AN OVERVIEW OF THE INTERFACE BETWEEN ASPECTS OF SOMALI
PHONOLOGY AND MORPHOLOGY: A RESOURCE GUIDE FOR
ESL TEACHERS
by
Ahmed Mohamed
B.S., Afgoi College of Education, Mogadishu, Somalia, 1983
A Thesis
Submitted to the Graduate Faculty
of
St. Cloud State University
in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for the Degree
Master of Arts
St. Cloud, Minnesota
January, 2013 1
This thesis submitted by Ahmed Mohamed in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts at St. Cloud State University is hereby approved by the final examination committee.
______Chairperson
______
______
______Dean School of Graduate Studies ii
AN OVERVIEW OF THE INTERFACE BETWEEN ASPECTS OF SOMALI PHONOLOGY AND MORPHOLOGY: A RESOURCE GUIDE FOR ESL TEACHERS
Ahmed Mohamed
In writing this thesis, I pursue three objectives. First, the research is mainly designed as a reference book for English language teachers who have Somali ELL students in their classes. It gives a brief overview of the phonological and morphological structures of the Somali language. In so doing, it draws the teachers’ attention to the linguistic challenges their students face while acquiring English. By knowing how the students’ L1 language works, teachers will gain a sense of how to transition their students’ L1 to English as an L2. This insight can help them understand the challenges that their Somali students face when writing or speaking English.
The second objective is achieved by answering these two questions: 1. What are the salient phonological and morphological features of the Somali language? 2. What are the phonological and morphological features of the Somali language that may lead to negative transfer during the process of acquiring English?
Somali lacks five phonemes which are found in English: /p, v, z, ð, θ/. Similarly, English does not have seven phonemes that are present in Somali: /G, ɖ, ʔ, x, ʕ, ħ, and r/. The lack of these phonemes in either language may cause negative interference. In addition, the sounds /k/, /t/, and /m/ never occur at the end of a Somali word. This illustrates the fact that Somali hardly ever allows these sounds to occur in a coda cluster.
The syllable structures of both languages are fairly distinct. English permits syllable clusters in the onset and the coda, but Somali does allow either.
Orthographically, Somali has a transparent spelling, whereas English is opaque. For example, the sound /f/ is represented in spelling as
iii
Morphologically, Somali is an agglutinating language. This means that grammatical formation of words is determined by attaching morphemes (suffixes or prefixes) to the word root or stem to form a new part of speech. Nouns are inflected for number (plural, singular), for definiteness and indefiniteness, gender (masculine, feminine), and case (subjective, objective, possessive, absolutive). Verbs inflect to show person (first, second, third), gender (masculine, feminine), number (singular, plural), mood (indicative, imperative, subjective, conditional), aspect (habitual, progressive), and tense (present, past, future).
The third objective in writing this thesis is that I have an intrinsic passion to study my language. The Somalis are known as a nation of bards. Therefore, it has a long and rich history of oral tradition and literature. Poetry is one of the main means of cultural preservation. Somali has a rich poetic genre which consists not only of songs, but also of various forms of wisdom literature (proverbs, riddles).
This study presents a brief morphophological analysis of Somali. It compares these aspects in both Somali and English and highlights the areas that may cause challenges to Somali ELL students. It is advantageous if ELL teachers have some ideas about these aspects of Somali that are likely to interfere with the students’ acquisition of English.
______Month Year Approved by Research Committee:
______Ettien Koffi Chairperson
iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I wish to express to Professor Ettien Kofi my gratitude for the patience, advising, editing and commenting on successive versions of my thesis. I am indebted to Rhoda Fagerland who completely edited my thesis.
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
LIST OF TABLE ...... x
LIST OF FIGURE ...... xi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND SYMBOLS ...... xii
Chapter
1. A SOCIOLINGUISTIC OVERVIEW ...... 1
Lingusitic Background ...... 4
Language Family/Lineage ...... 5
2. OVERVIEW OF THE SOMALI SOUND SYSTEM AND ALPHABET ...... 8
Somali Phonology and Orthography ...... 8
An Overview of the Somali Alphabets (Shaqallada) ...... 8
Vowels ...... 10
Somali Consonant Phonemes ...... 10
Consonant Sound Systems (hab-dhawaaga-shaquallada) ...... 11
Gemination ...... 16
Somali Vowel Phonemes ...... 17
Diphthongs ...... 19
vi
Chapter Page
Tone and Accent ...... 21
Morphosyntactic Tone ...... 24
Sullable Structure ...... 25
Sullable Final Stops ...... 27
Consonant Cluster Simplification ...... 28
Restriction on Vowel Syllables ...... 28
Vowel Deletion ...... 29
3. NOMINAL DERIVATIONS ...... 31
Derivational Affixes in Nouns ...... 32
Derivation of Abstract Nouns ...... 36
Compound Nouns ...... 38
Nouns Derived from Adjectives ...... 40
Possessive Suffix <-le> ...... 41
Basic Structure of Somali Noun Phrases ...... 42
Vocative Suffixes ...... 42
Noun Reduplications ...... 44
Adjective ...... 46
Adverbs ...... 53
4. NOMINAL INFLECTIONS ...... 58
Types of Inflexion in Somali Nouns ...... 59
Noun Declensions ...... 59
vii
Chapter Page
Plural Form of Adjectives ...... 68
Comparative and Superlative ...... 69
Numerals ...... 70
Determiners ...... 71
5. VERB MORPHOLOGY ...... 77
Pronouns ...... 77
Verb Structure ...... 81
Verbal Inflection Categories ...... 89
Tense ...... 89
Aspect ...... 93
Habitual Present (Positive Form) ...... 99
Habitual Past ...... 100
Habitual Past (Negative Form) ...... 101
Mood ...... 102
Sentence Subordinate Clause (Main/Subordinate) ...... 111
Derivational Morphology of Somali Verbs ...... 116
Verb Reduplications ...... 121
Middle Voice ...... 122
6. IMPLICATIONS AND FINDINGS ...... 128
Inflectional Mistakes (Negative Transfer) ...... 129
Phonological Challenges ...... 132
viii
Chapter Page
Consonant Cluster Simplifications ...... 133
Stress and Tone Challenges (Negative Transfer) ...... 134
Implications ...... 135
Conclusion ...... 137
REFERENCES ...... 138
APPENDIX ...... 143
ix
LIST OF TABLE
Table Page
1. Somali Consonant Chart ...... 11
x
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure Page
1. The Classification of Somali in East Cushitic ...... 7
xi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND SYMBOLS
ABS absolutive case ADJ adjective ADP Adposition ADV adverb AP accentual pattern ART article AUX auxiliary verb C1, C2, C3 1st conjugation (C1), 2nd conjugation (C2) and 3rd conjugation (C3) CAU causative (derived verb) DEM demonstrative COLL collective D1, D2….D8 noun declensions (1st, 2nd ….8th declension) DET Determiner DM Declarative marker / mood classifier (MC) EXC exclusive EXP experiencial (derived noun) FACT factitive (derived verb) F/FEM feminine gender FUT future tense GEN genitive case H high tone HAB habitual tense IMP imperative INC inclusive INCH inchoative (derived verb) INF infinitive INFL Inflectional affixations INTR intransitive INTER interrogative IPRO independent pronoun L low tone LEX Verbal derivational affixes M. masculine gender NIMP negative imperative marker NEG negative form (word or verb)
xii NOM nominative case O object O PRO object pronoun OPT optative verb form PAS passive voice PAST past tense Pl. plural POT potential verb form PRES present tense PORG progressive tense Sing. singular S PRO subject pronoun ROOT base form verb SUBORD subordinate clause SUPR superlative marker TAM tense, aspect and mood markings TRN transitive VOC vocative case 1 first person 2 second person 3 third person * ungrammatical constructed form ?? sounds arkward // syllable boundary ⊘ zero /null
xiii
Chapter 1
A SOCIOLINGUISTIC OVERVIEW
This study is mainly designed as a reference book for English language teachers who are teaching Somali English language learners (ELL) students. It gives a brief overview of the phonological and morphological structures of the Somali language, in order to draw teachers’ attention to the linguistic challenges Somali students face as they acquire English. It is hoped that teachers, by knowing how their students’ first language works, will gain a sense of how the students’ first language
(L1) is different from their second language (L2), and that this insight can help them better understand the source of the difficulties that their first language (L1) Somali students face in writing and speaking English.
This study aims to answer two important questions:
1. What are the salient phonological and morphological features of the Somali
language?
2. What are the phonological and morphological features of the Somali
language that may lead to negative transfer during the process of English
acquisition?
The underlying hypothesis that remains to be verified is that Somali ELL students will acquire English quickly because the phonological and morphological
1 2 structures of their language are more complex than those of their second language,
English.
Before embarking on a full-blown analysis, it is important to provide a historical overview of the Somali people, their language, and the reason why many of them live in Minnesota.
The Land and the People (Dulka iyo Dadka)
The country of Somalia is located in eastern part of the Horn of Africa. The
Somali language is spoken by the Somali people. The countries where Somali is spoken include the following: Somalia, most parts of Djibouti, the eastern part of
Ethiopia, and the Northeastern part of Kenya. The exact number of Somali speakers is not known, but it is roughly estimated that there are about twelve million Somali speakers in the world. The Somali people are divided into three socio-economic groups. The first and the largest are nomadic pastoralists (reerguuraa). They herd livestock such as camels, goats, sheep, and cattle. They move from one place to another to find pasture and water for their flocks. The second group is made up of farmers (beeralay) who live between the two rivers: The Shebelle and the Juba. They cultivate crops and keep some livestock. The third group is the townspeople
(reermagaal). They are scattered all over the world because a large number of Somalis fled to neighboring countries as refugees, where they received resettlement from the
USA, Canada, and Australia and different countries in Europe.
For the past 21 years, Somalia has been in chaos: a state of anarchy. This lawlessness has compelled Somali citizens to flee to wherever they felt would be a
3 safe haven. The first Somali refugee influx to Minnesota began in the early 1990s.
Currently, there are “more Somalis living in Minnesota than anywhere else outside
East Africa” (Burke, 2001, p. 8).
In fact, the significant dialect variations in Somali are grouped into three categories:
1) Maxatiri: The Northern dialect is the standard used for official purposes
such as government operations, education, and broadcasting. The Northern
dialect is also most widely used across the country as the lingua franca. It is
called the standard form and prestigious dialect because it has been used by
scholars, politicians, and poets since the country’s independence. This
dialect enjoys official status, and it is regarded as the official dialect. It is
spoken in the northern, western, and southernmost areas of Somalia. There
is a fair degree of intelligibility between the Northern dialect and the
Banadiri.
2) Banadiri: This dialect is the second largest dialect, spoken along the Indian
Ocean coast and also in Mogadishu.
3) Maay: Lastly, this dialect is spoken in the southwestern area, stretching to
the Ethiopian border andto some coastal areas between Mogadishu and
Kismanyo. The Maay dialect is completely unintelligible to both Northern
and Banadiri dialect speakers (Saeed, 1999). There are very small pockets
of dialects within the three major dialect variations in the Somali language.
4
Linguistic Background
The Somali language had no official orthography before 1972. There were several systems of writing in existence, but none had gained or won the general acceptance of the people. The Somali republic was formed by the unification of the ex-British Somaliland Protectorate and the ex-Italian Somaliland. The ultra- nationalists pressed the notion and the need for having a national orthography, because the two different colonial systems of education, which did not share the same written language, employed translators in order to read correspondence between the government offices. This urgency of needing a national language forced the Somali government to set up a Linguistic Committee in 1961 to study and investigate the matter and also invited the public to submit their proposals to the Linguistic committee. About eighteen proposals were submitted to committee. The Linguistic
Committee was advised to present its recommendations to the Government, but they did not follow through due to political wrangling over the Somali script called
Osmania (Far Somali) and the Roman script (Latin).
Finally, the Roman script (Latin) was officially adopted in 1972 and remains the official writing system of Somali today. Prior to the adoption of this script, an indigenous alphabet known as Osmania had been introduced as a primary writing system by Cisman Kenadiid in 1922. It did not succeed because its orthography was difficult, and the Latin alphabet was more suitable for government offices as well as in public education. It could be used with available typewriters and was therefore economically viable.
5
On March, 7, 1974, the government launched a nationwide literacy campaign which aimed to promote and implement the new orthography and to teach every
Somali citizen. Government officials, universities, and public school students were intensively trained to teach and engage in the literacy campaign. As Wolf (2002) reports, “Astriking example of highly effective implementation was the master plan for introducing an official language and the new standard orthography in Somalia in
1972/3, after endless years of escaping decisions on which type of graphicization to adopt” (p. 338). Civil servants were compelled within three months to pass a test in writing the new orthography; failure resulted in loss of employment. A year after the campaign, the ministry of education instantly implemented Somali language as the medium of instruction for primary education and later made it mandatory for secondary schools.
Language Family/Lineage
Somali language is a member of the Cushitic family which branches off a larger language family: the Afro-Asiatic/Hamito-Semitic language phylum along with
Omotic, Chadic, Berber, and ancient Egyptian (Saeed, 1999). Somali is a sub-group of
East Cushitic languages which comprises more than thirty languages. The most prominent East Cushitic languages are Oromo and Somali.
There are internal classifications within East Cushitic; the major divisions are between the highland East Cushitic and the lowland Cushitic. Western Omo-Tana is a
6 distinct branch. There are two additional branches, Yaaku and Boon, which are considered endangered languages.
Although Cushitic can be seen as a single family, it consists of six major groups of languages. Some of them are very distinct from each other, while others show some commonalities but exhibit a number of substantially different internal subgroups. Some Cushitic languages are nearly extinct, such as Yaaku, which is spoken by a few elderly members of hunter-gatherers in Kenya (Hayward, 2000). The
Somali language has the second largest number of speakers within the Cushitic family after Oromo. Thus; Somali is a regional language that is spoken in the Horn of Africa region. It is mainly spoken in Somalia, Djibouti, Western Ethiopia, the North-
Easternprovince of Kenya, and by millions of Somali diaspora who are scattered around the world.
