NORTH NORTH FOR FOR Buyer’s Guide TIME TIME SIDE 2019 NAIOP 2019 NAIOP Pittsburgh Pittsburgh THE
Fall 2019 NICE WORK.
Daniel S. Deiseroth, P.E. President
It’s what we do. No need for fi reworks. Just know we’ve been doing it since 1954. If you look around Pittsburgh, chances are you’re looking at us. And what exceptional project management can do.
A FULL-SERVICE CIVIL ENGINEERING FIRM 412.921.4030 GatewayEngineers.com
B U I L D WITH C O NFID E N C E CONTENTS | Fall 2019
05 President’s Message 07 Executive Director’s Message 29 Eye On the Economy
Feature 33 Office Market 08 Update Time for the North Side 37 Industrial Market Update 41 Capital Market Update 47 Legal/Legislative Outlook Transportation and Permitting – An Evolved and Refined Process 51 Benchmarks 23 Development Profile Changes on the Horizon 371 North Shore Drive – SAP Pittsburgh Office for LERTA 55 Voices 59 News from the Counties 73 People / Events
77 Buyers Guide 2019
www.developingpittsburgh.com 3 LISTEN BETTER. PLAN BETTER. BUILD BETTER.
Since 1916
BUTLER BUILDERS SINCE 1965
a COMMITTED partner for your SUCCESS Fairchance Construction Co. <> 724.564.7485 <> www.fairchanceconstruction.com PUBLISHER Tall Timber Group President’s Message www.talltimbergroup.com
EDITOR Jeff Burd 412-366-1857 [email protected] As we head into fall, it is a great We all must remember, however, that time to reflect on a very eventful public policy has the ability to facilitate PRODUCTION year for development in general, continued development or to hinder Carson Publishing, Inc. and for NAIOP Pittsburgh as a it. While real estate development has Kevin J. Gordon Chapter. So many important and had an unprecedented good run, [email protected] interesting projects are underway, our overall regional growth numbers recently completed or starting off. still show challenges. Without GRAPHIC DESIGN The explosion of great development an environment that makes new 321Blink projects in the strip, the continued development attractive, we will face tech emergence in Lawrenceville, a shortage in the very near future of CONTRIBUTING PHOTOGRAPHY airport corridor growth, and the first locations for the new and growing NAIOP Pittsburgh completed – and occupied – buildings businesses that are putting Pittsburgh Cory Klein Photography at Hazelwood Green all bode well for on so many “Best of” lists. our region and our industry. AE7 Architects Now is not the time to put the brakes Tall Timber Group As a chapter, NAIOP Pittsburgh on development. To do so would Northside Leadership Conference continues to make great progress jeopardize the progress we’ve made in growing our membership, as a region, and an industry, and CONTRIBUTING EDITORS dramatically increasing our advocacy poses a threat to the many good jobs Jeremy Marshall platform, and continuing to provide in the development and construction Karen Kukish great networking and service to the industries. It would also jeopardize real estate development community the region’s continued economic ADVERTISING SALES in the region. development overall. Karen Kukish One aspect that is particularly Real estate development has played 412-837-6971 important to me, to NAIOP and a central role in boosting our region’s [email protected] to our region is our Developing economy, including key contributions Leaders (DLs) program. The DL to the university driven tech economy MORE INFORMATION: program has grown tremendously, in Lawrenceville and the Strip, and DevelopingPittsburghTM is published by now totaling 111 members in the the improvements in East Liberty, Tall Timber Group for NAIOP Pittsburgh Pittsburgh chapter – nearly one-third Downtown, and the South Side. The 412-928-8303 of our membership. Our DLs are commercial real estate development www.naioppittsburgh.com engaged and active, bringing new industry can continue to be a key energy, new programs and new partner in the emergence of new No part of this magazine may be perspectives to the development industries and neighborhoods, IF reproduced without written permission industry. Importantly, our DLs are a we make sure the environment for by the Publisher. very diverse crowd, showing that real