Public Document Pack SPEAKERS PANEL (PLANNING) Day: Wednesday Date: 15 January 2020 Time: 10.00 am Place: Guardsman Tony Downes House, Manchester Road, Droylsden, M43 6SF Item AGENDA Page No. No 1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE To receive any apologies from Members of the Panel. 2. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST To receive any declarations of interest from Members of the Council. 3. MINUTES 1 - 8 The Minutes of the meeting of the Speakers Panel (Planning) held on 18 December 2019, having been circulated, to be signed by the Chair as a correct record. 4. OBJECTIONS TO PROPOSED TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH 9 - 16 (ANNAN STREET AND LIME GROVE, DENTON) (PROHIBITION AND RESTRICTION OF WAITING AND LOADING ONLY) ORDER 2019 & TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH (LIME GROVE, DENTON) (ONE WAY TRAFFIC) ORDER 2019 Report of the Assistant Director of Operations and Neighbourhoods attached. 5. OBJECTIONS TO PROPOSED THE TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN 17 - 24 BOROUGH (FRANK STREET, JOHN SHEPLEY STREET AREA, HYDE) (PROHIBITION OF WAITING) ORDER 2018 Report of the Director of Operations and Neighbourhoods attached. 6. OBJECTIONS TO THE PROPOSED TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN 25 - 32 BOROUGH (DOUGLAS STREET, HYDE) (SCHOOL ENTRANCE PROHIBITION OF STOPPING) ORDER 2018 AND THE TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH (DOUGLAS STREET, JAMES DRIVE, HYDE) (PROHIBITION OF WAITING) ORDER 2018 Report of the Director of Operations and Neighbourhoods attached. 7. OBJECTIONS TO THE TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH 33 - 42 (BROADBOTTOM ROAD, MOTTRAM) (PROHIBITION OF WAITING) ORDER 2019 From: Democratic Services Unit – any further information may be obtained from the reporting officer or from Benjamin Hopkins, Senior Democratic Services Officer, to whom any apologies for absence should be notified. Item AGENDA Page No. No Report of the Director of Operations and Neighbourhoods attached. 8. OBJECTIONS TO THE TAMESIDE METROPOLITAN BOROUGH (KNOWL 43 - 52 STREET, STALYBRIDGE) (PROHIBITION OF WAITING) ORDER 2019 Report of the Assistant Director of Operations and Neighbourhoods attached. 9. PLANNING APPLICATIONS To consider the schedule of applications. a) 19/00067/FUL - HILL STREET WORKS, HILL STREET, HYDE 53 - 78 10. URGENT ITEMS To consider any other items, which the Chair is of the opinion should be considered as a matter of urgency. From: Democratic Services Unit – any further information may be obtained from the reporting officer or from Benjamin Hopkins, Senior Democratic Services Officer, to whom any apologies for absence should be notified. Agenda Item 3 SPEAKERS PANEL (PLANNING) 18 December 2019 Present: Councillor McNally (Chair) Councillors: Choksi, Glover, Gosling, Lewis, Owen, Ricci, Ward and Wild Apologies: Councillors: Dickinson and Naylor 33. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST There were no declarations of interest declared by Members. 34. AMENDMENT OF ORDER OF BUSINESS In accordance with the Council’s constitution, the Chair advised Members of a change in the order of business to the published agenda. 35. MINUTES The Minutes of the proceedings of the meeting held on 13 November 2019, having been circulated, were approved and signed by the Chair as a correct record. 36. PLANNING APPLICATIONS The Panel gave consideration to the schedule of applications submitted and it was:- RESOLVED That the applications for planning permission be determined as detailed below:- Name and Application No: 19/00817/FUL Alex Jones Proposed Development: Installation of security, barbed wire on roof – retrospective Doctors Surgery, 156 Stockport Road, Ashton-under-Lyne Speaker(s)/Late Councillor Bray addressed the Panel objecting to the Representations: application. Alex Jones, the applicant, addressed the Panel in relation to the application. Decision: That planning permission be refused for reasons as detailed within the submitted report. Page 1 Name and Application No 19/00264/FUL Scout Green Ltd Proposed Development: Full planning permission for the demolition of existing buildings and erection of 55 dwellings with associated car parking and access arrangements. Scout Green, Scout Green Depot, Mossley Speaker(s)/Late Gareth Glennon, on behalf of the applicant, addressed the Representations: Panel in relation to the application. Decision: That planning permission be granted subject to conditions as detailed within the submitted report and the prior completion of a Section 106 Agreement. Name and Application No 19/00555/FUL Onward Homes Proposed Development: Residential development comprising of 46 units (6No. 2 bedroom houses; 21No. 3 bedroom houses; 9No. 4 bedroom houses & 10No. 2 bedroom bungalows) including associated infrastructure. Cleared Land Bounded by Hattersley Road East, Melandra Crescent and Kenworthy Close, Mottram Speaker(s)/Late The Development Manager advised and circulated Representations amendments to conditions 2, 4, 8, 22 within the submitted report to be replaced with the following conditions: The development hereby approved shall be carried out strictly in