Figure 1 shows the current position of Somali within the Cushitic language.
7
(Source: Saeed, 1999)
Figure 1: The Classification of Somali in East Cushitic
Chapter 2
OVERVIEW OF THE SOMALI SOUND SYSTEM AND ALPHABET
Somali Phonology and Orthography
This chapter will focus briefly on Somali phonology and orthogarphy. These phonological units include consonants, vowels, grapheme to phoneme inventory, syllable structure, morphosyntatic behavior, and tonal aspect.
An Overview of the Somali Alphabets (Shaqallada)
The basic set of Somali consonant graphemes consists of 22 graphemes; each of them represents specific sounds. The Somali alphabet uses all but three (
,
The chart below shows both Somali and English consonant graphemes and consonant phonemes:
8 9
Pronunciations Somali consonant Somali consonant English English ( in Somali) graphemes phonemes consonant consonant graphemes phonemes
[ba] [b] [b] [ta] [p] The shaded columns show the English graphemes and phonemes that do not exist in Somali languages. There are no diatrics or other special characters; however, Somali has three consonant diagraphs: 10 Vowels Somali has a five-vowel system, just like other languages in the Afro-Asiatic family. All vowels in Somali may be categorized as short or long, depending on the pronunciation. The short vowels , The long vowels The vowel length is phonemic in Somali, so this is represented in the orthography by noting single vowel graphemes and vowel geminates as represented the chart below: Short vowels Long vowels Somali Consonant Phonemes The 22 Somali consonants are written below in the standard orthography, followed by their corresponding IPA Symbols and basic phonetic descriptions (place of articulation and manner of articulation): 11 Table 1: Somali Consonant Chart Bilabial Labio- Alveolar Platoaveolar Retroflex Velar Uvular Pharyngeal Glottal dental Stopsvoiceless t k ʔ Stops b d ɖ g G voiced Fricatives f s ʃ χ Ћ h voiceless Fricatives ʕ voiced Affricatives ʧ voiceless Nasal m n Trill r Lateral l Glides w j Koffi (2010)1 proposes the above table for Somali Consonants. Consonant Sound Systems (hab-dhawaaqa- shaqallada) The sounds of the Somali alphabet are each represented by a specific letter. The alphabet does not comprise all the letters of the English alphabet. Each consonant sound is described in the following examples: 1 The consonant chart in Saeed (1999, p. 7) omits the places of articulation. This piece of nformation has been supplied by comparing Saeed’s chart at http:// Weston.ruter.net/project/ipa- chart/view/keyboard/. Moreover, Saeed does not follow the IPA convention of listing voiceless consonants before their voiced counter parts. This is Koffi’s adaptation of Saeed’s chart with IPA. 12 The sound /b/ is a voiced bilabial plosive, represented orthographically as , and sounding as it is in English. It sounds more like unaspirated English [p] when it occurs at the end of a word: ‘plain’ ‘ice’ The sound /t/ is a voiceless dental plosive. It is represented orthographically as The sound /ʧ/ or /ʤ/ is the only affricative, and it is the palato-alveolar affricative, orthographically represented as The sound /ћ/ is a pharyngeal fricative, which is written as ‘go out’ The sound /χ/ is a voiceless uvular fricative and is represented as It is the sound used for the .(خ) sound is only found in loan words from Arabic Scottish pronunciation of the word 13 The sound /d/ is a voiced dental plosive, which is written as ‘people’ ‘many’ ‘flood’ ‘move’ ‘fire’ pail’ The sound /r/ is a voiced alveolar trill and is scripted as an goat’ The sound /s/ is a voiceless alveolar fricative and is denoted as an ‘nose’ ‘give’ ‘hide’ ‘oil’ ‘horn’ The phoneme /ʃ/ sound is voiceless palate-alveolar fricative. It is written as a diagraph The sound /ɖ/ is a retroflex plosive. It is represented as a digraph 2 At the end of a word, it sounds more like [t], for example: 14 In Chapter 1, dialectical variations within the Somali language were described. In one dialect, this diagraph Northern dialect Southern dialect <ádhi> ‘sheep and goats’ <ári> ‘sheep and goats’ The phoneme/ʕ/ is a voiced pharyngeal fricative and is represented as a ‘aaaa’. This sound is made by sudden contraction of the glottis, as in the sound /x/ but with vibration of the vocal cord, for example: well’ The sound /g/ is a voiced velar stop, orthographically written as The sound /f/ is a voiceless labio-dental fricative; it is denoted as <áfar> ‘four’ <áf> ‘mouth’ 15 The sound /G/ is a voiced uvular plosive. It has a grapheme representation It is very hard for non-native speakers to .(ق) q>. This sound is like the Arabic> pronounce, but the best way to try is to pronounce The sound /k/ is a voiceless velar, orthographically written as ‘thousand’ The sound /l/ is a voiced velar lateral approximant, orthographically written as Then sound /m/ is a bilabial nasal, ‘honey’ time’ ‘or’ ‘men’ ‘lung’ The sound /n/ is a voiced velar nasal, orthographically denoted as 16 ‘peace’ ‘knife’ ‘breast’ ‘woman’ ‘mercy’/ ‘piety’ The sound /w/ is a voiced bilabial approximate or semi-vowel represented as ‘rhinoceros’ ‘saint’ ‘ram’ ‘spear’ ‘news’ The sound /j/ is a voiced palatal approximant or semi-vowel, orthographically represented as The sound/ʔ/ is a glottal stop, written as <’>. Usually it occurs between vowels. However, it can occur at the beginning of monosyllabic words which begin with vowels: without’ Gemination There are a number of consonants in Somali that may be pronounced as doubled consonants. These are called as geminate consonants. The list below shows all of the Somali consonants, with examples of those which may be found as double consonants: 17 b d dh g Somali Vowel Phonemes Somali Vowel Chart Height Front Back [+ATR] [-ATR] High [i, ɪ] [u,ʊ] [i, u] [ɪ, ʊ] Mid [e, ɛ] [o,ɔ] [e, o] [ɛ, ɔ] Low [æ] [ɑ] [e, o] [æ] The above IPA chart of the Somali vowel (Koffi 2010) shows qualities of the variants of each vowel: The Somali Language has five short and five long vowels, which are illustrated in the following sections. Short vowels. The short vowels are represented in the orthography by five single graphemes, as shown below: The vowel is pronounced as the vowel [a] in the English word ‘rat’: The vowel 18 ‘change’ The vowel is pronounced like [i]in the English word ‘pin’: ‘iron’ The vowel [o] is pronounced as in the English word ‘top’: The vowel [u] is pronounced the same as in the English word ‘put’: Long vowels. Long vowels are represented in the orthography by doubling vowels as in the examples below: The The vowel The The 19 The ‘mountain’ ‘book’ ‘Somali hut’ Diphthongs Somali has five short and five long diphthongs. Their orthographic representations follow: Short diphthongs. The below examples show the pronunciations of the short type diphthongs: 3 Note that the diphthongs 20 Long diphthongs. The long dipthongs are phonologically conditioned because nouns ending in <-a> take <-aay>, nouns ending in <-o> take <-ooy>; all other nouns that do not end <-a> and <-o>, which means they could end any other vowels or with consonants take <-eey>, <-oow> and i) <-ay> on female names and nouns ii) <-ow> on male names and nouns The long Somali diphthongs, then, are ‘Oh, help!’ ‘Oh, Anab!’ ‘Oh, mother!’ ‘Oh, Hassan!’ In conclusion, there are fifteen consonant phonemes that exist both in Somali and English. The below chart shows the Somali sounds that are like English: Manner of Somali phonemes English phonemes Shared phonemes articulation stop /b/, /t/, /d/, /k/, /g/ /b/, /t/, /d/, /k/, /g/ yes nasal /m/, /n/ /m/, /n/ yes fricative /f/, /s/,/ʃ/, /h/ /f/, /s/,/ʃ/, /h/ Yes affricative /ʧ/, /ʤ/ /ʧ/ Yes glide /w/, /j/ /w/, /j/ Yes lateral /l/ /l/ Yes 21 There are five phonemes and a glottal stop in the Somali language that are not found in English. The below chart illustrates the Somali sounds that are not like English: Manner of articulation Somali phonemes Shared phonemes stops /g/, /ɖ/, /ʔ/ no fricatives /x/,/ʕ/,/ħ/, no trill /r/ no As shown in the above chart, Somali has five phonemes and a glottal stop that are not found in English.Somali speakers who are English Language Learners (ELL) or English as Second Language (ESL) students will encounter grapheme to phoneme confusion replacing English reading. This study will help ELL teachers to understand and to be aware of the above phonemes that have different sound representation. Tone and Accent In the mid-thirties, Armstrong (1964) hinted that Somali had several instances of tone alterations within the words. Later on, several authors (Klingenhen, 1949; Andrezewski, 1956; Vycihl, 1956) further discussed the nature of tonal alterations and their relationship with stress in Somali. As a result of these studies, tone and stress in Somali were subsequently described in greater detail by Andrezewski (e.g., 1956, 22 1964, and 1977), who developed a phonemic concept of “accentual units.” This means a set of fixed alternations of tone and stress. Hyman (1981a, 1981b) showed the fundamental nature of Somali as a tonal accent system, and also demonstrated that neither tone nor accent is marked at the abstract level. That means each accent mora is assigned a high tone (+accent) at a later level, while each unaccented mora (-accent) is assigned a low tone. The mora is defined as an accent-carrying unit in the Somali language. It is represented in phonological convention by μ: “Accent in Somali is a property of the vowel (or mora), while it is a property of the syllable in English” (Hyman, 1981, p. 177). Finally, Somali has three basic tones with two levels of pitch as shown the below chart: Tone Symbol Characteristic Example 1 featureHigh tone á Acute, or strong stress <ínan> ‘a boy’ 2 Low tone a No stress, or un-accented stress The mora is a carrying unit of tone and will be marked on vowels. On long vowels, the tone mark will be placed on the first vowel, for example, <áa>, <àa>. For clarification, it should be noted that the falling tone (high-low sequence) is a tone that falls from high to low, and only occur in the long vowels. Saeed (1993, p. 24) demonstrated three phonetic pitch levels of the syllables of two words 23 3 an inan in 3 in2 2 1 ta 1 Level 2 (mid) is high tone in the second syllable of Level 3 (highest) is a high tone in, the second syllable of Level 1 is a (lower) tone in the third syllable of Clements states, “The majority of African languages are tonal languages or tonal-accent languages, in which differences in relative pitch are used to show lexical and grammatical distinctions” (2000, p.152). The intonation of Somali words and sentences is governed by the placement of the stress-tone on a certain vowel. Usually, stress-tone is placed on vowel units: a short vowel is one vowel unit, and a long vowel and diphthongs are made up of two vowel units. For example, the Somali word ‘enter’ is made up of one vowel unit, and the Somali word 24 Subject case Absolutive case Word: nin nín‘a man’ Tone: L H Gender and number in nouns are also marked by stress-tone only as shown in the examples below: Gender: ínan ‘a boy’ inán ‘a girl’ Tone: HL LH Number: èy ‘a dog’ éy ‘dogs’ Tone: Falling H Similarly, some words of different categories such as prepositions (Prep) and pronouns (Pro) are spelled the same way. Only the tone can help distinguish between the two: Words: kú ‘in’, ‘on’ (Prep) ku ‘you’ (Pro) Tone: H L Words: lá ‘with’ (prep) la ‘someone’ (Pro) Tone: H L MorphosyntacticTone Tonal variations are used to mark case, gender, number, and verbal inflection as shown in the examples below: 25 Words: Orthographically, tone is not marked in writing. Only native speakers understand where a word needs to be stressed or not. Therefore, one of most the difficult areas that foreigners face when learning the Somali language is correctly locating tone marking when reading. Syllable Structure Regarding syllables, Clements points out “In most African languages, words can be exhaustively divided into a sequence of syllables. That is, each word can be analyzed into a succession of units of the same general form, typically containing a peak of prominence V (representing a vowel, diphthongs, and syllabic consonants), usually preceded and sometimes followed by a less prominent margin consonant C (representing a consonant cluster). An initial margin is termed onset and a final margin is a coda” (2000, p. 140). However, the basic Somali syllable structure can be described as (C) V (C). As Saeed notes, in Somali (1999, p. 16), syllable structure can only occur with one of three following combinations: a) A syllable can consist of a single vowel (V). The vowel can be short :< u> ‘to or for’, long: 26 b) A syllable can consist of a consonant (C) followed by a vowel: c) A syllable can consist of a consonant (C) followed by a vowel which is followed by consonant: structures can be summarized as follows: 1. V ( short vowel) or VV long vowel or dipthong) 2. CV(consonant vowel) or CVV(consonant long vowel, diphthong) 3. CVC(consonant vowel consonant), CVVC(consonant long vowel, or diphthong, consonant) When a Somali word begins with a vowel, a glottal is inserted before the vowel, in order to provide onset to the syllable. Therefore, a Somali words like ‘dog’ is transcribed and pronounced as [ʔey]. Additionally, Somali does not allow consonant clusters in any position in the syllable. There can only be a maximum of one consonant in the onset or coda in the same syllable. Consonant clusters only occur across syllable boundaries and consist of a maximum of two consonants. The following examples will show the syllable boundaries of words that begin and end with consonants. These words are taken from Saeed (1999), with//standing for a syllable boundary: 27 Moreover, whenthe consonants /b/, /d/, /ɖ/, /g/, /G/, /l/, /m/, /n/, and /r/ occur at the syllable boundary, they become double consonants (form long geminates, ‘shaqaladdalabbanlaabma’), as shown the following examples: ‘short’(pl.) ‘folded’(pl.) ‘be quiet’ ‘three’ However, when a word begins with a vowel, a glottal stop is made to precede that vowel, as in the examples below: <éy> [ʔey] ‘a dog’ <ídan> [ʔdæn] ‘incense burner’ Somali syllable structure is less complex when compared to its English counterpart. The below table summarizes the syllable structures of both languages: English Syllable structure Somali Syllable structure English onset C, CC, CCC Somali onset C English rhyme VV(C)(C)(C)(C) Somali V, VV, VC, VVC Syllable Final Stops The phonemes /t/ and /k/, which are voiceless stops, do not occur in the coda syllables. If they are supposed to be in this position, their voiced counter parts /d/ and/g/ occur there instead. The nasal stop /m/ also doesn’t occur in the coda but is replaced there by /n/ : 28 (/k/ → [g] / _ // as in <*ilik> ‘tooth’ → (/t/ → [d]/ _ // as in <*gunut > ‘kont’ → /m/ → [n] _ // as in (Data taken from Saeed, 1993) Consonant Cluster Simplification Somali does not allow consonant clusters (VCC) in the coda. As a result of the re-syllabification applies to avoid this illicit construction, the cluster will be simplified to (VC), unless re-syllabification occurs as (CV//CV): Thus, <*cább> becomes <*cádd> becomes Because of this constraint, it is likely that Somali ELL students will simplify English complex syllable codas in writing. So, Restriction on Vowel Syllables In Somali, there is a restriction on a V syllable following a CV. In such cases, an epenthetic consonant [y] is inserted, as shown in the below examples: 1. 