Needs Assessment for Wharves and Rail Depots in Hampshire
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Hampshire Minerals and Waste Development Framework Needs Assessment for Wharves and Rail Depots in Hampshire Update February 2011 A Study by Land & Mineral Management Limited for Hampshire County Council, Portsmouth City Council, Southampton City Council, New Forest National Park Authority and the South Downs National Park. Front Cover – Aerial shot of the River Itchen wharves – Copyright - Digital Millennium Map Partnership, 2006 CONTENTS SECTIONS Executive Summary 1. Introduction and Background 2. Hampshire Wharves and Rail Depots - Operations Review of Existing Operations and – Capacities of existing wharf and rail depots in Hampshire 3. Establishing what the Future Need for Wharves and Rail Depots up to 2030 4. Possible Constraints and Issues Related to the continued use or expansion of Wharves and Rail Depots in Hampshire 5. Meeting Hampshire’s Future Need for Wharves and Rail Depots in Hampshire 6. Proposals for Wharf and Rail Depot Site Safeguarding – including Possible Safeguarding Measures 7. Summary and Recommendations TABLES Table 1 Probable Import and Export Facilities in Hampshire c.1990 Table 2 Crown Estate Landings of Marine Dredged Sand and Gravel at Hampshire Ports from 1989/90 (tonnes) Table 3 Hampshire Imports of Land Won Aggregate by Sea or Rail (tonnes) Table 4 Probable Changes to Hampshire Site Operators since 1990 Table 5 Hampshire Wharves and Rail Depots ‘Lost’ or ‘Gained’ since 1990 Table 6 Recent Average Annual Aggregate Imports into South Hampshire Wharves (2004- 2009) and Rail Depots (2003-2007) (k.tonnes) Table 7 Potential Maximum Aggregate Imports Capacity at Existing South Hampshire Wharf and Rail Depots Table 8 Adjusted Potential Maximum Aggregate Imports Capacity at Existing South Hampshire Wharf and Rail Depots Table 9 Hampshire Primary Aggregate Sales by Type 1998-2009 (excluding road imports) Table 10 National Statistics for Hard/Crushed Rock Compared to Sand and Gravel (k.tonnes) in England Table 11 Draft Revised Regional Guidelines for Primary Aggregates in the South East 2005- 2020 (m.tonnes) Table 12 Comparison of Population and Total Aggregate Demand Forecasts by Hampshire Area (2006-2030) Table 13 Hampshire Aggregate Import Forecast Scenarios (2011-2030) Table 14 Classification of Hampshire Wharf and Rail Depot Facilities FIGURES AND PLANS Figure 1 Site Location Diagram for Wharves and Rail Depots and other sites identified in the Assessment Plan W1 Southampton (Western Docks) Plan W2 Southampton Wharves (River Itchen) Need Assessment for Wharves and Rail Depots (Update February 2011) Plan W3 Fareham Wharf Plan W4 Tipner Wharf Plan W5 Kendalls Wharf Plan W6 Bedhampton Wharf Plan W7 Marchwood Wharves Plan PW1 Possible New Minerals and Waste Handling Wharf Facilities at Marchwood Military Port and Dibden Bay Plan PW2 Port of Southampton /Southampton Water Plan PW3 Port of Portsmouth / Portsmouth Water Plan R1 Fareham Depot Plan R2 Botley Depot Plan R3 Eastleigh East and West Depots Plan PR1 Possible New Aggregates Rail Depot at Basingstoke Plan PR2 Possible New Aggregates/Recycling Rail Depot Facilities at Micheldever APPENDICES APPENDIX 1 South East Plan (May 2009) - selected new Transport, Waste and Mineral Policies APPENDIX 2 Hampshire, Portsmouth and Southampton Minerals and Waste Local Plan (Adopted December 1998) - Wharves and Rail Depot Policies APPENDIX 3 London Plan Implementation Report Policies for Safeguarding Wharves on the River Thames APPENDIX 4 Recommended potential areas of content for the development of replacement Hampshire Wharves and Rail Depot Policies (policies S13 (Wharves and Depots), S14 (Safeguarding) and DC18 (Wharves and Depots) to replace the quashed Core Strategy policies REFERENCES Land & Mineral Management Ltd. 2 Need Assessment for Wharves and Rail Depots (Update February 2011) EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This needs assessment has been conducted to support part of the necessary background work required by Hampshire (Hampshire County Council, Southampton City Council, Portsmouth City Council, New Forest National Park Authority and the South Downs National Park), to support the delivery of the Hampshire Minerals and Waste Development Framework. It is an update of an assessment completed by Land & Mineral Management in 2009. The assessment will particularly support the development of the Hampshire Minerals and Waste Plan which will update and replace the adopted Hampshire Minerals and Waste Core Strategy. The main objective of the assessment was to establish the need within the plan period for wharves and rail depots based on the current and future potential of existing and new facilities for the importation and exportation of minerals and waste, including their transportation