DOCSLIB.ORG

Report to the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Report to the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government The Planning Inspectorate Report to the Secretary of 4/09 Kite Wing Temple Quay House 2 The Square State for Communities and Temple Quay Bristol BS1 6PN 0117 372 6372 Local Government e-mail: enquiries@planning- inspectorate.gsi.gov.uk by D R Cullingford BA MPhil MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Date 2 March 2007 Local Government CITY OF YORK COUNCIL Applications by PERSIMMON HOMES (YORKSHIRE) LIMITED & HOGG BUILDERS (YORK) LIMITED & THE JOSEPH ROWNTREE HOUSING TRUST Inquiry held from 13 June to 24 July 2006 Formal site visits undertaken on 25 & 28 July 2006 with additional visits on 30 & 31 August and 19-21 September 2006 Land at Germany Beck, east of Fordlands Road, Fulford, York, & Land west of Metcalfe Lane, Osbaldwick, York File References: APP/C2741/V/05/1189897 & YH 5343/310/2 APP/C2741/V/05/1189885 & YH 5343/310/1 Report: APP/C2741/V/05/1189897 & APP/C2741/V/05/1189885 CONTENTS 1. PROCEDURAL MATTERS ............................................................................................................................................ 3 THE SCHEMES IN OUTLINE; AGREEMENTS AND CONDITIONS...................................................................................................... 4 THE PRE INQUIRY MEETING...................................................................................................................................................... 6 The state of planning policy in York.................................................................................................................................... 6 New and emerging policy .................................................................................................................................................... 7 Criticism of some Council decisions.................................................................................................................................... 8 Human Rights...................................................................................................................................................................... 9 THE NEED FOR EIA ................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Germany Beck ..................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Derwenthorpe.................................................................................................................................................................... 10 2. THE SITES AND THEIR SURROUNDINGS.............................................................................................................. 12 GERMANY BECK ..................................................................................................................................................................... 12 The site .............................................................................................................................................................................. 12 The surroundings............................................................................................................................................................... 13 Pedestrians and cyclists .................................................................................................................................................... 14 Public transport................................................................................................................................................................. 15 Roads and traffic ............................................................................................................................................................... 15 DERWENTHORPE ..................................................................................................................................................................... 16 The site .............................................................................................................................................................................. 16 The surroundings............................................................................................................................................................... 17 Pedestrians and cyclists .................................................................................................................................................... 18 Public transport................................................................................................................................................................. 19 Roads and traffic ............................................................................................................................................................... 19 3. THE PROPOSALS.......................................................................................................................................................... 21 GERMANY BECK ..................................................................................................................................................................... 21 Design and layout ............................................................................................................................................................................. 21 Open space and landscaping............................................................................................................................................................. 21 Housing and sustainability................................................................................................................................................................ 22 Sustainable travel.............................................................................................................................................................................. 22 Operations and environmental protection......................................................................................................................................... 23 DERWENTHORPE ..................................................................................................................................................................... 23 Design and layout ............................................................................................................................................................................. 24 Open space and landscaping............................................................................................................................................................. 25 Housing and sustainability................................................................................................................................................................ 26 Sustainable travel.............................................................................................................................................................................. 26 Operations and environmental protection......................................................................................................................................... 