29 Vowel Deletion Some structural complications arise when affixation results in the creation of trisyllabic situation, (C1) V1 C2 V2 C3 V3. If the V2 happens to be a short vowel, it is deleted, and the structure is reduced to a disyllabic word: 1. 2. However, this rule of vowel deletion is not applicable to trisyllabic structure with the form (C1) V1 C2 C3 V2 C4 V3 or (C1) V1 C2 V2 C3 C4 V3 because the result of deleting V2 would create a consonant cluster. Sequences of three consonants are forbidden in Somali syllable structure. In summary, the Somali language has 22 consonant phonemes, each of which is represented by a specific sound and letter. These consonants occur in every place of articulation in the above table. Somali consonants do not constitute all English consonants; they lack the English consonants , Somali has five vowels: five short and five long. Similarly, there are five short diphthongs and five long diphthongs. Somali is a tonal language. Its utterances, words, and sentences are determined by the placement of the stress-tone on certain vowels in words. As mentioned before, Somali has three basic tones with two levels of pitch: 30 1. High tone á acute/accented 2. Low tone a no stress/unaccented 3. Falling tone as àa diminishing strong to weak stress Phonotatically, Somali syllable structure is (C) V (C). Clusters of two consonants do not occur word-initially or word-finally, which means they only occur at syllable boundaries. When a vowel occurs in word-initial position, aglottal stop is inserted before it. The phonemes /t/ and /k/, which are voiceless stops, do not occur in the coda syllables. The next two chapters will be briefly discussed the Somali morphology. Chapter 3 NOMINAL DERIVATIONS The rest of this study is primarily focused on Somali morphology.Word formation can be done either by shifting a word from one grammatical category to another or from one semantic type to another within the category, such as a verb derived from another type of verb. However, the main topics to be dealt within this chapter on nominal morphology are: 1) Derivational Morphology 2) Inflectional Morphology According to the UCLA International Institute (n.d.), Morphologically, Somali is an agglutinative language. This means grammatical information is determined morphologically by way of attaching affixes (prefixes or suffixes) to word roots and stems. Nouns change or “inflect” to show grammatical information such as definiteness (definite or indefinite), gender (masculine or feminine), number (singular or plural), and case (nominative, genitive, accusative or vocative). Verbs inflect to show person (first, second, third), number (singular, plural), gender (masculine, feminine), mood (indicative, imperative, subjunctive, conditional), aspect (perfect, imperfect), tense (present, past, future), and polarity (affirmative, negative). 31 32 Derivational Affixes in Nouns The derivational process of Somali nouns means that it is possible to derive nouns from other parts of speech, or from other nouns. Two main derivations will be examined in this chapter. Nouns derived from verb roots. Some nouns are derived from verb roots without adding any suffixations. Saeed (1999) named this process “category shift.” Mostly, these nouns are regarded as masculine nouns: [Verb + zero suffix = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived noun 1. Verbal nouns derived from verbs. Verbal nouns are derived from the verb stem by suffixing <-id> or <-to > to root verbs, <-n> to causative and factitive verbs, and <-asho> for middle voice. As an example, the derived verbal nouns are feminine abstract nouns as shown below: 33 [Verb + <-id>, <-to>, <-n>& -asho> = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived verbal noun 1. 2. (Data taken from Saeed, 1999, p. 194) Masculine verbal nouns are formed by suffixing <-itaan> to verb roots: [Verb+ <-itaan > = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived verbal noun 1. Saeed (1999) pointed out some verbal nouns which are derived from verbs with “specific semantic modifications.” Nouns derived by suffixing <-niin> to a root verb are shown in the chart below: 34 [Verb + <-niin > = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived verbal noun 1. Some other masculine nouns are formed by adding the suffix <-e> (<-ye> after stem ending in <-i>) to a verb. Saeed (1999) named this affix “genitive/instrumental suffix”. This type of genitive suffix is similar or equivalent to the English genitive suffix <-er> as in “player,” “boxer,” or “killer”, for example. The nouns derived belong to Declension 7: [Verb + <-e> = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived noun 1. A very small number of feminine nouns are derived from verbs by adding the genitive suffixes <-to> and <-aa> which lexically carry genitive information like the 35 affix <-e> mentioned above. In addition, the suffix <-to> derives nouns, forming an occupational/ professional status, whereas asuffix <-aa> which seems archaic. For example: [Verb + <-to/-aa> = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived noun 1. Nouns derived from verbs are mostly masculine, even though feminine nouns are also found. According to Saeed (1999), “A further affix <-aal> creates for a verb, a derived noun meaning a product of verb V” (p. 151). This is illustrated in the examples below: [Verb+ <-aal> = Derived noun] Verb Suffix Derived noun 1. 36 In conclusion, Somali nouns may be derived from nouns or other parts of speech. Saeed described as a “category shift” (1999) by which nouns arederived from other nouns with zero affixations process. Verbal nouns are derived from verbs by adding suffixial morphemes, and they are mostly masculine. A very small number of feminine nouns are derived from verbs. Derivation of Abstract Nouns There aretwosuffixes, <-nimo> and <-tooyo>, which when added to concrete nouns form abstract nouns of quality. All these nouns belong to Declension 6, and thus are nouns derived from other nouns. For example: [Noun + < -nimo/-tooyo> = Derived noun] Noun Suffix Derived noun 1. 2. 37 Somali has also borrowed the Arabic suffix <-i4yad> to help create abstract feminine nouns, as seen in the table below: [Loan noun + suffix <-iyad> = Derived noun] Loan noun Suffix Derived noun 1. The antonym suffix <-daro> ‘lack of’ is added to certain abstract nouns that show goodness or praise deserving qualities. The resulting feminine noun shows an unfavorable situation, as in the table below: [Noun+ <-daro> = Derived noun] Noun Suffix Derived noun 1. <árxan> ‘mercy’ <- 4 In the examples above, each loan word noun ends with <-i>. It may be note worthing that one <-i> is dropped when the suffix <-iyad> is added. 38 Compound Nouns There are basically three types of compound nouns. The first class of compound noun is formed by a combination of two nouns, as shown in the examples below: [Noun + Noun = Derived noun] Noun Noun Derived compound noun 1. <áf> ‘language’ The second class of compound nouns consists of a noun and an adjective (N + Adj = N). Some resulting nouns have agentive case endings <-eed/-ood>, as illustrated in the table below: 39 [ Noun + Adjective = Derived noun ] Nouns Suffix Derived compound noun 1. Similarly, this second class of compound nouns may be formed by adding the adjective <-weyn> ‘big’ as a suffix to nouns, as shown in the examples below: [Noun + Adjective= Derived noun] Noun Adjective Derived compound noun 1. The third class of compound nouns is formed by a combination of nouns and verbs. These are the most common compound nouns and are called deverbals because the last element is a verbal noun derived from a verb root. Saeed (1999) described these compounds as follows: 40 [Noun + Verb = Derived noun] Noun Verb Derived compound noun 1. Nouns Derived from Adjectives Feminine abstract nouns are derived from adjectives by adding the suffix <- aan>. This type of derivation is similar to the English abstract suffix <-ness> as in ‘whiteness’, ‘shortness’, and readiness, as shown in the table below: Adjective Suffix Derived noun 1. 41 Possessive Suffix <-le> When the suffix <-le> is added to a noun, it forms a derived masculine noun, which means ‘owner of something’ or ‘possessor of something’, as illustrated in the table below: [Noun + <-le> = Derived noun] Noun Suffix Derived noun 1 The Somali possessives are determiners which are suffixed to the nouns and agree in gender. The examples below illustrate suffixes, which consist of combinations of possessive determiners and the definite articles <-ka/-ta> ‘the’: Determiner Suffix <-ka> Masculine Suffix <-ta> Feminine my <-ga> táyga <-da> táyda our <-ga> káaga <-da> táada his/its (M.) <-sa> kíisa <-sa> tíisa her/its (F.) <-da> keeda <-da> téeda our (incl.) <-nna> kéenna <-nna> téenna our (excl.) <-ga> káyaga <-da> táyada your (pl.) <-nna> kíinna <-nna> tíinna their <-da> kóoda <-da> tóoda 42 Basic Structure of Somali Noun Phrases In a single noun phrase (NP), generally the head-initial occurs in the following order: Noun Possessive Definite/ indefinite article Adjective Demonstrative article Relative Clause Interrogative article NP {N (Det) (Demon.art) (Interro.art) (Adj) (Relative clause)}, the examples below show the possible occurences of a noun phrase in Somali: house/the big house’ going to’ Vocative Suffixes The vocative is used to indicate direct speech such as an address to one or when using one’s personal name. In the vocative, the names are offset by comas; for example, 43 <-yahay/-yahow>. The suffix <-aay> is added to nouns ending in the vowel <-a>. In nouns ending in the vowel <-o>, the <-ooy> is added, but elsewhere <-èey> is used. The form of the suffix is phonologically conditioned. These suffixes do not occur in the short vowel variants <-éy/-áy/-óy> (these are not diphthongs as were seen on page 19). Vocatives with suffix: <-éey/ -áay/ -óoy/-ow> (honorific). In Somali, using the word honorific is hard because Somali society believes in an egalitarianism system; however, this affixation is used for respected, elderly, or professional people in the examples below: 1. 4. name) for God) Vocatives with suffix: <-yahay/-yahow> (neutral). The below table illustrates some examples of vocative suffixes (neutral): 1. <ínanyahay> M.sing. ‘boy!’, ‘Oh boy!’ (cf. ínan) 2. 5 ‘o’ tends to be arahaic where it is generally used to honor in an address. 44 Noun Reduplications In linguistics, noun reduplication is a morphological process by which a root or stem of a word is partially or completely repeated. The purpose of reduplication is to show grammatical function such as plurality in inflections; it is also used in lexical derivations to form new words. Therefore, groups of Somali nouns undergo this morphological process to form plurality. Group A: These plural nouns are formed by a complete reduplication of the singular noun; the examples below present a derivational model: Singular noun (CV) Plural formation (CVCV) Underlying form /áf/ ‘language/mouth’ 1) Complete reduplication afáf Surface form afáf “languages/mouths’ Underlying form /bòg/ ‘page’ 1) Complete reduplication *bogbòg 2) Consonant onset deletion bog-óg 3) Vowel alternation boóg Surface form bogág ‘pages’ Group B: This group of plurals is formed by adding partial suffixing reduplication to singular nouns, where the first consonant of the stem (C) is followed by the first short vowel (V). In this case, consonant cluster simplification occurs because CVVCCVVC is simplified to CVVCVC. For example: 45 Singular ((CVVC) Plural formation (*CVVCCVVC) → Meaning (CVV∅C∅VC) Underlying form /faas/̀ ‘axe’ 1) Reduplication faasfà as̀ 2) Consonant onset faas̀ -aas̀ deletion3) Vowel deletion faas- -ás Surface form faasás ‘axes’ The reduplication forms of Group C: These plural nouns are formed by adding suffixing reduplication to the singular noun. The nasal Singular Plural formations(partial Meaning reduplication) (CVC) (*CVCCVC) → (CV∅CVC) Underlying form /nín/ ‘man’ 1) Reduplication nínnín 2)Consonant onset deletion nín-ín 3) Vowel alternation nín-án 4) Consonant alternation ním-án Surface form nimán ‘men’ 46 The reduplicated forms of ‘strap’, which are Group D: Singular Plural formations (partial Menaing reduplication) CVVC (*CVVCCVVC) → (CVV∅CV∅C) Underlying form /béer/ ‘liver’ 1) Reduplication béerbéer 2) Consonant onset béer-éer deletion3) Vowel deletion béer-er Vowel alternation béer-ár Surface form beerár ‘livers’ The reduplicated forms of ‘abdomen’, ‘enemies’, ‘smokes’, Adjective Adjectives are one of the major classes of the Somali parts of speech. They can occur both attributively as post-nominal markers and predicatively as complements of the copula 47 A. Sentence: B. Sentence: < wuu gaaban yahay> Gloss: w aa + uu gaaban yahay DM + he short is Trans: ‘he is short’ C. Sentence: Gloss: waa+uu cad yahay DM+ he white is Trans: ‘he is white’ In (a), the adjective shows an attributive construction, whereas in (b) it shows a predicative construction with a complement of the copular verb; at the sametime, the adjective Adjectives are distinguished from nouns in four ways: 1. They do not occur with determiners. 