ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: out of the FORREST
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ABSTRACT Title of dissertation: OUT OF THE FORREST AND INTO THE BOOTH: PERFORMANCE OF MASCULINITY ON THE AMERICAN STAGE, 1828-1865 Karl M. Kippola, Doctor of Philosophy, 2003 Dissertation Directed by: Professor Heather S. Nathans Depar tment of Theatre My dissertation seeks to understand how and why the performance of American masculinity changed so dramatically from 1828 to 1865 and the gradual process of transition from Edwin Forrest’s rugged masculinity to Edwin Booth’s almost effe te intellectualism. Within the scope of my dissertation, I seek not merely to construct an isolated theatrical history but rather a history of cultural formations inextricably linked to the dynamic political, cultural, and social changes of this period. In Chapter One, I examine evolutions in manly rhetoric and oratory, and a brief survey of nineteenth -century advice literature, to better understand the performance of masculinity in the public sphere. In the second chapter, I investigate the masculine performance of Edwin Forrest (America’s first great actor) on- and off -stage and examine his adaptation of Robert T. Conrad’s Jack Cade as an example of his consciously constructed manly identity. In Chapter Three, I explore the wide range and variety of actors between Forrest and Booth (artistically and chronologically), as well as performances and representations of immigrant, Indian, Black, and working- class males as alternate visions of masculinity. In Chapter Four, I look at the Astor Place Riot (May 19, 1849) as a theatrical and political spectacle that suggests the incompatability of working-class individualism and the gentility of the emerging middle class and elite. In the final chapter, I explore Booth’s restrained image of masculinity and passiv e acceptance of personal tragedies as a reflection of the “invisible,” middle -class performance of ideal manhood. In the forty -year period that marked the complex evolution from Forrest’s debut to Booth’s triumph as Hamlet, the American definition of mascu linity fragmented along lines of class, race, and politics. I suggest that the national stage not only mirrored but magnified this process through the creation of physical characters upon which contemporary ideals of masculinity could be inscribed. Each splintered group demanded the reflection of their own values and models of behavior unique to their respective situations, and each searched for a sense of masculine, communal belonging. OUT OF THE FORREST AND INTO THE BOOTH: PERFORMANCE OF MASCU LINITY ON THE AMERICAN STAGE, 1828-1865 by Karl M. Kippola Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland, College Park in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2003 Advisory Committee: Professor Heather Nathans, Chair Professor Jackson Bryer Professor David Grimsted Professor Franklin Hildy Professor Robert Levine Professor Catherine Schuler Copyright by Karl M. Kippola 2003 ii ACKNOWLEDGME NTS Many people deserve thanks for their assistance on my doctoral journey. First and foremost, I would like to thank the members of my committee, especially Dr. Heather Nathans whose encouragement, mentorship, and enthusiasm made this project possible. I would like to thank all of the people at the Library Company of Philadelphia and the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, especially Jim Green, for the Mellon Fellowship that allowed me to explore a wide range of materials in their collections. I also would like the thank the staffs of the Library of Congress, the rare book division of the University of Pennsylvania library, the Harvard Theatre Collection, and the New York Public Library. I would like to thank my colleagues Korey Rothman and Stacey Stewart for their support and inspiration. Finally, I must thank my wife Antoinette for her boundless patience and understanding. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEGMENTS……………………………………………………. ii LIST OF FIGURES………………………………………………………… vi INTRODUC TION………………………………………………………….. 1 Chapter Structure…………………………………………………… 6 Contrasting Manhoods in Colonial America and the Early Republic………………………………………………………….. 10 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 24 CHAPTER ONE Learning to Play the Man: Images and Rhetoric of “Reconstructed Manhood”………………………….. 26 Masculinity’s Evolution…………………………………………….. 28 Developing an American Masculine Speech……………………….. 29 The Presidential Elections of 1828: A Masculine Revolu tion……… 33 Competing Masculinities of the “Great Triumvirate”……………… 48 Abraham Lincoln: An Unlikely Masculine Model…………………. 61 Henry Ward Beecher: A Softer Religion and Manhood……………. 71 Teaching Nationality and Manhood: Nineteen th -Century Advice Literature…………………………………………………………. 