investment continues to be productive estate can attract and support great here. All rights reserved. careers for professionals of all ages, Our great staff at NAIOP Pittsburgh races and genders. Our DLs are clearly This information is carefully gathered and your Board are working hard contributing to the more inclusive to ensure that the interests of the and compiled in such a manner as to economy we all want to see. ensure maximum accuracy. We cannot, industry are well represented and to and do not, guarantee either the cor- The growth in DLs reflects recognition promote a broader appreciation of rectness of all information furnished of both the value of real estate as the fundamental contributions our nor the complete absence of errors and a career and its value to the overall industry makes to the prosperity of economy in our region. Attracting our region. omissions. Hence, responsibility for same talented young professionals to neither can be, nor is, assumed. our ranks demonstrates a number of positive trends and perceptions: Keep up with regional construction development is cool; it brings great and real estate events at: projects into being; it is a key driver www.buildingpittsburgh.com of the region’s economy; and it provides widespread professional opportunities – more so than at any time in recent memory. Younger professionals see an exciting and rewarding career that also allows them to help to grow the region and improve the quality of life for the Don Smith Jr. residents. NAIOP Pittsburgh President
Cover photo by Joey Studios
www.developingpittsburgh.com 5
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S MESSAGE
ast month marked my one year as Executive Director come will be about setting up and delivering legit policy wins of NAIOP Pittsburgh. And for our chapter, this past year for the Pittsburgh CRE community. has been one characterized by growth, innovation, L As we close out the second half of 2019, NAIOP Pittsburgh and incremental change. Building from the many years of will finish strong with great events for premium networking excellence, 2018-19 has been one of NAIOP Pittsburgh’s best and continued advocacy for the CRE community. In October, years. Our membership grew by over 15 percent, our events NAIOP Pittsburgh will celebrate our 20th Annual Night At The consistently sold to capacity, including record attendance at Fights, which is the most unique event of any association in the 26th Annual Awards Banquet, and our Developing Leaders the Pittsburgh region. Additionally, our fall schedule is full of (DL) program skyrocketed this year with strong programming. quality programming. Please visit www.naioppittsburgh.com to Additionally, in keeping in line with our aforementioned DL check out our upcoming programming and to find sponsorship program, our chapter engaged NAIOP Corporate to relaunch information for Night At The Fights. our mentoring program, Mentorship Connect. Working with the board and our great DL leadership, Mentorship Connect Sincerely, booked over 66 mentorship sessions in 2019. While organizational growth has been positive, the policy landscape remains fraught with risks for the CRE community. Worrisome riverfront zoning implications, changes to incentives, inclusionary zoning, permitting gridlock, and possible tax increases, are just some of the policy concerns affecting the Pittsburgh CRE community. When matched with possible effects of the growing U.S. – China trade war, policy decisions by our elected leaders will play a critical role in determining the pace of investment growth. NAIOP Pittsburgh has engaged heavily with our elected leaders over the past year. And in the year to come, there will be no slowdown from us. The last year has been about Brandon J. Mendoza re-establishing our presence at the policy table. The year to Executive Director NAIOP Pittsburgh
Architecture Interior Design
Planning Consulting
PITTSBURGH
412-921-4300 www.DLAplus.com
Connect with us:
@DLA_PLus LinkeDin.com/comPAny/3017087
www.developingpittsburgh.com 7 Time for the North Side
8 DEVELOPING PITTSBURGH | Fall 2019 TIME NORTHFOR THE SIDE
Use courtesy Northside Leadership Conference.
