EXCLUSIVE POLITICAL COVERAGE: NEWS, FEATURES, AND ANALYSIS INSIDE HILL MIKE SAUDI ARMS DONNER WEST BLOCK CLIMBERS P.27 DUFFY P.9 DEAL P.24 WINNER P. 25 RENOS P. 28

TWENTY-SEVENTH YEAR, NO. 1335 CANADA’S POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT NEWSPAPER MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 $5.00

NEWS TERRORISM NEWS SENATE SPENDING ‘CANADA DOES NOT AND WILL Duffy’s not guilty verdict casts doubt NOT PAY RANSOM TO TERRORISTS on prospects for DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY’: PM legal action against former Senators Sen. Larry Campbell weighs in.

BY ABBAS RANA have not paid back $528,000 that Auditor A senior member General Michael Fergu- of the Senate’s power- son fl agged as misspent ful Internal Economy, money, on the grounds Budgets and Admin- that chances of success istration Committee is are less than 50 per cent, questioning the Senate’s given what happened decision to pursue legal in the Mike Duffy trial, action against seven and legal costs could former Senators who surpass what’s owed. Continued on page 26

NEWS POLITICAL FUNDRAISERS Wilson-Raybould’s fundraising activity

Canadian John Ridsdel, right, was killed by the Abu Sayyaf, and Canadian Robert Hall, left, remains in captivity in the Philippines. CP offside on many reported last week that the RCMP is investigating the beheading of Mr. Ridsdel to bring his killers to Canadian justice. Image: BNO News/YouTube levels, say critics BY ABBAS RANA the names of dangerous re- areas, they should not expect ous, you are certainly taking gions around the world on Ca- any consular assistance, says matters into your own hands nstead of issuing travel nadian passports and it should a former Liberal MP. and there’s nothing that can Fundraiser attracts heat. Iadvisories online, the federal specifi cally state that if Cana- “If you travel to areas government should identify dians choose to travel to these that are known to be danger- Continued on page 13 BY DEREK ABMA Trudeau (Papineau, Que.) has been facing While political some intense criti- NEWS LOBBYING NEWS LEGISLATION pundits say there is a cism in recent weeks role for politicians in because of a $500-a- party fundraisers, they person Liberal Party Five-year ban on lobbying Budget, assisted-dying, also say the recent fundraiser on April 7 instance of Justice at the Toronto offi ce of excessive, say former RCMP labour bills to take Minister Jody Wilson- law fi rm Torys LLP, for Raybould serving as which the attendance the key attraction at an of Ms. Wilson-Raybould political Hill staffers precedence: LeBlanc exclusive, high-priced (Vancouver Granville, event at the offi ce of a B.C.) was presented as ‘It is a problem,’ says André Albanati. House could sit late nights: LeBlanc. prominent Toronto law the main draw. fi rm was inappropriate While the offi ce of BY LAURA RYCKEWAERT amend the Federal Account- BY ALLY FOSTER consecutive sitting sched- on many levels. Confl ict of Interest and ability Act, in particular to ule so far this year, and The government of Ethics Commissioner Former political staffers reduce the fi ve-year lobbying PARLIAMENT HILL—The Government House Leader Prime Minister Justin Mary Dawson has con- are encouraging the Liberal House is back this week for government to review and Continued on page 15 three weeks, the longest Continued on page 21 Continued on page 22 2 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 FEATURE BUZZ

involved in another debate. And we now know what they’ll be arguing—the pros and New senior bureaucrat ON cons of heckling in the House of Commons. announced for HEARD THE HILL Indigenous Affairs BY DEREK ABMA The Prime Minister’s Offi ce announced last week that Diane Lafl eur will become an associate deputy minister at Indigenous and Northern Affairs as of May 9. She is currently an assistant deputy minis- ter at Finance Canada, specializing in federal- Anderson, provincial relations and social policy, a position she’s held since 2013. She has worked in a variety of senior roles at Finance since 1998. Greenspon to debate Ms. Lafl eur will fi ll a job vacated by Hé- lène Laurendeau, who earlier this month moved up the food chain to become deputy minister of Indigenous Affairs. media, democracy Such changes come at a busy time for this department, amid a suicide crisis in the northern Ontario First Nations community of Attawapiskat and a federal budget that at Travers Debates has put an extra $8.4-billion toward native Montreal lawyer Brian Mitchell is one of three issues over the next fi ve years. people who are so far running for president of the federal Conservative party. Photograph courtesy Trudeau government sure of Brian Mitchell likes that Barber guy Mr. Feschuk and Ms. Brosseau have been assigned to support the merits of allowing heckling from MPs being paid a minimum of $170,400 a year to discuss and decide the laws of this country, while Ms. Simpson and Mr. Cuzner will take the other side. The fourth annual Travers Debates are set for the National Arts Centre in Ottawa on the evening of Tuesday, May 17. Tickets cost $125 each and are on sale at Travers- Debates.ca. Money raised goes toward the R. James Travers Foreign Corresponding Fellowship, named after journalist James Travers who died in 2011. Conservatives have three candidates for president, so far

Three people have so far put their names forward for the presidency of the Conservative Party of Canada, to be de- cided in early June. Michael Barber is again meeting with senior The candidates are Brian Mitchell, Kara members of the Canadian government. Johnson, and Louis Charles Fortier. As many Photograph courtesy of Michael Barber’s LinkedIn as four more candidates are expected to come forward, according to one party insider. In order for any of these candidates to be- Another cabinet retreat and the Prime come president, they must be elected to a seat Minister’s Offi ce has again delivered to on the party’s national council at the party’s ministers an appearance from British gov- convention at the end of this month, and all ernment guru Michael Barber. are running in contested regions. The newly Mr. Barber joined the Trudeau cabinet last elected national council is to elect the president week in Kananaskis, Alta., to talk up his phi- at its fi rst meeting, which is scheduled for the losophy of “deliverology.” He caught up with fi rst weekend after the convention. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and friends Mr. Mitchell, a Montreal lawyer, con- back in January as well, when cabinet was fi rmed to The Hill Times that he recently on retreat in Andrews-by-the-Sea, N.B. resigned his seat on the CBC/Radio-Can- Mr. Barber’s role is to stress to our leaders ada board of directors in order to run that it’s not enough just to know how to make for this party position. He had been on the pizza; you have to know how to deliver that the board for the last eight years, which pizza as well—and to the right address. he said he “thoroughly enjoyed,” but that Mr. Barber was a key player in the gov- Pictured top to bottom right to left, Bruce Anderson and Edward Greenspon are set to face off against “some people asked that I use my talents in ernment of former British prime minister each other in this year’s Travers Debates. The second debate that night will feature, Maclean’s Scott service of our party.” Tony Blair between 2001 and 2005, holding Feschuck, NDP MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau, Katie Simpson, and Liberal MP Rodger Cuzner. The Hill Times Mr. Mitchell and Mr. Fortier are among the title of chief adviser on delivery. photograph by Jake Wright/photograph courtesy of Public Policy Forum and photographs courtesy of Travers Debates seven people competing for three positions He told reporters last week that the Lib- on the council to represent Quebec. Others eral government has shown “real progress” on governing in a deliverology-like way, he upcoming Travers Debates will fea- Mr. Greenspon will argue that this is are Marc-Olivier Fortin, Svetlana Litvin, with members of cabinet “thinking of ways ture Abacus Data chairman Bruce An- indeed a threat to democracy while Mr. An- Serge Marcotte, Jimmy Yu, and Richard Yufe. T they can help each other, challenges they derson and Public Policy Forum president derson will oppose this notion. Ms. Johnson is one of seven people face, and how to get this whole results-and- Edward Greenspon discussing whether the As previously reported in this space, Ma- looking for fi ll four spots on the council delivery agenda moving along.” current mainstream-media landscape that clean’s Scott Feschuk, former CTV reporter form Ontario. Others are Ghina Al-Sewaidi, is seeing scores of journalists laid off is a Katie Simpson, Liberal MP Rodger Cuzner, Cheryl Bannier, Jai Bhatti, Matthew John, Continued on page 35 threat to democracy itself. and NDP MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau will be Joe Preston, and Matthijs Van Gaalen.

Finding resolution outside of the courtroom. INFORMATION. ADVICE. GUIDANCE. Q Mediation Q Collaborative Family Law We are here to help you through your separation or divorce Q Private Settlement Conferences Q Mediation/Arbitration Q Arbitration

Low Murchison Radnoff LLP s #ARLING!VENUE /TTAWAs  s  sWWWLMRLAWYERSCOM EVENTS WOMEN IN FINANCE MAY 10 PRESENTED BY: 7:30-9:00 AM OTTAWA MARRIOTT HOTEL

On May 10 join Hill Times Events as we explore what it will take to encourage greater participation of women in finance. Opening remarks will be delivered by the Minister of Small Business and Tourism Ms. Bardish Chagger, MP (Waterloo, Ont.).

This session will explore why there has been a decline in women-owned small to medium sized enterprises, the percentage of women serving on corporate boards and the importance for teaching financial literacy to women and girls.

There is no charge to attend for Hill Times subscribers and $20.00 for non-subscribers. Advance registration is required.

Supported By:

hilltimes.com/events 4 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 NEWS CANADIAN CULTURE Will Joly’s CanCon sweeping review push back changes already underway in TV sector?

on April 23 said it is “seeking reconsideration of the lack of reg- ‘If I were the input from Canadians on how to ulation on online services—Cana- president of the strengthen the creation, dis- dian and foreign—which results covery, and export of Canadian in no Canadian-content quotas or CBC or the chair content.” requirements to contribute funds of the CRTC, I’d It added: “The cultural sector is to support Canadian productions. at the heart of Canada’s creative NDP heritage critic Pierre kind of feel that … economy. It is confronted with Nantel (Longueuil—Saint-Hu- there’s something new challenges and opportunities bert, Que.) said he supports the in the face of rapid technological government’s move to review big looking over my advances and changes in how Canada’s cultural industries and Canadians produce and consume he hopes some of the CRTC’s shoulder,’ says Ian content. These consultations will recent moves are reconsidered. Morrison. help the government determine “[CRTC Chairman] Jean-Pierre how best to assist the cultural sec- Blais has put the big effort to- tor in navigating these changes wards the consumers for cheaper BY DEREK ABMA and seizing opportunities to prices, more affordability, but he contribute to Canada’s economic also has to wait and balance this eritage Minister Mélanie Jo- growth and innovation.” [to] make sure that we protect our Heritage Minister Mélanie Joly has initiated a review of how Canadian content Hly’s recent launch of a broad- The fi rst phase involves an on- distinction, that we protect the gets made and consumed in the digital age, and some are wondering what based review of how Canadian line survey that will be available fact that we have support for our it will mean for CRTC regulations and how the CBC operates. The Hill Times content gets made and consumed until May 20. Details are expected culture [industries],” he said. photograph by Jake Wright in the digital age comes just as in June on what the next part of Mr. Nantel said his biggest new TV regulations are taking ef- this review will entail. worry is that much of today’s the meantime, we have to keep Ms. Ashton used the example fect and there is some speculation Ian Morrison, spokesman for youth, who consume most of their moving with our plan to make the of the burgeoning technology of that some changes might be up Friends of Canadian Broadcast- video from the internet, will grow public broadcaster more digital, virtual reality. for reconsideration. ing, said this new project of Ms. up with virtually no exposure to more local, more relevant, and “With a VR headset, you could The Canadian Radio-television Joly could be a sign that some of Canadian content. more ambitious with our Cana- be up north and still visit a mu- and Telecommunications Com- the CRTC’s recent decisions are He said one of the issues this dian programming.” seum and see art. So would you mission (CRTC) launched a up for reconsideration. process should address is the fact Also changing the situation call something like that visual art, process in 2013 called Let’s Talk “I think [the Liberals] under- foreign, online-based content ser- at the CBC is the fact it received or would you call it VR and inter- TV that involved surveys, writ- stand that a lot of what the CRTC vices do not charge sales taxes, funding boost of $675-million over active digital media?” she said. ten submissions, and a two-week is doing is very much Harper which means they contribute fi ve years in the Liberal govern- “That’s where the digital shift hearing that resulted in a series government related,” he said. virtually nothing to government ment’s fi rst budget, following a can actually allow more people to of decisions issued last year. The Mr. Morrison recalled how the or the economy in Canada while period in which the Conservative enjoy culture. … So I think what process dealt with some of the Conservative government indi- enjoying a price advantage over government had gradually reduced Joly is trying to do is take a much same issues Ms. Joly’s (Ahuntsic- cated it wanted a pick-and-pay TV Canadian competitors. core annual funding to the CBC by bigger-picture look at all of what’s Cartierville, Que.) review seems regime in its 2013 Throne Speech, Mr. Nantel said he would also $115-million a year, resulting in job out there and how digital plat- poised to get into, such as the before the CRTC’s review of the like to see this review consider cuts and other rationing. forms and digital media can help internet’s increasing role as TV industry even got underway. how to deal with the effects of Toronto-based media consul- foster all of this Canadian content a source of video content for Mr. Morrison said the CRTC’s large foreign internet companies tant Kelly Lynne Ashton said she’s and get greater access to it.” households, and the how Cana- recent decisions were consumer- like Google and Facebook gob- “pretty excited” about this review Rather that going over ground dian companies can compete with centric and failed to adequately bling up advertising dollars from of Canada’ cultural industries being the CRTC already covered and pos- major U.S. entities like Netfl ix consider the pain they would Canada that, in the past, would undertaken by the government. sibly pushing back on some of its and YouTube. cause the TV industry. He cited a have gone to local TV stations or “It’s been awhile in coming,” determinations, Ms. Ashton said CRTC spokeswoman Patricia study done by Nordicity—spon- newspapers. she said. “We’ve needed this for a the government’s new consultation Valladao said it’s too early to say sored by his group along with Mr. Morrison said this review few years.” is “much bigger than Talk TV. Talk what will come of this new gov- organizations such as Unifor and should give CBC offi cials reason Ms. Ashton said a key to the TV was looking at just the delivery ernment initiative or how it will the Alliance of Canadian Cin- to take a step back from its ongo- government’s review will be as- of television content. And it didn’t affect the CRTC’s past moves. ema, Television and Radio Artists ing restructuring process, which sessing mechanisms that are used really go far enough,” she said, not- “For the last couple of years, (ACTRA)—that found decisions includes measures to focus more to fund content. With this in mind, ing there is still a lack of regulation we have been engaged in signifi - by the CRTC resulting from its on content for mobile- and web- she said “silos” into which differ- on online services even as they are cant changes and public reviews TV-industry review would result based platforms. Mr. Morrison ent forms of cultural work are increasingly fulfi lling the same role of CRTC policy,” she said last in the loss of more than 15,000 and others have argued that this separated need to “break down.” regulated TV-service distributors week on the sidelines of yet an- jobs and negatively affect gross is simply an excuse to produce “The way that government traditionally have. other commission hearing—this domestic product by more than content that’s cheaper. has been supporting the cultural As for as how the govern- one dealing with whether broad- $1.4-billion by 2020, taking into Last week, he cited data from industries has been that there’s a ment’s newly launched consulta- band internet should be consid- consideration the direct impact ComScore that indicates the fund for music and there’s a fund tion affects the CBC, Ms. Ashton ered a basic service with guaran- on the TV industry and spinoff CBC’s websites typically have for books and there’s a fund for said: “I’m not sure how Heritage teed access across the country. effects. less than 10,000 people viewing television and fi lm. That has got is thinking in terms of how it’s Ms. Valladao said the public A backgrounder released by them at any give minute, while its to stop because content is not working on the new relationship record created by CRTC consul- Heritage Canada indicated that, TV and radio properties have a being created that way anymore with the CBC, whether that is tations on TV, the internet, and in 2010, Canada’s cultural sector per-minute, combined audience of because of digital. The lines have part of this process or separate other relevant topics can be used accounted for 642,486 jobs and about 800,000. blurred. Creators are looking at process. But I don’t think one has to “enrich the process” that the generated $47.7-billion in eco- “[Ms. Joly] was saying, ‘Okay, many different ways of cross-plat- to happen before the other.” Department of Canadian Heritage nomic activity, which was three this is the government’s fi le now. form content creation, but also [email protected] is now embarking on. per cent of Canada’s GDP and We’re going to take a strong look using digital to deliver content.” The Hill Times A key decision that emerged more than double the agricultur- at all of this stuff,’ ” Mr. Morrison from the CRTC’s TV review al, fi sheries, and forestry indus- said. “So that puts the current was requiring television-service tries combined. leadership of the CBC kind of on PUBLIC INPUT providers to allow customers to Mr. Morrison said this latest notice, and the leadership of the pick channels they want on an initiative from the heritage min- CRTC as well, that the govern- A SAMPLE OF QUESTIONS IN THE ONLINE á la carte basis. It also granted ster might provide a reprieve for ment is now in the driver’s seat.” SURVEY IN THE FIRST PHASE OF THE exemptions from regulation— TV channels that were at risk of He added: “I think if I were the including on Canadian-content being denied carriage by service president of the CBC or the chair GOVERNMENT’S REVIEW OF CANADIAN quotas— for Canadian-based on- providers due to a lack of demand of the CRTC, I’d kind of feel that CONTENT IN THE DIGITAL WORLD: demand video services that make among consumers. … there’s something big looking themselves available through “They’ll be in there saying, over my shoulder.” traditional TV services and also ‘Hey, wait a minute, are you CBC spokeswoman Alexan- • As a Canadian culture/media consumer, looking ahead to 2020, what will be the most as standalone online services. taking us off the air right when dra Fortier said in an email: “We typical way(s) for you to access content? The CRTC also loosened up there’s a major consultation welcome this public consultation • What are the key roles for CBC/Radio-Canada to play in supporting Canadian-content requirements about what should happen going and this important review of our • Canadian content creation, discovery and export in a digital world? for domestic channels, and ended forward?’ ” he said. “It might put sector. The government under- • How important is it to you to have access to local content in your community? the requirement that most of the the breaks on things.” stands the need for change for • How important is it for you to have access to Canadian content in a digital world? channels TV-service customers He cited reported quotes from institutions like ours operating in • What are the most signifi cant barriers facing the culture sector in the creation, discover receive must be Canadian. Ms. Joly about how “everything’s a rapidly changing communica- and export of Canadian content in a digital world? A news release from the on the table” with this review. He tions, technology, broadcasting, • Looking ahead, what do you believe will be the most effective tools for ensuring the Canadian Heritage Department speculated that this could mean a and telecom landscape. … In creation and discovery of great Canadian content in a digital world?

