DOCSLIB.ORG

Focus on an Island Rule May Hide Morphological Disparity in Insular Plants LETTER Joshua I

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

LETTER Focus on an island rule may hide morphological disparity in insular plants LETTER Joshua I. Briana,1 and Nathanael Walker-Haleb,1 The island rule (1, 2) posits that large mainland species case of island gigantism in stature but dwarfism in evolve to be small on islands, while small mainland leaves. However, C. repens is more closely related species evolve to be large. Biddick et al. (3) assess to Coprosma petiolata (4), which appears to repre- the signal of an island rule in plant traits on islands sent a case of island dwarfism in both stature and off the coast of New Zealand, concluding that some leaves, indicating that this process can be extremely plant traits show evidence of an island rule while variable. others do not. We applaud Biddick et al. for their ap- We consider that this variation may represent a plication of the island rule to plants. However, we ob- process of island plants exploring more of trait space serve significant heterogeneity in their data, and while than mainland relatives (5, 6), even in situations of so- analysis on a trait-by-trait basis may reveal an island rule, called anagenesis (5, 7). Analyses of separate traits can it may obscure evidence of island lineages explor- reflect an island rule but hide divergent patterns of ing more of trait space than their mainland relatives. among-trait evolution. In general, we expect that pop- A single plant species may demonstrate consider- ulations colonizing islands will be more subject to drift able variation in growth form, as their data suggest. (8), which could drive nonadaptive morphological For example, they use Veronica elliptica for multiple change (9) and cause island lineages to explore more comparisons; leaf area shows a 5-fold difference be- of trait space for both traits and trait covariance. Al- tween 2 different sources (rows 38–40 vs. 114–116 in though in a separate study these authors did not de- their dataset S1). As both sources were literature de- tect allometric change for island vines (10), it remains rived for this within-species data, it is difficult to see to be tested for more plant groups. how such large variation is accounted for through This dataset represents a valuable resource to un- their modeling of “collection method” and “species derstand the evolution of plant morphology on islands. identity” as random effects; this may create a gradi- A more holistic approach, focusing on multivariate ent that reflects within-species variation rather than analysis of plant traits, making full use of the available an evolutionary trend. Additionally, this variation phylogenetic data for these taxa, is capable of revealing may disguise a different trend than size convergence. the dynamics of evolution on islands. Such dynamics For example, for observations that had both leaf and may be obscured when searching for size convergence stature measurements, 36 showed different patterns on a trait-by-trait basis. between leaf and stature, suggesting they are not uniformly becoming gigantic or dwarfed. Closely re- Acknowledgments lated species can also display significant heterogeneity. J.I.B. and N.W.-H. were supported by the Woolf Fisher Trust. Coprosma repens For example, the comparison of to We thank Caroline Parins-Fukuchi and Stephen Smith for their the closely related Coprosma chathamica reveals a helpful discussion. 1 J. B. Foster, Evolution of mammals on islands. Nature 202, 234–235 (1964). 2 L. Van Valen, A new evolutionary law. Evol. Theory 1,1–30 (1973). 3 M. Biddick, A. Hendriks, K. C. Burns, Plants obey (and disobey) the island rule. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 116, 17632–17634 (2019). 4 J. T. Cantley, A. S. Markey, N. G. Swenson, S. C. Keeley, Biogeography and evolutionary diversification in one of the most widely distributed and species rich genera of the Pacific. AoB Plants 8, plw043 (2016). 5 K. C. Burns, Evolution in Isolation: The Search for an Island Syndrome in Plants (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2019). 6 N. M. Nürk, G. W. Atchison, C. E. Hughes, Island woodiness underpins accelerated disparification in plant radiations. New Phytol. 224, 518–531 (2019). 7 B. C. Emerson, J. Pati~no, Anagenesis, cladogenesis, and speciation on islands. Trends Ecol. Evol. (Amst.) 33, 488–491 (2018). aDepartment of Zoology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3EJ, United Kingdom; and bDepartment of Plant Sciences, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3EA, United Kingdom Author contributions: J.I.B. and N.W.-H. designed research, performed research, and wrote the paper. The authors declare no competing interest. Published under the PNAS license. 1To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: [email protected] or [email protected]. www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1916554116 PNAS Latest Articles | 1of2 Downloaded by guest on September 26, 2021 8 E. Mayr, Change of Genetic Environment and Evolution, Evolution as a Process, J. Huxley, A. C. Hardy, E. B. Ford, Eds. (Allen and Unwin, London, 1954). 9 R. R. Ackermann, J. M. Cheverud, Detecting genetic drift versus selection in human evolution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 101, 17946–17951 (2004). 10 M. Biddick, I. Hutton, K. C. Burns, Independent evolution of allometric traits: A test of the allometric constraint hypothesis in island vines. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. Lond. 126, 203–211 (2018). 2of2 | www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1916554116 Brian and Walker-Hale Downloaded by guest on September 26, 2021.
Recommended publications
  • KS2 Tortoise Shapes and Sizes

