DOCSLIB.ORG

The Denial of Holy Communion Due to Obstinate Perseverance in Manifest Grave Sin

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Denial of Holy Communion Due to Obstinate Perseverance in Manifest Grave Sin THE DENIAL OF HOLY COMMUNION DUE TO OBSTINATE PERSEVERANCE IN MANIFEST GRAVE SIN : THE APPLICATION OF C. 915 IN THE AMERICAN CONTEXT by Laura MORRISON A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Canon Law Saint Paul University, Ottawa, Canada, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Canon Law Saint Paul University © Laura Morrison, Ottawa, Canada 2015 ABSTRACT The pastoral interpretation and application of the clause of c. 915 which says those who are obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to Holy Communions, as applied to persons in irregular marriages and politicians that espouse “pro- choice” platforms, is the focus of this study. A tremendous amount of confusion and alienation on the part of the faithful occurs in relation to the application of the pertinent clause in parishes and dioceses throughout the United States, due to the words used in the norm and an inconsistent application of them. The approaches within the Church are disparate. Some are told by their pastors that they simply must face the consequences of the choices they have made and not present themselves for Communion until their situation is corrected. Others are never approached about the issue. Few, though, are provided with an explanation of the law and an opportunity to discuss their personal circumstances in relation to it, in any meaningful way; that is, with an opportunity to make informed decisions about how to proceed in their lives. Most people to whom the law of c. 915 is applicable were not sufficiently catechized to know they could be denied Holy Communion if they divorced and civilly remarried or ran on a particular political party platform. As this study will show, there are historical reasons, some of which have been acknowledged by the Church, for why this is often not substantially the fault of those presenting for Communion. To some of the faithful it seems that the law or the manner by which it is applied is judgmental and evidences a lack of charity. Others, though, propound a theory that it is charity which prompts them to support denial of Communion. The disunity which the current application prompts, demonstrates the demand for a new approach to the application of c. 915; one that focuses on catechesis and reconciliation, and more evidences the charity and mercy required of the followers of Christ. A portion of the study that offers reflections on the theological underpinnings of c. 915 also provides perspectives for addressing its application in consideration of notions of conscience and moral law that should be factored into any application of the clause. Additionally, the study proposes an original program which employs restorative justice principles in a neutral setting and may profitably be used to avert the pastoral and canonical problems that have arisen in the application of c. 915. It is titled “Dialogue of Charity: kairos of Mercy” and includes three participants to a Dialogue meeting: (1) the Communicant, namely, the person who has been, or may be, denied Communion under the pertinent clause of c. 915; (2) the Canonist or, if not a degreed canonist, a cleric from the diocese knowledgeable in the pertinent canon law and Church doctrine; and (3) a Facilitator who is trained to prompt and address issues which arise during the Dialogue. The meeting is intended to provide a venue in which Communicants are encouraged to share details about themselves and be guided in understanding how their situation is viewed in terms of Church teaching and law, so they may discern a future course of action. Participation in the Dialogue can be invaluable in the event that the Communicant wishes to participate in a relevant legal process, to wit, taking recourse against a decision denying them Communion, petitioning, re-petitioning for a declaration of nullity of their marriage, or responding to a petition. During this time of mercy, in consideration of charity, and based on the findings of this study, the Church must approach the topic from the perspective of the obvious: that the matter of the application of the “obstinate perseverance in manifest grave sin” clause must be reviewed and that a remedy must be put into place for assisting those to whom the pertinent clause may be applied. TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.............................................................................................iv ABBREVIATIONS............................................................................................................v GENERAL INTRODUCTION……….……………………….………………..….