station. The limited funds will allow. office bearers as elected by their members have been The manager, who drew up the plans for the house coached in their particular jobs, especially in that of not only had to bear this in mind but also had to keep treasurer and secretary, which up till then had been the size of the home within the amount of Gordon’s filled by white persons.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Assembly
    4210 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thursday 16 November 2006 ______ Mr Speaker (The Hon. John Joseph Aquilina) took the chair at 10.00 a.m. Mr Speaker offered the Prayer. Mr SPEAKER: I acknowledge the Gadigal clan of the Eora nation and its elders and thank them for the custodianship of country. BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE Suspension of Standing and Sessional Orders Mr PETER DEBNAM: I seek leave to suspend standing and sessional orders to permit the introduction and passage through all its stages of the Parliamentary Contributory Superannuation (Criminal Charges) Bill. Leave not granted. CHILDREN AND YOUNG PERSONS (CARE AND PROTECTION) MISCELLANEOUS AMENDMENTS BILL COMPANION ANIMALS AMENDMENT BILL HOME BUILDING AMENDMENT (STATUTORY WARRANTIES) BILL WORLD YOUTH DAY BILL Messages received from the Legislative Council returning the bills without amendment. UNPROCLAIMED LEGISLATION Mr SPEAKER: Pursuant to standing orders, I table a list detailing all legislation unproclaimed 90 calendar days after assent as at 17 November 2006. VICTIMS SUPPORT AND REHABILITATION AMENDMENT BILL Second Reading Debate resumed from 14 November 2006. Mr CHRIS HARTCHER (Gosford) [10.03 a.m.]: The Victims Support and Rehabilitation Amendment Bill arises from a statutory review of the Victims Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996 and various cognate Acts. The support of victims in New South Wales remains a serious and ongoing government and community responsibility. There is genuine concern that the legal system continues to look more to the accused than it does to victims. It is welcome then that the statutory review recommended various proposals to extend the rights of victims to compensation. It recommended to extend the rights of victims to claim for psychological and psychiatric injury; to extend the number of people in a victim's family who can make application to half brothers and half sisters and, in appropriate cases, to grandparents; to make allowances for payments such as funeral expenses; and to make allowances for an assessor to make certain determinations.
    [Show full text]