www.developingpittsburgh.com 9 FEATURE
t seems like it’s the North Side’s 96-room hotel on East Ohio Street, to Highway capacity expansion created time. After a decade of booming a groundbreaking for apartments at the another set of barriers as Route 65, Irevitalization in neighborhoods like stables building, to the fountain just Route 28 and the Fort Duquesne East Liberty, Lawrenceville, and the Strip completed at the park, to the cancer Bridge became bypasses around the District, the answer to the question center at Allegheny General Hospital, North Side. Three Rivers Stadium of which neighborhood will be the there is something under construction was built and surrounded by acres of next hot spot is probably the North all over. And that doesn’t mention all asphalt. Allegheny Center became a Side. That may seem an odd answer, the small projects being done in all the barrier, isolating the residents of the considering that revitalization of the neighborhoods.” North Side. North Side has been ongoing for about Once an independent city of 75,000 When the industrial base of the region 50 years. It may also seem odd that people, called Allegheny City, the North began to disintegrate in the late 1970s, almost 20 years after the North Shore Side makes up about one-fifth of the the North Side had gone from one saw construction of two professional city. The NLC works for 15 different of America’s wealthiest communities sports stadiums and a casino – plus the smaller neighborhood groups that to one of Pittsburgh’s struggling development that fits in between – that cover the entire city proper along the neighborhoods. it’s the current day that feels more like Allegheny and Ohio rivers, stretching Redevelopment from the Ground Up a boom. north to the Pittsburgh suburban Mark Fatla, executive director of the boundaries. With the benefit of time and Northside Leadership Conference hindsight we can see that most of As Pittsburgh prospered in the 1950s (NLC), agrees with the assessment the government-led redevelopment and 1960s, new infrastructure and that the last couple of years have seen efforts in cities around the U.S. weren’t commercial development came to heightened development. terribly effective. By the time that the the North Side that had unintended City of Pittsburgh began looking at “The theme of this year’s banquet for negative consequences, or results redevelopment on the North Side, the Northside Leadership Conference that were opposite of the intentions. much of the industrial property along was ‘Northside Under Construction.’ Industrial development along the the rivers had become gravel lots. And the reason is there’s a lot of riverfront cut off neighborhoods The “Renaissances” that followed construction,” Fatla jokes. “From a from the rivers and from Downtown.
KEYSTONE+MOUNTAIN+LAKES REGIONAL COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS
LEADING THE WAY... • Over 17,000 highly skilled Carpenters • Over 90,000 sq. ft. State of the Art J.A.T.C. • Trained in all aspects of Carpentry Commercial | Mill Cabinet | Millwrights | Heavy Highway Pile Drivers | Floor Coverers | Residential
57 Counties of Pennsylvania | Western Maryland | State of West Virginia State of Virginia | District of Columbia | 10 Counties of North Carolina www.kmlcarpenters.org | 412.922.6200
10 DEVELOPING PITTSBURGH | Fall 2019 FEATURE
in Pittsburgh missed the North Side “We have been building to this point in Lawrenceville – and the spiking for the most part. What successes for 40 years. What’s happened on the prices – DePasquale saw the North occurred resulted from very localized North Side that is different from East Side as underserved by developers. programs. This pattern of renewal, Liberty is that we did this gradually, He found a willing partner in the one building or one block at a time, organically, and from the grassroots East Allegheny Community Council, continues today. up,” Fatla explains. “There was not a lot which urged October Development to of big foundation money. There wasn’t purchase the homes of two absentee Among the earliest redevelopment a lot of big political will. There wasn’t landlords that were contributing to the successes were the renovation of some catalytic development project blight of the neighborhood. homes in the Mexican War Streets in that triggered development. For the the late 1960s and 1970s. Built in the “Almost on the first day we were able to most part, people gravitated towards 1840s, the Mexican War Streets are an identify 18 homes to buy. We renovated historic district neighborhoods that historic district of single-family homes, those and sold them to private owners,” were gradually polishing themselves which have been restored largely by DePasquale recalls. “I’d say we are one house at a time. There wasn’t a individuals. Originally sold for as little upwards of 50 dwellings that we have giant upheaval that displaced large as $100, the dilapidated homes were rehabilitated or built new just in this numbers of people who couldn’t afford nearly replaced by a proposal to build neighborhood.” to stay here. It’s been a more organic 16 apartment buildings containing and equitable process. And as a result I DePasquale found the kinds of 5,000 units. The plan, developed in think there is increased investment.” opportunities to buy undervalued 1954, would have demolished all the property and add value that he didn’t homes between Allegheny General Allie DePasquale is one of those people find in Lawrenceville or East Liberty. In Hospital and Brighton Avenue that sit who was attracted to the North Side’s his mind, the successes of the East End between North Avenue and the railroad historic neighborhoods and potential. neighborhoods were proof of concept. line bisecting the North Side. Instead, a A small private developer, DePasquale’s grass roots rehabilitation of hundreds of company, October Development, “Those kinds of projects were homes created a vibrant neighborhood began buying and renovating single- succeeding in East Liberty and that thrived in the midst of blight for family homes in Deutschtown in 2007. Lawrenceville, so it wasn’t so much of a decades. Tired of the competition for properties risk about the type of project. The main risk was whether the North Side would
www.developingpittsburgh.com 11 YOUR REAL ESTATE EXPERTS
ONE CALL MAKES OUR TEAM, YOUR TEAM We deliver value by fully understanding your needs and creating options with customized solutions.
