56 Nordic Theatre Studies Vol. 27: No. 1 ABSTRACT

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

56 Nordic Theatre Studies Vol. 27: No. 1 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT Centripetal Force of locus: Dilemmas of Nomadism in Contemporary Lithuanian Artistic Practices By using two cases – a production, called !e Heart in Vilnius (2012) and a so- cial-artistic project Give Yourself to Vilnius (2014), the article aims to discuss the issue of a “liquid” mind-set (Bauman) as it is perceived, re!ected and formulated in contemporary Lithuanian artistic practices. "ese examples were intentionally chosen because both seem to address the issue of “roots” in one’s native land in opposition to physical or intellectual mobility. By establishing Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania, as the spiritual locus of emotional ful#llment, both cases dwell on a social anxiety that Zygmunt Bauman terms “a meaninglessness”, typical for a transitional society, where modernization progresses at a di$erent pace in di$er- ent strata. Moreover, whether it is a political statement or a popular attraction, both examples portray a nomad and nomadism of late modernity as an “Other”, drawing a divisional and alienating line between a “liquid” mind-set and a “sta- ble” one. Keywords: theatre, popular culture, liquid mind-set, anxiety, contemporary Lithuania. BIOGRAPHY Martynas Petrikas (Dr) is an Associate Professor at the Institute of Creative Media, Vilnius University (Lithuania) and a Lecturer at the Department of "eatre Studies, Faculty of Arts, Vytautas Magnus University (Kaunas, Lithua- nia). His #elds of interest, among others, are social aspects of theatrical practice, the history of Lithuanian theatre, and the history and theory of theatre criticism. His contribution to a collective monograph Postsovietinis Lietuvos teatras: (Post-Soviet Lithuanian Theatre: History, Identity, ) came out in print in 2014. [email protected] 56 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 Centripetal Force of locus Dilemmas of Nomadism in Contemporary Lithuanian Artistic Practices MARTYNAS PETRIKAS "e housekeeper Marguerite, a character in Le they were enveloped in light rabbit or heavy shear- Champ d’oliviers, a lesser-known Guy de Mau- ling coats, placed like little buns in the back seat passant 1890 novel, informs her master, the local of a ‘Moskvitch 401 or 407’ and taken to the local abbé, of her discomfort with a visit by un maoufa- hospital for vaccination against the measles. […] tan – equivalent of malfaiteur – for a lawbreaker or In their childhood they made a fundamental pact criminal in Provençal. In such a manner, good Mlle of inseparability between a dream and a duty. […] Marguerite refers to a stranger, a person without "ey were the #rst generation which perceived a life any evident provenance, profession or intentions as as motion. Freedom is a certain substance without a vagabond who is assumed to be a hazard at least to a permanent address: the Sixties’ generation gave a the usual rhythm of the day. However, not only the new content to this formula.”2 delicious dinner of poule au riz growing cold is at Rather symptomatically the issue of mobility was stake here. Metaphorically, the #gure of the stranger, one of the earliest that was discussed on the Lithua- his/her presence and activities possess an existential nian stage: the #rst play in Lithuanian that proved to threat to the wholesomeness of a micro-world in a be a popular success was the comedy America in the sun-soaked coastal village, as well as to the integrity Bathhouse, published in 1895. "e authors, Antanas of the lives of the characters in the novel. and Juozas Vilkutaičiai, evidently aimed not only at "us, a stranger, a world-roaming vagabond be- providing the amateur Lithuanian stage of the time comes a maoufatan in the eyes of the settled local with adequate playwriting, they saw their play as a populace. Anthropologically, what we have here is contribution to growing concerns about Lithuanian a con!ict between two di$erent life styles that have emigration. In the comedy, a credulous country girl, their roots, one in a settled and sedentary, and an- who under the charm of a wandering tailor, tries to other in a nomadic lifestyle. As Knut Ove Arntzen elope to the United States, ends up in a steam bath points out, in a philosophical context, the nomadic on the outskirts of the village and in shame. "us lifestyle corresponds to a metaphorical way of re- America in the Bathhouse set a satirical and didac- !ecting reality.1 In contrast to the idea of growth, tic tone that in subsequent decades became typical development and reproduction in a single place, for representing the issue of mobility on the Lith- which is the crucial element of a stable lifestyle, the uanian stage. As literary scholar Reda Pabarčienė notion of mobility and possibilities within a mobile points out, Petras Vaičiūnas (1890–1959, the most lifestyle for the nomads becomes a predisposition proli#c Lithuanian playwright of the Interwar peri- for learning and producing. In a similar manner, yet od), when addressing