……1 I. INTERPRETATION OF CANON 915 Introduction ..............................................................................................................7 1.1 – The Canonical Tradition Before the 1983 Code .............................................7 1.1.1 – The Pauline Tradition ..................................................................................7 1.1.2 – Canon 855 of the Pio-Benedictine Code ....................................................10 1.1.3 – Selected Commentators on Canon 855 ......................................................11 1.1.4 – The praxis Curiae Romanae on Canon 855 ...............................................16 1.1.5 – The iter of Canon 915 in the Revision of the 1917 Code ..........................19 1.2 – The Interpretation of the Current Law ..........................................................22 1.2.1 – Text and Context of Canon 915 .................................................................22 1.2.2 – Canon 712 of the Eastern Code .................................................................25 1.2.3 – Four Additional Texts of the Holy See ......................................................27 1.2.3.1 – Familiaris consortio................................................................................28 1.2.3.2 – Catechism of the Catholic Church ..........................................................30 1.2.3.3 – CDF Letter to Bishops ............................................................................31 1.2.3.4 – Pontifical Council for the Family Guidelines .........................................33 1.2.4 – Selected Authors on Canon 915 .................................................................34 1.2.4.1 – Commentaries and Canonical Opinions..................................................35 1.2.4.2 – The Travers-Myers Debate .....................................................................40 1.3 – The PCLT Declaration and Subsequent Developments................................46 1.3.1 – The PCLT Declaration ...............................................................................47 1.3.2 – Three Additional Documents .....................................................................52 1.3.2.1 – Ecclesia de Eucharistia...........................................................................52 1.3.2.2 – Redemptionis Sacramentum ....................................................................54 1.3.2.3 – Cardinal Ratzinger’s Letter to the USCCB .............................................56 1.3.3 – Authors After the PCLT Declaration .........................................................58 Conclusion .............................................................................................................66 II. CRITICAL REFLECTIONS ON THE APPLICATION OF CANON 915 Introduction ............................................................................................................72 2.1 – Confusion Regarding Church Teachings ......................................................72 2.1.1 – Confusion Experienced in the Wake of Vatican II ....................................74 2.1.2 – Confusion Acknowledged by the Magisterium .........................................80 2.1.3 – The Social-Historical Context for the Confusion ......................................85 2.1.4 – A New Approach to Catechetics ................................................................88 2.1.5 – A Renewed Understanding of Church .......................................................99 2.1.6 – The Doctrine on Marriage ........................................................................101 i 2.1.7 – Catholic Social Doctrine ..........................................................................103 2.2 – Pastoral Challenges in the Application of Canon 915 ................................105 2.2.1 – Lack of Charity ........................................................................................105 2.2.2 – Inattention to Other Canonical Norms .....................................................111 2.2.3 – Uneven Application .................................................................................113 2.2.4 – Lack of Direction to Pastors ....................................................................117 Conclusion ...........................................................................................................122 III. THEOLOGICAL REFLECTIONS Introduction ..........................................................................................................126 3.1 – Theology as the Underpinning of Canon 915 .............................................127 3.2 – Pope John Paul II, Personalism, and the Application of the Law ...............142 3.3 – Conscience and Moral Imputability ............................................................151 3.3.1 – Conscience ...............................................................................................153 3.3.2 – Moral Imputability
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Facultyhandbook
    FACULTY HANDBOOK 2017-2018 COPYRIGHT: LOYOLA UNIVERSITY MARYLAND TABLE OF CONTENTS REMINDER CALENDAR* ........................................................................................................................................i INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................................... iii FACULTY HANDBOOK AND ACADEMIC POLICY COMMITTEE ..............................................................iv ON-LINE RESOURCES ............................................................................................................................................. v I. ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF LOYOLA UNIVERSITY MARYLAND ......................................... I-1 A. Purpose ......................................................................................................................................................... I-1 B. 1852-1917 .................................................................................................................................................... I-1 C. 1917-1950 .................................................................................................................................................... I-2 D. 1950-1964 .................................................................................................................................................... I-4 E. 1964 To 1993 ..............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Kirby Catalogue Part 8 1891-1895
