10.0 TRANSPORTATION
10.1 INTRODUCTION The purpose of the Irving Thoroughfare Plan, as a component of the Compre- hensive Plan, is to accommodate the existing and future roadway transportation needs of the City. The Thoroughfare Plan is one element of a coordinated trans- portation system to address the intermodal and multi-modal transportation needs of the City, while maintaining and improving the social, economic, and environ- mental quality of the community.
The thoroughfare system is one of the most visible and permanent elements of the urban structure. Once the alignment and right-of-way of major transporta- tion facilities are established and adjacent property developed, it is difficult to obtain agreement to make significant changes to the system. Therefore, it is important that the City carefully evaluate its existing thoroughfare system with an eye toward preserving and enhancing its function. Because of increasing traffic congestion within the Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex, the continued growth of Irving as an employment center will be dependent upon the integration of thoroughfares with other multi-modal transportation systems.
10.2 SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT
10.2.1 Function of Thoroughfare Planning The Thoroughfare Plan defines a hierarchy of roadway functions that provide for both traffic movement and property access. The Plan also provides a clear statement of future roadway alignments, capacities (number of lanes), and right-of-way require- ments within the City of Irving. It has been developed to support the Future Land Use Plan by providing adequate capacity to move both people and goods.
Thoroughfare Plan and Growth
The Thoroughfare Plan is the basic element for ensuring the orderly implemen- tation of roadways in conjunction with economic growth and facilitates the pres- ervation of right-of-way in the development review process. The Plan provides guidance for determining appropriate land uses by identifying the ultimate con- figuration of the network. It also provides a guide for the programming of projects and allows for a rational and systematic provision of capacity. The Plan should reflect
Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving 10-1 community goals; provide continuous routes; match expected land use patterns and characteristics; integrate with the regional freeway, expressway, and arterial system, as well as the plans of surrounding local jurisdictions; be sensitive to topographical features and constraints; and adapt to changing conditions.
Traffic Impact Analysis Process
In order to ensure that proposed land uses are compatible with the proposed roadway system and to help modify that system when necessary, a process of analyzing traffic impacts in conjunction with development proposals is recom- mended. This process should be conducted to ensure that adequate access is available for the proposed development; that sufficient roadway capacity exists to accommodate it; that the development is compatible with the characteristics of adjacent roadways; and to identify any improvements or modifications nec- essary to maintain mobility within the community.
Access Management
Managing access to arterial streets protects the public investment in roadways and ensures that the desire for access to private property is balanced with the mobility needs of the larger community. Safe and convenient access is in the interest of both the public traveling on a street and the needs of adjacent land uses. A system of roadway access management can promote both of these interests. Key objectives of access management include the limitation of the number of driveways; the encouragement of shared access drives between busi- nesses, and a common circulation system within a cluster of businesses; and the incorporation of design features (such as left- and right-turn lanes and medi- ans) which facilitate traffic flow.
Transportation System Management
Transportation management strategies focus on alleviating traffic congestion by allowing the existing transportation system to operate more efficiently and by reducing travel demand. Transportation system management (TSM) pertains to the management of roadway supply through the addition of high occupancy vehicle (HOV) lanes, intersection improvements, signal re-timing, sidewalk wid- ening, traveler information systems (incident detection), etc. Transportation de- mand management (TDM) pertains to the alleviation of automobile traffic de- mand through enhanced transit and paratransit use, ridesharing, peak-spread- ing (flexible work schedules, staggered work hours, or compressed work weeks), and parking management. TDM programs are facilitated by Transportation Man- agement Organizations (TMO) which are proactive and involve the private sector in addressing transportation problems and needs. TSM and TDM strategies are complementary and should be considered before undertaking capital-intensive projects.
10-2 Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving Project Planning Coordination
Due to the shortage of public dollars for improvements to federal and state road- way facilities, it is critical that the City remain actively involved in the develop- ment of TxDOT, Texas Turnpike Authority, and other public and private roadway projects to ensure that areawide plans are coordinated with City planned road- ways. In addition, future travel demand cannot be met by a transportation pro- gram limited to the construction of new roadways or the widening of existing facilities. Rather, a multi-modal system will be required which will provide alter- native modes of travel to the private automobile. Therefore, the City should remain actively involved in the regional planning activities of DART and the Trin- ity Railway Express. With Irving emerging as a major business activity center, maintaining and enhancing traffic circulation will be vital to the economic health of the community.