    KS2 Tortoise Shapes and Sizes

    TORTOISE SHAPES AND SIZE... ? Not all tortoises look the same. What can you learn about a tortoise from looking at the shape of its shell? Some Galapagos tortoises have Some Galapagos tortoises have domed shells like this saddleback shells like this An adaptation is a feature an animal has which helps it survive. If an animal has a greater chance of surviving then it has a greater chance of having more babies who are also likely to have the same adaptation. In the space below, draw one of our Galapagos giant tortoises. Make notes describing the TASK 1 different adaptations of the tortoise and how those features might help the tortoise survive in the wild. Worksheet 2 KS2 1 ? Not all the Galapagos Islands have the same habitat. What can you tell about the habitat of a tortoise by looking at the shape of its shell? Some of the Galapagos Islands are Some of the Galapagos Islands are smaller and dryer, where tall cacti larger and wetter, where many plants grow. plants grow close to the ground. TASK 2 Of the two tortoise shell shapes, which is likely to be better for reaching tall cacti plants? ______________________________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________________________________ Which of these island types is likely to provide enough food for tortoises to grow to large sizes? ______________________________________________________________________________________________
  • An Introduction to Lemurs for Teachers and Educators

    An Introduction to Lemurs for Teachers and Educators

    AN INTRODUCTION TO LEMURS FOR TEACHERS AND EDUCATORS WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF AKO THE AYE-AYE The Ako the Aye-Aye Educator’s Guide introduces you to the remarkable world of lemurs. This guide provides background information about the biological concepts conveyed through the 21 Ako lessons. These lessons were created to accompany the Ako books. The Ako book series were developed by renowned primatologist Alison Jolly for students in Madagascar to inspire understanding and appreciation for the unique primates that share their island home. In addition to the books there is also a set of posters which showcase the habitat of each lemur species and their forest “neighbors.” GOALS OF THE AKO LESSONS: • Inspire students to make a positive difference for lemurs and other wildlife. • Promote environmental awareness, understanding and appreciation. • Provide activities that connect students to nature and motivate conservation action. HOW TO USE THIS GUIDE Each lesson aligns with a specific grade level (Kindergarten-1st, 2nd-3rd and 4th-5th) and one of the seven environmental themes below. Before carrying out an activity, we recommend reading the corresponding section in this guide that matches the theme of the lesson. The themes are: • LOOKING AT LEMURS—CLASSIFICATION AND BIODIVERSITY (PAGE 4) • EXPLORING LEMUR HABITATS (PAGE 10) • INVESTIGATING LEMUR ADAPTATIONS (PAGE 18) • DISCOVERING LEMUR COMMUNITIES—INTER-DEPENDENCE (PAGE 23) • LEARNING ABOUT LEMUR LIFE—LIFE CYCLES AND BEHAVIOR (PAGE 26) • DISCOVERING MADAGASCAR’S PEOPLE AND PLACES (PAGE 33) • MAKING A DIFFERENCE FOR LEMURS (PAGE 40) Lessons can be completed chronologically or independently. Each activity incorporates multiple learning styles and subject areas.
  • HABITAT MANAGEMENT PLAN Green Bay and Gravel Island

