May 15, 2019 Cultures, Concepts Stories and First InuitCommunities, Nations,Métisand A MediaProduction Guideto Working with ON-SCREEN PROTOCOLS &PATHWAYS:
A HEADING This report was funded with the support of:
This report was funded with the support of:
This report was funded with the support of:
This report was funded with the support of:
PREPARED FOR imagineNATIVE 401 Richmond St. West, Suite 446 Toronto, Ontario This report wasM5V 3A8funded with the support of: www.imagineNATIVE.org
This report was funded with the support of:
This report was funded with the support of:
The Canada MediaThe Fund, Canada The National Media Film Fund, Board of The Canada, National Ontario FilmCreates, Board Telefilm of Canada,Canada, Creative Ontario BC and Creates, Telefilm Canada, Creative the Inspirit FoundationBC and provided the Inspiritfunding for Foundation this study. Any provided opinions, findings, funding conclusions for this orstudy. recommendations Any opinions, findings, conclusions or expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funders or the recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of governments which they represent. The Government of Canada, the Government of Ontario and their agencies are in no way boundthe by funders the recommendations or the governments contained in whichthis document. they represent. The Government of Canada, the Government of Ontario and their agencies are in no way bound by the recommendations contained in this document. This report was commissioned by imagineNATIVE and written by independent consultant Marcia Nickerson. The Canada Media Fund, The NationalThis report Film was Board commissioned of Canada, byOntario imagineNATIVE Creates, Telefilm and written Canada, by independentCreative consultant Marcia Nickerson. BC and the Inspirit Foundation provided funding for this study. Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funders or the governments which they represent. The Government of Canada, the Government of Ontario and their agencies are in no way bound by the recommendations contained in this document.
This report was commissioned by imagineNATIVE and written by independent consultant Marcia Nickerson.
The Canada Media Fund, The National Film Board of Canada, Ontario Creates, Telefilm Canada, Creative BC and the Inspirit Foundation provided funding for this study. Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Canada Media Fund, The National Film Board of Canada, Ontario Creates, Telefilm Canada, Creative the funders or the governments whichThe they Canada represent. Media Fund, The The Government National Film of Board Canada, of Canada, the Government Ontario Creates, of Telefilm Ontario Canada, Creative and their agencies are in no way boundBC and by thetheBC Inspirit recommendations and Foundationthe Inspirit provided Foundation contained funding providedin for this this document.study. funding Any opinions, for this findings, study. Any conclusions opinions, or findings, conclusions or recommendationsrecommendations expressed in this expressed material arein thisthose material of the author are andthose do notof thenecessarily author reflect and do the not views necessarily of reflect the views of This report was commissioned by imagineNATIVEthe fundersthe or thefunders governmentsand written or the whichgovernments by independent they represent. which consultant The they Government represent. Marcia of Canada, Nickerson.The Government the Government of Canada,of Ontario the Government of Ontario and their agenciesand their are agencies in no way boundare in by no the way recommendations bound by the contained recommendations in this document. contained in this document. The Canada Media Fund, The National Film Board of Canada, Ontario Creates, Telefilm Canada, Creative This report was commissioned by imagineNATIVE and written by independent consultant Marcia Nickerson. BC and the Inspirit Foundation providedThis funding report for was this commissioned study. Any opinions, by imagineNATIVEfindings, conclusions and or written by independent consultant Marcia Nickerson. recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funders or the governments which they represent. The Government of Canada, the Government of Ontario and their agencies are in no way bound by the recommendations contained in this document.