2. They are not marked with gender or number. 3. They do predicatively act as complements of the coupla 4. Adjectives occur between clitic pronouns and verbs. 48 Somali adjectives often occur with the past form of the verb, <-aa> is the past tense of ‘to be’ suffixed to them.Andrzewzki (1969) described this type of adjectives actas hybrid verbs because of their characteristics, as in the below examples: D. Word: Gloss: small [+ past] Trans: ‘(he/it ) was small’ E. Sentence: <árday+gii wanaagsán+aa> Gloss: student + Det.M [+past] good [+past] Trans: ‘The student was good’ Derived adjectives. Somali adjectives consist of two groups: a small number of basic adjectives such as The suffixes <-an/-san> help derive adjectives from transitive verbs. Saeed (1999) explains the process as follows: [Caustive verb + <-an> or <-san> = Derived adjective] 49 Causative verb Suffix Derived adjective 1. san> Suffixation also applies to factive (FACT.) verbs to derive corresponding adjectives: [Factitve verb + <-an/ -san > = Derived adjectives] Factitive verb Suffix Derived adjective 1. The suffixes <-an/-san> are added to inchoative verbs to form derived adjective, for example: [Incho verb + <-an/ -san> = Derived adjectives] Inchoative verbs (INTR) Suffix Derived adjective 1. 50 There are some adjectives that are derived from nouns. However, there are four basic color adjectives in the Somali language. Others are formed through a derivational process, which consists of adding <-an /-san> to the root: Noun Suffix Derived adjectives 1. A few adjectives are derived from nouns by suffixing <-e>, as shown in the below examples: [Noun + <-e> = Derived adjective] Noun Suffix Derived adjective 1. 51 Noun adjectives. The suffixes <-leh>, <-ah>, and <-la> are added to some nouns to change them into adjectives. There are some distinct/specific nuances in meaning. For example, <-leh> describes an inherent quality possessed by the noun being described; <-ah> indicates the material or attribute; <-la> denotes the absence of something or being without something, as illustrated in the examples below: [Noun+ <-leh> = Derived adjective] Noun Suffix Derived adjective 1. [Noun + <-ah> = Derived adjective] Noun Suffix Derived adjective 1. ‘iron’ <-ah> ‘made of iron’ 2. 52 [Noun+ < -la> = Derived adjective] Noun Suffix Derived adjective 1. <ìndho>‘eyes’ <-la> Formation of compound adjectives. Compound adjectives are formed from separate words added together, as shown in the examples below: [Noun + Adjective = Derived Compound Adjective Noun Adjective Compound adjective 1. 2. ‘throat’<áf> ‘edge’ In conclusion, adjectives constitute a major portion of the Somali parts of speech. They can occur both attributively and predicatively. Adjectives are differentiated from nouns in many ways. For instance, they are not suffixed with determiners, they do not mark gender or number, and they often take a past tense form of the verb “to be.” In derivational morphology, most of the derived adjectives are formed from transitive verbs by adding the suffixes <-an> and <-san>. Similarly, 53 noun-adjectives are derived from nouns by suffixing <-leh>, <-ah>, and <- la>. Banti (1988a) identified three prefixes that employ reduplication of plural formation of adjectives: a) CVV prefixations b) CVC prefixations c) CV prefixations In Somali, morphological constructions denote comparative and superlative adjectives, as in English. Both comapartives and superlatives are maked by particles known as adpositionals (ADP). For example, the adpositional Adverbs The class of adverbs is not as complex as the other categories of the other parts of speech, but it has a major grammatical function. This means that an adverb has the sentential role of adverbial, which is very important to sentence structure. An adverb usually modifies an adjective or a verb. For example, 54 Derived adverbs. Adverbs do not have much morphological construction; a small number of Somali adverbs are derived from nouns by suffixing <-to> to make an adverb of time, as illustrated in the example below: Noun Suffix Derived adverb of time 1. Types of adverbs. Most of the Somali adverbs are derivatives, meaning they may be formed by combining two words. However, adverbs may be classified into nine categories, as illustrated in the tables below: 55 1. Adverbs of time: 1. 2. 7. day’ 2. Adverbs of place: 1. 4. 3. Adverb of Manner: 1. 3. < áad yar / qúnyar>‘slowly’ 6. thus/therefore’ 4. Adverbs of Quality: the word < áad> ‘very’ is used to intensify adjectives, as in the the below examples: 56 sentence: <áad bàanù necebahay> àad bàa+aan ù neceb+ahay gloss: much Foc + I ADP hating + am trans: ‘I hate her/it very much’ 5. Adverbs of Quantity: 1. 6. Adverbs of Affirmation: 1. ‘yes’ 7. Adverbs of Interrogation: 1. /hádma?> ‘when?’ gòor?>/immisa kol?> ‘how often?’ 8. Adverbs of Reason: 1. < sidáas> ‘because’ 3. 9. Adverbs of Comparison (comparative and superlative form): 1. ‘better’ 57 In summary, Somali adverbs are not as complex as other parts of speech, but they play a very important grammatical role in sentence structure. By definition, they modify adjectives and verbs, as mentioned in the above examples. Morphologically, a small number of adverbs are derived from nouns by adding the suffix <-to> to form adverbs of time. Chapter 4 NOMINAL INFLECTIONS In general, there are two genders in Somali nouns: masculine and feminine. For some words, the gender is clear (e.g., <ínan> ‘boy', is masculine in singular form, but the plural of <ínan> is Morphologically, a noun is comprised of a root and a single affix, which give a combination of gender and number markings. Nouns change or inflect to show grammatical information such as definiteness (definite or indefinite), gender (masculine or feminine), number (singular or plural), and case (nominative, genitive, accusative, or vocative). The morphological complexity is that there are several nouns classified into groups known as declensions. While there are specific singular nouns and plural suffixes for some groups or classes of nouns (e.g., the plural ending for declensions 1 and 3 is ‘o’) (Lecarme, 2002; Saeed, 1999). 58 59 Types of Inflexion in Somali Nouns The most significant and complicated inflectional process in Somali nouns occurs in plural formation. Plural formation consists of a root noun and a single affix which marks gender and number. This can be repesented by the following formula: Root + suffix <-ka> = Masculine noun Root + suffix <-ta> = Feminine noun Noun Declensions The plural formations of nouns are divided into eight declensions or classes. These declensions are categorized into groups according to their characteristic similarities, especially the way in which the plural is formed, the gender of the plural (masculine or feminine), and the stress-tone pattern (occurrence). The main complication is that several declensions have the same specific singular and plural suffixes for groups of classes e.g. the plural ending for declensions 1 and 3 is <-o> (Lecarme, 2002; Saeed, 1999). In addition, all the first three classes share the same stress-pattern. The second complication is the combination of a root noun with definite determiners (-ka/-ta). Each has a masculine <-a> from suffixing with <-k> and a feminine form suffixing with <-t> to agree with the head noun’s gender. Many scholars have classified Somali nouns according to different linguistic approaches. For example, Hyman (1981) and Banti (1998) base their classification was totally on accentual pattern (AP) and the phonological orientation of nouns. 60 Others like Andrzejewski (1964, 1979), Caney (1984), and Saeed (1993a), have determined declensions on both phonological and syntactic criteria. The table below shows the specific characteristics which are common to any certain class of nouns or shared by nouns in a specific declension, as Orwin presented in (1995, p. 32): 1. Stress-tone pattern in singular and plural form 2. Gender in singular and plural form 3. Word shape in singular form 4. Plural formation Declension 1. The gender polarities of the first declension are feminine in the singular and masculine in the plural. Plurals are formed by suffixing <-o> or <-yo>. If the singular form ends with <-i>, stress-tone occurs on the last mora. They undergo an accent lowering in plural formation; (accent lowering is used when the focus marker (C)V1C2V2C3V3→ (C1)V1C2C3V3. In this case, if the V2 in the stem is short, it will be deleted, as in 1. 61 Declension 2. Declension 2 is used mostly for masculine nouns in the singular and for feminine in the plural. If the masculine singular noun ends with the following consonants: , (and sometimes The Tonal Pattern on Declension 2. Declension 2 can be grouped into sub- classes according to the accentual pattern of the singular noun. The major group belongs to declension 2A, which has a high tone on the penultimate mora, but a tone low elsewhere: Declension 2A. 1. ‘fan 3. Declension 2B. Sub-declension 2B comprises a very small number of less than fifty words. They have a high tone on the last mora, and low elsewhere: 62 1. Summary of declension 2: 1. Singular masculine root + <-yo> = Feminine plural noun 2. Singular masculine root + <-o> = Feminine plural noun Declension 3. Declension 3 is masculine in both singular and plural. The suffix of plural formation is <-o>. If the singular noun ends with <-i>, the suffix is <- yo>. In singular, nouns have a high tone on the penultimate mora. Elsewhere the tone is low. In the plural, they have a high tone on the last mora. Most of the root nouns consist of two short syllables and undergo stem contraction in plural formations, as shown in the examples below: 1. < gálab> ‘afternoon’ 63 As you can see from the above examples, morphophonological changes occur to the final consonants of the singular nouns when they form plural nouns, for example, the Summary of declension 3: 1. Singular masculine root + <-o> = Masculine plural noun 2. Singular masculine root + <-yo> = Masculine plural noun Declension 4. Declension 4 consists of monosyllabic singular nouns, which are reduplicated to form their plurals. They have vowel plus consonant (V+ C) as a suffix. In singular from, they have a high tone on the penultimate mora, and in plural formation they have a high tone on the last mora, but low elsewhere. The noun ‘boy’ becomes 1. <áf > ‘mouth’ 8. 64 Summary table of declension 4: Singular masculine root + Declension 5. Nouns showing this declension are masculine in singular and feminine in plural. As Orwin noted (1995, p. 48), the only distinction between these nouns in the singular and the plural is the gender and the stress tone. This difference is tonal pattern, which occurs on the penultimate vowel in singular nouns and on the final vowel in plural nouns, is seen in the examples below: 1. <éy> ‘dog’ In addition, all noun forms belonging to declension 5 are homographs because they share the same spelling but have two different pronunciations and two distinct meanings. Tonal stress is not indicated in Somali spelling. Summary of declension 5: Singular masculine root + tonal change = Plural feminine, i.e., strees occurs in the penultimate V in singular nouns and on the final V in plural 65 Declension 6. All nouns that belong to declension 6 are feminine in the singular and masculine in the plural. Singular forms end in <-o>, while the plurals end in the suffix <-oyin>. The stress-tone pattern occurs on the penultimate vowel in singular and plural nouns, as illustrated in the below examples: 1. Summary table of declension 6: Singular feminine root + sufix <-oyin> = Plural masculine noun Declension 7. Declension 7 signals singular nouns that are always feminine, while the masculine plural of such nouns carry the suffix <-yaal>. Normally, the singular form of this declension does not end in <-o>. The word shape in the singular form of this group of nouns usuallly ends with <-e>. However, there are some nouns that do not end in <-e>, but are still regarded as declension 7. The stress-tone pattern of singular nouns occurs on the penultimate vowel, whereas plural nouns carry no stress-tone. There are few words that do not follow the same pattern (do not end in <- e>) but which belong to the Declension 7: 66 1. There are some examples of nouns that do not end <-e>, but are regarded as declension 7: 1. Sumary of declension 7: Singular masculine noun ending with <-e> + <-yaal> = Plural feminine noun Declension 8. The Somali language has nouns which are irregular, that is, they do not fit any of the declensions mentioned so far. Most of these words are Arabic loan words which form the plural in the same way as they do in Arabic: 67 1. A few native Somali nouns are irregular; most of these irregular nouns reverse their gender in the plural formation. Some of them are foreign loan words: 1. <íl> ‘eye’ Somali is morphologically complex. For example, there is an additional plural form “intensive plural,”or the plural of plurals. An intensive plural has suffixes ending in <-al> or <-yaal>. Here are some examples: 1. men’ 2. <ábti> ‘maternal uncle’ uncles’ maternal uncles’ 3. ‘hundered’ hundreds’ Summary of declension 8: plural masculine noun root + <-yaal> or <-al> = Feminine plural noun 68 For the most part, intensive plurals are used in poetic and proverbial phraseology, for example: “ Have ye over plains and plains gone to war? Plural Form of Adjectives The plural form of an adjective is formed when the adjective is describing a plural noun. Martin Orwin stated (1995) that if an adjective is made up of one syllable, the syllable is simply repeated to form the plural. Similarly, if an adjective is made up of more than one syllable, the first syllable is prefixed to the singular form, as shown in the below examples: Type of syllable Singular adjective Plural adjective One syllable sing. form < yár> ‘small’ sing. form More than one syllable sing. form (pl.) Banti (1988) identifies three prefixes that can be used in reduplicating to form plural adjectives, as illustrated in the below examples: 69 a) CVV prefixations Singular adjective Prefix Plural formation(Adj.) b) CVC prefixations Singular form (Adj) Prefix Plural