by non-road means within Hampshire. This included an assessment of:- Capacity of existing wharves and rail depots – including associated activities and facilities; Likely future demand for wharves and rail depots; Possible constraints to continued use or expansion at these sites; Potential need to retain existing unused preferred sites and identification of potential new and/or replacement sites. The research also included the undertaking of operator or site owner questionnaires, site visits, a review of references national policy guidelines and many other publications or documents with direct relevance to this assessment. The research has been structured in sections dealing with: Wharf and Rail Depot Operations Review – which includes understanding existing site capacities and any recent trends in meeting demand; Establishing Future Needs and Meeting the Needs for Wharves and Rail Depots – by using recognised forecasting sources, recent research and an alternative ‘bottom up’ approach to forecasting and then comparing relevant information obtained on the expansion potential of existing and new sites; Possible constraints and issues related to the continued use or expansion of wharves and rail depots in Hampshire – constraints and issues such as physical, planning and site specific constraints are considered; Meeting the need for wharves and rail depots in Hampshire – the development of various scenarios to meeting Hampshire’s needs for wharves and rail depots are made and considered; Proposals for Wharf and Rail Depot Site Safeguarding including Possible Safeguarding Measures – by identifying and prioritising sites by means such as size or impact or constraint, and then adopting recognised or other possible new safeguarding measures which can then be used for the most important sites.. The assessment was originally completed by Land & Mineral Management Limited. (LMML) in September 2009, when it assessed the need and requirements for wharves and rail depots up to 2026. The only formal response to the first assessment came in a letter from the agents for Associated British Ports (ABP) received in November 2010. In November 2010, Hampshire commissioned LMML to update the 2009 assessment. The update assesses the need for wharves and rail depots up to 2030, in line with the plan period Land & Mineral Management Ltd. 3 Need Assessment for Wharves and Rail Depots (Update February 2011) proposed for the Hampshire Minerals and Waste Plan. Relevant comments received from ABP regarding the 2009 assessment have been taken to account, where appropriate in this update, as well as relevant changes in national policy, guidance and other supporting documentation. Research for this assessment has identified the following main features and recommendations:- The dominant materials handled at Hampshire’s wharves and rail depots are construction aggregates in the form of marine sand and gravels or hard (crushed) rock - although other minerals are imported into Western Docks (Southampton), and wastes are handled at three other wharves; The combination of Hampshire’s existing wharves and rail depots infrastructure has changed relatively little in overall terms since 1989/90, when peak consumption of construction aggregates occurred in Great Britain; Additional aggregate capacity levels in excess of the 1989/1990 levels will probably not be required within the plan period up to 2030 – although it may be required by 2050; The current spare capacity of wharves and rail depots in Hampshire is most likely to be sufficient to meet the needs for the plan period to 2030 - unless existing wharf or rail site capacity is permanently lost from site closures, redevelopment or other reasons; If significant spare capacity remains at existing aggregate wharf and rail facilities then Hampshire only needs to identify a limited number of new additional aggregate wharf import facilities – and although these new sites are not likely to be needed until the end of the plan period, they will need safeguarding in the meantime; Recent industry research reports have indicated that it may be possible to see the development of sustainable alternative technology within the plan period to enable new aggregate supply modes (e.g. pipelines) or even a major new aggregate supply source in the South East (i.e. mined aggregates). Should full scale development of either of these potentially viable options commence within the plan period to 2030, then significant expansion of wharves or even new wharves may not be required; Recent industry research reports have indicated that it may be possible to see the development of sustainable alternative technology within the plan period to enable new aggregate supply modes (e.g. pipelines) or even a major new aggregate supply source in the South East (i.e. mined aggregates). Should full scale