OFFICE | RETAIL | INDUSTRIAL | ADVISORY
Cushman & Wakefield | Grant Street Associates, Inc. The Grant Building, Pittsburgh, PA 15219 www.gsa-cw.com 412-391-2600
GSA I F P A PG A PM FEATURE
Development of the North Shore parcels between Heinz Field and PNC Park is nearing completion. Cory Klein Photography
follow suit,” he says.” I think this is a has been very intentional,” Reichert 15 community groups. Fatla dispels better location than Lawrenceville so it says. “Separate from our business, we any assumption that the NSLC is the made more sense. It used to be the top live three blocks from our office in umbrella under which the other groups neighborhood in the city when Andy Manchester. My wife and I moved here operate Carnegie was walking up-and-down a few years ago and started attending “That is backwards. We’re the boat that these streets. The things that made it a church on the North Side. We loved everybody rides and they get to decide a top neighborhood then still exist. what was going on in the North Side. which way it goes,” he says. “We have Once we put renovated homes on the We love the activity, the improvement this grassroots, vertically-integrated market it was easy to get people to of the fabric of people’s lives and organization and the individual move here. It’s so convenient to be on livelihoods, in terms of the housing that community groups decide what the North side. they live and the businesses that they direction their neighborhood wishes operate. We planted ourselves here “I live on Lockhart Street and, when I to go. In turn the conference owns the because we wanted to live and work in get in my car every morning, within 30 primary source of capital, the Northside the neighborhood.” seconds I can be on a major highway Community Development Fund, which going in any direction.” In addition to its offices, Go Realty has has $13 million in assets for lending to Andrew Reichert, principal of Go Realty, rehabilitated five large single-family small business and real estate projects.” properties. Go Realty has stepped is another real estate professional This model of distributed community up the investment in the North Side who viewed the North Side through control in consensus, combined by undertaking the Allegheny City the prism of personal experience. with a funding source and the Stable Lofts, a renovation and new He and his wife Shannon, who is principal communications tool for construction hybrid that will bring 36 also a principal at Go Realty, moved the community, is unique among units of new living to historic stables to the North Side and have offices Pittsburgh community development located on West North Avenue. in Allegheny West. Go Realty’s main groups. Fatla understands why. business model is the purchase and October Development and Go Realty “It’s because it’s hard. Have you met management of stabilized assets in the benefitted from the partnership with any North Siders? Try getting 15 of near suburbs surrounding Pittsburgh. the NSLC. The non-profit looks for them in a room to agree on anything,” Their development model is focused owners and developers that are seeking he laughs. “We have all of the diversity closer to home. opportunities that fit the North Side’s and most of the assets that any city grass roots approach. NSLC acts as a “The concentration on the North Side has. Our residents are black and white, resource and convening entity for the
www.developingpittsburgh.com 13 FEATURE
rich and poor, gay and straight. They initially proposed a 12-story apartment the market was steadily maturing over live down by the river and up on a hill. that was met with opposition. Later, here. They saw an upward wave and Every variation you can imagine exists a revised design that reached eight believed they could reposition that within this one-fifth of the city, and they stories was also opposed by neighbors. property to do very well. But they wouldn’t have done it if they hadn’t all have to come together and figure In July, Trek and Q presented a smaller seen an upward wave.” out what works.” project to the Urban Redevelopment The grass roots approach can create Authority. The five-story mixed-use frustration for developers. Residents building will have fewer apartments – Redevelopment on a Grander Scale placed demands on the casino design, around 50 units – and less commercial in particular the parking garage, that space than the grand proposals that The upward wave of North Side weren’t demanded by the City of had been floated by earlier developers, redevelopment has been aided Pittsburgh and created delays in getting and Trek and Q Development. There dramatically by the success of the the project approved. Concerns about is no firm schedule for construction of large-scale developments over the rowdy fans on eight Sunday mornings the project. past three decades. Without the aid
Millcraft’s ambitious development of the Ohio riverfront west of Chateau Street is the next major commercial project in the pipeline for the North Side. Rendering by AE7 Architects, use courtesy Millcraft Investments.