accordance with the plans and specifications as approved unless required by any other conditions in this permission. Location Plan Site 2 dwg no. 102B Proposed Site 2 Plan: Roof Plan dwg no. 109 Rev D Proposed Site 2 Plan dwg no.111 Rev D Housetype A2 - 2B3P dwg no. 116 Housetype A4 - 2B4P dwg no. 117 D Housetype A4/B3 - 2B4P/3B5P dwg no. 118 B Housetype B3 - 3B5P dwg no. 119 A Housetype B3/B3/C3 - 3B5P/4B6P dwg no. 120 A Housetype B3/C3 - 3B5P/4B6P dwg no. 121 Housetype B4 - 3B5P dwg no. 122 Housetype C3/C6 - 4B6P 1 dwg no. 123 Housetype C3.2 - 4B6P dwg no. 124 Housetype C3/B3/C3 (Plot 11-13 and 22-24) - 3B5P/4B6P dwg no. 125A Boundary Treatment Details: Sheet 1 dwg no. 140 Boundary Treatment Details: Sheet 2 dwg no. 141 Central Square- Landscape General Arrangement HAT- TEP-Z0-ZZ-DR-L-74015 Rev P03 Site 2 - Landscape Masterplan HAT-TEP-Z0-ZZ-DR-L- 74045 Rev P05 Site 2 - Detailed Planting Plan Sheet 1 of 2 HAT-TEP- Page 2 XX-00-DR-L-74091 Rev P04 Site 2 - Detailed Planting Plan Sheet 2 of 2 HAT-TEP- XX-00-DR-L-74092 Rev P04 The car parking indicated on the approved plan ref Proposed Site 2 Plan dwg no.111 Rev D shall be provided to the full satisfaction of the Local Planning Authority and thereafter kept unobstructed and available for its intended purpose. The areas shall be maintained and kept available for the parking of vehicles at all times. Prior to occupation details of a residential Green Travel Plan has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The approved Travel Plan along with any relevant monitoring techniques shall be implemented to the satisfaction of the local Planning Authority prior to occupation of any part of the development. No development shall commence until a statement detailing Reasonable Avoidance Measures to be implemented on site to prevent harm to mammals and amphibians during the construction phase of the development hereby approved has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The measures to be implemented shall include the following: All excavations on site should be covered at night or a suitable ramp should be provided to all mammals/amphibians to exit excavations. All excavations should be checked for mammals/amphibians each morning prior to the re- commencement of any works. All exposed new pipework and drains should be capped at night so as to avoid trapping amphibians. All excavated materials/waste should be stored in skips or similar and not on the ground where it could be used as a refuge/resting area by amphibians. Alternatively all waste should be removed from site daily. All stored building materials that might be used as temporary resting places by amphibians should be stored off the ground on pallets or similar. Scaffold footings will be placed on sand to prevent newts taking temporary refuge underneath the footings. The avoidance measures shall be implemented in accordance with the approved details on the first commencement of development and shall remain in force as such for the full duration of the construction phase of the development. Jason Dugdale, on behalf of the applicant, addressed the Panel in relation the application. Decision: That planning permission be approved subject to conditions as detailed within the submitted report and the amended Page 3 conditions as detailed above. Name and Application No 19/00618/FUL Onward Homes Proposed Development: Construction of 15No. houses including associated infrastructure and area of public open space. Land Bounded by Underwood Road, Hattersley Road East and Melandra Cresent, Hattersley Speaker(s)/Late The Development Manager advised and circulated Representations amendments to conditions 2, 4, 21 within the submitted report to be replaced with the following conditions: The development hereby approved shall be carried out strictly in accordance with the plans and specifications as approved unless required by any other conditions in this permission. Site Location Plan dwg no.18-012/202 Site Location Master Plan 201A Proposed Site 1 Layout 207A Proposed Site 1 Layout: Roof Plan 206A Landscape Masterplan (purposes of Green Space Only) dwg no.D7404.004 draft Detailed Planting dwg no. D7404.008 Housetype A4 - 2B4P dwg no. 210 Housetype B3 - 3B5P dwg no. 211 Housetype C2 - 4B6P dwg no. 212 Street Elevations 1 dwg no. 215 Boundary Treatments dwg no. 226 The car parking indicated on the approved plan ref Proposed Site 2 Plan dwg no.111 Rev D shall be provided to the full satisfaction of the Local Planning Authority and thereafter kept unobstructed and available for its intended purpose. The areas shall be maintained and kept available for the parking of vehicles at all times. Prior to the re-information of land levels on the site, details (including scaled plans) of a landscaping scheme shall be provided to address the provision of the enhanced area of Public Open Space indicated on drawing no.s Proposed Site 1 Layout 207A and Landscape Masterplan (purposes of Green Space Only) dwg no.D7404.004 (draft). The scheme shall include details of the routing of footpaths, hard surfacing, soft landscaping (to include the location, number and species of specimens to be planted), street furniture and management responsibilities of the area.