ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY PUBLISHED BIMONTHLY

New Series, Vol. I, No. 6 NOVEMBER, 1929 Whole No. 46

EDITOR FRANCIS R. PACKARD, M.D., Philadelphia, Pa.

ASSOCIATE EDITORS LE ROY CRUMMER, M.D...... Los Angeles HARVEY CUSHING, M.D...... Boston IRVING S. CUTTER, M.D...... Chicago CHARLES L. DANA, M.D...... New York GEORGE DOCK, M.D...... Pasadena FIELDING H. GARRISON, M.D...... Washington HENRY BARTON JACOBS, M.D...... Baltimore HOWARD A. KELLY, M.D...... Baltimore ARNOLD C. KLEBS, M.D...... Nyon SAMUEL W. LAMBERT, M.D...... New York THOMAS McCRAE, M.D...... Philadelphia LEWIS STEPHEN PILCHER, M.D...... Brooklyn SIR D’ARCY POWER, K.B.E., F.R.C.S.(ENG.), F.S.A. London DAVID RIESMAN, M.D...... Philadelphia SIR HUMPHRY ROLLESTON, BART., K.C.B., M.D. Cambridge JOHN RUHRAH, M.D...... Baltimore CHARLES SINGER, M.D...... Oxford EDWARD C. STREETER, M.D...... Boston ALDRED SCOTT WARTHIN, M.D. ... Ann Arbor WILLIAM H. WELCH, M.D...... Baltimore CASEY A. WOOD, M.D...... Chicago

NEW YORK PAUL B. HOEBER, INC., PUBLISHERS SEVENTY-SIX FIFTH AVENUE ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY

New Series, Vol. I, No. 6 NOVEMBER, 1929 Whole No. 46

Original articles are published only with the understanding that they are contributed exclusively to the ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY. Manuscripts offered for publication, books for review, and all corre­ spondence relating to the editorial management should be addressed to the Editor, Dr. Francis R. Packard, 302 South 19th Street, Philadelphia, Pa. Communications regarding subscriptions, reprints, and all matters regarding the business management of the ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY should be addressed to the publishers, Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. 76 Fifth Avenue, New York City. The ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY is published six times a year, the six issues comprising on e volume. No advertising is carried. The subscription price is $10.00 a year, foreign $11.00. Current single num­ bers $2.50 per copy. A few sets of first series, Volumes I-X, are available in parts as published at $100.00 per set, or bound in boards, paper sides, canvas back, paper label, $125.00 per set. Price on available single volumes or numbers will be quoted on request. Entered as second-class matter, June 2, 1917, at the Post Office, New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1929, by Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. INDEX

Adler, Francis Heed: Sketches front the Book Reviews: Life of Albrecht von Graefe, 284 Packard, Francis R.: From Magic to American Association of History of Medicine, Science, etc., by Charles Singer, 244 Proceedings of 5th Annual Meeting, E. B. Further Correspondence of John Ray, Krumbhaar, Editorial, 736 edited by Robert W. J. Gunther, Anatomical Knowledge of the Ancient Hin­ 251 dus, Frederick S. Hammett, 325 History of the Medical Department of Appreciation of the Medical Profession and the United States Army, by P. M. the Divine Origin of Medicine, H. Burger, Ashburn, 738 37 History of Medicine, etc., by Fielding Ashburn, P. M.: History of the Medical H. Garrison, 246 Department of the United States Army, History of Printing, etc., by John review of, Francis R. Packard, 