Thesis Presented for the Degree Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The copyright of this thesis vests in the author. No quotation from it or information derived from it is to be published without full acknowledgement of the source. The thesis is to be used for private study or non- commercial research purposes only. Published by the University of Cape Town (UCT) in terms of the non-exclusive license granted to UCT by the author. University of Cape Town Thesis Presented for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY In the Department of Social Anthropology UNIVERSITY OF CAPE TOWN November 2009 Ambitions of cidade: War-displacement and concepts of the urban among bairro residents in Benguela, Angola University of Cape Town Sandra Roque Doctorate in Social Anthropology - Ambitions of cidade: War-displacement and concepts of the urban among bairro residents in Benguela, Angola Contents LIST OF TABLES ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- III LIST OF MAPS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- III ABSTRACT ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- V CHAPTER 1: ENCOUNTERS, SITES AND QUESTIONS -----------------------------------------------1 THE MAP IN THE DUST -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1 THE SITES OF THIS STUDY: BENGUELA AND BAIRRO CALOMBOTÃO --------------------------------------3 RECENT MIGRATION IN ANGOLA: WAR-DISPLACEMENT TO THE URBAN AREAS -----------------------------3 WAR-DISPLACEMENT TO BENGUELA -------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 WAR-DISPLACEMENT TO THE CIDADE: LIVING IN PROPER PLACES, BUILDING PROPER LIVES AND MAKING PROPER PEOPLE ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 12 METHODOLOGY: ON THE “FIELD”, NUMBERS AND ENCOUNTERS ---------------------------------------- 21 MY HOME TOWN AS MY „FIELD‟ ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 21 FROM A HOUSEHOLD SURVEY TO ENCOUNTERS AND CONVERSATIONS ------------------------------------- 24 THESIS OUTLINE ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 27 CHAPTER 2: BENGUELA 1850 TO THE PRESENT: A PERIOD OF PROFOUND CHANGE --- 29 BENGUELA AT THE END OF THE PERIOD OF COLONIAL TRADE ------------------------------------------- 30 THE END OF THE LINGERING SLAVE TRADE AND THE RUBBER BOOM --------------------------------------- 30 A SOCIALLY AND RACIALLY INTERWOVEN SOCIETY ----------------------------------------------------------- 33 CUBATAS, ADOBE AND QUINTAIS: SOCIAL DIVERSITY AND THE STRUCTURE OF TOWN SPACE ---------- 37 ESTABLISHMENT OF THE COLONIAL ADMINISTRATION ---------------------------------------------------- 42 CIVILIZADOS AND INDÍGENAS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 42 THE INDIGENATO ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 45 THE BEGINNING OF THE XX CENTURY: A TOWN UNDER COLONIAL CONTROL------------------------ 49 NO MORE RUBBER, NO MORE CARAVANS: THE (ALMOST) DEATH OF BENGUELA ------------------------- 49 THE COLONIAL TOWN: INTENSIFYING SOCIAL, RACIAL AND SPATIAL DIFFERENTIATION ---------------- 53 FROM WORLD WAR II TO INDEPENDENCE: THE RISE AND THE FALL OF THE COLONIAL POWER 59 THE ECONOMIC BOOM----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 59 POPULATION, SPACE AND SOCIETY ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 62 BENGUELA AFTER INDEPENDENCE: SOMECONSIDERATIONS ON SOCIAL AND SPATIAL STRUCTURE --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------University of Cape Town 68 INDEPENDENCE AND WARS: MAJOR POLITICAL, SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC CHANGES ---------------------- 68 BENGUELA‟S CHANGING SOCIAL AND SPATIAL DIFFERENTIATION ------------------------------------------ 69 CHAPTER 3: CIDADE AND BAIRRO: CLASSIFICATION, CONSTITUTION AND EXPERIENCE OF URBAN SPACE -------------------------------------------------------------------------- 72 “THE CIDADE HAS EVERYTHING” ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 73 CONSTITUTION OF THE URBAN SPACE -------------------------------------------------------------------------- 76 THE DUALIST PERSPECTIVE ON ANGOLAN URBAN SPACE ----------------------------------------------------- 76 CLASSIFICATION AND CONSTITUTION OF THE URBAN SPACE ------------------------------------------------- 83 PERCEPTIONS OF URBAN SPACE IN CALOMBOTÃO ---------------------------------------------------------- 87 “THIS IS NOT URBANISED; THIS IS A CONCENTRADO POPULACIONAL” -------------------------------------- 88 LAYERS OF THE “URBANISED” AND THE STRUCTURE OF URBAN SPACE: CIDADE, BAIRROS AND BAIRROS QUASE CIDADE -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 91 Sandra Roque i Doctorate in Social Anthropology - Ambitions of cidade: War-displacement and concepts of the urban among bairro residents in Benguela, Angola THE VALUE OF THE CIDADE AND ITS STRUCTURING POWER ----------------------------------------------- 95 THE CIDADE IS WHERE DEVELOPMENT HAPPENS --------------------------------------------------------------- 95 CIDADE IS THE PLACE WHERE ONE CAN ESTAR ACTUALIZADO ----------------------------------------------- 97 CONCLUSION: “CIDADE HAS THE FAME OF CIDADE” -------------------------------------------------------- 99 CHAPTER 4: MANUELA, A STORY OF DISPLACEMENT AND CHANGE ------------------ 101 FROM PEASANTS TO DISPLACED PEOPLE -------------------------------------------------------------------- 102 ARRIVING IN BENGUELA – BECOMING “OF THE BAIRRO” ------------------------------------------------ 106 AUNT ANTONIA‟S HOUSE ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 106 GETTING ESTABLISHED IN BENGUELA ------------------------------------------------------------------------- 110 FROM A LIFE OF BAIRRO TO A LIFE OF CIDADE ------------------------------------------------------------- 115 DISCOVERING A GOOD LIFE IN JOSEFA‟S HOUSE -------------------------------------------------------------- 115 MANUELA‟S VITAL CONJUNCTURE ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 118 GETTING TO THE CIDADE ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 125 MANUELA‟S TRAJECTORY: HABITUS, STRATEGY AND TACTICS ---------------------------------------- 128 CHAPTER 5: A HOUSE AND A JOB: IMAGININGS OF AN ORGANISED LIFE------------ 131 BUILDING AN ORGANISED HOUSE ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 132 IN CONSTRUÇÃO DEFINITIVA: BUILDING MATERIALS AND THE STRUCTURE OF THE HOUSE ----------- 132 BUILDING HOUSES, MAKING PEOPLE---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 135 HAVING “ALL THE CONDITIONS”: FURNITURE AND APPLIANCES IN AN ORGANISED HOUSE ----------- 138 SPECTATORS OF PROPRIETY: FOR WHOM ARE ORGANISED HOUSES DISPLAYED? ------------------------ 143 A HOUSE THAT MAKES SOMEONE OF YOU: AN ORGANISED HOUSE AND SYMBOLIC POWER ----------- 146 WHAT DO YOU DO TO MAKE A LIVING: JOBS, NEGÓCIOS AND OTHER SMALL THINGS-------------- 147 A PERMANENT JOB ABOVE ALL ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 147 JOBS, MATERIAL SECURITY AND AN ORGANISED LIFE ------------------------------------------------------- 153 THE SYMBOLIC POWER OF A PERMANENT JOB: A PROPER JOB TO HAVE A PROPER LIFE ---------------- 157 CONCLUSION: MATERIAL PROPERTY AND „DEVELOPED PERSONS‟ ------------------------------------ 159 CHAPTER 6: AMBITIONS OF CIDADE AND PATHS TOWARDS AVANÇO ---------------- 161 PROTESTANT MISSIONS, CIDADE AND EDUCATION TO BECOME A PROPER PERSON ----------------- 162 WITHIN THE MARGINS OF “COMELICA” ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 162 WOMEN OF THE MISSIONS: RAISED TO BECOME PROPER WIVES-------------------------------------------- 168 ANTONIO FORTUNATOUniversity‟S RETURN TO THE CIDADE of ----------------------------------------------------------- Cape Town 172 JOÃO FORTUNATO‟S AMBITIONS, PROJECTS AND OPPORTUNITIES ------------------------------------ 175 MOVING TO THE CIDADE------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 175 CUBAL: FROM BEING A CIDADE TO BECOMING THE INTERIOR ---------------------------------------------- 176 JOÃO FORTUNATO‟S LIFE IN THE CIDADE: MOVING UP TOWARDS AVANÇO ------------------------------ 178 MANUELA AND JOÃO FORTUNATO: TWO TRAJECTORIES TOWARDS THE CIDADE AND AVANÇO - 181 JOÃO AND MANUELA: HIGHLIGHTING PATHS TOWARDS AVANÇO ---------------------------------------- 182 HABITUS, CONJUNCTURES AND THE POSSIBILITY OF CHANGE --------------------------------------------- 186 CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSIONS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 191 LIST OF REFERENCES--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 197 APPENDIX A: QUESTIONNAIRE -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 209 APPENDIX B: ON CLASSIFICATIONS OF PEOPLE