Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems
7.0 DIESEL ENGINE STARTING nuclear facilities must be capable of SYSTEMS achieving a minimum voltage and frequency upon initiation of a "start" signal. This chapter presents the requirements for Both conditions must be achieved within an starting a diesel engine for an EDG in a acceptable time frame that meets the nuclear plant and the equipment and plant’s Technical Specifications. systems required to accomplish it. Typical specifications involve the engine Learning Objectives starting from keepwarm conditions and accelerating to a minimum, self-sustaining As a result of this lesson, you will be able to: rotational speed (RPM). Simultaneously, the generator must establish the required 1. Describe the requirements for starting voltage and frequency all within the time an Emergency Diesel Generator in a limits specified. An example of a set of nuclear plant application. typical EDG specifications is given below:
2. Identify the components and describe • 60 Hz + 1.2 Hz the operation of a direct air injection, com-pressed air diesel engine starting • Rated Voltage (4000 + 320 volts) system. • < 10 seconds 3. Identify the components and describe the operation of an air motor type, com- 7.2 Starting Characteristics pressed air diesel engine starting system. By reviewing the operational characteristics of the diesel engine, we can gain a better 4. Identify the components and describe understanding of what is required of the the operation of a typical starting air starting system. supply system used in a nuclear plant application. 7.2.1 Admission of Air
5. Identify the components and describe A fresh charge of air must enter the the operation of an electric diesel cylinder during the intake event to provide engine starting system for a nuclear the oxygen required to support combustion application diesel engine. of the fuel. This is accomplished by either of two ways. For a 4-stroke cycle engine, 7.1 Technical Specification Starting this is accomplished by the downward Requirements motion of the piston during the intake stroke. For a 2-stroke cycle engine, the In accordance with the applicable pumping action of the engine-driven blower regulatory requirements, emergency diesel (positive displacement or centrifugal) generators specified for use as emergency delivers the air charge to the cylinders. onsite power supplies at commercial
Rev 1/11 7-1 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems
7.2.2 Compression of Air Charge any pressure lost past the piston rings and valves and any heat lost to the incoming air Once the cylinder has been charged with charge or relatively cool internal fresh air, the rapid upward or inward components of the engine. Assuming the movement of the piston compresses the air engine is mechanically sound, the charge, increasing its temperature to a compression, and therefore ignition point higher than that required to ignite the temperature, becomes a function of the fuel. engine compression ratio, valve or port timing, and cranking speed. 7.2.3 Injection of Fuel The single most important element in With the piston near to top or inner most attaining the compression pressure, and point of its stroke, fuel is injected into the therefore the air charge temperature heated air charge where combustion required for ignition of the fuel, is the occurs and power is delivered to the cranking or rotational speed of the engine crankshaft. As the cylinders begin to fire, during the starting sequence. Figure 7-1 the engine achieves self-sustained depicts a typical relationship between the operation. cranking speed (RPM) and the compression pressure (PSIG) achieved for For the three activities listed to occur, the a high speed diesel engine. Several engine crankshaft must be rotated by an factors contribute to this relationship: external source of power. The engine starting system stores energy either as • The more rapid the rate of compression compressed air in the system’s air is, the higher the pressure and receivers or as chemical energy in the temperature of the air charge. designated storage batteries. Upon initiation of a start signal, the stored energy • Rapid compression allows less time for is converted into the mechanical energy pressure to be lost past the piston rings needed to rotate the engine components. and valves.
7.2.4 Compression Characteristics • At higher cranking speeds, less time is available for the heat of compression to Charging the cylinder with air and injecting be lost from the engine cylinders. the fuel at the proper time are basic functions of crankshaft rotation. Crankshaft 7.3 Starting System Capability rotation also causes the air charge to be compressed; however, the rotation alone In addition to the engine start criteria listed does not ensure the air charge will reach in section 7.2, the EDG starting system the temperature needed to ignite the fuel must have a capacity and redundancy injected into the cylinder. commensurate with the safety function of the unit. The actual temperature achieved is a function of the compression pressure minus 7.3.1 System Capacity
Rev 1/11 7-2 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems
Each starting system must have an energy 7.3.3 Energy Storage System storage capacity sufficient to support a specific number of start attempts prior to The energy required for starting the EDG is reaching a low energy level (e.g. low air stored as compressed air in designated air pressure, low battery voltage). For receivers or as chemical energy stored in a example, a starting air system may be battery bank. In either system, a minimum required to perform two consecutive start energy level must be maintained at all attempts before reaching a specified low times for the unit to be considered pressure of 150 psig. operable.
