Sixteenth International Seapower Symposium: Report of the Proceedings
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
U.S. Naval War College U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons International Seapower Symposium Events 10-2003 Sixteenth International Seapower Symposium: Report of the Proceedings The U.S. Naval War College Follow this and additional works at: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/iss Recommended Citation Naval War College, The U.S., "Sixteenth International Seapower Symposium: Report of the Proceedings" (2003). International Seapower Symposium. 1. https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/iss/1 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the Events at U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in International Seapower Symposium by an authorized administrator of U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. SIXTEENTH INTERNATIONAL SEAPOWER SYMPOSIUM Report of the Proceedings Layout for rows 1 and 2: 47 45 43 41 39 37 35 33 31 29 27 25 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 2321191715131197531US 246810121416182022 CNO 1 Kuwait MG Ahmad Y. Al Mulla 2 Panama GEN Jose Antonio Isaza Ros 3 Albania RADM Kudret Celaj 4 Bangladesh RADM Shah Iqbal Mujtaba 5 New Zealand RADM Peter M. McHaffie 6 Sweden RADM Jörgen Eriksson 7 South Africa VADM Johan F. Retief 8 Sri Lanka VADM Daya W. K. Sandagiri 9 Israel VADM Yedidia Ya’ari 10 Italy ADM Marcello de Donno 11 Ghana RADM John Kodzo Gbena 12 Nigeria VADM Samuel Afolayan 13 Chile ADM Miguel Vergara 14 Canada VADM Ronald S. Buck 15 Uruguay ADM Carlos Giani 16 Peru ADM Ricardo Arbocco 17 Romania RADM Victor Blidea 18 Kenya MG P. O. Awitta 19 Poland ADM Roman Krzyóelewski 20 Finland RADM Hans V. Holmstrom 21 Azerbaijan RADM Sultanov 22 Belgium VADM Michel Hellemans 23 Jordan BG Dari Rageb Nofal Alzaben 24 Australia VADM Chris Ritchie 25 Qatar BG Mubarak Ahmed S. A. Al-Mannai 26 Georgia VADM Gigla Zurab Iremadze 27 Thailand VADM Werapon Waranon 28 Pakistan ADM Shahid Karimullah 29 Portugal ADM Francisco Antonio Torres Vidal Abreu 30 Croatia RADM Zdravko Kardum 31 Japan ADM Koichi Furusho 32 Ecuador RADM Victor Hugo Rosero Barba 33 Malta BRIG Rupert Montanaro 34 Singapore RADM Ronnie Tay 35 Philippines VADM Ernesto De Leon 36 Germany VADM Lutz Feldt 37 Korea ADM Jung-Il Moon 38 Netherlands VADM Ruurt A. A. Klaver 39 Bulgaria RADM Emil Ivanov Lyutskanov 40 Yemen BG Ruais Al Mujajwar 41 Dominican Republic VADM Euripides Antonio Uribe Peguero 42 Argentina VADM Jorge Omar Godoy 43 Norway RADM Jan Eirik Finseth 44 Denmark RADM Kurt Birger Jensen SIXTEENTH INTERNATIONAL SEAPOWER SYMPOSIUM Report of the Proceedings 26–29 October 2003 Edited by John B. Hattendorf Ernest J. King Professor of Maritime History Naval War College AVAL OP F N ER O AT F I E O I N H S C I SIXTEENTH N M T U E I R S N O A P T M IO Y N S AL ER SEAPOW U.S. NAVAL WAR COLLEGE NEWPORT,RHODE ISLAND 2004 Editor’s Note The editor has made every attempt to establish a clear and accurate record of the symposium proceedings, one that faithfully records the opinions and views of the participants. In establishing the printed text from speaking notes, transcripts, seminar notes, and tape recordings of speakers or of the official English-language simultaneous translators, the editor has silently corrected slips of grammar, spell- ing, and wording. He has inserted full names and ranks, when omitted by the speaker, and occasionally a word or phrase in square brackets to clarify the text. The editor acknowledges with appreciation the valuable support and assis- tance of Commander Carol Elliott, Deborah Maddix, and the staff of the Naval War College’s Special Events Department; Pelham Boyer, the managing editor of the Naval War College Press; Margaret Richard as copyeditor and lead proofreader with the support of Erin Poe and Kathleen Koegler; Professor John Waghelstein for Spanish translations; Captain Tatsuro Sato for Japanese translations; Jason Peters of the Graphics Department; and Jo-Ann Parks and the JIL Information Systems Academic Support Office. Newport June 2004 J. B. H. Table of Contents Plenary Sessions Chapter 1 Welcoming Remarks Rear Admiral Ronald A. Route, U.S. Navy President, Naval War College ..................................................1 Chapter 2 Keynote Address: Sea Power for Peace, Prosperity, and Security Admiral Vern Clark, U.S. Navy Chief of Naval Operations .......................................................5 Chapter 3 Panel Discussion One: Maritime Coalitions at the Tactical Level Moderator: Rear Admiral Richard B. Porterfield, United States..........................................................................13 Panel: Coordinating Rules of Engagement Vice Admiral Ruurt A. A. Klaver, Netherlands ..............15 C4 Connectivity Vice Admiral