    HABITAT MANAGEMENT PLAN Green Bay and Gravel Island

    HABITAT MANAGEMENT PLAN Green Bay and Gravel Island National Wildlife Refuges October 2017 Habitat Management Plans provide long-term guidance for management decisions; set forth goals, objectives, and strategies needed to accomplish refuge purposes; and, identify the Fish and Wildlife Service’s best estimate of future needs. These plans detail program planning levels that are sometimes substantially above current budget allocations and as such, are primarily for Service strategic planning and program prioritization purposes. The plans do not constitute a commitment for staffing increases, operational and maintenance increases, or funding for future land acquisition. The National Wildlife Refuge System, managed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, is the world's premier system of public lands and waters set aside to conserve America's fish, wildlife, and plants. Since the designation of the first wildlife refuge in 1903, the System has grown to encompass more than 150 million acres, 556 national wildlife refuges and other units of the Refuge System, plus 38 wetland management districts. This page intentionally left blank. Habitat Management Plan for Green Bay and Gravel Island National Wildlife Refuges EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Habitat Management Plan (HMP) provides vision and specific guidance on enhancing and managing habitat for the resources of concern (ROC) at the refuge. The contributions of the refuge to ecosystem- and landscape-scale wildlife and biodiversity conservation, specifically migratory waterfowl, are incorporated into this HMP. The HMP is intended to provide habitat management direction for the next 15 years. The HMP is also needed to ensure that the refuge continues to conserve habitat for migratory birds in the context of climate change, which affects all units of the National Wildlife Refuge System.
  • Human Translocation As an Alternative Hypothesis to Explain the Presence of Giant Tortoises on Remote Islands in the Southwestern Indian Ocean

    Human Translocation As an Alternative Hypothesis to Explain the Presence of Giant Tortoises on Remote Islands in the Southwestern Indian Ocean

    See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298072054 Human translocation as an alternative hypothesis to explain the presence of giant tortoises on remote islands in the Southwestern Indian Ocean ARTICLE in JOURNAL OF BIOGEOGRAPHY · MARCH 2016 Impact Factor: 4.59 · DOI: 10.1111/jbi.12751 READS 63 3 AUTHORS: Lucienne Wilmé Patrick Waeber Missouri Botanical Garden ETH Zurich 50 PUBLICATIONS 599 CITATIONS 37 PUBLICATIONS 113 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE Jörg U. Ganzhorn University of Hamburg 208 PUBLICATIONS 5,425 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate, Available from: Lucienne Wilmé letting you access and read them immediately. Retrieved on: 18 March 2016 Journal of Biogeography (J. Biogeogr.) (2016) PERSPECTIVE Human translocation as an alternative hypothesis to explain the presence of giant tortoises on remote islands in the south-western Indian Ocean Lucienne Wilme1,2,*, Patrick O. Waeber3 and Joerg U. Ganzhorn4 1School of Agronomy, Water and Forest ABSTRACT Department, University of Antananarivo, Giant tortoises are known from several remote islands in the Indian Ocean Madagascar, 2Missouri Botanical Garden, (IO). Our present understanding of ocean circulation patterns, the age of the Madagascar Research & Conservation Program, Madagascar, 3Forest Management islands, and the life history traits of giant tortoises makes it difficult to com- and Development, Department of prehend how these animals arrived
  • Lemurs, Little and Large