migration in his plays, would in a less approving tone, the Latvian sociologist Tālis usually draw a pattern of inward movement for the Tisenkopfs described the generations that were born characters: only temporary excursions out of the na- in the Soviet Union during the Sixties: “as children tive place were deemed acceptable.3 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 57 A clash between nomadic and settled lifestyles of the twentieth century. Moreover, under Soviet strongly resonates in contemporary sociology, where rule, the notion of Lithuanian nationality was in- Zygmunt Bauman terms the mind-set of late mo- tentionally transformed into depoliticized “folk”, to dernity as “liquid” in contrast to its “solid” modern use the philosopher Nerija Putinaitė’s wording, thus predecessor.4 Bauman’s late modern subject is “light increasing its rural, ethnographic and pre-modern and liquid”: an individual who shifts her/his geo- connotations.9 As such it remained in popular im- graphical, social, political, marital, sexual, cultural agery after 1990, fuelling controversies on Lithuani- positions in a !uid manner, excluding her/himself anness further. Perceived in this way, an opposition from traditional forms of support, such as family, between the doxa of stability and the “liquid” heter- community, nation and state. In a metaphorical odoxy can easily be transferable to a political debate sense, such a nomad withstands the common law and an economic argument. of gravity, which presupposes a power relationship In a political sense, increased mobility can be between the core and the peripheral, where the for- related to social strati#cation, or as Bauman notes, mer attracts the latter, thus de#ning its actions and rather than homogenizing the human condition, trajectory. the technological diminution of temporal/spatial Moreover, as Rosi Braidotti points out, some of distances tends to polarize it. For some people, mo- the greatest trips can take place without physically bility gives freedom of meaning-creation, yet, by the moving from one’s habitat. According to Braidot- same token, is condemned by others for meaning- ti, a nomadic mind-set should be regarded as aim- lessness.10 In Lithuania these were metaphorically ing at the subversion of a set of conventions and expressed by the infamous division of society into at consciousness-raising, rather than the literal act “runkeliai” (the beetroots) and “elitas” (the elite), of traveling.5 Consequently, the nomad becomes a which has grown into a #xture of public discourse lawbreaker in a political sense, or, as Bauman ar- in the #rst decade of the twenty-#rst century. It is gues, in the contemporary world, mobility (physical interesting to note, how such a division semantically or indeed intellectual) has become a powerful tool included an opposition between “rooted” stability in the restrati#cation of social hierarchies.6 and “detached” mobility that explicitly becomes a Society in post-Soviet Lithuania provides a good domain of “the elite”.11 "us, the upper echelons of insight into the clash between two di$erent mind- society were equaled to those who are able to ben- sets. As sociologist Jolanta Kuznecovienė notes, e#t from the nomadic or “liquid” lifestyle, whereas contemporary Lithuanian cultural practices can be the physically or intellectually “rooted” rest were de- divided and grouped into two distinct tendencies, graded. Because of such a lack of equilibrium social which advocate for either a national or transnation- tensions are highly possible in di$erent layers of so- al identity.7 Moreover, globalization in economics ciety, Emmanuel Todd observes that modernization and the consequent increase of mobility both phys- progresses at di$erent paces, whereas the ideals of ical and intellectual is proportional to the in!ux of liberty and individualism are not necessarily em- intercultural elements into the local socio-cultural braced as positive in all strata.12 pattern, thus the possibility to detect “unique” fea- "e Lithuanian artist and scholar Kęstutis Šapo- tures in Lithuanian identity is diminishing. In the ka provides an additional correlation between social typical quest for a de#nition of national uniqueness, divisions and contemporary Lithuanian art. In his the side arguing on emotional and ethical grounds 2011 review of Žilvinas Kempinas’ personal exhi- substitutes the lack of clear-cut features by elevating bition in Vilnius, the scholar argues that Kempinas’ national and transnational identities into a moral “ingenious and amusing”, “intentionally lightheart- opposition.8 In other words, transnational identity, ed yet suggestive enough” and, above all, perfect- springing out of the nomadic or “liquid” mind-set, ly executed work mirrors cultural preferences and is opposed to the doxa of stable and homogenous tastes of the Lithuanian bourgeoisie.13 "is well- nationality, which, in the Lithuanian case, was cre- heeled stratum, which arrived at a dominant posi- ated in the course of nation-building in the #rst half tion in the Nineties, to use Šapoka’s wording, “is too 58 Nordic Theatre Studies vol.