The generic nuclear application starting air With the compressed air systems, the system also provides control air for diesel receivers must be kept above a minimum engine controls and instrumentation during pressure. This is accomplished by air standby and during operation. The control compressors which automatically recharge air portion of the Starting Air System will be the system when the low pressure limit is discussed in Chapter 10, "Emergency reached. For electric powered systems, Diesel Generator Control and Monitoring." the batteries are maintained at a voltage above the minimum electrical storage 7.3.2 System Redundancy capacity by the battery charging systems. The electric system will be discussed in To preclude a single failure, which could greater detail later in this chapter. prevent the engine from starting, each unit is required to be equipped with two parallel, 7.4 Starting Air Systems non-connected redundant starting systems. Each system must be capable of starting There are two types of compressed air the EDG in the event of a failure in the starting systems used in nuclear plant other system. applications: the direct air injection system shown in Figure 7-2A and the air motor In some specifications, the requirement system shown in Figure 7-2B. In both was to attempt to start the engine on one systems, air is stored under pressure in air system and then go to the second receiver tanks. Quick opening solenoid- (redundant) system if the engine failed to operated air admission valves prevent air start. This philosophy wastes time and from reaching the engine until actuated by probably results in a failed start in that the an engine start signal. unit would not be up to rated speed in the required time. 7.4.1 Direct Air Injection Systems
All of the systems furnished to date use This system is also often referred to as the both systems simultaneously (in tandem) 'air over piston' or the 'cylinder air start' such that if one system failed, the other system. system would automatically start the unit with only an extended time probable, but With the direct air injection system (Figure not a failure to start. 7-2A), air under pressure is applied to the
Rev 1/11 7-3 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems inlet of the Starting Air Admission Valve This is usually controlled by a speed and to the Starting Air Solenoid Valve. sensing device monitoring the engine With no start signal present, both valves speed (RPM). The Solenoid Valve then remain closed. Upon receiving a "start" closes, allowing the Air Admission Valve to signal, the Solenoid Valve opens, directing close. Air then vents from the Starting Air air to the Air Admission Valve pilot section, Distributor and Starting Air Header. This causing the main valve to open. allows the spring-loaded Starting Air Check Valves to close and returns the engine Downstream of the Air Admission Valve, starting air system to the standby mode. the air flow is split. The major portion of the air is passed to the Starting Air Header. A 7.4.1.1 Starting Air Admission Valves small portion of the air is also directed to the Starting Air Distributor. Air from the Figure 7-3 shows a typical pilot-operated, Starting Air Header enters each of the poppet type Starting Admission Valve. The Starting Air Check Valves. Starting Air Solenoid Valve is generally mounded Check Valves, where used, are mounted in directly to the Admission Valve. In other each of the engine cylinder heads. For the applications, the Solenoid Valve may be Fairbanks-Morse Opposed Piston engine, mounted remotely to the Admission Valve the starting air check valves mount through and connected by pipe or tubing. the wall of the cylinder liner. The design of these valves is such that they will remain In the standby mode, the spring-loaded closed until acted upon by a pilot signal valve poppet is held in the closed position from the Starting Air Distributor. by the force of the spring. Air from the air receiver enters the valve as shown. The The Starting Air Distributor, driven by the design of the valve poppet is such that the engines camshaft or accessory drive gear air pressure acting against the poppet is train, provides a pilot air signal in proper balanced by the equal areas of the valve sequence to each of the Starting Air Check poppet. The force of the spring is sufficient Valves. At the appropriate time, usually a to keep the valve closed. A portion of the few degrees past Top Dead Center (TDC), air entering the valve (pilot air) is directed the pilot air signal is applied to each to the inlet of the Solenoid Valve. In Starting Air Check Valve, causing it to standby, the Solenoid Valve is also closed open. Starting air, under pressure, is (not energized). admitted directly into the engine cylinder. This air pressure rapidly pushes each When a "start" signal is generated, it is piston downward in succession. As each applied to the Solenoid Valve. This signal piston is later moving upward, the air energizes the solenoid coil. The magnetic charge is compressed in preparation for field created lifts the valve plunger, opening injection of the fuel. the valve. Pilot air is then directed through the signal port (orifice) to the top of the pilot As the engine achieves self-sustained piston (part of the valve poppet). The force operational speed, a signal from the control of the air pressure applied to the pilot system shuts off the starting air supply. piston exceeds the force of the spring