738 Clyde Oswald, 125 Makers of Nursing History, etc., by ■Dall, James Moores: The Sack-’Em Up Meta Rutter Pennock, 247 Men, etc., review of, Francis R. Packard, Medical and Allied Topics in Latin 359 . Poetry, by Heinrich Oppenheimer, Bath Olivers—Doctor and Biscuit, Edward 613 B. Krumbhaar, 253 Medical Leaders from Hippocrates to Beaumont, William, and His Book, etc., Osler, by Samuel W. Lambert and William S. Miller, 155 George M. Goodwin, 737 Beiter, Raymond E.: Charles Edward Isaacs, Old Masterpieces in Surgery, etc., by a Forgotten American Kidney Physiolo­ Alfred Brown, 488 gist, 363 Role of Scientific Societies in the 17th Berthold, Arnold Adolf, a Biographic Sketch Century, by Martha Ornstein, 248 of, Homer P. Rush, 208 Short History of Medicine, etc., by Bibliotheca Osleriana, editorial, Francis R. Charles Singer, 250 Packard, 733 Sir Isaac Newton, etc., edited by F. E. Book Reviews: Brasch, 121 Cardio-Vascular Diseases since Harvey’s Storia della Medicina, by Arturo Discovery, by Sir Humphry Davy RoIIes- Castiglioni, 126 ton, 360 The Sack-’Em Up Men, etc., by Funk, Elmer H.: The Peaks of Medical James Moores Ball, 359 History, etc., by Charles L. Dana, 251 William Harvey, by Archibald History of Pathology, by Esmond R. Malloch, 361 Long, 736 Riesman, David: Kyklos, etc., 124 Intercolonial Aspects of the Revolution, Grundlagen und Ziele der Medizin der etc., by Michael Kraus, 361 Gegenwart, by Theodor Brugsch et Krumbhaar, E. B. Opuscula Selecta al., 123 Neerlandicorum de Arte Medica: Het Waring, James J.: Rene Theophile Boeck van Surgien van Thomas Scel- Hyacinthe Laennec, by Gerald B. Iinck van Thienen, 362 Webb, 360 McCrae, Thomas: Die Entwicklung der Brasch, F. E.: Sir Isaac Newton, etc., review Lehre van der Herzkrankheiten, of, Francis R. Packard, 121 by Max Neuburger, 122 Brown, Alfred: Old Masterpieces in Surgery, Max von Pettenhofer, etc., by Edgar etc., review of, Francis R. Packard, 488 Erskine Hume, 122 Brugsch, Theodor, et al.: Grundlagen und Old Age, the Major Involution, by Ziele der Medizin der Gegenwart, review Aldred Scott Warthin, 739 of, David Riesman, 123 Packard, Francis R.: Consecratio Medici Brunschwig, Alexander: Hieronymus Bruns- and Other Papers, by Harvey Cush­ schwig of Strassburg, 640 ing, 252 Brunschwig, Hieronymus, of Strassburg, Esculape chez les Artistes, by Caba­ Alexander Brunschwig, 640 nes, 122 Exercitatio Anatomica de Motu Burger, H.: The Appreciation of the Medical Cordis . . . Guilielmi Harvei, 121 Profession and the Divine Origin of Medi­ Four Centuries of Medical History in cine, 37 Canada, etc., by John J. Heagerty, Burr, Charles W.: Dr. James and His Medical 486 Dictionary, 180 Y^abanes: Esculape chez les Artistes, review Evolution and Life, Sir Andrew Macphail, of, Francis R. Packard, 122 553. California Medical History Seminar, editorial, Exercitatio Anatomica de Motu Cordis . . . Guilielmi Harvei, review of, Francis R. Cardio-Vascular Diseases Since Harvey’s Packard, 121 Discovery, by Sir Humphry Davy Rolles- ton, review of, 360 JTewster, John, George C. Peachey, 229 “Castel of Helth” and Its Author, Sir Thomas Elyot, W. G. Aitchison Robertson, Four Centuries of Medical History in Canada, 270 etc., by John J. Heagerty, review of, Castiglioni, Arturo: Storia della Medicina, Francis R. Packard, 486 review of, Francis