Recommended publications
  • The Lessons of the Last Romanovs: Neither Bolshevism Nor Tsarism
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 19, Number 43, October 30, 1992 The lessons of the last Romanovs: neither Bolshevism nor tsarism by Denise Henderson Cheka (secret police) of the Urals in 1917 and therefore responsible for the captive Romanovs, a "proletarian Jacob­ The LastTsar: The Life and Death of in." Lenin himself proclaimed: "At least a hundred Ra­ Nicholas II ped by Edward Radzinsky, trans. by Marian Schwartz manovs must have their heads chop off in order to unlearn their descendants of crimes." And Trotsky, speakinggeneral­ Doubleday, New York, 1992 ly, added, "We must put an end once and for all to the Papish­ 462 pages, hardbound, $25 Quaker babble about the sanctity of human life." The turning point for the 'ancien regime' The downfall of a regime usually leads to an outpouring of There is no doubt that both the secret way in which the memoirs, analysis, romance, and other sorts of history, and Romanovs were executed, without trial, and the fact that for the fall of the 300-year-old Romanov dynasty in 1915, when 70 years the Bolsheviks practiced state terrorism against the Nicholas II abdicated for himself and his son, has been no Soviet population, thereby making open discussion about exception. This year, Edward Radzinsky, a Russian play­ the ancien regime taboo, have contributed to the fascination wright and historian, who began his researches on Nicholas Russians and others have with the death of Nicholas II and II 20 years ago, has added The Last Tsar: The Lifeand Death his family.But more important than Radzinsky's description of Nicholas II to that literature.
    [Show full text]
  • Generate PDF of This Page
    Institute of National Remembrance https://ipn.gov.pl/en/digital-resources/articles/4397,Battle-of-Warsaw-1920.html 2021-10-01, 13:56 11.08.2020 Battle of Warsaw, 1920 We invite you to read an article by Mirosław Szumiło, D.Sc. on the Battle of Warsaw, 1920. The text is also available in French and Russian (see attached pdf files). The Battle of Warsaw was one of the most important moments of the Polish-Bolshevik war, one of the most decisive events in the history of Poland, Europe and the entire world. However, excluding Poland, this fact is almost completely unknown to the citizens of European countries. This phenomenon was noticed a decade after the battle had taken place by a British diplomat, Lord Edgar Vincent d’Abernon, a direct witness of the events. In his book of 1931 “The Eighteenth Decisive Battle of the World: Warsaw, 1920”, he claimed that in the contemporary history of civilisation there are, in fact, few events of greater importance than the Battle of Warsaw of 1920. There is also no other which has been more overlooked. To better understand the origin and importance of the battle of Warsaw, one needs to become acquainted with a short summary of the Polish-Bolshevik war and, first and foremost, to get to know the goals of both fighting sides. We ought to start with stating the obvious, namely, that the Bolshevik regime, led by Vladimir Lenin, was, from the very beginning, focused on expansion. Prof. Richard Pipes, a prolific American historian, stated: “the Bolsheviks took power not to change Russia, but to use it as a trampoline for world revolution”.
    [Show full text]
  • Lithuanians and Poles Against Communism After 1956. Parallel Ways to Freedom?