27 CASES FOR THOSE IN FAVOUR OF THE APPLICATIONS ......................................................................................... 28 4. THE CASE FOR PERSIMMON HOMES AND HOGG BUILDERS ....................................................................... 28 PLANS AND PREMATURITY ...................................................................................................................................................... 28 HOUSING; NUMBERS, MARKETS AND NEEDS............................................................................................................................ 30 Numerical housing requirements....................................................................................................................................... 30 The market and the requirement for family housing.......................................................................................................... 31 Meeting the need for affordable housing........................................................................................................................... 32 The need for affordable housing....................................................................................................................................................... 32 The provision of affordable housing................................................................................................................................................. 32 SITE SELECTION;GERMANY BECK .......................................................................................................................................... 34 Is there a sequentially preferable site?.............................................................................................................................. 34 Is the location sustainable? ............................................................................................................................................... 34 THE SUITABILITY OF THE SCHEME;GERMANY BECK............................................................................................................... 35 Is the scheme ‘designed for
Load more

Recommended publications
  • BRI 51 1 Shorter-Contributions 307..387
    318 SHORTER CONTRIBUTIONS An Early Roman Fort at Thirkleby, North Yorkshire By MARTIN MILLETT and RICHARD BRICKSTOCK ABSTRACT This paper reports the discovery through aerial photography of a Roman fort at Thirkleby, near Thirsk in North Yorkshire. It appears to have two structural phases, and surface finds indicate that it dates from the Flavian period. The significance of its location on the intersection of routes north–south along the edge of the Vale of York and east–west connecting Malton and Aldborough is discussed in the context of Roman annexation of the North. Keywords: Thirkleby; Roman fort; Roman roads; Yorkshire INTRODUCTION The unusually dry conditions in northern England in the summer of 2018 produced a substantial crop of new sites discovered through aerial photography. By chance, the Google Earth satellite image coverage for parts of Yorkshire has been updated with a set of images taken on 1 July 2018, during the drought. Amongst the numerous sites revealed in this imagery – often in areas where crop-marks are rarely visible – is a previously unknown Roman fort (FIG.1).1 The site (SE 4718 7728) lies just to the west of the modern A19, on the southern side of the Thirkleby beck at its confluence with the Carr Dike stream, about 6 km south-east of Thirsk. It is situated on level ground at a height of about 32 m above sea level on the southern edge of the flood plain of the beck, which is clearly visible on the aerial images. A further narrow relict stream bed runs beside it to the south-east.
    [Show full text]
  • Yorkshire GREEN Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study
    Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Yorkshire GREEN Project Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study (YG-NSC-00001) National Grid National Grid House Warwick Technology Park Gallows Hill Warwick CV34 6DA Final - March 2021 Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Page intentionally blank Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Document Control Document Properties Organisation AECOM Ltd Author Alison Williams Approved by Michael Williams Title Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Document Reference YG-NSC-00001 Version History Date Version Status Description/Changes 02 March 2021 V8 Final version Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Page intentionally blank Yorkshire GREEN Project – Corridor and Preliminary Routeing and Siting Study Report Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Overview and Purpose 1 1.2 Background and Need 3 1.3 Description of the Project 3 1.4 Structure of this Report 7 1.5 The Project Team 7 2. APPROACH TO ROUTEING AND SITING 8 2.1 Overview of National Grid’s Approach 8 2.2 Route and Site Selection Process 11 2.3 Overview of Stages of Development 11 3. THE STUDY AREA 16 3.1 Introduction 16 3.2 York North Study Area 16 3.3 Tadcaster Study Area 17 3.4 Monk Fryston Study Area 17 4. YORK NORTH OPTIONS APPRAISAL 19 4.1 Approach to Appraisal 19 4.2 CSEC Siting Area Identification 19 4.3 Substation Siting Area Identification 19 4.4 Overhead Line Routeing Identification 20 4.5 Combination Options 20 4.6 Screening of York North Options 24 4.7 Options Appraisal Summary of Remaining York North Options 28 4.8 The Holford Rules and Horlock Rules 76 4.9 York North Preferred Option 76 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Mary Rose Trust 2013 Annual Report
    Annual Review 2013 Learning Conservation Heritage Mary Rose Annual Review 2013_v11.indd 1 20/06/2013 15:49 2 www.maryrose.org Annual Review 2013 Mary Rose Annual Review 2013_v11.indd 2 20/06/2013 15:49 Annual Review 2013 www.maryrose.org 3 Mary Rose Annual Review 2013_v11.indd 3 20/06/2013 15:49 4 www.maryrose.org Annual Review 2013 Mary Rose Annual Review 2013_v11.indd 4 20/06/2013 15:50 Chairman & Chief Executive Foreword This last year has been momentous for the Mary Rose Trust, In tandem with this, much research is opening up to the Trust and the achievements have been of national and international and is now higher in our priorities. The human remains, importance. The Mary Rose Project has been an exemplar now boldly explained more fully in our exhibition, can be of both excavation and conservation over its thirty plus year studied scientifically for the secrets they can reveal. Medical history, but experts from afar now declare the new museum research is included within our ambitions and we will be to be the exemplar of exhibition for future generations. New working with leading universities in this area. Similarly, standards have been set, and the success of our ambition has our Head of Collections is already involved in pioneering been confirmed by the early comments being received. work in new forms of conservation techniques, which could revolutionise the affordability and timescales of future Elsewhere in this review you will read more about the projects. These are just two examples of a number of areas challenges that were met in reaching this point.
