Key Police Disclosure

THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CIV 2014-485-11344

WELLINGTON REGISTRY

Under The Judicature Amendment Act 1972, Part 30 of the High Court Rules, the Bill of Rights Act 1990, and the Search and Surveillance Act 2012

In the matter of An application for judicial review

And in the matter of A search warrant issued by Judge IM Malosi of the Manukau District Court on 30 September 2014

Between N A HAGER Applicant

And HER MAJESTY’S ATTORNEY-GENERAL First Respondent

And THE NEW ZEALAND POLICE Second Respondent

And THE MANUKAU DISTRICT COURT Third Respondent

Key Evidence Bundle

Volume 4: Key Police Disclosure

Solicitor Counsel Thomas Bennion Julian Miles QC Felix Geiringer Bennion Law Richmond Chambers Terrace Chambers L1, 181 Cuba Street L5, General Buildings No. 1 The Terrace PO Box 25 433 33 Shortland Street PO Box 10 201 Wellington 6146 PO Box 1008 Wellington 6143 Tel: +64 4 473 5755 Auckland 1140 Tel: +64 4 909 7297 Fax: +64 4 381 3276 Tel: + 64 9 600 5504 Fax: +64 4 909 7298 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

Radio LIVE

14/08/2014

MH Mike HOSKING

NH Nicky HAGER

MH Dirty Politics broadly claims that the government runs an attack type campaign using bloggers like Cameron SLATER to attack those they don’t like. Many of the allegations ironically come from leaked emails and Nicky HAGAR is with us, good morning.

NH Good morning.

MH Given this isn’t a long interview, give us your best shot. Is there anything corrupt or illegal here, anything that will bring the government down?

NH It’s not my job to bring down the government. It is my job to let people know about the government and what we had was we had was we had a kind of an attack operation being organised from the Prime Minister’s office for example the one I said last night was you had John KEY’s longest term press officer working out of the beehive, Mike SLAW, breaking into the Labour Party computers, digging out dirt and then coordinating step by step with Cameron SLATER while he launched that information on his blog.

MH Okay we’ve heard that, that’s now in the public domain. That’s that’s your best bit, that’s as bad as it gets.

NH No no no, you’ve got John KEY in charge of the SIS and arranging to have information tipped off to Whale Oil Blog to attack the Labour Party. There’s outrageous stuff about the Minister Judith COLLINS leaking information and organising smears with Cameron SLATER. It goes like

1 60 there’s sex attacks on people as in digging out sexual dirt to pressure and to try to humiliate opponents, it runs on.

MH Right, okay lets go, lets go to the Labour thing and Jason EDE, are you accusing him of illegally hacking into the Labour Party computers?

NH That’s certainly what its, I’m definitely saying that he definitely did hack into them and whether it’s illegal will be determined but I expect there’ll probably be a police complaint.

MH Alright and will he be charged with something?

NH I don’t know that of course but more important than that than the actual charging is that when you’re the leader of the country like his boss and when you’re the leader of the office, you’re responsible for the actions of your, of your staff and if you get the benefits of the attacks on your opponents, you’re also accountable for when they’ve done dirty tricks.

MH Indeed so so my over arching sense of this Nicky is that what you’ve got here is is an attack style system with, run by the government that you don’t like fair enough that’s your opinion and you don’t have to, your argument then would be that we should all be shocked and upset and outraged by this, am I reading this right so far?

NH That’s right. I think if you’re a government that runs the we’re friendly and relaxed and we just and we don’t get involved in negative politics, then you don’t quietly do your negative politics at the same time and tryna do it on the quiet with no one knowing.

MH You’ve gotta be but but Nicky government’s have done this forever. This is not new or and it’s not news.

NH Actually it is new and it is news. If you look back to the last time we had a lot of attack politics which was the Muldoon era. Muldoon used to stand up and say ‘I’ve got an SIS file’ not sneak it off to his bloggers to do it or attack people to their front not stab them in their backs. I actually think people don’t know about this and they’ve got a total right

2 61 to know that politics is being conducted in this way.

MH So you’re telling me that the vast majority of New Zealanders have no understanding that governments, as long as I’ve been around in this industry which is now 30 years, have not systematically leaked passed on information that’s beneficial to them and negative to their opponents and they haven’t done that on a regular basis year in year out. This is all new to everybody is it?

NH Now you’re twisting what I’m saying, if, what, sometimes all governments will release information that serves their purpose and polis, of course they do that but having an organised dirty tricks campaign where you don’t, where you’re actually using third parties like bloggers to smear people, to dig out dirt about their personal lives…

MH Isn’t isn’t a blogger just a modern version of a journalist from the press gallery, that’s the only difference here.

NH The difference between a blogger and a journalist in the press gallery is that bloggers don’t have to obey any ethics so they can go after…

MH Alright.

NH …peoples sex lives, they can break the law, they can do all kinds of things and when a governments prepared to use them in sort of an uncontrollable attack dog like that, they gotta wear it if comes out and people find out that they’ve done it.

MH A couple that you obviously the irony has not escaped you that you attack people for leaked emails and yet you’re entire books based on them, leaked emails.

NH The irony is, the difference is that I am not working for a political party. I am not part of some secret plots. My job…(inaudible) to the public.

MH So it makes it alright for you to have leaked emails but not other people. So Cameron SLATER’s allowed a leaked email to set himself against

3 62 somebody but you’re not allowed a leaked email to publish a book to damage a government.

NH (inaudible) your news organisation would happily have received the same emails as part of informing the public, that’s a completely different process from having an organised pro…system coming down from the Prime Minister’s office and Judith COLLINS’ office to smear their opponents where they’re leaking government information.

MH Well what are you looking to do, what are you looking to do. You’re looking to smear the government aren’t you.

NH Actually no I am looking to inform the public at an election time…

MH Well that’s what Cameron SLATER’s doing, he’s looking to inform the public. You just don’t like what he’s informing the public with and you’re arguing what you’re informing the public is more important than what Cameron SLATER informs the public with, same material, leaked information, his is on a website, yours is in a book.

NH Again, I say I totally disagree. If I was been give…

MH You can't disagree because it’s a statement of fact.

NH Would you let me answer the question. If I was been given this information by the Labour Party or another party and releasing it as my own, then there would be a completely dishonest process going on which is what’s happening with Cameron SLATER.

MH Okay.

NH I’m being upfront about where I got it and how I’m using it (inaudible).

MH Well you’re not being upfront about where you got it, where’d you get it from?

NH I got it from somebody who is not associated with any party or any political people who happen to come across it across it because they

4 63 were angry (inaudible).

MH How did they come across it. How did they come across it.

NH Because there were a group of people (inaudible)…

MH They hacked it, they hacked into SLATER’s computer system.

NH …who broke down his computer yes.

MH So they broke, they broke illegally broke his computer system, stole his emails and passed them onto you.

NH They that did and anybody in the media would have legally and joyously received such important political information and put it out to the public which is what I did.

MH Right. One of the accusations in there is Peter DUNN, there’s an email there about tobacco money that’s undeclared, this is an email from SLATER right. You don’t know that emails true do you, that’s just just SLATER ranting on in a private email correct?

NH Precisely (inaudible).

MH So why would you pub…why would you publish something you have no idea whether it’s accurate or not.

NH I, because is said in the book that this is only him saying it and it is not verified (inaudible).

MH So that’s so that’s legitimate on your behalf is it so you can get stolen emails that potentially libel people and just publish it and go well that’s okay.

NH Okay now I’ll answer the question which is that the particular person who was putting it out which was Cameron SLATER, we now know was being paid by the tobacco industry to put information on his blog site in favour of tobacco on behalf of the tobacco industry (inaudible).

5 64 MH And what’s wrong, what’s wrong with that.

NH (inaudible) clearly doing it…

MH What’s wrong with that.

NH Just, it just means when he says something about where tobacco money is going, he knows much more about it than you or I.

MH That that’s fine and so maybe you’ve exposed Cameron SLATER as a person who takes money and pumps out peoples information, other people would call that public relations, that’s got nothing to do with the government, you drag a government minister in with an allegation that you don’t know to be true and that’s acceptable journalism in your view is it.

NH I’ll tell you once more, when somebody who is working with the tobacco industry and taking their money privately chats about a minister…

MH You believe him.

NH …and claims to know stuff about them when they work with the tobacco industry, I think that’s very interesting information…

MH It’s interesting, it’s interesting.

NH …I said in the book, I said in the book….

MH But you can't verify it.

NH Which is exactly what I said in the book.

MH So you're happy to take stolen emails with information you can't verify and because they’re interesting, public them.

NH I put information of the highest public interest before the public at exactly the time when you should hold governments to account which is before an election.

6 65 MH How how are you holding Peter DUNN to account with a piece of information you don’t know to be true.

NH Peter DUNN has been suspected of being in the pocket of…

MH That’s not knowing something to be true.

NH …(inaudible) for many years.

MH It’s been, you suspect people of a million things.

NH Yeah and so when somebody who is working with the tobacco industry says that about him…

MH That’s enough for you.

NH …I wrote I wrote that there is that we do not know if this is true and he’s already denied it but this is an interesting thing that someone who works with him says, I think that’s okay.

MH Alright appreciate your time very much - Nicky HAGAR, the book Dirty Politics, the main target Cameron SLATER

END OF AUDIO

7 66 ONE News

Q and A : 17/08/2014

“Dirty Politics” Nicky Hager: Source to release information”

SW Susan WOOD

NH Nicky HAGER

SW The author of Dirty Politics Investigative Journalist Nicky Hager joins me from Wellington today. Good morning to you.

NH Good morning.

SW Error ridden left wing ah conspiracy is essentially what Cameron Slater is saying, please respond to that.

NH Um when somebody doesn’t wanna answer the real issues of what’s going on and it was actually been the same with the National Party Leader, um they call you names and they say you’ve got it all wrong but actually all I have written is a book which lays out step by step the evidence of their own words and their own actions so I I think what we’re seeing is damage control not um not not debate.

SW Nobody has questioned the veracity of the emails that is true but you have drawn links, you said this leads to that and this probably means that, isn’t it time now to put up the evidence to prove those links, the links to John Key for example?

NH Ah ac…I think I’ve laid out the information as well as I can but yes actually um I’m happy I’m actually happy to use your programme to explain this because in the last few days peop…various journalists have been saying “Can we please see the material”, John Keys said I’d made it up at one stage and so I said I have to go back to the source so I’d like to lay that out now. When I, when I finished the book I was advised

1 67 by my lawyer that I should return all the materials to my source because a a court judgement had come out which meant that I’m might be forced because it was a book to hand over all the material and expose my source. I have since gone back to the source, I’ve done that in the last couple of days and I’ve said “Can I please start to release the information” which I’d very much like to do and the source told me no but what I think what is going on with this source is that the source has decided that he is going to release the information but not let me do it and what I’ve asked the source is that the source respect what I have already done with, if if he does that that he respect what I’ve already done, which is that he takes out people’s names who aren’t part of the story, that he doesn’t put in private information which people don’t need to hear, in other words that he sticks to the things which I did in the book which is not to have collateral damage while we talk about the important political issues.

SW Understood.

NH Yeah.

SW I know that you are not going to tell me your source and I’m not even gonna ask but I’m gonna ask you rule out somebody who has been named by Cameron Slater.

NH You’re welcome to do that.

SW Would you please rule out Kim Dotcom as your source?

NH Absolutely categorically nothing to do with it and if it had been, I would’ve said go to someone else.

SW Is there anything there that has not been released? Have you been through all the emails? Have you got all the, for want of a better term, the “dirt”. Is there anything else there in those emails?

NH Um I had a very large body of material. I actually it’s not a, I haven’t written a report or a dossier. I tried to write an interesting book which

2 68 people would turn the pages on, I’m a writer and so yes of course there’s other material there and I think if it comes out which I have a feeling it is gonna come out, I think if people read it, it will actually be worse than the book because while I had to make it a readable book and take things out, when you just go page after page of this cynicism and the nastiness, that’s quite an experience.

SW Is there anything there, Mr Slater this morning saying he’s got half of ah the Caucus , the Labour Caucus there, that he’s got a lot of relationships with Labour um MPs and Labour people, in those emails and those masses of documents, what sort of ah what sort of correspondence was there with people from the left?

NH Well I didn’t have all his materials of course. I got given a, I got given a dump which someone had got, there wasn’t a single communication with the, with Labour Party people, ah there were I think there were one or two mentions of him talking to left wing bloggers, once or twice and and I think I think that Cameron Slater is spinning basically because he’s the son of the National Party President, he is a National Party person, he helps, the whole book is full, basically the book isn’t about Cameron Slater, it’s about the way that he gets used and involved by the National Party and the leaders to do their dirty work for them.

SW And he would say you’re a Labour Party or a Left Wing collaborator and that’s that’s your agenda so just address that.

NH I’m happy to do that. I, my, people know who I am. I care about human rights. I actually I’ve written books about the environment. If you wanna call that the left that’s fine but in terms of party, but in terms of party alliance, I have been doing this job as an investigative journalist for 20 years. You don’t, I don’t want to be in any way associated with any parties and I’m not, I do my work and people judge my work by its quality.

SW So if you had come across this information about a left wing

3 69 government, you would’ve written this book?

NH Just like I did about Helen Clarke’s government with the book I wrote about about her and genetic engineering and got a lot of flack for because the the point is you that hold governments accountable and I was prepared to do it to Labour and I’m prepared to do it to National, that’s right.

SW If you only got part of that information, how do you know that you’ve represented it fairly in the book?

NH To be fair there may be things where I didn’t have it quite right and there’s a body of information I didn’t see but the great thing about this is when, when a journalist gets leaked two documents especially from a political source, you don’t know what you’re getting, you don’t know what you're missing. I got thousands of documents. I could compare them with each other, I could spend hours checking what he’d written on his blog site, checking what the politicians had been saying in public, trying to piece it together and when I said it appears or this is my conclusion, that was because sometimes it wasn’t totally sure what it meant and so I was separating out what I could absolutely say, this is what they said, this is how who said what to whom and then sometimes I would say this appears and that means I’m telling the reader I’m this is my conclusion and that’s what someone should do, tell the truth.

SW Thank you for your time this morning, author Nicky Hager.

4 70

Radio LIVE

14/08/2014

SP Sean PLUNKET

NH Nicky HAGER

SP Well, well well well, we’re getting that text that Kim DOTCOM has sent to a contact of Cam SLATER’s in which Kim DOTCOM appears to implicate himself as being involved in the book “Dirty Politics” by Nicky HAGER but joining us on line now is Nicky HAGER, Nicky good morning to you.

NH Gidday.

SP Gidday. Did you hear what Cameron SLATER had to say?

NH No don’t know at all sorry.

SP Okay well what Cameron SLATER, well I’ll just ask you a question in that case, have you ever met Kim DOTCOM?

NH Yes. I met him at…

SP How many…how many times?

NH I met him at the Auckland Town Hall when there was a public meeting on GCSB and I met him one time earlier when his lawyer, one of his lawyers who was my lawyer through Fairfax, asked me if I would go and talk to them about the GCSB, that’s about two years ago.

SP And where did you visit him?

NH At at the mansion yeah.

SP At the mansion? You never been to the mansion other than that, only

1 71

one visit?

NH Totally yes.

SP Absolutely. Mr SLATER…

NH And…

SP Yeah.

NH and if where this is going is some hint that, in some way, Kim DOTCOM was any way involved in my book, I'm very happy to tell you it is totally untrue.

SP Oh you leapt to that pretty quickly.

NH Yes well of course, I’m not stupid, I assume that’s where it’s going. Come on.

SP Okay well I can tell you that Mr SLATER has told us this morning that he believes and he has three witnesses who tell, who say that you have visited the Kim DOT man COM mansion on multiple occasions.

NH It’s not true.

SP It is not true?

NH Totally untrue.

SP Okay where did you get this from then?

NH I, I got this, as I explained in the foreword of the book, I was approached by somebody…

SP Who?

NH Course I can't say whom I spoke to.

SP Why not?

2 72

NH Because they would get in trouble with the police and I’ve promised to keep their identity a secret. But but but Sean…

SP Why would they get in trouble with the pol…, hang on, hang on why would they get in trouble with the police Nicky?

NH Because they are a hacker which as I also was absolutely up front about, I’ve never had hacked information before but I got it and I thought it was so important I would use it but can I say, I’ll tell you what I say, I have never and I would never take information for one of my books for articles from a person who was in a political party or who was a political person. This is a highly valued principle to me.

SP Did you know, did you, did you…okay…I’m gonna ask you another question.

NH Sure.

SP Did, was this hacker personally known to you?

NH Yes.

SP Is this person or did you ask that person whether they were aligned to any current or emerging political party?

NH Course I did, of course I did. I checked out their motives in great detail and I know as I’ve just said that they have nothing to do with any political party.

SP How did they so this is someone who simply what outta the blue decided to hack Cameron SLATER.

NH I can't give you exact details because I’m not going to identify who my source is but I’ve told the story which is a true story which is that Cameron SLATER wrote some nasty comments about a guy who died in a car crash on the West Coast…

3 73

SP Mm

NH …and some people crashed his computer, I think there was a number of them…

SP Yeah.

NH …but I don’t know them all and that was how I ended up I believe, that’s how I ended up with the information.

SP So someone motivated by what hatred of Cameron SLATER?

NH Oh anger at him I think but what…

SP Okay.

NH …but that that’s jumping to conclusions possibly but that certainly seems to be the case yeah.

SP Alright and you decided to indulge that sense of revenge?

NH No. Sean, if someone had come to you with a pile of documents about what was happening in the Prime Minister’s office and all around the country in politics, I guarantee you would’ve been just as interested in them as I am.

SP I I would have been Nicky.

NH Yeah course.

SP And what I would’ve done I would’ve asked the question is this information obtained legally.

NH Of course I asked those questions.

SP Am I breaking the law in using it and I would also and Mr SLATER made this observation this morning, I would’ve also approached the people whose private and personal information that was and given them the chance to comment on what I was to publish.

4 74

NH Yes people always say that. The problem is that if you do that, you run the risk that they will put an injunction on you and the public will never hear about it so so you’re put, you are actually put in a bind and I actually think, the only thing that you’ve said so far of Cameron SLATER’s which I agree with is that in an ideal world I would go to him and I would put all, all the information just like I might have done with Don BRASH with the Hollow Man, the problem is someone puts an injunction on you and you never, the story never comes out.

SP So you choose to keep your source secret and carefully manipulate this information and release it and it’s strange Nicky because I get the impression in the book that you’re talking about having a better way of doing politics in this country, a way that is about the contest of ideas, not name calling and not sleaze yet you have released this stolen information at a time and in a way that is guaranteed for at least a few days in this election campaign to ensure that everyone is down in the gutter.

NH Well that, if you wanna put it in a very negative way. Let me put it differently to you. I was given some information. My job through many projects on many subjects is basically like a public servant, to let the public know things which, which the spin doctors and other people mightn’t of told them otherwise, I did my best to write it in a fair and accurate way and actually without name calling, without being shirty, with laying out the facts.

SP Oh oh come on that’s a bit rich given, given the stream of the narrative Nicky.

NH Excuse me, let, oh well maybe you think so, let other people read that because I go out of my way…

SP You will be shocked and disgusted at what you hear, come on Nicky.

NH Well.

5 75

SP That’s the way you were selling this book.

NH Well I, I’d ask your listeners. are they shocked and disgusted to hear that one of John KEY’s top press people was going inside the Labour Party’s computers to hack out dirt and then planning step by step how to (inaudible) blog.

SP How do you know it wasn’t a disloyal member of the Labour Party who was providing that information to Jason EADE? Did you ever ask Jason EADE for the details that you were gonna make that accusation of him, did you ever approach Jason EADE and give him a chance to explain?

NH I think, I think, I don’t think you’ve actually read the book because it’s clear that it couldn’t have come from the Labour Party, it came, I’ve got the details where EADE and Cameron SLATER worked together to go into the Labour Party’s computers. If you read, if you read the chapter you’ll find out the facts.

SP Can I ask you Nicky how do you expect to be taken seriously when in being a self appointed public servant interested in the protection of people’s privacy, you have utterly breached a number of people’s privacies. You have also and you’ve admitted to me this morning, you have deviated from normal journalistic practice in not approaching people.

NH No I didn’t say that.

SP Yeah yes you have.

NH What no no.

SP You said you didn’t approach anyone who was gonna be named in this book.

NH And I’ll tell you something cause I lecture to journalism students regularly all around the country. Journalistic practices that you go for comment if it’s realistic but if its completely unrealistic then you have to

6 76

do what I did which is that you would make absolutely sure that your facts are correct and that book has been checked and lawyered and I won't be, you’ll find if I had one thing wrong I would be in court or I will be sued but that’s not gonna happen cause I’ve got it so accurate.

SP Well Mr SLATER, Mr SLATER is talking about going to the police and the Privacy Commissioner when he returns.

NH Well if I was Mr SLATER you know, he actually got his computer hacked back in Jan…back in January whenever it was, it’s the truth, I assume he went to the police then, it was completely correct, he’s allowed to go to the police about that however I do not, I do not.

SP And you’re happy to publish information that was gathered as a result of a criminal act?

NH And that’s right don’t worry I’ve got a lawyer and I’ve done absolutely nothing wrong and you wouldn’t do anything wrong if you’d received it and and used it as well, that’s a different matter.

SP Can I ask you, can I ask you the other thing that Mr SLATER said was Nicky he said look I’m sure if he had all this information, there was also stuff about my interactions with people from all sorts of other political parties who feed me me dirt and conspire with me.

NH Hey that man has just been caught out, doing disgraceful things.

SP Can I, nah nah they’re not disgrace….

NH Can I ask you a question?

SP Where’s the crime, where’s the crime?

NH Can I ask you a question?

SP Yeah.

NH He’s spinning, he’s not telling the truth…

7 77

SP Nah nah I just.

NH …that’s what I’m saying.

SP Well okay but I’d like you to answer my questions cause you know how journalism works …

NH Yeah

SP …cause you lecture in it Nicky.

NH Yeah

SP I am answering your questions when he says

NH Is there no other information in that 8 gigabytes from the Labour Party or any other political party?

SP None he had miniscule interaction with a couple of left wing bloggers, maybe two or three or four times and there was nothing to do with any interaction with the Labour Party, is what I can tell you, or any other party.

NH And we just, are you gonna realise that 8 gigs then?

SP I’m not sure I took, there’s a, as I say in the foreword of the book when you get information like that, there’s all kinds of stuff in it and it included a lot of personal as in embarrassing personal stuff about Cameron SLATER and other people and their private like sexual affairs and all kinds of things and I don’t believe in publishing that kind of thing and if all the material comes out well if I was Cameron SLATER I wouldn’t wanna be it published at all.

NH Are you saying it coulda been worse Nicky.