    Lithuanians and Poles against Communism after 1956. Parallel Ways to Freedom? The project has been co-financed by the Department of Public and Cultural Diplomacy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs within the competition ‘Cooperation in the field of public diplomacy 2013.’ The publication expresses only the views of the author and must not be identified with the official stance of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The book is available under the Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0, Poland. Some rights have been reserved to the authors and the Faculty of International and Po- litical Studies of the Jagiellonian University. This piece has been created as a part of the competition ‘Cooperation in the Field of Public Diplomacy in 2013,’ implemented by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 2013. It is permitted to use this work, provided that the above information, including the information on the applicable license, holders of rights and competition ‘Cooperation in the field of public diplomacy 2013’ is included. Translated from Polish by Anna Sekułowicz and Łukasz Moskała Translated from Lithuanian by Aldona Matulytė Copy-edited by Keith Horeschka Cover designe by Bartłomiej Klepiński ISBN 978-609-8086-05-8 © PI Bernardinai.lt, 2015 © Jagiellonian University, 2015 Lithuanians and Poles against Communism after 1956. Parallel Ways to Freedom? Editet by Katarzyna Korzeniewska, Adam Mielczarek, Monika Kareniauskaitė, and Małgorzata Stefanowicz Vilnius 2015 Table of Contents 7 Katarzyna Korzeniewska, Adam Mielczarek, Monika Kareniauskaitė, Małgorzata
    [Show full text]
  • Requiem for a Pagan Soul. Pagan Reminiscences in 19Th Century Cemeteries in Lithuania
    SUOMALAISEN KUOLEMANTUTKIMUKSEN SEURA SYKSY 2016 Thanatos ISSN 2242-6280, vol. 5 2/2016 © Suomalaisen Kuolemantutkimuksen Seura Ry. https://thanatosjournal.files.wordpress.com/2016/12/bazaraite_etal_requiem.pdf Requiem for a pagan soul. Pagan reminiscences in 19th century cemeteries in Lithuania Eglė Bazaraitė Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa Teresa Heitor Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa Maria Manuel Oliveira Universidade do Minho The historian of death must not be afraid to embrace the centuries until they run into a millennium. (Ariès 1981, xvi) Abstract European burial grounds suffered a great shift in the 19th century: hygienic strategies of city development brought them to be outside of the city cores. A new model of cemetery handed a right to memory for those social classes that were sentenced to forgetting before: it was the time of the rise of the individual. Following garden development – from hortus conclusus to an open landscape – first through the use of the false funeral monuments in the gardens, then placing real tombs in natural milieu (for example, a tomb of Jean-Jacques Rousseau in Île des Peupliers in Ermenonville) – people got accustomed to see death in the garden and burial spaces acquired Edenic expression. Lithuania was the very last European country to accept Christianity; all the territory was only Christianised in the beginning of the 15th century. Therefore this article approaches burial grounds in Lithuania as places where pagan culture meets recent Christian attitudes and concerns. The first trigger for this research was an urge to identify elements of pagan beliefs in spatial solutions of Lithuanian cemeteries. In order to decode a morphogenetic identity of Lithuanian burial grounds, two 19th-century cemeteries in Vilnius, Lithuania, were approached from a syntactic point of view taking into account the mythological references of Christianity and Baltic paganism.
    [Show full text]
  • LITUANUS Cumulative Index 1954-2004 (PDF)
    LITUANUS Cumulative Index 1954-2004 Art and Artists [Aleksa, Petras]. See Jautokas. 23:3 (1977) 59-65. [Algminas, Arvydas]. See Matranga. 31:2 (1985) 27-32. Anderson, Donald J. “Lithuanian Bookplates Ex Libris.” 26:4 (1980) 42-49. ——. “The Art of Algimantas Kezys.” 27:1 (1981) 49-62. ——. “Lithuanian Art: Exhibition 90 ‘My Religious Beliefs’.” 36:4 (1990) 16-26. ——. “Lithuanian Artists in North America.” 40:2 (1994) 43-57. Andriußyt∂, Rasa. “Rimvydas Jankauskas (Kampas).” 45:3 (1999) 48-56. Artists in Lithuania. “The Younger Generation of Graphic Artists in Lithuania: Eleven Reproductions.” 19:2 (1973) 55-66. [Augius, Paulius]. See Jurkus. 5:4 (1959) 118-120. See Kuraus- kas. 14:1 (1968) 40-64. Außrien∂, Nora. “Außrin∂ Marcinkeviçi∆t∂-Kerr.” 50:3 (2004) 33-34. Bagdonas, Juozas. “Profile of an Artist.” 29:4 (1983) 50-62. Bakßys Richardson, Milda. ”Juozas Jakßtas: A Lithuanian Carv- er Confronts the Venerable Oak.” 47:2 (2001) 4, 19-53. Baltrußaitis, Jurgis. “Arts and Crafts in the Lithuanian Home- stead.” 7:1 (1961) 18-21. ——. “Distinguishing Inner Marks of Roerich’s Painting.” Translated by W. Edward Brown. 20:1 (1974) 38-48. [Balukas, Vanda 1923–2004]. “The Canvas is the Message.” 28:3 (1982) 33-36. [Banys, Nijol∂]. See Kezys. 43:4 (1997) 55-61. [Barysait∂, DΩoja]. See Kuç∂nas-Foti. 44:4 (1998) 11-22. 13 ART AND ARTISTS [Bookplates and small art works]. Augusts, Gvido. 46:3 (2000) 20. Daukßait∂-Katinien∂, Irena. 26:4 (1980) 47. Eidrigeviçius, Stasys 26:4 (1980) 48. Indraßius, Algirdas. 44:1 (1998) 44. Ivanauskait∂, Jurga. 48:4 (2002) 39.