    [Show full text]
  • Parish Council Meeting Agenda – 12Th September 2016 19.30 Tower Room St Nicholas Church
    DUNNINGTON PARISH COUNCIL Chairman : Cllr Stuart Kay Tel : 01904 488357 Clerk : Julie Bone Tel : 01904 672199 Email : [email protected] Parish Council Meeting Agenda – 12th September 2016 19.30 Tower Room St Nicholas Church 1 FORMALITIES 1.1 Apologies and reasons for non-attendance Cllr Josette Farmer - Away 1.2 Parish Council approval of Apologies and reasons for absence 1.3 Previous Meeting Minutes (11/7/16). 1.4 Declaration of Interest 2 POLICE REPORT 2.1 Police Report 3 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION Any member of the parish may speak for up to 5 minutes on any matter on the Agenda with the session lasting no more than 20 minutes 4 PREFERRED SITES CONSULTATION 4.1 Discussion by the PC on the Preferred sites Consultation 5 SCOUT HUT 5.1 Scout hut – Follow up to July Meeting 6 COMMON ROAD – TRANSPORT ISSUES 7 LEGAL SUPPORT 8 INTERNAL AUDITOR 9 AMATEUR ADVERTISING 10 YORKSHIRE MARATHON 11 LOCAL AND NEIGHBOURHOOD PLANS 11.1 Update on the Local Plan – Cllr J Brooks 11.2 Update on the DPC Neighbourhood Plan – Cllr S Kay 11.3 Housing allocation Neighbourhood Plan – Cllr A Brooks 12 FINANCE AND CORRESPONDENCE 12.1 Full updated Accounts and Accruals to date for 2016/17 12.2 Correspondence – See list below of previously circulated correspondence. 12.3 Report Finance and Strategy group – Cllr A Brooks 13 REVIEWS 13.1 Local projects – Cllr S Kay 13.2 PFA Update – Cllr J Farmer 13.3 Web site – Cllr A Dykes 13.4 In-Bloom – Cllr R Freer 13.5 Environment – Cllr L Turnbull 13.5.1 Grimme Site 13.6 Cemetery – Cllr N Ford 13.7 Playpark – Cllr J Maggs 13.8 Transport – Cllr J Maggs 13.9 Emergency Plan – Cllr L Black 14 PLANNING - Ongoing Applications 14.1 Dunnington Lodge Cottage Elvington Lane Dunnington York YO19 5LT - Fell Cypress tree in a Conservation Area 14.2 Quality Clinical Reagents 15 Chessingham Park Dunnington York YO19 5SE - Variation of condition 2 of permitted application 15/00756/FUL to add first floor escape door and external metal staircase to rear 14.3 Kiln Cottage 13 Common Road Dunnington York YO19 5NG - Erection of 1no.