Fatla believes the grass roots growth of photographs, it is difficult to grasp (or more, with any luck) influenced is more sustainable and attracts just how much the narrow two-block decisions about how Heinz Field was developers with varying skill sets, strip of land between the Ninth Street built. Perhaps no project has seen even if it increases the potential for Bridge and West End Bridge have been View from West End Overlook more pushback recently than the NIMBY intervention. By attracting transformed. redevelopment of Federal North’s developers with a diversity of thinking Garden Theater. Commercial development on the North JANUARY 2019 and experience, Fatla believes the Side began with the construction of The misfortune of economic timing North Side development environment corporate offices on the gravel lots has undone some of the proposed was more attractive to the large-scale that lined Isabella Street in the 1980s. plans for the central business corner developers that followed. During the 1990s, two major projects of the North Side, but neighbors in the “[Projects like] Nova Place are a product – ALCOA’s headquarters and Lincoln surrounding streets have also slammed of the process, not the cause of it,” he North Shore – provided inertia to the the door on the project. The current says. “The reason Faros was interested theory that the North Side’s proximity developers, Trek and Q Development, in the property was that they saw that to Downtown and highways would
14 DEVELOPING PITTSBURGH | Fall 2019 FEATURE
attract residential and commercial developer,” recalls Ford. “The Steelers office as the predominant use for the tenants. At the end of that decade, the invited us to submit a proposal. Frank North Shore development, those same replacement of Three Rivers Stadium Cass and I drove down on a beautiful parking resources become available for with two new major sports stadiums day when the riverfront improvements their tenants. kicked off a new era of large-scale had just been completed and the “I have to give credit to the city and the development. When PNC Park and stadiums were almost open. It was a teams for their planning. In the 1990s Heinz Field opened in 2001, the beautiful spring day. He and I walked up they got together and put a master plan business generated from 82 baseball and down the park, looked at the site, in place for the development and we games and ten football games (plus and said to each other that it seemed really followed that plan,” Ford says. one or two extra most years) created like a natural for us. The rest is history.” “That master plan required that a big demand for more commercial space. During the past 15 years, through public investment go into parks and When those stadiums were nearing two business cycles, Continental has infrastructure. That fixed what wasn’t completion, the Sports and Exhibition developed four major office buildings there before. Unlike with Three Rivers Authority, the Pirates, and the Steelers totaling 635,000 square feet and Stadium, they took the steps that invited developers to propose the roughly 140,000 square feet of ground attracted development. I have to give
commercial build-out of the vacant floor restaurant/entertainment space. the teams and the city credit for what property between the new stadiums. What was once a sea of parking spaces they did 20 years ago. They planned for Continental Real Estate was just has become an 18-hourView commercial from success.” West End Overlook completing its Waterfront project district. With two major league sports teams and had hired Barry Ford to grow its Ford notes that there weren’t a lot of anchoring the North Shore, other Pittsburgh real estate operations. The developers competing for the North development followed beyondJANUARY what 2019 North Shore opportunity was one of Shore project. One of the concerns Continental developed. The Steelers the first he helped pursue. was that it would be difficult to mix and Promowest built Stage AE, a live “We were doing smaller projects in the commercial development with the music venue. Four different hotels were region but were looking for a project to parking required but he says that developed between Federal Street and really plant our flag to show we were the opposite has been true. Parking North Shore Drive. Infill development a Pittsburgh company. I’m a Pittsburgh resources that support the Steelers of entertainment and dining changed guy and we wanted to show that we and Pirates are used almost entirely in Federal Street. First National Bank built were committed to being a Pittsburgh the evening and on weekends. With a new headquarters there. The Rubinoff