    Archival list The Kirby Collection Catalogue Irish College Rome ARCHIVES PONTIFICAL IRISH COLLEGE, ROME Code Date Description and Extent KIR/ 1890 / 494 circa 1890 Holograph letter from Sr. Mary, Rome, to Kirby: Writer thanks Kirby for consenting to be their confessor. Query as to steps to be taken. [see KIR/1890/316] ['Sr. Mary' would appear to be the Foundress of the Little Company of Mary.] 3pp 495 31 December Holograph letter from J.J. Farr, Chettendale, Marrickville, 1890 to Kirby: Personal letter. [Although this letter is dated 'December 31st 1890', the postscript which states 'All well but very hot here' is dated January 5th 1891.] 1p 1 1 January Holograph letter from Sr. M. Peter Frances O'Reilly, 1891 Lisbon, to Kirby: Convent news. Sisters M. de Ricci and Martha died during 1890. School has fallen off considerably of late years, probably due to number of schools now in the country and 'rage amongst the higher class for foreign governesses'. Requests Pope's blessing on 'his Irish children in Bon Successo, Lisbon' and a special one on the writer who celebrates Golden Jubilee of her profession on 5 October of present year. Necessary to re-open novitiate to admit 2 'promising novices', the one French and the other from Loanda, a former pupil'. 4pp 2 1 January Holograph letter from Sr. M. Ignatius Walsh, Yarrawonga, 1891 Victoria, to Kirby: Personal letter. 4pp 3 1 January Holograph letter from Sr. Mary A. Beckett, Birr, to Kirby: 1891 Thanks Kirby for painting of Our Lady of Mercy, which writer has had framed in Dublin and erected in their own chapel 'in time for St.
    [Show full text]
  • CNZP Streamlined JMT Reductions.Docx
    Symposium on the 2015 Synod on the Family Conscience and the Synod: An Evolving Quaestio Disputata James T. Bretzke, S.J. ERTAINLY UNDER THE FRANCIS PAPACY our Roman teapot is filled to the brim with leaves clamoring to be read and deciphered—too many in fact for even a cursory overview. C Instead I would like to articulate one hypothesis and then probe it by looking at just a couple of the tea-leaves that have collected around contrasting views on the relationship of conscience and Church teaching. First the hypothesis: I believe that a helpful way to read the tea- leaves is by considering them in terms of a major cultural paradigm shift taking place in the Church.1 This shift began with the run-up to Vatican II and we’ve been witnessing something of a protracted tug- of-war ever since. Clearly in the Franciscan papacy the energy has again shifted and this in turn has occasioned a considerable amount of push-back from forces that once enjoyed great influence in the previ- ous two pontificates. One core tension revolves around various understandings of con- science, and especially in connection to its relationship to the Church’s magisterium. For example, in the Instrumentum laboris for the Octo- ber 2015 Synod, the paragraphs on conscience, especially no. 137, came in for considerable critical attention before the Synod opened. The problematic paragraph suggested that couples “under the regular guidance of a competent spiritual guide… [could] make choices which are humanly fulfilling and ones which conform to God’s will” and that these might strike a balance between the “objective moral norm which does not permit considering the act of generation a reality to be de- 1 For a fuller treatment of this paradigm shift in the papacy of Pope Francis, see James T.
    [Show full text]
  • Fantastic Interview
    HOME CONTACT US ABOUT US SUBSCRIBE CURRENT EDITION: Front Sunday Sermons Catholic Replies Washington Watch Prayer First Teachers From The Mail Top Stories for Thursday, September 5th, 2013: THE WANDERER E-EDITION: Past Editions: 09.05.2013 PURCHASE A SUBSCRIPTION SUBMIT AN ANNOUNCEMENT SUBMIT A NEWS RELEASE Our Lady of Guadalupe, Conejos, Colorado SUBMIT A LETTER TO THE EDITOR Interview With Cardinal Burke . Insights On The Church ABOUT US And Modern Society CONTACT US By DON FIER (Editor’s Note: Raymond Leo Cardinal Burke, prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura in Rome, who formerly served as bishop of the FAQ Diocese of La Crosse, Wis., and archbishop of the Archdiocese of St. Louis, Mo., recently spent some time in the United States. The Catholic Servant was granted the opportunity to interview His Eminence in mid-July on a variety of topics at Eternal Life’s The Church Teaches Forum in Louisville, Ky. The Catholic Servant — a Minneapolis- based newspaper — gave The Wanderer permission to reprint the interview. (Don Fier serves on the Board of Directors for The Catholic Servant and he writes the Learn Your Faithcolumn for The Wanderer.) + + + Q. Six years ago, Pope Benedict issued Summorum Pontificum, which allowed for the usage of the Tridentine Mass on a wider scale in the Church. In his accompanying letter to the bishops, the Holy Father stated that “the two Forms of the usage of the Roman Rite can be mutually enriching.” Do you see concrete benefits that have come to the Church in the past several years because ofSummorum Pontificum? A.
