A Dissertation Entitled Addressing Challenges with Big Data For

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Dissertation Entitled Addressing Challenges with Big Data For A Dissertation entitled Addressing Challenges with Big Data for Maritime Navigation: AIS Data within the Great Lakes System by Samir K. Dhar Submitted to the Graduate Faculty as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Doctor of Philosophy Degree in Spatially Integrated Social Science ________________________________________ Dr. Peter S. Lindquist, Committee Chair ________________________________________ Dr. Kevin P. Czajkowski, Committee Member ________________________________________ Dr. Neil Reid, Committee Member ________________________________________ Dr. Mark A. Vonderembse, Committee Member ________________________________________ Dr. Richard D. Stewart, Committee Member ________________________________________ Dr. Amanda Bryant-Friedrich, Dean College of Graduate Studies The University of Toledo December 2016 Copyright 2016, Samir K. Dhar This document is copyrighted material. Under copyright law, no parts of this document may be reproduced without the expressed permission of the author. An Abstract of Addressing Challenges with Big Data for Maritime Navigation: AIS Data within the Great Lakes System by Samir K. Dhar Submitted to the Graduate Faculty as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Doctor of Philosophy Degree in Spatially Integrated Social Science The University of Toledo Expected May 2016 The study presented here deals with commercial vessel tracking in the Great Lakes using the Automatic Identification System (AIS). Specific objectives within this study include development of methods for data acquisition, data reduction, storage and management, and reporting of vessel activity within the Great Lakes using AIS. These data show considerable promise in tracking commodity flows through the system as well as documenting traffic volumes at key locations requiring infrastructure investment (particularly dredging). Other applications include detecting vessel calls at specific terminals, locks and other navigation points of interest. This study will document the techniques developed to acquire, reduce, aggregate and store AIS data at The University of Toledo. Specific topics of the paper include: data reducing techniques to reduce data volumes, vessel path tracking, estimate speed on waterway network, detection of vessel calls made at a dock, and a data analysis and mining for errors within AIS data. The study also revealed the importance of AIS technology in maritime safety, but the data is coupled with errors and inaccuracy. These errors within the AIS data will have to be addressed and rectified in future to make the data accurate and useful. The data reduction algorithm shows a 98% reduction in AIS data making it more manageable. In future similar data reduction techniques can possibly be used with traffic GPS data collected for highways and railways. I dedicate this dissertation to my best friend and wife Madhavi Dhar whose sacrificial care made it possible for me to complete it successfully. I would also like to remember my parents, as they would always say education is a kind of treasure that no one can take it away from you ever. Acknowledgements First, I would like to acknowledge my professor and committee chair, Dr. Peter S. Lindquist, for giving me the opportunity to work on projects that eventually led to this dissertation. I would also like to thank Dr. Richard Stewart (aka Captain Stewart) and Dr. Mark Vonderembse for their insight into the maritime transportation industry. I would like to thank my committee members, Dr. Kevin P. Czajkowski, Dr. Neil Reid, for their valuable input and guidance towards my dissertation. Besides all the people on screen, there are few people behind the screen that were very instrumental and helpful in collecting first-hand information and providing resources related to my dissertation. I would like to acknowledge Douglas McDonald (MARAD), Brian J. Tetreault (USACE), Kenneth Ned Mitchell, PhD (USACE), David Winkler, Krithica Kantharaj, and all the others from different government agencies whom I had the pleasure of meeting them during conferences and meetings. Finally, I would like to thank late Dr. Udayan Nandkeolyar, who was one of the original committee member. I like to thanks him for his wisdom and encouragement that he gave me every time with a smile on his face. vi Table of Contents Abstract .............................................................................................................................. iv Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................ vi Table of Contents .............................................................................................................. vii List of Tables ......................................................................................................................x List of Figures .................................................................................................................... xi List of Graphs .................................................................................................................. xiii 1 Introduction ..........................................................................................................1 1.1 Problem Statement .............................................................................................3 1.2 Objectives ..........................................................................................................4 2 GLNS & Vessel Traffic Service ..............................................................................6 2.1 Background and Context....................................................................................6 2.1.1 Great Lakes Economy .......................................................................10 2.2 Vessel Traffic Service ......................................................................................13 2.2.1 VTS History ......................................................................................14 2.2.2 Automatic Radar Plotting Aids .........................................................16 2.3 Automatic Identification System (AIS) ...........................................................17 3 AIS Technology .....................................................................................................18 3.1 AIS Regulations ...............................................................................................19 3.2 AIS Equipment Setup ......................................................................................20 