SP That’s exactly what I’m saying, lucky he was me who got it.

NH Some might say, do you really expect this book to change a thing in the

8 78

election. All it will do is make the John KEY haters hate him more and those who hate the left hate them more.

SP You know what I’m not sure, I’ve wondered this myself, I have no idea what effect this will have on the election but that’s not why I do my work, I’m not trying to get a 1% change in a poll or something like that, if I’d, if I had my way…

NH The why didn’t you, then why didn’t you wait till after the election?

SP Because if I had waited if I had had information about the Prime Minister’s office and all kinds of important political information and held it to after the…

NH You haven’t drawn a single link, you haven’t drawn, you haven’t actually…

SP Can I finish my answer?

NH Okay.

SP If I had important information about the Prime Minister and the Prime Minister’s office and and had it been a Labour government and I’d held it till after the election, you will be saying to me why were you be protecting the Labour government…

NH Yeah.

SP It’s the same, it’s my job to put out information when people are voting so they know what’s going on if they think it’s fine what I’ve revealed or that I’m just you know being silly then they can judge it that way but they have at least got a right to know.

NH You haven’t actually drawn, you haven’t actually proven in any of this that the Prime Minister knew anything about it.

SP What I, what there is absolutely clear evidence of is that over time while John KEY’s staff were using Cameron SLATER and doing more and

9 79

more operations of smears and things, can I just…

NH They weren’t using, they were involved in…

SP …collaborate…

NH …what every journalist knows is the trading of information and Helen CLARKE was probably the master at this Nicky.

SP Sean I’m suspecting you haven’t read the book because there are things which are, if if if what John KEY’s staff had been doing had been giving them its of information about their housing policies or something and hoping they used them, that would be absolutely normal.

NH All politicians trade dirt on each other, personal dirt on each other…

SP If I…

NH …all the time and they use journalists as the conduit for that dirt.

SP If I found out about the Labour government trading in personal attacks and dirty tricks and the kind of stuff which I’ve revealed in this book…

NH And the sort of stuff that says what Helen CLARKE did to get rid of her Minister of Police.

SP Just a moment, I I wrote a book about Helen CLARKE’s government which got me in a lot of trouble because because I’m prepared to be even handed about this. I think, you say that you know it but actually most people around the country don’t know these things and they’ve got a right to know them and of course people in the press gallery a lot of them were suspecting the things that I’ve written about although they didn’t have proper evidence but people do have a right to know this.

NH Yeah and given that you haven’t been leaked anything on the Labour Party, are you prepared to admit that the Labour Department may do exactly the same?

10 80

SP Um I thought hard about this while I wrote the book, yes of course they might but there is actually no Labour Party equivalent of the Whale Oil Blog and about.

NH The Standard.

SP Oh that is, that is…

NH So is this a book against bloggers or is it a book against National, I’m trying to get it straight in my head.

SP It’s a book against politicians using other people to do their personal attacks for them and their dirty tricks and then claiming they had nothing about it, that’s what the book about and like if this had been a book about MULDOON, we’d be talking about him…

NH Colin MOYLE.

SP using the SIS…exactly but what…

NH But you’ve got no proof, well hang on it wouldn’t be, you’ve got no proof that John KEY has used SIS or security information and passed it to Jason EADE and leaked it to Whale Oil. You make some assumptions…

SP Well sorry, I’m sorry

NH …you make some assumptions Nicky.

SP When you’ve got Whale Oil chuckling about how he’s been tipped off which information to ask for and getting it fast tracked from the only people officials who know which are in the Prime Minister’s office I think that’s a pretty, (inaudible) pretty strong argument.

NH let’s apply that same rule to you, when you’ve got Kim DOTCOM laughing and skiteing about how he took Cameron SLATER down with your book, that’s good enough for me.

11 81

SP Well then I’m sorry that you don’t have an evidence based approach.

NH Well exactly the same evidenced based approach you’re using Nicky.

SP Well it’s actually not. What I, what I’m telling about is that I had, I’ve got that communications where SLATER is saying I’ve been told to ask for this information at the Prime Minister’s office, they’re tracking it for me, this is gonna bring down the Labour leader I’m gonna really do them.

NH Did it, did it or was Cameron SLATER like he often does blowing smoke out his bottom.

SP Well he, what it showed was that he had been told to ask for particular information…

NH What you think it shows is.

SP Well do you know what, I would recommend to your readers go read the book because they’re not gonna know it from you and I knowing it.

NH Okay.

SP But actually there’s very important issues there.

NH You're denying any link to Kim DOTCOM?

SP Of course I am.

SP And you’re denying that you committed a criminal act in using stolen information to publish a book…

NH I’m absolutely certain about that cause I checked it with my lawyer.

SP …and make, and make profit, and make profit from it.

NH Correct.

SP Thank you very much for your time Nicky, have a good day. Cheers.

12 82

NH Cheers Sean.

13 83

325

327

328

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION BRANCH Counties-Manukau District Private Bag 76 920 Manukau NEW ZEALAND Telephone: (09) 261 1300 Facsimile: (09) 2622686

19-12-2014

Steve Price By e-mail [email protected]

Official Information/Privacy Act Request dated 5 December 2014

Dear Mr Price,

I refer to your letter dated 5 December 2014.

I respond accordingly referencing paragraph numbers cited in your appendix.

1a You have requested a statement of the reasons for: the decision to search Mr Hager’s residence; the decision to apply for a search warrant and the decision to execute the search warrant in the manner it was executed. Police acknowledge Mr Hager’s right pursuant to section 23 of the Official Information Act to request a statement of the reasons supporting those decisions. Police has already provided a copy of the search warrant application which sets out the reasons upon which the search of Mr Hager’s residence was based. A further copy of the search warrant application is enclosed with the name of the officer who obtained the warrant disclosed. The remaining redactions are withheld under sections 6 c & 9 (2) a of the Official Information Act & sections 27 (1) c & 29 (1) of the Privacy Act.

The only other document in existence that is in any way relevant to this request is the Police Investigation Plan. That document is withheld in it’s entirely under section 27 (1) c of the Privacy Act & Section 6 c of the Official information Act.

1b The decision to apply for the search warrant to search Mr Hager’s residence was made by myself in consultation with Assistant Commissioner Malcolm Burgess. This was a verbal process and no documents exist in relation to it. The exact date is not recorded but is recollected to be in late September 2014.

Legal advice was also sought from Police Legal Services and provided by email. This document is subject to legal professional privilege and is withheld pursuant to sections 9(2)(h) of the Official Information Act and 29(1)(f) of the Privacy Act to maintain legal professional privilege.

329

2 No decisions were discussed with the Minister of Police or any other Government Minister. The Police Minister’s Office and the Department of Prime Minister & Cabinet were notified that the warrant had been executed after the fact. In relation to this notification there are three e- mails from the Police Deputy Executive Public Affairs to the Police Ministers Office, an e-mail to a media manager at the Office of the Department of Prime Minister & Cabinet and a letter responding to a separate Official Information Act request to another party. Redacted copies of the e-mails and the letter are enclosed. Redactions have been made to protect the privacy of individuals under section 9 (2) a of the Official Information Act & section 29 (1) of the Privacy act.

3 This request has already been responded to. The only documents that were provided to the Court in connection with the warrant application were the search warrant and search warrant application.

4 The decision to search Mr Hager’s residence was not discussed with any Public Affairs staff. Public Affairs staff were notified of the fact that the search warrant was going to be executed by way of e-mails. These e-mails are internal communications relating to an active investigation and disclosure of them is refused under section 27 (1) c of the Privacy Act & Section 6 c of the Official information Act. I have enclosed however copies of generic Police media responses also discussed under paragraph 9.

5 The decision to search Mr Hager’s residence was not discussed with the SIS, GCSB or members or staff of the Committee for Domestic and External security Co-ordination. Your request is refused pursuant to sections 18(e) of the Official Information Act and section 29(2)(b) of the Privacy Act as the information does not exist.

6 The material relied upon to execute the search warrant is clearly outlined in the search warrant application. A redacted copy of the search warrant application and source documents referred to in the application have already been disclosed.

Disclosure of Mr Slater's complaint statement and any other enquires pursued during the Police investigation would be likely to prejudice the investigation and this request is refused under sections 6(c) of the Official Information Act and 27(1)(c) of the Privacy Act.

7 The investigation of Mr Slater’s complaint has been approached in the same way as any other complaint received by Police. As this matter is a current Police investigation Police consider that disclosure of any of the information about what inquiries Police may or may not have

330 conducted would be likely to to prejudice the investigation and your request is therefore refused under sections 6(c) of the Official Information Act and 27(1)(c) of the Privacy Act.

8 No approach has been made to the Prime Minister about Rawshark’s identity. Your request is refused pursuant to sections 18(e) of the Official Information Act and section 29(2)(b) of the Privacy Act as the information does not exist

9 You have already been provided with Detective Sergeant Beal's notebook entries which outline any contact made by him during the search as well as all other documents relating to the search.

Police did not make any pro-active communication to media. Outside the communication to the Police Minister’s Office and Department of Prime Minister & Cabinet [as documented in the response to paragraph 2] there were no other communications pertaining to the search made outside Police until media queries were received the following week. A copy of generic media responses is enclosed. Police have received a large number of media queries about this case from individual journalists on an ongoing basis. These queries and documents outlining the Police response to them are withheld under section 9 (2) a of the Official information Act & section 29 (1) a of the Privacy Act.

The only other communications pertaining to the search during or after it are e-mails notifying Police Public Affairs of the search as well as Assistant Commissioner Burgess. These e-mails are internal communications relating to an active investigation and disclosure of them is refused under section 27 (1) c of the Privacy Act & Section 6 c of the Official information Act.

10 Police's current policy & practice around search warrants is governed by the Evidence Act 2006 & Search & Surveillance Act 2012. Copies of the relevant chapters of the Police Search Manuel are enclosed.

You will be aware that Police are entitled to charge for processing Official Information Act requests. Considerable Police time has been spent on processing this request and earlier requests for which you have not been billed.

Please note however that any further requests which are made under the Official Information Act in relation to this matter will incur charges as outlined on the Ministry of Justice website.

The appendix to this letter outlines what specific documents are enclosed in relation to which paragraph in response to this request.

331

You have the right to complain to the Ombudsman/Privacy Commissioner to seek an investigation and review of my decision if you are not satisfied with the way I have responded to your request.

Yours Faithfully

D.C.LYNCH Detective Inspector District Manager; Criminal Investigations Counties-Manukau Police

APPENDIX OF DOCUMENTS SUPPLIED

PARA REF DOCUMENT REDACTION REASON 1 Search Warrant application OIA sections 6 c & 9 (2) & PA sections 27 (1) c & 29 (1) 2 E-mail Police DCEPA dated OIA section 9 (2) a & PA 29 (1) 2-10-2014 to Police Minister’s a Office 2 E-mail Police DCEPA dated OIA section 9 (2) a & PA 29 (1) 6-10-2014 to Police Minister’s a Office 2 E-mail Police DCEPA dated OIA section 9 (2) a & PA 29 (1) 7-10-2014 to Police Minister’s a Office 2 E-mail Police DCEPA dated OIA section 9 (2) a & PA 29 (1) 2-10-2014 to Department of a Prime Minister & Cabinet 2 Letter dated 27-11-2014 from OIA section 9 (2) a & PA 29 (1) Police DCEPA a 4/9 Generic Police Media Unredacted responses 10 Police Search Manuel Unredacted chapter 1 10 Police Search Manuel Unredacted chapter 2 10 Police Search Manuel Unredacted Chapter 5 10 Police Search Manuel Unredacted Chapter 13

332 Part 5 – Carrying out search powers with or without warrants, Continued…

Version : 7.0

Search warrants, production orders and examination orders involving media organisations This section contains these topics: • Background • Procedural guidelines (search warrants, production orders and examination orders) • Notice to Crown Prosecutor • Protection of journalists' sources

Background From time to time, news media organisations have information about or record the commission of offences on film, tape, photographs or sound recordings while they are covering newsworthy events. Such media material can be important to subsequent Police enquiries or in judicial proceedings and the Police may be duty bound to obtain: • an examination order for the purpose of seeking information, or • a search warrant or production order for the purpose of seizing or having produced such film, tape, photographs, sound or digital recordings.

However, news media organisations are very sensitive to the Police having recourse to their information or material for any reason and consider such access to be a potential threat to media freedom. Their principal concern is that reporters, film crews and photographers may be at risk if they are ever perceived by offenders as being gatherers of evidence for Police.

To minimise the risk of complaints when the Police execute search warrants on the premises of media organisations or serve production orders or examination orders, and to ensure compliance with the Search and Surveillance Act 2012 you must follow the procedures below.

Procedural guidelines (search warrants, production orders and examination orders) Act only where the offence is serious enough to warrant the obtaining of: • a search warrant, or production order and cannot be otherwise resolved without the seizure of any film, photographs, tape, sound or digital recordings, or • an examination order and cannot be otherwise resolved without obtaining the information.

Follow these general steps (not necessarily in order) in addition to other requirements detailed in the Search chapter for exercising search, production and examination powers generally. Step Action 1 Before you apply for a search warrant or production order obtain the authority of: • a Police Executive member in the case of Police National Headquarters, or • a district commander in the case of a district matter.

If you wish to apply for an examination order you must have the approval of: • a Deputy Commissioner, or • an Assistant Commissioner, or • the District Commander (other than an acting District Commander) of the Police district in which the constable is stationed. 2 Make an application to a Judge unless in the circumstances this is impractical.

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 34 of 36 433

Part 5 – Carrying out search powers with or without warrants, Continued…

Version : 7.0 3 Maintain close liaison with the "manager" of the particular news media premises prior to the execution of the search warrant, production order or examination order. Note: • The exception being where the manager is a suspect or is otherwise involved in the subject matter of the search warrant. • If the manager is a suspect, seek a search warrant rather than a production order.

The reasons for the execution of a search warrant, production order or examination order should always be explained where it is reasonably practical to do so. 4 Be aware that journalists have rights conferred on them under section 68 of the Evidence Act 2006 to protect certain sources.

If you are serving a production or examination order, or intend to exercise a search power under a search warrant on the manager of a news media outlet and you believe they may be able to claim rights to protect certain sources or other privilege, then you: • must give the manager or their lawyer, a reasonable opportunity to claim a privilege recognised under Subpart 5 of Part 4 of the Search and Surveillance Act 2012, and • may, if you are unable to identify or contact the manager or their lawyer, within a reasonable period: - apply to a Judge of the High Court (in relation to journalist's rights to protect certain sources) or to a Judge of the District Court (in respect of all other privileges) for a determination as to the status of the thing, and - do any thing necessary to enable the court to make that determination. (s145) 5 If you receive or expect to receive a claim of privilege and are unable to search a thing pending resolution of the privilege claim, then follow the 'Procedures when searches involve privileged material' (steps 4 to 9) in the chapter "Part 13 - Privilege and immunities under the Act".

Note: You may still secure the thing to be searched, but must not search it, and deliver the thing or copy of it to the court to enable a determination of a privilege claim. 6 Where you use any seized material to facilitate interviews of suspects, you should not disclose the source of the material to the persons being interviewed. 7 Avoid calling news media personnel, such as reporters, film crews or photographers as witnesses. If this is not practicable, serve a witness summons that describes the seized material being produced in evidence, to preserve the impartiality of the witness. 8 In accordance with normal Police practices of evidential disclosure, provide defence counsel with access to seized film, photographs, tape, sound or digital recordings prior to any judicial hearing. 9 You should notify an authorised person who represents the particular news media organisation involved of any film, tape, sound or digital recording or photograph that is copied. The notification should include the reasons and the authorisation for doing so, either under the Search and Surveillance Act 2012 or with consent from that authorised person.

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 35 of 36 434

Part 5 – Carrying out search powers with or without warrants, Continued…

Version : 7.0 10 Advise the Manager: Brand and Media at PNHQ as soon as possible where a search warrant is executed on the premises of a media organisation or a production order or examination order is undertaken, so that any media questions directed to the Commissioner can be quickly dealt with.

Notice to Crown Prosecutor The procedural guidelines must be brought to the notice of the Crown Prosecutor in any case where it is intended to call a member of the news media to give evidence relating to any film, photograph, tape, sound or digital recording seized by Police.

Protection of journalists' sources Note the provision under section 68 and 69 of the Evidence Act 2006. The privilege conferred on journalists under section 68 is recognised for the purposes of the Search and Surveillance Act 2012 (see section 136). See the section 'Procedural guidelines (search warrants, production orders and examination orders involving media organisations' in this chapter.

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 36 of 36 435

Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0

What are recognised privileges? Recognised privileges These privileges are recognised under section 136 of the Search and Surveillance Act 2012. Description Evidence Applicability to Court for Act 2006 power exercised determining (section) claims of privilege (s136(3)) Legal professional privilege, 53(5) Search, examination District Court to the extent that it forms and production part of the general law Privilege for communication 54 Search, examination District Court with legal advisers and production Privilege for preparatory 56 Search, examination District Court material to proceedings and production Privilege for settlement 57 Search, examination District Court negotiations or mediation and production Privilege for communication 58 Search, examination District Court with ministers of religion and production Privilege in criminal 59 Search, examination District Court proceedings for information and production obtained by medical practitioners and clinical psychologists Privilege against self- 60 Examination and District Court incrimination, but only to the production only extent provided in section 138 of the Search and Note: This privilege Surveillance Act does not apply to thing(s) seized under a search power (s136(1)(g)) Privilege for informers 64 Search, examination District Court and production The rights conferred on a 68 Search, examination High Court journalist to protect certain and production sources

Note: No privilege applies in respect of any communication or information if there is a prima facie case that the communication of information is made or received, or compiled or prepared: • for a dishonest purpose, or • to enable or aid any person to commit or plan to commit what the person claiming the privilege knew, or ought reasonably to have known, to be an offence. (s136 (2))

Lawyers' trust accounts The privilege for communications with legal advisers (s54 of the Evidence Act 2006) does not prevent, limit, or affect: • the making of a production order, issuing of a search warrant, or exercise of any other search power in respect of a relevant document, or

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 3 of 9 438 Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0 • the obligation to comply with that production order, search warrant, or other search power in respect of a relevant document, or • the admissibility, in a criminal proceeding for an offence described in the production order, search warrant or for an offence in respect of which any other search power was exercised, of any evidence that relates to the contents of a document obtained under the production order or search warrant, or as the result of the exercise of any other search power. (s137(2)

Meaning of 'document' In the context of legal professional privilege, 'document', means books of account or accounting records kept: • by a solicitor in relation to any trust account money that is subject to section 112 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006; or • by a nominee company that: - is subject to practice rules made by the Council of the New Zealand Law Society under section 96 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006; and - is operated by a barrister and solicitor or an incorporated law firm as a nominee in respect of securities and documents of title held for clients. (s137(1))

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 4 of 9 439 Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0

Procedures when searches involve privileged material Search warrants and other search powers Follow these steps when executing a search warrant or other search power that authorises the search and seizure of any privileged material held by a legal adviser, minister of religion, medical practitioner or clinical psychologist. Step Action 1 Do not execute a search warrant or undertake a warrantless search unless: • the legal adviser, minister of religion, medical practitioner, or clinical psychologist, or • a representative of them is present. (ss143 & 144) 2 If you are unable to contact the legal adviser, minister of religion, medical practitioner, or clinical psychologist or their representative prior to starting the search, you must instead contact: • the New Zealand Law Society, or • the church or professional body to which the person belongs and ask them to appoint a person to represent the interests of their clients, parishioners or patients in relation to the search. 3 Before conducting the search, you must give the legal adviser, minister of religion, medical practitioner, or clinical psychologist, or their representative, or person appointed by their professional body to represent them, a reasonable opportunity to: • claim privilege, or • make an interim claim of privilege if they have not yet been able to contact their client, parishioner or patient for further instructions. 4 If you receive or expect to receive a claim of privilege and are unable to search a thing because of the privilege, you: • may secure the thing (if the thing is intangible (e.g. computer data), do this by making a forensic copy) • may deliver the thing or a copy of it to the court to enable a determination of a privilege claim to be made • must supply the person who may or does claim privilege with a copy of, or access to, the secured thing • must not search the thing secured, unless no claim of privilege is made, or a claim is withdrawn, or the search is in accordance with the directions of the court determining the claim of privilege. (s146) 5 Use the appropriate section 146 'Application for determination of claim of privilege' form located in Police Forms > Search and Surveillance > Privilege, when making an application. Remember: • if the privilege claimed relates to the rights conferred to a journalist to protect certain sources, then use the application addressed to a Judge of the High Court of New Zealand, otherwise for all other privilege claims use the application addressed to the District Court Judge • a person cannot claim privilege against self-incrimination for a thing seized under a search power Note: This privilege only applies when an examination order or production order is being executed. (s136)

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 5 of 9 440 Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0 6 If the person wishes to claim privilege in respect of any thing seized or sought to be seized by you, they must give you a detailed list of the things for which privilege is claimed, as soon as practicable after being: • given the opportunity to claim privilege, or • advised that a search is to be, is being, or has been conducted.

If the thing(s) cannot be adequately detailed, they may apply (with a copy of the secured thing) to a judge for directions or relief.

Note: If you have seized or intend to seize any thing and a detailed list of things for which privilege is claimed is not forthcoming, then instigate an application to the Judge by using the 'Application for relief if claim of privilege cannot be particularised' form located in Police Forms > Search and Surveillance > Privilege. (s147) 7 Complete a POL 268 listing all documents seized before leaving the premises. Show this to the person or their representative who is present and invite them to check the accuracy of the inventory. 8 If they object to the seizure of any document and mark the inventory to that effect: • place the documents objected to in an envelope in their presence and seal it • deliver it as soon as practicable to a district court judge with a brief statement of the facts to determine the claim of privilege. 9 Before removing any document from the premises, give the person or their representative a reasonable opportunity to make a copy of the document if requested. 10 Leave the original POL 268 form with the legal adviser, minister of religion, medical practitioner, or clinical psychologist or their representative.

Discovering privileged material during a search If you are executing a search warrant or another search power and you have reasonable grounds to believe that any thing discovered during the search may be privileged material, then you: • must provide any person who you believe may be able to claim a privilege a reasonable opportunity to claim it, and • may, if you are unable to identify or contact a person who may be able to claim a privilege, or that person’s lawyer, within a reasonable period: - apply to a Judge to determine the status of the thing, and - do anything necessary to enable the court to make that determination.

Note: Use the 'Application for determination of status' form located in Police Forms > Search and Surveillance > Privilege, when making an application. (s145)

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 6 of 9 441 Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0

Privilege relating to production and examination orders Responding to an assertion of privilege A production or an examination order does not affect the privilege against self- incrimination that a person may have under section 60 of the Evidence Act 2006. Any assertion of a privilege against self-incrimination must be based on this section.