6 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 NEWS NATIONAL SECURITY Opposition blasts Liberals for lack of consultation on security committee

the work of Canadian Security After the Intelligence Service (CSIS) and Conservative the Communications Security Establishment (CSE). But there’s government no external oversight of the intel- introduced its anti- ligence roles of RCMP, Canada Border Services Agency, Citizen- terrorism bill last ship and Immigration Canada, year, the Liberals Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development, and the promised, if elected, Privy Council Offi ce. On Jan. 8, Prime Minister that an all-party Justin Trudeau (Papineau, Que.) committee of appointed fi ve-term Liberal MP David McGuinty (Ottawa South, Parliamentarians Ont.) as chair of this proposed would be established security committee. After his ap- pointment, Mr. McGuinty trav- to monitor the top- elled with Public Safety Minister secret activities of Ralph Goodale (Wascana, Sask.) to Britain to see fi rsthand the in- national security ner workings of its parliamentary intelligence oversight committee. agencies. Opposition parties criticized the appointment of Mr. McGuinty BY ABBAS RANA before the committee has even been established or its members By not consulting the opposi- selected. Also, they said it would tion parties so far in creating have been better if Mr. Trudeau Canada’s fi rst all-party committee had let MPs of this committee to of parliamentarians to oversee elect the chair. intelligence agencies, the Trudeau “It was just someone who was government is “hurting the cred- already named chair of a com- ibility” of a “signature initiative” of mittee that doesn’t even exist now,” Mr. O’Toole said. “I get along its mandate, say opposition MPs. The Senate National Security, pictured in this fi le photo. Conservative MP Erin O’Toole and NDP MP Murray Rankin say well with David McGuinty. I have “It hurts it out of the gate, no that Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale’s last week’s letter indicating his intent to seek input from opposition parties respect for him. He was kind of question,” Conservative MP Erin in establishing the National Security Oversight Committee is a step in the right direction. The Hill Times photographs by Jake named out of the blue and, to O’Toole (Durham, Ont.), a former Wright Cabinet minister in the Stephen most observers, it seems like it Harper government, said in an was his consolation prize for not interview with The Hill Times. being in cabinet.” response from the minister to Mr. Rankin told The Hill Times brief interview three weeks ago With the government constant- Mr. McGuinty is the brother of his fi rst letter. He said although in a second interview that Mr. he told The Hill Times that he ly touting “its open, transparent former Ontario premier Dalton it took the minister about two Goodale’s letter was not ad- was satisfi ed with the progress in sunny ways, all that sort of stuff,” McGuinty. months to respond, he’s happy dressed to him but he was copied. establishing this committee and its approach to this security com- Two-term NDP MP Murray that he received any outreach He said that although being cop- that the government is doing its mittee “runs contrary entirely to Rankin (Victoria, B.C.), a Harvard from the government. Mr. O’Toole ied on a letter does not constitute best to ensure it gets this project that,” Mr. O’Toole said. University trained lawyer and a said that Mr. Goodale’s letter is a consultation, he’s hopeful that right. After the Conservatives former law professor, criticized step in the right direction and he the government will reach out to “We’re on the timeline that introduced the controversial Bill the government for failing to hopes the minister will arrange opposition parties in the coming Minister Goodale suggested from C-51, the so-called Anti-Terrorism reach out to opposition parties for briefi ngs and updates for opposi- weeks and months. the beginning. We hope to have Bill in January last year, Liber- consultation. tion parties on a regular basis. “They say in the letter they the bill on the fl oor by June,” said als called for more robust over- “It’s an opportunity missed,” In the letter from Mr. Goodale, want to consult and so I want to Mr. McGuinty. “We’re working our sight of the country’s intelligence said Mr. Rankin, who in the past dated April 20, he acknowledged live in hope that they do engage way through the details. We’re agencies. They promised, if served as a special advocate in Mr. O’Toole’s March 1 letter and with parliamentary colleagues,” looking at comparative examples. elected, that an all-party commit- classifi ed immigration and refu- said that he has taken “careful said Mr. Rankin. “That hasn’t We’re making sure this is a very tee of parliamentarians would be gee matters and as legal counsel note of suggestions” and will happened in the months since strongly Canadian approach to established to monitor the to the SIRC. “This [consultation] reach out to opposition parties. the government got elected and this challenge, it is Charter com- top-secret activities of national is long overdue and I support the As to the functions of this this is a signature initiative of pliant, it’s going to be properly security agencies. initiative of having a robust com- national security committee of the government. After all, [this resourced, properly empowered, The Liberals voted in support mittee that has its eyes on all of Parliamentarians, Mr. Goodale is ] the fi rst such committee in properly mandated, properly mis- of C-51 but also pledged to repeal the apparatuses; not just CSIS but wrote: “The function of this com- the history of the country with sioned, properly membershipped. some of its controversial provi- CSEC, border security, and the mittee will be to provide review security-cleared parliamentar- These things are core to making sions upon forming government. whole thing. It was an excellent and scrutiny of the national ians. I believe I have a fair bit to sure we get the Canadian model.” The government is expected idea, but to get off on the wrong security activities undertaken by say, based on my experience.” Scott Bardsley, press secre- to table a bill prior to the summer footing is unfortunate.” agencies and departments of the He said that NDP Leader Tom tary to Mr. Goodale, said that parliamentary recess to establish Because opposition parties Government of Canada. The Com- Mulcair (Outremont, Que.) also Mr. Goodale will be consulting this national security committee. were never consulted, Mr. O’Toole mittee will ensure that agencies sent a letter at the end of Febru- Parliamentarians of all parties Elected offi cials in countries such sent two letters—on March 1 and and departments are working ary to Mr. Trudeau about lack of in the coming weeks before the as the United States, Australia, Great April 15—to Mr. Goodale to offer effectively to keep Canadians safe. consultation in the development legislation is tabled. Britain, and New Zealand have his input into how this committee It will also ensure that agencies of this committee. “He looks forward to working access to the national security activi- should be established, including and departments are conducting As of last week, It was not with all parties in a spirit of col- ties of their top-secret agencies, but suggestions on its mandate, struc- themselves in ways that are consis- known precisely what the man- laboration and non-partisanship Canadian politicians do not. ture, and duties. tent with our laws, our fundamen- date, budget, and membership to ensure the long-term success of Currently, the Security Intel- Late last week, Mr. O’Toole tal values, the democratic nature of this committee would be. Mr. this project,” said Mr. Bardsley. ligence Review Committee (SIRC) told The Hill Times in a second of our open society, and with the McGuinty was not available for [email protected] does after-the-fact reviews of interview that he received a rights and freedoms of Canadians.” an interview last week, but in a The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 7 IMPOLITIC JUSTIN TRUDEAU & ENVIRONMENT Trudeau fl irts with betrayal and political backlash

A new Enbridge project to replace an aging ern Alberta have been cancelled and those that Alberta is hurting, pipeline from Alberta to Wisconsin will also continue to pump oil (in an attempt to cut their but what about the add more capacity; half the volume promised losses) are losing money daily. by Northern Gateway. That lower-profi le proj- “Why build pipelines to sell oil at prices environmentally- ect won NEB approval last week and is likely that do not even cover the cost of getting it concerned Canadians to be endorsed by federal cabinet this fall, with out of the ground?,” Rubin writes. As to the construction to start in 2019. oil industry’s hope that prices will rebound who voted for Trudeau This doesn’t address Notley’s primary and new pipelines will be required after expecting him to be better concern, however, which is fi nding new 2020, Rubin says if the world is serious markets in Asia and Europe, rather than about the Paris climate change commit- than Stephen Harper—not shipping exclusively to the U.S. Having a ment that means “a huge and irreversible just better-looking? single customer has meant deeply dis- decline in the combustion of oil.” counted prices for Canadian product—the Meanwhile, Trudeau and Notley appear The fact that people are asking raises serious cheapest oil on the market. less seized with the urgency of getting off doubts about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s However, economist Jeff Rubin argues, in an fossil fuels than with wringing every last honesty, not to mention his environmental cred. illuminating article for the Centre for Inter- drop of profi t from the sector. Asked in New The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright national Governance Innovation, that Alberta York how stopping climate change can be producers are penalized—and will continue compatible with more pipelines, Trudeau to be—because tarry bitumen is expensive to replied: “Do I agree that in the future we are Yes, Alberta is hurting, but what about the refi ne, and must travel long distances to Gulf going to have to get off fossil fuels? Abso- environmentally-concerned Canadians who SUSAN RILEY State refi neries, not because of lack of pipelines. lutely. Is that future tomorrow? No, its not.” voted for Trudeau expecting him to be better The problem becomes more acute with the When, then? We have heard this before than Stephen Harper—not just better-looking? collapse of oil prices; indeed, the oilsands only and we are still waiting for transformative Susan Riley is a veteran political colum- ATINEAU, QUE.–Is the Northern make economic sense when prices are high change—not the retrenchment of a dying nist who writes regularly for The Hill Times. GGateway pipeline dead, or isn’t it? The and rising. Already some 17 projects in north- industry. The Hill Times fact that people are asking raises seri- ous doubts about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s honesty, not to mention his environmental cred. Trudeau was never against pipelines per se; indeed, he endorsed the since-rejected Keystone project. But he spoke unambigu- ously against the Northern Gateway, which would bring bitumen from the Alberta oilsands across the Rocky Mountains, to Kitimat, on the northern B.C. Coast. From there it would be loaded into super-tankers that would ply the narrow and treacherous Hecate Strait to open ocean. Not on my watch, said a campaigning Trudeau. Northern Gateway, which would also traverse the Great Bear Rainforest and more than 700 waterways, was approved by the National Energy Board in 2014, with some 200 conditions. But its fate appeared sealed when Trudeau promised, pre-elec- tion, a formal moratorium on tanker traffi c on the northern B.C. Coast. That promise was thrown into confu- sion last week when Transport Minister Marc Garneau would not confi rm the moratorium’s reach (or whether diesel and refi ned oil might be exempted) and when reports circulated that Trudeau might be open to rerouting the Northern Gateway to Prince Rupert, further north. Questioned by reporters, he insisted “the Great Bear Rainforest is no place for a crude pipeline.” But what about the rest of the coast? This sudden ambiguity appeared to spring from conversations with Alberta Premier Rachel Notley, who has also ex- perienced a change of heart on Northern Gateway. It could be that neither are seri- ously considering the northern route; that they are fl oating a trial balloon, intended to make everyone feel better when they en- dorse the Kinder Morgan pipeline instead. But that project is also controversial: it would twin an existing line between the oilsands and Burnaby, B.C., which would increase oil tanker traffi c from 80 to 400 a year in Vancouver’s harbour. Notley is desperate to get Alberta bitu- men to Asia and is bargaining hard with Get your eyes checked. B.C. Premier Christy Clark, agreeing to buy clean B.C. hydro only if Clark drops her objections to Kinder Morgan. Notley And more. appears to have the prime minister in her corner. The only obstacle is people living along A comprehensive eye exam can do more than test your vision— the contentious routes, both First Nations communities and Vancouver urbanites. it could help detect potentially life threatening conditions, like Trudeau is trying to hang on to his four seats in Alberta—and, perhaps, erase his brain tumours, high blood pressure and diabetes. father’s legacy—by “getting oil to tidewa- ter,” but he stands to lose the 17 seats his party picked up in British Columbia. Book an eye exam with your And for what? Currently, there is excess doctor of optometry today. pipeline capacity—a result, partly, of the oil price collapse and abundant, high quality opto.ca Middle Eastern oil arriving by tanker. 8 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016

Editor Kate Malloy Assistant Deputy Editor Abbas Rana Publishers Anne Marie Creskey, Deputy Editor Derek Abma Online Editor, Power & Influence Editor Ally Foster Jim Creskey, Ross Dickson Managing Editor Kristen Shane Deputy Editor Peter Mezereeuw General Manager, CFO Andrew Morrow

EDITORIAL MINING ACCOUNTABILITY Disagree with Nicholls on carbon Liberals should push mining tax, Tories should offer ideas too e: “It’s not easy being a green grow the size of government. RConservative,” (The Hill By making the polluter pay, accountability internationally Times, April 25, p. 9). I have to the revenue-neutral carbon challenge Gerry Nicholls’ claim tax helps correct a market that a carbon tax is tantamount imbalance and stimulates he New York Times recently published a story mining industries, but the consequences of large- to ideological treason for people economic development in clean on Canadian mining fi rms’ abroad and focused scale mining production by Canadian fi rms also T who bank right of centre. alternatives. on the Guatemalan village of Lote Oche, where involves “extensive collateral damage to the en- Conservatives who If Conservatives don’t like Margarita Caal Caal along with 10 other women vironment. Metal mining can lead to erosion and acknowledge the seriousness the solutions offered by those have launched a negligence suit in Canada against sedimentation, the formation of sinkholes, and the of climate change, including on the left to counter the press- Hudbay Minerals Inc. after she and 10 other women contamination of waters and rivers by chemicals a heavyweight like George ing problem of climate change, claimed that in 2007 “truckloads of soldiers, police such as arsenic, aluminum, magnesium, iron, and Shultz, Ronald Reagan’s they are going to have to pro- offi cers and mining security offi cials and men, who mercury.” As well, “Canadian mining corporations secretary of state, advocated pose something better—some- said belonged to a Canadian mining company” have demonstrated a disregard for registered for a revenue-neutral carbon thing that effectively reduces came to their village to evict them from their land, nature reserves and protected zones.” The report tax. They preferred this emissions while stimulating the took turns raping the women, and set their homes also said, “each year, a number of protesters who policy over its alternative, economy. Opting for “feel-good on fi re. Hudbay, which was not the owner of the raise concerns against mining activities are seri- cap and trade, because it’s vagueness” just doesn’t cut it. mine at the time, and does not own the mine any- ously injured, persecuted, or even killed.” transparent, predictable, Cheryl McNamara more, denies any wrongdoing, saying no mining Here in Canada, the new federal Liberal gov- cost effective, and does not Toronto, Ont. security offi cials were at the Lote Ocho evictions ernment is not saying much about calling for and that no rapes took place. It is also facing claims stronger mechanisms for holding mining com- over the death of a local leader and the shooting panies accountable. As The Hill Times reported and paralysis of a bystander during protests in the recently, several cabinet ministers with related nearby town of El Estor in 2009, reported The New fi les either dodged or declined questions from Climate doublespeak by the Grits York Times. Hudbay says no negligence took place reporter Peter Mazereeuw, or declined to say in 2009 when it owned the mine and that security whether change to existing government mining ’m increasingly annoyed with The latest bit of doublespeak guards were defending themselves from armed accountability policy was needed. Ithe constant climate double- goes to the heart of national protesters. The new federal Liberal government should speak coming from the Trudeau unity apparently. Environment According to Global Affairs Canada, more establish a code of conduct in the mining and government. Doublespeak and Climate Change Minister than 50 per cent of the world’s publicly-listed exploration industries abroad and it should occurs when someone talks in Catherine McKenna said that exploration and mining companies were head- move on Liberal MP John McKay’s former pri- half-truths or uses mild expres- the Liberals will risk a national quartered in Canada in 2013, including 1,500 vate member’s bill from the last Parliament to sions designed to hide the truth. unity crisis by moving too fast companies with an interest in 8,000 properties create an ombudsman to investigate complaints The Liberals’ climate language on carbon pricing. So she would in more than 100 countries around the world. of violations of human rights, international is deliberately ambiguous and have us believe that the country The Council on Hemispheric Affairs, based criminal law, and environmental degradation. contradictory to purposely will fall apart if we move aggres- in Washington, D.C., released a report in 2014 The Liberals pushed it in opposition and during shape public opinion on govern- sively on climate policy. “That’s revealing that Canadian companies control ap- the campaign, they should lead on it in govern- ment climate action. actually been a real good way to proximately 50 to 70 per cent of Latin America ment. Following the recent fi rst split up our country,” said McK- ministers meeting ending with enna at the Broadbent Institute the Vancouver declaration, Prime summit in Ottawa. Minister Justin Trudeau said, “we By using doublespeak, Trudeau must also continue to generate and his cabinet are quietly lying wealth from our abundant natural to themselves and Canadians. resources to fund this transition to You can’t have it both ways. Sup- a low-carbon economy.” porting fossil fuels and reducing What he really means is that carbon emissions do not mix. putting pipelines in the ground The Liberals must make a will help pay for the country’s choice. At some point, Canadi- transition to a greener future. A ans will realize they are being complete oxymoron! That would deceived and manipulated. be like a drug cartel using illegal Rolly Montpellier money to build a hospital. Ottawa, Ont.

Diseases of poverty remain biggest mass killers rime Minister Justin Trudeau countries, but Canada has never Pannounced Canada’s bid met this target, and Trudeau has for a seat on the UN Security remained silent about it. Council with a promise to “build Canadian resources, fair the world of tomorrow” by re- mindedness, and ingenuity are storing Canada’s role as global needed more than ever to lead peacekeeper and champion of global humanitarian efforts to human rights. Trudeau’s prom- eradicate diseases like TB. A ise honours the legacy of Lester public commitment to increased Pearson, who helped to estab- foreign aid, directed towards lish the UN peacekeeping force programs with proven results, in the 1950s, but it does not go is a promise that Trudeau must far enough. Pearson also cre- make so that “the world of to- ated the UN’s target of 0.7 per morrow” is a truly better world. cent of gross national income Chitra Ramaswami for foreign aid spending by rich Calgary, Alta.

EDITORIAL Cardozo, John Chenier, David Coletto, Sheila Copps, David DIRECTOR OF ADVERTISING Steve Macdonald DELIVERY INQUIRIES Please send letters to the editor to the SENIOR REPORTERS Tim Naumetz, and Crane, Jim Creskey, Murray Dobbin, Gwynne Dyer, Michael CORPORATE ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Craig Caldbick, [email protected] above street address or e-mail to news@ Laura Ryckewaert Geist, Greg Elmer, Alice Funke, J.L. Granatstein, Éric Grenier, Martin Reaume, Ulle Baum 613-688-8822 hilltimes.com. Deadline is Wednesday at REPORTER, POWER & INFLUENCE ASSISTANT Dennis Gruending, Cory Hann, Tim Harper, Chantal Hébert, noon, Ottawa time. Please include your full EDITOR Rachel Aiello Jenn Jefferys, David T. Jones, Joe Jordan, Warren Kinsella, PRODUCTION name, address and daytime phone number. NEWS REPORTER Chelsea Nash Camille Labchuk, Gillian McEachern, Arthur Milnes, Nancy PRODUCTION MANAGER Benoit Deneault The Hill Times reserves the right to edit PHOTOGRAPHERS Sam Garcia, Cynthia Münster, Peckford, Kate Purchase, Tim Powers, Michael Qaqish, SENIOR GRAPHIC, ONLINE DESIGNER Joey Sabourin letters. Letters do not reflect the views of and Jake Wright Jeremy Richler, Susan Riley, Ken Rubin, Sarah Schmidt, Rick JUNIOR GRAPHIC DESIGNER Melanie Brown The Hill Times. Thank you. POWER & INFLUENCE ASSISTANT EDITOR Smith, Evan Sotiropoulos, Scott Taylor, Ian Wayne, Nelson WEB DESIGNER Kobra Amirsardari Wiseman, Les Whittington and Armine Yalnizyan Publications Mail Agreement No. 40068926 Christina Leadlay PUBLISHED EVERY MONDAY AND WEDNESDAY RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN EDITORIAL CARTOONIST Michael De Adder ADMINISTRATION BY HILL TIMES PUBLISHING INC. ADDRESSES TO: CIRCULATION DEPT. CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Denis Calnan, Simon ADVERTISING FINANCE/ADMINISTRATION Tracey Wale 69 Sparks Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5A5 69 Sparks Street, Ottawa, ON K1P 5A5 Doyle, Christopher Guly, Leslie MacKinnon, Carl VP OF ADVERTISING AND BUSINESS RECEPTION Alia Kellock Heward (613) 232-5952 Fax (613) 232-9055 Meyer and Cynthia Münster DEVELOPMENT Don Turner CIRCULATION SALES MANAGER Chris Peixoto Canadian Publications Mail Agreement No. 40068926 CMCA 2012 Better AUDITED Newspaper COLUMNISTS Keith Brooks, Karl Bélanger, Andrew ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Amanda Keenan • www.hilltimes.com Winner THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 9 EDITORIAL & COMMENT

COPPS’ CORNER MIKE DUFFY & SENATE

Senator Mike Duffy, In the end, Duffy pictured April 21 on his way into the Ontario courthouse, mess may prompt a was cleared later that day on charges better Red Chamber of bribery, fraud, and Duffy gave each guest a chance sprinkled his partisan commen- breach of But the discredit to be heard. He refrained from the tary with juicy insider tidbits that trust. The that this whole oft-used interview practice of cutting political junkies absolutely soaked Hill Times people off to posit an opposing point. up. He was, undoubtedly, the best photograph affair visited on the In most instances, he never fundraiser on the Conservative cir- by Cynthia promoted his personal opinion. He cuit after the prime minister. Münster Red Chamber is far simply provided a forum for politi- But when he became a politi- from over. cians to debate their differences. cal liability, Conservatives were Duffy didn’t seem to have a quick to construct his demise. mean bone in his body until he Retired Senators Marjory Le- was so close to his Senate dream, Breton and Irving Gerstein, along that he could taste it. with current Senators David Tka- That happened when he over- chuk and Carolyn Stewart Olsen, rode a Halifax journalist by broad- followed prime ministerial offi ce casting a language story about Lib- orders in an orchestrated effort Even after the complete exon- But the discredit that this SHEILA COPPS eral leader Stéphane Dion during to throw Duffy under the bus. eration, journalists were weighing whole affair visited on the Red the 2008 election. The story killed Two of them are still sitting in the in on matters of moral, if not legal Chamber is far from over. the Grit campaign in its tracks. Senate with virtually no negative rectitude. Out-dated rules, or lack TTAWA—Mike Duffy spent Duffy broadcast outtakes repercussions from the mess they For some, the not guilty deci- thereof, inexplicable residency Omost of his media life trying of a tortuous interview, which collectively created. sion on all 31 charges means requirements, and lax travel poli- to get into the Senate. purported to underscore the The Senators got help from nothing. A National Post headline cies scream out for reform. He must now spend his Senate francophone leader’s inability to some journalists, happy to weigh screamed out: “Andrew Coyne: The notion that new Sena- life trying to stay out of the media. understand the English language. in on Duffy’s troubles with the when not criminal does not con- tors are non-partisan is welcome It was common insider knowl- Outtakes are usually thrown in venom often reserved for turncoat stitute innocent.” in theory. But its application in edge, even when Mike worked the editing heap, when the inter- former reporters. The media backlash that Duffy practice could prove to be a more for the Canadian Broadcasting viewer, or the interviewee miscue Duffy made a great target. It faced is not going away any time diffi cult challenge. Corporation, that ‘the Duff’ would on a question during a pre-taped was a lot easier to get exclusive soon. The appointment of Sena- like to become a Senator. interview and subsequently re- leaked stories from the prime min- He was wise to let his lawyer tor Peter Harder was a good Most journalists make a per- ask or re-answer it. ister’s offi ce by focussing all media do the talking for him on a day start. His background as a prime sonal point of refusing to cross that CTV was subsequently found attention on a few rogue Senators. when he could have gloated about ministerial assistant, balanced Rubicon. They take pride in cyni- guilty of violating broadcast But when the judgment came the vindication. by a lifetime of public service, cism, which can be a necessary lens standards by making the decision in last week, it was unequivocal. Hopefully, Duffy will author a will hold him in good stead in the through which to interpret politics. to carry the offending clip. By The accused was innocent on all book that could give the layman management of a new Senate. Duffy was never that way. As a that time, Duffy had already been counts, with particularly vitriolic some insight into his side of the In the end, the Duffy mess may journalist, he was widely respected elevated to the Senate. judicial criticism reserved for the full story. prompt a better Red Chamber. by politicians for giving everyone By all accounts, Duffy was a PMO and those Conservatives Meanwhile, Stephen Harper’s Sheila Copps is a former Jean a fair shake. When he received the great draw as a Senator. His com- who concocted and defended this actions did not go unpunished. Chrétien-era Cabinet minister and nod to host his own show, he had no mand of politics, and his friendly- “monstrous” deception. This senatorial mess defi nitely a former deputy prime minister. shortage of guests. All parties liked speaking style were popular on Duffy now has the arduous task contributed to the prime minis- She is a registered lobbyist today. to appear on the program because the rubber chicken circuit. Duff of rebuilding his tattered reputation. ter’s electoral defeat. The Hill Times