3.3 Technical Model of AIS...................................................................................23 3.4 AIS Message ....................................................................................................27 3.5 AIS Working Concept......................................................................................32 vii 3.6 Long Range Identification System ...................................................................37 3.7 Satellite AIS .....................................................................................................40 3.8 e-Navigation .....................................................................................................46 3.9 Application(s) of AIS .......................................................................................49 4 AIS Data Analysis and Mining ..............................................................................55 4.1 Study Area .......................................................................................................56 4.2 AIS Data Acquisition .......................................................................................57 4.3 AIS Data and Data Analysis ............................................................................60 4.4 Geo-Visualization of AIS Data ........................................................................64 4.5 AIS Data-Mining for Errors .............................................................................65 5 AIS Data Reduction ...............................................................................................70 5.1 AIS Data Reduction Technique .......................................................................70 5.2 AIS Distill Pseudo Code ..................................................................................72 5.3 Results .................................................................................................…...75 6 Application of Distilled AIS Data..........................................................................80 6.1 AIS Application – Calculate Vessel Calls .......................................................80 6.1.1 Pseudo Code – Vessel Call ...............................................................82 6.2 AIS Application – Tracking Vessel Path .........................................................83 6.3 AIS Application – Estimating Speed on Waterway Network ..........................87 7 Conclusion and Discussions ..................................................................................91 References ..........................................................................................................................97 A AIS Message Tables ............................................................................................101 A.1 Navigation Status ..........................................................................................101 viii A.2 Rate of Turn (ROT).......................................................................................102
Recommended publications
  • Winter 2015 Bearfacts
    ALGOMA CENTRAL CORPORATION NEWSLETTER ● WINTER 2015 President’s Message Company Announcements Seaway Max self-unloading bulk freighters became effective. These As part of the strategic planning contracts replace three of the review, the difficult decision was contracts with a Chinese shipyard made to sell the Real Estate that were cancelled earlier this year. portfolio. At this time I wish to thank our employees at Algoma Central On November 30th Algoma Properties for their hard work and announced we have contracts in dedication to the Corporation and place to build two 740 foot Seaway wish them every success wherever Max self-unloading bulk freighters to their future may take them. join the Company's Great Lakes – St. Lawrence Waterway dry-bulk One of the reasons for divesting the fleet. These new Equinox Class real estate portfolio was to focus the ships will be built by Jiangsu Corporation on its core Marine Yangzijiang Shipbuilding Co. Ltd. businesses. and will feature a standard rear boom. It has been nine months since I took To that end, in recent months the helm at ACC and what an Algoma has made a series of Equinox Class Deliveries experience it has been! announcements with respect to investments in the marine business The new orders bring the total of My arrival in Canada coincided with both domestically and Equinox Class vessels under the opening of the Welland Canal and internationally. construction to seven. In total, the end of a very long and Algoma expects to invest challenging winter for the domestic On November 10th we announced approximately $450 million in this vessels that continued to operate that our wholly owned subsidiary, phase of its fleet renewal program.
    [Show full text]
  • SLSMC 1999 Annual Report
    TABLE of CONTENTS 2 40 Years of Service 2 The Beginnings 2 Highlights 3 Statistical Comparisons 4 President’s Message and Performance Review 5 The Commercialization Mandate 6 State of the Organization at Handover 9 Financial Matters 11 The Financial Year in Review 14 Management’s Report 15 Auditor’s Report 16 Consolidated Financial Statements 19 Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 26 Management Executive Officers Offices Governance The St. Lawrence Seaway Authority: 40 YEARS OF SERVICE THE BEGINNINGS… THE ST. LAWRENCE SEAWAY – SOME HIGHLIGHTS 1951 1959 he St. Lawrence Seaway Authority Act T and the International Rapids Power On April 25, the icebreaker “D’Iberville” Development Act allow Canadians to begin begins the first through transit of the St. navigation works on the Canadian side of Lawrence Seaway, officially opened by the river from Montreal to Lake Ontario, as Queen Elizabeth and President Eisenhower well as in the Welland Canal. At the same on June 26. time, a joint U.S. Canadian project begins power works in the International Rapids 1973 section of the St. Lawrence. The U.S. also The Welland Canal realignment to bypass begins work on the Wiley-Dondero Canal the City of Welland opens to navigation. that will bypass the International Rapids. Co-operation and consultation on the ele- 1978 ments of the modern Seaway commences. Seaway operations become self-supporting, 1954 depending on revenue from tolls and invest- ments. The federal government still con- The St. Lawrence Seaway Authority is tributes to major capital works. established by an Act of Parliament, with the mandate to acquire lands for, construct, 1983 operate and maintain a deep draft waterway The Seaway carries its billionth tonne of between the port of Montreal and Lake cargo.
