Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly FROM THE EDITOR’S DESK ........................ Rev. Joseph W. Koterski, S.J. PRESIDENT’S LETTER ............................................William L. Saunders ARTICLES 40 Serving the Divorced and Remarried Well ...................................... Thomas J. Nash Numbers 1/2 Amoris Laetitia and “Pastoral Discernment”: Spring/Summer 2017 Areas of Concern ..............................................................Rev. Thomas V. Berg The Canonical Position of Amoris Laetitia ......................................Edward N. Peters Michael Novak, 1933-2017 ........................................................William L. Saunders The Vibrance of Reality: On Being a “Rigid” Thomist .........Rev. James V. Schall, S.J. The Catholic Mind ......................................................................Jude P. Dougherty Implications of Obergefell for the Catholic Church in the U.S. .................................Rev. Gerald E. Murray, J.C.D. Obergefell v. Hodges: A Judicial Flight into Fantasyland ....................... D. Q. McInerny Lessons from the Jürgen Habermas and Joseph Ratzinger Debate .............................................Eduardo Echeverria Keeping Men Open to the Divine: James V. Schall on Modernity and Catholic Social and Political Thought .............................................. Brian Jones Remodernism: A Revival of Realism ...................................Rev. John J. Conley, S.J. Do Catholics Need Ecclesiastical Permission to Divorce? ..............Edward N. Peters Religious Warfare .........................................................................Jude P. Dougherty BOOK REVIEWS The Authority of Women in the Catholic Church by Monica Migliorino Miller ..................................Catherine Brown Tkacz The Servant and the Ladder: Cooperation with Evil in the Twenty-First Century by Andrew McClean Cummings ......................................... D. Q. McInerny A Universe from Nothing: Why There Is Something Rather than Nothing by Lawrence M. Krauss........................................................ D. Q. McInerny ISSN 1084-3035 Christianity, Democracy, and the Shadow of Constantine ........................................ George E. Demacopoulos and Aristotle Papanikolaou, editors... Jude P. Dougherty Fellowship of Catholic Scholars P.O. Box 495 Return to Order: From a Frenzied Economy to an Organic Christian Order Notre Dame, IN 46556 by John Horvat II .......................................................Christopher H. Owen catholicscholars.org God or Nothing: A Conversation on Faith by Robert Cardinal Sarah with Nicholas Diat ....................... Steven C. Abell Fr. Joseph Koterski, SJ, editor [email protected] Mary—Ten Test Questions for the World’s Finest Woman by William P. Welty ...............................................Msgr. Charles M. Mangan Prof. Elizabeth C. Shaw, associate editor [email protected] OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS FCS Quarterly • Spring/Summer 2017 1 FROM THE EDITOR’S DESK THE PRESIDENT’S LETTER Rev. Joseph W. Koterski, S.J. th Fordham University 40 Anniversary Convention in September New Documents Friends— Fellowship of n this letter, I wish to emphasize one thing: featured, and our Wright and O’Boyle awards will be Catholic Scholars from the CDF The Fellowship will celebrate its fortieth presented to Weigel and Alvare. anniversary this year. I urge you to alert old friends who may not have Scholarship Inspired by the Holy Spirit, I in Service to the Church mong the most recent publications to appear The primary means to do so will be our annual attended for years. I hope as many of us as possible from the Congregation for the Doctrine of convention, which this year will be held in Arlington, can gather to celebrate forty years of faithful scholarly Virginia. All details will soon be available at our web FROM THE EDITOR’S DESK .............................................. 2 the Faith (CDF) is a short but fascinating service to the Church. history of that institution entitled To Promote page: www.catholicscholars.org. The convention This should be fun. Spread the word. And plan to PRESIDENT'S LETTER .......................................................... 