If a person refuses to produce any information or document under a production order or to answer any question under an examination order on the ground that it is a privileged communication under section 60 of the Evidence Act 2006, you may apply to a District Court Judge for an order determining whether or not the claim is valid.

Use the section 139 'Application for determination of claim of privilege' form located in Police Forms > Search and Surveillance > Privilege, when making an application. Note: If the privilege claimed involves the rights of journalists to protect certain sources, then use the application form addressed to a Judge of the High Court of New Zealand. In all other privilege cases use the application form addressed to the District Court Judge.

A person seeking privilege must offer sufficient evidence to enable the judge to assess whether self-incrimination is reasonably likely if the person produced the information or document.

If a person against whom a production or examination order is made could assert another privilege in a criminal proceeding, then they have that same privilege in respect of the order. A judge must, on an application, disallow a privilege claim if they are satisfied that the claim to privilege would, under section 67(1) of the Evidence Act 2006, be disallowed in a proceeding.

For the purpose of determining any application for privilege, the judge may require the information or document to be produced.

Note: Section 63 of the Evidence Act 2006 does not apply to production or examination orders. (ss138 & 139)

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 7 of 9 442 Part 13 – Privilege and immunities under the Act, Continued…

Version : 1.0

Effect of privilege claims Effect of privilege on search warrant and other search powers A person who claims privilege in respect of anything that is seized or sought to be seized has the right to: • prevent the search under the Act of any communication or information to which the privilege would apply if it were sought to be disclosed in a proceeding, pending determination of the claim to privilege and later, if the claim is upheld • require the return of a copy of, or access to, any such communication or information to the person if it is seized or secured by a person exercising a search power pending determination of the claim to privilege. (s142)

Admission of evidence when privilege claims are upheld If a Judge upholds a claim to privilege, the communication or information to which the privilege applies is not admissible in any proceedings arising from, or related to the: • execution of the search warrant, or • exercise of another search or surveillance power, or • carrying out of an examination or production order. (s148)

This is an uncontrolled document printed for reference only. The controlled document can be found in the Police Instructions site which is accessible via the New Zealand Police Intranet.

Page 8 of 9 443 LYNCH, David

From: JONES, Karen Sent: Thursday, 2 October 2014 12:34 To: DPMC] Subject: Reactive response re Warrant - heads up re likely media interest

Heads up - fyi this matter is not yet public but may become so as court action is very likely this afternoon.

Police response to Warrant ......

Police confirms it has today removed computers and related items under search warrant from a Wellington address as part of its ongoing investigation into the alleged hacking of Mr Slater's emails.

Police has to date spoken with a number of people as part of the investigation. However, we encourage anyone else who believes they may have information relevant to the investigation to come forward to Police.

ENDS

Karen Jones Deputy Chief Executive: Public Affairs | New Zealand Police P | M | E PNHQ, 180 Molesworth Street, Thorndon, PO Box 3017, Wellington, www.police.govt.nz Safer Communities Together

NZ Police on Facebook

Follow @NZPolice

NZ Police on YouTube

1 445

446

448

449

450

451 #,2/?; (<,

"--/;;/. *628=/ +,<-1/.! 510 $./6<202/9 67< ?,<-1/.

13./8.1/01 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ L^ftF\b`mjiEAQ@ P\_ j J q` Ljo J no`i`_ oj L ^ft F?ECP \i_ I h Bjo^jh

14./0.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//17 D`m\ B `n i A\h`mji QJ?RCP Em`thjpoc+ B _ Ujm _ Uc\ ` M \ D\qjpm 18./0.1/03 /7940 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//64 A\h`mji Q\o`m q ô h 2 L`rn Rc` \oo\^fn r`m` h\_` aj jr ib \ kjno ji c n Uc\ ` M ] jb ji Q\opm_\t hjmi ib+ i A\h`mji QJ?RCP ja ^t]`m ]p t ib rc ^c c` _`n^m ]`_ Hp__ F\ + rcj _ `_ i \ mj\_ ^m\nc ji oc` U`no Aj\no ja oc` Qjpoc n \i_+ \n a`m\ Km Q \o`m n\tn c` n c\_ \ ^jino\io o m\_` ja _`\oc ocm`\on i oc` \no 13 cjpmn onbjoojoc`kjiorc`m` q`\ôp\ tc\_ojhjq`hta\h t+ KmQ\o`moj_P\_jL`r X`\ \i_ P` `\n`_ /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 BmotNj o^n9Fjr L ^ft F?ECP Qjh`r``fn \o`m+jpo jaoc` ]p`+ m`^` q`_\k\^f\b`9\i7 bb\]to`SQ@_bo\ nojm\b` 02./7.1/03 \oo\^fkj o^n n _`q ^`+ oc` ^jioìon ja rc ^c \kk`\m`_ oj c\q` jm b i\o`_ amjh oc` \oo\^f ji Q \o`m n kj nji ib L`r r`]n o` Mi oc` SQ@ r`m` ocjpn\i_n ja _j^phìon oc\o m`q`\ `_ _ aa`mìo k\ on ja oc` X`\ \i_ n kj o ^\ i\o ji\ N\mot \oo\^f kj o ^n+ \ np] `ô oc\o pio ocì c\_ \mb` t ]`ì \ h\oo`m ja ìq mjihìo nk`^p \o ji \i_ _ì \ Rc n r\n q`mt _ aa`mìo amjh ht pnp\ njpm^`n \i_ iq`no b\o jin c\q` ijo pn`_ oc n otk` ja njpm^` ]àjm` ]po ]` `q` ijo \ n ib ` h\ jm i`rn jmb\i n\o ji i oc` ^jpio t rjp _ opmi _jri np^c a\^ i\o ib \i_ hkjmo\io h\o`m \ Qpkk `hìo`_ ]t njh` L\o ji\ N\mot njpm^`n+ o c\n \ jr`_ nojm `n oj ]` oj _ oc\o oc` kp] ^ c\n \ m bco oj fijr c\_ ij k\ o i j]o\ i ib oc` h\o`m \ \i_ ^\iijo n\t \itoc ib ` n` \]jpo on jm b in Rc` iajmh\o ji oc\o \mm q`_ ji oc` SQ@ ^jin no`_ ja ocjpn\i_n ja k\b`n ja ^jiq`mn\o jin ji D\^`]jjf \i_ ]t ` h\ ]òr`ì Q \o`m \i_ c n ^ jn`no kj o ^\ \nnj^ \o`n9 H\nji C_` amjh oc` kmh` h ino`mnjaa ^`+^ jnàmì_\i_^\]iòh ino`m Hp_ocAj in+nom\o`bt ^jinp o\io oj L\o ji\ KNn Q hji Jpnf+ Q \o`m \i_ Jpnf n \kkmìo ^` Hjm_\i U \hn+ oc` m ^ jn` ^j \]jm\ojm B\q _ D\mm\m \i_ \ iòjrmf ja m bco r ib ] jbb`mn Rc`m` r`m` \ nj NP k`jk ` np^c \n A\mm ^f Em\c\h o r\n ^ `\m oc\o oc`n` h\o`m \ n r`m` ji t \ am\ô ji a Q \o`m n _j^phìon+ ]po oc`t b q` \ q q _ k ôpm` ja c n \i_ c n ^j `\bp`n \ô q o `n Rc` kmj `ô r\n np__ì t hp^c r _`m \i_ hjm` hkjmo\io oc\i pno oc` Uc\ ` M ] jb

03./7.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ Ljoo` Q`q`i Qc\mk Ljo U\o^c`_ L ^ft F?ECP

03./7.1/03 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/0 L ^ft F\b`m _ì `n Q`\i NJSLICR Ljo J noì`_ oj L ^ft F?ECP I h Bjo^jh P\_ j J q` iqjq`hìo iBmot Nj o ^n @jjf 03./7.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ L^ftF\b`m9Bmot K f` FMQI LE Ljo J noì`_ oj L ^ft F?ECP Nj o ^n L`rno\ f X@ 511

05./7.1/03 /49// 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//53 Nj o^n n\n`\ut Bpi^\i E?PLCP ]pn i`nn m`b\m_ `nn Rc` Bjh i ji Njno ja rcj n i kjr`m

05./7.1/03 0093/ 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//58 io`mq `r9 Uc\ ` M 2 LCUQ Ljo U\o^c`_ A\h`mji QJ?RCP ] jbb`m A\h`mji Q \o`m 05./7.1/03 03901 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//56 io`mq `r9 A\h`mji N\om ^f EMUCP A\h`mji QJ?RCP Q \o`m J n\ MUCL 2 L`rn

05./7.1/03 05924 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//63 Q \o`m9 B`\oc ocm`\on Rjq\ M @P CL Ljo U\o^c`_ jq`m BmotNj o^n 2 L`rn

06./7.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ L^ftF\b`m Bmot U\ \^` AF?NK?L Ljo J no`i`_ oj L ^ft F?ECP Nj o ^n P\_ j L`r X`\ \i_

06./7.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ BmotNj o^n9\i U\ \^` AF?NK?L Ljo J noì`_ oj Q hji ICJJCP òc^\ hià`_ P\_ j L`r X`\ \i_

06./7.1/03 05938 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///0 Uc\ ` M \ `b`n D` s K?PU AI K?PU AI \i_ EPCCLF?JEF no\o` oc\o QJ?RCP c\n m` `\n`_ o`so h`nn\b`n ji c n ] jb A\h`mji QJ?RCP c\^f ib api_`_ ]t Ac\m ` EPCCLF?JEF ]`or``i I h BMRAMK \i_ U\ti` RCKNCPM QJ?RCP ^ \ hn oc`n` h`nn\b`n kmjq` I h Bjo^jh L`rno\ f X@ BMRAMKk\_ajmcn`h\ noj]`c\^f`_

06./7.1/03 05938 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///0 Uc\`M \ `b`n D` s K?PU AI BMRAMK or``o`_ ji Rr oo`m oc\o Q \o`m n rmjib \i_ \ m bco r ib ^jink m\^t oc`jm no \i_ I h BMRAMK c\^f ib api_`_ ]t Ac\m ` EPCCLF?JEF m`a`mnojKmQ\o`m\n KmBmot@jb Bjo^jh L`rno\ f X@

06./7.1/03 06931 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///1 IhBjo^jhcon]\^f N\om ^` BMSE?L BMSE?L rm o`n oc\o BMRAMK c\n _ì `_ oc` \^^pn\o ji ]t Uc\ ` M ] jbb`m A\h`mji I h BMRAMK \oQ\o`mA\hn LX F`m\ _ QJ?RCP oc\o c` r\n m`nkjin ] ` ajm c\^f ib QJ?RCPQ ] jb r`]n o` `\m `m oc n t`\m BMRAMK n lpjo`_ \n n\t ib q` n\ _ o ]àjm` \i_ n\t o \b\ i oj ]` k`ma`ô t ^ `\m c\_ ijo ib oj _j r oc \it \ `b`_ c\^f ib ?i_ rc ` r` m` ji oc` np] `ô+ c\_ ijoc ib oj _j rocL^ftF\b`mn]jjf+òc`m

06./7.1/03 06931 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///1 I h Bjo^jh c on]\^f N\om ^` BMSE?L F?ECP oj _ RTLX n O ? kmjbm\hh` oj_\t '06./7.1/03( oc\o BMRAMK r\n \]nj po` t L ^ft F?ECP \oQ\o`mA\hn LX F`m\ _ ^\o`bjm ^\ t ijo oc` njpm^` ja iajmh\o ji c` c\_ m`^` q`_ 06./7.1/03 00942 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ B otNj o^n L^ft Mi` L`rn Ljo U\o^c`_ L ^ft F?ECP F\b`m9 Qjpm^` oj m` `\n` iajmh\o ji 512

06./7.1/03 06931 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///1 IhBjo^jhcon]\^f N\om ^` BMSE?L BMSE?L lpjo`n QJ?RCP U` \ fijr ]t ijr oc\o c\_ ht `h\ n c\^f`_ i D`]pm\mt+ v A\h`mji QJ?RCP \oQ\o`mA\hn LX F`m\ _ r` \ nj fijr oc\o B\q _ D?PP?P c\n c\_ c n io` `ôp\ kmjk`mot noj ì+ \i_ oc\o K\mf K RAFCJJc\_cnk`mnji\ `h\ nc\^f`_\i_cnjaa^`]mjfì ioj Uc\o ^\i\njm`q`\ n oc\o Rjit JCLR LM+ oc` ]pn i`nnh\i rcj ajmh`m t a i\i^ \ t npkkjmo`_ I h BMRAMK \ nj c\_ c n jaa ^` ]mjfì ioj 06./7.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ io`mq`rrocL^ft Em\`h` F JJ Ljo J noì`_ oj L ^ft F?ECP F\b`mh \pocjm ja P\_ j J q` B ot Nj o ^n

07./7.1/03 04948 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///2 Aj in b\q` j] oj N\om ^f EMUCP EMUCP m`kjmo`_ oc\o c`.nc` oc` c\^f`mZ ^m`\o`_ \ or oo`m \^^jpio+ ^\ `_ Uc\ `_phk+ >Uc\ `_phk Uc\ ` M o kno`m 2 L`rn \i_kjno`_hjm``h\ nji o+ pno fòc`ji`n oc`tn\toc`tnìoojL^ftF\b`majmcn ]jjf 07./7.1/03 04948 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///2 Aj inb\q` j]oj N\om ^f EMUCP Km ?\mji @F?RL?ECP n oc` h\i Km F\b`m n\tn a mno rìo in _` J\]jpm n ^jhkpo`mn L ^ft F?ECP Uc\ ` M o kno`m 2 L`rn ]àjm` o` ib Uc\ ` M + rcj ojjf \_q\io\b` Km @F?RL?ECP n am ì_ ja Q \o`m n rcj o kk`_ c h jaa oj \ n`^pm ot a \r i J\]jpm n r`]n o` 07./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///3 F\b`m ]jjf9 k`mnji Rc` L\o ji\ Rcmjpbc c n jm c`m >Uc\ `_phk or oo`m \^^jpio oc` k`mnji rcj ^ \ hn oj ]` oc` Uc\ ` >Uc\ `_phk ^ \ h ib oj ]` c\^f`m @pn i`nn P`q `r M c\^f`m c\n ijr kjno`_ ifn oj n`q`m\ n^m`ì ncjon ja `h\ n ^jh`n ajmr\m_

07./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///3 F\b`m]jjf9k`mnji Rc` L\o ji\ Qk`\f ib ji P\_ j J q` \o h __\t+ L ^ft F?ECP n\ _ c` r\n pi\] ` oj n\t a Uc\ `_phk L ^ft F?ECP ^ \ h ib oj ]` c\^f`m @pn i`nn P`q `r r\n oc` m`\ _`\ ^jh`n ajmr\m_

07./7.1/03 00930 00./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//70 Uc\ ` M c\^f`m 2 L`rn ji i` no\aa KmF\b`m^\hnc`r\nnìo\SQ@h`hjmtno^frococ` _\o\ji o+]poc\nni^`nìo o L ^ft F?ECP pk j\_n `h\ 2 L`rn ]\^f oj c n njpm^` n^m`ìncjon 07./7.1/03 05905 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//23 Uc\ `_phk \^^jpio @mjjf Q\] i oj `\f hjm` 2 L`rn _j^phìon 07./7.1/03 07905 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///4 F\^f`_ `h\ n ? h`` ESJJ TCP Rc n \ao`mijji oc` >Uc\ `Bphk Rr oo`m \^^jpio if`_ oj \ u ka ` ji oc` K`b\ ^j iu >Uc\ `_phk m`q`\ `_ ji i` K ^c\` DMV r`]n o` rc ^c ^jio\ i`_ 01 a `n oc\o \kk`\m oj ]` n^m`ìbm\]n ja `h\ n nìo oj \i_ amjh F\h nc Q \o`m n bh\ \^^jpio PSRFCPDMPB Qopaa ^j iu 07./7.1/03 07905 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///4 F\^f`_`h\ n ? h`` ESJJ TCP F\b`m n\ _ c` c\_ ijo n`ì oc` Rr oo`m \^^jpio \i_ c\_ ijo c`\m_ amjh c n njpm^` \]jpo L ^ft F?ECP m`q`\ `_ ji i` K ^c\` DMV oc` m ioìo ji oj m` `\n` oc` iajmh\o ji F\h nc \h ijo ^`mo\ i rcj n ]`c i_ oc` \^^jpioZ oc if o n f` t oc\o oc n r ]` ht njpm^` PSRFCPDMPB m`nkji_ ib oj oc` m`lp`no oc\o ^\h` oj m` `\n` oc` h\o`m \ Qopaa ^j iu F\b`m n\_ c` c\_ nkjfì r oc c n njpm^` \o oc` r``fì_ oj omt oj bò njh` ja oc` iajmh\oji]\^f ijm_`mojm``\n` o \i_oc`tn\_9 J`\qòcnojh` o njpi_`_ f` oc`t r`m` bj ib oj _j njhòc ib ]po _ _i o c\q` \it hjm` _ò\ F` r` ^jh`_ oc` _phk 07./7.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//24 Fjr >rc\ `_phk K\moti @P?B@SPW h bco _`noj t oc` Rc` B\ t @ jb kjkp \m qjo` ajm 513 L\o ji\ 06./7.1/03 /49// 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//86 N\om ^f Ejr`m9 I`t n N\om ^f EMUCP r`\f if n ì`ht LX F`m\ _ r oc i 07./7.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//26 >Uc\ `_phk jjfn Nò` E`jmb` a nct Wjpm LX 08./7.1/03 /7945 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///5 Uct oc` Uc\ `_phk B\q _ D QFCP D QFCP no\o`_ "oc` a mno ^jio\ô Yr oc oc` c\^f`mZ ^\h` ji` r``f \bj Y01.7.03Z+ F?AICP F\^f`m ^\h` ajmr\m_ LX F`m\ _ ncjmo t \ao`m \pocjm L ^ft F?ECP \iijpi^`_ c` c\_ \ i`r ]jjf ^jh ib- r\n h\_` ocmjpbc ì^tko`_ `h\ \i_ njpbco \ jpmi\ no n k `_b` ja njpm^` kmjo`ô ji-" " o r\nio pio Qpi_\ti bco Y06./7.1/03Z oc`F`m\ _r\n\] òj ^jia mh oc` k`mnjir\nbìp i` oc`tkmjq_`_ _ò\ nrc ^c h\o^c`_ roc iajmh\o ji b\oc`m`_ amjh \ijoc`m njpm^` Bò\ n r`m` kmjq _`_ rc ^c h\o^c`_ iajmh\o ji b\oc`m`_ amjh joc`m njpm^`n-" "?i_ ocì ^\h` oc` a mno "_phk"+ \n oc` c\^f`m ^\ `_ o"- "Djpm t`\mn ja Q \o`m n`h\ ^jhhpi^\o jin roc\i `s kmjno opo`r`m` h\_` \q\ \] ` ajm _jri j\_ amjh oc` a `nc\m ib n o` K`b\-^j-iu" " cì oc` k`mnji `h\ `_oc`ji tkp] ^^jhhìooc`t ioì_ oj h\f`+_ìtib kj o ^\ hjo q\o ji ]po \ _`n m` oj "o\f` _jri oc n ^jmmpko iòrjmf"- "Kt i`so ]\o^c ja `\fn r kmjq` oc n"" 08./7.1/03 0194/ /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///6 Q \o`m ^jhkpo`m c\^f 2 L`rn \ `b\o ji \nn`nn`_ ]t kj ^` 08./7.1/03 03928 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//62 Aj in pir n` oj Q hji UMLE k\nn iajmh\o ji oj 2 L`rn Q \o`m 1/./7.1/03 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//52 LpfòcÙc\` Di`RjjocAjphi

10./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///7 Uc\`M 9pkojoc`m L`r X`\ \i_ Ucì c` YQJ? CPZ \kk\ p_`_ oc` _`\oc ja \ "a`m\ " U`no Aj\no`m oc` kjno oc\o i`^fn J noì`m npkkjn`_ t i^ o`_ F?ECP n njpm^` oj c\^f oc` Uc\ ` M n o`- 10./7.1/03 05942 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//61 I`t ^\o`bjm ^\ t Q hji UMLE Ljo U\o^c`_ _ì`n Q\o`mM? 2 L`rn _ n^pnn ji 11./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0///8 Q \o`m a\^`n B\q _ D QFCP "QJ? CPa `_ \^jhk\ ioroc oc` Nmq\^tAjhhnnji`m\ao`mF?ECPpn`_ t`\mnja A\h`mji QJ?RCP kmjn`^po ji ajm LX F`m\ _ c\^f`_ `h\ \i_ nj^ \ h`_ \ ^jiq`mn\o jin oj rm o` oc` ]jjfv" ]m`\^c ib km q\^t

11./7.1/03 02934 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//65 Q \o`m kmjn`^po`_ ajm 2 L`rn ji i` no\aa " c`_m`ôjmjaFph\iPbconNmj^``_ibn no\fibocÙc\`M ]jbb`moj^jpmo Q hji HSBB pn ib km q\o` 2 L`rn jq`m a q` _\tn i Môj]`m ajm ]m`\^c ib oc` km q\^t ja ]pn i`nnh\i K\oo @ jha ` _-" iajmh\o ji 12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//0/ Uc\ ` M \i_ am ì_n Nc R?WJMP Nmjq _`n iajmh\o ji \]jpo H\nji CBC; Q hji JSQI; A\mm ^f EP?F?K; I\oc`m i` LX F`m\ _ P AF; A\oct MBECPQ 12./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//00 R _\ r\q` ja _ mo oc\o B\q _ D QFCP D QFCP no\o`n " c`m` n \i \rap ojo\ ot+ rc ^c \kk`\mn oj c\q` \ nj hjo q\o`_ oc` L ^ft F?ECP ^jp _ nr\hk ``ô ji LX F`m\ _ c\^f`m rcj ]mjf` ioj oc` n o` \ao`m oc` "a`m\ " ^jhhìo i H\ip\mt-" 514 "" c`\m_ \ mphjpm \]jpo njh`ji` rcj c\_ njh` nopaa+" n\tn F\b`m+ rcjn` ]jjfn ji nk `n c\q` bì`m\o`_ ^jio\ôn i ^ m^ `n- "F` \ m`\_t c\_ \ k \i i c n h i_ oj nòpk\ roo`m\^^jpio\i_nk\nc o\ jpooc`m`-" F\b`m n\tn c` nkìo r``fn o\ f ib oc` k`mnji ioj òo ib c h n`` oc` h\o`m \ \i_ pn` o oj ]p _ oc` i\mm\o q` rc ^c ]`^\h` B mot Nj o ^n- c` c\^f`m+ n\tn F\b`m+ b\q` c h `q`mtoc ib- " q` n`ì `q`mtoc ib- h 0// k`m ^ìo npm`-" c` c\^f`m ocì `skm`nn`_ \ _`nm` oj f``k ]\^f njh` h\o`m \ ajm c hn` a- "U` f i_ ja i`bjo \o`_ cjr hp^c+" c` n\tn- " n\ _ ^\i c\q` \ oc` kj o ^\ nopaa -" F\b`m bjo rc\o c` \nf`_ ajm \i_ nj+ oc` ]jjf r\n rm ooì-"