    [Show full text]
  • Blessed Sacrament, Wichita, KS B 4C 02-0858 Pam Hesse FRANKLIN 648-4377 LAW OFFICE Joni J
    Blessed Sacrament CATHOLIC CHURCH July 25, 2021 The Seventeenth Sunday in Ordinary Time John 6:1-15 Fr. Andrew Heiman Pastor Fr. Matt Siegman Parochial Vicar Mass Times Sacraments and Stewardship Monday - Friday When I talk about stewardship, I often think of the 6:30am & 8am “time, talent, and treasure” formula that people my age learned Thursday 5:30pm growing up in Catholic schools. More recently, the diocese has (Extraordinary Form) recognized that stewardship is “the grateful response of a Saturday Christian disciple who recognizes and receives God’s gifts and 6:30am & 4pm shares these gifts in love of God and neighbor.” We can easily Sunday apply this definition to our time, talent, and treasure: After we 6:30am, 9am (streamed), focus our attention, we recognize the vast multitude of gifts we receive from God 11am, & 5:30pm every day. Confession When we try to apply that definition of stewardship to the rest of our lives, Monday - Friday though, it gets a little harder. Time, talent, and treasure give us a nice, clean 7:30-7:50am workspace. But if we limit our stewardship to these categories, we run the risk of Saturday 3-3:50pm getting ourselves stuck in a box. In reality, the entirety of our life is a gift from God. Sunday during Masses The only worthy response is to give ourselves entirely over to God. We can’t settle if a priest is available. for just giving God one hour of my Sunday. That’s only 0.6% of the week, for those who are counting.
    [Show full text]
  • Encyclical Letter Humanae Vitae in the Course of Time
    Philosophy and Canon Law vol. 5 (2019), pp. 23–34 ISSN 2451-2141 https://doi.org/10.31261/PaCL.2019.05.02 Marek Petro University of Prešov in Prešov, Slovakia https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2024-9981 Encyclical Letter Humanae Vitae in the Course of Time Abst ract: The content of Humanae Vitae (1968) caused an ongoing debate all over the world. It has also stirred up factual crisis of moral theology. The crisis has caused subjectivity of morality and this has caused further crisis. The most serious feature of the crisis seems to be an effort to accept moral pluralism inside the Catholic Church. The renewal of moral theology the Second Vatican Council talked about has been left blocked. A couple of years after the Second Vatican Council, but before publishing Humanae Vitae, warning of St. Paul VI calls for continuity with moral tradition as a criterion for the autonomy of Catholic moral theology. In spite of much op- position of some bishops, theologians, and laypeople, the teaching of the encyclical letter has priceless value. The truth about marital love and value of life is in its center. It is proclaimed in an overview of the teaching of the Catholic Church from Humanae Vitae to Evangelium Vitae. In its nature, family is invited to fullness of love and, at the same time, it is the heart of civilization of love. Unfortunately, current family has found itself between the two civilizations—civilization of love on the one hand and civilization of death and uncontrolled pleasure on the other. The teaching of the encyclical Humanae Vitae is a constant guide when protecting true marital love and family in the course of time.