R. Packard, 126 Friedenwald, Harry: Ms. Copies of Medical Chance, Burton: Squier Littell, 50 Works of Isaac Judaeus; Diploma of Jew­ Circulation of the Blood, Bibliographical ish Graduate of Medicine of University of Matters pertaining to the Discovery of the, Padua in 1695, 629 E. B. Krumbhaar, 57 Funk, Elmer H.: The Peaks of Medical Cohn, Alfred E.: The Development of the History, by Charles L. Dana, review of, 251 Harveian Circulation, 16 Further Correspondence of John Ray, edited Consecratio Medici and Other Papers, by by Robert W. J. Gunther, review of, Harvey Cushing, review of, Francis R. Francis R. Packard, 251 Packard, 252 Correspondence : QJalen’s Birth, Date of, Joseph Walsh, 378 Pare’s “Oeuvres,” Harvey Cushing, 356 Crummer, Le Roy: Copy of Jenner Note Garrison, Fielding H.: A Brief Note on Medi­ Book, 403 cal Philately, 451 Cushing, Harvey: Consecratio Medici and History of Medicine, etc., review of, Francis Other Papers, review of, Francis R. R. Packard, 246 Packard, 252 von Graefe, Albrecht, Sketches from the Life Pare’s “Oeuvres,” Correspondence, 356 of, Francis Heed Adler, 284 Grundlagen und Ziele der Medizin der T^Sana, Charles L.: The Peaks of Medical Gegenwart, by Theodor Brugsch et al., •‘“''History, review of, Elmer H. Funk, 251 review of, David Riesman, 123 Diploma of Jewish Graduate of Medicine of Gudger, E. W.: Some Early and Late Illus­ Padua in 1695, Harry Friedenwald, 629 trations of Comparative Osteology, 334 Diseases of Ancient Man, Some, Joseph L. Gunther, Robert W. J.: Further Correspond­ Miller, 394 ence of John Ray, review of, Francis R. Packard, 251 TTditorials: ' Ancient Herbals, 116 L-Jaitian Medicine, History of, Robert P. Bibliothica Osleriana, Francis R. Pack­ 1 1 Parsons, 291 ard, 741 Hammett, Frederick S.: Anatomical Knowl­ California Medical History Seminar, 741 edge of the Ancient Hindus, 325 Home of John Hunter in London, Harvei, Guilielmi, Exercitatio Anatomica de Francis R. Packard, 611 Motu Cordis, review of, Francis R. Pack­ Hygiene in the Middle Ages, David ard, 121 Riesman, 243 Harveian Circulation, the Development of Medical Manuscripts, 356 the, Alfred E. Cohn, 16 Proceedings of 5th Annual Meeting of Harvey Family, Memorial Group of, Sir the American Association of the D’Arcy Power, 241 History of Medicine, E. B. Krumb­ Harvey, Samuel C.: The History of Hemosta­ haar, 736 sis. 127 Sir Christopher Wren, Anatomist, 481 Harvey, William, by Archibald Malloch, Elyot, Sir Thomas, “The Castel of Helth” review of, Francis R. Packard, 361 and Its Author, W. G. Aitchison Robert­ Heagerty, John J.: Four Centuries of Medical son, 270 History in Canada, etc., review of, Francis Entwicklung der Lehre von der Herzkrank- R. Packard, 486 heiten, by Max Neuburger, review of, Thomas McCrae, 122 Hemostasis, History of, Samuel C. Harvey, Epilepsy in the Light of History, E. H. 127 Pirkner, 453 Herbals, Ancient, editorial, 116 Esculape chez les Artistes, by Cabanes, review Hindus, Ancient, Anatomical Knowledge of, of, Francis R. Packard, 122 Frederick S. Hammett, 325 History of the Medical Department of the ^/Jacphail, Sir Andrew: Evolution and Life, United States Army, by P. M. Ashburn, .553 review of, Francis R. Packard, 738 Magic to Science, etc., by Charles Singer, History of Medicine, with Medical Chronol­ review of, Francis