University of Florida Thesis Or Dissertation Formatting
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
POSED AND DEPOSED: PROPAGANDA AND RESISTANCE IN CARTE-DE-VISITE PHOTOGRAPHS OF MAXIMILIAN VON HABSBURG DURING MEXICO’S SECOND EMPIRE (1864-1867) By ELEANOR ANNE LAUGHLIN A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2014 © 2014 Eleanor Anne Laughlin To Elsa Violet, that she may pursue even those goals that seem impossible to achieve ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This dissertation would not have reached completion without the support of numerous organizations, mentors, scholars, and friends. The primary research I conducted in Mexico City, Brussels and Paris was made possible through the generous funding of the University of Florida’s Alumni Fellowship (2007-2011). The University of New Mexico’s Richard E. Greenleaf Research Fellowship (2011) granted me access to UNM’s photograph collections at the Center for Southwest Research in Albuquerque. I give special thanks to the University of Florida’s Latin American Studies Center for their support during the writing phase via the Doctoral Teaching Competitition Award (2012). I am deeply indebted to my dissertation advisors, Melissa Hyde and Maya Stanfield- Mazzi. The guidance and thoughtful constructive criticism they have offered over the years have imprinted this project, my work, and my life. I truly appreciate all of the energy they dedicated toward helping me become a more critical thinker and writer. I feel that I have become a better person in the process. They have been true mentors. Thanks also go to my dissertation committee members: Brigitte Weltman-Aron for her encouragement, support, and suggestions; and Glenn Willumson for his guidance in the areas of photographic history and at the Harn. I also owe a debt of gratitude to Ray Hernandez-Duran for his time and insights. The discussions I had with him while I was researching at the University of New Mexico were formative to my project. He readily shared his nuanced understanding of nineteenth-century visual culture in Mexico and offered suggestions enthusiastically. Catherine Zuromskis was also generous with her knowledge and her ideas during my tenure in Albuquerque. In Mexico City, I had the honor of meeting with Amparo Gómez Tepexicuapan who supported my understanding of Maximilian’s regime and was kind enough to grant me a high degree of access to his portraits and objects from the collection at the Museo Nacional de Historia at Chapultepec Castle. Alma 4 Montero welcomed me and my ideas to the Museo Nacional de Virreinato with an open mind and open arms. I thank Beatrice St. Laurent and Bill Fash for their inspiration that led me to this topic during my M.A. course work and field school in Copan, Honduras. I also want to thank Deborah Amberson, Im Sue Lee, Josefina de la Maza, Michelle Carlson, Amy Marcy, Mary Brown, Jenny and Matt Wolfe, Jane Anne Blakney-Bailey, Mandy Strasik, Pam Brekka, Carlee Forbes, Leslie Todd, Nicole Soukup, Anisa Perbtani, the Vincents, the Cohens, the Bells, and the Schmidts for their encouragement and companionship at this time in my life. During my stay in Mexico City, I benefitted from the assistance and kindness of many people. Numerous librarians at the Biblioteca Justino Fernandez within the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, the Biblioteca Nacional de Antropología e Historia, the Archivo Técnico de Consejo de Arqueología, and Mapoteca Manuel Orozco y Berra were fundamental to my daily work. Ana Luisa Madrigal Limón at the Archivo Histórico del Museo Nacional de Antropología was very dedicated to assisting me with my project. In Paris, the Service Historique de la Défense at the Chateau de Vincennes, the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Richlieu, and the Archives Nationales were helpful with access to their sources. I owe a debt of gratitude to Anne Godfroid at the Musée Royal de l’Armée et d’Histoire Militaire in Brussels for her enthusiasm and helpfulness. In the course of my travels many families welcomed me into their homes. I am grateful to the de Ravello family for their kindness, but I cannot express enough thanks to Lori de Ravello for her enthusiastic friendship and swift rescue after my hospitalization in Albuquerque. Katy and Gabriel Yapur offered me a safe haven from the chaos of Mexico City. Their smiles were constant and contagious and they were always available to lend a hand. Among the many interesting residents I met there, I am grateful to Leslie Bary for her adventurous spirit, her 5 infectious laughter, and the invitation to speak on my topic at the University of Louisiana. My talk and the events surrounding it were valuable experiences, which I hope have better prepared me for the job market. I owe a great deal of thanks to another resident, James Middleton, who took this harassed, blond woman by the hand and escorted me to parts of Mexico City where I would have otherwise been too intimidated to venture alone. Katy and Gabriel also introduced me to their daughter, Michele Yapur, who offered a much-needed retreat from the lonely city while I was working in France. In Paris my landlords Claude and Maryelle Raffetin kept me smiling with occasional dinners over which we discussed English grammar and papal politics. Finally, I want to thank my family. I am incredibly grateful for my mom and dad’s tag- team approach to my emotional and physical support throughout my life. In many ways their guidance, interests, and daily example have planted the seeds of this project over the course of our lives together. The cultural heritage that my step-father brought to our family has been a gift that enhanced my life. And I will be eternally grateful to Linda Laughlin for showing me by example that a woman could participate in an intellectual argument and still be considered a feminine and loving person. Most importantly, I want to thank Mike Volk for the support he has given me during this project. He knew before saying “I do” that he was not only gaining a partner, but also a doctoral student. However, I don’t think he counted on endless meals of pasta with Mollie the dog as his only companion while I was away researching, months of single- parenting on weekends so that I could write, or living with the distracted version of me when I am working on a deadline. For everything that he has sacrificed, I thank him deeply. This goal simply would not have come to fruition without him. I thank him not only for encouraging me to pursue my dreams, but for standing by his word when challenges arose and especially for his steady, calming presence by my side. I hope he has had some fun along the way. 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...............................................................................................................4 LIST OF FIGURES .........................................................................................................................9 ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................15 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................17 Previous Research ...................................................................................................................20 The French Intervention (1861-67) ........................................................................................22 The Second Mexican Empire (1864-67) .................................................................................27 The Carte-de-visite and the Second Mexican Empire (1860s) ...............................................36 Chapters ..................................................................................................................................39 2 BETWEEN TECHNOLOGY AND TRADITION: THE ROLES OF PHOTOGRAPHY AND PUBLIC CEREMONY IN THE CONTRUCTION OF THE EMPEROR’S IMAGE ...................................................................................................................................45 Early Photography in Mexico .................................................................................................55 Marvelous Possessions for the Masses: The Carte-de-Visite .................................................61 Portraits of Maximilian prior to the Mexican Empire ............................................................72 Maximilian Meets the Mexicans ............................................................................................77 Representations of Sovereignty during the Spanish Colonial Period .....................................82 From Miramar to Mexico: Maximilian and Public Ceremony ...............................................90 The Painted State Portrait, Realized .......................................................................................98 Summary: A regime of contradictions ..................................................................................100 3 THE EMPEROR’S NEW CLOTHES ..................................................................................110 “Maximiliano (charro)” in the Making .................................................................................116 Maximilian and Mexican Costume .......................................................................................119 The Political Landscape ........................................................................................................124 Maximilian Among his