Winter 2019/2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Second Thoughts and Short Reviews: Winter 2018/19_2 By Brian Wilson and Dan Morgan Reviews are by Brian Wilson unless signed [DM] Winter/1 is here and Autumn 2018/3 is here. Index: ADAMS Doctor Atomic Symphony, Harmonielehre_RSNO/Peter Oundjian (Chandos) BACH (JS and CPE) Sonatas_ Paradiso Musicale (with TELEMANN) (BIS) BERLIOZ Collected recordings_Warner - Berlioz Odyssey_LSO/Colin Davis (LSO Live) - Te Deum_Staatskapelle Dresden/Colin Davis (Profil) (with MOZART Kyrie in D) CARDOSO Lamentations, Requiem, etc._ Cupertinos/Luís Toscano_Hyperion - Lamentations, etc_Westminster Cathedral Choir/James O’Donnell (with REBELO, DE CRISTO: Masterpieces of Portuguese Polyphony)_Hyperion Helios - Lamentations (excerpts) – see Amaræ Morti - Missa miserere, Magnificat_ Ensemble Vocal Européen/Philippe Herreweghe_Harmonia Mundi - Magnificats, Missa secundi toni, Motets_Girton College Choir/Gareth Wilson_Toccata - Sacred Music_The Sixteen/Harry Christophers_Coro (with LOBO) FÉVIN Masses_Brabant Ensemble/Rice_Hyperion GLASS String Quartets_Smith Quartet_Signum GOSS Theorbo Concerto_ Matthew Wadsworth (theorbo); Scottish CO/Benjamin Marquise Gilmore (Deux-Elles) KRESS, TELEMANN Violin Concertos from Darmstadt_ Darmstädtler Barocksolisten/Johannes Pramsohler (Audax) LISZT Piano Sonata_Sophie Pacini_C-Avi (with SCHUMANN Carnaval) - Piano Sonata; Hungarian Rhapsody No.6_Martha Argerich (with CHOPIN, BRAHMS, PROKOFIEV, RAVEL – Debut recital) LÔBO, Duarte Sacred Music_The Sixteen/Harry Christophers_Coro (with CARDOSO) LOBO, Alonoso Sacred Music_Coro Victoria/Ana Fernandez-Vega (Brilliant Classics) MESSIAEN Oiseaux exotiques, etc._Loriod/Neumann_Supraphon (see emusic.com). - Turangalîla_Loriod_INA (see emusic.com). - Livre d’orgue_Winpenny_Naxos; Thiry_La Dolce Volta; Ericsson_BIS MOZART String Quintets_Klenke Quartet_Accentus; Talich Quartet_La Dolce Volta NEPOMUCENO Symphony in G, etc._ Minas Gerais Philharmonic Orchestra/Fabio Mechetti (Naxos) PHINOT Oratio Jeremiæ – see Amaræ morti REBELO Sacred Music_Westminster Cathedral Choir/James O’Donnell (with Masterpieces of Portuguese Polyphony) (Hyperion Helios) - Sacred Music_The Sixteen/Harry Christophers (with MELGÁS) (Coro) REICH Different Trains, etc_Smith Quartet (Signum) SAINT-GEORGES (Chevalier de) Symphony, etc_LSO/Paul Freeman (Sony) SCHREKER Orchestral Works_Deutsche Staatsphilharmonie Rheinland-Pfalz/Christopher Ward (Capriccio) SCHUBERT Die schöne Müllerin_Mark Padmore/Paul Lewis (Harmonia Mundi) - and some alternative suggestions. SCHUMANN Carnaval_Sophie Pacini_C-Avi (with LISZT Sonata) STENHAMMAR Symphony No.2; Serenade in F_Gothenburg SO/Herbert Blomstedt (BIS) TELEMANN The Virtuoso Godfather_ Charivari Agréable/Kah-Ming Ng (with music by his contemporaries) (Signum) - Violin Concertos (see KRESS) MusicWeb International February 2019 Second Thoughts & Second Reviews - Winter 2019/2 - Sonatas (see BACH JS and CPE) WALTON Belshazzar_RPO/Previn_IMP (see emusic.com). Al Andalus - Arabic-Andalusian Music_Paniagua_Harmonia Mundi Amaræ Morti – music by CARDOSO, LASSUS, PHINOT, etc._ El León de Oro/Peter Phillips_Hyperion Danças Brasileiras São Paulo Symphony Orchestra (OSESP)/Roberto Minczuk (BIS) Extravagantes Seicento: Sonatas for violin and viola da gamba at the Habsburg Court_Girandole Armoniche_Arcana God is not a Terrorist Ustad Saami (Indigo Music) *** I promised to keep readers up to date on emusic.com. Unfortunately, there are still very few classical recordings there to recommend and none of the labels which they lost seem to have returned, so it’s still ‘jam yesterday and jam tomorrow’. A series of recordings of Mozart’s piano music, including the piano trios and piano quartets, which may look attractive, doesn’t even name the performers. A New Year’s Concert, which might easily be mistaken for the latest Vienna Phil recording, since it’s entitled Neujahrskonzert, is an omnium gatherum of recordings for budget labels from the Tbilisi Orchestra and the St Petersburg Radio and TV Orchestra. At £10.50 for three hours of music, it looks like decent value but it’s not the Vienna Phil and it seems to offer only waltzes, without the variety that the VPO offer in their concerts. Furthermore, if you browse recent ‘classical’ recordings, most of what is offered would be hard to classify as such. Click on some of the promising offerings and you find ‘that album is unavailable’. There still is some gold and silver among the dross, such as the INA Archives recording of MESSIAEN’s Turangalîla Symphony, with Yvonne Loriod, a January 1959 broadcast in a decent transfer for £5.88, though you probably won’t want the announcements before and after, in French and German. An even better Messiaen bargain featuring Yvonne Loriod, this time with the Czech Philharmonic and Václav Neumann comes in the form of Oiseaux exotiques, La Bouscarle and Réveil des oiseaux on Supraphon for just £1.26. The recording, supervised by the composer, is no longer available on CD except in a 6-CD package. Since I reviewed this in DL News 