This report was commissioned by imagineNATIVE and written by independent consultant Marcia Nickerson. b. Archiving materials associated withafilm a.Useofarchives inanew film 5. Working withArchival Materials Working4. Crew withIndigenous orCast d.Developing community capacity and benefits agreements b. 3. Working Communities inIndigenous Working2. Content withIndigenous 1. Working Lands onIndigenous Consent Reciprocity Responsibility Respect Screen-Based Protocols Principles This IsNotAMap Narrative Sovereignty Purpose OfOn-Screen Protocols HOW TO USETHISDOCUMENT FORWORD 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 3 c. Virtual Realityc. accessibility archival and b. crew non-Indigenous Sensitizing a. Paying ofactors community and members e. Script development Hiring acommunityc. liaison a. Building respectfula. Building relationships based ontrust g. Meaningful collaboration e. Sensitive matter subject lifed. Individual stories Ensure thatyouc. proper obtainthe consent permission and b. Valuing cultural ofIndigenous intellectual and property us aboutuswithout a. Nothing b. Recognizing Jurisdiction Indigenous a. Cultural Territorial and Protocols Overview Storytelling ofIndigenous Consent Process intent the Outlining offilm,how how itwillbeusedand widelyitwillbedistributed 42 30 30 42 34 34 43 43 38 39 26 39 39 25 14 10 10 16 18 19 16 16 17 12 12 31 15 13 1 1 9 6 7 5
1 CONTENT 2 CONTENTS BIBLIOGRAPHY /RESOURCES Sample Community Safety Protocols Sample Filmmaker’s Code ofProfessional Responsibility Sample Protocol for on Set Action Respectful Sample Code ofConduct Etiquette for Filming inFirst NationCommunities Releases 69 Canadian Guilds in the Unions and Film Television and Production Sector Key Creative Positions ofProductionStages Basic Information ofProduction onStages inTelevision Film and Developing Reciprocity Agreements Questions to working askwhen withScreen Producers Developing Community Protocols APPENDIX B:RESOURCESFOR COMMUNITIES Ownership, Control, Access, &Possession Relationships Reframing NarrativeUNDRIP and Sovereignty Free, Prior &Informed Consent CultureIndigenous Intellectual and Property (ICIP) Cultural Appropriation Cultural Genocide Historical Underpinnings APPENDIX CONTEXT A: FOR SCREENPROTOCOLS INCANADA Unions Festivals /Showcases Film Commissions PublicFundingNational and Moving Forward Working Context inthe ofReconciliation Nation-to-Nation and IMPLEMENTING PROTOCOLS 7. Marketing &Distribution Strategies Releases6. 48 48 46 60 49 68 47 50 69 69 66 66 66 76 63 67 62 65 63 53 73 57 52 52 52 55 53 53 61 61 71 71 Art Napoleon and Huw Eirug who provided HuwEirugwho Napoleonand Art sampledocumentation We would like to acknowledge Darlene Naponse, Barbara Hager, in Canada: ABackground Report.” Guide to Working withFirst InuitCommunities Nations,Métisand Communications MDR:“Developing aMediaProductionfrom conducted for imagineNATIVE by Maria Marilyn DeRosaand Burgess also incorporatesThis document integrates and initialresearch the voicesthe within. to represent nationalconsultation ofthe findings the capture and expertise, wisepractices, experiences. and strives Thisdocument difficult; and emotional stillcreators to managed share their group facilitated by Wapikoni Mobile.Conversations were often Toronto, Montreal, Saskatoon, and Iqaluit, aswell asayouth focus sessionsinWinnipeg, engagement with additional Vancouver, interviews screen withIndigenous creators,one-one-one coupled participated throughout process. the There were upwards of25 Also many thanks to many the screen content creators that Agluvak Puskas, Alethea Arnaquq-Baril Younging, HankWhite, Jean Francois Obomsawin, Stephan Alanis Obomsawin, Loretta Todd, JesseWente, LisaJackson, Greg guidance,their generosity expertise, and ofspirit: gratitude to members the nationalprotocols ofthe for advisory First foremost, and imagineNATIVE would like to express much
profound commitment to community. onthe impact and Committee Advisory Indigenous ofthe member a had who This guideisdedicated ofGreg inloving Younging, memory a Inspirit the and Foundation.BC, Film Board ofCanada, Ontario Creates, Telefilm Canada, Creative protocolsof the Canada possible:The MediaFund, National The finally,And gratitude to funders the development the thatmade Alliance, CreativeArts Creative and BC, Manitoba. Beusekom NationalFilm The and Board, Media Independent the Alexandre Terres and Nequado Michelle van envues/LandInSight, Roger Boyer Winnipeg the and Film Indigenous Summit, Nunavutthe Film Commission, OdileJoannette Wapikoni, and throughout consultation the process, including: HuwEirugand Special thanks to to helped who those facilitate spaces faces and literacy screen inthe sector. for community useinorder to buildcommunity capacity and Marcia Nickerson