R. Packard, 244 ogy, etc., by Fielding H. Garrison, review Makers of Nursing History, etc., by Meta of, Francis R. Packard, 246 Rutter Pennock, review of, Francis R. History of Pathology, by Esmond R. Long, Packard, 247 review of, 736 Malloch, Archibald: William Harvey, review History of Printing, etc., by John Clyde of, Francis R. Packard, 361 Oswald, review of, Francis R. Packard, 125 Max von Pettenkofer, etc., by Edgar Erskine Hume, Edgar Erskine: Max von Petten- Hume, review of, Thomas McCrae, 122 kofer, etc., review of, Thomas McCrae, 122 McCrae, Thomas: Die Entwicklung der Hunter, John, the Homes of, in London, Lehre von den Herzkrankheiten, by Max editorial, Francis R. Packard, 611 Neuburger, review of, 122 Hygiene in the Middle Ages, editorial, David Max von Pettenkofer, etc., by Edgar Riesman, 243 Erskine Hume, review of, 122 Old Age, the Major Involution, by Aldred T ntercolonial Aspects of the Revolution, etc., Scott Warthin, review of, 739 by Michael Kraus, review of, 361 McGowan, Frank J., and Eugene H. Pool: Isaac Judaeus, Ms. Copies of Medical Works Surgery at the New York Hospital 100 of, Harvey Friedenwald, 629 Years Ago, 489 Isaacs, Charles Edward, a Forgotten Ameri­ Medical and Allied Topics in Latin Poetry, can Kidney Physiologist, Raymond E. by Heinrich Oppenheimer, review of, Beiter, 363 Francis R. Packard, 613 Medical Leaders from Hippocrates to Osler, ames, Dr., and His Medical Dictionary, by Samuel W. Lambert and George M. J Charles W. Burr, 180 Goodwin, review of, Francis R. Packard, Jenner Note Book, Copy of, LeRoy Crummer, 737 403 Medical Manuscripts, editorial, 356 Johnson, Alba B.: William Potter Memorial Medieval Physician, T. Wingate Todd, 615 Lecture, Introductory, 14 Middleton, William S.: Philip Syng Physick, Johnson’s, Samuel, Medical Experiences, Sir 562 Humphry Rolleston, 540 Miller, Joseph L.: Some Diseases of Ancient Man, 394 LZ'raus, Michael: Intercolonial Aspects of Miller, William S.: William Beaumont and 1 the Revolution, etc., review of, 361 His Book. Elisha North and His Copy of Krumbhaar, Edward B.: Bath Olivers— Beaumont’s Book, 155 Doctor and Biscuit, 253 Millingen, Julius, Lord Byron’s Physician, Bibliographical Matters Pertaining to the Casey A. Wood, 260 Discovery of the Circulation of the Mitchell, S. Weir, Personal Glimpses of, J. Blood, 57 Madison Taylor, 583 Opuscula Selecta Neerlandicorum de Arte Moodie, Roy L.: Studies in Paleopathology Medica: Het Boeck van Surgien van xxiii. Surgery in Pre-Columbian Peru, Thomas Scellinck van Thienen, review 698 of, 362 Moore, Robert A.: Gabriel Honore de Proceedings of 5th Annual Meeting of Riquetti, Count of Mirabeau, 191 American Association of History of Medicine, editorial, 736 NTeuburger, Max: Die Entwicklung der Kyklos, etc., review of, David Riesman, 124 1 Lehre von den Herzkrankheiten, review of, Thomas McCrae, 122 T ambert, Samuel W., and Goodwin, George Newton, Sir Isaac, etc., edited by F. E. M.: Medical Leaders from Hippocrates Brasch, review of, Francis R. Packard, 121 North, Elisha, and His Copy of Beaumont’s to Osler, review of, Francis R. Packard, Book, etc., William S. Miller, 155 737 Larrey, Napoleon’s Chief Surgeon, E. Robert CAld Age, the Major Involution, by Aldred Wiese, 435 Scott Warthin, review of, Thomas McCrae, 739 • Lister, Martin, Zoologist and