www.developingpittsburgh.com 15 FEATURE
Company developed a 232,000 square foot business service center for ALCOA just east of Federal Street on Isabella Street. As the North Shore was maturing as a sports and entertainment hub, the area received another boost when Pennsylvania’s Gaming Commission awarded Rivers Casino the license to build on a site between Reedsdale Street and the Ohio River. Financial trouble with the original developer slowed construction but the casino opened in August 2009. At the other end of the North Side’s riverfront, two major apartment complexes were built in the early 2000s. The 232-unit Morgan at North Shore apartments were built by Lincoln Properties. Originally known as Lincoln North Shore, the project was new three-story garden apartments perched on the banks Redevelopment of the West Deutschtown neighborhood is attracting new construction and of the Allegheny River. At the other restoration of businesses along the East Ohio Street corridor and the intersecting streets. end of the architectural spectrum,
16 DEVELOPING PITTSBURGH | Fall 2019 FEATURE
former H. J. Heinz Company buildings built in the 1890s were converted into the Heinz Lofts, a 266-unit complex developed by Ferchilll Group in the mid-2000s. The aforementioned Nova Place is a more recent major project success story. New York-based Faros Properties acquired the former Allegheny Center Mall and adjacent apartments in 2013, with the intention of converting the defunct mall into office space for emerging technology companies. Allegheny Center Mall had been emblematic of the decaying fabric of the North Side decades before. The mall cut off Federal Street just north of Lacock Street, and created a one-way circular traffic pattern that pushed vehicles away from the North Side’s heart. Faros’ plan was to invest more than $125 million in upgrades that would make the mall viable as a technology hub. “We thought it was an opportunity The Allegheny City Stables Lofts will blend new construction (rendered on the left) with the res- to acquire a tremendous amount toration of an historic structure. Rendering courtesy Go Realty. of physical infrastructure that was,
We know what it takes to achieve success.
Nobody reaches the top without support.
Our experienced commercial bankers are committed to helping your business grow.
800.325.2265 • stbank.com
MEMBER FDIC
www.developingpittsburgh.com 17 FEATURE
Allegheny Commons Park sits in the heart of the North Side Flats. Photo by Jeremy Marshall. Use courtesy Northside Leadership Conference.
in our view, in a great location,” says back up and upgrading the rent rolls. 3,000-car parking garage. Jeremy Leventhal, managing partner Turning to the Allegheny Center Mall, As of Spring 2019, a bevy of new at Faros Properties. “It was proximate Faros employed dozens of Pittsburgh leases lifted the occupancy level in the to the city, the North Shore and we contractors, architects, engineers, and mall and adjoining office tower to 92 had the ability to reshape a significant consultants to convert the 1.5 million percent. Faros has attracted a number portion of that neighborhood. We saw square foot space. In the process, they of technology tenants, including the that as a great opportunity.” created a 10,000 square foot fitness Pittsburgh Technology Council. Faros began by rejuvenating the Park center, the Federal Galley restaurant, One of the largest developments View apartments, bringing occupancy one of Pittsburgh’s first co-working spaces, Alloy 26, and renovated the underway on the North Side today is an
hfflp.com proven results in real estate capital markets solutions
HFF PITTSBURGH One Oxford Centre, 301 Grant Street, Suite 1100, Pittsburgh, PA 15219 (412) 281-8714
DEBT PLACEMENT | INVESTMENT SALES | EQUITY PLACEMENT ADVISORY SERVICES | LOAN SALES | LOAN SERVICING