    [Show full text]
  • Interview of Archbishop Raymond Burke on Canon
    present President. But in any case, no matter who to put someone in office who will do what is right is the President of the United States, here is a and just, or someone who won’t. And so if you, Interview of Archbishop world leader with a tremendous capacity to knowing that abortion is a grave crime against Raymond Burke on promote the common good, but at the same time human life – is the killing of an innocent, sadly, who could—by promoting and defenseless human life -and you vote for the Canon 915 implementing anti-life legislation measures— candidate who says that he intends to make that could be an agent of death. more available – that practice of infanticide -you The entire transcript of Randall Terry’s Mar. 2, bear a responsibility. That is, you have cooperated 2009, interview of Archbishop Raymond Burke is Mr. Terry: If I was a Catholic in another country, in the election of this person into office, there’s no provided below: I would be watching the news unfold in America question about it. hearing the silence of so many Catholics, the Mr. Terry: Your Excellency, it’s a delight to be debate over communion, and it might have the Mr. Terry: Archbishop, thank you for your time. with you. Thank you so much. effect of me just saying, “Well, we have abortion Do you have any closing comments or here, they’ve got it there, let’s just all learn to live exhortations? Archbishop Raymond Burke: Pleased to have with it and go on about our business.” you come, and to visit with you.
    [Show full text]
  • Morality of Contraceptives Based on When Personhood Begins Joella R
    Cedarville University DigitalCommons@Cedarville Student Papers Honors Program Fall 2013 Morality of Contraceptives Based on When Personhood Begins Joella R. Gerber Cedarville University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/ honors_program_papers Part of the Bioethics and Medical Ethics Commons, and the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Gerber, Joella R., "Morality of Contraceptives Based on When Personhood Begins" (2013). Student Papers. 2. http://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/honors_program_papers/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@Cedarville, a service of the Centennial Library. It has been accepted for inclusion in Student Papers by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Cedarville. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Morality of Contraceptives Based on When Personhood Begins Joella Gerber The use of contraceptives has been controversial in recent days, especially concerning the government mandate for insurance and health care companies to financially cover contraceptives for their policy holders. The term ‘contraceptive’ includes anything that deliberately prevents conception or impregnation, including condoms, birth control pills, intrauterine methods, and barrier methods (Miriam-Webster, 2013). The morality of contraception largely hinges on the belief of when personhood begins. Throughout history, religious, scientific, and philosophical ideas surrounding the beginning of personhood have created dissention about the moment when a human being becomes a person. This debate has been especially important among Christians, and opposing views have further separated Roman Catholics and Protestant Evangelicals. One view of personhood, largely endorsed by the Roman Catholic magisterium, is that personhood begins at the moment when God thinks of the being.
    [Show full text]
  • Humanae Vitae (1968), by Pope Paul VI [1]
    Published on The Embryo Project Encyclopedia (https://embryo.asu.edu) Humanae Vitae (1968), by Pope Paul VI [1] By: Brind'Amour, Katherine Garcia, Benjamin Keywords: Catholicism [2] Popes [3] Reproductive rights [4] The “Humanae Vitae,” meaning “Of Human Life” and subtitled “On the Regulation of Birth,” was an encyclical promulgated in Rome, Italy, on 25 July 1968 by Pope Paul VI [6]. This encyclical defended and reiterated the Roman Catholic Church’s stance on family planning [7] and reproductive issues such as abortion [8], sterilization [9], and contraception [10]. The document continues to have a controversial reputation today, as its statements regarding birth control [11] strike many Catholics as unreasonable. First, the encyclical acknowledges that there are often circumstances in which a married couple would desire to limit the size of their family. In a thorough discussion of sexual relationships, Pope Paul VI [6] writes that sex is primarily intended to produce offspring but is welcome in marriage even when that is not its immediate aim. The document warns, however, that the sexual act must remain intact for the purpose of procreation [12] and that the “generative process” should never be intentionally interrupted, as doing so would go against the Natural Law and the Roman Catholic Church’s teachings. The encyclical goes on to explain how practicing artificial contraception [10] can negatively affect the balance of life and God’s plan for all people. Among the consequences listed are claims that practicing artificial contraception [10] lowers moral standards and allows men to view women simply as a means of satisfying their own personal sexual desires.