80 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 100 CHAPTER TWO “A Glorious Image of Unperverted Manhood:” Edwin Forrest as America’s Masculine Ideal………. 102 The Forrestonian Ethos……………………………………………… 102 Strenuous Realism: Forrest’s Acting Style…………………………. 117 Forrest as Political Animal and Champion of the Masses………….. 125 iv Forrest as a Father of American Drama…………………………….. 131 Jack Cade: A Case Study………………………………………….… 135 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 166 CHAPTER THREE Imitators and Innovators: The Spectrum of Masculine Models…………………………………… 170 The State of the Art: Romantic vs. Classical Acting……………….. 171 Founding Fathers of American Actin g: British Stars in America’s Heavens…………………………………………………………… 179 Romantic Redux: Emulating Forrest……………………………….. 197 Classical Copycats: Looking for the High Road……………………. 205 Comic Mockeries: The Lighter Side of American Manhood………. 212 Indians, Immigrants, Yankees, and Slaves: Alternate Masculine Visions…………………………………………………………… 220 Metamora and Perceptions of the Native American Indian… 220 Minstrelsy to Uncle Tom’s Cabin : Visions of Black Masculinity………………………………………………. 229 Immigrant Masculinity: Sobering the Irishman…………….. 242 Yankee to Mose: A Lower -Class Image to Embrace……….. 246 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 250 CHAPTER FOUR The Astor Place Riot: A Masculine Identity Worth Dying For…………………………………………… 252 The Astor Place Riot, a Drama in Five Acts………………………… 257 The Characters: (Anti)Hero – Edwin Forrest……………….. 257 (Anti)Hero – William Charles Macready…………… 259 The Setting: Astor Place Opera House……………………… 262 v ACT ONE: Eminence in Yankeeland – Macready’s First American Tour (1826-1827)……………………………… 264 ACT TWO: Savage Invasion – Forrest’s First Tour of England (1836-37)……………………………………….. 267 ACT THREE: Democracy vs. Ar istocracy – Macready’s Second Trip to America (1834-1844)……………………. 270 ACT FOUR: Much Ado About a Hiss; or, Forrest’s Final Trip to London (1845-1846)……………………………… 276 ACT FIVE: Masculine Showdown; or, Macready Last Trip to Amer ica (1848-1849)…………………………….. 282 Epilogue: Clearing the Rubble and Assigning the Blame….. 291 Conclusion………………………………………………………….. 294 CHAPTER FIVE “Sanctified by the American Bourgeoisie:” The Genteel Manliness of Edwin Booth……………. 299 Changing Audiences: The Feminization of the American Stage…… 303 Booth the Man: “Darling of Misfortune”…………………………… 310 Booth the Actor: “Nature’s sweet interpreter”……………………… 315 Booth’s Hamlet: “a nineteenth -century gentleman”………………... 319 Beyond Hamlet: “a man beneath whose calm exterior sleeps a hellish tempest of passion”………………………………………. 335 Out of the Forrest and Into the Booth: “Two stars keep not their motion in one sphere”……………………………………………. 342 Conclu sion………………………………………………………….. 354 CONCLUSION A Multitude of Masculinities……………………….. 356 BIBLIOGRPAHY…………………………………………………………… 361 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1. George Washington………………………………………………………… 19 2. Thomas Wignell as Darby in Darby’s Return …………………………..… 20 3. John Quincy Adams……………………………………………………... 36 4. Andrew Jackson……………………………………………………...….. 43 5. John C. Calhoun…………………………………………………...…….. 50 6. Henry Clay……………………………………………………...……….. 53 7. Daniel Webster……………………………………………..………….… 57 8. Abraham Lincoln………………………………………..…………….… 62 9. Henry Ward Beecher………………………………..………………….… 72 10. Edwin Forrest at 21……………………………..…………………….…. 103 11. Edwin Forrest as Spartacus………………..………………………….…. 110 12. Cartoon of Edwin Forrest as Spartacus………………………………...… 112 13. Edwin Forrest at 45………………………………………………..……... 126 14. Edwin Forrest as Jack Cade…………………………………..………….. 135 15. Robert T. Conrad…………………………………………..…………….. 143 16. Cartoon of Andrew Jackson defeating the United States Bank…..…….... 147 17. Thomas Abthorpe Cooper……………………………………..……….… 181 18. George Frederick Cooke…………………………………..………….…. 185 19. Edmund Kean as Richard III…………………………..…………….…… 187 vii 20. Junius Brutus Booth as Richard III………………..……………….…….. 190 21. William Charles Macready as Macbeth………..………………….…….. 191 22. John McCullough as Coriolanus…………..……………………….……. 198 23. James E. Murdoch as Petruchio………..………………………….…….. 205 24. Edward L. Davenport as Brutus…..……………………………….…….. 207 25. Laurence Barrett as Cassius……………………..……………….……… 210 26. James H. Hackett as Falstaff………………..………………….………… 213 27. James H. Hackett………………………..……………………..…………. 215 28. William Evans Burton as Bob Acres in The Rivals…………...………… 217 29. Edwin Forrest as Metamora……………………………………….…….. 221 30. John Vanderlyn’s The Death of Jane McCrea ……..………………….… 224 31. Thomas D. Rice as Jim Crow……………………………..……………... 229 32. Cartoon of Urban African American……………………………..…….... 232 33. Uncle Tom and Little Eva………………………………………………... 236 34. Frederick Douglass………………………………………………………. 240 35. John Brougham as Sir Lucius O’Trigger in The Rivals……………….….. 2 45 36. Francis S. Chanfrau as Mose………………………………………………