    Lemurs, Little and Large

    Lesson Description LEMURS, LITTLE Students practice measuring and learn that lemurs come in many sizes by measuring the length of Bitika the mouse lemur AND LARGE and other lemur species that she encounters on her evening adventure. The discussion focuses on lemur biodiversity (and 2-3rd grade also island gigantism and dwarfism) and the risks and benefits Language Arts, Science. Math of being big and small. Students will know that lemurs come in a variety of sizes and be able to use different tools ● Sets of marked lemur measurement rope and and units to measure them. identification, made using: ● Lemur Fact Cards ● Thick yarn or twine (15 feet long, one per group of ● Measure the length of different lemur species students plus one for the teacher) ● Describe why lemurs are so diverse in size ● Toilet paper, paper towel roll, or similar tube ● Measure lengths using a variety of tools ● Paper clips (8 per group of students ) ● Compare various units of measurement ● Colored tape (to mark lengths on rope) ● Describe why island species are sometimes very ● Masking tape to tape the ends of the large or very small lemur measuring rope to the floor ● Understand complexity of conservation issues ● Menabe-Antanimena Ako Poster i LOOKING AT LEMURS SETUP . Print out one set of Lemur Fact Cards for each rope. Cut out each card and hole-punch the corner. Place a paper clip through the hole. The paper clip will be used to attach the card at the distance representing the length of each lemur depicted. Cut one 15 foot length of yarn for each student group.
  • Comparative Thinking in Biology

    Comparative Thinking in Biology

    Comparative Thinking in Biology Adrian Currie This material has been published in the Cambridge University Press series Elements in the Philosophy of Biology, edited by Grant Ramsey and Michael Ruse. This version is free to view and download for personal use only. Not for re-distribution, re-sale or use in derivative works. © Adrian Currie. Acknowledgements I’m grateful to Marta Halina, Sabina Leonelli, Alison McConwell, Aaron Novick, Trevor Pearce, Russell Powell, William Wong and two anonymous referees for extremely useful and kind feedback on draft material. Also thanks to Grant Ramsey and Michael Ruse. Ideas from this element were presented to Exeter’s Cognition and Culture reading group, at Philosophy of Biology at Dolphin Beach 13 and at the Recent Trends in Philosophy of Biology conference in Bilkent; thanks to the audiences there. Many thanks to Kimberly Brumble for the wonderful illustrations. Some of the research for this Element was funded by the Templeton World Charity Foundation. Dedicated to the incomparable Kate. Table of Contents Cats versus Dogs............................................................................................................................... 1 1. Comparative Thinking .......................................................................................................... 14 1.1 Comparative Concepts .................................................................................................... 14 1.2 Two Kinds of Inference ...................................................................................................
  • Does Relaxed Predation Drive Phenotypic Divergence Among Insular Populations?

    Does Relaxed Predation Drive Phenotypic Divergence Among Insular Populations?

    doi: 10.1111/jeb.12421 Does relaxed predation drive phenotypic divergence among insular populations? A. RUNEMARK*, M. BRYDEGAARD† &E.I.SVENSSON* *Evolutionary Ecology Unit, Department of Biology, Lund University, Lund, Sweden †Atomic Physics Division, Department of Physics, Lund University, Lund, Sweden Keywords: Abstract antipredator defence; The evolution of striking phenotypes on islands is a well-known phenome- body size; non, and there has been a long-standing debate on the patterns of body size coloration; evolution on islands. The ecological causes driving divergence in insular crypsis; populations are, however, poorly understood. Reduced predator fauna is lizards; expected to lower escape propensity, increase body size and relax selection Podarcis; for crypsis in small-bodied, insular prey species. Here, we investigated population divergence; whether escape behaviour, body size and dorsal coloration have diverged as variance. predicted under predation release in spatially replicated islet and mainland populations of the lizard species Podarcis gaigeae. We show that islet lizards escape approaching observers at shorter distances and are larger than main- land lizards. Additionally, we found evidence for larger between-population variation in body size among the islet populations than mainland popu- lations. Moreover, islet populations are significantly more divergent in dorsal coloration and match their respective habitats poorer than mainland lizards. These results strongly suggest that predation release on islets has driven population divergence in phenotypic and behavioural traits and that selective release has affected both trait means and variances. Relaxed preda- tion pressure is therefore likely to be one of the major ecological factors driving body size divergence on these islands. adjacent mainland localities.
  • The Island Rule and Its Application to Multiple Plant Traits