Plan Update
The Thoroughfare Plan should be reviewed on a regular basis and updated to respond to changes in local conditions. As new information about prospective developments is obtained, the Plan should be refined to maintain a balance be- tween public mobility and neighborhood integrity throughout the community.
The major benefits provided by the Thoroughfare Plan include:
• minimizing the amount of right-of-way needed in advance of new devel- opment, or as it occurs;
• designing roadways that will stabilize traffic and land-use patterns;
• limiting the potential for high traffic volumes on neighborhood streets;
• anticipating when funds must be programmed for needed roadway im- provements; and
• reducing the potential deterioration of economic growth due to increased traffic congestion.
Five elements form the framework of an effective Thoroughfare Plan:
1. A long-range Plan that addresses projected growth.
2. A process to review the traffic impacts of new developments.
3. Implementation of access management and Transportation System Man- agement programs.
4. Coordination with regional and state (Texas Turnpike Authority, TxDOT, Dallas County, DART) planning programs.
5. A process for updating/revising the Plan as conditions warrant.
Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving 10-3 10.2.2 Thoroughfare Planning Process Several elements must be considered in the process of developing a Thoroughfare Plan, including the Future Land Use Plan, travel demands, movement and access requirements, and physical constraints to roadway construction. The type of land uses that are existing and planned for an area affect the roadway capacity and access needs for that area. For example, a densely developed commercial or office area with higher travel demand will require more closely spaced roadways with greater capacity than will a low density residential area. Moreover, special efforts will be required in the thoroughfare planning process to ensure that the integrity of residential neighbor- hoods is protected from unwanted and undesired vehicular traffic.
Balancing the movement and access functions of the thoroughfare system is another consideration in the planning process. Roadways serve two competing functions: the movement of traffic and access to properties. A conflict exists as ingress and egress maneuvers from local properties impede the movement of traffic on major roadways, and as high traffic volumes impede turning movements in and out of driveways. Con- trolling access so that these two competing functions occur on separate sections of the thoroughfare system is a primary objective of the process.
Finally, review and comment by government decision makers, civic and neighbor- hood interest groups, and the citizenry in general is one of the most important steps in the planning process. No planning can be successfully implemented without the input from, and support of, these groups and individuals, as they will ultimately deter- mine the balance between maintaining mobility and neighborhood integrity.
One of the key analytical tools used in the preparation of most Thoroughfare Plans is a travel demand forecasting model. Currently, long range travel projections for the Metroplex are prepared by the North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG). To develop more detailed traffic forecasts for roadways within the City of Irving, the Traffic and Transportation Department initiated the development of a sub- area model. This model uses the basic modeling procedures of the NCTCOG to maintain consistency in the traffic forecasting process, but focuses on the Irving area rather than the region as a whole. An overview of this process is described in a later section of this report. As with the NCTCOG regional model, the Irving model uses employment and population data based on the Future Land Use Plan prepared as a part of the comprehensive planning process.
10-4 Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving 10.3 EXISTING CONDITIONS
10.3.1 Overview of Existing Conditions The initial step in the development of the Thoroughfare Plan was a complete assess- ment of the existing conditions of the transportation system. This assessment was prepared as part of the Baseline Analysis report submitted earlier in the process. In that analysis, three topic areas were addressed: the existing transportation framework, work travel characteristics, and factors influencing growth in future travel demand. A synopsis of conditions and issues is provided below.
Irving’s existing transportation network is comprised of two distinct city-wide functional systems: the regional freeway network and the local arterial roadway network. Seven different freeways within Irving serve regional access throughout the Metroplex. These are IH 635, SH 114, SH 183, SH 161, SH Loop 12 and SH Spurs 348 and 482. Additionally, Irving is within close proximity to several other major regional facilities (IH 30, IH 35E, SH 360 and SH 121).
Within Irving, a network of arterial and collector roadways provides for vehicular traffic movement throughout the City. North-south movement is accommo- dated via Belt Line Road, MacArthur Boulevard, Valley View Lane, Esters Road, Story Road, and O’Connor Road/Boulevard. Of these, Belt Line and MacArthur serve as spines that provide cross-town circulation. East-west circulation is provided via Irving Boulevard, Shady Grove Road, Pioneer Drive, Rochelle Road/ Boulevard, Northgate Drive, Walnut Hill Lane, and Royal Lane.