POST-PARTISAN PUNDIT JUSTIN TRUDEAU

“Ho hum, another picture of the prime minister in the news- Forget the steak, focus on the sizzle paper striking a yoga pose. Boy, that’s getting old.” This is why, to keep things fresh, the Liberals may eventually To offset any swer the following question which Send Trudeau to a visually hip and dreamy, doesn’t necessarily have to get more creative with is scientifi cally designed to test a interesting location, i.e. a gym- mean he’s also a good leader, right? their photo ops, i.e. Trudeau might backlash, the person’s aptitude for the job. nasium, a physics lab, the White But as a rule, citizens are will- have to box a panda bear, in a Which of the following two House, etc. ing to suspend reality and accept physics lab, using a yoga-style Liberals may have to actions would be more likely to Have Trudeau inundate jour- public relations-induced illusions fi ghting technique. improve a political candidate’s im- nalists with a slew of captivating about their leaders But even then, Canadians tone down the glitz age: (a) authoring a 500-page study photo ops, e.g. Trudeau sparring After all, it gives us a sense of might start to wonder, “Hey I and focus on getting examining public infrastructure in a boxing match, Trudeau peer- pride and maybe even a feeling of see so many pictures of Trudeau funding or (b) posing in a photo-op ing into a microscope, Trudeau security to think the people leading acting like a hip celebrity maybe Trudeau endorsed with a pair of adorable panda bears? hugging pandas, or Trudeau pos- our country are brilliant or strong it means he doesn’t care about If you answered “B,” the panda ing with Hollywood celebrities. or somehow blessed by the gods. regular slobs like me.” by Fields and photo-op, congratulations, you Bask in the glow of resulting Indeed, it’s for the sake of To offset such a backlash the Streams magazine clearly understand the basic prin- positive media coverage. image that throughout history Liberals may have to tone down ciple of political communications, Using this formula, the monarchs have always surround- the glitz and focus on getting instead of GQ. which is that when it comes to Liberals have managed to craft ed themselves with pomp and Trudeau endorsed by Fields and persuasion, people are typically in- Trudeau’s image so that he comes circumstance. Streams magazine instead of GQ. fl uenced not by intellectual appeals across as a leader who’s dripping As George Bernard Shaw once Imagery campaigns for politi- but by simplistic visual imagery. with coolness and awesomeness put it, “Kings are not born, but cians must always be carefully Simply put, as a species we’re and oodles of sensitivity. made by universal hallucination.” monitored and calibrated. wired to assume that if something One day he looks like a sexy At any rate, this is the emo- And that’s a good lesson for glitters, then it’s probably gold. pugilist, the next day like a physics tional need which Trudeau and would-be communicators. GERRY NICHOLLS Certainly this is something genius, the next, like a movie star. his team are tapping into. The political images them- Prime Minister Justin Trudeau It’s no wonder GQ magazine Mind you, such a communica- selves might be simple, but the and his communications team recently named Trudeau, “the tions strategy also contains risks. strategy behind them can be understands extremely well. most stylish politician alive.” It’s possible, for instance, that tricky. AKVILLE, ONT.—Anyone In fact, you can break down Of course, in reality all this the Liberal image-making machine Gerry Nicholls is a communi- Oout there pondering a career Trudeau’s image-building com- imagery stuff is nonsensical. could over fl ood the media market cations consultant. in the exciting world of political munication strategy into a simple I mean, just because Trudeau is with Trudeau photo ops and hence www.gerrynicholls.com communications should fi rst an- three-point formula: cleverly marketed as stylish and reach an “imagery saturation point.” The Hill times 10 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 THE WAR ROOM DONALD TRUMP Want to defeat Donald Trump, North America?

Like everyone else, Mexicans Don’t be outraged and have been transfi xed by the offended all the time. Be ongoing psychodrama that is Donald Trump. Photograph by Canadian instead: wear Gage Skidmore him down with civility and honesty and decency.

WARREN KINSELLA

UNTA NIZUC, MEXICO—A wall. Don- Pald Trump, the bilious billionaire who is edging ever closer to the Oval Offi ce, wants to build a great big wall between this country and the United States. He says he is going to get Mexicans to pay for it. The reason? Mexicans are “rapists,” he says. “Murderers,” too. Now, like everyone else, Mexicans have been transfi xed by the ongoing psychodra- ma that is Donald Trump. They’ve watched, for months, as a horrifi ed Republican es- tablishment—and then a perplexed and/or concerned Democrat establishment—have tried to come to grips with Trump’s undeni- able momentum. They’re not big fans. Former Mexican president Vincente Fox called Trump “racist and ignorant” for what he said about Mexi- co. He said Trump’s anti-Mexican insults— which the short-fi ngered vulgarian has repeated over and over—were “disgraceful and highly offensive.” “He thinks building the ‘Trump Wall’ will right every wrong in the United States,” Fox said. “Indeed, he’s built a huge mental wall around himself already, which doesn’t al- low him to see the greatness of our people.” And Mexico is indeed great. It was the place where fi ve complex civilizations came into being some 13,000 years ago—and several centuries before pink-skinned (or, in Trump’s case, orange-skinned) Europe- ans arrived. The Olmec, Maya, Teotihuacan, Toltec, and Aztec indigenous peoples were innovating in architecture, mathematics, astronomy, medicine, and theology while Donald Trump’s ancestors were still drag- ging their hirsute knuckles around in what driving—and reading and driving—but intellectual—Ford Nation only grew more mier, Bill Davis. Davis famously personi- would later become Rhineland Germany. those things turned out to be true, too. popular. A large segment of Torontonians fi ed the “bland works” formula, and always (Oh, and on Trump’s German anteced- He used racial epithets to describe non- loved how Rob and Doug Ford enraged the did his utmost to be as unexciting as pos- ents: Vincente Fox said that the putative white Torontonians, who form a majority in establishment. They weren’t horrifi ed by sible. Tory, a smart student, did likewise. He Republican Party nominee reminded him that city of some fi ve million. He said and their outrageousness—they were drawn to it. beat Ford Nation, and rather decisively, too. of Adolf Hitler. We note, without comment, did awful things—on one occasion bowl- Ford Nation voters, in the main, were Politicians (or, more accurately, anti-pol- that Hitler had a deep, documented affi n- ing over a female councillor who got in his angry, older white men living in Toronto’s iticians) like Rob Ford and Donald Trump ity for the birthplace of the Trump family way, and on another occasion extending inner suburbs. They lacked post-secondary are cut from the same cloth. They have no name. Draw your own conclusions.) his middle fi nger to a child. He swore at education and riches, but Rob Ford was legislative accomplishments to speak of. Anyway. It’s hard to spend too much time people. He got drunk in public. their guy. The more the media and the They have no overriding policy goal. They thinking about a subject as ugly as Trump- Mexicans heard all about Rob Ford elites attacked him, the more they liked it. simply are the ultra-conservative million- ism, in a place as beautiful as this. But, as his because, for a time, he was the most famous Sound familiar? aire sons of millionaire fathers. So, to get team’s sturmabteilung march gets closer to Canadian who ever lived—more famous And then, around the time that Ford noticed, they talk louder. They are more the prize in Cleveland, we need to. Can he be that Michael J. Fox, Celine Dion, and Arcade was planning another run at the mayor’s outrageous. They say things no one else will. stopped? Can he be beaten? Fire all put together. He appeared on Jimmy offi ce—and around the time that he was For a while, as Rob Ford showed an as- Take it from visiting Canadians, Mexi- Kimmel. He was name-checked in late-night grappling with a cancer diagnosis that tounded Canada (and a bemused U.S. and can allies: Trump-style politicians can in- talk show monologues. He was international would ultimately (and tragically) kill him— Mexico) that sort of demented populism deed be beaten. Up in the frigid North, we news—day after interminable day. something unexpected happened. Some- will work. Then, eventually, it doesn’t. had extended exposure to a variant on the Mexicans observing the Trump phenom- thing surprising, to those who had reluc- The Ford Nation movement was Trump genus: former Ford Nation. enon with dismay will be sadly familiar tantly come to acknowledge the immense defeated—just as Trump’s can and will Once formidable, once unstoppable, with how too many Toronto voters initially power of Ford Nation. be beaten—for this reason: after a while, Ford Nation was ultimately defeated by reacted to Rob Ford. Rob Ford became a lot less popular. He average folks simply get tired of being at that uniquely Canadian personality trait: Instead of denouncing him, they laughed started to lose. Because Torontonians had the circus all the time. After a while—and relentless, plodding civility. at him. Instead of seeking his ouster, they become weary of all the drama, all the time. even if they distrust or dislike govern- Ford Nation, many Americans will per- indicated they would be willing to vote for When the city’s 2014 municipal election ment, as many Canadians and Americans haps recall, was just as offensive, and just as him again. Instead of opposing him, they rolled around, Ford Nation’s principal chal- and Mexicans increasingly do—they just bigoted, and just as out-of-control as is Don- lined up to get selfl ess taken with him—or lenger turned out to be a calm, thought- want to go home, watch TV, and not hear ald Trump. Despite all that, its champion Rob they stood in queues to purchase his bobble- ful, inoffensive former business executive from politicians anymore. Particularly the Ford won a landslide victory in the mayoral head doll, conveniently sold right out of the named John Tory. Tory—against whom, full shouty ones—who don’t know how to do race in Canada’s largest and most diverse city Offi ce of the Mayor of Toronto. disclosure, I had briefl y campaigned with anything but, you know, shout. in 2010—and his brother Doug very nearly Pundits and politicos roundly and angri- another candidate—was the embodiment Want to defeat Donald Trump, North repeated the feat in 2014. Rob, in particular, ly condemned Rob Ford, naturally. Political of wholesome Canadianness. Compared America? Don’t be outraged and offended would go on to become the most famous Ca- panel talking heads would intone—again to Ford, he was a bit boring. He was a little all the time. Be Canadian instead: wear him nadian. But for all the wrong reasons. and again—that, this time, he had gone too bland, even. He was nice. down with civility and honesty and decency. Ford denied smoking crack cocaine, far. That he was fi nished. And it worked. He won. Trump, like Ford, won’t know what hit then admitted he had indeed smoked it But with every elite dismissal—with Many years earlier, Tory had been chief him. Wall or no wall. while in offi ce. He denied drinking and every op-ed from yet another pointy-headed of staff to the long-serving Ontario pre- The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 11 INSIDE POLITICS JUSTIN TRUDEAU Trudeau’s anger can endear him to voters

Prime Minister spoke of “root causes” of terror with Times columnist Maureen Dowd The prime Justin Trudeau, the CBC’s Peter Mansbridge. wrote after the Brussels attacks, minister sounded pictured in this fi le “There is no question that remains “too cool for school.’’ photo, is no longer this happened because there is Obama’s resistance to cheap legitimately angry above the fray and someone who feels completely emotion, Dowd wrote, “has led he has been forced excluded, completely at war with him, time after time, to respond over the horrible to react with innocents, at war with a society. belatedly or bloodlessly in mo- death of Canadian resolve he lacked And our approach has to be, ments when Americans are in 2013. But the okay, where do those tensions alarmed, wanting solace and John Ridsdel at the fate of Robert Hall come from?” Trudeau said, leading solutions.’’ largely rests with Harper to accuse him of “rational- Obama reacted to the Brussels hands of terrorists. him and there can izing” terror attacks. killings while watching a baseball be no tougher test Last November, the newly in- game in Havana, but Dowd con- of a prime minis- stalled prime minister seemed shak- cluded he has kept his focus on ter’s resolve than en by the attacks in Paris. “These the fi ght against terrorism. that, writes Tim terrorist attacks are deeply worrying All leaders have been accused Harper. The Hill and obviously unsettling to people of being tone deaf in their re- Times photograph around the world,’’ he said, without sponse to terror attacks. by Andrew Meade specifi cally condemning them. George W. Bush channelled TIM HARPER A few months later, following American defi ance with his bullhorn the attacks in Brussels, he found his moment in the wreckage of the outrage. “This cannot and will not World Trade Center after 9/11, but his ometimes you’ve got to be times a country needs a leader to Trudeau has downplayed the fear be tolerated. Canada strongly con- Wild West hunt for Osama bin Laden Spissed off. channel anger and surely there spread by terror attacks, but since demns these cowardly acts. Those and his bid to form a coalition for the Justin Trudeau got there this was anger—along with sympathy becoming Liberal leader in 2013, responsible for carrying out these wrong war became both caricature week as his response to terrorism for Ridsdel’s family and friends— he has taken on the role of amateur senseless attacks must be brought and foreign policy folly. continues its remarkable evolution. over the brutal and senseless kill- psychologist, appeared shaken, and to justice and we will do all we can In January 2015, Stephen Harp- The prime minister sounded ing of an innocent Canadian. seemed devoid of genuine outrage. to help make that happen.’’ er chose to attend 200th birthday legitimately angry over the horrible Trudeau called it what it was, Indeed, his response to a Burki- Upon news of the senseless celebrations in Kingston, Ont., for death of Canadian John Ridsdel at “cold-blooded murder,” a substan- na Faso terror attack that killed six killing of Ridsdel, Trudeau said: Sir John A. Macdonald rather than the hands of terrorists, and resolute tive change in tone from a man Quebec humanitarian workers in “This was an act of cold-blooded march in Paris with other world in his statement that this country who, since becoming Liberal January was deemed so bland, the murder and the responsibility leaders condemning the Charlie will not pay terrorist ransoms—di- leader, has often appeared to be husband of one of the victims hung rests squarely with the terrorist Hebdo massacre. rectly or indirectly. overshooting in his quest to pro- up on the prime minister when group who took him hostage.’’ Trudeau is no longer above the This will not bring Ridsdel back vide perspective and undershoot- Trudeau called to offer condolences. He said Canada would work fray and he has been forced to react and it will not safeguard the fate of ing on the question of outrage. But there has been an unmis- with the Philippines and interna- with resolve he lacked in 2013. But another Canadian being held in the This is, in fact, a major testing of takable evolution. tional partners to bring the killers the fate of Hall largely rests with him Philippines. a prime minister barely six months In his fi rst substantive interview to justice. and there can be no tougher test of a Trudeau did not bow to the into his job. The fate of a second after winning the Liberal leader- In many ways, Trudeau’s prime minister’s resolve than that. knee jerk reaction that some of his Canadian being held, 50-year-old ship three years ago, bombs had default position has been to rise Tim Harper is a national affairs opponents urge, he did not send in Robert Hall, hangs in the balance. just killed three and maimed more above the fray, a mien much like writer for The Toronto Star. This the JTF2 or pledge to carpet bomb The no-ransom policy is noble than 200 at the fi nish line of the that of his new-found friend, column was released on April 27. terrorist strongholds, but some- and correct. And risky. Boston massacre, and Trudeau Barack Obama, who, as New York The Hill Times ECONOMIC CLUB OF CANADA

Child & Youth TALENT FOR Mental Health; Shifting the INNOVATION Lens to Our Youngest Harnessing Canadians Kimberly Dr. Hazen Gandy, Alex Moran, MD, FRCPC Munter Canada’s research CPA, CA Head, Division President & President % of Child and CEO CEO Adolescent Children’s advantage Children’s Psychiatry Hospital Mental Department of of Eastern Health Psychiatry, Faculty of Ontario Join Mitacs and leaders from business, Ontario Medicine, University (CHEO) of Ottawa, government, and academia as we examine Children’s Hospital strategies to effectively engage and employ of Eatern Ontarion our research innovators. As part of an ongoing initiative to shed light on the challenges of mental health facing Canadians, the Economic Club is eager to continue this important discussion and delve into the grassroots aspect of this topic bringing the focus to our children and youth. This panel will discuss and explore Register at mitacs.ca/en/events the issues facing our young people, important challenges facing healthcare systems in a time of fiscal restraint, and government policy initiatives that could make a significant difference. Tuesday, May 11, 2016 Forum: 1–4:30p.m. Wednesday, May 11th, 2016 National Arts Centre, Ottawa Reception: 4:30–6p.m. 11:30 a.m. - 1:30 p.m., The Fairmont Chateau Laurier - Laurier Ballroom 1 Rideau Street, Ottawa ~ Individual member ticket price $89, Individual Non-Member ticket price $110. Tables of 10 available. Lunch will be served. Advance registration is required – numbers are limited. For tickets call (613) 369-4363, visit www.mitacs.ca www.economicclub.ca 12 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 DIGITAL POLITICS CANCON Digital Cancon review: Let’s start be wary of old whine in new bottles at impossible The modernization of Cancon regulation offers the opportunity to rethink and go longstanding policies by prioritizing global markets, consumer choice, from there. competition, and the benefi ts of an expanded creative class that includes Where others struggle, we thrive. We are a team of the foremost infrastructure practitioners operating across both commercial and non- all stages of the lifecycle of an infrastructure asset. commercial participants. We work shoulder to shoulder with our clients to solve the most daunting infrastructure challenges of our time. We are KPMG’s Infrastructure team. Canadian Heritage Minister Mélanie Joly kpmg.ca/infrastructure surprised culture and internet watchers last week by announcing plans for a comprehensive MICHAEL GEIST review of Canadian content policies in a digital world. The Hill Times photograph Jake Wright

anadian Heritage Minister Mélanie Joly provider tax to fund the creation of Cancon. Csurprised culture and internet watch- An ISP tax (or levy) was rejected by the Su- ers last week by announcing plans for a preme Court of Canada in 2012, but rewriting comprehensive review of Canadian content the Broadcasting Act and the Telecommunica- policies in a digital world. Joly says every- tions Act will offer the possibility of new con- thing is on the table including broadcasting sumer fees to offset declining contributions regulation, Cancon funding mechanisms, from the broadcasting sector. Levies on Inter- copyright law, the role of the CBC, and the net access would run counter to other policy future of the Canadian Radio-television and goals, however, notably ensuring universal, Telecommunications Commission (CRTC). affordable broadband for all Canadians since While there is little doubt that the current increases to the cost of Internet service would framework was established for a different likely widen the digital divide. era, rules that have sheltered the industry The competing objectives highlight another from foreign competition and transferred complication of the consultation, namely the hundreds of millions of dollars from con- overlap between government departments. sumers to creator groups will not disappear Canadian Heritage will lead on cultural issues, without a fi ght. Indeed, the most common re- but there are signifi cant implications for oth- frain from the Canadian cultural community ers such as Minister of Innovation, Science is likely to be that the existing rules should and Economic Development Navdeep Bains be extended to the internet. (responsible for telecommunications and Joly’s consultation may be new, but copyright) and International Trade Minister questions about adapting Canadian content Chrystia Freeland (the TransPacifi c Partner- regulations to the digital environment have ship limits Canadian cultural policies). been around for some time. For example, Policy overlap is particularly pro- the primary impetus behind the CRTC’s nounced on copyright, with some groups much-maligned TalkTV consultation was the eyeing the Cancon consultation as the dramatic shift in the television landscape chance to demand further changes to the due to the internet. With rapid growth of Copyright Act, despite the fact that a review unregulated internet-based alternatives such of that law is already scheduled for 2017. as Netfl ix drawing millions of Canadian sub- Moreover, copyright was just modernized scribers and offering new venues for sales of in 2012, with new rules designed to foster Canadian content, the commission was faced digital user generated content, promote with diffi cult policy choices on how to adapt online distribution, and tackle websites that old rules into the digital reality. enable infringement. If anything, Canadian It implored creator groups to focus on copyright law is still more restrictive than leveraging the internet by competing on a its U.S. counterpart, where fair use laws of- global stage, while urging broadcasters to fer more fl exibility to creators of all stripes adopt consumer-friendly packages given than Canada’s fair dealing provisions. the emergence of greater consumer choice The modernization of Cancon regulation that ultimately seems likely to lead to a offers the opportunity to rethink longstanding mass exodus from the regulated system. policies by prioritizing global markets, con- The reaction from the Canadian culture sumer choice, competition, and the benefi ts of establishment? an expanded creative class that includes both Most paid lip service to competing for new commercial and non-commercial participants. audiences, focusing instead on demands for Next week’s column will examine some of the Netfl ix taxes, Cancon requirements for digital policy possibilities, but for now, Canadians services, retention of longstanding protection- should be wary of a consultation process that ist rules such as simultaneous substitution, could quickly devolve into a rush to regulate and the continuation of expensive consumer the internet with claims that cultural policies television packages to preserve existing chan- in the digital world is little more than old wine nels. There is little reason to believe those in new bottles.

© 2016 KPMG LLP, a Canadian limited liability partnership and a member groups will offer a different vision of Cana- Michael Geist holds the Canada Re- firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with dian content regulation this time round. search Chair in Internet and E-commerce KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. In fact, they will likely expect even more Law at the University of Ottawa, Faculty All rights reserved. The KPMG name and logo are registered trademarks or trademarks of KPMG International. from this consultation. In addition to regula- of Law. He can be reached at mgeist@uot- tions over internet-based video services, there tawa.ca or online at www.michaelgeist.ca. will be calls to implement an internet service The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 13 NEWS TERRORISM Feds should identify dangerous regions around the world on passports: former Liberal MP ‘Nobody gets released for free,’ said Gar Pardy, a former Department of Foreign Affairs offi cial who dealt with more than 100 cases of kidnapped Canadians.