Physician, S. Old Masterpieces in Surgery, etc., by Alfred Wood, 87 Brown, review of, Francis R. Packard, 488 Littell, Squier, Burton Chance, 50 Oppenheimer, Heinrich: Medical and Allied Long, Esmond R.: History of Pathology, Topics in Latin Poetry, review of, Francis review of, 736 R. Packard, 613 Opuscula Selecta Neerlandicorum de Arte Packard, Francis R.: William Harvey, by Medica: Het Boeck van Surgien van Archibald Malloch, review of, 361 Thomas Scellinck van Thienen, review of, Pare’s “Oeuvres,” Harvey Cushing, Corre­ E. B. Krumbhaar, 362 spondence, 356 Ornstein, Martha: The Role of Scientific Parsons, Robert P.: History of Haitian Societies in the 17th Century, review of, Medicine, 291 Francis R. Packard, 248 Peachey, George C.: John Fewster, 229 da Orta, Garcia, Louis H. Roddis, 198 Peaks of Medical History, by Charles L. Osler Memorial Library, Francis R. Packard, Dana, review of, Elmer H. Funk, 251 614 Pennock, Meta Rutter: Makers of Nursing Osteology, Comparative, Some Early and History, review of, Francis R. Packard, 247 Late Illustrations of, E. W. Gudger, 334 Pennsylvania Hospital, Reminiscences from Oswald, John Clyde: A History of Printing, the Early Days of, Edward A. Strecker, etc., review of, Francis R. Packard, 125 429 Personalities of the Hunterian Epoch, A. E. TDackard, Francis R.: Bibliotheca Osleriana, Mortimer Woolf, 105 editorial, 741 Philately, Medical, a Brief Note on, Fielding Consecratio Medici and Other Papers, by H. Garrison, 451 Harvey Cushing, review of, 252 Physick, Philip Syng, William S. Middleton, Esculape chez les Artistes, by Cabanes, 562 review of, 122 Pinkney, Ninian (Part 1), Frank Lester Exercitatio Anatomica de Motu Cordis Pleadwell, 666 . . . Guilielmi Harvei, review of, 121 Pirkner, E. H.: Epilepsy in the Light of Four Centuries of Medical History in History, 453 Canada, by John J. Heagerty, review of, Pitfield, Robert L.: A Pitiful, Ricketty, 486 Gasping, Staggering, Stuttering Tomfool, From Magic to Science, etc., by Charles .3.83 Singer, review of, 244 Pitiful, Ricketty, Gasping, Staggering, Further Correspondence of John Ray, Stuttering Tomfool, A, Robert L. Pitfield, edited by Robert W. J. Gunther, review 383 of, 251 Pleadwell, Frank Lester: Ninian Pinkney History of the Medical Department of the (Part 1), 666 United States Army, by P. M. Ashburn, Pool, Eugene H., and Frank J. McGowan: review of, 738 Surgery at the New York Hospital 100 History of Medicine, etc., by Fielding H. Years Ago, 489 Garrison, review of, 246 Power, Sir D’Arcy: A Memorial Group of the History of Printing, etc., by John Clyde Harvey Family, 241 Oswald, review of, 125 Public Health Movement in the United Makers of Nursing History, etc., by Meta States, Origins and Significance of, Richard Rutter Pennock, review of, 247 H. Shryock, 645 Medical and Allied Topics in Latin Poetry, by Heinrich Oppenheimer, review of, 613 J^amsay, David, Carnes Weeks, 600 Medical Leaders from Hippocrates to Osler, by Samuel W. Lambert and George M. Goodwin, review of, 737 Rene Theophile Hyacinthe Laennec, by Old Masterpieces in Surgery, by Alfred Gerald B. Webb, review of, James J. Brown, review of, 488 Waring, 360 Osler Memorial Library, 614 Riesman, David: Grundlagen und Ziele der Role of Scientific Societies in the 17th Medizin der Gegenwart, by Theodor Century, by Martha