Rev 1/11 7-4 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems holding the poppet in the closed position. closed, no air is applied to the Starting Air This differential force causes the valve Distributor. With no air pressure present, poppet to move downward, opening the the distributor spool valves are held in the valve. Air from the air receiver passes off cam or vent position by the force of the freely through the valve and on to the spring as shown in Figure 7-5. This Starting Air Header and Starting Air prevents the spool valve from contacting Distributor. the timing cam during normal engine operation or standby. Loss of a "start" signal closes the Solenoid Valve, which vents air from the pilot piston. When a 'start' signal is generated, the air Spring force causes the valve poppet to admission valve opens supplying high close returning to a standby mode. pressure starting air to the internal passages of the distributor housing. This 7.4.1.2 Starting Air Distributor air pressure forces the spool valves downward into contact with the timing cam Since the Starting Air Check Valves must as shown in Figure 7-6. In the high cam open at a specific time relative to the position, the spool valve is held in the vent position of the piston in the cylinder, a position, and no pilot air signal is applies to Starting Air Distributor is needed and the associated Starting Air Check Valve. provided. The Starting Air Distributor, which is timed from the engine camshaft(s) Rotation of the timing cam will eventually or other portion of the engine gear train, align the low portion of the cam with the directs a pilot signal to each Start Air Check spool valve as shown in Figure 7-7. The Valve, when the piston is slightly after top pressure of the starting air from the internal dead center and maintains that signal until passages of the distributor housing will the movement of the piston reaches keep the spool valve in contact with the approximately 120o after top dead center. timing cam. The spool valve moves A typical Start Air Distributor is shown in downward blocking the vent port and Figure 7-4. connecting the Starting Air Check Valve port. Starting air pressure is then applied The Starting Air Distributor consists of a to the pilot piston of the associated Start Air series of spool valve assemblies, one for Check Valve, opening the valve and each Starting Air Check Valve. One allowing starting air to enter the engine assembly for each cylinder is mounted in a cylinder. When the timing cam has moved common housing. The timing cam, timed beyond a spool valve position, the spool to the engine, causes each spool valve to valve is returned to the vent position and direct pilot air pressure to or vent the the air signal is removed from the Starting pressure from each of the Starting Air Air Check Valve. Check Valves. Operation of the spool valve assemblies is shown in Figures 7-5 With cessation of the 'start' signal, the Air through 7-7. Admission Valve closes allowing the air to vent from the Starting Air Distributor With the starting air admission valve internal passages. This loss of air pressure
Rev 1/11 7-5 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems allows the force of the spring to lift the the Starting Air Distributor as well as the spool valves off the timing cam. All of the Starting Air Header. The Starting Air spool valves will be returned to the off/vent Distributor is timed to direct a pilot signal to position, and the starting process will be the Starting Air Check Valve, when the terminated. piston for the cylinder involved is just past top dead center. The force supplied by the 7.4.1.3 Starting Air Check Valves pilot air signal, which is applied to the pilot piston, overcomes the spring force holding In the start mode, air from the Starting Air the valve closed. This opens the Starting Header is delivered to each of the Starting Air Check Valve allowing starting air to Air Check Valves mounted in the engine enter the engine cylinder. cylinder heads. In the Fairbanks-Morse Opposed Piston engine, the Starting Air The pressure of the starting air entering the Check Valves mount through the wall of the engine cylinder is applied to the top of the cylinder liner adjacent to the fuel injection engine’s piston forcing the piston nozzle. A typical Starting Air Check Valve downward and causing rotation of the is shown in Figures 7-8 and 7-9. crankshaft. This rotation subsequently causes upward motion of other engine The air start check valve assembly includes pistons. As each engine piston moves a poppet type valve which is located in a upward on the compression stroke, the air precision bore cast body or housing. A in that cylinder is compressed to achieve spring applied to the upper end of the valve the temperature required for ignition. keeps the valve in the closed position. The Rotation of the crankshaft also causes design of the valve including the balance rotation of the timing cam for the Starting piston is such that the starting air entering Air Distributor (see Figure 7-4). As the the valve body is balanced. Starting air engine’s piston nears the bottom of its pressure acting against the valve is stroke, the Starting Air Distributor closes balanced by the air pressure acting against the associated valve port and vents the the equal area of the balance piston. The pilot air signal from the Starting Air Check force of the spring is sufficient to hold the Valve. This allows the spring to return the valve in the closed position. A pilot inside valve to the closed position. As this occurs, the piston cap rests against the tip of the other Starting Air Check Valves are valve. receiving the pilot signal which results in a continuous rotation of the engine until Initiation of a ‘start’ signal opens the Air engine start is achieved or the start signal Admission Valve allowing air to enter the ceases. housing as shown. The balanced design of the valve maintains it in the closed position The Starting Air Check Valves have to until a pilot air signal is applied to the pilot remain closed during normal engine piston. operation. If a Starting Air Check Valve should not close or should leak, the As mentioned previously, air from the combustion gases from the cylinder will Starting Air Admission Valve is directed to leak out of the Starting Air Check Valve,