12./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//00 R_\ r\q`ja_mooc\o B\q _ D QFCP "F` YF\^f`mZ `h`mb`_ ji Kji_\t pno \n L\o ji\ n _ì \ n r`m` ]`^jh ib F?AICP ^jp _ nr\hk ``ô ji LX F`m\ _ nom_ìo roc\k`_bòjm``\n`njpm^` iajmh\ojikp] ^t- icnjitkp] ^ ^jhhìonja\m+c`n\_9" cn niokj o^\ thjoq\o`_- hijok\_oj_jocn- h ijo \nnj^ \o`_ roc Y io`miò N\mot ajpi_`mZ I h Bjo^jh i \it r\t- r\io oj o\f` _jri oc n ^jmmpko iòrjmf \i_ h\f` npm` o ^\i o ]` kpo ]\^f ojbòc`m- Kt i`so ]\o^c ja `\fn r kmjq` oc n-"

12./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//00 R_\ r\q`ja_mooc\o B\q _ D QFCP F`YK\mfK AFCJJZnk`\fnjaoc`]m`\f iojcnU` ibojijaa^`+oc` \o`m K\mf K RAFCJJ ^jp _ nr\hk ``ô ji LX F`m\ _ ]pmb \mt ja c n Pj_i`t ` `ôjm\o` jaa ^` \i_ oc` c\^f ib- " ^cjn` oj om`\o oc`n` oc ibn \n m\i_jh `qìon- Qjh` ja oc` iajmh\o ji r` q` n`ì ^jh` jpo m`^ìo t c\n h\_` h` m` `q\ p\o` oc\o-" c`m` c\q` ]`ì o`so h`nn\b`n kp] nc`_ i rc ^c Bjo^jh o\ fn \]jpo o\mbò ib Uc\ ` M oc` ot^jji n\tn o c\n ijoc ib oj_j roc m`^ìo `qìon ]po kj ion oj \i pk^jh ib_à\h\o ji \ô ji \b\ ino oc` ] jbb`m-

12./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//00 R_\ r\q`ja_mooc\o B\q _ D QFCP "Mi` hj_`m\ojm+ Nò` @` o+ oj _ oc` ^jhhpi ot \no r``f9 "Jjon ja oc ibn r` _j Nò` @CJR '] jb ^jp _ nr\hk ``ô ji LX F`m\ _ c`m` r ]` ^jin _`m`_ piòc ^\ ]t k`jk `- Coc ^\ ni o njhòc ib r` \m` rjmm `_ hj_`m\ojm( \]jpo- Mi t `b\ -"" 12./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//00 R_\ r\q`ja_mooc\o B\q _ D QFCP "Ajhkpo`m n`^pm ot n \ nj \ ^ji^`mi- Njp nji npnk`ôn c n ^jhkpo`m c\n ]`ì Rm\q n NMSJQML ^jp _ nr\hk ``ô ji LX F`m\ _ pi_`m \oo\^f or ^` n i^` F\b`m n ]jjf ^\h` jpo- " ^\i o n`` rc\o \oo\^f ib h` rjp_]miboj\ithjoq`-?itocibkj o^\ A\hrjp_f``kojchnà-"

12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//01 K i no`mn no\aa`m ojjf B\q _ D QFCP "L ^f @mt\io r\n i\h`_ i B mot Nj o ^n \n oc` k`mnji rcj c\_ pn`_ oc` L ^ft F?ECP k\ o i ] jb LX F`m\ _ kn`p_jith "Djmh`m F\^f" oj kjno \ijithjpn ^jhhìon ì^jpm\b ib ] jbb`m A\h`mjiQ \o`mn^\hk\bi\b\ ino\kp] ^n`mq\iorc ^cm`np o`_ i _`\oc ocm`\on-" 12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//01 Kino`mnno\aa`mojjf B\q _ D QFCP " c`F`m\_r\n\]òj^jiamhoc`pn`jaKm@mt\ionhino`m\ ^jhkpo`m \ o`mi\o q` njpm^` k\ o i ] jb LX F`m\ _ ocmjpbc _ò\ n j]o\ i`_ amjh \i i_ q _p\ joc`m oc\i oc` c\^f`m rcj \ nj \^^`nn`_ iajmh\o ji amjh Uc\` M _pmiboc`Bì \ jaQ`mq^`\oo\^f-" 12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//01 Kino`mnno\aa`mojjf B\q _ D QFCP "Ucì \nf`_ a c` pn`_ oc` i\h` "Djmh`m F\^f" oj _j nj+ c` n\ _9 "L ^ft F\b`m n\ _ L ^f @PW?LR k\ o i ] jb LX F`m\ _ r\n oc` k`mnji rcj kjno`_ \n oc\o-"" 'ajmh`m c\^f(

12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//01 Kino`mnno\aa`mojjf B\q _ D QFCP j_jaocì`r iajmh\oji+Km@mt\ion\_9"Uc\o r n\t n nojkk`_ L ^f @PW?LR k\ o i ] jb LX F`m\ _ ^jhhìo ib \mjpi_ oc\o o h`- c`t r`m` \]jpo oc` ji t ^jhhìon h\_` ji oc\o 'ajmh`m c\^f( ] jb-" 12./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//01 Kino`mnno\aa`mojjf B\q _ D QFCP A\h`mji QJ?RCP k\ o i ] jb LX F`m\ _ Q\o`m__ijomòpmi^\ n-F`__nì_\i`h\ n\tib9" hàjm\ tjpm`h\ noj ^jh` jpo D nc-" 515 12./7.1/03 /3910 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//50 Rc` rc\o oc\o Rj]t K?LF PC nr\ jr`_ L`r Rc` Ep\m_ \i X`\ \i_ n ` `ô ji ^\hk\ bi 12./7.1/03 04945 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//6/ Aj in màpn`n oj @mjjf Q?@ L Ljo U\o^c`_ \kj jb n` ajm \ `b`_ 2 L`rn `\f oj Q \o`m

13./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//02 Rc` c\^f`m m`q`\ `_ K\oo L NNCPR K\o`m \ r\n kmjq _`_ oj D? PD?V KCB ? ]t P?UQF?PI+ ojo\ ib 4/K@+ i^ p_`_ P?UQF?PI D? PD?V iqj ^`n+ ^jmkjm\o` k o^c _j^phìon+ \i_ cpi_m`_n ja k\b`n ja D\^`]jjf h`nn\b ib- c`t no\o` oc` iajmh\o ji m` \o`n oj Q \o`mn ^jhh`m^ \ \i_ ^jmkjm\o` ifn+ ^c à t ocmjpbc Q\o`mn jib o hàm ì_ A\mm ^fEP?F?K-

13./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//02 Rc`c\^f`mm`q`\`_ K?RRLNNCPR " h ijo tjpm mpi ja oc` h c\^f`m+" P\rnc\mf in no`_ \no r``f- "Uc ^c h`\in P?UQF?PI D? PD?V oc`m`\mìo h\it f` h` jpo oc`m`-Uc^c h`\inoc\o \nnjji \nk`jk` pi_`mno\i_ ht hjo q\o jin+ oc` no ja npnk`ôn i\mmjrn _jri oj ji`-" P\rnc\mf n\ _ c` r\n pi^ji^`mi`_ ]t r _ nk`^p \o ji jq`m c n _ìo ot+ \i_ ^\h`_oc`m`q`\ojinc`c`k`_]miboj bcor`m` hkjmo\io-" _jiom`\ thi_ k`jk ` oc if ib h \ 04 t`\m j _ _j ib o ajm oc` p u- o n n\a`m oc\o r\t+ \i_ o _j`ni o h\f` \ _ aa`mì^` ojr\m_n ht bj\ rc ^c n oj o\f` _jri oc` iòrjmf+" P\rnc\mf n\ _- P`kjmo ib oc n n\b\ c\n iqj q`_ ^jin _`m\] ` k\m\ij \ \i_ _\o\ n`^pm ot h`\npm`n ji ]joc n _`n- P\rnc\mf+ a`\m ib \mm`no ajm c\^f ib+ in non ji ^jhhpi ^\o ib ocmjpbc ì^mtko`_ `h\ n mjpo`_ ocmjpbc ^jhkpo`mn mpii ib oc` n`^pm` \ n jk`m\o ib ntno`h- 14./7.1/03 /1934 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//5/ Bmotkj o^n9L`r ?iojit JMUCLQRC L X`\ \i_ n jri Fjpn` Rc` Ep\m_ \i ja A\m_n n ^j \kn ib

14./7.1/03 /4906 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//03 Bjo^jh ]j\non ja B\q _ D?PP?P Bjo^jh_ì `n c`xnoc` c\^f`m ]`c i_ B mot Nj o ^n+ ]po \o oc` k\motxn ^\hk\ bi I h BMRAMK c\^f ib \ NK \i_ I r ] jb \pi^c oj_\t n\ _ oc n- màpn`n ^jhhìo y c\^f`_ jpm E`mh\i^m`_ o m\o ibntno`h \i_kpo jpm Nm h`K ino`mxn^m`_ o m\o ib oj u`mj ]`^\pn` _ _ixo f` oc` bpt+z n\ _ Bjo^jh- yWjp c\q` \ a bpm`_ ]t ijr oc`m`xn\ijoc`mNmh`K i no`m _jixo f`-z 14./7.1/03 /4906 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//03 Bjo^jh ]j\non ja B\q _ D?PP?P D?PP?P ocì h\f`n oc` aj jr ib no\o`hìon "0( Bjo^jh c\n ^jiq ô jin ajm c\^f ib \ NK \i_ I r ] jb c\^f ib1( Bjo^jh n q`mt r`\ oct 2( Bjo^jh c\o`n Q \o`m \i_ I`t 3( K\it `s màpn`n ^jhhìo Bjo^jh am ì_n \i_ no\aa`mn r`m` b q ib iajmh\o ji oj Q \o`m 4( Bjo^jh t`no`m_\t ]j\no`_ oc\o c`c\^f`_oc` E`mh\iNK ]`^\pn`c`_ _io f` ch 5( Bjo^jhn ^c\i^`n ja ijo ]` ib `som\_ o`_ oj oc` Si o`_ Qo\o`n \m` cpb` t ìc\i^`_ a c` h\i\b`_ oj ^c\ib` oc` Ejq`mihìo-" 14./7.1/03 0/926 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//04 Bjo^jh _ì `n c` n K\ooc`r I h BMRAMK ]`c i_ oc` Uc\ ` M @J?AIFMSQC I h Bjo^jh n\tn c n ^jhhìon t`no`m_\t \]jpo c\^f ib oc` E`mh\i Nm h` c\^f ib LX F`m\ _ Kino`mn^m`_om\oibc\_ijociboj_jrococ`c\^fibjaocÙc\`M ]jb- 516 Mi P\_j L`r X`\ \i_ ocn hjmi ib+ Bjo^jh n\_ oc`nojmtc\_ ijoc ib oj _j roc oc`c\^fibjaA\h`mjiQ\o`mnUc\`M ]jb- 14./7.1/03 029// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//05 B\q_ Dnc`m9Kt B\q _ D QFCP cnoj tr ocA\h`mji LX F`m\ _ Q \o`m 14./7.1/03 07904 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//06 Bjo^jh \_h on c` Rjq\ M @P CL M@PCLm`kjmonoc\oBM AMKn\tnBjo^jhnr`\mnjioc` q`njacnaq`^c _mì I h BMRAMK ^jp _ kjoìo \ t 2 L`rn c`c\_ijociboj_jrocL^ftF\b`mn]jjfBmotNj o^njmc\^fibocÙc\`M c\^fQ\o`mn`h\ n `h\ n o r\n ]\n`_ pkji+ ]po c` n\tn ^jp _ c\^f Q \o`m n ^jhkpo`m a c` r\io`_ oj- Fn^mhi\ k\nor\nm__`_rocc\^fib^jiqôjin+ i^p_ib_\o\`nkji\b`\i_ ^jhkpo`m am\p_- F` ^ \ hn oc` Nìo\bji \i_ L?Q? r`m` \hjib oc` q ô hn-

16./7.1/03 00916 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//07 Ac à Mh]p_nh\i oj B\q _ D QFCP B\h` @`q`m `t YU?ICKZ+ rcj _ _ ijo r\io oj ^jhhìo ji F\b`m n ]jjf+ n\ _ B\h` @`q`m t kmj]` h i no`m \ LX F`m\ _ nnp`n ]àjm` oc` Maa ^` ja oc` Mh]p_nh\i m\ n`_ ^ji^`min \]jpo oc` ^\k\^ ot oj U?ICK jaa ^`n c\i_ ` m`lp`non \i_ kj ^ `n pn`_ ]t _`k\mohìon+ m\oc`m oc\i \it \ `b`_ mjmo ib ja oc` ntno`h- " c\qì o j]n`mq`_ \itoc ib n i no`m- 17./7.1/03 03907 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//08 Ejjb `+ D\^`]jjf \i_ ?_\h @CLLCRR Q \o`m r\n oj_\t `sk`ô ib hjm` ja c n h`nn\b`noj]` h\_` kp] ^ ]t oc` c\^f`m A\h`mji QJ?RCP Rr oo`m oj ]` lpuu`_ LX F`m\ _ oj_\t- i F\^f ib iq`no b\o ji Q \o`m "J\no i bco Y16./7.1/03Z \o oc\o h`ò ib Y i ?p^f \i_Z F\b`m r\n o\ f ib \]jpo oc`m` n hjm` nopaa ^jh ib jpo r` cjr _j`n c` fijr= F` n j]q jpn t bjo oj ]` i ^jio\ô r oc oc` c\^f`m-" 17./7.1/03 05930 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//1/ BmotNj o^nc\^f`m B\q _ D QFCP "? `\f n \ n\aòt q\ q` i nj^ òt \i_ oc` Uc\ `j c\^f`m n \ "_`^ìo \i_ òc ^\ L ^ft F?ECP _`^ìo \i_ òc ^\ LX F`m\ _ k`mnji"+BmotNj o^n\pocjmL^ftF\b`moj_\k\^f`_c\ jak`jk` i?p^f\i_ k`mnji \no i bco-" 17./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//10 KN Ajin _`mn `b\ Pj_i`t R h`n \ô ji \b\ ino L ^ft F\b`m 18./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//11 K\iamjhhinomt B\q _ D QFCP D QFCP m`kjmon oc\o "\]jpo 47// ^jhhìon r`m` h\_` pi_`m oc` kn`p_jith- c` iq`no b\o`_ jq`m ] jb LX F`m\ _ h`nn\b`nr`m` if`_ oj\n`mq`m]` jibibojoc`hi nomt\i_ i^p_` iajmh\oji rc ^c \kk`\mn oj _ìo at c h-" " c` h`nn\b`n r`m` j]o\ i`_ amjh oc` Uc\ ` M n o` \i_ h\_` \q\ \] ` oj oc` F`m\ _-" " o nocjpbco oc`tr`m` o\fì\o oc` n\hò h` \n iajmh\o jik\nn`_ oj L^ft F\b`majmpn` ic nBmotNj o^n]jjf+]poijo]t oc` n\h`k`mnji-" 2/./7.1/03 01900 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//12 F\b`m n m` \o jinc k ?]] ` L?N CP L?N CP m`kjmo`_ oc\o "F` YF?ECPZ _`n^m ]`_ om\^f ib _jri oc` c\^f`m rcj L ^ft F?ECP r oc c\^f`m m`q`\ `_ Rc` Nm`nn \oo\^f`_ Q\o`mxn ntno`h\i_ nkì_ibr``fn^jiqiîbc hojnc\m`c n 517 iajmh\o ji- F\b`m kmjh n`_ c` rjp _ ìnpm` oc` iajmh\o ji m` `\n` r\n wwnjhòc ib hjm` \no ib\i_ja ] bb`m q\ p`xx oc\i oc` c\^f`mxn k\ii`_ roo`m _phk- F` n\ _ fijr ib oc` njpm^` ja iajmh\o ji \i_ oc` m hjo q`n ajm m` `\n ib o r\n `nnìo \ - ww fijrchYoc`c\^f`mZr` ijr+\i_ ompnoch+xxc`n\_-wwFnhjoq\ojir\n oc\o A\h`mji Q \o`m r\n \ ]\no\m_ \i_ r`x _j c h jq`m-xx ww c` m`\nji c` \oo\^f`_ c h r\n c` ocjpbco c` r\n \ k)))) xx" 2/./7.1/03 02913 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//87 Rc` `h\ oc\o R h Kpmkct+ Qc\ti` " \njnkjf`\o ìbocrococ`Kino`mm`nkjin]òj_\t'Hp_otAj in(-Qc` n A\h`mji QJ?RCP ]mjpbco _jri Hp_ oc Apmm ` bpii ib ajm D`` `t- ?it iajmh\o ji oc\o r` ^\i kmjq _` c`m ji c n ]\^fbmjpi_ n Aj in LX F`m\ _ \kkm`^ \o`_- c\q` jpo i`_ ajm c`m \ ^jh ib ] jb kjno \]jpo oc` h\nn q` no\aa opmijq`m \i_ nc` c\n \__`_ oc\o oj oc` m`q `r ja oc` Qo\o` Q`mq ^`n Ajhh nn ji`m- Qc` npniboc`m`q`rjaoc`n``qìonojbjji\om\r jjfibajm\itocib`n`- o nhtjkijioc\oD```tnkjnoji npioì\]`-"

2/./7.1/03 0393/ 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0// hoc`q^ohja\ B`m`f AFCLE Hp_ oc AMJJ LQ nh`\m ^\hk\ bi9 LX F`m\ _ Hp_ocAj inm`nbin

2/./7.1/03 /49// /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/012 K^c` `F`ronji L ^ft F?ECP io`mq `r9 L ^ft F\b`m K^c` `FCURQML LX F`m\ _ 20./7.1/03 0092/ /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//13 Qj F\b`m `_ \]jpo A\h`mji QJ?RCP ijo fijr ib rcj oc` Uc\ ` M c\^f`m r\n 20./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//14 ? ocài\i^`mnhì K\ooLNNCPR L NNCP no\o`noc\o" c`kôpm` nk\io`_]t\^\^c`ja`h\ n\i__j^phìon P?UQF?PI D? PD?V c\^f`_ amjh Uc\ `j ] jbb`m A\h`mji Q \o`m \i_ m` `\n`_ oj D\ ma\s K`_ \-" c` _j^phìon+ kmjq _`_ ]t q b \io` c\^f`m P\rnc\mf+ _ò\ ^jhh`m^ \ ifn ]òr`ì Q \o`m \i_ c n jib o h` am ì_ \i_ oj]\^^j j]]t no A\mm ^f Em\c\h-

20./7.1/03 /49// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//15 P`\ m`\nji ]`c i_ K\oo L NNCPR F\^f`_ `h\ n \kk`\m oj ncjr Fjo^c i n`^mò t k\ _ ] jbb`mn A\h`mji Q \o`m \i_ A\oct P?UQF?PI Hp_ oc Aj in _`h n` D? PD?V M_b`mn oj rm o` \oo\^f kjnon pi_`mh i ib oc` Q`m jpn Dm\p_ Maa ^`+ on _ m`ôjm ?_\h D`` `t+ \i_ oc` D i\i^ \ K\mfòn ?pocjm ot+ rcj r`m` kmj] ib c n ^j \kn`_ F\ijq`m D i\i^` i 1/00 \i_ 1/01 Iijr ib D\ a\s r\n iq`no b\o ib oc` c\^f`_ `h\ n+ o n ]` `q`_ M_b`mn 'fijri ]t oc` ] jb i\h` A\ôpn I\o`( rìo ocmjpbc c`m jri `h\ n \i_ ajpi_ njh` oc\o ^jp _ ]` n`ì \n hk ^\o ib Aj in Rc n ^jmm`nkji_ì^` ocì ajpi_ on r\t oj \ @``c q` no\aa`m ji Dm _\t i a\ô+ D\ ma\s _ _ ijo c\q` oc\o k\mo ^p \m i^m h i\o ib `h\ + \i_ oc` c\^f`m fijri \n P\rnc\mf n\ _ t`no`m_\t c` _ _ ijo c\q` o ` oc`m Rc\o `h\ r\ni o `\f`_ ]t h`+ c\_ ijocib oj_jr oc o+ n\_P\rnc\mf+rcjr\n\nj oc`njpm^àjmL^ftF\b`mn ]jjfBmot Nj o ^n

20./7.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//2/ Uct r` ocjpbco rc\o Ppnn` @mjri r` ocjpbco F\m_ L`rn /0./8.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//18 L`rnc o c\n^jhòj Dm\i M QSJJ T?L bco Rc` B h Njno /0./8.1/03 029// /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//16 ?i_ c`m` r\n h` A\h`mji QJ?RCP oc if ib F\b`m rjp _ Uc\ ` M pno ]pb h` 518 0.8.1/03 05914 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//38 F\^f`m m` `\n`n i`r B\q _ D QFCP " c`F`m\_ ijrc\n iajmh\ojikpmkjmoib oj ]` nj^\ h`_ \^jiq`mn\ojin\i_ Aj in ^jiq`mn\o jin LX F`m\ _ `h\ n ]òr`ì KnAj in\i_oc` ]jbb`m A\h`mji Q \o`m-"

/0./8.1/03 069/2 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//76 @ jbb`mn o\mb`o`_ K\oo L NNCPR ]pn i`nn jpmi\ no D? PD?V /0./8.1/03 06901 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//57 Aj in_`i`nQ\o`m 2 L`rn ji i` no\aa Hp_ oc AMJJ LQ ^jiq`mn\o ji 2 L`rn

/0./8.1/03 0892/ 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//60 QQ+Q\o`m ilp t Q hji Ujib ink`ôjm Eì`m\ r oi`nn`n oj ]` pi_`m 2 L`rn ja io` bì^` \i_ j\oc Q`^pm ot /1./8.1/03 /49// 00./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//74 Ucj n iq`no b\o ib ? h`` ESJJ TCP rcj= D? PD?V /1./8.1/03 0/9// /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//43 Hjpmijn njp 2 L`rn n`\m^c ib \ao`m \o`no BmotNj o^n `\fn

