Chapter 1. When Is Music Political?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Durham E-Theses Music, Civil Rights, and Counterculture: Critical Aesthetics and Resistance in the United States, 1957-1968 BARKER, THOMAS,PATRICK How to cite: BARKER, THOMAS,PATRICK (2016) Music, Civil Rights, and Counterculture: Critical Aesthetics and Resistance in the United States, 1957-1968, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/11693/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 Music, Civil Rights, and Counterculture: Critical Aesthetics and Resistance in the United States, 1957-1968 Thomas Barker PhD Music Department University of Durham 2016 Music, Civil Rights, and Counterculture: Critical Aesthetics and Resistance in the United States, 1957-1968 Thomas Barker Abstract This dissertation explores the role of music within the politics of liberation in the United States in the period of the late 1950s and the 1960s. Its focus is on the two dominant, but very different (and, it is argued, interconnected) mass political and cultural movements that converged in the course of the 1960s: civil rights and counterculture. Divergent tendencies in the popular musics of the period, which were drawn into the orbits of these two movements, are considered in the context of tensions between political commitment and aesthetic autonomy, between the call for collective political action and the pull of individualism, and between existing political reality and the utopian perspectives offered by art. The theoretical approach derives largely from critical theory (in particular Adorno, Bloch, and Marcuse), and the thesis argues that by tending toward autonomy and individualism popular musics in this period articulated a vision of society that was radically different from existing political realities. The study situates itself in the existing literature on protest music, but seeks to take this further by examining the complexity of responses in music of this period to protest and liberation movements beyond protest songs and politically committed music to discuss issues of social critique and critical reflection. After an initial consideration of what might be meant by the categories ‘protest music’ and socially or politically engaged music, considering among others the work of Eyerman and Jamison (1998), Mattern (1998), Roy (2010), Street (2011), and in particular Denisoff (1968), notions of political engagement and autonomy are discussed in relation to Adorno (1970) and Marcuse (1977). Subsequent chapters then function as case studies of particular tendencies as well as considering significant figures in the music of the period in the context of liberation, civil rights, Black Power, the counterculture, and the New Left. The Highlander Folk School is considered for the ways that it used music to foreground a collective political identity that was subverted by the needs of individual activists; Bob Dylan is examined in light of his retreat from collective political projects and his move toward aesthetic individualism that was nevertheless met with an increase in his perceived relevance to the liberation movements; John Coltrane for his experiments with autonomous music, despite the bitter political realities faced by many African Americans; and Frank Zappa, whose music, it is argued, attempted to stimulate a form of critical self-reflection amongst his audience. Contents Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 1 Aims and Methodology ....................................................................................................................... 1 Contexts: Historical, Political, and Conceptual .................................................................................. 2 Survey of Literature ............................................................................................................................ 5 Structure of Dissertation ................................................................................................................... 13 Chapter 1. When is Music Political? .................................................................................... 16 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 16 Protest Song ...................................................................................................................................... 17 Music and Political Engagement....................................................................................................... 25 Critical Theory: Autonomy as Political Critique .............................................................................. 31 Instrumental Reason ...................................................................................................................... 35 Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 39 Chapter 2. The Highlander Folk School, the Freedom Songs, and the Freedom Rides .. 40 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 40 Political Practices at Highlander ....................................................................................................... 43 Class, Race, and Place: Perceptions of the Freedom Songs .............................................................. 46 Interim Conclusions .......................................................................................................................... 50 2. The Freedom Songs in Context ................................................................................................. 51 The Freedom Rides ........................................................................................................................... 55 Context within the Civil Rights Movement .................................................................................. 55 The Early Rides: From the Bus to the Hospital ............................................................................ 57 (Non)Violent Clashes at the First Baptist Church ......................................................................... 60 Jail, No Bail .................................................................................................................................. 63 Parchman Prison Farm .................................................................................................................. 65 Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 68 Chapter 3. Bob Dylan, Individualism, and the Counterculture ........................................ 72 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 72 1. Demythologizing Dylan ............................................................................................................ 74 The Myth of Dylan’s Youth .............................................................................................................. 75 Dylan and Politics: A Quick Dip ...................................................................................................... 79 2. Dylan and the Collective Myth of the Individual ...................................................................... 89 Post-Protest Dylan ............................................................................................................................ 89 Situating Dylan: The Counterculture and the New Left ................................................................... 90 Dylan and the Counterculture ........................................................................................................... 96 Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 99 Chapter 4. John Coltrane and the Development of a Radical Black Aesthetic.............. 103 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 103 1. Jazz and Autonomy ................................................................................................................. 106 Autonomy or Not Autonomy .......................................................................................................... 106 Coltrane’s Early Development: Racism and Resistance ................................................................. 110 2. Coltrane’s Radical Aesthetics ................................................................................................