    [Show full text]
  • Leisure Ride 7, Foss Islands Cycle Track to Murton
    YORK CYCLE ROUTE MAP Start & Ride Notes Finish Easy cycle rides 1 Foss Islands Cycle Track takes you all the way for leisure to Osbaldwick along the route of the former Derwent Valley Light Railway which amongst One of a series of short rides other things, brought sugar beet from the suitable for most ages and abilities York countryside to Rowntree’s factory. It ran from Ce ntre 1913 until about 1980. Sustrans (Sustainable River Ouse Time: 1 hr 10 mins Transport) owns and manages the track as part Part of the York Cycle Route Map of Route 66. 2 Time: This ride may take 40 minutes on the way there and St. Nicholas Field – local nature reserve and 30 minutes on the return journey. environmental community centre. Route info: Approx 7 miles. Half on Foss Islands cycle track Ride 3 Potential new housing scheme site. Consultations which is motor traffic free until Osbaldwick then on country N 7 roads with traffic. The traffic varies with time of day and are taking place with planners to make sure the whether it is market day at the Cattle Market. cycle track is preserved and improved. 4 Holiday cottages. 5 Yorkshire Museum of Farming now called Murton Park because it incorporates a section of the Derwent Valley Light Railway, a Viking village and a Roman Fort. These are used in Cycling City York is a community-led partnership project involving City of York Council, cycle campaign groups, major employers, education themed school visits. You can visit the café and healthcare providers and cycle retailers.
    [Show full text]
  • Ships!), Maps, Lighthouses
    Price £2.00 (free to regular customers) 03.03.21 List up-dated Winter 2020 S H I P S V E S S E L S A N D M A R I N E A R C H I T E C T U R E 03.03.20 Update PHILATELIC SUPPLIES (M.B.O'Neill) 359 Norton Way South Letchworth Garden City HERTS ENGLAND SG6 1SZ (Telephone; 01462-684191 during my office hours 9.15-3.15pm Mon.-Fri.) Web-site: www.philatelicsupplies.co.uk email: [email protected] TERMS OF BUSINESS: & Notes on these lists: (Please read before ordering). 1). All stamps are unmounted mint unless specified otherwise. Prices in Sterling Pounds we aim to be HALF-CATALOGUE PRICE OR UNDER 2). Lists are updated about every 12-14 weeks to include most recent stock movements and New Issues; they are therefore reasonably accurate stockwise 100% pricewise. This reduces the need for "credit notes" and refunds. Alternatives may be listed in case some items are out of stock. However, these popular lists are still best used as soon as possible. Next listings will be printed in 4, 8 & 12 months time so please indicate when next we should send a list on your order form. 3). New Issues Services can be provided if you wish to keep your collection up to date on a Standing Order basis. Details & forms on request. Regret we do not run an on approval service. 4). All orders on our order forms are attended to by return of post. We will keep a photocopy it and return your annotated original.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 City of York Biodiversity Action Plan
    CITY OF YORK Local Biodiversity Action Plan 2017 City of York Local Biodiversity Action Plan - Executive Summary What is biodiversity and why is it important? Biodiversity is the variety of all species of plant and animal life on earth, and the places in which they live. Biodiversity has its own intrinsic value but is also provides us with a wide range of essential goods and services such as such as food, fresh water and clean air, natural flood and climate regulation and pollination of crops, but also less obvious services such as benefits to our health and wellbeing and providing a sense of place. We are experiencing global declines in biodiversity, and the goods and services which it provides are consistently undervalued. Efforts to protect and enhance biodiversity need to be significantly increased. The Biodiversity of the City of York The City of York area is a special place not only for its history, buildings and archaeology but also for its wildlife. York Minister is an 800 year old jewel in the historical crown of the city, but we also have our natural gems as well. York supports species and habitats which are of national, regional and local conservation importance including the endangered Tansy Beetle which until 2014 was known only to occur along stretches of the River Ouse around York and Selby; ancient flood meadows of which c.9-10% of the national resource occurs in York; populations of Otters and Water Voles on the River Ouse, River Foss and their tributaries; the country’s most northerly example of extensive lowland heath at Strensall Common; and internationally important populations of wetland birds in the Lower Derwent Valley.
