'Ambulant Amateurs': the Rise and Fade of the Anglo-German Fellowship
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
‘Ambulant amateurs’: the rise and fade of the Anglo-German Fellowship Charles Spicer Institute of Historical Research School of Advanced Study University of London Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2018 1 I hereby declare that the work presented in this thesis is entirely my own. ………………………………………….. Date …………….. 2 Abstract This thesis chronicles the fortunes of the Anglo-German Fellowship, the British society founded in 1935 that advocated friendship with Hitler’s Germany up to its suspension in October 1939 following the outbreak of war. Drawing on newly discovered and previously overlooked primary sources, thematic and chronological methods are combined to explore how the Fellowship’s leaders played a bigger role in the diplomatic crises of the late 1930s than previously acknowledged. Supported by its sister organisation in Germany, the Fellowship attracted support from British royal, political, diplomatic, aristocratic, business, financial, military, sporting and intelligence elites with its membership reaching nine hundred by 1938. Funded by business and financial interests and patronised by Anglo-German royalty, it was influenced by the German high command, welcomed by elements of the British establishment and infiltrated by British, German, Russian and Jewish intelligence agents. To the extent it has been covered in the secondary literature, those assessing the Fellowship have classed it alongside the nasty, the eccentric and the irrelevant within ‘the Fellow Travellers of the Right’ tradition. This thesis challenges those stereotypes, arguing that it has been consequently misinterpreted and underestimated both by scholars and in popular culture over the last eighty years. Using primary sources to build an objective prosopography of its membership, evidence is offered that the Fellowship was more than a fringe pressure group and dining club and achieved international credibility as a lobbying body, diplomatic intermediary and intelligence- gathering tool. Having surveyed the heritage of earlier transnational friendship societies, this thesis examines the business and economic motives, on both sides of the North Sea, in founding the Fellowship, before charting how it then recruited support from across the political spectrum. Arranging landmark meetings between British politicians and the National Socialist leadership, it proved itself as a conduit for diplomatic dialogue with Germany. The central chapters probe the prosopography to highlight the Fellowship’s penetration of the British Establishment before lifting the lid of respectability to 3 measure the extent to which it harboured pro-fascist and anti-Semitic enthusiasts for Hitler’s Germany. As the narrative moves into the final three years before war, two chapters explore how the Fellowship accessed the central political and diplomatic bodies in both countries including Downing Street, the houses of parliament, British political parties, Hitler’s Chancellery, the NSDAP, both foreign ministries and their embassies while simultaneously establishing dialogue with those opposing Hitler’s regime and challenging the wisdom of appeasement. Finally, the organisation’s legacy is examined to ask whether, by developing a different flavour of appeasement to Chamberlain’s, it offered a real alternative to war and whether this contributes to the continuing discourse surrounding inter-war appeasement. 4 ‘Ambulant amateurs’: the rise and fade of the Anglo-German Fellowship CONTENTS Page Abstract 3 List of abbreviations 6 Introduction The genesis and historiography of the Anglo-German Fellowship 7 Chapter 1 Gold, rubber and margarine: business, finance and the Fellowship 41 Chapter 2 Facing the politicians: the Fellowship, politics and diplomacy 70 Chapter 3 Coffee with Hitler: the years of optimism 96 Chapter 4 For King and Country: the Fellowship and the Establishment 119 Chapter 5 Sharks in the shallows: the Fellowship, anti-Semitism and the far right 148 Chapter 6 The ‘brink of peace’: from Coronation to Munich 174 Chapter 7 Fading into war: the failure of appeasement 210 Conclusion War and legacy 239 Appendices: I. Dramatis personae 263 II. The Anglo-German Fellowship: 1937 membership list 274 III. The Deutsch-Englische Gesellschaft: founding membership list 284 Bibliography 287 5 List of abbreviations ACC Archive of The Board of Deputies of British Jews, London Metropolitan Archives AGA Anglo-German Association AGF Anglo-German Fellowship BL The British Library, London BR Papers of Wilfred Ashley, 1st Baron Mount Temple, Broadlands archives, Hartley Library, University of Southampton CAB Records of the Cabinet Office, TNA CHAR Papers of Sir Winston Churchill, Churchill College, Cambridge