Continued from page 1 be done or have an expectation that the government can do anything in these cir- cumstances,” said former fi ve-term Liberal MP Dan McTeague in an interview with The Hill Times after the murder of Cana- dian John Ridsdel, 68, in the Philippines by the Abu Sayyaf Group, a violent separatist group and a criminal syndicate known for numerous kidnappings, assassinations, and which was asking for an $8-million ransom for Mr. Ridsdel. Another Canadian Robert Hall, 50, a Filipino woman, and a Norwe- gian man were still being held hostage by this group as of late last week. Kidnappers have demanded a ransom of about $8-mil- lion for each of them. Mr. McTeague, who served as par- liamentary secretary to the minister of foreign affairs between 2003 and 2005, said Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, right, said Canada ‘does not and will not pay ransom.’ Former Liberal MPs Dan McTeauge, centre, and David Kilgour. that he does not know of even one case The Hill Times photographs by Jake Wright when the Canadian government paid a ransom. In his position as parliamentary secretary, he oversaw the consular affairs issues. that terrorists understand that they cannot Mr. McTeague said that Mr. Trudeau In recent years, several Canadians But Canada and other countries often continue to fund their crimes and their should have made the statement that have been kidnapped but were freed do pay ransoms directly or indirectly to violence taking innocents hostage.” Canada does not pay ransom, before Mr. after a ransom was paid to their secure the release of their citizens from After Mr. Ridsdel’s murder and the Ridsdel was killed—not after. kidnappers. But the federal government kidnappers. prime minister’s statement, a number of for- “It’s okay for the federal government denied that ransoms were paid in However, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau mer foreign service offi cials and politicians and the prime minister to rightly claim that any of these cases. Amongst these (Papineau, Que.) said last week that Can- who in the past dealt with consular affairs we don’t pay ransoms. You should have cases include the release of former ada never does pay ransoms and he was have weighed in on whether Mr. Trudeau’s made that clear when the risk occurred,” Canadian diplomats Robert Fowler and right to say that, said another former MP. statement is accurate and whether govern- said Mr. McTeague. Louis Guay, and journalist Amanda “You’ve got to get that perception out ments do everything they can, including He said for Canadian companies operat- Lindhout. In both cases, it’s believed there,” said David Kilgour, former secre- paying ransom, to free their citizens from ing overseas with Canadian workers, it hundreds of thousands of dollars were tary of state for Latin America, Africa, and kidnappers for the safe release. should be mandatory for them to buy risk paid in ransom. Asia-Pacifi c in the Jean Chrétien govern- “Nobody gets released for free,” said insurance to deal with cases in which any [email protected] ment from 1997 to 2003. Gar Pardy, a former Department of Foreign of their employees are kidnapped. The Hill Times Mr. Kilgour, an Edmonton-area MP Affairs offi cial who dealt with more than for 27 years between 1979 and 2006, fi rst 100 cases of kidnapped Canadians. “Some- as a Progressive Conservative and later thing has to happen here, and even coun- Canada’s origin story as Liberal, said that while technically it tries like the [United States and Israel] who might be accurate for Canadian and other are the keepers of that particular policy in Western countries’ governments to say they a much more rigid way than others, they’ve May 10, 2016 do not pay ransom, it’s often done though done the same thing. There are cases in 7:30 am - 8:45 am intermediaries or a third parties. which they’ve made arrangements for the Parliamentary Restaurant, Centre Block “The fact is that it would be almost release of their people and [dealt] with the inhuman if a government of a wealthy kidnappers through intermediaries and $25—Free for parliamentarians and media country like Canada wouldn’t do their ut- people have been released as a result.” Breakfast included most including paying something through Mr. Pardy, who retired in 2003, declined a third party to get somebody free,” said to discuss the specifi cs of cases that he dealt with, but said in some cases money ^ŝŶĐĞŽŶĨĞĚĞƌĂƟŽŶŝŶϭϴϲϳ͕ĂŶĂĚĂŚĂƐŝĚĞŶƟĮĞĚ Mr. Kilgour. and conducted itself as a country of two founding During his time as a junior minister, Mr. was paid to kidnappers raised by families, Kilgour said that he dealt with a case of by employers, or covered by insurance. ŶĂƟŽŶƐ͕ƚŚĞƌŝƟƐŚĂŶĚƚŚĞ&ƌĞŶĐŚ͕ǁŚŝůĞ kidnapping of eight Canadians in Ecuador “A lot of the cases we had there was ƐƵďŽƌĚŝŶĂƟŶŐƚŚĞƐƚĂƚƵƐŽĨ/ŶĚŝŐĞŶŽƵƐƉĞŽƉůĞƐ͘ in 1999. Seven of these were employees kidnapping insurance, or sometimes the ŶĞǁƉƌŽũĞĐƚƐĞĞŬƐƚŽĂůƚĞƌƚŚĂƚŶĂƌƌĂƟǀĞƚŚƌŽƵŐŚ family raised some money and things like of United Pipeline Systems, an Edmonton ŽĸĐŝĂůƌĞĐŽŐŶŝƟŽŶ͕ŽŶƚŚĞϭϱϬƚŚĂŶŶŝǀĞƌƐĂƌLJŽĨ company, while the eighth was travelling that. [It] doesn’t always come back to the with three Spanish tourists. All eight were Canadian government as such in these ŽŶĨĞĚĞƌĂƟŽŶ͕ŽĨƚŚĞĨŽƵŶĚĂƟŽŶĂůĐŽŶƚƌŝďƵƟŽŶƐ believed to be kidnapped by Colombia’s cases,” said Mr. Pardy. ŽĨ/ŶĚŝŐĞŶŽƵƐƉĞŽƉůĞƐƚŽƚŚĞĨŽƌŵĂƟŽŶŽĨĂŶĂĚĂ͘ leftist rebels National Liberation Army. He said that had he been advising the Kathleen Mahoney͕WƌŽĨĞƐƐŽƌŽĨ>ĂǁĂƚƚŚĞ They were freed after their employer paid prime minister, he would have told Mr. hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJŽĨĂůŐĂƌLJƐƉĞĐŝĂůŝnjŝŶŐŝŶŚƵŵĂŶƌŝŐŚƚƐ͕ about $3.5-million in ransom. Trudeau not to say anything about whether Kathleen Mahoney, Professor of Law, University of Calgary, ƐƉĞĂŬƐƚŽƌĞƐĞƫŶŐĂŶĂĚĂ͛ƐŽƌŝŐŝŶƐƚŽƌLJ͘;/Ŷ At a press conference after a cabinet Canada does or does not pay ransom. Royal Society of Canada Fellow retreat in Kananaskis, Alta. last week, Mr. “He doesn’t have to say anything. These ŶŐůŝƐŚǁŝƚŚŝŶƚĞƌƉƌĞƚĂƟŽŶǀŝĂĐĞůůƉŚŽŶĞ͘Ϳ Trudeau (Papineau, Que.) said that Canada are all very diffi cult cases and there’s no does not pay ransom to kidnappers under need to set public conditions there, particu- any circumstances. larly. At the end of the day, there’s going to “Canada does not and will not pay be a set of negotiations going on in which, ideas-idees.ca/bigthinking ransom to terrorists directly or indirectly,” in effect, arrangements for release will be #bigthinking Mr. Trudeau said. “We need to make sure made,” Mr. Pardy said. 14 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 BACKROOMS MIKE DUFFY Mike Duffy story shows how diffi cult it is to separate right from wrong How is it possible that ORONTO—Theodore Roosevelt once and Ghomeshi is not guilty and Mike Duffy Tsaid: “When they call the roll in the is not guilty. the RCMP decided to Senate, the Senators do not know whether What now? Ghomeshi is off the media to answer ‘present’ or ‘not guilty.’ ” radar and people don’t understand why the charge Mike Duffy with Of course he was referring to the U.S. former CBC darling, despite declaring not 31 counts of bribery, Senate of more than a century ago, but guilty, is not back at his job. Oh yes, he is someone might argue that the former U.S. not a criminal but the courts cannot restore fraud, and breach of president’s malignity might apply to some morality and “standards.” trust, while the court present parliamentary organizations here But Mike Duffy, a person with whom in Canada. I have shared a long friendship and for dismissed all of them? To say that Canadians are slightly whom I am very happy about his legal confused about the events they have outcome, has been immediately reinstated been witnessing lately is wrong. They are as a Senator. completely confused. Two things, however, A few years ago, we had a commission they certainly know is that the legal system set up to tell us what happened to $60-mil- has nothing to do with the justice system, lion of the sponsorship scandal, and the re- While police and media branded Mike Duffy and they cannot count on the media to sult was that we spent another $60-million guilty, a courtroom judge decided otherwise, explain why. to be told that we needed to better control writes Angelo Persichilli.The Hill Times ANGELO PERSICHILLI Media have crucifi ed Jian Ghomeshi over government’s spending. photograph by Jake Wright and Mike Duffy. Then the courts step in I don’t know how much of taxpayers’ money was spent to fi nd out what was go- ing on in the Senate. The RCMP was called in and the Mounties completely exoner- ated Nigel Wright and hit Mike Duffy with dozens of accusations. Then last week, the legal system declared Duffy “a credible wit- ness” and not guilty on all charges. Further- more, the court had some not-too-fl attering words for Nigel Wright and the then-Prime Minister’s Offi ce. What happened to Wright and Duffy? Do they have a double personality like Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde? How is it possible that the RCMP decided to charge Duffy with 31 accounts of fraud while the court dismissed all of them? How is it pos- Propane: sible that Duffy, a potential villain to the RCMP, became “credible” and not guilty to our legal system? It is not the fi rst time there’s been such a disconnect. It happened with former prime minister Brian Mulroney in the Canada’s Smart Karlheinz Schreiber affair, and the late former privacy commissioner George Rad- wanski, both of whom were cleared of all serious allegations against them. Even if its presence in the media was massive during the Duffy ordeal, the Energy Solution PMO’s silence was astonishing. It was trashed for two years all over the media, Canadian propane powers households, businesses and vehicles from coast but the only public defence the offi ce of- fered was “no comment.” I was happy to see to coast. Whether it’s used to run energy efficient appliances or agricultural the lawyer of former prime minister Ste- flamers that protect crops from weeds and insects, propane can be relied on phen Harper, Robert Staley, eloquently il- lustrate what was known all along. Harper as a safe and affordable fuel that produces low emissions. never interfered in the legal system, he made his offi ce and himself available to the More than 5,300 carloads of propane move by rail in Canada every year, judicial system, and refused to make any comment until the end of the proceedings. and the propane and rail industries work together to ensure this important But two years of silence, fi lled only with energy source arrives at its destination safely. accusations and innuendos, cannot be un- done by a letter to the media by the lawyer. I understand that if there is a bite be- We train our employees to exceed safety standards. We also develop tween a man and a dog it is not necessarily news; it all depends on who is the biter. I also emergency plans, train local firefighters, and in case of emergency ensure understand that if a Prime Minister’s Offi ce, that highly skilled responders and state-of-the-art equipment are available or the prime minister himself, is involved in to keep communities and personnel safe. the news, the news is juicier. Still, I believe in balance. If opposition and media were screaming too much in one direction, the silence of the PMO was astonishing. People had to go through months of yelling, scream- ing, and deafening silence. We were praising and demonizing the same people. Now the problem is not that we don’t know who the difference between villains and heroes; the problem is that we don’t know the difference. propane.ca railcan.ca Angelo Persichilli is a freelance journal- ist and a former citizenship judge for the Greater Toronto Area. He was also a direc- tor of communications to prime minister ESSENTIAL GOODS — TRANSPORTED SAFELY Stephen Harper the summer of 2011 until end of March 2012, and is the former politi- cal editor of Canadese, Canada’s Italian- language newspaper in Toronto. [email protected] The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 15 NEWS LOBBYING Five-year ban on lobbying excessive, say former political staffers

The Federal er cannot work as a consultant think that’s worrisome.” lobbyist, though they can still be “The whole thing needs an Accountability employed as an in-house lobby- overhaul,” she said of the FAA. Act, a cornerstone ist “if lobbying activities do not A number of former staffers constitute a ‘signifi cant part of retweeted links to Ms. Austin’s campaign their duties,’ ” as described on the piece after it was published, many commitment lobbying commissioner’s website. signalling their agreement in Discussion and debate over criticizing the impact of the FAA, of the Harper the FAA and its impact was re- though some others said they cently reignited online, following disagreed. Conservatives, a series on the act put together “Anyone who came in after introduced a by the Institute for Research on the FAA was enacted [like me] Public Policy (IRPP) in its Policy knew the rules of the game. Made fi ve-year ban on Options magazine, including an the choice to accept a POH job,” lobbying activities April 20 piece by former Conser- tweeted Matthew Conway, a vative staffer Michele Austin, now former press secretary to Conser- for ‘designated senior adviser at Summa Strate- vative MP Tony Clement (Parry public offi ce holders’ gies in Ottawa. Sound-Muskoka) as Treasury She argued that the FAA has Board president, and now an as- after they left their had “a very negative long-term sistant to Mr. Clement as an MP. Hill jobs. impact on Canadian politics” The Lobbying Act is slated Tight squeeze: Liberal staff, some Hill media, and other politicos, including and has “virtually eliminated the for legislative review in 2017, lobbyists, gathered for a ‘Wonderful Wednesday’ at D’Arcy McGees Pub on ability of elected offi cials to at- and was last reviewed by the Sparks Street on Nov. 4, 2015, the day the new Liberal cabinet was sworn in. tract the best and the brightest to House Access to Information and The Hill Times Photograph by Jake Wright Continued from page 1 Ottawa.” Ethics Committee in 2012. While “If the FAA was intended concerns over the fi ve-year ban ban included under the Lobbying to foster and encourage a new decreasing the “talent pool” for Mr. Albinati, adding there was I accept a coffee at a reception, Act, saying it deters people from attitude in Ottawa, by the time hiring on the Hill were raised at already a one-year cooling off is that going to get my name in a working on the Hill and is overly it received royal assent, it had that time, the Conservative-dom- period for public offi ce holders. newspaper?” burdensome. become a monstrous list of heavy- inated committee recommended People put their lives on hold He said he goes over the FAA “From the time that the FAA handed rules and directors,” Ms. maintaining the ban. to work on the Hill, he said, and with his students so they know [Federal Accountability Act] Austin wrote. “The FAA issue was something while there they develop skills what is and isn’t allowed. was brought in, there have been “[Politically savvy individuals] that played politically well with and knowledge set around poli- “I think some of them are people from all sides of politics understand now, after a decade the Conservative base. It may tics and government. Having to surprised about how tight the saying a fi ve-year ban was too under the FAA, that this ban not have actually been solving a take on a role “completely sepa- rules are. So, ‘I’m going to do an extreme,” said Greg MacEachern, would severely limit their ability problem, and now Conservatives, rate from that,” post-Hill employ- internship. Can I do an internship a former Liberal staffer and now to fi nd a job after politics,” wrote as they are looking for work, ment, “is a bit of a steep hill for on the Hill? If I do, am I suddenly vice-president of government Ms. Austin, meaning many who may have had that made abun- many to climb.” under the fi ve-year ban if I do a relations at Environics Communi- do opt to work on the Hill are dantly clear for them,” said Mr. “They shouldn’t have to have 10-week internship? Can I not cations. “It is time to look at it.” “young partisans,” and that’s MacEachern, adding he thinks those trade offs to the extent that go and work for a GR company The Federal Accountability changed the dynamic between the FAA takes the view “that lob- it’s there,” he said. afterwards?’ And the answer is Act (FAA) was introduced and ministerial offi ces and the civil byists are bad.” The new Liberal government no,” he said, though he added that passed in 2006, the fi rst piece of service. He pointed to the fact that a has seen a “great deal of interest” students can apply for exemp- legislation put forward by the “Over time, the principles number of former Harper cabinet from people across the country tions, which they sometimes get. then-newly elected Conservative espoused by the FAA limited the ministers are now working as and has been able to hire “individ- Others disagree that the fi ve- government (64 days after being Harper government’s ability to re- consultants. While they “may not uals who have issue experience” year ban is a problem. sworn-in). It had been a corner- invigorate its staff and bring new be making the direct contact ... from different policy sectors, Erik Waddell, a former staffer stone campaign commitment and ideas on management practices to they’re advising a client on how thanks largely to the enthusiasm to James Moore as industry part of the party’s pledge to clean govern the country. Now it is up to make that contact,” he said. around a new majority Liberal minister and now a civil servant up Ottawa following the Liberal to the new government to decide Instead of a fi ve-year ban, Mr. government, said Mr. Albinati. in the Treasury Board Secre- sponsorship scandal. if its principles are worth saving,” MacEachern said a two-year But “over the long term there is tariat, said he doesn’t agree with It’s a large legislative pack- she wrote. ban would be more appropriate. concern” over the FAA limits, he criticism of the FAA ban and said age, both creating and amending Speaking with The Hill Times “That’s two budgetary cycles added. the rules were needed and staff existing legislation, including the last week, Ms. Austin, who left probably as well, so a lot of He said he’s heard from a few should have known what they Confl ict of Interest Act (in part, the Hill in 2013, said she was the things that you would have staff hired by the new govern- were getting into. establishing the confl ict of inter- “very pleasantly surprised” that worked on have gone, are either ment who “weren’t aware of the “The FAA does not limit em- est and ethics commissioner), and so many people were eager to not going to happen, or have provisions of the FAA specifi cally. ployment except in certain, very the Lobbying Registration Act. discuss the merits of the fi ve-year already happened,” he said. ... There were a few that were specifi c capacities. It just limits Along with creating the fed- ban, and she hopes “the conversa- André Albinati, a former Lib- surprised after they had taken the you from being able to lobby des- eral lobbying commissioner, the tion continues.” She’s a former eral staffer and now a principal position and then were in discus- ignated public offi ce holders on amended Lobbying Act created chief of staff to both Rona Am- at Earnscliffe Strategy, said he sions about understanding what behalf of clients seeking to infl u- by the FAA included a fi ve-year brose (Sturgeon River-Parkland, agrees that the fi ve-year ban “is the rules are as they apply.” ence government policy. There’s ban on lobbying activities for Alta.) as public works minister a problem” and something that Mr. Albinati said has “sym- a lot of jobs out there that are not “designated public offi ce holders” and to then minister of state Max- should concern the new govern- pathy” for former Conservative that, and most political staffers after leaving their government ime Bernier (Beauce, Que.). ment. staffers who are now covered by have skill sets that go well beyond jobs. The lobbying commissioner “We didn’t really know what “That should be of concern to the ban. being able to have a fat rolodex is able to grant exemptions to this [the FAA] would bring. And a government that is more inter- Paul Wilson, a former direc- full of contact numbers,” he said. ban in some instances. clearly as time has marched on, ested in having an activist public tor of policy for Stephen Harper, He added that while he sym- Designated public offi ce hold- it’s been a struggle to attract good policy discussion and engage- who left the Hill in 2011 and now pathizes with former Conserva- ers include: MPs; Senators; people to the political class,” she ment with stakeholders,” he said, teaches as part of Carleton Uni- tive and NDP staff struggling to staff on the prime ministerial said, adding when she was a chief adding the Government Relations versity’s political management fi nd jobs now, “the FAA is not the transition team; staff of cabi- of staff, at times it was hard to Institute of Canada, of which he is master’s program, said “unques- obstacle here.” net ministers, ministers of state hire staff and that she was always president, is currently surveying tionably” the fi ve-year ban “does Mr. Waddell said former staff or parliamentary secretaries; asked about whether the ban membership for opinions on the deter some very qualifi ed people” and senior civil servants “not be- governor-in-council appointees; would apply. FAA. from working in politics. He ing able to sell their contacts and and senior staff working for the She said she’s seen the im- The FAA is “a very heavy- said it should “be reconsidered” access to government for per- leader of the offi cial opposition in pact on people after they leave handed document that creates because it has closed “traditional sonal enrichment, that’s not an the House or Senate if appointed their public offi ce jobs. obligations and registrations and off-ramps for political staff.” example of a democratic defi cit,” under the Public Service Employ- “I have seen that happen with so forth in a way that have only “Just the weight of the require- and said he doesn’t think the ment Act. a number of former staff, who are been creeping further and further ments; there are people who may FAA’s lobbying limits “needs to be The ban means that for fi ve still struggling six months [after out as interpretations and codes say it’s just not worth it for me to modifi ed.” years after leaving government, a the 2015 election] now trying of conduct, etc., are additionally come and put myself under all of [email protected] designated public offi ce hold- to fi nd a job,” said Ms. Austin. “I built on the original act,” said those rules,” Mr. Wilson said. “If The Hill Times 16 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 OPINION DOCTOR-ASSISTED SUICIDE How should we then vote? Like it or not, MPs will be voting on Medical Assistance in Dying There is an irony here, as TTAWA—Death and taxes. They are Now it is not a matter of if there is legisla- Oabout all that is certain in this world, tion, it is a matter of what that legislation one of the chief complaints according to the often quoted words of looks like come June 6. of the bill is that that Benjamin Franklin. In Canada, however, For many MPs, this represents a moral it is now all but certain that there will be quagmire of a magnitude that many have many physicians and legislation in place governing how we as not yet faced in their elected careers. The institutions have asked that a society safeguard the now legal rights of question they are confronted with, to bor- their conscience rights be Canadians to request assistance in ending row aptly from theologian Francis Schaef- their life. fer’s book How Should We Then Live?, is protected should they choose Given the introduction of Bill C-14, how should we then vote? not to provide medical Medical Assistance in Dying, it is also a All political parties are giving their certainty that Members of Parliament will members a “free vote,” the right to vote assistance in dying. be forced to stand and cast a yea or nay with their conscience and not whipped ballot. along party lines. With the exception of Some may argue our elected Members the 31-member cabinet, who will always of Parliament should have been involved in vote in favour of government legislation, Canada’s federal Justice Minister Jody Wilson- the decision about whether or not to allow 307 MPs are now faced with a critically Raybould, pictured March 22 on the Hill, is euthanasia, assisted suicide, physician- important choice. responsible for the government’s doctor-assist- assisted suicide, or medical assistance in The easiest way to choose would be to MATT TRIEMSTRA ed suicide legislation. The Hill Times photograph by dying in the fi rst place, but the Supreme vote alongside their leaders. MPs could Jake Wright Court robbed them of that opportunity. choose to simply side with their party leader and the political party that got them elected. Additionally, despite this being a free vote MPs may worry about the practi- cal repercussions for not supporting their party. However, MPs are also elected to be the THANK YOU, MERCI voice of their constituents in Ottawa, re- gardless of political stripe. In past weeks, MPs have been fanning out across their ridings to hold ‘town halls’ to solicit feed- back. But the fundamental problem with these town halls is that they are often only attended by those who already feel most passionate about the issue, usually at one end of the spectrum or another. As of yet, no mechanism exists for an MP to poll the average of 90,000 people in their riding, so while soliciting constituent feedback is important, it still remains challenging to determine the mood of the electorate in each riding. Ultimately, despite how their leader votes or the views of their constituents, MPs also need to take into account their own personal convictions. This is a deeply personal issue, fraught with opposing and passionate debate. How we as a society treat end-of-life care is a mark of our hu- manity and MPs will be cognizant that how they vote on this legislation could be seen as a mark of theirs. Since this will be a free vote in the House of Commons, MPs will be entitled to vote with their conscience. There is an irony here, as one of the chief A special thank you to our keynote speakers for making the NACC complaints of the bill is that that many physicians and institutions have asked that their conscience rights be protected should they choose not to provide medi- cal assistance in dying. Therein lies one of the many layers of considerations each MP will deal with as they settle on a decision over the course of the coming Hon. Bardish Chagger, Minister of Small Business and Tourism weeks. As sure as death and taxes, the vote on Bill C-14 will soon make its way onto the fl oor of the House of Commons, and, rest assured, many MPs are already fully engaged in the process of consulting with their constituents, their leaders, and their own consciences. When the matter has been decided by men and women most often seen angling for votes by the average The NACC Symposium brought government and industry citizen, it will also have reminded us of the complex and fundamental roles they play in our democracy. Matt Triemstra is a director at Ensight Canada where he provides public affairs advice. He has over a decade of experi- ence consulting and working for Conser- www.airlinecouncil.ca vative Members of Parliament and the