/1./8.1/03 0/902 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//51 Acm n @\moji9 Acm n @?PRML R`^cij jbt h\f`n LX F`m\ _ ^jmmpko ji kjnn ] ` /1./8.1/03 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//20 I`t nc\mf ] o` t`o oj N`o` E`jmb` Rc`m` \m` mphjpmn oc\o >Uc\ `_phk r m` `\n` \ oc` h\o`m \ m` \o`_ oj oc` I`t if+ >Uc\ `_phk ^jh`= Wjpm LX ^jhhpi ^\o jin iqj q ib H\nji C_`+ ]po oc\oxn ijo rc\o >Uc\ `_phk c\n i_ ^\o`_

/1./8.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//25 Uc\`Bphk E`iiKAAMLLCJJ Rj_\t oc` >Uc\ `Bphk c\^f`m b\q` \i `s^ pn q` oj 2 L`rn Nj o ^\ C_ ojm+ N\om ^f Rc` @``c q` Ejr`m ]`ajm` m` `\n ib oc n oji bco K\i_\o`

/1./8.1/03 079/4 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//4/ F\^f`m9 Q \o`m+ Aj in N\om ^f EMUCP Ljo U\o^c`_ Rc n o h` oc` B mot Nj o ^n c\^f`m ^jio\ô`_ 2 L`rn oj n\t9 Hp_ oc Aj in \i_ A\h`mji F?AICP D\^`]jjf h`nn\b`n 2 L`rn Q \o`m \m` t ib \pocìo ^ Qj oc\o n rc\o oc` c\^f`m+ rcj bj`n ]t oc` \ \n`n Uc\ `_phk \i_ P\rnc\mf+ _ _ Rc` c\^f`m ocì m` `\n`_ oj 2 L`rn hjm` h`nn\b`n o n\tn _ìo at oc` pn`m \n Kn Aj in+ n\t ib9 Rc`t oc if oc`t ^\i bò \r\t r oc o Rc\o n nopk _ Rc` ^jioìo ja oc` hi`nn\b`n _ìo at oc` D\^`]jjf pn`m \n Hp_ oc Aj in+ ^ `\m \n _\t

/2./8.1/03 /49// 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//78 @m \i Pp_h\i9 @m \i Pp_h\i Bjo^jh n ]`ì LX F`m\ _ k kk`_v ]po o n kj o ^n \n pnp\ /2./8.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//34 F\^f`m c on ]\^f \o B\q _ D QFCP " cmjpbc ì^mtko`_ `h\ n+ oc` \ijithjpn c\^f`m t`no`m_\t \^^pn`_ Kn Aj in P?UQF?PI Aj in ^jiq`mn\oji LX F`m\ _ \i_Q\o`mjaijo]ìbnom\bco rococ`kp] ^-" 519 _ì \ " c`toc ifoc`t^\ibò\r\troc o]`^\pnòc`t_`ò`_ oc` jmbi\ D\^`]jjf \^^jpio oc\o Aj in r\n pn ib+ nj o _j`ni o c\q` c`m i\h` ji o- c\o n nopk _-" F` n\_ i c n jk iji+ oc`^jioìo ja oc` h`nn\b`n _ìo a `_oc`"D\^`]jjfSn`m" \n Hp_ oc Aj in+ "^ `\m \n _\t"- P\rnc\mf n\ _ oc` "n\h` om ^f" r\n \oo`hko`_ rcì B mot Nj o ^n r\n \pi^c`_+ rcì Q \o`m _ì`_ m`^` q ib `h\ n amjh oc`Nm h` K i no`mn km`nn n`^mò\mt H\nji C_`- c` c\^f`m ocì m` `\n`_ ^jk `n ja `h\ \__m`nn`n pi_`m \nnph`_ _ìo o `n rc^cc\_]`ìa `_]tQ\o`mpi_`mKmC_`ni\h`-

/2./8.1/03 029/2 /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//21 P\rnc\mf `h\ n B\q _ D QFCP m`q`\ _ò\ nja co LX F`m\ _ " c` c\^f`m fijri \n P\rnc\mf c\n m` `\n`_ ^jk `n ja `h\ n \kk\mìo t ioì_`_ j]n oj]\^fpk^\hn ioc` !(+-. #*)(-(%, ]jjf oc\o oc` Uc\ ` M ] jb r\n pn`_ ajm ^jhh`m^\ "co" j]nji]`c\aja \L\oji\ KN opmi`_ j]]tno-" 3.5.1/03 01930 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//28 Uc\ `_phk h\f`n K ^c\` DMV+ ?i_m`\ Q`q`m\ Rr oo`m \^^jpion c\q` `h`mb`_ n i^` oc` npnkìn ji kpmkjmo ib oj ]` oc` c\^f`m+ K\oo L NNCPR mòpmi oj Rr oo`m T?LAC K\oo ]po D\ma\sK`_\m`kj o`mK\oo Lkk` o+rcj r\n i^jio\ô rocP\rnc\mfajmcnnoj t L NNCPR \]jpo oc` \ `b`_ ifn ]òr`ì \oo\^f ] jbb`mn \i_ a i\i^ `m K\mf Fjo^c i+ ]` `q`n oc` Qopaa ^j iu \^^jpio >Uc\ `_phk1 n `b o h\o` 3.8.1/03 01936 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//30 HjciI`t9Qpnkìnji B\q _ D QFCP+ B`m`f P\rnc\mf ^jio\ô`_ oc` F`m\ _ oj n\t c` c\_ nò pk oc` >rc\ `_phk1 \^^jpio \i_ ja Uc\ `_phk Rr oo`m AFCLE ]\^f`_ pk oc` ^ \ h ]t m` `\n ib iajmh\o ji c` n\tn r\n o\fì amjh oc` c\^f \oo\^f ji oc` \^^jpio ijoc ib oj _j LX F`m\ _ Uc\ `j ] jb r oc pn

/3./8.1/03 0393/ /4./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//22 P\rnc\mfa `n9Rc` B\q _ D QFCP c` iajmh\o ji npkk `_ oj oc`"'+$)& ]t oc` c\^f`m P\rnc\mf ncjr \ m\ib` ja P?UQF?PI ] jbb`m \i_ oc` LX F`m\ _ ^jio\ô+ amjh k`mnji\ h`nn\b`n oj _ n^pnn ji \]jpo bjq`mihìo iajmh\o ji \i_ kj o ^ \i \kk`\moj i^p_` i^_ì^`n irc^cKnAj ink\nn`_ji iajmh\ojirc^cQ\o`m ocì pn`_ oj \oo\^f kj o ^\ jkkjiìon- /3./8.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//31 Rroo`mnpnkì_n Acm n IC?JJ Uc\ `_phk ]po L\o ji\ @pn i`nn c\^f`m mòpmin pno P`q `r cjpmn \o`m r oc i`r \^^jpio+ i`r Fjo^c i \ `b\o jin /3./8.1/03 04946 00./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//7/ @jbU\o^c9 Nò`m DMUJCP Uc\ `_phk ?i_ P\_ j L`r X`\ \i_ Rr oo`m ?i\m^ct /3./8.1/03 08905 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//37 Q\o`mnFbcAjpmo]_ B\q _ D QFCP oj nojk kp] ^\o ji LX F`m\ _

/4./8.1/03 0/917 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//40 Q\o`mbòno`hkjm\mt Q hji Ujib Ljo U\o^c`_ A\h`mji QJ?RCP i piô ji \b\ ino 2 L`rn c\^f`m /4./8.1/03 0/923 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//41 Bjo^jh9Q\o`mc\^f`m Q hji Ujib Bjo^jhoj_P\_jJ TCoc` iajmh\oji n hkjmo\ioajmk`jkòjfijr ioc` `\_ I h BMRAMK __ bm`\on` q^` oj 2 L`rn pkoj oc`` `ôji- LX " i htjk iji+rcj`q`moc` c\^f`m nc\n_jiòc` L`rX`\\i_ kp] ^\bm`\o 520 n`mq ^`+ ]`^\pn` rc\o r` fijr ijr n L\o ji\ n ]`c i_ nh`\m ib ja oc` m jkkjiìon; oc`t \m`]m`\fib oc` \r _j ib o; oc`t \m` pn ib piòc ^\ hòcj_n oj bòm_jaoc`mjkkjiìon- cà\ô ocnc\n]`ì_n^jn`_ n\bm`\on`mq^`]`^\pn` oc`t \m` \]jpo oj qjo` ajm oc` i`so Ejq`mihìo+ \i_ oc\o oc`t c\q` oc n iajmh\o ji nq`mtc`kap+"c`n\_- /4./8.1/03 01907 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//3/ o nohòjbj Mi` L`rn >Uc\ `_phk1 Uc\ `_phk /4./8.1/03 039// /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//33 F\^f`mfijri\n B\q _ D QFCP " fijrqb \ionh n\_\ib`mjpnai\ m`njmo- cjk`cnojmt p_b`nh`fi_t+"c` F?AICP P\rnc\mf lp on9 o n LX F`m\ _ n\_-"a __io_j o+rcjrjp_c\q`= a __io_j oocnr\t+cjr^jp_ oc\q` o h` oj bj ]`ì _ji`= "Bjioomtocn\ocjh`--pi`nntjpocif on hkjmo\ioìjpbcojmnf6t`\mn i \ - c if o ocmjpbc-" i \ n`m `n ja or`òn amjh oc` Uc\ `_phk1 \^^jpio+ P\rnc\mf n\ _ c` r\n ijo hjo q\o`_ ]t kj o ^\ `\i ibn ]po ]t "m\oa)))`mn" \ o`mh amjh oc` U\o`mb\o` n^\i_\ oj _`n^m ]` ocjn` \ `b`_ ja h\i kp \o ib oc` kj o ^\ ntno`h- " c n r\n i`q`m \]jpo k\mot kj o ^n ajm h`- c\q` _ji` rc\o nò jpo oj _j- o n o h` oj bj-

" j o\mbò`_ m\oa)))`mn9 Ejj_ p^f t ib- P`h\ i ib _phkn 'ja iajmh\o ji( \m` r oc jpmijn- Wjp a`` ib p^ft+ kpif= j \ joc`m m\oa)))`mn+ km`nìo \i_ apopm`9 Bji o h\f` h`^jh`jpo ja mò m`hìo-" c` \iijpi^`_ mò m`hìo amjh \ ^ìom\ mj ` i oc` n^\i_\ a on roc oc` F`m\ _ n pi_`mno\i_ ibja P\rnc\mfn ioìo jin+ rc ^c r`m` mà`mm`_ oj km jm oj \i \iijpi^`_ ^jpmo \ô ji ]t ] jbb`m A\h`mji Q \o`m-

"@t oc` o h` tjp m`\_ oc n+ `q`mt _`q ^` pn`_ i oc n jk`m\o ji r c\q` ]``i _`nomjt`_ \i_ _ nkjn`_ ja \ jib r oc \ oc` _`^mtko ji f`tn- Qj jib ?jo`\mj\-"

/4./8.1/03 00945 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//88 NKm`q`\n_`o\ nja Mi` L`rn Hp_ocAj in ilpmt

/4./8.1/03 03946 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//48 @mt^`C_r\m_n9Bmot @mt^` CBU?PBQ Nj o ^n rc\o \m` oc` LX F`m\ _ m`\ nnp`n= /4./8.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//27 Uc\`_phknbinjaa AcmnIC?JJ "Mi r oo`m+ >Uc\ `_phk1 '\ i`r \^^jpio \ao`m oc` jm b i\ r\n npnkì_`_ ]t oc` >Uc\ `_phk1 L\o ji\ @pn i`nn nj^ \ iòrjmf t`no`m_\t(+ oc` c\^f`m or`ò`_ \o h __\t+ " j o\mbò`_ m\oa))))mn9 521 P`q `r Ejj_ p^f t ib- P`h\ i ib _phkn \m` r oc jpmijn- Wjp a`` ib p^ft+ kpif="

c\o r\nncjmo t aj jr`_ ]t " j \ joc`m m\oa))))mn+ km`nìo \i_apopm`9 Bjio h\f` h` ^jh` jpo ja mò m`hìo-" 'J\ibp\b` r\mi ib9 oc`m` \m` ij \no`m nf i oc` jm b i\ or`òn-(

c` c\^f`m \ nj or`ò`_+ " c n r\n i`q`m \]jpo k\mot kj o ^n ajm h`- c\q` _ji` rc\o nòjpooj_j- o nohòjbj-"

?i_+"Bjioomtocn\o cjh`--pi `nntjp oc if on hkjmo\ioìjpbc ojmnf6t`\mn i \ - cif oocmjpbc"]àjm`\ai\ or`ò9

"@t oc` o h` tjp m`\_ oc n+ `q`mt _`q ^` pn`_ i oc n jk`m\o ji r c\q` ]``i _`nomjt`_ \i_ _ nkjn`_ ja \ jib r oc \ oc` _`^mtko ji f`tn --- Qj jib+ ?jo`\mj\!""

/4./8.1/03 069// /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//36 Q\o`mr\ion^jpmooj B\q _ D QFCP i\^\n`oj]`c`\m_oj_\t ioc`FbcAjpmo\o?p^f\i_+Q\o`mr \nfajm\ `b\ A\h`mji QJ?RCP no`h c\^f`m n a jr LX F`m\ _ c\oojoc`pn`jaoc` iajmh\oji]toc`F`m\_+ T2\i_D\ma\sK`_\- Q \o`m n\ _ c` ]` `q`_ c n Eh\ \^^jpio r\n c\^f`_ ji K\m^c 1 rc`i njh`ji` ^c\ib`_ oc` k\nnrjm_n \i_ ^jk `_ 0/ t`\mn ja `h\ n- F` ]` `q`_ oc` c\^f`m \o`m bjo ioj c n D\^`]jjf \^^jpio \i_ ^jk `_ km q\o` h`nn\b`n-

/4./8.1/03 0791/ 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//68 I`t\nf`_oj Mi` L`rn Ljo U\o^c`_ iq`no b\o` ifn ]òr`ì P ^c \i_ Uc\ ` M /5./8.1/03 00927 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//35 Ajhhnnjim``ôn B\q _ D QFCP ]jbb`mn^\hn LX F`m\ _ /6./8.1/03 /49// 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//54 Rroo`m1/039C`ôji Bm @ t^` CBU?PBQ ]`n cjb or`ònk\^` E`jaam`t K JJCP LX F`m\ _

/7./8.1/03 /7./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//32 B_oc`QQ.EAQ@ pno K\moti @P?B@SPW o\f` _jri Rc` B\ t @ jb >rc\ `_phk amjh Rr oo`m= /7./8.1/03 /49// 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//47 Pjn`h\mtK^A`j_9 Pjn`h\mt KAAJCMB F\b`m+ ]` ^\m`ap rc\o Rc` Lj oc`mi tjp r nc ajm ?_qj^\o`

/7./8.1/03 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//80 ?m`A\h`mjiQ\o`m Dm\if K?AQI?QW \i_ Hp_ oc Aj in ]\m` Dm\if t Qk`\f ib a\^`_ \mn= T`rnamjh\Qj^\ B`hj^m\ov /8./8.1/03 /49// /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//46 Hjci?mhnomjibji Hjci ?mhnomjib BmotNj o^n9Rc` LX F`m\ _ ^ jn`no r` q` c\_ oj \ 522 LX U\o`mb\o` /8./8.1/03 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//42 P\rnc\mf oc` K\moti @P?B@SPW ^jpiomt jr`n tjp Rc` B\ t @ jb /8./8.1/03 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//44 Np] ^ io`m`no^mpsja Bm E`__ n h\oo`m Mo\bj B\ t R h`n /8./8.1/03 0/904 /8./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//45 F\b`m \qj_n M q`m BSLL DL;I ?=6 ?L; MH? ;H 0?8AO -6=;H I6?9 >; A;F IEC; @EKHD6B?I I EK E< >; 9?H ?D >?I B6 ;I 7EEA ,?H O L ^ft F?ECP nc\h ib jpmi\ non U\ f\oj R h`n 1EB? ?8I ?D >EF; E< 6 8B;6D;H 6 /H 2B6 ;H"I ;C6?BI M;H; 688;II;9 6< ;H B\i ` ?WCPQ b j]\ ?_j]` c\^f >68A;HI 7HEA; ?D E )9E7; ;NFEI?D= 6 CEKD 6?D E< ;C6?B 688EKD D6C;I 6D9 F6IIMEH9I ! !+6C;HED 2B6 ;H >6I ME ;C6?B 699H;II;I 6D9 F6IIMEH9I B?I ;9 ?D >?I 96 6 )D9 IE >6 C;6DI ? "I L;HO B?A;BO >6 >?I M6I >; C; >E9 >6 M6I KI;9 E 8ECFHEC?I; >?C 768A ?D /6H8> ! /H )O;HI I6OI

/8./8.1/03 05918 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//66 Rjk `q` Irnco]t Mi` L`rn Ljo U\o^c`_ /H2B6;HH;@;8 I >6 >;EHO A\h`mji QJ?RCP b j]\ ?_j]` c\^f

/8./8.1/03 05920 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//72 A\h`mjiQ\o`mn^\n` K ^c\` D CJB jq`mrc` h ib D? PD?V

0/./8.1/03 /4922 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//55 Hp_b`^jin_`mnQ\o`m 2 L`rn ji i` no\aa i pi^o ji ^\n` 2 L`rn

0/./8.1/03 0/912 0/./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//67 Uc\`M nk`mnji\ Mi` L`rn A\h`mji QJ?RCP _ò\ nojm`h\i km q\o` 0/./8.1/03 0/922 00./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//71 Uc\`M _mjkn Jt_ \ ?LBCPQML Ljo U\o^c`_ i piô ji ] _ 2 L`rn 00./8.1/03 /49// 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//77 P`q`\ojin_\h\b` Dm\i M QSJJ T?L "K\it ^c à `s`^po q`n ]` `q`_ oc` F\b`m ]jjf r\n \ kj o ^\ no ib jk`m\o ji- a Ac à Cs`^po q`n @m\i_ I`t LX F`m\ _ HjciI`tocjpbco o ^jp_iobò \itrjmn` ajm c h \hjiocjpo amjh oc` ``ô ji c` r\nrmjib+"n\_\h\ipa\ôpmib^cà-"Fi_nbco n\rji_`map ocib\i_ojno ji oc` n _` i`n \i_ npbb`no cjr \ n op\o ji ^jp _ ]` h\i\b`_ ]òo`m r ocjpo c\q ib oj kpo tjpm i`^f ji oc` ] j^f+ n`\nt-" " c`Jàoc\qài\ tkpo\_ìo icn\mhjpmni^òc`#_motkj o^n^\hk\bi+ rc^c\ n``hna\mtjm^c`nom\o`_ ]por o]`ìjpbcoj^c\ibòc` Ejq`mihìo="

00./8.1/03 /7928 00./5.1/03 HKBR47 K0//73 A\h`mjiQ\o`m_p` Mi` L`rn ]àjm` n`^pm ot r\o^c_jb jq`m B mot Nj o ^n ^ \ hn 00./8.1/03 049/2 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//75 Q\o`mamjion ilpmt 2 L`rn A\h`mji QJ?RCP jq`mBomtNj o^n ^ \ hn 00./8.1/03 01./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//8/ Ucjnùnpk`mc`mj`n Dm\if K?AQI?QW \mì o m`\ = Dm\if t Qk`\f ib T`rnamjh\Qj^\ B`hj^m\ov 01./8.1/03 06934 04./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//83 Q\o`mhpnom`q`\ cn F\h nc DJCRAFCP njpm^`n+ p_b` mp `n LX F`m\ _ 523

02./8.1/03 0/948 04./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//82 N\p Rcjh\n9Kp_ N\p RFMK?Q no ^fn oj \rfr\m_ LX F`m\ _ ompocn\nr` \n_ ot kj o ^n 03./8.1/03 /6922 04./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//81 Bmo^\hn L`r X`\ \i_ F`m\ _ _ nm`b\m_`_ 11./8.1/03 /49// 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//85 C `ô ji 1/039B mot B\q _ D QFCP Ljo U\o^c`_ Nj o ^n \pocjm b q`n LX F`m\ _ c n q`m_ ô 11./8.1/03 /7912 11./8.1/03 HKBR47 K0//84 H\nji C_` m`n bin amjh @mì_\i K?LL LE "H\njiC_`c\nm`nbi`_aj jrib00t`\mnrococ`L\o ji\ N\mot ioc`r\f`ja Hjci ICW oc`L\oji\ N\ ot L`r X`\ \i_ F`m\ _ oc` B mot Nj o ^n n^\i_\ "- \ao`mB otNj o^n "KmC_`c\_]`ìrjmfibajmoc`L\oji\ N\mot]poocnhjmibiji T2nDmno i` n^\i_\ Km I`t ^jia mh`_ C_` c\_ m`n bi`_-" 11./8.1/03 12./8.1/03 HKBR47 om\in^m]`_ Uc`mòjijrajm Q`\i NJSLICR Ljo J noì`_ oj E`jmb i\ @CWCP E`jmb i\ @`t`m= P\_ j J q` 13./8.1/03 /490/ 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/017 L`r X`\ \i_ L ^ft F?ECP L ^ft F?ECP ` `ô jin9 _ mot om ^fn Rc` Ep\m_ \i c` k`_HjciI`tr i \ijoc`m o`mh