    [Show full text]
  • Great Lakes Maritime Institute
    JANUARY - FEBRUARY, 1978 Volume XXVII; Number 1 GREAT LAKES MARITIME INSTITUTE DOSSIN GREAT LAKES MUSEUM Belle Isle, Detroit, Michigan 48207 JAN/FEB, 1978 Page 2 MEMBERSHIP NOTES Welcome to 1978! A brand new year, a brand new slate, and a brand new outlook. It is going to be difficult to keep up with the pace set in 1977, but the continued success of the Institute demands that we not just meet, but surpass last year. At the close of the year our member­ ship had grown to approaching 1,50C. pretty good for an organization that had 97 members in 1959...but this year we’ll shoot for 1,600. It’ll take a lot of work, and you’ll have to help, but you always have, so we should make it. Telescope production last year produced a total of 244 pages, and in addition to that we produced the FITZGERALD book with 60 pages. For the uninitiated, this means your Editor typed, then Varityped 608 pages. This much production takes a lot of time, but we are going to do something about it, and we’ll have an announcement to make perhaps as early as the next issue. Not only will what we have planned result in far less work to getting Telescope out, but it will produce a far better product. Yes, 1977 was a good year...but 1978 looks better. MEETING NOTICES Regular membership meetings are scheduled for January 27, March 31, and May 19 (early to avoid Memorial Day weekend). All meetings will be at the Dossin Museum at 8:00 PM.
    [Show full text]
  • Your Cruise Great Lakes of North America
    Great Lakes of North America From 9/25/2022 From Milwaukee Ship: LE BELLOT to 10/2/2022 to Toronto Set sail with PONANT aboard Le Bellot for an 8-day cruise discovering the Great Lakes of North America, in the heart of a flamboyant nature full of the colours of the Indian summer. You will leave from Milwaukee, in the US state of Wisconsin, the beginning of your voyage following the footsteps of the first settlers, trappers and Native Americans, before a lovely sailing experience on Lake Michigan, a veritable inland sea. The next lake, Lake Huron, boasts a myriad of islands in its northern part, with white rocks capped with conifers plunging into the sapphire waters of the lake. Sumptuous landscapes unveil multiple original panoramas, in particular near Flowerpot Island*, which you will be able to approach by Zodiac®. You will also discover the charming city of Parry Sound, in the heart of the wonderful UNESCO Biosphere Reserve of Georgian Bay. Le Bellot will then sail the canal connecting Lake Erie to Lake Ontario. From this call in Port Colborne, you will be able to see the impressive sight of Niagara Falls. These three powerful waterfalls, renowned the world over, are an exquisite natural spectacle. To round off your cruise, you will sail along the shimmering waters of Lake Ontario before making your way to the cosmopolitan city of Toronto, where you will disembark. * Zodiac® cruise weather dependant. The information in this document is valid as of 10/1/2021 Great Lakes of North America YOUR STOPOVERS : MILWAUKEE Embarkation 9/25/2022 from 4:00 PM to 5:00 PM Departure 9/25/2022 at 6:00 PM Nested on the shores of Lake Michigan,Milwaukee , the largest city in the State of Wisconsin, harmoniously combines tradition and modernity.