3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 4 FORWARD so much more. that participated consultations inthe withMarcia –along Nickerson hasbecome –thisdocument were perpetuated.not Thanks to brilliancethe screen Indigenous the and of National the Advisory storytellers funders to ensure property Indigenous was protected to and ensure thatnegative on-screen stereotypes Our initialvisionwas to create thatwould apositive, guideproductions forward-thinking and framework generations to come. to screen Indigenous storytellers support –isastep towards ensuring screen avitalIndigenous sector for –inconcert progressions withthe It ismy thatare thatthisframework deepesthope undertaken being Australia’s protocols document. have brought usto Itwas thispointintime. alsoinspired by work the of Terri Janke developed who Screen members have who persevered for screen inthe have who and decades, industry cleared paths the that On-Screen Protocols &Pathways was inspired by remarkable the leaders, artists, Indigenous community and screenIndigenous storytellers. vitality and narrative ofIndigenous impact, importance, sovereignty urgent the and to need support Inourwork atimagineNATIVEthat brought to thisreport fruition. we have first-hand witnessed the hasbeenyears document The making inthe onbehalfofimagineNATIVE and Isincerely thankeveryone imagineNATIVE Executive Director Jason Ryle
HOW TO USETHISDOCUMENT funding decisions. funding by larger the industry, thataffects in amanner policy and are onlyeffective standards ifthe reflected therein are adopted promotionthe protocols. ofthe implementation and protocols The bodies,broadcastersfunding canassistin partners industry and providesThis section acontext illustrates and ways ofthe some Two:Section Protocols Implementing positive, practical and mutually beneficial, way. community how to work communities withIndigenous ina Ultimately isaboutshowing thisdocument production the for working content, with Indigenous concepts communities. and by screen Indigenous storytellers to providedeveloped guidelines isgearedThis section towards sharing bestpractices the Protocols Using One: Section in production. creators, communities Indigenous and thatmay beinvolved but alsoto stakeholders, larger industry content non-Indigenous attempts to speak onlyto not screen Indigenous content creators, audiences were identifiedfor It purpose the ofthis document. burgeoningthe Screen Indigenous industry, several different uniquecultural,Because ofthe historical socialand context of
ongoing basis.ongoing updated edited and inconsultation withstakeholders, onan areand considered thatwillbereviewed, document” a“living protocolsThe Screen Indigenous withinthe willbehoused Office meant to berigid, thatover and practice and time willchange. toIt isimportant acknowledge protocols thatthese are not Moving Forward own protocols. sample materials they into canadopt development the oftheir production, questionsto ofproduction impacts askaboutthe and faced withincoming productions, providing basic information on ismeantThis section to communities serve Indigenous thatare B:ResourcesAppendix for Communities communities’ expectations around relationships moving forward. relationshipoutlines principles thatare indicative ofIndigenous worldview communities ofIndigenous storytellers. and Italso ofnarrativepinnings sovereignty iskey to understanding the Understanding thishistory ofcolonization legalunder the and property rights. regard to cultural cultural genocide, appropriation cultural and companies gatekeepers and worldviews aboutIndigenous with serves toThis section educate production non-Indigenous Context A: Appendix for Screen Protocols inCanada -
5 HOW TO USE THIS DOCUMENT 6 PURPOSE OF ON SCREEN PROTOCOLS these protocolsthese are found withinthisdocument. vest. As aresult, pathways onlythe to facilitate navigation the of determine where protocols jurisdiction and over stories content and cite therefore all,and them content uponthe incumbent creator to communitiesIndigenous content. orIndigenous Itisimpossible to information withcommunities, data,engaging and aswell asfilming internationally, for purposes the research, ofacademic sharing of have beendeveloped nations,bothnationallyand in Indigenous knowledge, protocols serveto provide ofpractice. guidelines Protocols absenceIn the oflegislationprotecting traditional cultural and numerous specificto and nations,communities, cultures. and Ontario). Examples ofexisting protocols Indigenous inCanada are provincialnational and organizations such MétisNationof asthe they(whether bands, Act self-governing beIndian entities,or practices politicalprotocols and ofgifting, governments withestablished territorial protocols, ways receiving and ofgiving traditional knowledge, territorial, community and protocols. include These cultural and As languages. Indigenous such there are asmany varying nation, protected Métissettlements, according and, to StatisticsCanada, First Nationsreserves, four Inuitregions, eightconstitutionally nations,well individual Firstand over Nations;with50-odd 600 There are three Métis, peoplesinCanada: Indigenous Inuit, distinct PURPOSE OFONSCREENPROTOCOLS
60
• • • • intentThe indeveloping production thismedia guideisto: content.media or intellectual property) films,television intheir programs digital and content orconcepts (traditional orcontemporary cultures, knowledge companies to wishing feature First Nations,MétisorInuitpeople, Concepts Stories and isfor useby screen-storytellers production and Working withFirst InuitCommunities, Nations,Métisand Cultures, On-ScreenThe Protocols &Pathways: AMediaProduction Guideto content creators, production and companies. to encourage informed, respectful dialoguebetween communities, protection the and cultural ofIndigenous practices; finally, and keepers worldviews, about Indigenous cultural property and rights, educate screen content creators, production companies gate and share bestpractices developed by screen Indigenous storytellers; creators, partners; industry bodies,and funding provide decision-making for guidelines communities, content — Lindsay McIntyre, Filmmaker “Recognize protocol that afixed isnot asetofrulesyouit isnot can follow.” person tocommunity, person; from community to willvary from and changing itisafluidand thing thing;