/5.0/.1/03 059/3 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/7 L ^ft F\b`m n cjpn` 2 L`rn Ljo U\o^c`_ KmF\b`mn\_kj ^`c\_ijonkjfìojchni^òc`m\_\i_c`rjp_ijo m\ _`_ ]t kj ^` ^jjk`m\o` a \i_ rcì oc`t _ _- /5.0/.1/03 06904 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/007 Nj ^` m\ _ cjh` ja J\pm\ KAOS JJ?L L ^ft F\b`m L`rno\ f X@ /5.0/.1/03 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/000 Qo\o`hìo ]t L ^ft L ^ft F?ECP Mi cpmn_\t+ 1 Môj]`m+ a q` kj ^` \mm q`_ \o ht cjh` r oc \ r\mm\io oj n`\m^c L ^ft F?ECP F\b`m ji kj ^` \i_ n` u` kmjk`mot- r\n i ?p^f \i_ \o oc` o h` ajm orj _\tn ja `ôpm`n \o oc` 524 n` u ib kmjk`mot Si q`m notja ?p^f\i_- c`kj ^` nkìo jq`m oì cjpmn n`\m^c ib oc` cjpn`\i_ m`hjq ib kmjk`mot i \i \oo`hko oj _ n^jq`m oc` _ìo ot ja oc` k`mnji rcj kmjq_`_ iajmh\ojipn`_ iht]jjfBmotNj o^n- Qjji \ao`m oc` kj ^` \mm q`_+ oc` `\_ _ò`ô q` no\o`_ oc\o r\n ijo \ npnk`ô i oc`m^\n`+h`m`t\roi`nn- nkjfòjch]tkcji`\i_ iajmh`_choc\oc` rjp _a i_ ij iajmh\o ji i oc` cjpn`\]jpo htnjpm^`- Ljiòc` `nn+ c`\i_ cn ajpm^j `bp`nnù`_\ \mb`^j `ôjijak\k`mn\i_``ômji^`lpkhìo ]`jib ib ojhta\h t+ i^p_ib^jhkpo`mn+_mq`mn+kcji`n+ABn+\i Nj_ \i_ \ ^\h`m\- \h^jia_ìooc\ooc`kj ^òjjfijociboc\or c`koc`hrococ`m iq`no b\o ji- c` m \ô jin r`m` \ a nc ib `sk`_ o ji+ km`nph\] t ]`^\pn` oc`t c\q` ij _`\ rcj oc` njpm^` n \i_ cjk`_ oc`t h bco noph] ` \^mjnn iajmh\o ji \]jpo oc`h- ]` `qòc`kj ^`\ôjin\m`_\ib`mjpnajm jpmi\ nh iL`rX`\\i_- oh\oo`mn oj\ k`jk`rjmfib ioc`h`_\rcj^jp_nh \mtc\qòc`mkmjk`motn`\m^c`_ \i_nù`_oj jjfajmnjpm^`n-N`jk`\m` `nn f`tojc`koc`h`_\ ak`jk`\ô iocnr\t- c`kj ^`r\iok`jkòjm`nk`ôoc`mmj` inj^òt;oc`tncjp_ i opmi m`nk`ô joc`m k`jk ` n mj `n i nj^ òt- Kt iq`no b\o q` jpmi\ nh rjmf h`\in c\q` \i pii`bjo \] ` j] b\o ji oj kmjo`ô \ ht njpm^`n \i_ oc` ^jia _ì^`n ja joc`m k`jk ` rcj \kkmj\^c h`- r ijo^jjk`m\o` i \it r\troc oc` kj ^` i omtib oj_ n^jq`moc njmjoc`mnjpm^`n- \h i_n^pnnjirocht \rt`mn\]jporc\o ^\i_joj^c\ ìbòc`kj ^` \ô jin- /5.0/.1/03 079/0 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/006 LX ^jkn m\ _ Qfti`rn ^jh \p Ljo r\o^c`_ iq`no b\o q` m`kjmo`mn cjh`

/5.0/.1/03 0592/ /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/3 F\b`m9 Nj ^` m\ _ I\o ` @P?BDMPB L ^ft F?ECP _\ib`mjpn ajm Mi` L`rn jpmi\ nh /5.0/.1/03 07904 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/1 L ^ft F\b`m n cjpn` Qopaa "Mi c n r`]n o`+ F\b`m n \_ a q` jaa ^`mn c\_ n`\m^c`_ c n cjh` ajm 0/ cjpmn- c` L ^ft F?ECP m\ _`_ ]t kj ^` jaa ^`mnc\_o\fì"\ \mb`^j `ôji ja k\k`mn\i_ ` `ômji ^`lpkhìo]`jib ib oj ht a\h t+ i^ p_ ib ^jhkpo`mn+ _m q`mn+ kcji`n+ ABn+ \i Nj_ \i_ \ ^\h`m\"+ c` rmjo`- F` ^ \ h`_oc`t r`m` \] òj ^\mmt jpo oc` m\ __p` oj oc` "m\o`m _m\^ji \i n`\m^c \i_ npmq` ì^` ] +" rc ^c r\n k\nn`_ i 1/01 \h _ r _`nkm`\_ ^jiomjq`mnt- /5.0/.1/03 07907 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/2 BmotNj o^n9Nj ^` B\q _ D QFCP "Qjji \ao`m oc` kj ^` \mm q`_+ oc` `\_ _ò`ô q` no\o`_ oc\o r\n ijo \ npnk`ô i L ^ft F?ECP m\ _ L ^ft F\b`m n LX F`m\ _ oc`m^\n`+h`\mt\roi`nn-"F\b`mn\_ còj _ oc` _ò`ôqòc`m` r\nijocib i cjh` c n cjpn` rc ^c c` _ iajmh\o ji oc\o rjp _ pi^jq`m oc` njpm^`- "Ljiòc` `nn+ c` 525 \i_cnajpm^j `\bp`nnù`_\ \mb`^j `ôjijak\k`mn\i_``ômji^`lpkhìo ]`jibibojhta\h t+ i^p_ib^jhkpo`mn+_mq`n+kcji`n+ABn+\i NMB\i_ \ ^\h`m\"- F\b`mn\_c`rjp_ijo^jjk`m\o`rockj ^` i\itr\tojm`q`\ oc`BmotNj o^n njpm^` jm\itjoc`mnjpm^`-" ]` `q` oc` kj ^`\ôjin\m`_\ib`mjpnajm jpmi\ nh i L`r X`\ \i_"- /5.0/.1/03 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/4 U` ibojiNj ^`P\_ D`_`m ^j DSCLRCQ L ^ft F?ECP Fjh` ja ?pocjm ja R` `npm B mot Nj o ^n

/5.0/.1/03 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/011 Rc` ]p t ib c\n Rm\q` `m`q ]`bpi9 L ^ft F\b`m n ?jo`\mj\9 ? r _`m cjpn` m\ _`_ i k`mnk`^o q` m`q`ib` ajm oc n B mot Nj o ^n ]jjf

/6.0/.1/03 /49// /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/5 F\b`m qjrn oj kmjo`ô @ì FC?RFCP F\b`m n\ _ c` `sk`ô`_ `b\ km`nnpm` oj m`q` c n njpm^`- L ^ft F?ECP c\^f`m n B R\ \ QF?BUCJJ " c`m` nijr\t r `q`m^jjk`m\o`" Rc` Bjh i ji Njno

/6.0/.1/03 /49// /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/8 BmotNj o^n9Nj ^` B\q _ D QFCP cà\h tja jpmi\ noL^ftF\b`mc\q`]`ì àorjmm`_\i_\am\_\ao`m\0/ K\i_t F?ECP m\ _ kpon F\b`mn ji LX F`m\ _ cjpm kj ^` n`\m^c ja c n cjh` i \ ] _ oj a i_ oc` c\^f`m P\rnc\mf- `_b` F\b`m n nno`m K\i_tF\b`m r\nkm`nìo \o oc` m\_+ \i__`n^m ]`_ ji roo`m \no i bco rc\o ojjf k \^`- " j]n`mq`_kj ^`\noc`tn`\m^c`_ kj o`\i_m`nk`ôap '\i_n bcotnc``knc( ^`\mtnomibnkp `_amjh\]jq`#_motkj o^n+"nc`rmjo`- /6.0/.1/03 /491/ /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/0/6 F\b`m9 Nj ^` c\qì o Q\m\c KABMSE?JJ !3>; FHE7 ;C ; FE 8; M6I J>6J J>;O 9ED"J ADEM M>E J>; IEKH8; I 6D9 IE L ^ft F?ECP jjf`_ \o m\ _`_ iaj 2 L`rn ;L;HO7E9O"I 6 IKIF;8J EH DE7E9O I D 6 >EKI; 69 JME 6MO;HI 6J J>; FHEF;HJO 9KH D= J>; I;6H8> 6D9 M6I D 6D 526 ED=E D= ;=6 FHE8;II M J> FE 8; 67EKJ M>6J J>;O 8EK 9 EEA 6J -6=;H I6 9 !3>;O M;H; JH;69 D= ED =HEKD9 M> 8> J>;O H;6 O I>EK 9D"J >6L; 7;;D JH;69 D= ED J>;O M;H; 8HEII D= D;I J>;O I>EK 9D"J >6L; 8HEII;9 7KJ J>6J FKJ J D 6 L;HO JH 8AO ;=6 FEI J ED M>;H; CEIJ E< J>; C6J;H 6 D <68J 6 E< J>; C6J;H 6 D J>; >EKI; M6ID"J 8EL;H;9 7O J>; H M6HH6DJ < J M6I IKFFEI;9 JE 7; H; 6J;9 JE < D9 D= EKJ 67EKJ J>; IEKH8;I E< CO 7EEA ! -; 9 9 DEJ ADEM M>6J J>; ;=6 FHE8;II MEK 9 7; O;J /H -6=;H I6 9 ! "L; 7;;D >6L D= C;;J D=I M J> 6MO;HI 6D9 JHO D= JE H;IE L; J 7KJ J"I =E D= JE J6A; GK J; 6 M> ; ! 1E 8; MEK 9 DEJ < D9 M>6J J>;O M;H; EEA D= ; I6 9 !*;86KI; E< CO H;IFEDI 7 JO JE J> I IEKH8; 6D9 6 IEKH8;I >69 J6A;D ;NJH;C; O 86H; DA J MEK 9 >6FF;D !3> I I DEJ 6 =EE9 I =D 6J J>; FE 8; M;H; FH;F6H;9 JE 9E J>6J ! -6=;H I6 9 >; 6 IE >69 JE C6A; IKH; >; 8EK 9 H;JH ;L; J>; 8ED< 9;DJ 6 D I EJ>;H IEKH8;I J>6J FE 8; JEEA

/6.0/.1/03 /6900 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/002 Ajp _ F\b`m ^c\ `ib` ? `s K?QML kj ^` n`\m^c= L`r X`\ \i_ L`rn

/6.0/.1/03 /6940 /6.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/00/ L ^ft F\b`m9 _ bj oj Mi` L`rn L ^ft F?ECP \ ]`ajm` m`q`\ ib BmotNj o^nnjpm^`

/6.0/.1/03 059/0 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/003 L`r X`\ \i_ Nj ^` I\ t\i ISK?P m\ _n \pocjm ja _ mot io`mi\o ji\ kj o ^n 9 F\b`m ^m `n @pn i`nn R h`n ajp /6.0/.1/03 0691/ /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/001 J\]jpm lp`no jin A \ m` RPCTCRR B\q _ N?PICP c\mmjr ib F\b`m LX F`m\ _ n`\m^c /6.0/.1/03 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/004 Hjpmi\ non c\q` m bco B\q _ N\mf`m B\q _ N?PICP oj kmjo`^o njpm^`n J\]jpm

/6.0/.1/03 /89/4 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/01/ Bj ib jq`m oc` Ppnn` @mjri 4>6J J>; FE 8; 67IEK J; O I>EK 9 DEJ >6L; 9ED; D 6 9;CE8H68O M6I M>6J J>;O 9 9 L ^ft F?ECP r oi`nn F\m_ L`rn 6IJ 3>KHI96O I;D9 < L; E<< 8;HI JE 0 8AO -6=;H"I >EKI; M>;D J>;O AD;M >; M6I 67I;DJ 6D9 >6L; J>;C IF;D9 67EKJ '& >EKHI 9E D= J EL;H H;CEL; M>6J >; 9;I8H 7;9 6I !6 6H=; 8E ;8J ED E< F6F;HI 6D9 ; ;8JHED 8 ;GK FC;DJ 7; ED= D= JE CO <6C O D8 K9 D= 8ECFKJ;HI 9H L;I F>ED;I +,I 6D 1E9 6D9 6 86C;H6! 6D9 J>;D 76I 86 O 96H; > C JE =;J > I FEI;II EDI 6D9 9E8KC;DJI 768A L 6 J>; 8EKHJI

/6.0/.1/03 /892/ /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/010 L ^ft F\b`m \i_ oc` Jjm_ Qpo^c a\ n` a \b Rc` Ppi i\ojm /7.0/.1/03 /4914 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/005 F\b`mb`onEq`\ oo` Bt \i KMP?L+ L`r ) 8>6H JO 9H L; >6I 7;;D IJ6HJ;9 ED J>; = L; 6 JJ ; M;7I J; JE >; F > C M J> ;=6 ]jjno X`\ \i_ L`rn 8EIJI /7.0/.1/03 /8917 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/008 A\nc mj n i oj F\b`m n ? h`` ESJJ TCP -6=;H I6 9 >; 9 9 DEJ ADEM J>; F;HIED M>E >69 I;J J>; F6=; KF 7KJ M6I =H6J;;C 6D9 JE ;L;HOED; M>E >69 9ED6J;9 ; H IKFFEHJ 527

/7.0/.1/03 02911 /7.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/013 L ^ft F\b`m n Mi` L`rn K`b @\o`n npkkjmo`mn m\ n` ocjpn\i_n ajm `b\ a bco /8.0/.1/03 01901 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/022 J`b\ api_ ajm L ^ft Qk\mf Djpi_\o ji Qk\mf Djpi_\o ji F\b`m Q^jjk i_`k`i_`io L`rn

0/.0/.1/03 0/920 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/021 L ^ft F\b`m _ji\o jin Q\m\c PM@QML ! M6ID"J ;L;D IKH; M;"9 ;L;D =;J 6DO CED;O M>;D M6I 8EDJ68J;9 6D9 IEC;ED; L ^ft F?ECP ojk $3/+/// 2 L`rn I6 9 J>;O M6DJ;9 JE 9E J ! -6=;H JE 9 05 0;MIM H;

00.0/.1/03 /49// 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/015 Rpm]p `i^` ji oc` K ^c\` UP EFR Hjci ICW \ mr\q`n Qopaa 00.0/.1/03 /49// 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/016 Hjci Pjpbc\i9 Nm`nn Hjci PMSEF?L L ^ft F?ECP ^\i ]` ojj km`^ jpn LX F`m\ _ \]jpo on m bcon

00.0/.1/03 00921 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/018 Dm\i M Qp q\i9 U` Dm\i M QSJJ T?L Dm\i M Qp q\i i``_ oj fijr rcj LX F`m\ _ om`_ojaopkQDM]jnn

01.0/.1/03 /49// 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/020 F`\mo mì_ ib nojm `n Hj\ii\ K?RFCPQ @po o c\n \ nj ]`ì ^jiomjq`mn \ - K\it r`m` pic\kkt oc` k \oajmh r\n pn`_ oc n jkì i\o ji n r\ òn LX F`m\ _ r``fojm\n`hji`tajmBmotNj o^n\pocjmL^ftF\b`m\ao`mkj ^`m\_`_cn cjpn`- 01.0/.1/03 /8936 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/014 Pj_i`t F _`9 F\b`m Pj_i`t F _` Pj_i`t F _` ncjp _i o ]` npmkm n`_ LX F`m\ _ ]t m\ _ 01.0/.1/03 00935 02.0/.1/03 HKBR47 K0/02/ R\f ib noj ì `h\ n \o @ @CLLCRR a\^` q\ p` E``fuji` o`^cij jbt ^jhhpi ot

05/14

NZ Police – Trade Me Information Request Form (This request is made in accordance with the terms of the Letter of Agreement between Police and TradeMe) Details of Request

Request Date: 26/09/2014 Police File No: 140825/0055 (mandatory) Operation Name: Oracle

Police Employee Requesting the Information

Position: Detective Name: Joseph Teo QID: JTAB35

Phone: ( ) Mobile: Fax: ( )

Station: Manukau Email: [email protected]

Information Member's contact details or Relevant links to previous memberships, IP addresses, other members, etc Requested

Specify the Details of Auctions involving Member since: December 2013 information being sought by Police Detail other information sought and any comments: (attach separate Current cell phone number schedule if necessary)

Investigation Trade Me User Auction Number: Transaction Date: Particulars Name:

Provide sufficient Email Address: [email protected] Real Name: Nicky HAGER details to allow for Trade Me to readily Address: Other (specify): identify the relevant 73B Grafton Road, Roseneath, Date of birth: transaction or user. Wellington Provide a brief synopsis of the background that has given rise to this request: Police are investigating a complaint of Accessing a computer system for dishonest purpose.

Production Order Enclosed? NO

Does this request require urgent action (if yes then NO outline reasons

Is this request form submitted to support a previously NO made urgent verbal request?

I certify that the information sought is necessary (select which applies) To avoid prejudice to the maintenance of the law by any public sector agency, including the prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution, and punishment of offences; For the enforcement of a law imposing a pecuniary penalty; For the protection of the public revenue; For the conduct of proceedings before any Court or Tribunal (being proceedings that have been commenced or are reasonably in contemplation); To prevent or lessen a serious threat to public health or public safety; To prevent or lessen a serious threat to the life or health of the individual concerned or another individual. OR This information is requested under s69(4)(b) of the Second Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 2004

The completed form should be emailed to [email protected] Contact Trade Me during business hours on (04) 803 2604 or for Urgent After Hours requests on 564

10/12

NZ Police – Trade Me Information Request Form (This request is made in accordance with the terms of the Letter of Agreement between Police and TradeMe) Details of Request

Request Date: 12/09/2014 Police File No: 140825/0055 (mandatory) Operation Name: Oracle

Police Employee Requesting the Information

Position: Det Sgt Name: Simon Beal QID: SBAR61

Phone: Mobile: Fax: (09)2622662

Station: Manukau Email: [email protected]

Information Member's contact details or Relevant links to previous memberships, IP addresses, other members, etc Requested

Specify the Details of Auctions involving Member since: 2010 information being sought by Police Detail other information sought and any comments: (attach separate Details of any information held on the foillowing person including contact details, cookie details, IP schedule if addresses and trading/payment history on Trademe or any associated companies: necessary) Nicky HAGER, born or e-mail address [email protected].

Investigation Trade Me User Auction Number: Transaction Date: Particulars Name:

Provide sufficient Email Address: Real Name: details to allow for Trade Me to readily Address: Other (specify): identify the relevant transaction or user. Provide a brief synopsis of the background that has given rise to this request: Information required for high profile investigation of access to a computer system for dishonest purpose, Contrary to Section 249 Crimes Act 1961. The person has been identified as being in receipt of illegally obtained material. Production Order Enclosed? NO

Does this request require urgent action (if yes then YES Information is subject to an ongoing investigation which has strict time parameters, any timely reply would be outline reasons gratefully received.

Is this request form submitted to support a previously NO made urgent verbal request?

I certify that the information sought is necessary (select which applies) To avoid prejudice to the maintenance of the law by any public sector agency, including the prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution, and punishment of offences; For the enforcement of a law imposing a pecuniary penalty; For the protection of the public revenue; For the conduct of proceedings before any Court or Tribunal (being proceedings that have been commenced or are reasonably in contemplation); To prevent or lessen a serious and imminent threat to public health or public safety; To prevent or lessen a serious and imminent threat to the life or health of the individual concerned or another individual. OR This information is requested under s69(4)(b) of the Second Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 2004

The completed form should be emailed to [email protected]

565

Request for access to documents/information NZ POLICE - FORM 3 Under Official Information Act 1982 and Privacy Act 1993

Email: ; and

Fax: (09) 914 4118 and (04) 915 6346

Immigration client 18/09/2014 Date: number (if known)

1. Requestor’s details

Surname, Given Name: SMITH, Rachelle

2. Employer: New Zealand Police

42 Manukau Station Road Address: Manukau

5. Do you require confirmation of the person’s NZ Immigration status? Telephone: Yes No 3. I wish to receive your reply by?

Post As per above 6. I require other document/information as shown below: Email [email protected] nz

Fax

Document / Information Details

4. Details of person information is being requested for: Signature (if submitted by fax):

Surname, Given name:

Other known names:

Date of birth:

Passport (country/number)

Address (if known)

569 I am investigating a serious high profile fraud case. A person of interest to the case has indicated that they were in Vanuatu on the 22nd of August 2014.

At this stage we do not know the identity of this person but we believe that they are a New Zealand resident or citizen.

Is it possible to obtain a list of New Zealanders who were in Vanuatu on that date?

I understand that this may be a complicated request. If you require any further information please send me an email or give me a call.

[email protected]

My supervisor is Detective Sergeant Simon Beal. He can be contacted on .

570

Radio LIVE

17/08/2014

MH Mike HOSKING

NH Nicky HAGER

MH One day Nicky HAGER receives a package. It’s an 8 gigabyte USB digital storage device, the contents of which consisted of thousands of pages on Facebook and by email between blogger Cameron SLATER, Whale Oil and his close political associates, Jason EDE from the Prime Minister’s office, Cabinet Minister Judith COLLINS and others like consultant to National MP Simon LUSK. What is revealed is rather explosive insight into the inner workings and partnerships between blogs like Whale Oil and those in power where posts are ghost written by clients, blackmail campaigns are hatched, repeated searches for sex and the sleaze and a seamless flow of information between those in power and bloggers such as Cameron SLATER. All this alleged by Nicky HAGER and in a sense it is a book about understanding machinations behind modern political power. Nicky HAGER’s a journalist and author of books including Other Peoples Wars and The Hollow Men. His latest book is Dirty Politics, how attack politics is poisoning New Zealand’s political environ, Nicky good morning.

NH Good morning.

MH It was released only four days ago, the reaction has been huge but what I haven’t heard is what has been the reaction like compared to when The Hollow Men came out.

NH Funny when I was working on this book, I was thinking to myself that I was really producing what was in effect a slightly a sequel but mainly like an appendix to The Hollow Men cause I think of The Hollow Men as

1 598 being the best thing I could do in my life to explain how politics works and the way that we don’t want to act, how people work deceptively and so I didn’t actually expect a very large reaction from this. I didn’t as expect as large a reaction as I got to The Hollow Men and it’s been exactly the other way round, it’s been, it’s been ferocious and and it’s not, I’m not just talking about through the, through the news media where it has, where I’ve had a very busy few days, but the reaction to the book has been unlike anything I have ever experienced before and the amount of public reaction that I’ve been getting has blown me away.

MH Even compared to The Hollow Men?

NH Far far beyond The Hollow Men.

MH You say in the acknowledgements, I’m looking at the, it’s quite interesting, it was a National Party staffer that gave you the idea for the book, is that right?

NH Yeah that was my, that was thanking people who did. I, I can't remember, two or three years ago I was having a, having lunch down by Wellington Harbour with a friend who was working in in Parliament for the National Party who told me that there were all these machinations going on and told me the names of people who were sort of the network of attack dogs and strategists and people who you don’t see in public who are doing things and some of them were just names to me at the time and the person gave me a few documents to sort of spur my interest and it went on maybe I’ll work on this sometimes list so it was fair enough that I thanked them for putting the idea first in my mind.

MH For those who haven’t read the book Nicky HARGER, what is the essence if you could distil it down, what is the essence of Dirty Politics. We’ve had excerpts ad vernitum through the papers, what is the essence of the book?

2 599 NH Let me say first what it’s not. This is definitely even though the source material came from from the blogger Whale Oil, Cameron Slater, it’s not a book about him. It’s not, I’m actually not very interested in him particularly in himself. What it’s about, it’s about the political culture of New Zealand and long before I had access to this material, I’m not the only one in New Zealand who is thinking why is our politics full up of petty scandals, politicians being tripped up, a kind of nastiness. I I know, I’ve been coming across all sorts of people who had been mauled by Whale Oil or mocked on the Kiwi Blog and had had my own suspicions but absolutely no evidence that there was, there was a scale of personal attacks and orchestrated negative politics going on that I didn’t remember and the thing that, I suppose it come to the core of it, there’s been a strange situation where we’ve had a Prime Minister whose been saying he is relaxed and friendly and he looks it and he is it to some extent and yet at the same time there’s been all this negative politics going on and what I found, the core of the book is that I’ve found that at the same time as John KEY and the National Party were promoting themselves as above negative politics, they were willing to use these dirty dogs yeah.