formation (Adj) c) CV prefixations Singular form (Adj) Prefix Plural formation (Adj.) Comparative and Superlative There is no morphological construction that expresses comparative and superlative in Somali adjectives. Comparative and superlative adjectives are marked by adpositional particles. The adpositional Sentence: Gloss: man-that-nom. man-this abs. DM+she less short is Trans: ‘That man is shorter than this man’ 70 For the superlative case, the marker is an adpositional cluster ugu ́ (← ú + kú ‘to’, ‘for’ + ‘in’, ‘at’ or (u ́ +ú), as shown in the two charts: Chart A: Sentence: <áf somáaligu waa áfka úgu fudúd áfaka adúunka> Gloss: Language+Somali + the DM language+the SUPER easy languages-of Trans: world+‘the Somali the language is the easiest language of the world’ Chart B: Sentence: cali waa+uu ugú wèyn +yahay Gloss: Ali DM+ it SUPR old + is Trans: ‘Ali is the oldest’ Numerals All cardinal numbers are nouns. From one to eight, they are feminine, after which they become masculine. Their gender identifications are formed by the definite articles suffixed to them, as shown in the following examples: 71 1. All ordinal numbers are formed by suffixing <-aad> to the cardinal numbers: 1. Determiners Somali determiners are grammatically one part of speech; they are suffixed to nouns. There are four types of determiners: definite articles, demonstratives, interrogatives, and possessives. Somali does not have an indefinite article such as “a” 72 Definite articles: Masculine Feminine <-ka> ‘the’ <-ta> ‘the’ Somali articles have two basic forms: masculine <-ka>‘the’ and the feminie <- ta>‘the’. Each basic form has several variations (allomorphs), as shown below: Demonstratives: Masculine Feminine <-kán>‘this/these’ < -tan>‘this/these’ <-káa(s> ‘that/those’ (further from the <-táa(s)> ‘that/those’ (further from the speaker) speaker) <-kéer> ‘that/those’ (at the middle <-téer>‘that/those’ (at the middle distance<-kóo>‘that/ those’ (in the far distance) distance<-tóo> ‘that/) those’ (in the far distance) Definite articles are suffixed to nouns such as persons and things to define the point of reference or the knowledge of the speaker. Depending on the vowel variation of the definite articles <-a>, <-i>, and <-o>, each has a different meaning: a) spoken of is actually present or seen. 73 b) spoken of is not in the view of the speaker. c) In this chapter is dealing with definite article suffixes with nouns. The determiners show gender agreement but not plural agreement. Saeed (2000, p. 56) noted that “their initial consonants undergo the Sandhi process when attached to stems”. The masculine and the feminine determiner suffixes that begin with <-ka> and <-ta> may undergo changes in a number of cases, as shown by the following examples: a) The suffix initial <-k> remains when the masculine definite article <-k> is attached to any Somali nouns ending with , Indefinite noun Determiner <- Definite noun 1. b) Suffix initial <-k> changes to <-g> when the nouns ends in Indefinite noun Determiner <-ka> Definite noun ̀ 1. 74 c) Suffix initial <-k> changes to <-h> when the nouns ends in the vowels <-e> or <-o> (usually vowel assimilation occurs): Indefinite noun Determiner <-ka> Definite noun 1. <áabe> ‘a father’ ( d) Suffix initial <-k> deleted when the noun ends in or Indefinite noun Determiner <-ka> efinite noun 1. elder’ The feminine determiner suffixes that begin with <-t> also undergo change in a number of cases, as shown in the following examples: e) Suffix initial <-t> changes to <-d> when the nouns ends in Indefinite noun Determiner <– ta> Definite noun (F.) 1. leaders’/‘the chiefs’ 2. history’/‘the dates’ 75 f) Suffix initial <-t> remains unchanged when a noun ends in , Indefinite noun Determiner <-ta> Definite noun feminine) 1. 2. ‘iron’ <-ta> ‘the iron’ g) Suffix initial <-t> changes when a noun ends in <-dh>: Indefinite noun Determiner <-ta> feminine) Definite noun h) Suffix initial <-t> changes to <-sh> when a noun ends in<-l>.in addition,<-l> is deleted., for example: Indefinite noun Determiner <- Definite noun ta> feminine) 1. <úl> ‘a stick’ <-ta> → <- <ús+ha> ‘the stick’ sha> 2. The below chart shows a set of masculine definite determiners <-ka> and feminine definite determiners <-ta> when suffixed to nouns. The determiner’s begining consonant (<-k> in the masculine and <-t>) in feminine undergoes a series of 76 phonological changes depending on the noun’s final consonant (Sandhi rule); as in the chart below: Macsuline definite determiner Feminine definite determiner <-ka> <-ga> <-ha> <-a> <-ta> <-da> <-sha> <-dha> Chapter 5 VERB MORPHOLOGY Before about talking the main divisions of verbs and their morphological grammatical structures, it is essential to draw a brief overview of pronouns and their classes in order understand how they are attached to verbs. This will explain how independent and clitic pronouns are reflected on the roots of positive and negative verbs. Pronouns There are four classes of Somali pronouns: a) personal; b) interrogative; c) demonstrative; and d) possessive pronouns. The following are personal pronouns: Independent pronouns: pronouns that may stand on their own in a sentence. Grammatically they are nouns and they can also be gender marked. Syntactically, pronouns may occur either in the subjective or the objective case. Clitic pronouns: pronouns that do not show the morpho-syntax of nouns (Saeed, 1999). They can only go with a verb or a verbal group. Like the independent pronouns, clitic pronouns can be grouped into two groups: subjective and objective 77 78 pronouns. However, the objective has two subdivisions: first set and second set objective clitic pronouns, as illustrated in the examples below: 6Independent pronouns Clitic pronouns English Somali English Subjective Objective Objective pronoun subjective objective clitic pronoun pronoun pronoun pronoun pronoun First class second I aní+ga me aan i káyclass you (sing.) adí+ga you aad ku káa he/it(sing.) asá+ga him/it uu ∅ ∅ Mshe/. it(sing.) iyá+da her/it ay ∅ ∅ F.you (pl.) idín+ka you aannu (aan) ka kíin we (incl.) inná+ga us aynu ina kéen we (excl.) anná+ga us ay idin kayó they iyá+ga them iyaga ∅ ∅ Examples of independent pronouns: sentences: isa+ka maxay + baa ku dhacay? gloss: you:IPRO + the what + Foc you:CPRO happened trans: ‘you, what has happened to you’ 6 Note: All independent pronouns are masculine in gender except 79 Example of clitic pronouns: Sentences: DM + he went Trans: ‘he went’ By definition, the clitic is a morpheme that has structural characteristics of a word, but shows evidence of being phonologically bound to another word. The below chart shows the shorter version of possessive suffixes for both aboslutive and subjective cases; the only distinction is the occurrence of the stress- pattern: English Masculine Subject Feminine Subject absolutive absolutive my kaý káy taý táy your kaá káa taá táa his kiís kíis tiís tíis her keéd kéed teéd téed our (incl.) keén keen teén téen our (excl.) káyo kayo táyo tayo your (pl.) kiín kiin tiín tíin their koód kóod toód tóod 80 Possessive pronouns: There are two types of possessive pronouns: feminine and masculine. The table below summarizes the formation of possessive suffixes, which consist of the possessive suffix proper plus a definite article suffixes: Person M. F. possessive Pl. possessive pro. English possessive pro Formation Possessive pro. (definitive) (definitive) pro. 1st person ká(definitive)y+ga táy+da kúwayga my 2nd person káa+ga táa+da kúwaaga yours (sing.) 3rd person kíis+a tíis+a kúwiisa his (sing.) M. 3rd person kée+da tée+da kúweeda hers (sing.) F. 1st person káy+ga táy+da kúwayaga our (excl.) 1st person kée+nna tée+nna kúweenna ours (incl.) nd 2 person (pl.) kı́i+ná tíi+na kúwiinna yours 3rd person (pl.) kóo+da tóo+da kúwooda theirs There are other groups of possessive suffixes, used to express position and time, which form common phrases that equate in English as prepositions: 81 Another type of common phrase is formed when possessive suffix are added to numbers, as illustrated in the examples below: There is also a shorter version of common phrases with possessive suffixes formed without adding definite articles, as shown in the examples below: ‘most of’ Verb Structure Somali verbs consist of a root/stem to which affixes are added. Somali is an SOV language, which means the structure order of words is: Subject-Object-Verb Sentence: Trans: ‘a man went’ 82 Verb categories: Somali verbs can be classified in two basic ways: by their morphological structure and by their syntactic relation with other verbs. The largest class is weak verbs, which can be identified by their morphology. This class carries inflectional suffixes and in Somali grammar is known as suffix verb conjugations. The second class consists of strong verbs that take four types of prefixes, as in the examples below: 1. 2. 3. 4. Somali verbs carry an inflection and vowel alternation, which is an ancient Afro-asiatic pattern. Finally, the copula verb ‘I am well’ (literally, one is well) < wàa la fiicànyahay> ‘she is well’ Suffixation patterns in conjugations. A language with polymorphemic word in which the morphemes have well-marked boundaries, as in Somali, is called agglutinating. As a result of this agglutinating process, the Somali language has a morphophonological complexity associated with verbal derivational affixes, which are grouped into three major conjugation patterns as follows: 83 Conjugation 1 (C1): Verbs that denote root verbs with zero lexical affixations, for examlpe. Verb + zero suffix = Conjugation 1(C1) Conjugation 2A (C2A): Verbs are formed by adding the suffix <-i/-si> to the root or basic verb. When the vowel <-i> is suffixed, it makes a basic verb into causative verb, e.g., The summary of Conjugation 2A (C2A): Verb + <-i/-si > suffix = Conjugation 2A (C2A) Conjugation2B (C2B): These verbs are formed by suffixing <-ee/-ayn> to nouns and adjectives. Some examples of Conjugation 2B verbs are the following: Adjective Suffix Causative verb Meaning reduce’ The summary of Congujation 2B: Adjective or Noun + < -ee/ -ayn> suffix = Causative and Factitive verbs 84 Conjugation 3A (C3A): The suffix <-so> is added to the verb root to indicate the middle voice, e.g., ‘cook/boil’, Summary table of Conjugation 3A: Verb root + suffix <-os> = Conjugation3A(C3A) Conjugation3B (C3B): This conjugation is the same as in C3A, but theverb is governed by the phonological stem of contraction and the Sandhi rule that we discussed in Capter 2, for example, The summary of conjugation 3B: Verb root + suffix <-o> = Conjugation 3B (C3B) Saeed (1999) formulated a basic schema which represents the morphological structure of suffix verbs as [ROOT ─ LEX ─ AGR ─ INFL], where Root is the base form; LEX stands for the type of derived verb, for example, <-si> a causative suffix; AGR represents an affix that shows agreement with a subject nominal; and INFL represents the inflection’s ending, which identifies the tense type. For example: 85 Chart A: Sentenc Chart B: Sentence: DM+we: excl.drink Trans: ‘we drank/have drunk’ Chart C: Sentence: DM+ she eats Trans: ‘she eats’ Chart D: Sentence: 7 Note that 86 Table E: Sentence: The verb (2sing.3sing.F. and 2pl.), combine with inflectional suffixes <-ay>/<-een> and <-aa> /<-aan>, to distinguish five personal forms, though it is seen that it may be extended to an eight-person distinction by the use of subject pronouns, as in the below examples: 87 Person Full form (Clitic Present Present Past Past pronoun pro) tense tense tense tense Somali English Somali English I aní+ga aan cúnaa I eat cúnay I ate you (sing.) adí+ga aad cúntaa you eat cúntay you ate he/it (M.) isá+ga uu cúnaa he eats cúnay he ate she/it (F.) iyá+da ay cuntaa she eats cúntay she ate we (excl.) anná+ga aannu cúnnaa we eat cúnnay we ate we (incl.) inná+ga aynu cúnaa we eat cúnnay we ate you ( pl.) idín+ka aydin cúntaan you eat (pl.) cúnteen you ate they iyá+ga ay cúneen they eat cúntaan they ate Prefix verbs (second class of verb morphology). There are five prefix verbs in the Somali language; they are also known as root-changing verbs because the person marked is added as a prefix. The five verbs are as follows: Here is a Conjugation of the prefix verb 88 Prefix verb < yahay> ‘to be’ is considered as third class and differ in tense. The distinction is marked by a vowel change in the root. Saeed (1999) showed an essay schematic form which clearly describes the essence of the root-changing effect, as illustrated in the following examples: The underlined bold <-n> is used as both prefix and suffix. At the same time, it shows the root change and tense distinction: [ AGR + Root ] [Where AGR stands for agreement and Root stands for the verb]. The verb Person Full form Clitic Present (‘I Simple past (‘I pronoun pronoun know’) knew’) I aní+ga aan aqaán iqiín you (sing.) adí+ga aad taqaán tiqiín he/it (M.) isá+ga uu yaqaán yiqiín she/it (F.) iyá+da ay taqaán tiqiín we (excl.) anná+ga aannu naqaán niqiín we (incl.) inná+ga aynu naqaán niqiín you (pl.) idín+ka aydin taqaánniin tiqiíneen they iyá+ga ay yaqaániin yiqiínneen 89 Verbal Inflection Categories Inflectional morphology of verbs includes the following verbal categories: Tense: Present/Past//Future Aspect: Simple/Progressive/Habitual Mood: Declarative/Imperative/Optative/Potential/Conditional Negation: Positive/Negative Sentence subordination: main and subordinate clause Tense Tense is a grammatical category that shows the relation between the action and the state described by the verb and the time. Somali uses conjugations to indicate tenses. Present tense. The present refers to an action which may or may not be happening at present. It also may be used to express something that happens habitually or repeatedly. The present tense inflectional morpheme in English is <-s>, whereas the Somali inflectional morpheme is <-aa>. In general, the present tense has two meanings: present tense with dynamic verbs show a habitual or repeated action which still happens at the time of speaking, clauses with stative verbs express a state of feeling at the time, e.g., “the dynamic Here are some examples of two verbs 90 Person Full form Clitic Verb Inflectional Present verb pronoun Pronoun stem suffix formed I aní+ga