Conservative Resource Group on Parlia- ment Hill. Mr. Triemstra is registered to

T @NACC_CNLA lobby for the Archdiocese of Toronto and for the Christian Medical and Dental So-

ciety of Canada on the physician-assisted suicide. The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 17 OPINION CITIZENSHIP BILL Comparing Libs’ Bill C-6 to Tories’ Bill C-24

potentially by the previous C-24 government is hearing constitu- Hearing for both changes or proposed C-6 changes ent concerns. While the extent had an almost (see some of my analysis Citizen- of this willingness is unclear, the ship: Conference Board 2016). following is my take on pos- complete absence Assertions of those effected, for sible amendments, based on of Quebec-based better or worse, by the previous their broad consistency with the or current bill, would benefi t from “diversity and inclusion agenda” witnesses and the numbers of people potentially and the principles and philosophy French-speaking effected; and efforts to ensure dif- behind Bill C-6: ferent perspectives were heard. Revocation for fraud or mis- witnesses for both However, a number of sig- representation: There was broad nifi cant differences, refl ecting the support to ensure procedural bills and thus any change in government, are also protections comparable to perma- Quebec-specifi c notable: there were 18 witnesses nent residency (and even parking for Bill C-6 compared to 28 for Bill tickets). Some argued for revert- citizenship issues C-24, refl ecting the broader scope ing back to the former process that may refl ect of C-24 and a likely tighter time- requiring a Federal Court ruling; line by the current government; others argued for the Immigration its different mix of using as a litmus test support or Review Board (IRB) to expand source countries. not for revocation in cases of ter- its mandate to include citizen- ror or treason, about 40 per cent ship hearings, and thus ensure a of witnesses broadly supported comparable process of revocation this provision during Bill C-24, for both citizenship and perma- in contrast to about 25 per cent nent residency status. The former during C-6, refl ecting the govern- would return to the previous ment having ensured a majority of lengthy process with arguably too ANDREW GRIFFITH witnesses in support of the most many stages, the latter would re- controversial (to some) change; quire additional resources for the and generally, there was a more IRB. However, the argument for an open tone in discussion and ques- amendment to strengthen proce- TTAWA—Bill C-6, which tioning of witnesses by all sides, dural protections is compelling. Oalters the Citizenship Act, with witnesses for the most part Language and knowledge test- has completed the hearing pro- recognizing that a change in gov- ing: The government responded to cess and is now proceeding to a ernment meant a needed change constituent pressure by reverting clause-by-clause examination. It’s in tone and approach. to the previous age range of 18 Immigration Minister John McCallum did express some openness to amend- interesting to look at this bill and Shimon Fogel of Canadian Is- to 54 but did not, wisely in my ments and the nature of Liberal MPs’ questions suggested some areas of contrast the nature of testimony rael Jewish Advocacy exemplifi ed opinion, allow the knowledge test possible openness or where the government is hearing constituent concerns, to the former Conservative gov- this approach, going out of his to be taken with an interpreter. writes Andrew Griffi th. The Hill Times photograph by Jake Wright ernment’s Bill C-24, the Strength- way to recognize the arguments The revision of the study guide, ening Canadian Citizenship Act. against revocation while main- Discover Canada, and the related company abroad, health, and ment to demonstrate fl exibility, There are similarities and differ- taining his position. James Bissett citizenship test questions, will compassionate grounds), or re- will tell us both about the specifi c ences between the two. As well, and Martin Collacott did not, thus presumably (and should) in- verting to the previous guidance citizenship policy directions as well it’s noteworthy that a number of undermining their arguments as clude a complete rewrite in plain provided to citizenship judges, as their general approach to gov- suggestions were broadly in line they largely repeated word-for- language, much closer to the some measure of fl exibility or ex- erning. Will they view Parliament with the government’s overall word and tone of their earlier benchmark level of CLB-4. This ception would appear warranted. only as a way to deliver on their agenda of diversity and inclu- testimony; and, predictably, wit- would address many but not all Citizenship fees: While not political commitments, or will they sion. It will be interesting if the nesses that favoured a more fa- of the issues raised by witnesses part of legislation, the quintu- view Parliament as a more forum government actually responds cilitative approach to citizenship, without a further weakening of pling of fees in 2014-15 and ad- for more open policy discussions, to these by making amendments while welcoming the proposed the language requirements, which ditional cost of upfront language debates and decisions? to the bill. changes of Bill C-6, focused on is so important to integration. testing will reduce the number The upcoming clause-by- Here are some of the common what they perceived as remain- But given some of the witness applying, and thus the naturaliza- clause review starting May 3 will elements between the two sets ing gaps: procedural protections testimony, it will be interesting to tion rate, a trend already happen- illustrate their approach in both of hearings: there was an almost for revocation in cases of fraud see if the government maintains ing. Fees are a signifi cant barrier the particulars of C-6 as well as complete absence of Quebec- or misrepresentation, barriers to its current line. for lower income immigrants and the broader context. based witnesses and French- refugees and some immigrants Physical presence require- refugees. Given that a large part Andrew Griffi th is the author speaking witnesses, and thus any with respect to the knowledge ment: This provides a clear and of Canada’s relative success as of Multiculturalism in Canada: Quebec-specifi c citizenship issues test and language assessment, the common sense defi nition of resi- a diverse society refl ects a clear Evidence and Anecdote and Pol- that may refl ect its different mix need for exceptions for the physi- dency, facilitating decision-mak- pathway to citizenship, address- icy Arrogance or Innocent Bias: of source countries, particularly cal presence requirement and ing. However, given the nature of ing the cost, through a general re- Resetting Citizenship and Mul- from the Maghreb, where revoca- the high cost of citizenship fees a more mobile and global world, duction to perhaps $300, possibly ticulturalism and is a regular tion would likely be a particular ($630) and language assessment particularly for many economic combined for a partial waiver for media commentator and blogger concern; and there was a similar (about $200). immigrants, there is a strong case refugees, would help restore this (Multiculturalism Meanderings). and almost complete lack of Immigration Minister John for some forms of defi ned exemp- pathway to citizenship and politi- He is the former director general numeracy, with witnesses talk- McCallum did express some tions as many witnesses have cal integration. for Citizenship and Multicultural- ing either in conceptual terms, openness to amendments and attested to. Whether these should Whether the government will ism and has worked for a variety anecdotal examples, or principles, the nature of Liberal MPs’ ques- exemptions should be as in the consider amendments, or whether of government departments in without any reference to the tions suggested some areas of Immigration and Refugee Protec- the selection of witnesses was part Canada and abroad. numbers of people affected or possible openness or where the tion Act (working for a Canadian of a strategy to allow the govern- The Hill Times

he Liberal government has a decision to make: ratify the Trans-Pacific TPartnership or not? The pressure is high—from the business community to unions, farmers, provinces, and others. As the House of Commons International Trade Committee embarks on a cross-country tour to hear from Canadians on the deal, The Hill Times will offer a comprehensive look at the committee’s study, including what MPs are hearing and where they stand. TPP We’ll map out the ratification process, including next steps such as possible compensation for supply-managed sectors. And we’ll take the temperature of who’s for and against the 6,000-page deal and why. POLICY BRIEFING Communicate with those Publication Date: May 18, 2016 most responsible for Canada’s public policy decisions. Booking Deadline: May 13, 2016 )RUPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQRUWRUHVHUYH\RXUJRYHUQPHQWUHODWLRQVDQGSXEOLFD΍DLUV advertising space, contact The Hill Times display advertising department at 613-688-8825. 18 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 OPINION ASSISTED SUICIDE BILL Mental health concerns should not be lost during debate on medical assistance in dying bill In her speech to It is critical that principle of parity requires thoughtful dis- Parliament after cussions, given that as few as one in four the government amendments to this Canadians get help for their mental health tabled Bill C-14, problems. Health Minister legislation be done Being denied access to person-centred, Jane Philpott noted, thoughtfully, hand-in-hand recovery-oriented care can lead to the that many people same despair for people living with mental are ‘troubled by with the mental health health problems and illnesses as not hav- the prospect of community. Every line of ing access to palliative care does for those patients with a living with intolerable physical pain. psychiatric disorder legislation has the potential We need a robust pan-Canadian con- being eligible to deeply affect people who versation among people living with mental for assistance in health problems, their families, and care- dying on the basis are at their most vulnerable. givers, as well as health-care professionals, of psychological about acceptable measures that can best suffering alone.’ protect those living with mental illnesses. The Hill Times The MHCC strongly advocates that the photograph by voices of people with lived experience, and Jake Wright those who have survived a suicide attempt, LOUISE BRADLEY be involved in the process of considering this legislation and designing the mecha- nisms for its potential implementation. Central to this debate is the importance Ps return to the House of Commons of introducing concurrent suicide preven- this week to discuss medical assis- M tion policy initiatives, as well as public edu- tance in dying legislation. It’s an historic cation strategies, in order to provide clarity issue, and one that will be debated quickly about the difference between suicide and because of the fast-approaching June 6 medical assistance in dying. deadline for implementation, mandated by This topic is highly nuanced and IN CELEBRATION OF 40 YEARS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION IN CANADA, the Supreme Court of Canada. extremely complex. There are myriad per- The timing is apt, because today marks spectives to be evaluated, from the unique THE EUROPEAN UNION DELEGATION TO CANADA the beginning of Mental Health Week. In experiences of First Nations, Inuit and Mé- the race to pass Bill C-14, the government’s tis peoples and their communities, to the IS ORGANISING A CONFERENCE: legislation to regulate access to medically psychological health and safety concerns assisted dying, the special considerations of those involved in implementing medical around mental health concerns should not assistance in dying services. be lost. It is critical that amendments to this THE EU AND CANADA AS STRATEGIC PARTNERS In her speech to Parliament after the legislation be done thoughtfully, hand-in- government tabled Bill C-14, Health Min- hand with the mental health community. TOWARDS A NEW GENERATION RELATIONSHIP ister Jane Philpott noted, that many people Every line of legislation has the potential are “troubled by the prospect of patients to deeply affect people who are at their with a psychiatric disorder being eligible for most vulnerable. assistance in dying on the basis of psycho- There is much wisdom to be gleaned logical suffering alone. There are strongly through frank and open conversations. The held views on both sides of this issue. That health minister is correct: we have an his- is why legislating medical assistance in dy- toric opportunity to get this legislation right. ing has required a cautious approach.” We can’t squander it. The Mental Health Commission of Louise Bradley is president and CEO of Canada supports the federal government’s the Mental Health Commission of Canada. decision to take a phased approach with May 2 to 8 marks the 65th annual Men- Bill C-14, beginning by regulating medical tal Health Week to help stop the stigma assistance in dying for those conditions on and discrimination that surround mental which there has already been an extensive health problems and illnesses. Find out national dialogue. While we can all agree more at www.mentalhealthcommission.ca. there should not be discrimination between The Hill Times physical and mental illnesses, providing a Customize Your Work ■ Track a bill

NATIONAL GALLERY OF CANADA ■ Follow a committee (AUDITORIUM) 380 SUSSEX DRIVE, OTTAWA ■ Get immediate 09|05|2016 12:30 P.M. - 5:30 P.M. notification when #SPA #EUCANADA40 changes happen REGISTER AT EUCANADA40.CA

www.parliamentnow.ca THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 19 IN PROGRESS MONEY & POLITICS Why Bernie Sanders’ message about big money in politics needs to be heard in Canada

You don’t need to be rocket scientist judgement and ethically clean behaviour. A Now that his presidential to know what they’re selling: access to strict limit for corporate and unions dona- run in the U.S. is coming decision-makers at the cabinet table. tions has been in place for years in Ottawa, And we know how a system of fundrais- brought in by former prime minister Jean to an end, let’s get Bernie ing quotas in Quebec turned out. Chrétien in the aftermath of the Liberal Sanders up here to explain Last year, the commission charged with sponsorship scandal. investigating corruption in the construction So Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Ray- why big money needs to get industry “fi ngered the fundraising quotas bould wasn’t breaking any rule by being out of politics in Canada as imposed on the member of [Jean] Charest’s the guest of honour at the pricey fundraiser cabinet as a powerful incentive for col- organized by a Bay Street law fi rm. It just well. He can start his tour in lusive behaviour. In Ontario, Wynne has smells really bad and violates the spirit of B.C. and hopscotch over to maintained such a system,” Toronto Star Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, the government’s own code of conduct. columnist Chantal Hébert wrote recently, pictured at a town hall meeting in Phoenix, Arizona, Now that his presidential run in the U.S. Ontario and Quebec. who’s also noted Quebec voters are “still in July 2015. Photograph courtesy of Gage Skidmore is coming to an end, let’s get Sanders up waiting for a culture change in ethics.” here to explain why big money needs to get The governing Liberals in Ontario out of politics in Canada as well. He can haven’t done anything to fi x political tive press. But now the Ontario premier is start his tour in B.C. and hopscotch over to fundraising rules since coming to power in refusing to tap a non-partisan, independent Ontario and Quebec. 2003. Wynne herself has defended the sys- panel to spearhead the reforms. Sarah Schmidt is director of communica- tem for years—until she changed her mind But even strict rules, although vitally tions at the Broadbent Institute in Ottawa. SARAH SCHMIDT abruptly after a recent barrage of nega- important, aren’t a substitute for good The Hill Times

TTAWA—Imagine what Bernie Sand- Oers would think if he had time to read Canadian newspapers. “The secret price of admission to power; provincial cabinet ministers are assigned Investing in public transit is fundraising targets as high as $500,000 a year to fi ll Liberal coffers,” is how one one of the best bets we make headline sums up the sorry state of affairs with the governing party’s “Wild West” ap- as a country. proach to fundraising in Ontario. “Christy Clark’s private ‘allowance’ In Canada, ridership of public transit grew by 20% from B.C. Liberals is no joke,” is how one columnist captures the mess in which the over the last decade — faster than our population. British Columbia premier currently fi nds Find out how your province stacks up, herself, after it was reported that she’s col- lected $300,000 from the B.C Liberals since visit cuta.ca becoming 2011 for doing party work—in- cluding attending high-priced private fund- raising events with corporate donors eager to have the ear of the premier. “Philippe Couillard beset by ministe- rial misdeeds; ethics questions still hound Quebec Liberals,” is how a news story sum- marizes ongoing challenges of the Quebec government related to an anti-corruption probe that has ensnarled prolifi c party fun- draisers with ties to cabinet ministers. “Top Liberal in fundraising furor,” is how another sums up a recent misstep by the feder- al justice minister. The $500-a-head fundraiser in Toronto, dubbed as a “pay to play” event by the opposition, was hosted by a corporate law fi rm in Toronto with interests in Ottawa. Although Sanders’ presidential run is all but over, his call for a political revolution to get big money out of politics certainly resonated with voters in the United States. And given the state of affairs in key juris- dictions in Canada, Sanders’ message— getting big money out of politics is key to restoring democracy—is something we need to hear north of the border. “My major job is to mobilize the Ameri- can people to demand that Congress listen to them and their needs rather than just the big money interests,” Sanders has said over and over again in his unlikely bid for the Democratic presidential nominee. B.C. Premier Christy Clark should listen up. The Globe and Mail’s Gary Mason laid out last week why it’s so serious. “There is a matter of grave public interest here. The premier, the head of government, is selling access through party fundraising events. That is without dispute. And she is benefi ting from the proceeds that access gen- erates. It is a clear confl ict. And yet, she and her party treat it like a big joke,” Mason wrote. The ethical problem facing Wynne in Ontario is a bit different, but is rooted in the same problem: no ban on corporate and Let’s Move union donations (or, in the case of Ontario, huge loopholes to get around a contribution cuta.ca limit of nearly $10,000). In Ontario, that’s meant cabinet ministers have been given fundraising targets to hit every year. 20 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 OPINION BROADBAND High-speed broadband SHOWCASING CANADA’S TALENT DON’T MISS THE UPCOMING MOVIE NIGHT ON THE HILL is essential for rural and northern Canada

Join the Honourable Mélanie Joly, Minister of Canadian Heritage, The Federation of Canadian produces one-third of our economic output. at the Canadian Museum of History for a celebration screening of It is time to get Internet service in rural and Municipalities welcomed the northern Canada moving at full speed. federal government’s commitment The good news is that this conversa- tion is shifting from a debate over whether in the recent budget to spend broadband access is an essential service to ROOMM an additional $500-million over how we can work together as a nation to get everyone connected. the next fi ve years to expand The head of the CRTC, Jean-Pierre Blais, WINNER OF 9 CANADIAN SCREEN AWARDS, broadband services to rural recently talked about the importance of AS WELL AS THE OSCAR, GOLDEN GLOBE, developing a coherent national internet de- BAFTA AND CSA FOR BEST ACTRESS! and remote communities. These ployment strategy in Canada. As municipal STARRING investments have the potential leaders, we entirely agree with that senti- BRIE LARSON , to make a signifi cant difference ment, as well as the insistence that it will JACOB TREMBLAY and take a collective effort from all quarters of WENDY CREWSON in the lives of Canadians in society including, the CRTC, governments, underserved areas and should be and private industry, to make it happen. The CRTC is holding hearings right taken into account by the CRTC as now to better understand broadband LENNY ABRAHAMSON A it studies additional mechanisms connectivity across Canada. FCM ap- film peared there April 15 to lay out the case to fund the rollout of universal that high-speed broadband access must be An ELEVATION PICTURES broadband access. considered an essential service. This means presentation putting in place new funding mechanisms A Canada-Ireland that will support universal access in areas RAY ORB AND RAYMOND LOUIE coproduction produced by not served through private investments or DAVID GROSS targeted government funding programs. and long overdue conversation has begun But recognizing high-speed broadband as ED GUINEY A in Canada about how to ensure large a basic service is only part of the solution. The sections of our country are no longer cut In association with CRTC must also ensure the system adapts to off from an essential service which is taken THE MOVIE NETWORK ever-changing technological advancements for granted by so many others—access by regularly updating Canada’s broadband Based on the novel by to high-speed internet. For too long now, speed targets. Otherwise we run the risk of EMMA DONOGHUE many people in rural, remote, and north- drawing up plans for the best system with ern communities have either been forced the fastest upload and download standards #hillmovienight to live with inadequate and spotty online today only to see that system quickly become services, or in many cases, no high-speed inadequate to people’s needs tomorrow. internet at all. In fact, Canada’s current Canada also needs to ensure our national broadband coverage standards for upload system includes backup connections for parts and download speeds fall well behind of the country where internet outages can many industrialized nations. leave people without service for days or even In 2016, building a nationwide informa- weeks. For example, remote regions where re- JOIN THE STARS ON THE RED CARPET tion superhighway is as important to Cana- pairing a broken cable is a lengthy and com- da’s future as building the transcontinental plicated affair, or in the North where there is TUESDAY, MAY 3 AT 7:30 p.m. railroad was over 130 years ago. Simply put, simply no backup for satellite interruptions. it’s hard to live without. Imagine a small Making sure high-speed service is avail- Canadian Museum of History (Theatre) business owner trying to compete in today’s able to everyone will require signifi cant global economy without high-speed inter- public and private investment. We will all net. Or a patient waiting for crucial medical need to work together to build this network. test results that are delayed because those That is why Federation of Canadian Munici- results are not available online. Or a young palities welcomed the federal government’s person trying to improve their job skills WATCH FOR YOUR SPECIAL INVITATION commitment in the recent budget to spend without access to an online course. an additional $500-million over the next But in fact, too many Canadians do live fi ve years to expand broadband services to without it. A recent report published by the rural and remote communities. These invest- Canadian Radio-television Telecommunica- ments have the potential to make a signifi - tions Commission (CRTC) found that only THANK YOU TO OUR GENEROUS SPONSORS cant difference in the lives of Canadians in a fraction of people and businesses in rural underserved areas and should be taken into and remote communities have access to the account by the CRTC as it studies additional upload and download speeds that are almost mechanisms to fund the rollout of universal universally available in our urban centres. broadband access. For example, almost 100 per cent of people Canadians have always been willing to in urban areas have access to download work together to make sure that everyone speeds of between 16-25 megabytes per enjoys the quality of life we all expect and second (Mbps), compared to only 29 per cent deserve. Today, that means pulling together of Canadians in rural communities. That’s a as governments, businesses, and consumers signifi cant gap and it needs to be closed. to make sure that no matter where we live, Not only is a large section of our fellow a strong economy and connected, vibrant Canadians being cut off from vital services, hometowns are always just a click away. they are also being prevented from fully par- Raymond Louie is FCM president and ticipating in Canadian society and contribut- acting mayor of Vancouver. Ray Orb is ing the ideas and the innovations that make chair of FCM’s Rural Forum & president our country great. Rural Canada makes up of the Saskatchewan Association of Rural 30 per cent of the country’s population and Municipalities (SARM).