    [Show full text]
  • Port Arthur Shipyards Finding
    PORT ARTHUR SHIPBUILDING FONDS RECORDS GROUP 5 Please Read these two paragraphs first. This text file was originally produced as a hard copy finding aid produced some years ago for the museum staff and those making use of the Audrey Rushbrook Memorial Library and Archives. It is a long text file and was intended for on-site researchers. Many browsers have a 'find in page' feature in their browser that will permit you to search for words and phrases. Staff and others who are very familiar with this collection find the text file useful. You are of course welcome to use this text file but there is a more efficient way to search for information about specific items in the collection by using the Search the Collection tab. Specific items in the collections are given an inventory control number called an Accession Number usually in three parts, for example - 1993.0011.0001. (meaning the first item in the eleventh collections to be accessioned in 1993). Retain these numbers should you intend to visit the archives and use the material. Additional material has been added to the collection since this finding aid was produced. The most up to date information can be found online at our search engine link - archives and pictorial. Always schedule an appointment in advance should you intend to use the library/archive resources. This fonds consists of the corporate records and engineering drawings of the Port Arthur Shipbuilding Company [PASCOL], a division of Canadian Shipbuilding and Engineering. The material ranges in date from the establishment of the shipyard in 1910 to 1986 inclusive, with the bulk of the documents belonging to the early years with a gap to more modern records of the 1980's.
    [Show full text]
  • Spring 2010 Bearfacts
    ALGOMA CENTRAL CORPORATION NEWSLETTER ● SPRING 2010 President’s Message In February 2010, we acquired A very significant and important ownership of the Algoma Dartmouth. event we hope to see come to This vessel has been operated by fruition in 2010 will be the Algoma Tankers under a long-term announcement by the Federal bareboat charter arrangement since Government that they have followed 2009 providing fuel delivery and through with their proposal to waive vessel bunkering service within the the payment of the 25% import duty Halifax Harbour. on the importation of vessels built outside of Canada. Although we are In January 2010, our hotel in Sault well past the proposed January 1, Ste. Marie re-opened as the “Delta 2010 effective date, we continue to Sault Ste. Marie Waterfront Hotel be confident that this positive and Conference Centre”. The government initiative, to eliminate The Corporation‟s 2009 Annual renovation project was a terrific what is effectively a discriminatory Meeting of Shareholders‟ was held in success and we now own the only tax on marine transportation, will St. Catharines on April 30, 2010. At upscale, four star hotel in Sault Ste. result in the appropriate action in the the meeting, I indicated our 2009 Marie. near future. results were disappointing but went on to say that compared to many, The Algobay, the first new addition to The removal of this 25% import duty, our results were not so bad. Once our domestic dry-bulk fleet in many together with the finalization of our again, the benefit of having four years, arrived in Canada to innovative new vessel design and diversified business units was commence its first voyage on specification for both a self-unloader highlighted throughout 2009.
    [Show full text]
  • La Voie Maritime Du Saint-Laurent Cinquante Ans Et L’Avenir À Nos Portes
    d’arcy jenish la voie maritime du saint-laurent Cinquante ans et l’avenir à nos portes Traduit de l’anglais par michel gaulin © 2009 corporation de gestion de la voie maritime du saint-laurent Aucun extrait de cette publication ne peut être Catalogage avant publication reproduit, sauvegardé dans un système de de Bibliothèque et Archives Canada recherche documentaire ou transmis par quelque procédé que ce soit sans le consentement jenish, d’arcy, 1952– préalable écrit de l’éditeur ou l’obtention d’une La Voie maritime du Saint-Laurent: cinquante licence de The Canadian Copyright Licensing ans et l'avenir à nos portes/D'Arcy Jenish; Agency (Access Copyright). traduction de Michel Gaulin. Traduction de: The St. Lawrence Seaway. penumbra press, éditeurs Comprend un index. Bo x 940 | Manotick, on | Canada isbn 97 8-1-897323-85-4 k4m 1a8 | www.penumbrapress.ca 1. Voie maritime du Saint-Laurent—Histoire. i. Gaulin, Michel ii. Titre. fc2763.2.j46 2009 386.5’09714 C2009-900896-3 La Voie maritime du Saint-Laurent | Table des matières Avant-propos, R ichard Corfe 9 1 La Voie maritime aujourd’hui 13 2 Promesse tenue, 1959–1969 29 3 Croissance et optimisme, 1969–1979 45 4 Des années difficiles, 1980–1992 62 5 Un nouveau départ, 1992–2002 79 6 La Voie maritime: l’avenir 98 Index 113 La Voie maritime du Saint-Laurent | Avant-propos J’étais bien loin de penser, quand je me suis joint à l’Administration de la voie maritime du Saint- Laurent, en 1983, que j’occuperais la présidence de l’organisme au moment où il célébrerait son cinquantième anniversaire! Quand j’ai été embauché, la Voie maritime amorçait un changement de direction.