4 Aand Safeguard the Faith: From the Holy Office to the theme this year is Social Science and Religion. join us. ✠ Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (Libreria Editrice Our program planning is proceeding apace, but I ARTICLES Vaticana, 2015). can tell you now that noted Catholic scholars such as William Saunders Serving the Divorced and Remarried Well ........................5 The work begins with an account of the development George Weigel, Helen Alvare, and Pat Fagan will be Americans United for Life Amoris Laetitia and “Pastoral Discernment” .......................9 of the Holy Office as a congregation with universal juris- The Canonical Position of Amoris Laetitia ..........................15 diction that emerged out of the Roman Inquisition in the Michael Novak, 1933-2017 .................................................19 1540s. It then turns to the Holy Office’s reorganization The Vibrance of Reality: On Being a “Rigid” Thomist ...20 in the early twentieth century and the renaming of this The Catholic Mind ................................................................25 institution in 1965 as the Congregation for the Doctrine English language as To the Bishops of the Catholic on how to understand the status of these groups and Implications of Obergefell for the Catholic Church of the Faith—a rebranding that the Fathers of the Second Church regarding the Relationship between Hierarchical and movements in relation to the Church. It not only takes in the U.S. .............................................................................26 Vatican Council saw as crucial for the updating of the Charismatic Gifts in the Life and Mission of the Church note of the texts of the Code of Canon Law that are Obergefell v. Hodges: A Judicial Flight into Fantasyland ..32 Roman curia in light of the greatly altered circumstances (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2016). This is a docu- relevant to these initiatives but also provides a theologi- Lessons from the Jürgen Habermas and of the contemporary world. ment that discusses the notion of charisms within the cal approach to thinking about the action of the Holy Joseph Ratzinger Debate .................................................42 The bulk of the work describes the current status of Church, not only in regard to traditional ecclesial orga- Spirit in inspiring ways of life that serve the work of Keeping Men Open to the Divine .....................................55 the CDF by a review of the document that governs its nizations, institutes of consecrated life, and societies of charity in stable and reliable ways. Remodernism: A Revival of Realism ................................58 current jurisdiction and mandate, the constitution Pastor apostolic life, but also in regard to recent phenomena Do Catholics Need Ecclesiastical Permission Bonus of 1988. There are interesting sections on its missions such as ecclesial movements and new communities that New Books to Divorce? ..........................................................................61 of examining the doctrinal orthodoxy of various books are unified by a shared charism that makes it possible Religious Warfare...................................................................65 and other publications and of judging such cases as claims for groups of the faithful to follow Christ and to serve of apparitions, the admission to the priesthood of men various apostolic purposes of the Church. s busy as the cardinals of the Church are, we BOOK REVIEWS who were previously ministers in non-Catholic denomi- Of special interest is a theological account of are fortunate to have from them a number The Authority of Women in the Catholic Church....................67 nations, the absolution for certain types of excommunica- charisms according to the New Testament, with great of recent books that may be of interest to The Servant and the Ladder ........................................................68 tion, doubts concerning the validity of baptism, and cer- attention to the Church’s understanding of what it the members of the Fellowship. We will A Universe from Nothing ...............................................................72 Abriefly consider five of them here. tain types of cases concerning the matrimonial bond. means for there to be a gift of the Holy Spirit given Christianity, Democracy, and the Shadow of Constantine ...82 The remainder of the work reports on the relation- “for the good of all” and the need for the primacy of In A People of Hope (New York: Image Books, 2012), Return to Order ................................................................................83 ship of the CDF to such institutions as the Pontifical charity in those charisms that the Church formally we have a volume of remarks by Timothy Cardinal God or Nothing: A Conversation on Faith ................................84 Biblical Commission (especially on questions about the recognizes as such. Dolan of New York in conversation with John L. Allen, Mary–Ten Test Questions for the World’s Finest Woman.....85 proper interpretation of scripture), the International There are also sections on the recent teachings of Jr. What is particularly valuable about this book is the information it provides on a wide variety of topics that OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS .........................................