CHRS Papers of Group Captain Malcolm Grahame Christie, Churchill College, Cambridge CONWELL Papers of TP Conwell-Evans, Sir Martin Gilbert papers DAV Papers of JCC Davidson MP, UK Parliamentary Archives DBFP Documents on British Foreign Policy DEG Deutsch-Englische Gesellschaft DGFP Documents on German Foreign Policy FO Records of the Foreign Office, TNA GILB Papers of Sir Martin Gilbert, Lady Gilbert private collection HALIFAX Papers of Edward Wood, 1st Earl of Halifax, University of York HAMILTON/KCL Papers of General Sir Ian Hamilton, King’s College London HAMILTON/NRS Papers of the 14th Duke of Hamilton, National Records of Scotland INKP Papers of Thomas Inskip, 1st Viscount Caldecote, Churchill College Archives, Cambridge KERR/NRS Papers of Philip Kerr, 11th Marquess of Lothian, National Records of Scotland KV Records of the Security Service, TNA LASP Lascelles Papers, TNA LG Papers of David Lloyd George, 1st Earl Lloyd-George of Dwyfor, UK Parliamentary Archives NSDAP Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (National Socialist German Workers’ Party) NSB None So Blind: A Study of the Crisis Years, 1930-1939 by TP Conwell-Evans (1947) ODNB Oxford Dictionary of National Biography PIRI Papers of George Pitt-Rivers, Churchill College, Cambridge PREM1 Prime Minister’s Office records, TNA SCHROD Schroder Archive, Schroders plc, London TA True Account, by EWD Tennant (1957) TNA The National Archives, Kew, Richmond, Surrey, UK VNST Papers of Robert, 1st Viscount Vansittart, Churchill College, Cambridge Place of publication for secondary sources is London, unless stated otherwise 6 Introduction The genesis and historiography of the Anglo-German Fellowship In July 1939, with war looming, Ernest Tennant, the founder and honorary secretary of the Anglo-German Fellowship, undertook an unorthodox, secret mission to meet his sometime friend and colleague Joachim Ribbentrop in the recently-unified Greater Germany. Although Tennant travelled in his customary guise as a City merchant with business interests in the country, his trip was informally sanctioned by Downing Street and blessed by the prime minister, Neville Chamberlain. Ribbentrop, the former champagne salesman and distributer for Johnnie Walker whisky, was now (following a brief stint as ambassador to the Court of St James’s) Reich minister for foreign affairs. With Chamberlain’s dogged attempts at appeasement evidently failing and war only weeks away, the story of Tennant’s lone mission seems straight from a novel rather than the serious world of diplomacy. His hope was to ‘get Ribbentrop away from his present feeling of hostility to Britain and back nearer to his state of mind of seeking friendship with this country which existed until the beginning of 1937’.1 Given the intensity of the international diplomatic crisis that summer, with Ribbentrop immersed in negotiations with the Russians, it is significant that he immediately agreed to see Tennant at a time of his choosing and offered to arrange his accommodation in Salzburg. Tennant had suggested that, as ‘visiting the Foreign Minister in his magnificence in the Wilhelmstrasse is rather alarming for a private individual’, a quiet dinner might be best, so they could have ‘a real talk as we used to in the old days’.2 These two friends had conceived the Anglo-German Fellowship, and its sister society, the Deutsch-Englische Gesellschaft (hereafter, DEG), five years previously, ‘to promote good understanding between England and Germany and thus contribute to the maintenance of peace and the development of prosperity’. Wholly distinct organisationally, membership of the British Fellowship was only open to British nationals, while German Anglophiles could join the German organisation. The DEG had ‘fine premises’ in the shape of a mansion on 30 Bendlerstrasse in Berlin (‘a quiet 1 Tennant to Chamberlain, 4 July,1939, PREM 1/335 C497340, TNA. 2 Tennant to Ribbentrop, 10 July,1939, PREM 1/335 C497340, TNA. 7 street where the American Embassy and the homes of several ministers are situated’3) and branches in other German cities including Bremen, Hamburg, Heidelberg, Essen, Stuttgart and Wiesbaden which displayed portraits of the British king and welcomed English visitors.4 The Fellowship meanwhile was headquartered rather more modestly in a flat at 223 Cranmer Court in Chelsea, albeit its banquets were hosted at prominent London hotels including Grosvenor House, Claridge’s and the Dorchester. By December 1938, the Fellowship’s individual membership had reached exactly nine hundred and included luminaries from each of the British ‘Establishment’ elites – royal, political, diplomatic, aristocratic, business, financial, military, sporting and intelligence.5 This study seeks to explore how the Fellowship achieved such rapid success and whether it is fair to regard it as