Traffic congestion in Irving has approached critical levels, particularly on the freeway system. Over the last 10 years, area freeways have experienced in- creases in traffic volumes ranging from 6-117%. The largest increases have been on SH 114 (82-117%), IH 635 (100%) and SH 183 (33-62%).
There are also several arterials within Irving that are experiencing moderate to heavy congestion during peak hours of operation. These include Belt Line Road, between Story and Pioneer, and most interchanges with SH 183, SH 114, and SH Loop 12. Map 8 illustrates current congestion areas.
Most of the arterial roadways within the City currently have either four or six lanes. The major roadways that have only a two-lane cross-section include por- tions of O’Connor Road/Boulevard, Rochelle Road/Boulevard, Pioneer Drive, and Nursery Road. The roadway rights-of-way vary according to location. Gener- ally, in south Irving, rights-of-way vary between 60 and 100 feet because of preexisting adjacent development. In the more recently developed areas toward the north, right-of-way is typically 80 to 120 feet due to upgraded roadway stan- dards.
Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving 10-5 Travel characteristics data compiled by NCTCOG have been reviewed to determine the distribution of work trips that travel to, from, and within Irving. The data show that 24% of the daily work trips are made by Irving residents to employment locations within Irving, 43% are imported to Irving, and the remaining trips (33%) depart Irving daily for destinations in other cities. Of trips originating in Irving, 40% remain in Irving while 34% depart for Dallas. Of trips destined for Irving, 16% and 11% are imported from Dallas and Arlington/Grand Prairie, respectively. Journey-to-work data indicate sig- nificant interaction between Irving and Dallas. With the SH 183 and SH 114 travel corridors exceeding capacity at current employment levels, the traffic impacts on the area freeway infrastructure associated with future employment growth within Irving will be significant.
Growth in Irving is influenced by current development trends, roadway initia- tives for improvements, and transit initiatives for increased mobility. Regionally, DFW International Airport serves as a catalyst for economic growth in Irving. DFW, coupled with downtown Dallas and the emergence of Las Colinas as an economic center, make the SH 114/IH 635 corridor attractive for continued de- velopment.
High growth areas within Irving include Las Colinas, particularly in the Urban Center and along the SH 114 corridor, Valley Ranch, and the SH 161 corridor. The Urban Center currently employs nearly 30,000 persons. Based on the re- maining land capacity for the Urban Center alone, the potential for growth could surge from three to five times that of existing levels. Approximately 28,000 persons are employed in developments along the SH 114 corridor. With several large tracts of land available, continued growth is likely. Other potential develop- ments include the airport expansion zone; expansion of Texas Stadium by 40,000 seats; special generators in the Regional Activity District, such as a theme park near Texas Stadium; regional retail/commercial activity at the IH 635/SH 161 interchange area; commercial-related uses in south Irving in conjunction with the Lone Star Race Track in Grand Prairie; and the location of a major retail center at the IH 635/MacArthur interchange area.
Roadway initiatives contribute to development pressures on the roadway net- work by enhancing system capacity. Current roadway initiatives include City, County and State, and DART Transit Pass (Principal Arterial Street System) projects. Among the more significant projects are O’Connor Boulevard ( SH Spur 348 to SH 161), Valley View Lane (SH 183 to Walnut Hill), Belt Line Road (Rock Island to south city limits), Belt Line Road at the Trinity Railway Express, MacArthur Boulevard (Oakdale to south city limits), Rochelle Boulevard (O’Connor to Leone Drive), County Line Road (SH 183 to Valley View), Las Colinas Boule- vard (Royal to SH 161), Colwell Boulevard (Royal to Buffalo), and the recently completed MacArthur Boulevard (Royal to IH 635) and SH 161 frontage roads (O’Connor to IH 635). The Baseline Analysis report identified the specific loca- tions of current transportation improvement projects (plate 27, page 138).
10-6 Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving Several transit initiatives will serve to provide increased transit opportunities from and within Irving. With continued employment growth in north Irving, the potential exists for a reverse commute. Transit initiatives will serve to supplement the roadway network by providing alternative travel modes to commuters. Transit initiatives include the im- pending operation of the Trinity Railway Express from Dallas to the south Irving transit center; continued use of existing local DART bus service, express service, and park- and-ride facilities, and potential service to DFW Airport from north Irving; commuter rail service to the north Irving transit center; and the potential revival of the fixed guide- way Las Colinas Area Personnel Transit (APT) for use within the Urban Center and to potential remote parking facilities.
