Poems from a Quaker Heartland the Friend INDEPENDENT QUAKER JOURNALISM SINCE 1843
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
14 May 2010 £1.70 the DISCOVER THE CONTEMPORARYFriend QUAKER WAY Poems from a Quaker heartland the Friend INDEPENDENT QUAKER JOURNALISM SINCE 1843 CONTENTS – VOL 168 NO 20 3-5 News 3 Patriotism or profit? 4 Failure is not an option 5 An injustice system Bob Booth 6 A look at prison sentencing Richard Scatchard 7 Comment John Lampen, Rachael Booth and Ann Johnson 8-9 Letters 10-11 Poems from a Quaker heartland Sue Holden 12 Charles Morgan Peter Holland 13 Trust: lost and re-found Nöel Staples 14 Mornington Crescent ministry John Hall 16 q-eye: witness 17 Friends & Meetings Cover image: Lower Force waterfall at river Ure, Aysgarth, Wensleydale, North Yorkshire. Photo: Sheffield Tiger/ flickr CC:BY. See pages 10-11. Details from Matthew Jackson’s Quaker Meeting Place Garden. Photos: Peter Fishpool. See page 16. The Friend Subscriptions Fox Enquiry Team Editorial UK £72 per year by all payment types If you have information for Editor: including annual direct debit; the Friend’s new investigative Ian Kirk-Smith monthly payment by direct debit journalism unit £6.50; online only £45 per year. please email [email protected] Articles, images and For details of other rates, correspondence should be emailed contact Penny Dunn on or write to Fox, the Friend, 173 to [email protected] 020 7663 1178 or [email protected] Euston Road, London NW1 2BJ or sent to the address below. the Friend 173 Euston Road, London NW1 2BJ Tel: 020 7663 1010 Fax: 020 7663 1182 www.thefriend.org Editor: Ian Kirk-Smith [email protected] • Production editor: Jez Smith [email protected] • Sub-editor: Trish Carn [email protected] • News reporter: Symon Hill [email protected] • Arts editor: Rowena Loverance [email protected] • Environment editor: Laurie Michaelis [email protected] • Subscriptions officer: Penny Dunn [email protected] Tel: 020 7663 1178 • Advertisement manager: George Penaluna, Ad department, 54a Main Street, Cononley, Keighley BD20 8LL Tel: 01535 630230 [email protected] • Clerk of the trustees: A David Olver • ISSN: 0016-1268 The Friend Publications Limited is a registered charity, number 211649 • Printed by Headley Bros Ltd, Queens Road, Ashford, Kent TN24 8HH 2 the Friend, 14 May 2010 News Patriotism or profit? Symon Hill reports on campaigners’ efforts to put BAE Sytems’ activities ‘on the record’ The chairman of the arms probe a huge BAE deal with his Olver’s earlier claims about BAE’s company BAE Systems has refused country. As the tension rose, he innocence. to rule out arms sales to countries quoted Desmond Tutu’s claim ‘You have lied to the shareholders that threaten the UK. that the deal ‘unleashed a culture of this company,’ he insisted, ‘If you In a heated annual general of corruption that has seriously have a shred of personal integrity… meeting (AGM) in the Queen undermined the transition from you will today publicly apologise Elizabeth Centre in London, apartheid to democracy’. to the shareholders and the chairman Dick Olver insisted Andrew Feinstein challenged communities you misled and you that he was ‘passionate’ about Olver on BAE’s recent ‘plea will resign with immediate effect’. British industry. He defended bargains’. In February, British and Dick Olver rejected the himself from accusations that he is US authorities agreed to drop allegations ‘with every sinew of my more concerned with profit than corruption investigations in return being’. He added, ‘I have spent six patriotism. for relatively small payouts and years doing precisely the opposite In a room full of BAE images of confessions of guilt over more of what you suggest’. union flags, campaigners pointed minor offences. Under further questioning, Dick out that the UK now accounts for But Andrew Feinstein said Olver admitted that no director only a minority of BAE’s business. that the plea bargains contradict or senior employee had resigned, Dick Olver avoided a question even though BAE had pleaded from a shareholder who asked him guilty to conspiracy to mislead to ‘guarantee’ that he would not sell BAE Systems factfile the US Department of Justice. He arms to ‘countries which threaten was jeered as he claimed that none the UK’. To shouts of ‘answer the • BAE is the world’s largest arms of them knew the company was question!’, Olver only repeated company. misleading anyone. unspecific comments about • Around 95% of BAE’s sales are Demonstrators gathered in a ‘rigorous standards’. military. They include fighter peaceful protest outside the AGM The majority of questions aircraft, warships, tanks and to form a ‘People’s Jury’ and put a were asked by supporters of the artillery. giant puppet of Dick Olver ‘in the Campaign Against Arms Trade • BAE made £18.5bn in 2008. dock’. (CAAT), who buy single shares • BAE has military customers in CAAT’s Sarah Waldron described to gain access to the AGM. The over 100 countries, including this as ‘an attempt to get the true activists were themselves heckled Saudi Arabia and Indonesia. facts about BAE’s activities onto by traditional shareholders. • BAE has recently sold arms to the record, given that they are now The atmosphere in the room was both India and Pakistan. very unlikely to reach court, thanks set by the first question, asked by • BAE is facing corruption to the shameful plea bargains South African former MP Andrew allegations in five continents. between BAE and the UK and US Feinstein, who led attempts to authorities.’ the Friend, 14 May 2010 3 News Failure is not an option Joe Thwaites reports on an international conference on nuclear weapons The dispute between Iran and the deterrent for as long as nuclear negotiations in good faith’ towards United States reignited last week weapons exist’. In a move to disarmament of their arsenals; in New York at the opening of demonstrate greater transparency, states without nuclear weapons a United Nations conference to the US announced the number of agreed not to seek them; and review progress on disarmament nuclear weapons in its stockpile all countries are guaranteed the and non-proliferation of nuclear – 5,113. right to peaceful use of nuclear weapons. 189 states are participating in technology. Iranian president Mahmoud the eighth review conference of In a speech to an international Ahmadinejad used the opportunity the Nuclear Non Proliferation gathering of more than 800 to deflect attention from its nuclear Treaty (NPT) this month. The peace activists in advance of the programme and attack the United last meeting in 2005 was widely conference, UN secretary general States on its own record. He said acknowledged as a failure, after Ban Ki-Moon set out his hopes that as the only country to use deadlock over how to address for successful talks: ‘We know nuclear weapons offensively, the Iran’s nuclear programme and the that nuclear disarmament is not a United States was ‘among the most lack of serious commitments to distant, unattainable dream. It is an hated in history’. disarmament from nuclear armed urgent necessity, here and now. We Reiterating president Obama’s states. are determined to achieve it.’ vision set out in his speech in Created in 1968, the NPT rests Prague last year for a world free of on three pillars: recognised nuclear Joe Thwaites is a programme nuclear weapons, Hillary Clinton states (China, France, Russia, the assistant for the Quaker UN Office outlined steps the US has taken in UK and US) committed to ‘pursue in New York. this direction, but stated that ‘the A longer version of this article is United States will retain a nuclear Photo: UN Photo/Mark Garten. available at www.thefriend.org. 4 the Friend, 14 May 2010 [email protected] Report An injustice system Bob Booth asks ‘Whose hands are at work in the justice system?’ Photo: Robin Dude/flickr CC:BY. It was the epitome of a good positives – suicides down, fewer were happening – but were less Quaker event. There was an women and young people in publicised. openness and a listening and prison and a prison service now Magistrate John Myhill made learning from others who are able to be charged with corporate very clear how most cases are usually separated by the society manslaughter. ‘We legislators have complicated and need to be dealt around us. It was a chance to start not done well with the government with at a personal level, rather the radical changes so desperately passing 3,600 new criminal justice than in the generalised way that needed in our sadly ineffective laws since 1997.’ The balance is politicians often propose as an easy justice system. moving even further away from solution. Probation officer Ann The occasion was the 2010 community to punishment and Powell countered the generalisation conference of Quakers in prison – despite the proof of that they had been ‘de-skilled’ by Criminal Justice at Glenthorne reconvictions clearly pointing their merger with the prison service Quaker Centre and those present the other way. It was, she said, a in NOMS, the National Offender included probation and prison question of ‘waste management for Management Service, and she was officers, an ex-prison governor, unwanted people’ – an injustice quite optimistic about working a social worker, magistrates, system. better with both police and prisons. ex-prisoners, prison chaplains, a However, against this pessimism Most of us have not become policeman, a psychiatrist, a radical there was a more positive note computer watchers, she said. parliamentarian and so on. from other speakers. Experiences Paula Harvey on behalf of Vivien Stern told how the House at the chalk face show us that Quaker Peace & Social Witness of Lords was both frustrating ‘the offence does not define and the Crime, Community and and challenging.