aan keén <-aa> keénaa you (sing.) adí+ga aad keén <-taa> keéntaa he/it (sing.M.) isá+ga uu keé́n <-aa> keénaa she/it (sing.F.) iyá+da ay keen <-taa> keéntaa we anná+ga aynu keén <-naa> keénaa you (pl.) idín+ka aydin keén <-taan> keéntaan they iyá+ga ay keén <-aan> keénaan Person Full form Clitic Verb Inflectional Present verb pronoun Pronoun stem suffix formed I aní+ga aan karí <-aa> kariyaa you (sing) adí+ga aad karí <-taa> karisa he/it (sing.M.) isá+ga uu karí <-aa> karíyaa she/it (sing.F.) iyá+da ay kari <-taa> karísaa we anná+ga aynu karí <-naa> kainnaa you (pl.) idín+ka aydin karí <-taan> karísaan they iyá+ga ay karí <-aan> karíyaan Simple past tense. This tense refers a completed action in the past, for example, 91 Person Full form Clitic Verb Inflectional Past verb English pronoun Pronoun stem suffix formed I anì+ga aan keén <-ay> keénay I brought you adì+ga aad keén <-tay> keéntay you (sing.) brought he/it isá+ga u keén <-ay> keénay he/it (sing.M.) brought she/it iyá+da ay keén <-tay> keéntay she/it (sing.F.) brought /it we (pl.) anná+ga aynu keén <-nay> keénnay we brought you (pl.) iyá+ga aad keén <-teen> keénteen you brought they idín+ka ay keén <-een> keéneen they brought The prefix verb Person Full form Clitic Prefix/person Verb Suffix Past verb pronoun Pronoun marker stem ending formed I aní+ga aan <-zero> iqiín <-⊘> iqiín you (sing.) adí+ga aad <-t> iqiin <-⊘> tiqiín he (sing.M.) asá+ga uu <-y> iqiin <-⊘> yiqiin she (sing.F.) iyá+da ay <-t> iqiin <-⊘> tiqiin we anná+ga aynu <-n> iqiin <-⊘> niqiin you (pl.) idin+ka aad <-t> iqiin <-neen> tiqiinneen they iyá+ga ay <-y> iqiin <-neen> yiqiinneen 92 Summary chart of prefix verb: Pronoun + prefix + stem verb + tense ending Future tense. The future tense is formed with the infinitive form of main verb and the present tense. Plus Person Full Clitic Infinitive Tense Person Suffix Appro- form Pronoun verb maker marker ending priate pronou form of n he isá+ga uu dhisi doon <-⊘> <-naa> doonaa (sing.M. she) iyá+da ay dhisi doon <-t> <-taa> doontaa (sing.F.) we anná+ aynu dhisi doon <-n> <-naa> doonnaa ga you (pl.) idín+ka aad dhisi doon <-t> <-taan> doontaan they iyá+ga ay dhisi doon <-⊘> <-aan> doonaan 93 Therefore, the following manner: Summary chart of future tense: Pro + Verb Future tense Aspect Aspect is an internal structure of tense which carries information about whether the action is seen as complete or incomplete, habitual or a single occurrence, as in the following examples: a) b) Present progressive. This tense is used for actions that are currently happening or in the process of happening at the time of speaking. It may also be used for actions that may happen in the near future, as in, The below table explains the basic construction of present progressive in (C1) of the verb <-ay/-n/-s> and the endings of the present tense inflection suffix <-aa>, as shown in the below examples: 94 Person Full form Clitic Verb Progressive Suffix Verb form pronoun Pronoun stem marker I aní+ga aan keén <-ay> <-aa> keénayaa you adí+ga aad keén <-ay> <-saa> keénaysaa (sing.) he asá+ga uu keé́n <-ay> <-aa> keénayaa (sing.M.) <-ay> she iyá+da ay keé́n <-ay> <-saa> keénaysaa (sing.F.) we (pl.) anná+ga aynu keén <-ay> <-naa> keénaynaa you (pl.) idín+ka aad keén <-ay> <-saan> keénaysaan they iyá+ga ay keén <-ay> <-aan> keénayaan Summary chart: Pro+ stem verb + progressive marker (<-ay/-n/-s>) + tense suffix <-aa> = Progressive tense Suffixverbs (Positive form): Person Full form Clitic (C1) (C2) (C3) pronoun pronoun I aní+ga aan súgayaa karínayaa joogsáanayaa you (sing.) adí+ga aad súgeysaa karíneysaa joogsáneysaa he (sing.M.) isá+ga uu súgeyaa karíneyaa joogsáneyaa she (sing.F.) iyá+da ay súgeysaa karíneysaa joogsáneysaa we (pl.) anná+ga aynu súgeynaa karíneynaa joogsánaynaa you (pl.) idín+ka aad súgeysaan karíneysaan joogsáneysaan they iyá+ga ay súgeyaan karíneyaan joogsánayaan 95 Suffixverbs (negative form): Uncontracted negative formation The formation of the negative suffix verbs is shown in the below chart: Person Full form Clitic (C1) (C2) (C3) pro. pro. I aní+ga aan súgi maayó karín maayó joogsán maayó you (sing.) adí+ga aad súgi maysó/ karín joogsán sugi maysíd maysó/ maysó karín joogsan maysíd maysı́d́ he (sing.M.) isá+ga uu súgi maayo karín maayó joogsán maayó she (sing.F.) iyá+da ay súgi maysó karín maysó joogsan maysó́ we (pl) anná+ga aynu súgi mayno karín maynó joogsán maynó you (pl.) idín+ka aad súgi maysàan karìn joogsán maysàan maysàan they iyá+ga ay súgi maayàan karı́ǹ joogsan maayaan maayàan 96 Summary chart: Pronoun + stem verb + negative marker Suffix negative form Prefix verbs: The infinitive prefix is used to express as base for the progressive aspect. “When this verb P.171). However, the meaning of < aqoón> ‘to know’ is ‘I recognize’, ‘you recognize’ and so on, as shown in the below example: Prefixal verbs (positive form): Person Full form Clitic Verb Progres- Inflectional Verb form pronoun pronoun stem sive suffix present marker progressive I aní+ga aan aqoón <-ay> <-aa> aqoónayaa you(sing.) adí+ga aad aqoón <-ay> <-taa> aqoónaysaa he/it isá+ga uu aqoón <-ay> <-aa> aqoónayaa (sing.M.) she/it iyá+da ay aqoón <-ay> <-taa> aqoónaysaa (sing.F.) we (pl.) anná+ga aynu aqoón <-ay> <-naa> aqoónaynaa you (pl.) idín+ka aad aqoón <-ay> <-taan> aqoónaysaan they iyá+ga ay aqoón <-a> <-aan> aqoónayaan 97 Summary chart: Pronoun + stem verb + progressive marker <-ay> + <-n / -s-> + tense ending <-aa> = Present progressive Prefixal verbs (negative form): Orwin (1995) indicated that the negative form of the present progressive is formed the same way as the positive prefix verb form, except for the addition of the negative words < odhán máysó> ‘she is not saying’ Also, we will see when I ḿaodhánayó we ḿa odhanaynó you (sing.) ḿaodhánaysó/síd you (pl.) ḿa odhánaysáan he (M.) ḿa odhánayó they ḿaodhánayáan she (F.) ḿa odhánaysó 98 Past progressive. The past progressive is formed the same way as present progressive except that the inflectional past is used; it expresses actions that were continuous at some time in the past. For example: Suffix verb (positive form): Person Full form Clitic Verb progressive Inflectional Verb form pronoun pronoun stem marker suffix in past progressive I aní-ga aan keén <-ay> <-ay> keénayay you (sing.) adí+ga aad keén <-ay> <-t8ay> keénaysay he isá+ga uu keén <-ay> <-ay> keénayay she iyá+da ay keén <-ay> <-tay> keénaysay we anná+ga aynu keén <-ay> <-nay keénaynay you (pl.) idín+ka aad keén <-ay> <-teen> keénayseen they iyá+ga ay keén <-ay> <-een> keénayeen Prefix verb (positive form): The past continous is the same as the conjugated verbs except for the prefix form verb, as shown in the below example: 8 Note: the inflectional suffix <-t> changes to <-s> as shown in the above verb form in past progressive. 99 Person Full Clitic Verb Progressive Inflectional Verb formed form pronoun stem marker suffix in the past pronoun I ani-gá aan aqoón <-ay> <-ay> aqoónayay you adí+ga aad aqoón <-ay> <-tay> aqoónaysay (shein g.) isá+ga uu aqoón <-ay> <-ay> aqoónayay she iyá+da ay aqóon <-ay> <-tay> aqoónaysay we anná+ga aynu aqoón <-ay> <-nay> aqoónaynay you idin+ka aad aqoón <-ay> <-teen> aqoónayseen (pl.)they iyá+ga ay aqoón <-ay> <-een> aqoónayeen Summary chart of the past continous tense: Verb stem + Progressive marker (<-ay/-na>) + tense suffix <-ay> = Past progressive Habitual Present (Positive Form) This tense/aspect form expresses habitual or repeated action in the present tense. Unlike the habitual past, the auxiliary verb 9 Note: in habitual present tense, the auxiliary 100 Person Aux. C1 C2 C3 I kár/ jíra keéni káraa kárin karaa Joogsán /jíraa /jı́raá karaa/jíraa?? you (sing.) kar/ jíra keéni kárin joogsán kártaa/jírtaa kartaa/jirtaa kartaa/jirtaa he kár/ jíra keéni kárin karaa/jiraa joogsán karaa/jiraa karaa/jiraa she kár/ jíra keéni kárin joogsán kartaa/jirtaa kartaa/jirata kartaa/jirataa we kár/jíra keé́ni karnaa kárin karna joogsán karnaa you (pl.) kár/jíra keéni kartaan kárin kartaan joogsán karnaa they kár/jíra keéni kareen kárin kareen joogsán kareen Habitual Past This aspect is used to express a repeated or a habitual action in the past which is completed or no longer occurs. The verb used to see him’ cook’ 101 Person Aux. C 1 C 2 C 3 I jíray keéni jíray kárin jíray joogsán jíray you (sing.) jíray keéni jíray kárin jírtay joogsán jírtay he jíray keéni jíray kárin jíray joogsán jíray she jíray keéni jírtay kárin jírtay joogsán jíray we jíray keéni jírnay kárin jírnay joogsán jírnay you (pl.) jíray keéni jírteen kárin jírteen joogsán jírteen they jíray keéni jíreen kárin jíreen joogsán jíreen Habitual Past (Negative Form) This construction is formed by the unchanged verb form (invariable form) preceeded by a negative marker 102 Person Full Clitic Neg. C1 C2 C3 form pronoun marker pronoun I aní+ga aan má keeni jirin karín jirin joogsán jirin you adí+ga aad má keeni jirin karín jirin joogsán jirin (sing.) he/it isá+ga uu má keeni jirin karín jirin joogsán jirin (sing.) M. she/it iyá+da ay má keeni jirin karín jirin joogsán jirin (sing.) F. we anná+ga aynu má keeni jirney karín jirin joogsán jirin you idiń+ka aad má keeni jirin karín joogsán jirin (pl.) jirteen they iyá+ga ay má keeni jirin karín jirin joogsán jirin Summary chart: Pronoun + negative marker + infinitive main verb + Aux past = Habitual past (negative form) Mood The mood of a verb expresses the attitude of the speaker about what is being said. There are five basic moods in the Somali language: a) Declarative b) Imperative c) Optative 103 d) Potential e) Conditional Declarative mood. A declarative sentence simply makes a statement. It consists of a subject and a predicate. In Somali, declarative sentences are classified into three groups according to their ability to mark tense: a) Declarative without focus marker: this type of declarative sentence is marked by a mood classifier instead of a focus marker. As Andrzejewski (1975) stated, complementary distribution with focus markers , Sentence: b) Declarative with focus: Somali, as with other Cushitic languages like Rendile (Oomen 1978), Boni (Sasse, 1981), and Diyrayta (Hayward & Saeed, 1984), uses special words to identify words in focus. In Somali, there are three focus words :< bàa>, 104 Sentence: Sentence: <ín uu dílayo ayàan árkayey> Gloss: that + he is:killing Foc + I see:am Trans: ‘I see that he is killing’ c) Verbless declarative: The mood classifer declarative sentence when it occurs alone between the NP and the predicative NP. For example: Sentence: Sentence: Sentence: 105 Imperative mood. This form is used for making requests, giving commands and giving orders, as illustrated in the example below: Imperative: Suffix verbs (positive form): This form of imperative mood deals with the verb in three conjugations, as Person C1 C2A C2B C3A C3B Singular súg kári samèe joogsó qaadó ́ formPlural form súga karíya saméeya joogsá da qáata Suffix verbs (negative form): The negative imperative form takes the sentence particle marker 106 Person C1 C2A C2B C3A C3B Singular ha súgin ha kárin ha samáyn ha joogsán qaadán formPlural form ha ha karinína ha samyní ha joogsanína ha sugína na qaadanína Prefix verbs (positive form): The imperative of prefix verbs is not same as the imperative of the suffix verbs, because they are irregular verbs and therefore, they behave in a number of different ways. Saeed stated (2000) that the verb form of Pronoun Prefix verb (negative form): Pronoun Pro. (pl.) 107 Optative mood. This mood expresses wishes, hopes, or curses. Here are two common uses of mood: a) Mood that expresses wishes and hopes; b) Mood that entails curses or blessings, as seen in the below examples: This construction of mood, given in the below table, shows the three conjugation classes for the verbs Affirmation in the optative mood (suffix verbs, positive form): Person Full form pro. Clitic pro. (C1) (C2) (C3) I ani+ga an súgo karíyo joogsádo you (sing.) adí+ga ad súgtid karísid joogsátid he isá+ga há súgo karíyo joogsádo she iyá+da há súgto karíso joogsáto we (excl.) inná+ga aanu súgno karínno joogsanno we (incl.) anná+ga aynu súgn karínno joogsánno you (pl.) idín+ka ad súgteen karíseen joogsáteen they iyá+ga há súgeen karíyeen joogsádeen 108 Negation in the opatative mood: The negative marker (NM) person Neg. marker + Clitic (C1) (C2) (C3) pronoun I yáan +an súgin karín joogsán you (sing.) yáan +ad sugín karín joogsán he yáan + u sugín karín joogsán she yáan + ay sugín karín joogsán we (excl.) yáan + an(u) sugín karín joogsán we (incl.) yáy +nu sugín karín joogsán you (pl.) yáan +ad sugín karín joogsán they yáan +ay sugín karín joogsán Potential. Potential is a mood that expresses possibilities. It has a sentence marker < shów/sów keenteé> ‘perhaps/maybe you bring’ 109 Person Marker Verb stem Suffix Verb form I sów/shów keen <-ee> keenee you (sing.) sów/shów keen <-tee> keentee he sów/shów keen <-ee> keenee she sów/shów keen <-tee> keentee we sów/shów keen <-nee> keenee you (pl.) sów/shów keen <-teen> keenteen they sów/shów keen <-een> keeneen There are some other ways to express ‘maybe’or ‘perhaps’ in Somali language. For example: a) b) c) Conditional. Conditional sentences express hypothetical circumstances which could be in the present or past. The verb used in the conditional mood is an infinitive followed by an adjective ‘having’ or possessing’, as illustrated in the below examples: 110 Person Full form pronoun Clitic pronoun Verb Adjective In the negative form, the negative marker Person Negative marker Verb stem Suffix Verb form I má/aan keén <-eén> keeneén you (sing.) má/aan keén <-teén> keeteén he má/aan keén <-eén> keeneén she má/aan keén <-teén> keenteén we má/aan keén <-neén> keenneén you (pl.) má/aan keén <-teén> keenteén they má/aan keén <-eén> keeneén 111 Sentence Subordinate Clause (Main/Subordinate) By definition, the main clause of a sentence is called an independent clause because it consists of a subject and a verb and makes complete sense. The subordinate clause of a sentence is called a dependent clause. It begins with subordinate conjunctions or relative pronouns and consists of a verb and a subject, but needs additional information to complete the sense or thought. As Orwin (1995, p. 187) described, the word ‘I saw the book, which Ahmed took’ ‘I saw the book which Ahmed took’ However, there are several ways to form subordinate clauses in Somali. Orwin (1995) categorized these into two possible occurrences according to their syntactic constructions. 