MH So really even though Cameron SLATER appears right throughout the book and based largely on him, it’s not, you try and portray an understanding of the way modern power works, is that fair?

NH That’s a and its actually the same as with my other books. If you get a large body of material, I could’ve just produced a dossier, I could’ve done a dossier of emails.

MH Why did you?

NH Because…

MH Fran O’SULLIVAN said why didn’t you put it up on Wikipedia.

NH Well in fact the materials may come yet, we can talk about that but

3 600 because I’m a writer, I actually care about the wider issues of politics and how it works and what makes better politics and worse politics and when you get, when I get that information it actually gives me an opportunity to write about those bigger things themes, that’s why it’s not a dossier of dirt, it’s actually tryna be a thoughtful book and a fair book about how politics works and how people come to do dodgey things and and how why politics feels like it does for the public.

MH You talk about a two track approach in politics, two track, a phenomenon adapted from US republic and style politics, what is two track politics and how has it manifested itself here?

NH The first person who told me about two track politics interestingly is Simon LUSK, one of the characters in the book, this National Party strategist, after straight after The Hollow Men came out which is a few years ago um New Zealand being New Zealand I know his uncle, his uncle said Simon LUSK would like to get in contact with you and I had a very, he’d been mentioned vaguely in the book, we had this very friendly conversation back and forth where he told me this theories about negative campaigning and luckily I saved the emails because he was the one who first explained to me that what that, this is some time ago, in US politics there’s a lot of negative campaigning in US politics and what the republicans had realised was that when they are doing the attacks, when their politicians are doing the attacks themselves and smearing people and producing ads to try and make their opponents look bad, it rebounds on them that people think yuk I don’t like what they’re doing and so that’s where the con…the republican party concept of the two track politics came from and that is that the leader is has their hands kept clean and they rise about it all and they don’t join in the attacks and they don’t do, don’t do nasty politics but they have these other people who are part of the party who do it all for them and so they get the benefits of looking like they’re responsible and above that kind of politics while getting other people to do all the dirty work for them.

4 601 MH And Simon LUSK explained this to you?

NH He sent me articles and explained it to me. He’s a complex and interesting man. One of the things I tried to do with, tried to do with this book and my other books is not to demonise people. He believes in what he’s doing, he’s a strategist, I don’t happen to like some of what he does and I say that in the book and I’m not defending what he does but the people you know we had a reasonable discussion about politics yeah.

MH The other interesting thing that he does say and maybe this is part of the heart of it as well, part of the core perhaps, I’m quoting here from Simon LUSK “There are a few basic propositions with a negative campaign that are worth knowing about. It lowers voter turnout, favours right more than left as the right continues to turn out and drives away the independents” so in short if any people simply stop participating in politics so really is that what attack politics is also about?

NH When I wrote The Hollow Men I was, at that stage I thought that the tactics were mostly about how you win people to your side and put them off your opponents and what, reading US political strategy since and particularly looking at the material I got for this book, it was actually this really sinister and new idea that suddenly dawned on me of what was going on and that is that if a party, the party doesn’t have to win voters onto their side. If they can just make people think politics is all stuffed, they’re all as bad as each other, it’s nothing to do with me, they’re all idiots, I don’t want anything to do with this and people don’t vote, well that’s another way you can win elections and that’s, I mean that’s a really scary idea.

MH And what you read not just in the emails but the tactics and the processes, the methodical thinking about how information is released. I’m quoting here Cameron SLATER says “that website info will hit soon, watch the damage that ensues Aaron BATNIGAR. I’ve been meaning to ask you lol when do you run it? Cameron writes been working through it

5 602 all, was gonna do it this week but COFF is away. Far better to do it when the putz is back. Cameron the most damaging is the 18,000 emails and the credit cards transactions aaron F me I haven’t been that forensic myself this will be huge and so really what’s it about, it’s about death by a thousand cuts so you leak information, you release information very slowly.

NH Yeah nah not all listeners will know, what, the bit, the story you’re talking about there is the one which has been in the news which was about when Cameron SLATER and this man called Jason EAD from the Prime Minister’s department went inside the Labour Party’s computers, they downloaded their membership lists and their donors and their email servers and things and each of them had a copy and they worked through how they were going to put it out there and and I’m so tired, would you remind me where we’re up to in the interview sorry.

MH No I’m just, I’m just saying death by a thousand cuts, you leak stuff.

NH Yes thank you.

MH …slowly, that’s part of a modus operandi…

NH Yes so let me continue.

MH …isn’t it?

NH So what the point of, beg your pardon I’ve done 55 interviews. The point I was going…

MH You have haven’t you.

NH The point I was going to make that what they’re talking about there is not we have found out something that the Labour Party has done wrong and we will expose their wrong doing, all their conversations are about this will be great, this will basically hurt the Labour Party’s election campaign, it will distract them, it will mean that people won't give them donations, it will mean that people are scared to communicate with

6 603 them, they were joking about how they were hurting the ability of the Labour Party to run it’s campaign and to, in the middle of an election campaign. In other words this, I mean this is why I called it Dirty Politics because it wasn’t about putting information out there or debating the issues, this the hit that Jason EAD and Cameron SLATER did was simply to cause damage to their opponents so that they couldn’t campaign as well and it was easier for National to win.

MH Speak about the role to me of Jason EAD, I’m quoting you here “It is unusually grubby to have a member of the Prime Minister’s staff digging around in their opponents computer system looking for dirt. EAD was doing all this in his role as Senior Advisor to the PM based in his 9th floor Beehive office number 9042, only two doors away from John KEYS. Who is Jason EAD, what does he do?

NH Jason EAD is the longest serving of John KEYS so called press people and he’s from all the period covered by the book he was being paid by the public but his job wasn’t to help put out press releases to say what the government was doing and to announce press conferences and things. He was one of a number of staff in the Prime Minister’s department but he’s the most prominent of the materials I’ve got, whose job was to run essentially dirty tricks for the government and that meant that he was he was using the National Party Research Unit to dig dirt which the government itself would be embarrassed to put out and give it to Cameron SLATER or to David FARRO or other allies that they had and then they didn’t have to show that they were doing those tactics themselves. He would do things like the government was in trouble on an issue, the government controls the information of the country, they control the public servant, they would find out what information was in the public service could be used to attack their opponents and then Cameron SLATER would contact oh sorry Jason EAD would contact Cameron SLATER and say why don’t you put in an official information request in straight away and he would give him the words to say and then there’d be someone in the government department who was being

7 604 ordered from the Prime Minister’s office to release that information like the next day or something whereas most of us wait for a month or more, basically it was his job to use the privileges and the information that the government had and whatever tricks they could think up to damage their opponents but not to do it where the public could see what they were doing and might hold the government responsible but through the second track which was to give it out to the David FARRAs and Cameron SLATERs and others to do the attacks for them.

MH So it’s back, it’s back to that two track politics philosophy.

NH It is. I began the book by describing how the election campaign is started because really I mean the National Party only has one serious asset and that is John KEY. He’s a very very talented politician.

MH To that end would John KEY have known about Jason EAD’s activities or what Jason EAD have been a bad apple as they say?

NH On the material I’ve got, it doesn’t say I’ve just gone into John KEY’s office and checked with him but when you’ve got your longest term staff member running attack after attack for you. I personally do not believe that it is credible that that the Prime Minister didn’t know and a more important thing, what I see through, what I saw through the materials was in the early years it was Jason EAD who mainly dealt with Cameron SLATER and other people and planned the attacks with them. After in recent years after for example Cameron SLATER cooperated with Auckland National Party on that that sex scandal against, against the other candidate, against Len BROWN and more and more recent attacks, John KEY himself has been having much much more contact with Cameron SLATER. I think they’ve, I think they got careless in a way that they didn’t insulate it by the staff and John KEY himself has been doing more and more work with Cameron SLATER himself.

MH The big question that a lot of people ask and a lot of people are emailing me here is the ethics Nicky of taking other people’s emails…

8 605 NH Quite quite so

MH …and publishing and publishing them for all to see. How do you respond to that?

NH I mean that has been the attack line against me and I fronted this from the beginning, I said…

MH You say they’re…

NH …I have to say where it came from. Let me, let me give my answer. My answer is that actually this is the same as every leak ever. Leaks are about getting unauthorised information. If you look, if you look at the ones, I’ll give to you some big ones from history - the New Zealand example, the Wine Box Papers which exposed in the 1980’s widespread large scale tax avoidance. The people who released that information were in big trouble. There were court cases, it was called theft. If you look at the Pentagon Papers which helped to end the Vietnam War in the United States, that was called theft. If you look at Edward SNOWDEN at the moment, I mean he’s in the risk of being chucked in prison. The fact is that leaks are a safety valve in democracies and other countries where information that comes out that wasn’t supposed to come out, you can get in trouble for it. You run, I run the risk, my sources run the risk but the reason why countries have leaks is because the governments control information and sometimes that means that important things don’t come out and it has to come out and it’s a safety valve and yes it always…

MH So as with the Pentagon Papers which I think actually the New York Times didn’t want to publish it at first but they ended up doing it, privacy is trumped by public interests?

NH Secrecy and confidentiality is trumped by public interest but oddly enough and one of the things I’ve been accused of which I really really would like to say a word about is, I actually strongly believe in privacy. I

9 606 think if you were to look at the body of the material I got, and see how different journalists would’ve handled that, I’m at absolutely at the privacy end of that. I could have humiliated Cameron SLATER. I don’t believe in that. I could’ve humiliated some other people too. That’s no…

MH And what do you mean by that?

NH I mean that if you get given, same with Don BRASH with The Hollow Man, when you get given a great big dump of other peoples material, it includes their personal things, it includes embarrassing things that they’ve done about their personal lives, it includes a whole lot of stuff which is just nobody else’s business and I’m not gonna publish that and I haven’t.

MH Why not? If you, if you…

NH There’s actually a simple formula, a leak is inherently not a good idea. People shouldn’t have their information leaked and you have to have an extremely high public interest, wars, lies, dirty politics, you have to have a very good public interest reason before you do it and and the fact people’s, like everyone else have dodgy things in their personal life or they just have their own personal business, that’s not what leak…that not what leak, that’s not my, my belief of leaking is for, my belief if you’re gonna leak stuff, as in all the things I do, you do it for the highest public interest and you have no right to release information which doesn’t reach that high public interest that is going on.

MH Some would say that the information that you received was stolen and not leaked though.

NH Do you know what, the SNOWDEN stuff is called, is called stolen, the Pentagon papers were called stolen. Every book I’ve ever done I’ve been told that it’s stolen. I was up front from the start. I received information from a source I’d never had before which was the person, one of the people who who’d attacked Cameron SLATER’s computer after he called the guy on the West Coast who died, a feral who’d done

10 607 the world a favour, that, I have to be up front about where that came from because it was true but actually this is no different from the government department person who leaks information. It’s always technically wrong and you’ve gotta have a very good reason to do it and say it had just been about Cameron SLATER’s personal life, I’d have handled it back again, handed it back again, it wouldn’t been justified.

MH So Nicky you are, you are sitting on some very grubby stuff that you have not released?

NH Yes some of its really grubby but actually most of it, we’re all entitled to our private lives and I and just because I have that material means I just have to put it out of my mind, it’s no one else’s business and I’m not going to release it and in fact what I, on Q and A this morning, on TVNZ, I explained what’s happening with material, I’ve had various people saying to me the Prime Minister said you made it up and so I went back to my source and said would you mind, cause I gave it all back for legal reasons so that I couldn’t be, have an injunction, legal action forcing me to reveal it or something. I went back to my source in the last couple of days and said would you mind if I took a pile of the source documents about Jason EAD and Judith COLLINS and things and spread it round the media and the source said to me no actually which is not the answer I expected and said that basically implied that they might release the information themselves and at that stage once again I said to them fine your business but will you please do what I’ve done with the book and not release the personal stuff. I just, no I think I think that I am acting ethically in the public interest and if and I’m not prepared to cross the line into doing things which are unethical like revealing people’s personal information.

MH So will that, will that information, ever be released do you think?

NH Yeah…

MH And when?

11 608 NH …I think the implication is its going to be released and I don’t know. Maybe in a few days or something, I actually don’t know the answer.

MH Is, is the source involved in the political world?

NH No. You may heard me saying in other interviews if, I actually don’t believe that people should accept leaked information from political actors, political parties, political people and I know this makes it difficult when you work in Parliament and sometimes they might feel they have to but actually if someone who is obviously political brings you stuff then that’s their motives at work, not your own ones. I had someone come to me who had got the stuff because they’d attacked this computer and attacked that Whale Oil website cause they were mad at him and then they ended up with the stuff and I talked through very seriously what their motives were and who they were and if for example as has been accused it had come from Kim Dotcom, I would’ve said haha thank you no thank cause I don’t actually wanna be part of someone else’s political plans, I wanna be doing my work.

MH I’m speaking with journalist Nicky HAGAR about his new book Dirty Politics, you also talk about in the book front organisations like the New Zealand Taxpayers Union, an idea that too is modelled on an overseas example, can you explain the nature of these front organisations, how do they work?

NH Yeah politicians are looking at ways of gaining creditability through third parties and in the cases of Taxpayers Union which I think probably quite a lot of people have heard about in the last few months and since it appeared suddenly in the news media, it was set up by a man, David FARRA who’s the Chief Pollster of the National Party, long term National employee and the Chief Pollster, he does, his company does the canvassing around the country, that’s helping on the election campaigning, he’s a totally integrated part of the National Party election machine.

12 609 MH But we all know that don’t we?

NH We know that but then he founds an organisation and is the main sorta brains behind it which we’re supposed to believe is a non partisan independent organisation which is just working in the public interest. Now this is known all round the world. There are, there are the mothers for more motorways groups that are, that are paid for by the roading lobbyies, there are the groups which are set up to, by the food industry to explain why obesity’s not a problem. It is, it’s a well known phenomenon, it’s called astro-turfing, it’s a joke on grass roots, it’s a well known phenomenon that if your credibility’s not very good on an issue, you pay some money and you get an organisation which will say the things that you want it to that will look independent and from what I saw of the Taxpayers Union, the person it’s fronted by whose all through the documents I’ve got is a very, is a National Party political activist in different ways. I think that it is a classic case of a front group.

MH Wanna talk a little bit about the, another device that is used in persuading opinion and you talk about it a fair amount, that’s the sex or the sleaze factor and you say quoting you ‘SLATER’s sex related attacks fall into two types. One is political blackmail aka Rodney HYDE’ you alleged he was blackmailed, what is the other one?

NH The other, the other one’s actually the worst one in my opinion. The blackmail was ugly, well the intended blackmail but you can actually hear them planning it and deciding how they do it but the other one’s much more important. I mean what you see over and over is Cameron SLATER and his mates going around looking for sexual information or sexual indiscretions about anyone that they don’t like over and over about anyone they don’t like and at first it seems like the purpose of this is so that they’ve got something to smear people with which of course in the case of Len BROWN they did, working it hand in hand with the Auckland National Party but there’s actually a distinctly more sinister part to this and what Cameron SLATER explicitly says you know going

13 610 to his prostitute friend and saying ‘Dig me more dirt on the pollies, the politicians, I want’. Basically and this is, this is again is out of the dirtiest end of politics overseas, if you know, if you’ve got dirt on somebody, if you know that you can humiliate a leading journalist or a politician you have power over them, they’re scared of you and I mean it is the most unscrupulous possible way of getting power and people can read in their own words their discussions about what, about digging this dirt and what and why they’re doing it. I mean it’s really objectionable and this comes to the heart of, what was the public interest in writing a book like this?

MH I’m quoting here from your book, page 116, quoting ‘rattle your cages to see if Len rooted in brothels. He declared confident he will have, I’d love a hooker to come forward and tell all about Lenny. His friend wrote back ‘what man in grey suits hasn’t? SLATER continued ‘Get me dirt, he’ll get away with it otherwise. Whatever you’ve got or can rustle up what he likes, when, how and how he pays.’ His friend said ‘I will get my sticky feelers out’.

NH I mean this is…

MH Sleazy stuff.

NH this is truly disgusting. What this was for people who haven’t read the book yet, what that was about was he had already done the attacks on Len BROWN at that stage but Lenny, Len BROWN hadn’t resigned and so he was straight back to it trying to dig more sexual scandal about him, it’s really grubby.

MH Is there a left version of Cameron SLATER? I mean dirty politics happens on all sides. I talked to Marion HOBBS earlier, we talked to you know Mike WILLIAMS allegedly going to Australia to allegedly try and dig up dirt on John KEY. I mean dirty politics is both on the left and the right.

14 611 NH Maybe up to a point but no I want to dispute that. I think there are plenty of politicians actually in all parties. I don’t wanna be part of a…they’re all dogs, they’re all dirty and yuk, don’t have anything to do with politics…I don’t really don’t wanna buy into that kind of idea. There are plenty of people who go into politics for good motives, there are, there are many people who are doing their, their earnest best job to debate the issues and things and there are some people who cross the lines because they think they can get away with it. If somebody flies to Australia to try and find out if the Prime Minister has has done or John KEY has done something unethical in his past as in something genuinely which reflects on his credibility as a politician, maybe that’s okay and if somebody finds out that David CUNLIFFE has done something in his past which genuinely reflects on whether we should trust him as a politician, then probably that is appropriate political information but most of the stuff that I write about in the book was not about whether people have used their power properly or accountability of a government, all those things which are legitimate politics, they’re about trip them up, embarrass them, smear them, scare them, have power over them. I mean there’s a complete dif…and I haven’t seen an, I mean I say this to the listeners, have you seen the equivalent of Whale Oil on the other side. I just hope that the people on the left of politics don’t see Cameron SLATER supposedly being effective and decide that they will do the same, don’t do it.

MH The sex thing, the sleaze thing, is that a model too borrowed from overseas, the scandal, is this part of the, the manual of, of undermining in the machinations of power?

NH Yes I think well look you’ve always got to be careful when, I have to be care…everyone has to be careful when they talk about something being new. Politicians have been tricky through the history of the world, probably there have been personal attacks through the history of the world but when you talk about what, the thing which is newer here is when it’s actually a systematic coordinated strategy as opposed to

15 612 politicians doing stuff and that’s the thing that felt kinda made me very uneasy as I read this stuff because it did seem that this was a systematic concerted new tactic yeah.

MH There also have been people are saying why didn’t you go back to the people, you mentioned Rodney HYDE, the email exchanges do make riveting reading for example the plan to get rid of Rodney HYDE to replace him with Don BRASH and just quoting here ‘6 days to go before the Act board meeting. LUSK found the leverage he needed to help force HYDE out and install his client’, at 10pm on the Sunday he explained the plan to SLATER via Facebook message cam, he wrote ‘We can f up Rodney.’ He had heard about HYDE sending some inappropriate text messages to a young woman quoting ‘Jordan is talking to a girl that Rodney has been sending dodgy texts to’ and SLATER says ‘Get the texts. I can get them for Jonathan MARSHALL’ and so on, Rodney laughs at that. Why didn’t you go back to Rodney and ring him up and say hey what’s this all about.

NH Fair question. When you, when I work on a book like this, if you know in an ideal world, I would go, cause we’re talking about journalist ethics here, I, in a ideal world, I would go to each person who something was written about, I would present the facts to them and I would put their side in the story. That’s what the newspaper tries to do and so on right? In the real world which I have to deal with, if I have got some explosive information which there are very strong interests would like to try and stop, if they knew it was coming and took legal action against it, it would never ever see the light of day literally and so what do I do, because I lecture on journalistic ethics to students whenever I can, journalistic students, I care about these things, the simple answer is that if you cannot go for comment and you can't always go for comment, then you have an extra responsibility to be really really careful with your facts and not go beyond what you can actually prove without going for comment.

MH Finally Nicky this book, Dirty Politics, how attack politics is poisoning

16 613 New Zealand’s political environment, what does this mean, this book mean for the average New Zealander, what will this book mean to them?

NH Do you know, I hope they’ll read it actually. What I, the thing I hope doesn’t, the thing I don’t wanna happen is that they think they’re all sleaze bags and get put off politics. If that, if that’s the effect of my book, I will be totally depressed and will have failed. The whole point of doing this is that people see it a different way. People think I don’t believe in doing it that way that they condemn the people who do it, that other political actors think that I’m not gonna go down that track cause it will get me in trouble too and it was the wrong way to do it, in other words the only reason from my point of view of revealing dirty things is because you’re trying to talk about a vision of how it should be better.

MH Nicky HAGAR thanks for joining us this morning on Sunday morning.

END OF AUDIO

17 614 Schedule 1a 01/10

New Zealand Police New Zealand Bankers• Association Information Request Form j

To: Date of Request: 24109/2014 I Address: Police FILE No: 140825/0055

ir Bus hrs: Fax: I. Email: I

.; Member of Pollce requesting the information

1 Rank and Name Detective Joseph TEO Phone ( ) ...... ,___ ....,,.------····-~~---·~ ...... ,.. ,.... I Station --Manukau----··· ·-----, _ ____ '"'·-·---- Mobi!e Email [email protected] Fax ·--- ·~····.. ·-----····"··········- ...... ~·~·~··· · ·· ·"''"'" "'''""''""' ______Operation Name (if applicable):

Information Requested This request relies on Principle 11 (e)(i) to assist in the detection of suspected • Details of information sought I criminal offending, namely; Fraud, Dishonest Access of a Computer System by Police (attach separate schedule if necessary) I The infom,ation will allow for a preliminary investigation to determine the scale • De~ails of images sough! by of suspected offending (if any), thereby avoiding prejudice to the maintenance Police (Time/dale & location of I of the law through the detection of serious criminal offending in respect of· -~ I > HAGER/Nicky Search warrant enclosed DOB: (If applicable} I 738 Grafton Road, Roseneath, Wellington NO I Information sought:

Urgency , 1. Do you hold any accounts under the above names, including credit cards, I. (outline reasons in request) Itrusts. I I NO 2. Does the above person have signatory links on any other accounts. I 3. If so, when were the accounts (including credit cards) opened.

14.What are the current balances and account numbers.

I s. Who are the signatories on the accounts and what are their full details, including names, addresses, dates of birth and cellphone numbers.

6. If there is an account, may I have details of all transactions on each account for the last 3 months.

7. Also the dates, times and locations of the last week of transactions to establish a location for him.

' 8. If no accounts are currently held, were any held in the past, who were the Isignatories and what was the closing date/reason.