One block south of the Hill Locally Owned & Operated since 1921 INSPIRED BY TALENT. VIEWED EVERYWHERE. O 3PARKS3T /TTAWAs   ,UGGAGEs,EATHER'OODSs(ANDBAGS www.ottawaleathergoods.com "USINESS#ASESs!CCESSORIES THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 21 NEWS LEGISLATION Budget, assisted- dying, RCMP labour bills to take precedence: LeBlanc

‘We were never these deadlines driving the agenda” and that he certainly doesn’t intend for this hysterical—as were the rush to be the status quo, but that it’s “the reality we have between now and June, so NDP—on time allocation. we’re going to deal with it.” It is a necessary Debate on the medical assistance in dying instrument to move the bill will start Monday, he said. “So I’m hoping we can sit late into the night on Monday and Government House Leader Dominic LeBlanc, NDP House Leader Peter Julian, and Conservative legislation forward,’ Tuesday evening.” Mr. LeBlanc said the gov- House Leader Andrew Scheer. The Hill Times photographs by Jake Wright ernment’s goal is to get the bill to committee says Government House sometime this week, before Friday. Leader Dominic LeBlanc. Mr. LeBlanc said it would require an amendments.” Trade Organization trade facilitation rules, “expeditious but thoughtful handling” of Streamlining the Senate process dealing with things such as the expedited the bill, which gives mentally-competent Mr. LeBlanc said he has discussed the movement and clearance of goods, Mr. Continued from page 1 adults who are suffering a serious and time constraints with the Senate leader- LeBlanc said. incurable disease and are deemed to be ship, and that the government’s repre- In the fall, he said there would be a fo- Dominic LeBlanc says to expect some suffering the right to apply for medically- sentative in the Senate, Peter Harder, has cus on legislating vehicle safety and recalls late-night sittings while the government assisted death. suggested to his colleagues that they do as in Canada, as well as pushing through Bill works to push through three bills before Both NDP and the Conservative House much pre-studying as possible—particular- C-10, the bill that aims to make changes the House adjourns for the summer in leaders raised concerns about the Liber- ly on the doctor-assisted dying bill—so that to the Air Canada Public Participation June. The House will take a one-week als rushing debate on the legislation, and if there are recommendations for amend- Act. The Liberal government used a motion break in May and will sit again for four emphasized that they want members of all ments, that they can be made at the House of time allocation last week to limit debate consecutive weeks at the end of May and parties to have the ability to raise concerns. stage, rather than having to bounce back. on that bill, something that Liberals, while June. Conservative House Leader Andrew “I’m respectful of the fact that it’s not in opposition, were critical of the Conser- Mr. LeBlanc (Beausejour, N.B.) told Scheer (Regina-Qu’Appelle, Que.) said ideal for us to dump on the Senate, in the vative government for doing. The Hill Times the government will push the bill is extremely complex and serious, third week of June, a whole series of bills When asked why this was used, and through the Medical Assistance in Dying and needs to be given adequate time in the and say, ‘Pass them right away,’” he added. whether it can be expected to happen more Bill, C-14; the budget-implementation House for members of all parties to voice “I don’t think that’s respectful.” often considering the current time con- bill, C-15; and the RCMP labour relations their concerns. He told The Hill Times that Both Mr. Julian and Mr. Scheer said straints, Mr. LeBlanc said, “We were never bill, C-7. one of his biggest concerns is the language they plan to push back on the budget bill hysterical—as were the NDP—on time The Supreme Court of Canada gave the used that might force doctors and medical in the coming weeks, which both MPs said allocation. We thought the previous govern- government an extended deadline of June staff to be involved in the process, even falls short on a range of commitments that ment abused it, but it is a necessary instru- 6 to pass the assisted-dying bill, and until when it goes against their moral beliefs. were made. ment to move the legislation forward.” May 17 to complete C-7. Mr. LeBlanc said Mr. Scheer said he recognizes the Mr. Scheer said the bill “has gone way Mr. LeBlanc said he hopes time allocation the House “would not adjourn” for the sum- court-imposed deadline, but added that the past the $10-billion defi cit ... without a real is not a measure that the government has to mer without seeing the budget-implemen- Conservatives would like to see the govern- jobs plan.” use often, but that occasionally, it’s necessary. tation bill pass and would use the extended ment erring on the side of more debate, He said the Conservatives will suggest The controversial bill, which was nota- Commons sitting hours, if necessary, rather and if necessary, ask for another deadline amendments that could reduce the defi cit bly opposed by Liberal MP Doug Eyolfson than extend the number of sitting days. extension. or channel spending into tangible job- (Charleswood-St. James-Assiniboia- For the months of May and June, the NDP House Leader Peter Julian (New creation initiatives. He also said they will Headingley, Man.) during the vote in the focus will be on legislation that has manda- Westminster-Burnaby, B.C.) agreed. “Hope- focus on the “disappointing” freezing of the House of Commons on April 20, changes tory deadlines or major implications if not fully, they will allow the kind of debate that small-business tax rate, which was not in the current legislation to mandate that Air passed by the summer break. we’re going to need over the next week or line with the Liberals’ election promise to Canada maintain general maintenance op- When the House returns in the fall, two so that all members of Parliament can reduce it over a three-year term. erations in Winnipeg, Montreal, and parts bills in line with last year’s election plat- be heard.” The RCMP labour relations bill—which of Ontario, as opposed to the more special- form will get their turn, he said. In antici- Mr. LeBlanc acknowledged these con- responds to last year’s Supreme Court ized work that has been required up until pation of that, Mr. LeBlanc said to expect cerns. “Various people have talked about decision that the RCMP should be entitled now. The Conservatives and NDP both between fi ve and 10 new bills to be tabled amendments and changes, and if they’re to collective bargaining rights—is at the oppose the bill, largely citing the potential before Parliament adjourns so they can be sincere about that, then let’s get it to com- report stage and isn’t expected to see much loss of high-skilled, high-paid jobs. considered by the opposition and left well mittee where we can hear the witnesses push back or delay going forward. “Here is a bill that the Liberals basically positioned to be examined immediately and the committee can make amendments,” brought in ... even quicker than the former after summer break. he said. “A protracted second reading will Time allocation déjà-vu Conservative government used to do, after not allow us to hear from various groups Among the fi ve to 10 new bills to be only a few hours of debate. … We think An ‘expeditious but thoughtful’ approach that have views on the bill itself and al- tabled before the House breaks in June will that’s irresponsible,” said Mr. Julian. Mr. LeBlanc said it’s “not ideal to have low [time for] the committees to consider be one that aligns Canada with World [email protected] TRUSTED ADVISOR AND INFLUENTIAL VOICE.

A respected advisor on fiscal, economic and business issues that are important to building a prosperous future for Canadians and Canadian business. 22 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 NEWS FUNDRAISING

tives to ministers and parliamen- only, and you give a speech and tary secretaries, but added that then you leave. A few people may her offi ce “does not administer be able to say hi to you. But you’re that document … and those rules not there behind closed doors at an do not carry the force of law.” exclusive, invite-only event that’s Duff Conacher, co-founder of high priced, giving people an op- Democracy Watch, said: “It’s facade portunity to secretly lobby you, and to say, ‘Oh, the party organized this selling access to yourself for cash.” and the money goes to them.’ She’s He added: “You have to go a senior minister of the party.” beyond the law to the spirit of the He referred to the Confl ict of law. Is it maintaining the highest Interest’s section on “purpose,” ethical standard to be selling ac- which says it exists in part to cess to yourself for cash?” “minimize the possibility of con- While the Liberal govern- fl icts arising between the private ment has not admitted any fault interests and public duties of in the April 7 fundraiser, Mr. public offi ce holders.” Adams said he hopes the nega- “So minimize them by saying tive publicity generated by this you can’t do these events,” Mr. case convinces it not to partake in Conacher said. such events in the future. Mr. Adams added: “The Liber- “I think that they’ll take a hit on als presented themselves after public perceptions of how squeaky the election as a group of people clean they really are,” he said, that would be more circumspect adding that the money raised from about raising money from people these types of fundraisers might who might potentially benefi t not be enough to justify the poten- from the decisions of ministers. tial political fallout. This clearly fails that test. … They “They have chosen not to said they were raising the bar and admit that a mistake was made. now they’re not meeting the bar What we don’t know yet is wheth- that they raised themselves.” er they think there was a mistake When asked to explain why made,” Mr. Adams said. Ms. Wilson-Raybould’s atten- Mr. Conacher said that, given the dance at the Toronto fundraiser way the Liberals presented them- did not contravene Mr. Trudeau’s selves both before and after last own directives on accountability, year’s election campaign, it would PMO spokesman Cameron Ah- be a grave mistake politically not to mad said Mr. Trudeau has already change their approach to political addressed this issue publicly. fundraising. He said the Liberals In the House of Commons on “won the swing [vote], as did the April 19, interim Conservative Leader Conservatives in 2006, by promising Rona Ambrose (Sturgeon River- to clean up politics and govern in an Parkland, Alta.) quoted Mr. Trudeau’s honest and ethical way. own directives from his “Accountable “It’s a hot-button issue. I be- Government” document back at him. lieve that polls show that this is a Mr. Trudeau replied: “Mr. main issue that swings voters, and Speaker, the Liberal Party of if they sense a government is gov- Canada has always followed all erning for its friends and lobby- the rules and all the regulations ists—especially lobbyists who pay involved with Elections Canada for access—as opposed to govern- and political donations.” ing for everyone, they’ll abandon Hot tickets: Some are wondering whether controversy caused over the attendance of Justice Minister Jody Wilson- He then brought up scandals the government very quickly.” Raybould, right, at a recent Liberal fundraiser will convince Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government to show more the previous Conservative gov- [email protected] restraint in terms of access to senior members of government at high-priced events. The Hill Times photographs by Jake Wright ernment had been involved in. The Hill Times Liberal Party spokesman Braeden Caley said about 70 people attended the April 7 event BY THE BOOK in Toronto. If everyone paid the full Wilson-Raybould’s cost of admission, that reception RULES ON POLITICAL would have raised around $35,000 for the party. Mr. Caley did not FUNDRAISING AND verify this or provide a list of who CONTRIBUTIONS fundraising activity offside was there, though he said the party would comply with Elections Cana- da’s policy that requires parties to From the Confl ict of Interest Act disclose all those who provide do- “No public offi ce holder shall on many levels, say critics nations of at least $200 in quarterly personally solicit funds from any reports. It’s not known whether or person or organization if it would not the crowd was primarily made place the public offi ce holder in a up of people from the legal sector. confl ict of interest.” Trudeau’s own in politics, said even with the ethics organizations because they have Mr. Adams said politicians From the prime minister’s commission’s “narrow” interpretation made fi nancial contributions to looking to raise money for their “Open and Accountable directives appear to of how the Confl ict of Interest Act politicians and political parties.” parties should avoid gatherings Government 2015” document: directly forbid the applies in this case, Mr. Trudeau’s Mr. Adams said: “There’s no that involve “a group of people own guidelines issued at the start of reasonable interpretation of the whose commonality is an interest • Ministers and Parliamentary justice minister’s his mandate should have prevented original guidelines, it seems to in the ministry that you lead. If you Secretaries must ensure that something like this from occurring. me, that would permit this.” are the minister of public works political fundraising activities or appearance at a “The guidelines that the prime As for the ethics commissioner’s and you go to a fundraiser that is considerations do not affect, or Liberal fundraiser minister issued in the fall seem, okay on the matter, Mr. Adams said organized by a contractor and is at- appear to affect, the exercise of on their face, plainly to prohibit she “has never been a very aggres- tended mainly by contractors that their offi cial duties or the access held at a prominent this,” he said. sive or energetic enforcer of ethical work for government, it seems ob- of individuals or organizations to law fi rm, says A document issued by the norms” and “has taken a very narrow vious that you don’t need the prime government. Prime Minister’s Offi ce on Nov. 27, view of what her job was.” minister’s accountability rules to • There should be no preferential Carleton University called “Open and Accountable Gov- The commissioner’s offi ce, in understand why that is an issue. access to government, or ernment 2015,” featured a section response to questions from The “If the minister of justice were appearance of preferential access, professor Paul about fundraising that said: “Minis- Hill Times, citing the only section holding a similar fundraiser in accorded to individuals or org Adams. ters and parliamentary secretaries of the Confl ict of Interest Act that her own constituency or back in nizations because they have made must ensure that political fundrais- deals with fundraising, said Ms. British Columbia with a group fi nancial contributions to ing activities or considerations do Wilson-Raybould did not appear that was not selected based on politicians and political parties. Continued from page 1 not affect, or appear to affect, the to have contravened the rule their relationship to the justice • There should be no singling out, exercise of their offi cial duties or preventing “a public offi ce holder system, I think there would be or appearance of singling out, of fi rmed that Ms. Wilson-Raybould the access of individuals or organi- from personally soliciting funds fewer issues,” Mr. Adams said. individuals or organizations as ta checked with her offi ce and was zations to government.” if it would place the public offi ce Mr. Conacher said “high-priced, gets of political fundraising cleared to participate, critics say It also said “there should be holder in a confl ict of interest.” private, exclusive events” should be because they have offi cial dealings this is not enough. no preferential access to govern- Ms. Dawson’s offi ce noted the avoided. “You can still hold a low- with Ministers and Parliamentary Paul Adams, a Carleton Universi- ment, or appearance of preferential “stricter rules” contained in the priced, large, public event where Secretaries, or their staff or ty journalism professor specializing access, accorded to individuals or prime minister’s November direc- anybody can go. It’s not invitation- departments. THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 23 OPINION CRIMINAL JUSTICE & REHABILITATION CORCAN offers rehabilitative programming, employment for offenders

This is done through awaiting trial and not yet convicted that fewer offenders have the op- offenders to acquire this skill-set removed from their communities, of a crime—and building more jails portunity to gain these valuable has largely disappeared. their families and—in some cases— on-the-job and to accommodate them is unneces- and highly sought after skills. Further, during this last decade, their children to serve federal sen- third-party certifi ed sary. Further, the cost of incarcer- And while some may think we CSC has undergone a signifi cant tences in prison. Given the signifi - vocational training ating an individual in Canada is ex- don’t “owe” offenders access to such revamping of its core rehabilita- cant mental health needs of women orbitant—well more than $100,000 training, the reality is that—without tive programming, consolidating offenders, it is time we re-set the in manufacturing, annually for federal offenders. it—offenders are far more likely to world renowned programming into conversation on the incarceration textiles, construction, But there’s another dimen- enter back into the cycle of crime a one size fi ts all model. Though of women generally when a high sion to this story that is being if they can’t gain a foothold in the the spirit behind the integrated proportion have, themselves, been and services. In former overlooked. Rehabilitative pro- mainstream job market. The real- correctional program model the victims of abuse. prime minister Stephen gramming and employment and ity is that over 90 percent of those (ICMP) is to address the multiple Better harnessing the consider- Harper’s last budget training opportunities for offend- serving federal time for a crime will needs of offenders—and ensure all able $2.3-billion spent on fed- ers, most of whom will be released be released. Further, the average offenders access to at least some eral corrections must go beyond in 2015, CORCAN back into the community, has, in level of educational achievement for programming—many who deliver a discussion about whether or not operations were some cases, decreased signifi cant- those entering a federal penitentia- these programs are deeply con- to build more prisons. The more ‘streamlined’ and certain ly over the last decade. This has ry is Grade 8. The prospects for their cerned that this new model does than 15,000 women and men meant that while certain offenders economic independence are bleak not suffi ciently address the roots of who are currently incarcerated in locations were closed. are being incarcerated for longer unless we seize the opportunity violence. In particular, the elimina- federal prisons, and those who are periods, there are actually fewer while they are serving time. tion of a specialized program dedi- employed to support them in their opportunities for them to emerge Another reduction in access cated to family/domestic violence rehabilitation, fully understand from a costly prison stay with tan- to training can be seen in the is especially troubling given the that effective programming and gible skills that enable them to be signifi cant changes to CSC’s food complex, often multi-generational access to relevant education and employable and self-suffi cient. operation services which, until re- roots of violence and trauma. Rec- training opportunities may be one A case in point is CORCAN. cently, provided higher functioning ognizing the extremely high rates of their only hopes for a better life. STAN STAPLETON Little known outside of the Cor- offenders with the chance to work of incarceration among indigenous It’s time we take a hard look at rectional Service of Canada (CSC), with professionally trained chefs. offenders, it’s clear that the ICPM how we best use the time spent and it provides eligible offenders with In so doing, they assisted in the cannot address the devastating funds deployed on federal offend- employment and employability preparation of meals for inmates in fall out from Canada’s residential ers to give them the best shot at a ast week’s issue of The Hill skills training. This is done through large institutions. Such experiences school legacy which has affected brighter future. LTimes featured a perspective on-the-job and third-party certifi ed enabled some offenders to leave many of these men and women. Stan Stapleton is the presi- from a network of academics and vocational training in manufac- prison with valuable experience Finally, there are real and tough dent of the National Union of advocates who are recommending turing, textiles, construction, and that could be parlayed into decent questions about how to manage Solicitor General Employees rep- a halt to the expansion to Canada’s services. In former prime minister paying jobs as cooks in restaurants Canada’s fastest growing offender resenting all of Canada’s federal federal/provincial/territorial prison Stephen Harper’s last budget in and hotels. Owing to CSC’s major population, women. Owing in part parole offi cers and other rehabili- infrastructure. The argument is 2015, CORCAN operations were transition to a cook chill system to the previous government’s tough tative staff within and outside of that a signifi cant proportion of “streamlined” and certain locations where food is largely pre-cooked on crime approach to criminal Canada’s federal penitentiaries. Canada’s incarcerated are, in fact, were closed. The consequence is off site, the opportunity for federal justice, more women are being The Hill Times

Let’s #GetLoud to support mental health Find out how you can be a part of it at mentalhealthcommission.ca

@MHCC_ /theMHCC /1MHCC @theMHCC /Mental Health Commission of Canada 24 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 DONNER PRIZE WINNER

Q&A DONALD SAVOIE ‘We have lost sight of what government is good at’