    The Island Rule and Its Application to Multiple Plant Traits

    The island rule and its application to multiple plant traits Annemieke Lona Hedi Hendriks A thesis submitted to the Victoria University of Wellington in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Ecology and Biodiversity Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand 2019 ii “The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder” Ralph W. Sockman. iii iv General Abstract Aim The Island Rule refers to a continuum of body size changes where large mainland species evolve to become smaller and small species evolve to become larger on islands. Previous work focuses almost solely on animals, with virtually no previous tests of its predictions on plants. I tested for (1) reduced floral size diversity on islands, a logical corollary of the island rule and (2) evidence of the Island Rule in plant stature, leaf size and petiole length. Location Small islands surrounding New Zealand; Antipodes, Auckland, Bounty, Campbell, Chatham, Kermadec, Lord Howe, Macquarie, Norfolk, Snares, Stewart and the Three Kings. Methods I compared the morphology of 65 island endemics and their closest ‘mainland’ relative. Species pairs were identified. Differences between archipelagos located at various latitudes were also assessed. Results Floral sizes were reduced on islands relative to the ‘mainland’, consistent with predictions of the Island Rule. Plant stature, leaf size and petiole length conformed to the Island Rule, with smaller plants increasing in size, and larger plants decreasing in size. Main conclusions Results indicate that the conceptual umbrella of the Island Rule can be expanded to plants, accelerating understanding of how plant traits evolve on isolated islands.
  • Ecological Release and Allometry Explain Insular Gigantism and Shape Variation in a Widespread North American Rodent

    Ecological Release and Allometry Explain Insular Gigantism and Shape Variation in a Widespread North American Rodent

    ECOLOGICAL RELEASE AND ALLOMETRY EXPLAIN INSULAR GIGANTISM AND SHAPE VARIATION IN A WIDESPREAD NORTH AMERICAN RODENT By Mariah C. Schlis-Elias A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Biology Austin Peay State University January 2020 Thesis Committee: Dr. Mollie Cashner, Committee Chair Dr. Jason Malaney Dr. Chris Gienger College of Graduate Studies Austin Pe y Document Approval Sheet state ArUniversity Thesis/Dissertation/Research Paper/Literacy Paper/Field Study Last Name: APSU Email: Concentration: Student Agreement In presenting this document in partial fulfillmentof the requirements for a degree at Austin Peay State University, I agree that the library shall make it available to borrowers under the rules of the library. Brief quotations from this document are allowable without special permission, provided that accurate acknowledgement of the source is made. Permissions for extensive quotation or reproduction of this document may be granted by my major professor or, in his/her absence, by the Head of Interlibrary Services when, in the opinion of either, the proposed use of the material is for scholarly purposes. Any copying or use of the material in this document for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. �ia�f Student�� Date Committee Approval We are submitting this document written by ,,{kyia.b, &kl,:s. - f]1C\.,S, . We have examined the final copy of this document for form and content. We recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the student's degree. Graduate Committee Major Professor og��Q Second Professor O"? �ec.
  • Knapp, Michael; Thomas, Jessica E.; Haile, James; Prost, Stefan; Ho, Simon Y

    Knapp, Michael; Thomas, Jessica E.; Haile, James; Prost, Stefan; Ho, Simon Y

    Mitogenomic evidence of close relationships between New Zealand's extinct giant raptors and small-sized Australian sister-taxa Knapp, Michael; Thomas, Jessica E.; Haile, James; Prost, Stefan; Ho, Simon Y. W.; Dussex, Nicolas; Cameron-Christie, Sophia; Kardailsky, Olga; Barnett, Ross; Bunce, Michael; Gilbert, M. Thomas P.; Scofield, R. Paul Published in: Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution DOI: 10.1016/j.ympev.2019.01.026 Publication date: 2019 Document version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Document license: Unspecified Citation for published version (APA): Knapp, M., Thomas, J. E., Haile, J., Prost, S., Ho, S. Y. W., Dussex, N., Cameron-Christie, S., Kardailsky, O., Barnett, R., Bunce, M., Gilbert, M. T. P., & Scofield, R. P. (2019). Mitogenomic evidence of close relationships between New Zealand's extinct giant raptors and small-sized Australian sister-taxa. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 134, 122-128. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2019.01.026 Download date: 25. sep.. 2021 Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 134 (2019) 122–128 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ympev Mitogenomic evidence of close relationships between New Zealand’s extinct giant raptors and small-sized Australian sister-taxa T ⁎ Michael Knappa, , Jessica E. Thomasb,c,1, James Hailec,1, Stefan Prostd,e, Simon Y.W. Hof, Nicolas Dussexa,g, Sophia Cameron-Christiea, Olga Kardailskya, Ross Barnettc, Michael Bunceh, M. Thomas P. Gilbertc,i, R. Paul Scofieldj
  • An Extinct Monkey from Haiti and the Origins of the Greater Antillean Primates