10.3.2 Issues/Concerns Several issues and concerns identified as part of the scoping interviews and Baseline Analysis are addressed in the Thoroughfare Plan. These are as follows: • The need for east-west routes other than SH 183. • Access to Las Colinas/Urban Center. • Improvements to the Texas Stadium area. • Access improvements from SH 183 to the Trinity Railway Express. • Realignment of Hunter-Ferrell Road. • Realignment of Valley View Lane. • Traffic impacts of the proposed racetrack. • Improved circulation at Irving Mall. • Traffic impacts of a major retail center at IH 635/MacArthur Boulevard intersection. • Additional access to Valley Ranch. Of equal importance is the preparation of a Plan that will address changing com- muting patterns. A report published by the Eno Transportation Foundation en- titled Commuting in America, II examined population patterns and trends rela- tive to commuting on the basis of 1990 census data. The study found that commuting patterns have changed due to the growth of the labor force as well as the continued suburbanization of metropolitan areas.
Americans increasingly prefer driving to work rather than using public transpor- tation. The growth rate in the number of vehicles has outpaced that of popula- tion over the last decade. While population has increased by less than 10%, the number of vehicles has increased by more than 17%.
Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving 10-7 The report also found that 42% of the nation’s jobs in 1990 were located in the sub- urbs, up from 37% in 1980. Reverse commuting (city to suburb) rose substantially, while traditional commuting (suburb to city) decreased. Single occupant private ve- hicle users increased by over 22 million, even though the number of workers in- creased by only 19 million. Fewer than 1 in 10 cars destined for work trips had an occupant other than the driver, while public transit was used by approximately 1 in 20 persons. On the basis of these trends, it will be necessary to maximize the efficiency of the existing street system, as well as to provide new roadways and alternative modes of travel. Only through a comprehensive approach can a Plan be developed that will sufficiently meet future travel desires, provide economic benefits for the community, and be compatible with other elements of the urban environment.
10.4 THOROUGHFARE PLAN DEVELOPMENT Functional street classification and travel demand forecasting model develop- ment and application are two components of the Thoroughfare Plan develop- ment process. Functional classifications reflect the role or function that indi- vidual roadways are intended to serve within the overall system. The travel fore- casting model assists in evaluating improvement alternatives by providing fu- ture travel forecasts for the local and regional transportation networks, thereby enabling a Plan to be developed that can adequately serve projected traffic de- mands.
10.4.1 Functional Street Classification Functional street classification recognizes that streets are part of a system having diverse origins and destinations. A typical trip involves the following stages: primary movement, transition, collection/distribution, access, and termination. Functional classifications also describe and reflect a set of characteristics common to all road- ways within each classification. Functions range from providing mobility for through traffic and major traffic flows to providing access to specific properties. Characteris- tics unique to each classification include the degree of continuity, general capacity, and traffic control characteristics.
The road system within a community can be divided into four general classifica- tions based on a hierarchial function. These include:
Freeways/Expressways: High capacity facilities with controlled access. They are intended to carry high volumes of longer distance trips, and are a regional supplement to the arterial system. Freeways differ from expressways in that access is more restrictive in nature.
10-8 Comprehensive Plan • City of Irving Arterial Streets: Facilities which are used to move large volumes of through traffic at relatively high speeds throughout the community. Arterial streets are more or less continuous throughout the community and their primary func- tion is to provide movement of traffic. Property access is a low priority func- tion.
Collector Streets: Those streets which are used to carry moderate amounts of traffic volumes and provide limited access to adjacent properties. Their function is to collect and distribute traffic to and from local and arterial streets. Collectors supplement the arterial system and should not be continuous for long distances.
Local Streets: Those streets which are used for low volume, low speed traffic movements. Their function is to provide direct access to adjacent properties.
In short, the functional classification of streets provides for the circulation of traffic in the hierarchy of movement from one classification to the next. Func- tional change can be subdivided further into major or minor designations to further describe their role in the community. For each classification there is typically a recommended set of operational and design criteria. Thus, facilities are grouped according to the character of service (movement or access) that they are intended to provide. Figure 16 illustrates the relative roles of each clas- sification to achieve its intended function.
FIGURE 16 ROADWAY FUNCTION BY CLASSIFICATION