    [Show full text]
  • Great Lakes St. Lawrence Seaway Study
    GREAT LAKES ST. LAWRENCE SEAWAY STUDY Final Report Fall 2007 GREAT LAKES ST. LAWRENCE SEAWAY STUDY By: Transport Canada U.S. Army Corps of Engineers U.S. Department of Transportation The St. Lawrence Seaway Management Corporation Saint Lawrence Seaway Development Corporation Environment Canada U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Publication This publication is also available in French under the title: Étude des Grands Lacs et de la Voie maritime du Saint-Laurent. Rapport final, automne 2007. Permission is granted by the Department of Transport, Canada, and the U.S. Department of Transportation, to copy and/or reproduce the contents of this publication in whole or in part provided that full acknowledgement is given to the Department of Transport, Canada, and the U.S. Department of Transportation, and that the material be accurately reproduced. While the use of this material has been authorized, the Department of Transport, Canada, and the U.S. Department of Transportation, shall not be responsible for the manner in which the information is presented, nor for any interpretation thereof. The information in this publication is to be considered solely as a guide and should not be quoted as or considered to be a legal authority. It may become obsolete in whole or in part at any time without notice. Publication design and layout by ACR Communications Inc. ii Great Lakes St. Lawrence Seaway Study FOREWORD AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are pleased to present the binational report on the Great Lakes St. Lawrence Seaway Study, the result of collaborative research and analysis by seven federal departments and agencies from Canada and the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • The Chicago Water Diversion Controversy, III, 31 Marq
    Marquette Law Review Volume 31 Article 3 Issue 1 May 1947 The hicC ago Water Diversion Controversy, III Herbert H. Naujoks Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.marquette.edu/mulr Part of the Law Commons Repository Citation Herbert H. Naujoks, The Chicago Water Diversion Controversy, III, 31 Marq. L. Rev. 28 (1947). Available at: http://scholarship.law.marquette.edu/mulr/vol31/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Marquette Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Marquette Law Review by an authorized administrator of Marquette Law Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE CHICAGO WATER DIVERSION CONTROVERSY* HERBERT H. NAUJOKS PART THREE: WHAT OF THE FUTURE? (a) In General In Parts One and Two of this article the writer discussed the history and background of the Chicago Water Diversion Controversy, the decisions rendered by the United States Supreme Court, the various rulings of the Governmental officials and Departments, the efforts made in Congress and in the Supreme Court to authorize a large diversion, the present status of the problem, and finally the legal questions that were or still are involved. Almost a half century of litigation and dispute has failed to settle permanently this im- portant problem, and the question arises, "What of the future ?". How can this perennial problem be settled once and for all? To attempt to answer this, one must consider not only the rulings of the Court but also the physical and engineering details of the sewage disposal and water supply problems of metropolitan Chicago.
    [Show full text]
  • Print Cruise Information
    A Voyage along the Great Lakes – with Smithsonian Journeys From 9/18/2022 From Toronto Ship: LE BELLOT to 9/25/2022 to Milwaukee In alliance with Smithsonian Journeys. This cruise is part of a collection of PONANT voyages that are specially-tailored for English-speaking travelers who want to engage with the world. In addition to the usual elements of the PONANT experience, the listed price for these voyages includes transfers to and from the ship, talks and discussions aboard ship by world class experts, and a shore excursion or activity in each port of call that encourages guests to embrace the sights, sounds, tastes, and smells of the local environment and culture. Set sail with PONANT aboard Le Bellot for an 8-day cruise to discover the Great Lakes amidst the splendid colours of early autumn. You will leave from cosmopolitan and dynamicToronto, Ontario, on the shore of Lake Ontario. Canada’s largest city will charm you with its museums, parks, and gardens. Shore excursion in each port of call + transfers Le Bellot will then sail the canal connecting Lake Ontario andLake Erie. included From your call in Port Colborne, you will be able to see the impressive Niagara Falls. These three powerful waterfalls, renowned the world over, are an exquisite natural spectacle. Your next lake, Lake Huron, boasts myriad islands in its northern part, with white rocks capped with conifers plunging into the sapphire waters of the lake. Here you will discover the charming city of Parry Sound, in the heart of the fantastic UNESCO Biosphere Reserve of Georgian Bay, and the quaint town of Little Current, gateway to Manitoulin Island, the world’s largest freshwater island.