Ernesto De Leon, Philippines...................17 Major General Ahmad Yusef Al Mulla, Kuwait ..............20 Force Protection Admiral Marcello de Donno, Italy..................................21 ISR Collaboration Rear Admiral Richard B. Porterfield, United States......24 Discussion .............................................................................29 Chapter 4 Luncheon Address: Maritime Power for the Twenty-First Century Admiral Thomas H. Collins Commandant, U.S. Coast Guard ...........................................41 Discussion .............................................................................47 Chapter 5 Panel Discussion Two: New Operational Challenges of Maritime Security Moderator: Rear Admiral Jan Eirik Finseth, Norway ....................55 Panel: Maritime Interception Vice Admiral Ronald S. Buck, Canada ...........................55 Antipiracy Rear Admiral Ronnie Tay, Singapore ............................63 Port Security Vice Admiral Yedidia Ya’ari, Israel ................................66 Controlling Contraband Admiral Miguel Vergara, Chile ......................................69 Humanitarian Assistance, Nation-Building, and Peacekeeping Rear Admiral Jan Eirik Finseth, Norway........................74 Discussion .............................................................................79 Chapter 6 Panel Discussion Three: Maritime Coalitions at the Tactical Level Moderator: Vice Admiral Chris Ritchie, Australia .........................85 Panel: Enhanced Military Readiness Admiral Shahid Karimullah, Pakistan............................85 Worldwide Maritime Intelligence Admiral Thomas H. Collins, United States....................89 Western Pacific Admiral Koichi Furusho, Japan......................................92 Mediterranean Admiral Gregory G. Johnson, United States..................94 Africa Vice Admiral Johan F. Retief, South Africa....................98 Latin America Vice Admiral Jorge Omar Godoy, Argentina...............101 North Atlantic Admiral Roman Krzyóelewski, Poland .........................105 Arabian Sea Vice Admiral Chris Ritchie, Australia...........................109 Discussion ...........................................................................112 ii Chapter 7 Luncheon Address: Maritime Power for the Twenty-First Century The Honorable Gordon England Secretary of the Navy, United States ...................................119 Discussion ...........................................................................126 Chapter 8 Seminar Working Group Reports Moderator: Dr. Kenneth Watman Chairman, War Gaming Department Naval War College ...............................................................129 Seminar One: Rear Admiral Mujtaba, Bangladesh .............................130 Seminar Two: Rear Admiral El-Arbi, Tunisia......................................131 Seminar Three: Rear Admiral Davidson, Canada..................................132 Seminar Four: Rear Admiral McHaffie, New Zealand .........................136 Seminar Five: Vice Admiral Afolayan, Nigeria....................................143 Discussion ...........................................................................145 Chapter 9 Closing Remarks Rear Admiral Ronald A. Route.....................................................149 Admiral Vern Clark ......................................................................149 Chapter 10 Seminar Working Groups Introduction..................................................................................155 Orders of Battle and Platform Capabilities.......................156 Seminar One: Freedom of Navigation.................................................160 Seminar Two: Piracy ............................................................................162 Seminar Three: Preventing Loss of Life at Sea ......................................167 Seminar Four: Naval Support to Civil Authorities ...............................170 iii Seminar Five: Antiterrorism/MIO; Suspected WMD at Sea ................173 Seminar Six: Antiterrorism/Force Protection ....................................178 Seminar Seven: Illegal Fishing ...............................................................181 Seminar Eight: Humanitarian Assistance ..............................................185 Chapter 11 List of Delegates ..........................................................................189 iv List of Illustrations Chapter 3 Panel Discussion One: Maritime Coalitions at the Tactical Level Figure 1. Numerous C4 Challenges.......................................................21 Figure 2. Coalition Naval Order of Battle, 11 September 2001 ...........24 Figure 3. Coalition Naval Order of Battle, 16 February 2002..............25 Figure 4. 2002 Coalition ISR Collaboration .........................................26 Figure 5. Today’s