    [Show full text]
  • Making a Sustainable Community: Life in Derwenthorpe, York, 2012–2018
    Making a sustainable community: life in Derwenthorpe, York, 2012–2018 by Deborah Quilgars, Alison Dyke, Alison Wallace and Sarah West This report presents the results of a six-year evaluation of Derwenthorpe, an urban extension of about 500 homes in York, developed by the Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust (JRHT) and David Wilson Homes. The research documented the extent to which it met its aims to create a socially and environmentally sustainable community ‘fit for the 21st century’. Making a sustainable community: life in Derwenthorpe, York, 2012– 2018 Deborah Quilgars, Alison Dyke, Alison Wallace and Sarah West This report presents the results of a six-year evaluation of Derwenthorpe, an urban extension of about 500 homes in York, developed by the Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust (JRHT) and David Wilson Homes. The research documented the extent to which it met its aims to create a socially and environmentally sustainable community ‘fit for the 21st century’. The research demonstrated that mainstream housing developers can successfully deliver sustainable homes and communities at scale, in particular delivering high-quality living environments. However, technical build issues and differential buy-in from residents means that environmental and social measures need to be built into the model as far as possible from the outset. The research involved an environmental survey and longitudinal qualitative interviews to document residents’ experiences over the period 2012–2018. It also compared Derwenthorpe with three other sustainable housing developments in England. Actions • Greater emphasis on the design, space standards and aesthetics of new developments should be incorporated into Government-level directives. • Housing providers must work with resident groups to set up inclusive governance structures to promote the long-term social sustainability of communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Third Local Transport Strategy 2011 to 2021
    Keep Tyne and Wear Moving LTP3: The Third Local Transport Plan for Tyne and Wear Strategy 2011 - 2021 March 2011 Contents Foreword by the Chair of the ITA 2 Executive Summary Executive Summary i Part 1: Introduction and background Chapter 1 Introduction 2 1.1 About this document 2 1.2 Role of the Local Transport Plan 3 1.3 Building on the achievements of LTP2 3 1.4 Review of document 5 Chapter 2 Statutory assessments of the LTP 8 2.1 Introduction 8 2.2 Strategic Environmental Assessment 8 2.3 Health Impact Assessment 8 2.4 Equality Impact Assessment 9 2.5 Habitats Regulation Assessment 9 Chapter 3 Changes from Draft to Final 12 3.1 Listening to transport users 12 3.2 Summary of responses 13 3.3 Summary of changes 15 Chapter 4 Context 22 4.1 Policy context 22 4.2 Transport geography of Tyne and Wear 27 4.2.1 Overview 27 4.2.2 Tyne and Wear's transport network 30 4.3 Socio-economic background 41 4.4 Sustainability Baseline and Key Issues 47 4.5 Trends and forecasts 49 Part 2: Objectives, key issues and challenges Chapter 5 The Vision 56 Chapter 6 Supporting economic development and regeneration 59 6.1 Regeneration goals 59 Tyne and Wear Local Transport Plan 3 Strategy 2011-21 Contents 6.2 Reduce the gap between Tyne and Wear's economic growth rate and other English regions 61 6.3 Reliability and predictability of journey times 61 6.4 Connectivity and access to labour markets 62 6.5 Housing provision 64 6.6 Resilience 64 Chapter 7 Addressing climate change 67 7.1 Introduction 67 7.2 Targets 69 7.3 Forecasts for Tyne and Wear 72 7.4 Meeting
    [Show full text]
  • Agenda Reports Pack (Public) 01/04/2014, 17.30
    Notice of a public meeting of Cabinet To: Councillors Alexander (Chair), Crisp, Cunningham- Cross, Levene, Looker, Merrett, Simpson-Laing (Vice- Chair) and Williams Date: Tuesday, 1 April 2014 Time: 5.30 pm Venue: The George Hudson Board Room - 1st Floor West Offices (F045) A G E N D A Notice to Members - Calling In : Members are reminded that, should they wish to call in any item* on this agenda, notice must be given to Democracy Support Group by 4:00 pm on Thursday 3 April 2014 . *With the exception of matters that have been the subject of a previous call in, require Full Council approval or are urgent which are not subject to the call-in provisions. Any called in items will be considered by the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Committee. 1. Declarations of Interest At this point, Members are asked to declare: • any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests • any prejudicial interests or • any disclosable pecuniary interests which they may have in respect of business on this agenda. 2. Exclusion of Press and Public To consider the exclusion of the press and public from the meeting during consideration of the following: Annexes 1 to 4 to Agenda Item 8 (Formation of a Y.P.O. Limited Company) on the grounds that they contain information relating to the financial or business affairs of any particular person (including the authority holding that information). This information is classed as exempt under paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A to Section 100A of the Local Government Act 1972 (as revised by The Local Government (Access to Information) (Variation) Order 2006).