-
within the contextwithin the ofexisting barriers. commence development the standards industry ofIndigenous by providing however, anexacting framework; intent the isto protocols are intended not to create barriers for creators Indigenous creative practices, whileallowing proprietary matters to flourish. These Indigenous”, inaway thatmore adequately reflects cultures and includes developing production that“allow models usto bemore screen-storytellers.imposed onIndigenous Decolonizing practices practicesIndigenous addressing and western the structures thatare protocolsof these isintimately linked decolonization withthe of intent withwhich they were given. According to respondents, idea the bestpracticesThe stories and withinare shared spirit withthe and protocols have overwhelming similarities. pathways screen thatIndigenous storytellers use to navigate these whileprotocols peoples.And Indigenous themselves may differ, the standards developedan initialcollection industry ofIndigenous by practices inCanada are and meant to and serveas bothguidelines communities. their and protocols The best thatfollow stem from culturalIndigenous material, interacting and people withIndigenous Protocols provide appropriate ethicalways and ofworking with
NARRATIVE SOVEREIGNTY sovereignty, that’s my identity. my “Mylanguage, sentiments: my song, spiritual beliefs;thatismy leaders echoed former Akwesasne Grand ChiefMike Mitchell’s basis identity- the of Indigenous many nationhood… and Indigenous threatenedand cultures and languages survival the ofIndigenous a legacy ofintergenerational trauma communities, withinIndigenous nations’governanceIndigenous practices, institutionsand left Residential School program. policieshave These eroded many legacythe ofcolonial policiessuch the and Act Indian asthe peoplesinvolves Indigenous and taking stock recognizing ofand A key first step inresetting relationship the between Crown the relationships.nation-to-nation rights, for stage ithassetthe discussionsofrenewed ongoing forprovides Indigenous humanrights anethicaland framework Declaration Peoples RightsofIndigenous onthe (UNDRIP), which With Canadian the government United ofthe adoption Nations screenIndigenous creators inCanada strive for “narrative sovereignty”. cultural repression, cultural appropriation, misrepresentation, and After to whatamounts over ahundred years ofcultural genocide, — “When Italk aboutnarrative sovereignty, by people. non-Indigenous documentaries –have beentold and peoples–bothfictional Indigenous majoritywhelming ofstories told about entire history offilmmaking, over the about themselves... Throughout the of control over stories the are that told to nations of the have measure some I’mreallywhat talking ability aboutisthe Director, Screen Indigenous Office Jesse Wente, .3 ” 2 ”
-
7 NARRATIVE SOVEREIGNTY 8 NARRATIVE SOVEREIGNTY the storythe strength ofthe people. oftheir injustices ongoing and whilelooking forward to future the sharing and people’s their honour journey abalance find and between historical expression revitalization. and screen Indigenous storytellers seekto unique cultural (orniche) process ofthe product -itispart ofcultural Making screen-based Indigenous isaboutmore media thancreatinga cultures traditional inpreserving and cultural practices stories. and modern the re-generation, bothindepicting reflections ofchanging Film, television, screen other and are media practices incultural • • protect Cultural Property interests; Rightsand and • projects, trulyIndigenous peoplesmust: Indigenous support and notions nations musthave control over own stories. To assure sovereign culturaland property heritage and isparamount. Sovereign ownershipIndigenous control and over rights their to intellectual their identity,and for and purpose the protocols, of these recognition of founding nations.Culture underpinning isafundamental ofsovereignty creators strive to own their sovereignty assert three ofthe asone As iscurrently reflected inFrench Canada, English and Indigenous Cultural property. ensure appropriate consents, access to, control and of creative sidesof production; have decisionmaking control over the and funding the
“with often predicated onstories agoodway”, resilience depicting -“in Itinvolvesis soimportant. creation the ofnew narratives thatare reasons ofthe This isone concept that the ofnarrative sovereignty point for screen content creators. capacity necessary buildthe and are underway remain and afocal to development the efforts support screen Indigenous ofthe sector visionofnarrativeWhile the sovereignty isaspirational atthispoint, film practice. acknowledges traditional these teachings to appliesthem and
a
agoodmind”. Narrativegood heart”, “with and sovereignty
THIS IS NOT A MAP
“We are becoming another resource. “If you really need to have us in your They have taken timber and gold and story, tell the truth of your history, as fish and now they want our stories. difficult as that may be. Find the They are continuing to take our resources intersections of truth in the history of and profit from it.“ settlers. There are as many Indigenous — Darlene Naponse, Filmmaker stories as there are settler stories. You cannot tell a story truthfully if you do not come from this place.”