Rev 1/11 7-6 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems and it will become extremely hot and may outward from the rotor to make contact with further seize. It is important to occasionally the bore of the housing. As air enters the check the Starting Air Check Valves and inlet of the housing, the pressure is applied the associated Starting Air Supply Header to the sliding vanes as shown, causing the to determine that none of the valves are rotor to rotate. Air continues to enter as the leaking. volume between the rotor and housing increases. 7.4.2 Starting Air Motor System The pressure differential between the air In the air motor system, shown in Figure 7- inlet and the exhaust (atmospheric 2B, engine rotation is accomplished by a pressure) creates the torque necessary for rotary vane or piston type air motor which the rotor to rotate. As the starting air engages with a ring gear mounted to the reaches the exhaust port, it is exhausted to periphery of the engine flywheel. During a the atmosphere as pressurized air start sequence, the drive mechanism of the continues to enter the inlet. starting air motor engages with the flywheel ring gear. Air entering the starting air motor The power and rotary motion of the rotor is then causes rotation of the engine transmitted through shafts and in some crankshaft. Upon completion of the start applications, through gears to the starter sequence, the air is shut off and vented drive gear which is engaged with the allowing the starting air motor to disengage flywheel ring gear. The subsequent from the flywheel gear. rotation of the engine flywheel and crankshaft is used to generate the engine 7.4.2.1 Starting Air Admission Valve start.
The Starting Air Admission Valve used with 7.4.2.3 Start Drive Gear - Bendix the air motor system is similar to that used in the direct injection system. Notice in As the starting air motor in required only Figure 7-2B that the solenoid valve is not intermittently, a drive mechanism is connected directly to the Air Admission provided which will engage and disengage Valve but feeds the pilot signal through the the starter from the flywheel ring gear as drive mechanism of the Starting Air Motor. needed. A starter drive gear, often referred With this configuration, the Starting Air to as a Bendix, is shown in Figure 7-11. Motor drive fully engages with the flywheel ring gear prior to achieving rotation of the The starter drive mechanism that is shown Starting Air Motor. mounts either directly to the rotor shaft or to an output shaft via a set of reduction gears. 7.4.2.2 Vane Type Air Motors Where used, the reduction gears allow the rotor to rotate at a high RPM while A typical vane type Starting Air Motor is increasing the overall output torque. A shown in Figure 7-10. It consists of a rotor drive gear is provided which will mesh with mounted off center within a cylindrical the teeth of the ring gear on the flywheel. housing. A set of sliding vanes radiate When the starting motor is not required to
Rev 1/11 7-7 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems rotate the crankshaft, the drive gear the solenoid valve closes blocking air flow assembly is spring loaded in the to the starter drive piston, which disengaged position. A drive piston is disengages the drive gear and blocks the provided to engage the drive gear with the air flow to the air admission valve. Loss of flywheel ring gear during the ‘start’ the pilot signal to the pilot piston of the air sequence. admission valve allows the valve to close, returning the start system to the standby To prevent over-speeding of the starting air mode. motor as the engine begins to fire, an overrunning clutch is incorporated between 7.4.3 Supplemental Components the drive gear and the rotor shaft. This clutch mechanism engages the rotor shaft In order to meet the "fast start" with the drive gear when the starting motor requirements of diesel engines in nuclear is driving the engine flywheel. As the applications, it is necessary to move the engine RPM increases, the speed of the fuel racks to the full fuel position as soon as drive gear is greater than that of the rotor possible. The following two devices are shaft. At this point, the clutch mechanism employed to work with the starting air releases the drive gear from the rotor shaft. system to bypass the governor and give the The drive gear can continue to rotate with cylinders full fuel during the start sequence. the engine flywheel without transmitting that high speed to the starting motor rotor 7.4.3.1 Governor Boost Cylinder assembly. A governor boost cylinder, as shown in 7.4.2.4 Starting Motor Operation Figure 7-12, is mounted to the side and below the level of the governor housing. It When a ‘start’ signal is received, the is hydraulically connected to both the solenoid valve opens (see Figure 7-2B) governor oil sump and to the governor directing air pressure to the drive piston power piston housing. port in the starter housing as shown in Figure 7-11. This air pressure moves the The boost cylinder is simply a pneumatic- drive piston causing the starter drive gear hydraulic cylinder with a spring loaded to engage with the engine flywheel ring