1. A relative clause verb forms when the head noun is not the subject of the relative clause. There are two secnerios for such clauses: a) When the head noun plus the relative clause is not the head noun (main subject): the following sentences show when the head noun + relative clause is not the subject of the sentence: 112 ínannku ku shaqynayó> that the boy is working with’ cabtay> milked’ b) When the head noun plus the relative clause is the subject of the sentence: ‘the truck which he boarded broke down’ ‘the goat which he is bringing will eat it’ Compare the above examples with the following sentences in which head noun plus the relative clause is not the subject of the sentence: doonaa > 2. A relative clause verb forms when the head noun is the subjectof the relative clause. Similarly, there are two possible ways for this to occur: c) When the head noun + relative clause is not the subject of the sentence: d) When the head noun + relative clause is the subject of the sentence: 113 Finally, Saeed (1999:208) found that there are different characteristics that distinguish subordinate clauses from main clauses: 1) Main sentence types found in main clause- interrogative, imperative, optative, etc.are not found in subordinate clauses. 2) The declarative marker example: a) Sentence: b) Sentence: <*Ahmed - yimid> Gloss: Sentence Ahmed no DM came Trans: ‘Ahmed came’ : The example above (b) is an ungrammatical sentence because it lacks any declarative marker. Every main clause must contain one and only one focus marker (, clauses. There are two (and only two) grammatically acceptable ways to correct it, as illustrated in the following examples: 114 c) Sentence: d) Sentence: <*Axmed - yimid> Gloss: Ahmed no: Foc came Trans: ‘Ahmed came’ The example above (d) is an ungrammatical sentence because it lacks thefocus marker marker e) Sentence: 1) The negative marker clause, but is replaced by following examples: f) Sectence: 115 g) Sentence: <* odayga af ingriisiga ku ma hadlin waad argtay> Gloss: old man + the tongue English in not speak you: 2sing. saw:PAST Trans: ‘you saw the old man who does not speak English’ The same process is applied when a negative subordinate occurs at the beginning of the relative clause>. It may be negated only by using the negative marker sentences illustrate: h) Sectence: i) Sectence: <*in Farax ma imaanin waan rabbaa> Gloss: that farax not come I want Tran: ‘I do not want Farax to come’ ( Literally: that Farah not come I want) j) Sentence: 116 To sum up, a negative subordinate clause is formed by replacing the negative marker Derivational Morphology of Somali Verbs In derivational morphology of verbs, the derivation of verbs from nouns and verbal stems will be discussed. Verbs derived from nouns. Inchoative verbs are derived by suffixing <-ow/- oob> to a noun (N), forming an intransitive verb meaning ‘to become N’. For example: Noun Suffix Derived verb 1. As Saeed (1999) presented, the affix has two allomorphs: <-ow> occurs before a consonant or the end of a word, whereas <-oob> occurs before a vowel, as illustrated in the below examples: A) Sentence: Gloss: DM+ it: M cold + INCH + 3sing. M: PAST Trans: ‘It (M) became to cold or it (M) froze’ 117 B) Sentence: Gloss: DM+he: M old + INCH+ 3sing. M: PAST Trans: ‘he (M) became to an old’ Verbs derived from adjectives. The affix <-ow/aan> is added to adjectives to derive intransitive verbs that mean ‘becomes adjective state.’ These impersonal verbs are not conjugated with any personal pronouns except with “it”: Adjective Suffix Derived Verb 1. ow/aan> Summary chart: Adjective + suffix <-ow/ -aan> = Derived Verb Derived experiencial verbs (EXP V). Another suffix, <-ood> is added to form a derived intransitive verb when attached to nouns describing a state of experience: Noun Suffix Derived verb 1. affair’ ood> 118 Summary chart: Noun + suffix <-ood> = Derived experiencial Verb (EXP V) Derived factive verbs (FACT V). The suffix <-ays> forms verbs from both nouns and adjectives. Saeed (1999, p. 136) writes that the suffix <-ays> has several allomorphs. It has the principal forms is <-ee> in the imperative. However, it changes to <-ayn> or <-eyn> in the infinitive form: Noun Suffix Derived factitive verbs 1. Summary chart: Noun + suffix <-ee> = Derived factitive verb In some cases, the derived factitive verbs show a state of accomplishment/achievement: 119 Adjective Suffix Derived factitive verbs 1. Summary chart: Adjective + Suffix <-ee> = Derived factitive verb Causative derive dverbs (CAUS V). There are two suffixes that create causative derived verbs.The first is <-i> which changes an intransitive verb to a transitive verb. This suffix <-i> means to “casue/accomplish.” Verb (TRN.) Suffix Derived verb (INTRN.) 1. The second causative affix is <-sii>, which can be suffixed to both intransitive (INTRN) and transitive (TRN) verbs. This suffix is mostly attached to activity verbs, provided the subject of the sentence is [+ an animate], as illustrated in the below examples: 120 Sentence: Gloss: boy + the eat caus: IMPERATIVE rice + the Trans: ‘ make the boy eat the rice’ Sentence: <Àxmed ayàa wiila+shii cun+síiyey Gloss: Ahmed Foc boys + the ate: caus: 3Sing: PAST rice bariìs+kii> + the Trans: ‘Ahmed made the boys to eat the rice’ Passive voice. Basically, Somali does not have a definite syntactic formation, but some constructions are formed when the affix <-am10> is added to causative verbs, as shown in the below examples: a) Sentence: Gloss: Axmed door + the Foc + he open + Past Trans: Ahmed opened the door’ b) Sentence: 10 In the above examples, a) shows a passive voice whereas b) shows middle voice. Saeed has the suffix <-am>, but in my dialect the suffix is <-m>. 121 Secondly, the non-person pronoun/non-specific pronoun <-la> ‘someone’ is used to form a passive construction when it occurs between the head noun and the predicate. For example: c) Sentence: Trans: ‘the lion was killed by someone’ d) Sentencs: Gloss: bag + the DM someone steal + PAST Trans: ‘the bag was stolen by someone’ The below listed casuative root verbs may form derived passives (where word ending m → n): Verb Reduplications Plural intensive verbs express emphatic, intensified, or repeated action and are formed by a complete reduplication of the stem verb. As Saeed (1987) stated, reduplication in Somali literature is basically a copying of the first syllable of the singular form on to the the beginning of the singular to form the plural. 122 Morphologically it is described as a reduplication of linguistic constituents (i.e., words stem, and root). All these verbs belong to (C1). Full reduplication involves a duplication of the entire syllable or word, as shown in the below example: Singular verb Reduplication/Plural verbs 1. Summary chart: Copying of the first syllable + the beginning of the singular form = plural verb Middle voice In English, the middle voice is voice which describes the subject doing an action for himself/herself. It is usually expressed with reflexive pronouns as in the examples below: 123 a) Ahmed killed Ali Active voice b) Ali was killed by Ahmed Passive voice c) Ahmed killed (himself) Middle voice Jeffrey explaining this English structure: “In form, middle voice sentences, unlike passives, are not signaled by any special grammatical morphemes. They are marked by the intransitive use of a basically transitive verb” (1995, p. 184). In Somali, the middle voice is derived when suffix is added to a verb stem, creating middle verb. The verb stem is often a causative verb. For example, adding the suffix <-o> to the cassuative verb As Saeed (1999) noted, there are several forms of middle voice affixation: An imperative is suffixed by <-o>; as in An infinitive is suffixed by<-an>; as in In any other cases the affix <-at> become <-ad> before a vowel; Many Somali authors have studied the literature describing the affixation of middle voice verbs have given them different linguistic names. Moreno (1955) classifies some as riflessivo, Burno (1984) medio-riflessivo; Andrzejwski (1968) and Plugliell (1984) both gave the same label of autobenefactive and Saeed called it middle voice. According to Saeed (1999), there are six types of middle voice in Somali verbs: 1) Reflexive action: this denotes that the subject acts as an agent of the action or by doing the action for one’s own benefit: 124 Stem verb Suffix Derived middle voice 1. sure’ 2) Body action (movement): This denotes middle voices that affect body gesture, posture movement it is formed by adding the suffix <-o/-so> to the verb stem, as shown in the below examples : Stem verb Suffix Derived middle voice 1. 3) Emotional state: This middle verb expresses the emotionality of the subject: Stem verb Suffix Derived middle voice 1. 4) Reciprocal: As Saeed (1999) described this type of middle verb expresses actions that are reciprocal and at the same time shows bi-directional activities, for example, 125 oral riddle’. The sentence below describes the reciprocal activity used by middle verbs with the reciprocal pronoun: Sentence: Trans: ‘they killed each other’ There is a certain group of reciprocal verbs which mainly describe becoming a family unit or arriving at unity, and they are transitive verbs: 1. 3. 5) In voluntary state of change: As Saeed (1999) stated some middle verbs express an involuntary state of change where the subject (animate/inanimate) has no control at all. For example: 1. 4. 6) Autobenefactive: These verbs express actions which are productive and also beneficial to the subject. This type of middle verb is very common in 126 Somali, where middle affixation reflects that the doer (subject) does the action of the verb for his or her benefit; thus, these are called autobenefactive middle verbs: Stem verb Mid.voice suffix Middle verbs 1. <-o> Summary table: Stem verb + suffix <-o/-so> = Imperative middle verb In summary, Somali is an agglutinative language that uses a number of affixations and particles to agree on and change the meaning of words. Morphologically, verbs consist of a stem or root to which affixes are added. Basically, Somali verbs are divided into two classes. The first class, weak verbs carry inflectional suffixes. In Somali verbs there are suffixes that maybe added to the basic form verbs in order to alter the meaning in some predictable way. This process is known as verb Conjugation. For example, 127 Conjugation 2 (C2) is formed by adding the suffix <-i> to the basic form, for example, when <-i> added to to the verb The second group of verbs, known as strong verbs consists of a small number that take prefix. Verbs are inflected in four tenses: present, past, present progressive, and past progressive, in addition to a subjective mood form for present and future tenses. In derivational morphology, verbs are derived from nouns, adjectives and verbal stems. There are four types of moods in Somali verbs: imperative, potential, optative, and conditional.In addition, there are three voices in Somali verbs: active voice, passive voice and middle voice. Chapter 6 IMPLICATIONS AND FINDINGS In the previous chapters, aspects of Somali Phonology and Morphology have been briefly outlined. The discussion began with Somali consonants, vowels, stress patterns, and tonal features. The entire study is aimed at giving ESL/ ELL teachers a brief background of Somali phonology and morphology in order to help them understand aspects of Somali structures. With this background, they may be able understand issues of transfer when their Somali students speak or write. Even though I am a native Somali speaker; I have not studied my language in any formal way, but rather I studied it in a self-oriented way. As a result, I cannot consider myself a Somali language expert. I have language competence compared to non-native speakers. My personal weaknesses have been originated by reliance on the previous linguistic literature written by Somali experts such as Saeed, B. W. Andrzejewski, Krik, and Martin Owrin. The research of Somali is only in its beginnings, even though the language is rich and well known for its poets and proverbs: it is known as the “language of poets.” In spite of the caveats, my research has shown that transfers between Somali and English may be anticipated not only phonologically but morphologically as well. An understanding of transfer in second Language Acquisition is vital. Gass and 128 129 Slinker (2001, pp. 65-66.) noted that “The acceptance and/or rejection of language transfer as a viable concept has been related to the acceptance or rejection of the specific theory with which it has been associate”. In order to better understand the notion of language transfer, it is very important to address the idea of contrastive analysis of the native language and the target language (CAH). This entails comparing L1 and TL in order to find their similarities and differences. There are two types of language transfer. One is positive (also known as facilitator/correct) and the other is negative (also known as interference). My research led me to conclude that there are several areas of negative transfers. Inflectional Mistakes (Negative Transfer) There are many differences in the grammatical rules of Somali and English that can make learning English difficult. For instance, the tense/aspect inflection of Somali verbs may pose difficulties for Somali English Language Learners. John Saeed (1999, p. 79) stated “Verbs as a category are identified by the tense, aspect and mood information they carry, which are signaled largely by affixes, but also vowel alteration and accentual patterns.” Verbs can be subcategorized in two intertwined (intersecting) ways: by their morphological formation and by their structural (syntactic) relationship with other verbs. However, three classes of verbs are governed by their morphology. The largest group is defined by its inflectional suffix; these are also known as “weak” verbs. Then there are four prefix (or strong) verbs: 130 that was completed in the past. The tense markers of verbs in Somali are represented with the inflections: This could be confusing to learners of English, because English does not inflect of verbs according to gender or number, except in the third person singular, such as A. The student writer showed the correct inflection on the verb B. These samples begin to show the common pattern followed by students. They skip the parts of English morphology that are confusing. When unsure about how to show the inflection of the verb, these students left the verb in the simple form. 131 Another difference in verb inflection between Somali and English is the use of double past tense verbs (Somali nominal past). This phenomenon is found in the English writing by Somali students, because Somali has nominal tense morphemes. This means that the tense is carried on the nouns, which are not a subset of the tense forms that appear in verbs. There are some illustrative examples of nomial predicates: 1. Sentence: Gloss: Problem- the Gulf-Det [+nom] still permanent is Trans: ‘the crisis in the Gulf still persists’ 2. Sentence: Gloss: Problem- the [past] Gulf- the [+nom] ended [+past] Trans: ‘The crisis inthe Gulf has ended’ (Lecarme, 2002) When writing in English, Somali writers make the mistake of writing two verbs in the past tense. The following example came from writing samples of a high school student; it was in response to the essay question, “What did you do last summer?” 