    An Extinct Monkey from Haiti and the Origins of the Greater Antillean Primates

    An extinct monkey from Haiti and the origins of the Greater Antillean primates Siobhán B. Cookea,b,c,1, Alfred L. Rosenbergera,b,d,e, and Samuel Turveyf aGraduate Center, City University of New York, New York, NY 10016; bNew York Consortium in Evolutionary Primatology, New York, NY 10016; cDepartment of Evolutionary Anthropology, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708; dDepartment of Anthropology and Archaeology, Brooklyn College, City University of New York, Brooklyn, NY 11210; eDepartment of Mammalogy, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY 10024; and fInstitute of Zoology, Zoological Society of London, London NW1 4RY, United Kingdom Edited* by Elwyn L. Simons, Duke University, Durham, NC, and approved December 30, 2010 (received for review June 29, 2010) A new extinct Late Quaternary platyrrhine from Haiti, Insulacebus fragment (Fig. 2 and Table 1). The latter preserves alveoli from toussaintiana, is described here from the most complete Caribbean left P4 to the right canine. subfossil primate dentition yet recorded, demonstrating the likely coexistence of two primate species on Hispaniola. Like other Carib- Etymology bean platyrrhines, I. toussaintiana exhibits primitive features resem- Insula (L.) means island, and cebus (Gr.) means monkey; The bling early Middle Miocene Patagonian fossils, reflecting an early species name, toussaintiana, is in honor of Toussainte Louverture derivation before the Amazonian community of modern New World (1743–1803), a Haitian hero and a founding father of the nation. anthropoids was configured. This, in combination with the young age of the fossils, provides a unique opportunity to examine a different Type Locality and Site Description parallel radiation of platyrrhines that survived into modern times, but The material was recovered in June 1984 from Late Quaternary ′ ′ is only distantly related to extant mainland forms.
  • Carlquist Revisited: History, Success, and Applicability of a Natural History Model

    Carlquist Revisited: History, Success, and Applicability of a Natural History Model

    Carlquist revisited: history, success, and applicability of a natural history model Stephen R. Midway & Anne-Marie C. Hodge Biology & Philosophy ISSN 0169-3867 Volume 27 Number 4 Biol Philos (2012) 27:497-520 DOI 10.1007/s10539-011-9296-9 1 23 Your article is protected by copyright and all rights are held exclusively by Springer Science+Business Media B.V.. This e-offprint is for personal use only and shall not be self- archived in electronic repositories. If you wish to self-archive your work, please use the accepted author’s version for posting to your own website or your institution’s repository. You may further deposit the accepted author’s version on a funder’s repository at a funder’s request, provided it is not made publicly available until 12 months after publication. 1 23 Author's personal copy Biol Philos (2012) 27:497–520 DOI 10.1007/s10539-011-9296-9 Carlquist revisited: history, success, and applicability of a natural history model Stephen R. Midway • Anne-Marie C. Hodge Received: 6 April 2011 / Accepted: 17 October 2011 / Published online: 10 November 2011 Ó Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011 Abstract In 1966, island biogeographer Sherwin Carlquist published a list of 24 principles governing long-distance dispersal and evolution on islands. The 24 principles describe many aspects of island biology, from long-distance dispersal and establishment to community change and assemblage. Although this was an active period for island biogeography, other models and research garnered much more attention than did Carlquist’s. In this review, over 40 years of support for or against Carlquist’s principles is presented.