650

651

Bank transactions from PD 5/732-773 reformated 712B

07/07/2015 Tidal wave of dirt that could swamp election - National - NZ Herald News Hager: "I'd rather it didn't look like someone was playing politics too much." He says he wouldn't want to see content dripfed up to election day. "When you act anonymously like that person is, it's only natural people will question your motives and wonder who you are." So, with WhaleDump in the background, it's a confident Rodney MP Mark Mitchell who rejects the entire 10 pages in the book that claim his selection in 2011 was a rort driven by Slater and his coconspirator, Simon Lusk. "The information that's in there has a completely distorted picture that is not true." He says he will take action after the election "all options are on the table" including a defamation case. "This Nicky Hager has done a complete hatchet job on me. My conscience is clear [on selection]. Simon and Cameron had their own thoughts on that." Dirty Politics claims Lusk and Slater manipulated the selection of Mitchell in Rodney by abusing and deriding his opponents through the Whale Oil blog. Hager claims Mitchell would not have won otherwise. Mitchell says: "The delegates are not influenced by anyone other than the candidate." Ask Mitchell is Slater if a mate, and he hedges. It's a big question to ask a National MP about Slater given the last week the blogger is the most unwelcome, leastliked person to have ever been a National Party member, says one source. Mitchell says they've known each other since they were kids and come from old National Party families. He speaks of returning to New Zealand from working abroad: "One of the things I wanted to do was stay true to my own set of personal values and that means not having people tell me who I can and can't talk to. I don't want to have people say who you can and can't associate with." One person Mitchell chooses not to associate with is Dotcom, who he met at a barbecue last year. He testified at the trial of John Banks how the tycoon threatened Key and the National Government. "I feel New Zealand has never been put in a position where it has had to face an ordeal like Kim Dotcom. There is a big risk of our own House of Representatives being captured by him." He speaks of the breakin to his Wellington office, the later burglary of his Rodney electorate office and the hacking. "I chose to treat these things as random events. Some of the information we've seen come out recently has made me reevaluate that." There have been text messages published in which Dotcom talks about targeting Whale Oil the tycoon says it has nothing to do with recent events but points to an upcoming defamation action against the blogger. At the Whale Oil blog, moderator Travis Poulson says he's "skimmed" through most of the book and wonders if Hager was "given everything or just been given what would be most negative towards National". "I haven't read any of his other material," he says. "Some of it seems a bit extreme, a bit 'conspiracy theorist'. I'm not interested in that kind of thing." And when it comes to extradition a courtgoverned process signed off by the Justice Minister of the day Poulson claims it will be rorted by Dotcom changing the government. He says this view, which has been denied repeatedly by Dotcom, is held among those who visit the Whale Oil blog. Poulson, who volunteers hours every evening monitoring the comment section on Whale Oil, talks of seeing the blog referred to as a "cesspit". In his view, its a functioning community of people who enjoy each other's online company and one which has cleaned up its act this year. A great deal more effort goes into removing some of the more offensive comments. Death threats and swearing are now banned, although a quick glance through the comments shows racism still seems fine discussion on tikanga brings comments about compensation claims from Maori for toilet paper and soap, and a reference to welfare. One moderator, Pete Belt, told the community last week: "Lots of things we do here will be considered unethical by people. Ethical isn't something we are worried about. Only legal." It's a community which is now under threat. People's secrets are exposed, he says. Emails to the blog contain "personal information". "That's a gross invasion of privacy. There would be quite a few dozen, if not hundreds, of people who would be quite concerned." Computer security is also a concern. Poulson suspects his computer has been under attack twice since Hager's book came out. "I can't see what attacking me would bring to any motive. Anything political Cam would keep to himself. "I'm just a volunteer for the blog." He looks back over the week which has gone and says, "It feels like a long time. It's going to to be a shitstorm for days and weeks to come." But it should not return to how it was, says Hager. "[Slater] will keep going. But if he's not totally discredited, then something is seriously wrong." NZ Herald

Readable version 869 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11313026 3/3

07/07/2015 Minister's staffer took part in blog - National - NZ Herald News • The Whale Oil site boasted its largest number of visitors in the wake of the book's publication although others have questioned the validity of the figures. The site also reported Pak N Save's advertising agency had set up an "exclusion" to make sure its adverts no longer appear on the blog. NZ Herald

Readable version 871 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11313039 2/2

07/07/2015 The hacker revealed - industries - business | Stuff.co.nz Although some of the material has been covered in Dirty Politics, significant chunks refer to matters yet to be reported. Hager concluded a nexus existed between Slater, Graham and Food and Grocery Council chief executive Katherine Rich, that was used to surreptitiously attack opponents of corporate members of the council. New evidence shows:

An email from Slater in January 2014 in which the blogger wrote "December hits coin" and invoiced Facilitate Communication $6555.

A series of emails the same month from Graham to Slater, headed "Hit" and sometimes including "KR," including draft posts savagely critical of council members' commercial rivals or political opponents. Shortly afterwards Slater posted articles - nearly identical to Graham's draft - on Whale Oil.

An unreported email exchange between Graham, Slater and Rich discussing the political leanings of the Generation Zero climate-change lobby group, concluding with Graham saying: "That's our job. They're on the target list."

Countdown,the subject of more than a dozen critical blog postsin the months following the hack, was concerned but guarded when approached for comment. Following a wave of negative publicity earlier this year, the supermarket giant is now the subject of a Commerce Commission investigation into its business practices.

Countdown managing director Dave Chambers said of the hacked emails: "If these claims are correct this is not only disappointing but very disturbing given the subsequent impact on our business."

Slater was combative and denied being influenced by payment in his choice of article subjects. "I don't write posts for money, I write posts for personal interest," he said. "You should all get off the high horse called sanctimony and perhaps mount the lame donkey called hypocrisy."

Rich would respond only with written statements: "We do not pay for media coverage or blogs."

She confirmed the unreported email was legitimate, but said: "The conclusions being drawn illustrate the dangers of drawing conclusions from incomplete information, whether it's gained from eavesdropping on a private conversation in a pub, intercepting the post, or reading someone's private emails".

Reporting this saga has involved considerable paranoia and data- security measures on both sides. Rawshark, fearing arrest for hacking, insists on communicating through encrypted emails routed through computers running the secure Tails operating system.

Slater, wary of more personal information being hacked and claiming his mobile phone has been subject to message bombing, preferred talking through an encrypted phone messaging service.

In an atmosphere charged by leaks and leapt-to conclusions, it's worth noting that several tantalising leads provided by Rawshark's hack have turned out, following investigation, to have benign or comedic explanation. A Facebook chat about meetings with SkyCity casino's executive, at first glance sinister, turned out to be about Slater's failed attempt to solicit advertising while he was editor of the now- defunct Truth newspaper.

Then there was the time Slater boasted online of "a request to sell 10 Mig-29s to another country" and hiring an Antonov-124 cargo plane to ferry the military jets to their end customer.

The deal appears to have been nothing but a joke. "If I did that stuff do you think I'd be wasting my time blogging?" Slater said. "Basically this fool has taken trash-talking pub chat and thinks it's fact. Too funny."

- Sunday Star Times

Readable version 873 http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/10417726/The-hacker-revealed 2/2 07/07/2015 Whaledump signs off | The National Business Review

Whaledump signs off

CHRIS KEALL FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 5, 2014

John Key this morning: already moved on to other dangers (@Michael_Parkin)

Rawshark, the individual claiming to be the Dirty Politics hacker, has signed off.

On Twitter, @Whaledump2 (a new account after the original was suspended by the social network yesterday), the hacker tweeted at midday, "To targeted ratf****rs: Good luck lying. Remaining dumps are with journos. You feeling lucky, punk?"

That was shortly followed by "To all other ratf****rs, present and future: Don't make me come out of retirement." (Language warning: there are no asterisk in the original tweets.)

The hacker also tweeted, "This was never about party politics for me. I have done what I set out to do. It is time to go." Readable version 964 http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/whaledump-signs-ck-161980 1/3 07/07/2015 Whaledump signs off | The National Business Review And, "Don't try this at home.. unless you think it's important enough to risk 7 years in jail. Think it through" before a final tweet:

"By the time you read this, every device used in this operation will have been destroyed and disposed of along with all the decryption keys ... So long, Aotearoa!"

Hours before High Court date The hacker's announcement came just just a couple of hours before Whale Oil blogger Cameron Slater is due in the High Court at Auckland, applying for an injunction to stop Fairfax (Stuff), APN (Herald) and MediaWorks (TV3) from publishing his emails (some from Whaledump, some supplied directly by the hacker known as Rawshawk — presumably also the person behind the material released on @Whaledump [UPDATE: Slater lost].

There is a degree of tension for National.

Some in the party will be anxiously waiting to see if any of Whaledump's final material includes message between Mr Slater and (then) senior communications aide Jason Ede discussing the release of SIS documents under OIA to the Whale Oil blogger — and particularly whether such a conversation references what the PM knew, or not. However, if something that hot had landed in the laps of Fairfax or APN this morning, it's likely they would have rushed it online ahead of today's 2.15pm High Court hearing.

Ridden out the Whale scare? If there is no major dirt in the final dump and Whaledump stays in retirement, then it looks like National has managed to ride out the hacker scare.

There has been a major casualty, the already-teetering Judith Collins, but a clutch of polls over the past two days show National steady or rising.

Several figures in the saga have seen their reputations take a battering. But the juiciest allegations have been against those in the right wing blogsphere, PR and (the already unloved) finance company sector. Like other commentators, I'm itching to say the PM's nice guy/everyman image has taken a hit. But the preferred PM polls are simply not showing it.

Whaledump might be scratching his (or her) blowhole, wondering exactly http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/whaledump-signs-ck-161980 Readable version 964A2/3 07/07/2015 Whaledump signs off | The National Business Review what kind of allegations of shabby behaviour it would take to actually move public opinion.

And arguably the departure of one-time future leadership candidate Ms Collins has been a setback for the opposition. A more centralist successor to Mr Key, when he eventually retires, will have a better shot of beating Labour and the Greens.

With investigations now underway by the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security and others, there is still potential for the PM and other Dirty Politics actors to come a cropper. But none of the inquiries will report back until long after the election. The various investigations could well weigh on John Key's enthusiasm to stay on for the 2017 race, but they won't impact September 20.

Dotcom's "Moment of Truth" still to come National is not totally in the clear.

It still faces Kim Dotcom's September 15 rally at the Auckland Town hall, at which the Internet Party founder promises to drop a "bombshell" on John Key.

The question now: will Dotcom's bombshell prove concussive, or seem a fizzer next to the Whaledump's meaty revelations?

What do you think? Are you being more careful with your email post Dirty Politics? Click here to vote in our subscriberonly business pulse poll. [email protected]

Follow @ChrisKeall

Readable version 965 http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/whaledump-signs-ck-161980 3/3 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 1 Description: RESEARCH Status: ACTIONED Source IR: 1

Assigned To: sbar61 (Simon Beal) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE snc823 (STEPHEN TREVOR Assigned by: 02/09/2014 NIGHTINGALE) on:

INSTRUCTIONS Review of Nicky HAGER book Dirty Politics.

Obtain copy of publication and review for potential leads to identity of Hacker.

PROGRESS Book reviewed, only evidential part of the book in regard to the source of the information the 'hacker' is on pages 12 and 13.

Highlighted in the attachments to NIA occurrence 140825/0055

1372 POL.90000.0182 POL.90000.0183 POL.90000.0184 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 2 Description: VICTIM - Obtain statement from victim SLATER Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: psbo68 (Paul Stenzel) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: AREA CANVASS Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 02/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Contact the Victim Cameron SLATER

Obtain an overview of the complaint, details of any possible offences:

Required Formal Statement od Complaint detailing the offences and relevant witnesses. Written consent to access E-mails, Facebook, Twitter and any other perceived hacks Details of any potential witnesses and suspects.

PROGRESS Complaint statement and screenshots believed to be of compromise obtained.

1373 POL.90000.0183 POL.90000.0184 POL.90000.0185 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 3 Description: Information Requests Google,Facebook,Twitter Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: psbo68 (Paul Stenzel) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 03/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS The Victim Cameron Slater has authorised Police to gain access to his media.

E-mails - Google Facebook Twitter Whaleoil

Please prepare appropriate information requests or production orders to progress these enquiries

PROGRESS

1374 POL.90000.0184 POL.90000.0185 POL.90000.0186 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 5 Description: SOCIAL MEDIA/ MEDIA Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 03/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS An extensive amount of information has been placed on Social media in regard to this matter.

Full analytical review in conjunction with intel required to identify persons who have stated the know the identity of or been contacted by the hacker.

Eg Nicky HAGER has stated in media that knows who the hacker is and returned documentation to them

Linked to each of these persons needs to be their contact details, address, e-mail, mobile phone, social media details etc.. for future potential investigative techniques

PROGRESS

1375 POL.90000.0185 POL.90000.0186 POL.90000.0187 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 6 Description: WITNESS - Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 03/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS has been identified by Cameron SLATER as being his IT consultant for the Whaleoil blog

Interview to see if has anything evidential to provide which may assist in identifying the hacker.

Assess whether FWS is required.

Assess whether or SLATER have any records for the whaleoil site that was formerly hosted in the US. (US company have stated that they no longer hold this data)

PROGRESS Update 30/09/2014 JTAB35

0946 hrs - Phone message left for to meet next week.

Provides limited technical support for SLATER. Only assisted with setting up the Whale oil website on the Linode server. His technical background is also limited and has basic server management and keeping things running. He isn't converse with hacking etc.

During the DDOS attack Feb 2014, the website server was locked out and neither SLATER and couldn't access the website.

managed to access the data and copy a limited amount of the Whaleoil site through a personal Linode account.

No server and/or IP address connection logs were obtained.

had no dealings with setting up SLATERS email and social media accounts. He also had no dealing with setting up any of SLATERS personal home equipment.

If a technical problem was too difficult for he would outsource the problem to someone else. i.e setting up the Whaleoil website was done by someone else.

SLATER he thinks had secure access to the Linode Whale oil based site.

No further information was obtained prior to the server being closed down.

Will make contact with him next week in person to discuss further.

1376 POL.90000.0186 POL.90000.0187 POL.90000.0188 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 8 Description: ECL examination Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: sbar61 (Simon Beal) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 03/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS SLATER has intimated that he may be prepared to hand over his computer in an attempt to identify any malware that may have been used to hack his e-mails, facebook and twitter.

Consult with Matt Taylor at ECL and Cameron SLATER to identify the best method to do this.

Mitigating risks around allegations of further leaks needs to be a consideration.

PROGRESS Slater's I-mac has been cloned and Luke Robinson of Southern area ECL has been tasked to conduct the analysis.

Some technical issues with Slater's computer when it was returned has prevented the handing over of the cellphone and laptop at this stage.

Slater has stated that the laptop that he uses was not purchased at the time of the 'hack' and therefore is not of evidential value for looking at compromises.

Slater has stated that his cell phone a samsung galaxy S4 has been stripped and then put back together again and will not be the compromise.

1377 POL.90000.0187 POL.90000.0188 POL.90000.0189 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 9 Description: MEDIA - NIPPERT Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: AREA CANVASS Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 04/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Twitter account Whaledump has been closed down by Slater.

@Whaledump2 has started up on twitter as is supposedly the hacker starting back up

To Do:

Full capture of Whaledump2 data on an ongoing daily basis. Matt NIPPERT is supposedly the hacker contact person to show authenticity of twitter account as being the genuine hacker, need to identify method of communication and details of the e-mails, social media or phone numbers that relate.

PROGRESS

1378 POL.90000.0188 POL.90000.0189 POL.90000.0190 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 10 Description: POI - Nicky HAGER Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: rsbe65 (Rachelle Smith) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: PERSON ENQUIRY Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 04/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Release of Book Dirty Politics and media releases post the release have stated that Nicky HAGER knows the identity of the hacker and has been in communication with the hacker on a number of occasions:

To do: Obtain background information on HAGER in particular contact details, address, e-mail, mobile phone, social media details etc.. for future potential investigative techniques

Identify properties and trusts that HAGER may have or be associated to.

PROGRESS Immigration check by DS BEAL on 30th September 2014.

HAGER is a New Zealand Citizen currently in New Zealand and last re entered NZ on 2/7/2013

1379 POL.90000.0189 POL.90000.0190 POL.90000.0191 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 11 Description: MEDIA - David FISHER Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: rsbe65 (Rachelle Smith) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 04/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Post release of the Book Dirty Politics and then subsequent media releases have indicated that David Fisher (NZ Herald) knows the identity of the hacker and has been in communication with the hacker:

To do: Obtain background information on Fisher in particular contact details, address, e-mail, mobile phone, social media details etc.. for future potential investigative techniques

PROGRESS As per the people of interest spreadsheet.

1380 POL.90000.0190 POL.90000.0191 POL.90000.0192 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 12 Description: MEDIA - Paddy GOWER Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: rsbe65 (Rachelle Smith) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 04/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Post release of the Book Dirty Politics and then subsequent media releases have indicated that Paddy GOWER (TV3) knows the identity of the hacker and has been in communication with the hacker:

To do: Obtain background information on GOWER in particular contact details, address, e-mail, mobile phone, social media details etc.. for future potential investigative techniques

PROGRESS As per the people of interest spreadsheet.

1381 POL.90000.0191 POL.90000.0192 POL.90000.0193 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 19 Description: PRODUCTION ORDER - SEARCH WARRANT HAGER Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: SUSPECT ENQUIRY Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 22/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Nicky HAGER has openly stated that he knows the identity of the hacker and has been in communication with the hacker.

To Do: Prepare a Production order for the telephone data and any other online data that can be captured to assist in the identification of the hacker.

Prepare a Search warrant for the seizure of any electronic item capable of holding data which may identify the hacker, held by Nicky Hager at any appropriate location.

PROGRESS

1382 POL.90000.0192 POL.90000.0193 POL.90000.0194 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 22 Description: MEDIA - capture of source video Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: AREA CANVASS Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 22/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS

PROGRESS

1383 POL.90000.0193 POL.90000.0194 POL.90000.0195 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 23 Description: 1S file - Judd HALL Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 24/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS From social media and Nicky HAGER it has been mooted that the motive for the hack was based on comments made by Cameron SLATER in his blog regarding the death of Judd HALL on the West Coast of New Zealand after a police pursuit.

To Do: Obtain a copy od the 1S file, conduct a review to see if any persons linked to the report may have links to persons capable of carrying out the hack

PROGRESS Directional given to Analyst Justine Moore

Update JTAB35 - 30/09/14

Electronic file access provided by Det Kirsten NORTON. file location in shared folder 504/working folder/Op manuka/

Doc10217 full crown file. Pol 47 in 1S folder.

1384 POL.90000.0194 POL.90000.0195 POL.90000.0196 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 24 Description: POI - HAGER travel Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: rsbe65 (Rachelle Smith) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: PERSON ENQUIRY Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 29/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Westpac accounts and credit cards for HAGER show that payment has been made in 2014 for travel by Air New Zealand and Jetstar.

HAGER in many media interviews has stated that there has been personal meets with the hacker.

To Do: - Identify who travelled on those payments - Identify dates of travel and destination(s) - Identify vehicles that HAGER can use for meets and conduct enquiries to see if they are located elsewhere than in Wellington

PROGRESS Other charges on the credit card include : Wpchrg.Com $26 US

From google searces this is for wordpress services in the US (generally relating to blogs)

29/09/2014 RSBE65 Information request sent to Westpac Bank for bank records from December 2013 up to May 2014 (Currently we only have records for May 2014 - August 2014). This is to establish any other flights booked around the time of the hacking and book release.

29/09/2014 RSBE65 Contacted Air NZ fraud dept ( ). They will give information with an information request form (no production order required). He said to email info request to [email protected].

29/09/2014 RSBE65 Airport Police advise the following contact for Jet Star: Duty Manager for Jet Star Called at 1330hrs - Straight to voicemail

10/10/2014 RSBE65 Information request emailed to [email protected] for information on HAGER's domestic travel.

13/10/2014 RSBE65 Jetstar call centre provide as their government agencies contact

1385 POL.90000.0195 POL.90000.0196 POL.90000.0197

NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 25 Description: WHALEOIL site Status: ACTIONED Source IR: 1

Assigned To: jtab35 (Joseph Teo) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 30/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS One of the compromises for Cameron Slater appears to be the Whaleoil blog site when it was hosted in the US.

This is because the hacker appears to have access to the IP addresses of persons contributing to the site.

To Do: Make enquiries with the US host of that site in an attempt to identify the compromise and the identity or location of the hacker.

PROGRESS Update JTAB35 30/09/2014

Phone enquiry with www.linode.com 001-609-380-7100

The service provider does not hold any logs relating to Denial of service attacks as they are attacked on a daily basis.

Linode provide the physical infrastructure and a virtual private server for a person to host a website. Once the account is closed with Linode, they delete the VPS and data is lost. They do not keep backups.

A person can copy the VPS data over the internet if required though to preserve the data.

Any data relating to the website being accessed or attacked will be kept on the VPS.

1387 POL.90000.0197 POL.90000.0198 POL.90000.0199 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 26 Description: INTERNET TRAFFIC Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: rsbe65 (Rachelle Smith) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: GENERAL INVESTIGATION Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 30/09/2014

INSTRUCTIONS SLATER has stated in his complaint statement that he believes his e-mails and facebook were compromised over an haour and a half period on the 2nd March 2014:

To Do: Contact ISP's in New Zealand to establish if there are any IP addresses that had a specific peak in e-mail type data over that time period which was via the TOR network.

PROGRESS

1388 POL.90000.0198 POL.90000.0199 POL.90000.0200 NZ Police - RESTRICTED - Criminal Investigation Database General Access

Thursday 22/01/2015 Operation Name: ORACLE

Directive Number: 27 Description: SEARCH WARRANT Status: ACTIVE Source IR: 1

Assigned To: sbar61 (Simon Beal) Squad: 2IC External Target: Type: PERSON ENQUIRY Class: IMMEDIATE Assigned by: sbar61 (Simon Beal) on: 15/10/2014

INSTRUCTIONS Prepare Search Warrant for the home address and any other known address for Nicky HAGER.

HAGER has openly admitted personally knowing and contacting the source frequently.

Despite claims of return of items it is believed there will be hard copy or electronic data linking back to the hacker within HAGER's control.

Ensure Search Warrant is legally sound and that Legal Section review the warrant prior to swearing out.

Journalistic Privilege to be considered.

PROGRESS Search warrant executed 2/10/2014.

Computers, thumb drives, i-pod, dictaphone all recovered with numerous items of paperwork.

Journalistic privilege claimed and Auckland High Court holds the exhibits at this point in time.

Only exhibit that no privilege is claimed over ifs the phone of daughter

1389 POL.90000.0199 POL.90000.0200 POL.90000.0201