piston. As the force of the spring moves gear. This piston movement also opens an the piston down, oil is drawn from the outlet port which directs pilot air pressure to governor oil sump through the inlet check the pilot port of the starting air admission valve to fill the volume above the piston. valve causing it to open. The volume below the piston is connected to the starting air header. With the air admission valve open, full starting air pressure is directed to the inlet When a ‘start’ signal is generated, air under of the starting air motor causing it to rotate, pressure from the starting air header or driving the flywheel ring gear and rotating supply pipe to the air start motor enters the engine crankshaft. When the ‘start’ below the piston forcing it upward sharply. signal is turned off by the control system, This discharges the oil above the piston
Rev 1/11 7-8 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems past the outlet check valve to the governor 7.4.3.3 Other Fuel Rack Boost Systems power piston. This increased oil pressure quickly moves the fuel control linkage to the Some engines such as the Colt Pielstick full fuel position ensuring a rapid engine engine line include fuel rack boost cylinders start and acceleration. and shuttle valves that are part of the engine fuel rack control system. These The oil supplied by the boost cylinder units do not use the governor boost bleeds off through the internal passages of cylinder system as described above. the governor as the governor takes over operation of the fuel control linkage. The 7.4.4 Starting Air Supply System outlet check valve prevents governor oil pressure from entering the boost cylinder. Regardless of the type of starting air Closure of the starting air admission valve system used, sufficient air pressure and drops air pressure from the boost cylinder volume must be available at all times to and the spring again moves the piston ensure engine start capability. The air to downward, refilling the space above the support engine starting is automatically piston with oil from the governor oil sump. maintained in ASME Class 3 air receivers located near the engine. It is the starting On the actuators used with the electronic air supply system which maintains the air governing systems (to be discussed in pressure and volume in these receivers. A Chapter 8), the boost oil does not actually typical starting air supply system is shown lift the power piston but charges portions of in Figure 7-13. Starting air piping is ASME the hydraulic circuit with oil which allows Class 3 and designed for seismic loading. the governor to take control earlier than would be the case without the boost oil. 7.4.4.1 Air Receivers
7.4.3.2 Shuttle Valve Compressed air receivers are cylindrical pressure vessels whose design and When only one boost cylinder is used, a construction is governed by the shuttle valve is installed to maintain the requirements of the ASME Boiler and redundancy and separation required by Pressure Vessel Code, Construction of nuclear specifications. Unfired Pressure Vessels. The generic plant air receivers are designed to conform Under normal conditions, the shuttle valve to the requirements of ASME Code, takes a center position directing air from Section III for Class 3 components. both headers to the underside of the boost cylinder piston. However, should a failure Their specific size (volume) is a function of of one of the redundant systems occur, the the size of the engine they are required to air pressure from the operational side start and the number and duration of start causes the shuttle valve to shift blocking off attempts specified by the FSAR. The the failed side and directing air from the generic FSAR requirement is to have air operational side to the boost cylinder. storage capability to provide two (2) consecutive diesel engine starts. The two
Rev 1/11 7-9 of 28 USNRC HRTD Emergency Diesel Generator Diesel Engine Starting Systems
(2) start capability is required to assure that The generic starting air compressors are the engine can help mitigate the designed to deliver 40 SCFM at 250 psig. consequences of design basis events (e.g. They require Class 1E power and are LOCA). A number of the later plants indirectly tested by diesel start tests. specified capacity for five (5) start attempts, a starting attempt generally taking more air If two compressors are inoperable on one than a successful start. NOTE: If either diesel, then the diesel is inoperable. starting air receiver is inoperable on one diesel, then the diesel is inoperable. In some specifications, the air compressors were sized such that the tanks had to be 7.4.4.2 Air Compressors charged from atmospheric pressure to high cut-out pressure within 30 minutes. Starting air compressors are normally of the reciprocating (piston) type. They are 7.4.4.3 Pressure Switches usually multiple-stage, multi-cylinder types with cylinders configured in a “V” or “W”. Operation of the compressor is controlled They may be either air cooled or water by a pressure switch located on the air cooled. receiver. Set at a specified "cut-in" pressure, the switch starts the compressor Compressor capacity is based upon the when the pressure becomes lower than the amount of time required to recharge the set pressure and allows the compressor to receiver from a specified (cut-in) pressure run until the receiver is at or slightly above to the desired operational pressure. the desire operating pressure. As the air Compressor capacity may be determined pressure reaches the operating pressure, using the following formula: the pressure switch opens the circuit, stopping (unloading) the compressor.