    [Show full text]
  • Itineraries of Jewish Actors During the Firs
    ABSTRACT Reconstructing a Nomadic Network: Itineraries of Jewish Actors during the First Lithuanian Independence !is article discusses the phenomenon of openness and its nomadic nature in the activities of Jewish actors performing in Kaunas during the "rst Lithuanian independence. Jewish theatre between the two world wars had an active and intense life in Kaunas. Two to four independent theatres existed at one time and international stars were often touring in Lithuania. Nevertheless, Lithuanian Jewish theatre life was never regarded by Lithuanian or European theatre society as signi"cant since Jewish theatre never had su#cient ambition and resources to become such. On the one hand, Jewish theatre organized itself in a nomadic way, that is, Jewish actors and directors were constantly on the road, touring from one country to another. On the other hand, there was a tense competition between the local Jewish theatres both for subsidies and for audiences. !is competition did not allow the Jewish community to create a theatre that could represent Jewish culture convincingly. Being a theatre of an ethnic minority, Jewish theatre did not enjoy the same attention from the state that was given to the Lithuanian National !eatre. !e nomadic nature of the Jewish theatre is shown through the perspective of the concept of nomadic as developed by Deleuze and Guattari. Keywords: Jewish theatre, Kaunas, nomadic, "rst Lithuanian independence, Yiddish culture. BIOGRAPHY management. 78 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 Nordic Theatre Studies vol. 27: no. 1 Reconstructing a Nomadic Network Itineraries of Jewish Actors during the First Lithuanian Independence INA PUKELYTĖ Networking and the maintenance of horizontal links of intermezzo1 and thus implicitly shows the inter- were always common to European theatre commu- relation between theatre and the nomadic: “!e nities.
    [Show full text]
  • IN the Theatre JOURNALISM DURING the FIRST Lithuanian INDEPENDENCE
    Meno istorija ir kritika / Art History & Criticism 12 ISSN 1822-4555 (Print), ISSN 1822-4547 (Online) http://dx.doi.org/10.7220/1822-4547.12.7 Ina PUKELYtė Vytautas Magnus University, Kaunas, Lithuania Representation of “THE OTHER” IN THE THeatre 83 Journalism during THE First LITHuanian Independence REP JOU Summary. The article discusses the notion of the Other as it reveals itself through the content of the Lithuanian R press media in the time period between 1926 and 1940. Articles describing the performances of the Lithuanian R ESENTATION OF “THE OF ESENTATION National Theatre are discussed. The content of these articles shows that Russian artists working in independent DU NALISM Lithuania were considered as a dangerous Other who exploits Lithuania ideologically and economically. Although such artists as Andrius Oleka-Žilinskas, Mikhail Chekhov, Vera Solovjova and others came to work in Kaunas in order to escape the Soviet regime, they were accused in Lithuania as being pro-Bolshevik and pro-Communist. The research shows that Lithuanian theatre journalists only considered Russians as dangerous to the young independent state but not Jewish or Polish artists. One can presume that Lithuania feared the communist regime R so much that it tried to avoid any collaboration, including this with artists, which could harm the development of THE ING the independent state. In spite that Russian theatre artists enriched Lithuanian National Theatre, they were forced to leave Lithuania and never come back. Keywords: Lithuanian theatre during the first independence, representation of the Other in Lithuanian theatre, theatre and the Other, theatre journalism. F O I THE R ST ST R L ” IN THE THE IN ” The first Lithuanian independence (1918-1940) is realize this objective, we shall take advantage of the ITHUANIAN known as the time period when the notion of Lithu- philosophical notion of the Other since it allows to anian national identity was created.