2015/3, emusic.com downloads have been transformed to the highest bit-rate of 320kb/s. To the best of my knowledge, however, the claim on the Supraphon cover ‘digital recording’ is grossly misleading – the LP was released in 1969 (SUAST50749), well before the era of digital recording. Incidentally, that LP cost 25/6, which is almost exactly £1.26; who said that nothing ever stays the same? I must stress that the false claim is made by Supraphon, not by emusic.com. Those unwilling to commit to an emusic.com subscription, will find the Supraphon for £1.99 (mp3) or £2.49 (lossless) at 7digital.com. There’s no booklet from either source or, indeed, with the streamed version of the 6-CD set from Naxos Music Library. MusicWeb International p2 Second Thoughts & Second Reviews - Winter 2019/2 Many fine recordings disappeared with the demise of the super-budget Carlton Classics and IMP Classics CD labels. Some of these are available from emusic.com and one highlight is André Previn’s remake of WALTON’s Belshazzar’s Feast, not the better-known LSO version but the one which originally appeared on the RPO’s own label, with Benjamin Luxon, the Brighton Festival Chorus and Collegium Musicum of London in 1986. The coupling is the Henry V Suite. At £5.88, that’s less expensive than the nearest mp3 version that I can find, at £7.49, with the least expensive lossless download at £7.99. There’s no booklet with any version that I can find. *** Al Andalus - Arabic-Andalusian Music Inshad - Baitan - Insiraf [4:00] Touchia - Sana’a [3:33] (no title) [3:27] Sana’a [3:22] M’saddar - Sana’a [3:03] M’saddar [4:24] M’shalya [2:20] Sana’a - Touchia [1:47] Sana’a [1:25] M’saddar - Sana’a [1:48] Taqsim [2:34] M’shalya - Touchia - Sana’a [2:19] Taqsim - Sana’a [3:58] Taqsim - Muas-sa-taquil - Sana’a [4:26] Atrium Musicæ de Madrid/Gregorio Paniagua rec. October 1976 ADD. HARMONIA MUNDI MUSIQUE D’ABORD HMA195389 [42:26] Reviewed as lossless download (no booklet) from CD from First released on LP in 1977 and on full-price CD in 1992, then twice on the budget-price Musique d’Abord label, with different covers, this may be hard to come by on disc: Amazon UK report three only in stock. Those content with mp3 should find it for around £4.99, but it’s worth paying a little extra ($9.55) for the eclassical.com lossless version. Neither comes with a booklet, but the d’Abord series notes are usually minimal. All you really need to know is that the music is performed on traditional instruments by a team whose recordings are influenced by North African practice. The music is always rhythmic, if a little more restrained than you may be expecting, though Taqsim - Sana’a on the penultimate track sounds almost like the prototype of Ravel’s Boléro. Don’t confuse this with similar recordings by Eduardo Paniagua and Musica Antigua on his own label Pneuma – DL Roundup March 2009 and DL News 2013/5 where I expressed some reservations about the performance style. MusicWeb International p3 Second Thoughts & Second Reviews - Winter 2019/2 Antoine de FÉVIN (c.1470-c.1511/12) Missa Ave Maria [33:19] Ascendens Christus in altum [6:18] Sancta Trinitas a4 [3:20] Antoine de FÉVIN and Arnold von BRUCK (1490? 1500?-1554) Sancta Trinitas a6 [3:50] Chant Salve sancta parens [0:42] Antoine de FÉVIN Missa Salve sancta parens [31:42] The Brabant Ensemble/Stephen Rice Texts and translations included rec. All Saints Church, East Finchley, London, 29-31 January 2018. DDD. Bonus download track: JOSQUIN des PREZ (c.1450/55-1521) Ave Maria … virgo serena [5:52] HYPERION CDA68265 [85:05] For purchase details see reviews by Gary Higginson and Richard Hanlon. Reviewed as 24/96 download with pdf booklet and bonus track from The name Antoine de Févin is hardly familiar, even among renaissance specialists. His very dates and birthplace are uncertain, as is the question whether the contemporary composer Robert de Févin was his brother (probably). Prior to this Hyperion release, we had the Requiem which either he or Anthonius Divitis composed, (just) possibly for the death of Anne of Brittany (ÆON ÆCD1216 – review – Zig-Zag Territoires ZZT110501 – review) together with shorter pieces included in various collections. Of the two Requiem recordings, that on Æon is ruled out for me by what I call the ‘Khartoum on ice’ syndrome whereby everything has to be controlled by gimmick, the prime example of which is having the sword in Wagner’s Siegfried forged on a gas cooker in a bijou kitchenette in the Stuttgart production; I kid you not. (Euroarts 2052088 – review of earlier release – or box set – review). Organum and Marcel Pérès on Æon produce some absolutely wonderful singing, but spoil things completely by the application of Pérès’ unproven theories based on Corsican folksong – elaborate melismata and doubling the bass line an octave lower, also known as the dreaded ‘chapel-bass’. My reservations apply to most of Pérès’ other recordings – see Autumn 2018/3 – and many of those of Graindelavoix, who subscribe to Organum’s low-pitch approach. Nor am I totally convinced by the Zig-Zag alternative.