There was resounding consensus from participants during the — Catherine Martin, Filmmaker engagement process that these protocols should be considered and Educator a living document and not serve as a static checklist on how to make productions with Indigenous content. Rather, these protocols The non-Indigenous production community should consider the are intended to inform policies, processes, and practices, but they ways in which they can reinforce Indigenous narrative sovereignty are not a map for non-Indigenous practitioners to access Indigenous and what roles they can play to promote Indigenous cultural stories. In this spirit, the following checklist has been industries, rather than reinvent Indigenous stories in their own image. developed for non-Indigenous practitioners:
• If it is not representative of your culture or background; • If it has anything to do with Indigenous history or culture; • If you have to question your belongingness to a group or community; • If you are uncertain your good intentions will deliver balance and respect; or • If you are unsure this is a story you should be telling; then… THIS IS NOT A MAP THIS IS NOT Don't Do It.
9 10 SCREEN-BASED PROTOCOLS PRINCIPLES fundamental tofundamental execution the ofprotocols. Screen storytellers described following the principles as SCREEN-BASED PROTOCOLS PRINCIPLES RECIPROCITY RESPECT CONSENT RESPONSIBILITY
Respect • • • forward ofcontent inallaspects creation includes: and teaching Indigenous The ofrespect isatraditional thatcarries one – and the responsibilities the – and relationships. withthose thatgoalong respect relationships isalsoaboutbuilding –which process isalong content creation; knowledge cultures and isa key driving force for much Indigenous respect for preservation the protection and ofIndigenous consulted; traditions,and isanoverarching principle raised by allofthose respect for customary their lands, peoples,their laws Indigenous — “Respect isoften born oftransparency opencommunication.”and Kevin Lee Burton, Filmmaker
to community. differenceis the between creative responsibility responsibility and with community inside.That filmonthe the outside,and onthe responsibility.” As respondent one explained: Visualize acircle to creative “community ‘individual freedom/license’ from Thus there shiftrequired mental isafundamental to shiftthinking Responsibility after film. the community exists onlyon-location, butbefore, not during and preventand voyeurism. Itwas emphasized thatresponsibility to often withthatcomes responsibility the to respect sacred the How willthisaffect community future the and generations? And first the times priority creators ofIndigenous iscommunity based: inherent responsibility accountability and to community. Often It isalsoclear screen thatIndigenous storytellers recognize an “When acommunity that you come from — Shane Belcourt, Filmmaker Belcourt, —Shane “Let repeat me first –the that and —Alethea Arnaquq-Baril, Filmmaker foremost responsibility isto community.” matter feel aresponsibility to tell stories that but MIS-represented for acentury, you beenso,has represented beenunder not is self-imposed orcommunity imposed.” We carry alotofresponsibility it whether and that are not just entertaining.
Circle ofResponsibility mfrt rtui mf E op n con n p o m io ic f u S t N tio o r ns c K C i —NylaInnuksuk, Filmmaker “Maybe we aren’t making movies because o l L drivesthat usto tell stories. oral storytelling. Maybeit’s ourresponsibility combinedmyths withadeephistory of our rich culture nuanced and withscary land we live beautiful,untouched most inthe 0 s & D torie Leg P D S en s d u 0 L n s y o S n
SCREEN-BASED s in ti i r K c t i i c r r e North b e t PRO ECTS e TV SERIES d s l l u o e i F f b C n o FILM m
e d
d p
c
America. n
n
t
E