    [Show full text]
  • E.XTENSIONS of REMARKS an APPEAL to CONGRESSIONAL Gion to the Individuals That Are Affected Requested That I Convey Their Message to CONSCIENCE by It
    15342 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS June 18, 1979 By Mr. MARKEY: H.R. 4156: Mr. SHELBY. AMENDMENTS H.R. 4522. A blll !or the relief of Annette H.R. 4157: Mr. COELHO, Mr. LAGOMARSINO, Jutta Wohrle; to the Committee on the Mr. PANETTA, and Mr. LUNGREN. Under clause 6 of rule XXIII, pro­ Judiciary. H.R. 4158: Mr. MITCHELL of Maryland, Mr. posed amendments were submitted as By Mr. QUILLEN: SYMMS, Mr. GRISHAM, Mr. WHITEHURST, Mr. follows: HoLLAND, Mr. WINN, Mr. McKINNEY, Mr. NEAL, H.R. 4057 H.R. 4523. A bill directing the President to Mr. BAFALIS, Mr. EDWARDS Of California, Mr. By Mr. KELLY: award a medal of honor to Jordan M. Robin­ FRENZEL, Mr. LAGOMARSINO, Mr. AMBRO, Mr. son; to the Committee on Armed Services. -on page 1, line 8, Insert the following new MINETA, Mr. CHAPPELL, Mr. DoRNAN, Mr. ED­ section 3: GAR, Mr. BURGENER, Mr. WEISS, Mr. McHUGH, SEc. 3. Section 5(e) of the Food Stamp Act Mr. AKAKA, Mr. HoPKINS, and Mr. CoURTER. of 1977 is amended by inserting the following ADDITIONAL SPONSORS H.R. 4443: Mr. SOLARZ, Mr. MURPHY of new sentence: "Any individual 1s entitled to Pennsylvania, and Mr. STGERMAIN. claim a deduction from his household in­ Under clause 4 of rule XXII, sponsors H. Oon. Res. 59: Mr. CHENEY. to come, above the standard deduction, !or his were added public bills and resolu­ H. Con. Res. 1:l4: lvLr. n.N.LJ.E.R.::ION of Illinois, medical and dental expenses, to the extent tions as follows: Mr. ANTHONY, Mr. BADHAM, Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Zinoviev (Biography + Primary Sources)
    Gregory Zinoviev was born in Yelizavetgrad, Ukraine, Russia on 23rd September, 1883. The son of a Jewish diary farmers, Zinoviev received no formal schooling and was educated at home. At the age of fourteen he found work as a clerk. Zinoviev joined the Social Democratic Party in 1901. He became involved in trade union activities and as a result of police persecution he left Russia and went to live in Berlin before moving on to Paris. In 1903 Zinoviev met Vladimir Lenin and George Plekhanov in Switzerland. At the Second Congress of the Social Democratic Party in London in 1903, there was a dispute between Vladimir Lenin and Jules Martov, two of the party's main leaders. Lenin argued for a small party of professional revolutionaries with alarge fringe of non-party sympathisers and supporters. Martov disagreed believing it was better to have a large party of activists. Martov won the vote 28-23 but Lenin was unwilling to accept the result and formed a faction known as the Bolsheviks. Those who remained loyal to Martov became known as Mensheviks. Leon Trotsky, who got to know him during this period compared him to Lev Kamenev: "Zinoviev and Kamenev are two profoundly different types. Zinoviev is an agitator. Kamenev a propagandist. Zinoviev was guided in the main by a subtle political instinct. Kamenev was given to reasoning and analyzing. Zinoviev was always inclined to fly off at a tangent. Kamenev, on the contrary, erred on the side of excessive caution. Zinoviev was entirely absorbed by politics, cultivating no other interests and appetites.