Gill-Queen’s University Press). media—resonates there as well. In Donald Savoie talks Mr. Savoie is a former as- a democracy, in a capitalist society, about winning this sistant secretary of the Treasury what is government good at is a Board and deputy principal of question that resonates throughout year’s Donner Prize the Canadian Centre for Manage- the Western World. Morale in pub- for his book, What ment Development who has also lic service in the Western World has worked as an adviser to foreign, plummeted. That morale problem Is Government federal, provincial and territo- has to be addressed. We can’t keep Good At?: A rial governments as well as at belittling government in Western the OECD, the World Bank, the democracy—we need to fi x it. Canadian Answer. United Nations. He’s the author Throwing criticism at it is not good of 40 books. enough. We need to do better.” Mr. Savoie, Canada research BY KATE MALLOY chair in public administration Why is this book important and and governance and a profes- who should read it? overnments are needed for sor of public administration at “Students of public adminis- Gtheir visionary investments, the University of Moncton, is tration should read it, but also but they’ve lost sight of what already working on two more practitioners should read it as they’re good at and need to ad- books, on economic development well, and politicians. I wrote it dress the problem urgently for the policy and another on the state of in an accessible style because I sake of public policy and democra- Canadian democracy. am hoping that Canadians will cy, says Don Savoie who won the take note and will start to debate prestigious $50,000 Donner Prize Why did you want to write this the fundamental question—what for the best public policy book of book? is government good at? This the year last week in Toronto. “I think it is a fundamental book launches that debate. Let’s One of Canada’s leading question of the last 30 years that get into it. I don’t have the fi nal experts on the machinery of government and the public need to answer, but I know we need to government, Mr. Savoie won the ask: we have lost sight of what gov- initiate the debate.” prize, also known as “the Giller ernment is good at. What we have Don Savoie: ‘I wanted Canadians to deal with the issue—what is government for policy wonks,” for his book been hearing is full of criticism, but Why do you think your book won good at—try to sort out the good from bad. The book is a fi rst crack at it. This What Is Government Good At?: we haven’t counterbalanced it by the Donner Prize, the best public is a fundamental point of public policy. If we sort out that issue, we can focus A Canadian Answer, published in trying to sort out what is govern- policy book of the year? on things the government isn’t as good at. If government doesn’t learn to row 2015 by McGill-Queen’s Univer- ment good at, and what it isn’t “That is a tough question. better, it may not be able to steer the ship at sea.’ The Hill Times photographs by sity Press. good at. I think it is a fundamental It would have been a diffi cult Jake Wright Morale, he said, in the public question for public policy, and, choice, because the other four service has crashed here and in frankly, for democracy. I decided, books are excellent. I just feel What do you think of the prime need to give public service the the entire Western World and ‘Let’s start by exploring it,’—it fortunate the jury decides this minister’s use of the “deliverol- ability to work away from the me- addressing the problem and certainly isn’t the last word, by any should be my year. But the other ogy” guru from the U.K.? dia to provide the kind of delivery learning to give life back to the means, but it is a start.” books are solid books. A member “Let’s give it a chance—let’s of government programs that we bureaucracy is one of the great- of the jury told me it is a relevant see if it works. I am of a certain had 30 or 40 years ago. est challenges facing the federal What is your main message? book, for a relevant year, in a vintage now, where the cynicism “We have to ask questions. Do government here in Canada. “We need government for relevant time. I happen to believe in me says this is a lot of what we have too many oversight bod- He said he doesn’t have the visionary investments for the econ- that as well.” we have seen before. I think ies? My answer is yes. We have 12 fi nal answer on what govern- omy to grow. When you look at the the more fundamental question offi cers of Parliament; Britain and ment is good at, but wants to iPhone, you can see government in Why now? Government has been is: how much accountability Australia have two or three. Do ignite a national discussion and it—through research and develop- broken for a while? requirements have we built in? we have too many accountability hopes Parliament will look at ment subsidies, government was an “We haven’t dealt with it. We How many oversight bodies do requirements? Yes. Do we have the issue. He said he also doesn’t important part of the iPhone, and have just gone around belittling we have? Do we have too many too many reporting requirements expect Prime Minister Justin of BlackBerry, of transportation, government and bureaucracy. We central agencies? Is it too large? If on government managers? Yes. If Trudeau (Papineau, Que.) to read ports, and airports. Government haven’t had a full-blown debate. we were to address those ques- you look at those things, you have his book, but hopes one of Mr. had done a number of things for I hope that debate takes place in tions we might get a bit more more of a chance of reigniting Trudeau’s advisers will write a economic success. Where I think Parliament, within political parties mileage. Over the last 34 years we morale in the public service.” two-page memo on the book’s government has failed is in manag- and the media have a role to play. have tried different measures and fundamental question. ing operations. It has not been as It is everybody’s business. Political buzzwords, this one might work “We haven’t had a full-blown effi cient as it could be, and it has parties have a special role to play better than the others. debate. I hope that debate takes not been as effi cient as it was 30 in that issue. The government at “The point I am making is What Is place in Parliament, within politi- years ago. It has lost ground and the moment ran on the campaign, that I think the system requires a Government Good cal parties and the media have we need to address it with a sense ‘Government can do better.’ It much more fundamental rethink. At?: A Canadian a role to play. It is everybody’s of urgency.” resonated with Canadians. All our At some point, government needs Answer, by business. Political parties have a political parties need to address to ask the question: have we Donald J. Savoie, special role to play in that issue. What does the title mean? What this as their issue—what is govern- added too many oversight bod- McGill-Queen’s The government at the moment is government good at? ment good for? ies? Have we built in too many University Press, ran on the campaign, ‘Govern- “This is the fundamental ques- “I am not suggesting that gov- accountability requirements? 388 pp., $34.95. ment can do better.’ It resonated tion. When I was writing this, a ernment needs to do more—not Have we hampered managers to with Canadians. All our political leading businessman asked me by a long shot. I think we have the point where they don’t own parties need to address this as what book I was working on, and I lost sight of the core responsibil- their work anymore? Those are their issue—what is government told him the title and he said, ‘Jeez, ity of government.” fundamental questions that need good for?” that will be a short book!’ That view to be addressed.” What’s your next book? The book, which was also on is prevalent amongst too many Have you had any feedback on “I have two. One is getting The Hill Times’ 100 Best Books Canadians, and amongst too many your book from the new federal What’s the greatest challenge facing the fi nal touches, which is on in 2015, was shortlisted along in the Western World, and I wanted Liberal government? the current federal government? economic development policy. I with four other best books for the Canadians to deal with the issue— “Politicians have given me And what’s best solution? have also started another one on prestigious Donner Prize, includ- what is government good at—try feedback. Two premiers have told “One of the greatest chal- the state of Canadian democracy. ing Back to the Well: Rethinking to sort out the good from bad. The me separately that they want to lenges is learning to give life to I am going to have fun with that the Future of Water, by Marq de book is a fi rst crack at it. This is a address the question that I am bureaucracy, to tell the public one. I am doing a lot of research Villers (Goose Lane Editions); fundamental point of public policy. raising.” service: you are important institu- to when Canada was born, Middle Power, Middle Kingdom: If we sort out that issue, we can fo- tions; how can we make it better; and the kind of institutions we What Canadians Need to Know cus on things the government isn’t Do you hope Prime Minister Jus- we value your expertise— let’s imported, what did we learn by About China in the 21st Century, as good at. If government doesn’t tin Trudeau reads your book and deal with the morale problem, British institutions and apply- by David Mulroney (Allen Lane/ learn to row better, it may not be learns from it? because the public arm is the face ing them in a country that didn’t Penguin Canada); From Treaty able to steer the ship at sea.” “He is a busy man. I think of government. If it doesn’t work have the socio-economic circum- Peoples to Treaty Nation: A Road reading an academic tome might properly we have a problem. One stances that Great Britain has, Map for All Canadians, by Greg Is this book applicable to other be a bit much. But I would hope of the fundamental things govern- how did we make that work, is it Poelzer and Ken S. Coates (UBC countries and other governments? that someone in the PMO would ment can do is ask the question of still working. Early days. I know Press); and Leading Universities “The book has been reviewed put forward a two-page briefi ng the number of oversight bodies. where I want to go with it, but I in a Competitive World, by Robert in the U.S and the reaction from note on the book and the funda- We may have gone too far in have a lot more research to do.” Lacroix and Louis Maheu (Mc- Americans—academics and the mental question.” terms of transparency. We may The Hill Times THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 25 MIDDLE EAST ARMS

bia.” Saudi Arabia’s brutal bombing campaign in Yemen against the There seems to The Saudi arms Houthi rebels has sparked outrage be little, if any, in most Western capitals. The United movement on Nations Panel of Experts on Yemen Justin Trudeau’s “documented 119 coalition [bomb- commitment to deal: More than ing] sorties relating to violations of re-engage with the laws of war.” Iran. In short, There is little doubt that Sté- so far, Trudeau’s phane Dion and his boss would like Middle East meets the eye? us to believe that Saudi Arabia’s policy looks total disregard for civilian lives and disturbingly its targeting of medical facilities in like Stephen leading gambit—that he was in fact Yemen (a possible war crime) are Harper’s, writes The stunningly stupid following Canadian law in signing irrelevant when it comes to signing Murray Dobbin. the export permits. Dion attacked decision to go ahead arms exports permits. But it appears The Hill Times The Globe and Mail for its accusa- to many governments, international photograph by with a $15-billion sale tion of hypocrisy claiming that “the agencies, and NGOs as decisive. Jake Wright of light armoured Foreign Affairs minister may block In swimming against the inter- the exports permits at any time if national tide, Dion’s new foreign vehicles (LAVs) to there were serious evidence of mis- policy philosophy—“responsible use of the military equipment.” That conviction”—might better be called Saudi Arabia has the is, presumably, after our LAVs have “conviction when convenient.” been used to attack civilians. But in But putting all of this down to potential to expose fact the export control guidelines a botched political calculation re- Justin Trudeau as a don’t refer to “serious misuse” but garding Canadian jobs is not a very to whether “there is no reasonable convincing explanation. Does this phoney. risk that the goods might be used ugly bit of Trudeau policy reveal against the civilian population.” something more substantive? What There is no need here to repeat does it say about the government’s what everyone already knows overall Middle East policy? One of about the hideous human rights re- the reasons Dion has given for the cord of Saudi Arabia—it is amongst arms sale is that Saudi Arabia is an the worst of the worst. And in fact ally in the fi ght against Islamic ex- MURRAY DOBBIN the Saudi government has used ex- tremism. But anyone with knowl- actly this kind of armoured vehicle edge of its roots knows that Saudi against its own dissenting citizens. Arabia is the motherland when it According to Belkis Wille, Ye- comes to radical Islam. Right now OWELL RIVER, B.C.—It is men researcher for Human Rights in the U.S. there is a fi erce debate Pdiffi cult to predict what kind of Watch: “The Saudis have used raging about whether or not to re- government misstep can seriously such vehicles to violently suppress lease a secret 28-page section of a tarnish a government’s reputa- peaceful protests in eastern Saudi 2002 congressional report on 9/11, tion. Some mistakes have legs and Arabia in 2011 and 2012.” Is there a dealing with possible involvement others, inexplicably, seem not to. “reasonable risk” that it will do so of elements of the Saudi regime in But the stunningly stupid decision again? Everything we know about the terror attacks. to go ahead with a $15-billion sale the new and far more aggressive While it is still relatively early of light armoured vehicles (LAVs) regime in Riyadh today says yes. days in the Trudeau government to Saudi Arabia has the potential In January, the regime executed 47 promises of a signifi cant shift in ME to expose Justin “Canada is back” prisoners (most by beheading) on a policy are still nowhere to be seen. A Trudeau as a phony. Indeed you single day, many of them for simply 2013 assessment of where Trudeau could hardly design an issue so demonstrating against the govern- would go on the Israeli-Palestinian perfectly fi tted to reveal a govern- ment. The regime executed 151 in confl ict suggested major shifts in ment with a progressive public 2015—the most in 20 years. balancing the interests of the two face contradicted by a ruthless The Saudi government de- sides. But so far Canada’s support disregard for human rights. It scribed the executed as “terrorists” for Israel seems unwavering. begs the question as to whether but the law defi ning terrorism What stands out is Trudeau’s the spin doctors simply misjudged casts an enormous net. A terrorist support of a Conservative resolu- how widespread the public revul- is “anyone who demands reform, tion that would have the govern- sion would be or whether there is exposes corruption or otherwise ment “condemn” any advocacy for something deeper going on. Is it engages in dissent or violence the BDS (boycott, divest, sanction) really just about jobs or is there a against the government.” campaign for Palestinian rights. contradictory, they are in fact quite three decades has the tension be- hard-nosed commitment, inherited While the arms-sales guidelines He also opposes the EU’s new consistent. The two countries share tween the U.S. and Israel and Saudi from the Conservatives, to a back- aim to protect the civilian popula- product labelling initiative “that a number of common enemies, Arabia, its two principal Middle ward Middle East foreign policy? tion of the country in question, require products produced in the including Shia Islam, Iran, pan- East allies, been greater. One way Dion has been severely weak- surely the Trudeau government settlements and sold in the EU Arab nationalism, the Assad regime for Dion to indicate he’s not offside ened by his performance on the should consider the use of its to be clearly marked.” And there in Syria, and Hezbollah. They are on rebalancing Middle East policy Saudi arms sale fi le. First he wasn’t exports against civilians anywhere seems to be little if any move- also the most vociferous regional would be to end his self-righteous upfront about the government’s to be a human rights deal-breaker. ment on Trudeau’s commitment to opponents of U.S. and EU efforts posturing on the LAV deal and inability to get out of the contract— It is precisely this situation which re-engage with Iran. In short, so at a rapprochement with Iran. If reverse the export permits. saying it was legally committed has prompted Canada’s allies in the far, Trudeau’s Middle East policy Canada doesn’t move on its pledges Murray Dobbin is a journalist, by the Conservative government’s European Parliament “to launch an looks disturbingly like Harper’s. regarding policy change, it will fi nd commentator, and author based in actions. He compounded his cred- initiative aimed at imposing an EU While policies supporting both itself increasingly at odds with the Powell River, B.C. ibility problem with another mis- arms embargo against Saudi Ara- Israel and Saudi Arabia may seem U.S. and EU. At no time in the past The Hill Times UN CONSEILLER DE CONFIANCE. UNE VOIX INFLUENTE.

Un conseiller respecté sur les questions fiscales, économiques et d’affaires qui sont importantes pour assurer un avenir prospère aux Canadiens et aux entreprises canadiennes. 26 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 NEWS SENATE SPENDING

Seven former Senators who New Brunswick Independent John against Sen. Brazeau and Mr. chose not to make use of the Wallace, say more work needs to be Harb. Sen. Brazeau’s trial will Duffy’s not arbitration process and have not done to further clarify Senate rules. start on June 12 in Ottawa and paid back the money may now face The Senate expense saga start- Mr. Harb is scheduled to appear legal action. They include former ed in late 2012 and in November before a judge on May 20. Liberal Senators Sharon Carstairs, 2013 led to the suspension of Sen. Wallin returned to the guilty verdict Marie-P. Charette-Poulin, Rose- three Conservative Senators— Senate in September. After his Marie Losier-Cool, Bill Rompkey, Sen. Duffy, Pamela Wallin, and April 21 verdict, Sen. Duffy has and Rod Zimmer, and former Patrick Brazeau, while Liberal been reinstated in full standing Conservative Senators Don Oliver Senator Mac Harb resigned from with access to his offi ce, staff, and casts doubt on and Gerry St. Germain. his seat in August 2013. The Senate resources. Bob Ransford, a spokesman RCMP has also fi led criminal [email protected] for Mr. St. Germain who owes charges related to expense claims The Hill Times the Senate $67,120, told The Hill prospects for Times, last week that the former British Columbia Senator has SENATE AUDIT advised the Senate administration that he has no plans to return the REPAYMENT STATUS OF FORMER SENATORS legal action money as he believes his expens- es were legitimate and related to the Senate business. If the Senate Name Amount Outstanding decides to take legal action, Mr. Sharon Carstairs $7,528.00 against former St. Germain will “vigorously” de- Marie-P. Charette-Poulin $125,828.00 fend himself, the spokesman said. Rose-Marie Losier-Cool $110,051.00 “He has informed Senate ad- Don H. Oliver $24,739.50 ministration that he is not going to Bill Rompkey $17,292.00 Senators be reimbursing for expense that he Gerry St. Germain $67,120.00 believes were legitimately claimed Rod A. A. Zimmer $176,014.00 for Senate business, and if they pursue action against him, he will All of these former Senators have not paid back the money. Senate arbitration cess in legal action to recovering vigorously defend himself.” Source: Senate of Canada the money from Senators. She Linda Oliver, wife of Mr. Oliver process cost said that the lawyer reviewing who owes $24,739.50, declined a this issue will advise the Senate comment for this article, saying SENATE AUDIT taxpayers $200,000- how strong the case is against the former Senator is facing a these former Senators. serious health challenges and is AUDITOR GENERAL MICHAEL FERGUSON $225,000: Liberal “I think what we’re doing is focused on that. AUDIT REPORT fi ne. We’ve already sent it off to Sen. Campbell also said that Sen. Jane Cordy. an outside legal counsel and the the Internal Economy Commit- process is already underway now,” tee will also discuss if Sen. Duffy Name Amount Flagged Continued from page 1 she said. should get the about $270,000 in Ind. Sen. Pierre-Hugues Boisvenu $61,076 “I’m not sure, I’m not a lawyer. salary that he did not receive in Conservative Sen. Claude Carignan $3,516 In an interview with The Hill We have an outside counsel looking his approximately two years of Former Liberal Sen. Sharon Carstairs $7,528 Times last week, British Colum- at that, right now. I would assume suspension. He said the fi nal deci- Former Liberal Sen. Marie-P Charette-Poulin $131,434 bia Ind. Sen. Larry Campbell that a good lawyer will evaluate sion will likely be made by a vote Liberal Sen. James Cowan $10,397 said that in light of Sen. Duffy’s everything that he or she has before of all Senators, which is the same Conservative Sen. Jean-Guy Dagenais $3,538 (Cavendish, P.E.I.) trial verdict, them and make the decision, and kind of process that resulted in Liberal Sen. Joseph Day $19,634 the Senate’s Internal Economy I’m not making the decision.” him being suspended in Novem- Conservative Sen. Nicole Eaton $3,489 Committee will discuss this week Because of the Senate ex- ber 2013. Conservative Sen. Leo Housakos $8,319 if it’s worth pursuing legal cases penses issue, the Senate invited Mr. In July 2014, the RCMP Conservative Sen. Janis Johnson $22,706 against the fi ve former Liberal Ferguson in June 2013 to conduct charged Sen. Duffy on 31 counts Liberal Sen. Colin Kenny $35,549 and two former Conservative a comprehensive audit of all 116 of fraud, breach of trust, and Former Conservative Sen. Noel Kinsella $9,386 Senators who have not paid back Senators’ expenses that served in bribery. After 62 days of hearings Former Liberal Sen. Rose-Marie Losier Cool $110,051 the more than half-million dollars the Red Chamber between April that started in April of last year Liberal Sen. Sandra Lovelace Nicholas $75,227 that, in Mr. Ferguson’s view, was 2011 and March 2013. In his fi nal and concluded in February, Judge Ind. Sen. Elaine McCoy $10,298 misspent. report tabled in June of last year, Charles Vaillancourt rendered his Liberal Sen. Terry Mercer $29,338 “At the end of the day, value Mr. Ferguson red-fl agged the decision on April 21, exonerating Liberal Sen. Pana Merchant $5,500 for money and chances of success questionable expense claims of Sen. Duffy on all charges related Former PC Sen. Lowell Murray $16,300 in it, all of these things have to be 30 Senators for about $1-million to his travel, residential, and Former Conservative Sen. Don Oliver $48,088 considered. It’s up in the air,” said combined. The audit cost the tax- offi ce expenses. In his 308-page Conservative Sen. Dennis Patterson $22,985 Sen. Campbell. “My question is do payers about $24-million in which verdict, Mr. Vaillancourt said he Former Liberal Sen. Robert Patterson $11,493 we go spend—I don’t know how the auditors reviewed about 80,000 found Sen. Duffy to be a “credible Conservative Sen. Don Plett $4,095 much—a considerable amount of expense-claim transactions. witness.” He said that the Crown Former Liberal Sen. Vivienne Poy $15,317 money in a legal process where Of the 30 Senators, Mr. Fer- failed to prove beyond a reason- Conservative Sen. Nancy Greene Raine $2,800 it costs us more than we return. guson referred the fi les of nine able doubt that Sen. Duffy had Former Liberal Sen. Bill Rompkey $17,292 It’s one of those questions that current and former Senators to the a criminal intent in the way he Liberal Sen. Nick Sibbeston $50,102 we’re going to have to address RCMP. By deadline last week, the spent money. Former Conservative Sen. Gerry St. Germain $67,588 and, quite frankly, nobody’s go- RCMP had not publicly indicated “After reviewing the submis- Former Conservative Sen. Terry Stratton $5,466 ing to be happy. In the public, it’s if criminal charges would be laid sions and the facts in this case, I Conservative Sen. David Tkachuk $7,391 like you’re damned if you do and against any of these nine Senators. am not satisfi ed that the Crown Former Liberal Sen. Rod Zimmer $176,014 you’re damned if you don’t.” For the current and former has proven the guilt of Sena- * All current Senators have paid the money back On Friday, April 22—the day Senators who disputed the au- tor Duffy in relation to alleged Source: Auditor General of Canada after Sen. Duffy’s verdict—Quebec dit report, the Senate’s Internal fraudulent residency declarations Conservative Sen. Leo Housakos, Economy Committee arranged an and/or expense claims in connec- chair of the Internal Economy independent arbitration process tion thereto beyond a reasonable SENATE ARBITRATION Committee, and Nova Scotia Lib- headed by former Supreme Court doubt,” wrote the judge in his eral Sen. Jane Cordy, deputy chair, judge Ian Binnie to give a fi nal verdict. SENATE ARBITRATION PROCESS CONCLUSIONS issued a statement instructing the chance to Senators to defend In the verdict, Mr. Vaillancourt Senate law clerk Michel Patrice to their claims. Of the 30 Senators, described Senate administrative retain an outside legal counsel to 14 chose to challenge Mr. Fer- rules as “inadequate, poorly com- start the legal process to recover guson’s fi ndings and took their municated [and] criteria-lacking.” Name Amount Required to be Paid money from the former Senators cases to Mr. Binnie. Mr. Fergu- “Where a Senator in good faith Ind. Sen. Pierre-Hugues Boisvenu $20,467 who have not paid back money son fl agged $322,611 in alleged tries to apply bad (inadequate, Conservative Sen. Jean-Guy Dagenais $2,267 owed. In an email to The Hill Times, questionable claims for these 14 poorly communicated, criteria- Liberal Sen. Joseph Day $3,050 Mr. Patrice said that he could not Senators. In his fi nal report that lacking) policy, he/she can’t be Liberal Sen. Colin Kenny $27,458 comment further. was made public on March 21, found criminally responsible if Liberal Sen. Sandra Lovelace Nicholas $38,023 “I have been instructed to seek Mr. Binnie upheld 55 per cent errors were made. Bad policy Liberal Sen. Terry Mercer $10,536 outside counsel to initiate legal of Mr. Ferguson’s audit fi ndings breeds bad practice,” wrote Judge Liberal Sen. Pana Merchant $820 action in this matter,” wrote Mr. and asked these Senators to pay Vaillancourt. “Bad policy predict- Former PC Sen. Lowell Murray $15,324 Patrice. “As this is now consid- back $177,898.14 within 30 days ably fosters mistakes.” Conservative Sen. Dennis Patterson $13,762 ered a legal matter, we are not or face legal action. All 14 paid Since the Senate expenses issue Former Liberal Sen. Robert Patterson $11,492 at liberty to discuss the details back their designated amounts. fi rst became public in late 2012, Conservative Sen. Don Plett $404 including but not limited to any A spokesman for Sen. Cordy the Senate has made a number of Liberal Sen. Nick Sibbeston $26,924 correspondence between the par- told The Hill Times last week that changes to tighten up the Senate Former Conservative Sen. Terry Stratton $5,466 ties involved.” the Senate arbitration process cost rules such as ending the “honour Conservative Sen. David Tkachuk $1,900 Sen. Cordy, in an interview the taxpayers between $200,000 system” and requiring documenta- * All current and former Senators who took their cases to the arbitration with The Hill Times, declined to and $225,000, but added that the tion to prove residency require- process have paid the money back. comment on the chances of suc- costs are still being fi nalized. ments. But some Senators, like Source: Ian Binnie’s Senate Arbitration Report THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 27 HILL CLIMBERS POLITICAL STAFFERS