Ornstein, review of, Brugsch et al., review of, 123 248 Hygiene in the Middle Ages, Editorial, 243 Short History of Medicine, etc., by Charles Kyklos, etc., review of, 124 Singer, review of, 250 de Riquetti, Gabriel Honore, Count of Sir Isaac Newton, etc., edited by F. E. Mirabeau, Robert A. Moore, 191 Brasch, review of, 121 Robertson, W. G. Aitchison: “The Castel of Storia della Medicina, by Arturo Castigli- Helth” and Its Author, Sir Thomas Elyot, oni, review of, 126 270 The Homes of John Hunter in London, Roddis, Louis H.: Garcia da Orta, 198 Editorial, 611 Role of Scientific Societies in the 17th The Sack-’Em Up Men, etc., by James Century, by Martha Ornstein, review of, Moores Ball, review of, 359 Francis R. Packard, 248 RoIIeston, Sir Humphry: Samuel Johnson’s '"Taylor, J. Madison: Personal Glimpses of Medical Experiences, 540 A S. Weir Mitchell, 583 RoIIeston, Sir Humphry Davy: Cardio­ Thomson, Sir St. Clair: The Strenuous Life vascular Diseases Since Harvey’s Dis­ of a Physician in the 18th Century, 1 covery, review of, 360 Todd, T. Wingate: The Medieval Physician, Rush, Homer P.: A Biographic Sketch of 615 Arnold Adolf Berthold, 208 Toomey, Thomas N.: The First General Medical Treatise Published in the Western Qack-’Em Up Men, The, etc., by James Hemisphere, 215 Moores Ball, review of, Francis R. Pack­ Treatise, The First General Medical, ard, 359 Published in the New World, Thomas N. Samuel Johnson’s Medical Experiences, Sir Toomey, 215 Humphry RoIIeston, 540 Short History of Medicine, etc., by Charles yWagoner, G. W.: An Etruscan Bronze Singer, review of, Francis R. Packard, 250 * * Statuette Depicting a Posterior Superior Shryock, Richard H.: Origins and Signifi­ Dislocation of the Hip, 599 cance of Public Health Movement in the Walsh, Joseph: Date of Galen’s Birth, 378 United States, 645 Waring, James J.: Rene Theophile Hya­ Singer, Charles: A Short History of Medicine, cinthe Laennec, by Gerald B. Webb, review etc., review of, Francis R. Packard, 250 of, 360 From Magic to Science, etc., review of, Waring, Joseph Ioor: An Incident in Early Francis R. Packard, 244 South Carolina Medicine, 608 South Carolina Medicine, Early, an Incident Warthin, Aldred Scott: Old Age, the Major in, Joseph Ioor Waring, 608 Involution, review of, Thomas McCrae, 739 Statuette, Etruscan Bronze, Depicting a Webb, Gerald B.: Rene Theophile Hyacinthe Posterior Superior Dislocation of the Hip, Laennec, review of, James J. Waring, 360 G. W. Wagoner, 599 Weeks, Carnes: David Ramsay, 600 Storia della Medicina, by Arturo Castiglioni, Wiese, E. Robert: Larrey, Napoleon’s Chief review of, Francis R. Packard, 126 Surgeon, 435 Strecker, Edward A.: Reminiscences from the William Potter Memorial Lecture, Intro­ Early Days of the Pennsylvania Hospital, ductory, Alba B. Johnson, 14 429 Wood, Casey A.: Julius Millingen, Lord Strenuous Life of a Physician in the 18th Byron’s Physician, 260 Century, Sir St. Clair Thomson, 1 Wood, S.: Martin Lister, Zoologist and Physi­ Studies in Paleopathology, xxm. Surgery in Pre-Columbian Peru, Roy L. Moodie, cian, 87 698 Woolf, A. E. Mortimer: Some Personalities Surgery at the New York Hospital 100 Years of the Hunterian Epoch, 105 Ago, Eugene H. Pool and Frank J. Wren, Sir Christopher, Anatomist, Editorial, 481

Paul B. Hoeber, Inc., 76 Fifth Avenue, New York