    [Show full text]
  • Document (PDF)
    JULY ☆ AUGUST, 1982 Volume XXXI; Number 4 * GREAT LAKES MARITIME INSTITUTE DOSSIN GREAT LAKES MUSEUM Belle Isle, Detroit, Michigan 48207 TELESCOPE Page 86 MEMBERSHIP NOTES • The St. Lawrence Seaway Exhibit will open on August 4th. All Institute members in the Detroit area will receive an invitation to attend the special reception being held that night at the Museum. At this time, we sire planning to have a guest speaker from the St. Lawrence Seaway Authority. The Marine Flea Market will be held on August 14th at the Museum. Those interested in renting a table should send a self-addressed envelope to the Museum for details. MEETING NOTICES • The Robert E. Lee Annual Dinner will be held on September 14th at the Detroit Boat Club. At this time, we haven’t confirmed a guest speaker for the dinner. Those living within the Detroit area (480 , 481___, 482____ , Canada: Sarnia to Amherstburg) will receive details for the dinner in mid-August. Those living outside this area, should send a self-addressed envelope to the Institute for details. The business and entertainment meetings tire scheduled for the 3rd Friday of each month. Business meetings are scheduled for August 20 and October 15. The November entertainment meeting will be held on the 19th. All meetings are at 8 p.m. at the Museum. CONTENTS • Membership notes, meeting dates, etc. 86 The Henry Ford II Opens 1982 Season by James Clarkson 87 British Naval Vessels on the Upper Lakes 1761-1796 by Brian Dunnigan 92 St. Lawrence Seaway Exhibit to Open by John Polacsek 99 Great Lakes & Seaway News Edited by Frederic Weber 102 Published at Detroit, Michigan by the GREAT LAKES MARITIME INSTITUTE ©All rights reserved.
    [Show full text]
  • Sept-Îles Sept-Îles
    MaritiMe Magazine 59 • SEPT-ÎLES Awakening of a giant / Le réveil d’un géant • St. Lawrence Shipoperators – 75 ans/years – Armateurs du Saint-Laurent No Port payé à Québec. Envoi de poste-publications - Convention no 40046923 - Adresse de retour: 175, rue Saint-Paul, Québec (Québec) Canada G1K 3W2 60 Maritime Magazine60 8,95 $ Awakening of a Giant SEPT-ÎLES Le réveil d’un géant 75 years/ans www.maritimemag.com St. Lawrence Shipoperators Armateurs du Saint-Laurent 1 CARGO HANDLING ETIQUETTE LESSON NO. 64 We always do. In fact, the experienced crews aboard our versatile fl eet of bulkers and self-unloaders are schooled in the good graces MAKE SURE TO of visiting. They make sure their ships arrive on time and don’t overstay their welcome. Host customers always want them back. RSVP Canada Steamship Lines, the fl eet with good cargo handling manners — have us over today! Canada Steamship Lines 759 Square Victoria, Montreal (Qc) Canada H2Y 2K3 Tel: 514.982.3800 • Fax: 514.982.3910 [email protected] A DIVISION OF CSL GROUP INC. www.cslcan.ca printemps 2011 • spring 2011 60 SUMMARY Éditeur / Publisher: SOMMAIRE Pierre Terrien [email protected] Rédacteur en chef / Editor: Leo Ryan [email protected] CHRONIQUES / COLUMNS Collaborateurs / Contributing editors: Alison Bates, Bill Beck, Paul Beesley, Terence F. Bowles Michael Broad, Stephen J. Brooks, FORUM Stephen Brown, Raymond Johnston, Andrew Livingstone, 4 Michel Desjardins Carroll McCormick, Pierre Métivier, Leo Quigley, Wylie Spicer, Allan Swift, Nicole Trépanier FIRST WATCH Traducteurs
    [Show full text]