132 C. The student correctly used the past tense form of the verb The use of double verbs in past tense sentences is a direct result of the double tense markers in Somali. Phonological Challenges In this section I will focus on negative phonetic/phonological transfer without going into details. I will only mention sounds that are most troublesome to Somali speakers. Somali ELL (English language Learner) students encounter several morphological difficulties while acquiring English as a second language (L2): 1. There is no real distinction between the voiced /b/ bilabial stop and the voiceless /p/ bilabial stop. So, spelled as 2. The past tense morpheme [-ed] is pronounced as [-id] irrespective of whether it should be pronounced [t] or [d]. 3. Somali ELL students face a great deal of confusion both in the spelling and the pronunciation of and no difference in spelling or pronunciation; e.g., 133 4. Similarly, the grapheme encounter it, they tend to pronounce is [s ]. 5. The grapheme two completely different sounds. If a Somali student encounters the word [ʕɔʟ] it sounds to non-native speakers that there is not consonant at the beginning of the word, < call> sounds like [ɔʟ]. 6. Consonant cluster simplification is a common problem because the Somali language does not allow consonant clusters. English orthography is oblique, whereas Somali spelling is transparent; that is, every word is pronounced as it is written. For this reason, Somali students tend to pronounce every grapheme they see. Therefore, they would say the following English words: Words Pronouncitions ‘knife' is pronounced as ‘phase’ or Consonant Cluster Simplifications A common error that Somali ELL students make is consonant cluster simplifications because their native language does not allow constant clusters. 134 Therefore, they will simplify clusters when they see them in English. The following English words are typical examples: Consonant cluster Cluster simplifications ‘fifth’ is spelled as Stress and Tone Challenges (Negative Transfer) Stress placement is unpredictable because the Somali language is a tonal language. Therefore, Somali Ell students put stress where no stress is needed, for example, “I cAN do that.” Analyzing Somali ELL writings, conversing with students, and asking their teachers, I found out that Somali speaker add /i/ to the end of words with a voiceless stop /k/ or /t/. I asked the following words to Somali ELL students to test this error (epenthesis): English words Spelling 135 Somali ELL student use epenthesis because their native language has syllable restrictions against final position of /t/, /k/ and /m/, which leads an addition of vowel /i/. In polysyllabic words, Somali ELL students may have problems distinguishing the frontness and the blackness of the vowel, e.g., low front [æ] for bat; and low back [ɑ] for Bob and [ɒ] for bought. Implications English Language Learners from all backgrounds will have unique issues when they begin learning English. As educators, it is our job to realize and understand these issues and adapt our teaching accordingly. One problem for teachers of Somali students is that most people in the United States know very little about Somalia, its people, and its culture, and even less about Somali as a language. A basic knowledge of the Somali language and grammatical rules will make teaching students easier and will, hopefully, lead to greater success of the students. Knowledge about certain sociolinguistic factors is also important when teaching Somali students. Almost all Somali students come from a restricted code environment now that they are living in the United States. As new citizens in the United States, most are from lower income families without access to books and other academic materials. Many Somali parents do not read or write in Somali, and therefore lack an understanding of how writing systems work. Many are struggling to learn English themselves, and others have learned little to no English. This leaves students 136 translating for their parents, rather than receiving outside help from them. Over a long period of time, this may lead to a strong ability and understanding in both languages, but until they have mastered the English language, both languages will suffer, because the students will not have a strong hold on either and will constantly be switching between the two. For students who do have some experience in writing, learning to write in English can be much more difficult, because English has opaque orthography, meaning that the spelling of words is not directly tied to the phonetic representation. The Somali writing system, however, is transparent, meaning the spelling is directly related to the phonetic representation of the words. This leads to difficulty in spelling and pronunciation of English words for students who are already literate in Somali. To understand about Somali student writing in English, knowledge about the findings explained above can help ELL teachers to give extra time and focus on the unique needs of Somali students. Explanations and discussions about understanding phonological and morphological structures are important, because these aspects are widely used in everyday English as well as in academic writing. If these issues are not addressed, it can lead students to avoid using these grammatical units, which will make their English seem “broken.” Ungrammatical usage often causes teachers to question the intelligences of their students.As a result, I believe that the findings in this study will help ELL teachers understand some of the sources of errors made by their Somali students. 137 Conclusion With the large numbers of new citizens from Somalia, the United States has had to make some adaptations, especially in areas with larger numbers of new immigrants, such as Minnesota. Education is a major issue because the systems in the United States are very different from those in Somalia and in refugee camps. Teachers of ESL students will have to adapt their teaching styles and lesson plans to enable them to cater to the unique needs of Somali students. It is hoped that the information in this thesis will help teachers who have Somali students in their classes. REFERENCES 138 REFERENCES Andrzejewski, B. W. (1956). "Grammatical introduction" to: Galaal, Muuse Haaji Ismaa'iil, 1956 Hikmad Soomaali. London: Oxford University Press. Andrzejewski, B. W. (1964). The declensions of Somali nouns. London: School of Oriental and African Studies. Andrejeweski, B. W. (1968). Inflectional Characteristics of the So-called ‘Weak Verbs’ in Somali. African Language Studies, 9, 1-51. London. Andrejeweski, B. W. (1975). The role of indicator particles in Somali." Afroasiatic Linguistics, 1(6), 123-191. Andrejeweski, B. W. (1977). Five years of written Somali: A report on progress and prospects. International African Institute Bulletin, 47, 4-5. Supplement to Africa 4:4. London. Andrejeweski, B. W. (1979). The case system in Somali. Mimeo, School of Oriental & African Studies, University of London. Armstrong, L. (1964). The phonetic structure of Somali. Farnborough: Gregg Press. Banti, G. (1988). Two Cushitic systems: Somali and Oromo nouns. In H. Van der Hulst & N. Smith (Eds.), Autosegmental studies in pitch accent (pp. 11-49). Dordrecht: Foris. 139 140 Bruno, B. (1984). Note sui verbi de derivazione nominale in Somalo. Aspetti morfologici, lessicali e della focalizzazione. Studi Somali, 5, 115-131. Ed. A. Puglielli. Roma: Ministero degli afari esteri—Dipartiemnto per la cooperazione allo sviluppo. Burke, H. (2001). Immunization and the Twin Cities Somali community: Findings from a focus group assessment. Minneapolis, MN: Minnesota Department of Health, Refugee Health Program. Caney, J. (1984). The role of the newspaper and the school text book in the modernisation of Somali vocabulary. In T. Labahm (Ed.), Proceedings of the second international congress of Somali studies. Volume I. Linguistics and literature (pp. 373-378). Hamburg: Helmut Buske. Clements, G. N. (2000). In defense of serialism. The Linguistic Review, 17, 181-197. Gass, S., & Selinker, L. (2001). Second language acquisition: An introductory course. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Haywood, & Saeed. (1984). NP focus in Somali and Dirayta: A comparison of baa and pa. In T. Labahn (Ed.), Proceedings of the second international congress of Somali studies. Volume I: Linguistics and literature (pp. 1-22). Hamburg: Helmut Buske. Hayward, R. J. (2000). Afroasiatic. In B. Heine & D. Nurse (Eds.), African languages: An introduction (PP. 74-98). Cambridge, UK, & New York: Cambridge University Press. 141 Hunter, F. M. (1880). A grammar of the Somali language with an English-Somali, Somali-English vocabulary. Bombay: Byculla Press. Hyman, L. (1981). Tonal accent in Somali. Studies in African Linguistics, 12(2), 169- 203. Hyman, L. (1981). L'accento tonale in somalo. In G. R. Cardona & F. Agostini (Eds.), Studi Somali 1. Fonologia e lessico (pp. 109-139). Kirk, J. W. C. (1905). A grammar of the Somali language, with examples in prose and verse, and an account of the Yibir and Midgan dialects. Cambridge, England. Klingenheben, A. (1949). Ist das Somali eine Ton-Sprache? Zeitschrift fur Phonetik, 5(6), 289-303. Koffi, E. (2010). The pronunciation of <-ED> in coda cluster in Somali-accented English. In J. Levis & K. LeVelle (Eds.), Proceeding of the 1st Pronunciation in Second Language Learning and Teaching Conference, Iwoa State University, September 2009 (pp. 119-134). Ames, IA: Iowa State University. Lidz, J. (1995). Morphological reflexive marking: Evidence from Kananda. Linguistcs Inquiry, 26(4). Lecarme, J. (2002). Gender "polarity": Theoretical aspects of Somali nominal morphology. In P. Boucher (Ed.), Many morphologies (pp. 109-141). Cascadilla Press. Moreno, M. M. (1955). Il Somalo della Somalia: grammatica e testi del Benadir, Darod e Digbil, Rome, Instituto Poligrafico della Stato. 142 Oomen, A. (1978). Focus in the Rendille Clause. SAL, 9, 35-65. Source: Laura Downing, III. Linguistic Bibliography. Guthrie E.71. Orwin, M. (1995). Colloquial Somali—a complete language course. London: Routledge. Puglielli, A. (1984). Derived nouns in Somali; Part 1. In T. Labahn (Ed.), Proceedings of the Second International Congress of Somali Studies (2nd: Hamburg: 1983). Volume I: Linguistics and Literature (pp. 55-68). Hamburg: Helmut Buske. Saeed, J. I. (1993). Somali reference grammar (2nd rev. ed.). Kensington, MD: Dunwoody Press. Saeed, J. I. (1999). Somali. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Sasse, H. J. (1981). “Basic word order” and functional sentense perspective in Boni. – FoL, 15, 253-290. UCLA language materials project. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.lmp.ucla.edu/Profile.aspx?menu=004&LangID=202. Wolf, A. (2002). Does education matter? Myths about education and economic growth. London: Penguin. Vycichl, W. (1956). Zur tonologie des Somali. Rivista degli Studi Orientali XXXI, Roma. APPENDIX 143 144 The Months The Somali year is divided into four seasons: ‘windy season’, Months corresspond to to both Arabic and English, and they are named as follows: Somali Arabic English Dago Moharram January Bil duráh horé Safar Februray Bil duráh dambé Rabia al Awal March Rajal horé Rabia al Akhir April Rajal dhexé Jumad al Awal May Rajal dembé Jumad al akhir June Saboox Rajab july Wàa baris Shabáan August Sakaád /Sòon Rammadàn September Soonfur Shawwáal October Sidataal Dulqáda November Arafo Dul hijjah December (Data taken from Hunter, 1880). The days The names of the days in Somali are borrowed from the Middle east (Arab countries). Somali Arabic English Sunday اﻻﺣ ﺪ Axad Monday اﻻﺛ ﻨ ﯿﻦ Isniin Tuesday اﻟ ﺜﻼﺛ ﺎء Salaaha Wednesday اﻻرﺑ ﻌﺎء Arabca Thrusday اﻟ ﺨﻤ ﯿﺲ Khamiis Friday اﻟ ﺠﻤ ﻌﺔ Jimce Saturday اﻟ ﺴ ﺒﺖ Sabti 145 The Importance of Proverbs Somali has a rich tradition of proverbs and poems, passed on from previous generations and embellished by individual speakers. Proverbs play a very important role in everyday speech. Here is an example of Educational: Aqoon la'aani waa iftiin la'aan.‘Being without knowledge is to be without light’.The reason I selected this proverb is to show how educatuion is so important in Somali culture. [s] [s] [sha] [ɢ] - - [ka]
. It is pronounced very similar to its English counterpart: ‘cow’ ‘take’ ‘secret sign’
‘skin’ ‘crooked’
‘to wet’
‘box’ ‘flee’ <-itaan>
‘kill’ <-itaan>
‘write’ <-itaan>
‘flee’ <-niin>
‘marry’ <-niin>
‘write’ <-e>
‘hide’ <-e>
‘write’ <-aa>
‘write’ <-aal>
‘dig’ <-aal>
‘straps’ are formed by the same process. ‘mode or manner’ 2. ‘manner’ 5. ‘so or and ‘pen/pencils’
‘watch’ ‘pen or pencils’ the
‘nose’ ‘pen/pencil’
‘3’ ,
‘a cow’ (M<-ka.) > → <-a> ‘the female cow’ 2. ,
- -
- - - ‘some of’ ‘half of’
‘wait for’, or ‘take’.
‘wait’, ‘wait!’ ‘perhaps/maybe we bring’ ‘poison’ <-ee> ‘be smoothed’