    [Show full text]
  • Statement of Common Ground Natural England
    A19 / A184 Testo’s Junction Improvement TR010020 7.7(1) Statement of Common Ground Natural England Planning Act 2008 Rule 8(1)(e) Infrastructure Planning (Examination Procedure) Rules 2010 Volume 7 March 2018 A19 / A184 Testo’s Junction Improvement Statement of Common Ground – Natural England Infrastructure Planning Planning Act 2008 The Infrastructure Planning (Examination Procedure) Rules 2010 A19 / A184 TESTO’S JUNCTION IMPROVEMENT The A19 / A184 (Testo’s Junction Improvement) Development Consent Order 201[ ] ______________________________________________ Statement of Common Ground – Natural England ______________________________________________ Regulation Number: Rule 8(1)(e) Planning Inspectorate Scheme TR010020 Reference Application Document Reference TR010020/APP/7.7(1) Author: A19 Project Team, Highways England & Jacobs Version Date Status of Version Rev 1 March 2018 Updated for Examination Deadline 5 Rev 0 November 2017 Submitted for Examination Deadline 1 Planning Inspectorate Scheme Ref: TR010020 Application Document Ref: TR010020/APP/7.7(1) (Volume 7) A19 / A184 Testo’s Junction Improvement Statement of Common Ground – Natural England Page Left Intentionally Blank Planning Inspectorate Scheme Ref: TR010020 Application Document Ref: TR010020/APP/7.7(1) (Volume 7) A19 / A184 Testos Junction Improvement Development Consent Order Planning Inspectorate Reference: TR010020 Statement of Common Ground Between HIGHWAYS ENGLAND and NATURAL ENGLAND Document control Document properties Parties Highways England and Natural England Author
    [Show full text]
  • 'The Admiralty War Staff and Its Influence on the Conduct of The
    ‘The Admiralty War Staff and its influence on the conduct of the naval between 1914 and 1918.’ Nicholas Duncan Black University College University of London. Ph.D. Thesis. 2005. UMI Number: U592637 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U592637 Published by ProQuest LLC 2013. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 CONTENTS Page Abstract 4 Acknowledgements 5 Abbreviations 6 Introduction 9 Chapter 1. 23 The Admiralty War Staff, 1912-1918. An analysis of the personnel. Chapter 2. 55 The establishment of the War Staff, and its work before the outbreak of war in August 1914. Chapter 3. 78 The Churchill-Battenberg Regime, August-October 1914. Chapter 4. 103 The Churchill-Fisher Regime, October 1914 - May 1915. Chapter 5. 130 The Balfour-Jackson Regime, May 1915 - November 1916. Figure 5.1: Range of battle outcomes based on differing uses of the 5BS and 3BCS 156 Chapter 6: 167 The Jellicoe Era, November 1916 - December 1917. Chapter 7. 206 The Geddes-Wemyss Regime, December 1917 - November 1918 Conclusion 226 Appendices 236 Appendix A.
    [Show full text]