    [Show full text]
  • Humanae Vitae by Greg Witherow
    Humanae Vitae By Greg Witherow The year 1960 was pivotal for contraception. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration had just approved the birth control pill for use by the American public. This act culminated years of labor by Margaret Sanger, the founder of the American birth control movement and Planned Parenthood, who helped provide funding in its development1. The Pill was by no means the first contraceptive. But with its ease and near 100% effectiveness it brought contraception into the mainstream. Yet initially, contraceptives were not universally legal in the United States. It was not until the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a Connecticut law outlawing contraception2 in 1965 and a subsequent 1972 case3 (giving the unmarried access to contraception) that contraceptives were universally available in the United States4. With the ensuing use of contraception, dramatic changes were unleashed in Western civilization, often in ways unanticipated by the public. For the first time in the history of mankind, sexual intercourse had been effectively decoupled from pro creation. The social implications were immense. Women saw the Pill as Liberation. They could now control their destiny and the natural workings of their bodies. No longer would they be burdened with children they didn’t choose to have. Men instinctively saw something different; for them the Age of Unfettered Sex was about to dawn5. No longer would sex have consequences that required additional social obligations. And in the wake of contraception loomed the abortion and pornography industries. While always existing at the periphery, these trades were now moved to the threshold of the mainstream6, with contraception as the necessary stepping-stone.
    [Show full text]
  • Pastoral Care of Couples in Irregular Marriages : a Reflection on Amoris Laetitia Chapter- 8
    PASTORAL CARE OF COUPLES IN IRREGULAR MARRIAGES : A REFLECTION ON AMORIS LAETITIA CHAPTER- 8 Introduction Issuing the Apostolic Exhortation Amoris laetitia (promulgated during the Extraordinary Jubilee of Mercy, on 19 March 2016), Pope Francis has brought out the continued reflection by the Synod of 2015 on the Church s teaching about the sacrament of matrimony and the Christian understanding of the family. The Exhortation once again calls the Church to revitalize the pastoral assistance to the people of God in the light of God s mercy and love. Amoris laetitia calls forth more compassionate, practical and situational interpretation of canonical norms pertaining to the essential ends and properties of the sacrament of matrimony in the context of the administration of the sacraments of penance and Eucharist and other pastoral care to be rendered to the families in irregular marriages. The Holy Father takes a special step ahead and invites those involved in the pastoral ministry to strengthen the families, and to reach out to those who are in irregular marriages including those alienated from the life of the Church. His Holiness also exhorts that a sympathetic and a accompaniment approach has to be adopted towards those with a distorted understanding of Christian teaching on marriage and family life, and those who may have in some way defected from the Catholic communion, and yet desire to be more fully integrated into the life of the Church, especially in the reception of the Sacraments of Penance and Eucharist. Pope Francis addresses all important challenges the Church faces today in the context of marriage and family.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Century and New Ventures
    Chapter 4 A New Century and New Ventures he men who would lead the province withdraw the Society from any parish that did not in the first decades of the 20th century have either a college or at least the prospects of a would bring to their post a variety of college attached to it. While Fr. McKinnon was not experiences. With the resignation of Fr. anxious for the Society to lose the parish where so Purbrick 47-year-old Fr. Thomas Gannon, much effort had just been expended to build the TSJ, was appointed as his successor. Gannon had been new church, more importantly, he recognized that rector-president of St. John’s College (Fordham) for there was a growing need for a school that would four years and served several stints as socius to the cater to the educational and religious needs of the provincial. He would later serve as tertian instructor sons of wealthy Catholics in New York City.36 There and then have the distinction of being the first were a number of private day schools in Manhattan American Assistant to the Superior General when that catered to the children of the wealthy and it the United States was separated from the English was to these that the growing number of well-to-do Assistancy in 1915. He would be succeeded in the Catholics had often turned to educate their sons. office by Fr. Joseph Hanselman, SJ. Born in 1856 Rightly fearing - at a time when prejudice against and entering the Society in 1878, Fr. Hanselman Catholics was not unknown - that the atmosphere had spent most of his priestly life at the College in these schools was not conducive to the spiritual of the Holy Cross, first as prefect of discipline and development of Catholic young men, Fr.
    [Show full text]