    [Show full text]
  • “Oblivious of Gens”…
    UDC 94(47):355.40 A. M. PLEKHANOV DOI: 10.25206/2542-0488-2018-1-7-11 Society for the Study СОВРЕМЕННОСТЬ» № 1 2018 ВЕСТНИК. СЕРИЯ «ОБЩЕСТВО. ИСТОРИЯ. ОМСКИЙ НАУЧНЫЙ of the History of Russian Secret Services, Moscow, Russia «IT SEEMS THAT WE GROW YOUNGER GENERATION “OBLIVIOUS OF GENS”…» Alexander Mikhailovich Plekhanov is a Ph.D in history, professor, full member of the International Informatization Academy, veteran of the KGB of the USSR, retired colonel, author of several monographs devoted to the biography of F. E. Dzerzhinsky, the history of Russian secret services, defense and protection of the state border and the history of Cossacks. He is a founder of the Society for the Study of the History of Russian Secret Services and a founder of the conference «Historical Readings at the Lubyanka». This interview was given by A. M. Plekhanov during his participation in the International research and practice conference «The Activities of Russian Secret Services in the Age of Social Cataclysms», which held in Omsk on November 23rd 2017 and edited in Moscow on January 2018. It is devoted to the current state and prospects of studying the history of Russia’s secret services. Keywords: Russian secret services, state security agencies, F. E. Dzerzhinsky. References 7. Teplyakov A. G. «Nepronitsayemyye nedra»: VCHK-OGPU v Sibiri. 1918–1929 gg. [«Impenetrable bowels»: Cheka-OGPU in 1. Deyatel’nost’ otechestvennykh spetssluzhb v epokhu Siberia. 1918–1929]. Moscow: AIRO-XXI, 2007. 288 p. ISBN 978- sotsial’nykh kataklizmov [The activities of Russian special services 5-91022-042-7. (In Russ.). in the era of social cataclysms].
    [Show full text]
  • Comparing Terrors: State Terrorism in Revolutionary France and Russia
    W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 2011 Comparing Terrors: State Terrorism in Revolutionary France and Russia Anne Cabrié Forsythe College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the European History Commons Recommended Citation Forsythe, Anne Cabrié, "Comparing Terrors: State Terrorism in Revolutionary France and Russia" (2011). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539626669. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-f7fy-7w09 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Comparing Terrors: State Terrorism in Revolutionary France and Russia Anne Cabrie Forsythe Richmond, Virginia Bachelors of Arts, Mary Baldwin College, January 2006 A Thesis presented to the Graduate Faculty of the College of William and Mary in Candidacy for the Degree of Master of Arts Lyon G. Tyler Department of History The College of William and Mary January 2011 APPROVAL PAGE This Thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Anne Cabrie Forsythe Approved by the Committee, December 2010 Committee Ch&fr Associate Professor Gail M. Bossenga, History The College of William and Mary James Pinckney Harrison Professor Frederick C. Corney, History The College of William and Mary Professor Carl J. Strikwerda, History Dean of the Faculty of Arts & Sciences The College of William and Mary n4~ Associate Professor Hiroshi Kitamura, History The College of William and Mary ABSTRACT PAGE This paper compares how the National Convention and the Sovnarkom were able to declare terror and how they operated each terror in terms of their definition of revolutionary justice.
    [Show full text]
  • 7. Nationalism in Post-Soviet Lithuania
    After Independence: Making and Protecting the Nation in Postcolonial and Postcommunist States Lowell W. Barrington, Editor http://www.press.umich.edu/titleDetailDesc.do?id=126246 The University of Michigan Press 7. Nationalism in Post-Soviet Lithuania New Approaches for the Nation of “Innocent Sufferers” TERRY D. CLARK Most scholars argue that, in contrast to many of the states of the for- mer Soviet Union, Lithuania has had few dif‹culties with its national minorities.1 Much of this owes to Lithuanians constituting over 80 percent of the population, while the two largest national minorities comprise approximately 8 percent (Russians) and 7 percent (Poles) respectively. Given these demographics, the new Lithuanian state, unlike its Baltic neighbors, exercised the so-called zero option—granting citizenship to all individuals on its state territory at the time of restoration of independence irrespective of their national identity. This was a major factor in the rela- tively tranquil relations between national communities in the country.2 The argument for comparatively tranquil relations between national communities, however, is not the same as making the case that nationalism as a phenomenon does not exist in the political system. This chapter argues that nationalism has existed in one form or another since the late Soviet era. While it has not led to con›ict of the sort seen in the other Baltic republics or parts of the former Soviet Union, it has nonetheless con- tributed to social dif‹culties and unrest, particularly in the period leading up to and immediately following the restoration of independence. But, since the immediate postindependence period, nationalism has also been both weakened and transformed.
    [Show full text]