to her ministerial team, including Bonnie Natural Resources Leask who was hired as a special adviser Minister Carr hires for policy and regional affairs. Daniel Pujdak was hired as a policy and regional policy adviser regional affairs adviser in Ms. Bennett’s offi ce in February. Until recently, he was a for Quebec, and a senior adviser for the Chiefs of Ontario in policy adviser Toronto, working on “government relations, policy coordinator and strategic initiatives” Natural Resources Minister Jim Carr, in the role, as described on his LinkedIn profi le, after starting out as a senior policy Yanique Williams is a policy meanwhile, has bolstered his ministerial poli- cy team, including hiring Guillaume Julien as analyst for intergovernmental affairs and adviser for small business the environment at the political forum, and Ontario desk adviser to a regional policy adviser for Quebec in April. Previously, Mr. Julien worked on con- which is a coordinating body for 134 First Small Business and Tourism Nations communities in the province. Elyse Banham, left, is now a special assistant to National Defence Minis- Minister Bardish Chagger. tract for more than a year for multinational mining company Glencore (formerly Xstra- Mr. Pujdak previously worked for the ter Harjit Sajjan, as is Anthony Di Carlo. Photographs courtesy of LinkedIn Photograph courtesy of LinkedIn ta Nickel), as communications and external Assembly of First Nations, working his affairs coordinator for Raglan Mine, a way up to the title of senior policy analyst large nickel mining operation in northern in the spring of 2012 after fi rst being hired Quebec’s Nunavik region. Before that, he in May 2010. He’s a former member of the was a governmental and public affairs Great Lakes Executive Committee. adviser at Hill and Knowlton Strategies in Ryan Cotter, who in recent years has Quebec. He studied at Laval University. served as executive assistant to Liberal MP Zara Rabinovitch has also been hired Hedy Fry (Vancouver Centre, B.C.), is now in Mr. Carr’s offi ce as a policy adviser. Un- a special assistant for operations in Ms. til recently, she was living and working in Bennett’s ministerial offi ce. He’s a former Washington D.C. as editor of the Migration parliamentary assistant to Ms. Bennett Policy Institute’s online journal, the Migra- who represents Toronto-St. Paul’s, Ont., tion Information Source, after starting off and has also overseen communications with the institute as a communications on former Liberal Maria Minna’s 2008 re- intern in the summer of 2014. election campaign. Before that, she spent two months as Alexsa McKenzie has also joined Ms. Ariel Gough is a policy adviser to Families, Children and Social John Gosal is now a senior a special assistant for intergovernmental Bennett’s ministerial offi ce as liaison to the Development Minister Jean-Yves Duclos, while Emilie Gauducon is policy adviser to Mr. Sajjan. affairs at the Canadian Embassy in Wash- Parliamentary Secretary for Indigenous now the minister’s press secretary. Photographs courtesy of LinkedIn Photograph courtesy of LinkedIn ington, D.C., after starting off as a media Affairs, Liberal MP Yvonne Jones. relations intern at the embassy. Ms. KcKenzie was until recently a Ms. Rabinovitch has also briefl y worked communications adviser for the Institut as a programs manager at Wild Culture, Tshakapesh in Sept-Îles, Que., an Innu cul- which published the Journal of Wild Culture, tural and educational institution. The Innu and as a publications intern at the National are aboriginal peoples located in areas of HILL CLIMBERS Bureau of Asian Research in Seattle, Wash- Quebec and Labrador. ington. Starting in 2006, she spent a num- She studied civil law at McGill Univer- BY LAURA RYCKEWAERT ber of years working for Fleetwood Films, sity, during which time she was involved becoming an associate producer, writer, and in the McGill Law Journal and the McGill researcher, and worked on a documentary International journal of Sustainable Devel- mini-series on the Hidden World of the Harem opment Law and Policy, and has been in- for VisionTV Canada, including episodes on volved with Lawyers Without Borders. She ‘The Sultan’s Women,’ and ‘Secret Files of the was a student-at-law at Quebec law fi rm Justice Minister Wilson- Dionne Schulze S.E.N.C., which mainly Inquisition,’ according to her LinkedIn profi le. She has also spent a year as co-editor works with Aboriginal governments, orga- at the Association for the Study of Ethnic- nizations and individuals, according to its ity and Nationalism in the U.K., where she website. Raybould hires Smith Since then, Ms. McKenzie has worked studied a master of science in comparative politics at the London School of Economics in Montreal for law fi rms Hennan Blaikie and Political Science. Ms. Rabinovitch has LLP and Murdoch & Archambault, and has a bachelor degree in political science and also worked with the First Nations Human as policy director Resources Development Commission of English literature from UBC. Jeffrey Kovalik-Plouffe is a special as- Quebec. sistant to the minister who joined the offi ce Back in the summer of 2006, she in- terned in the offi ce of Quebec’s Aboriginal Rights Committee as part of its 2013 study back in February. Up until then, he was in Affairs Minister. In 2004, she was a speaker Chloé Luciani- examining Canada’s international and Winnipeg serving as executive director of at the United Nations Permanent Forum on national human rights obligations. the Manitoba Liberal Party and as presi- Girouard said it’s been Indigenous Issues, discussing gender pres- Mr. Smith oversees senior policy adviser dent of JKP and Company in the city, as ence within the forum’s work. ‘pretty hectic’ but ‘a Jessica Prince. indicated by his LinkedIn account. Whitney Morrison is now a regional Mr. Kovalik-Plouffe was campaign man- blast so far,’ serving assistant to Ms. Wilson-Raybould, who ager for Mr. Carr in Winnipeg South Centre Heritage Minister represents Vancouver Granville, B.C. Until during the 2015 election. In other campaign as press secretary last summer, Ms. Morrison was a policy experience, he was deputy campaign man- Joly hires an issues to National Revenue analyst for the B.C. Assembly of First Na- ager for the party in Manitoba during the tions, beginning in January 2012, according 2011 federal election, and later that year was manager for strategic Minister Diane to her LinkedIn profi le, and helped in part deputy campaign manager for the Manitoba communications to support the regional chief, who was Ms. Liberal leader Jon Gerrard (he had previ- Lebouthillier. Wilson-Raybould. Ms. Wilson-Raybould ously spent almost a year as legislative and constituency assistant to Mr. Gerrard). Finally, Canadian Heritage Minister who was fi rst elected regional chief of the Mélanie Joly hired Sandra Aubé to serve B.C. Assembly of First Nations in 2009 and He’s also been campaign manager for ustice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould as an issues manager for strategic com- was re-elected in 2012. Manitoba Liberal Party candidate Terry Hay- has hired Keith Smith to work as her munications in her ministerial offi ce back J Ms. Morrison has also previously ward in Provencher, Man. in 2013; deputy cam- director of policy in her ministerial offi ce, in February. worked as a regional coordinator for the paign manager to now Ontario Liberal MPP helping to navigate the complicated justice Ms. Aubé was previously working in Ki- Aboriginal Sport, Recreation and Physi- Ann Hoggarth in Barrie, Ont., in 2014; and fi les and provide advice in the role. gali, Rwanda as a public relations special- cal Activity Partner Council in B.C.; and then campaign manager for John Orlikow’s Mr. Smith was most recently working ist and content strategist. Before that, she as a program manager assistant with 2014 bid for re-election as the city councillor as director of policy research and interna- was living in Montreal, and has worked the B.C. Ministry of Jobs, Tourism and for River Heights-Fort Garry in Winnipeg. tional affairs in the human rights promo- in the city as a senior communications Innovation in Vancouver managing the In other past experience, he’s previously tion branch at the Canadian Human Rights adviser for the Association Québécoise des “Welcoming and Inclusive Community worked as a projects coordinator for the City Commission. The commission is responsi- centres de la petite enfance and before that Dialogue Program” in 2010, as indicated of Winnipeg, and is a former vice-chair for ble for administering the Canadian Human as a senior adviser to the chief of staff and by her online profi le. the Winnipeg Public Library Board. He stud- Rights Act and ensuring compliance with director of communications at the Centre She’s also a former constituency as- ied a double major in politics and theatre at the Employment Equity Act as an indepen- hospitalier de l’Université de Montreal. sistant intern to B.C. NDP MLA Doug the University of Winnipeg. dent government agency. She’s a former journalist and editor in the Donaldson in his offi ce in Hazelton, B.C., He has previously worked for what was TV section of Radio-Canada in Montreal, and and before that worked for a time as team then called federal department of Aborigi- has also done research, writing and produc- leader for food action with the Storytell- Indigenous Affairs nal Affairs and Northern Affairs Canada tion work for RDI. Among other experience, er’s Foundation in the city. Ms. Morrison as director of the intergovernmental and Minister Bennett adds to she’s also been science editor at ComSanté studied political science, with a minor in international relations directorate. In this Research Group. Ms. Aubé studied a bachelor the First Nations studies program, at the role, Mr. Smith worked with the UN, the her ministerial staff team and master’s degree in communications at University of British Columbia (UBC), and Organisation of American States and other Université due Quebec à Montreal. was involved in the First Nations Student Indigenous and Northern Affairs Minis- international groups and forums. He has [email protected] Association at the school. ter Carolyn Bennett has added more staff also testifi ed before the Senate Human The Hill Times 28 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 HILL LIFE & PEOPLE PARLIAMENT BUILDINGS Steel going up as interim House Chamber construction begins this month

it lets in is expected to decrease The courtyard of the energy costs for the building. West Block building The steel columns that sup- port the glass-domed roof will be is being renovated to visible to occupants inside the include a new infi ll interim House Chamber. ARCOP/FGM Architects was building, all topped subcontracted for design work on 1 by a glass-domed the building and infi ll, while PCL Constructors was awarded the roof, which will main West Block project construc- tion management contract. include an interim “The glass roof itself and the House of Commons structure for that has been in planning since March of last year Chamber for when … which took us through roughly work on Centre to August, and then from August we started some fabrication [of Block begins in 2018. the required steel],” said Mark Koeppelaar, vice-president of projects at Walters Group, which LAURA RYCKEWAERT was subcontracted to do steel work on the West Block. ranes on the West Block build- “A lot of work goes into fi nish- Cing site will be busy in the ing them and making sure the coming weeks with the installa- surface varnishes are cleaned tion of large steel beams in the up,” he said, referring to the steel building’s courtyard as part of “trees and branches,” as they’ve the structure of the new interim been dubbed, that will support House of Commons Chamber be- the new roof. “You’ll be able to ing topped by a glass-domed roof. walk up to them and touch them. “They’re preparing to install They’re very visible.” the large, tall steel columns that The tops of these “trees and will be essentially holding up the branches” may be visible to pe- new glass roof, so they’re prep- destrians this summer, depending ping the column bases now for on your viewpoint, he added. that and the columns themselves. The “geometry” of the glass- The installation is going to begin domed roof made construction 2 within the next two to three planning to install the steel more weeks,” said Ezio DiMillo, director complicated, said Mr. Koeppelaar, general in the Parliamentary Pre- and they ended up “having to go cinct branch of Public Services through a step-by-step sequential and Procurement, in an interview erection in [the] digital model just to with The Hill Times last week. understand each step, the stability The West Block’s courtyard has of the structure.” This three-dimen- undergone major changes as part of sional model included any “tempo- the estimated $863-million overall rary steel” needed to support the rehabilitation of the historic build- new structure, as well as assessing ing, which fi rst opened in 1865. “which cranes were available, the Workers excavated roughly capacity of the cranes. Some [steel] two-storeys down in order to elements we had to splice in two build-up a new building base in pieces to ensure that they could be the courtyard, including two new erected with the crane.” basement levels, to support a new While it’s more complicated 3 infi ll structure, which is estimated work, Mr. Koeppelaar said his fi rm to cost $115-million. has dealt with “similar challenges” in Steel framing has already the past. For example, it helped con- been installed to shape out the struct the curved-glass wall of the 1. The West Block’s courtyard pictured on April 8, new basement fl oors—the bot- Shaw Centre in downtown Ottawa. 2016. The new concrete fl oor for the courtyard, upon tom level will house mechanical The permanent infi ll structure which the new, permanent infi ll will be built, can be and electrical systems while the will be converted into new com- seen. 2. An artist’s rendering of the interim House top basement level will include mittee rooms once the House of Chamber, which shows the steel ‘trees and branches’ committee rooms, work on both is Commons Chamber returns to the that will support the glass-domed roof. 3. The West ongoing—and concrete has now Centre Block—expected around Block building, and cranes, as pictured April 28, been poured overtop to create a 2028, at this point. 2016. 4. A peak at the stripped down interior of the new ground level in the court- Along with work on the infi ll, West Block, as pictured April 13, 2016. Photographs yard. Mr. Koeppelaar’s fi rm has helped courtesy of Public Services and The Hill Times photograph by The new infi ll—which will also with steel work on the West Block’s Laura Ryckewaert include government and opposi- interior, which was stripped down tion lobbies along with viewing to bare brick as part of renovation galleries—will sit on top of this work. It installed the new steel concrete within the courtyard, and frame required to split the old Con- a glass-domed roof will top the federation Room 200—previously entire courtyard space. This roof used to host special parliamentary will be triple-glazed and include events—back into two fl oors of 4 moveable blinds to help deal with glare from the sun. The sunlight Continued on page 29 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 29 HILL LIFE & PEOPLE PARLIAMENT BUILDINGS

Continued from page 28 to have cost roughly $2.64-billion It’s 100 years old. There are no Asbestos abatement is also part starting with anyone displaced by to date by 2018. The department’s existing, really precise drawings of the overall work required on the work on the Centre Block. 2016-17 report on plans and priori- of the entire building,” said Thierry GCC, as well as seismic upgrades, Members of the House Govern- offi ce space, as per the original ties indicates $510.8-million will be Montpetit, a senior director with though Mr. Montpetit said some ment Operations and Estimates building design. spent on related work this fi scal the Parliamentary Precinct’s reno- heritage feature aspects of the Committee got a tour of the West The West Block hasn’t undergone year, with another $504.7-million vation management and delivery building, namely “the decorative Block and Wellington Building con- major renovations since the 1960s, in planned spending for 2017-18, section at Public Services. plaster” and columns, contain some struction sites on April 14, including and along with the other neo-Gothic and $106-million for 2018-19. All A new, underground visitor’s asbestos and will be left in place. going down into the 20-meter-deep buildings in the Parliamentary Pre- work remains “on time, on scope welcome centre is also being built in “In trying to keep the heritage pit excavated for the West Block cinct, was in dire need of work. and on budget,” according to Public three phases on the Hill, the fi rst of fi nishes we have to balance. It’s section of the new underground Along with seismic upgrades Services. which is being completed as part of very safely incased; there will be visitor’s welcome centre. and the abatement of asbestos Organized in domino-fashion, the West Block rehabilitation project. no exposure,” he said. “It was very interesting to see and other hazardous materials, each major step of the Hill’s reno- Excavation for this fi rst under- “[Once completed] you’ll be it,” said committee member NDP extensive masonry restoration vation depends on the completion ground phase, which started in 2015, able to walk through the north MP Erin Weir (Regina-Lewvan, work was done in the building, of a step before it. In order for the is almost complete, with concrete entrance [of the GCC], walk Sask.), adding a highlight for him including essentially taking it Centre Block to be emptied for pouring for the foundation and walls through the majestic stairs that was being able to see “the top of apart brick-by-brick, numbering renovations in 2018, work on the already “well underway,” according were there before, and see right the Peace Tower from the bottom those to be restored and re- West Block and the nearby Govern- to Public Services. The other two through to the Senate Chamber in of the pit that will be the new visi- turned, and ultimately replacing ment Conference Centre (GCC) at phases will be done in conjunction the background.” tor’s centre.” around 1.4-million bricks. 2 Rideau Street fi rst needs to fi nish. with rehabilitation of the Centre Next up for completion is Liberal MP Nick Whalen (St. Currently, mechanical and The West Block is slated for Block and East Block buildings. the Wellington Building, at the John’s East, N.L.) said it was “a electrical work is ongoing inside completion in 2017, while reha- Meanwhile, work on the GCC corner of Bank and Wellington very interesting walk through the the West Block, and once com- bilitation of the GCC, which will is well underway, including re- streets, which will also serve an West Block,” and seeing where the pleted, building occupants will house the interim Senate Cham- fi tting the old railway station’s important interim function when interim House Chamber will go. enjoy new technologies similar ber, will wrap up in time for the “concourse” space to accommo- renovations begin on the Centre He added that, as a new MP, he to other recently renovated Hill start of the 2018 parliamentary date the interim Senate Chamber. Block, providing 70 parliamentary was unfamiliar with the building, spaces, such as the Valour Build- session—at which point the inter- Structural supports are being offi ces, 10 committee rooms, and a which has been under construc- ing. Steel studs for partitions are im House and Senate Chambers prepared for installation as part new Library of Parliament branch, tion since 2011. also being installed, as are “all of will start being used. Centre Block of that work, including to help among other things. These Reno- From the “concrete slab of the the conduits and so on that are is expected to take about a decade support raised viewing galleries. vations are estimated to cost a fl oor of the Chamber,” he said it required to future-proof the build- to renovate, with work on the East “[In] the concourse, [people] total of $425.2-million, and include “looks like it’s going to be a very ing for IT and security and multi- Block building slated to follow. would embark on the train there, restoration of a unique, Byzantine- impressive, inspirational Chamber.” media,” said Mr. DiMillo. Asbestos Survey stickers are already so it was just a rough cement slab. style mosaic, which adorns the Mr. Whalen also lauded the abatement is “99 per cent done.” visible throughout the Centre We had to prepare that to bring lobby ceiling by the building’s work he saw done inside the Wel- A new Library of Parliament Block building as part of “heritage some conduits and some electrical Wellington Street entrance. lington Building, another space satellite branch is being added to the recording,” which has been ongo- feeds to support the [interim Sen- Public Services is set to hand new to him. “Those murals were West Block, which includes a caf- ing for months and will “con- ate] Chamber,” said Mr. Montpetit. over the building to the House just spectacular,” he said referring eteria. The “Hot Room,” the offi ce for tinue throughout the year,” to help He said “we’re going through of Commons administration this to the building’s lobby mosaic, press gallery members on the Hill, develop a 3-D model to plan the the material choices” for the month, with fi nal fi nishes, system which dates to the 1920s. will also go in the building, but Mr. building’s overall renovation, said interim Chamber with the Senate, tests and other “commissioning” “I think you want people, DiMillo said last week that the loca- Public Services. Some work, like but “something tells me that it work still to take place. Some offi c- when they come to government tion of that space is “being discussed on northern ventilation towers, is probably will be red.” es are already furnished inside the buildings in their capital, to be now” by Public Services and the already underway. Construction work on the GCC, building, which is expected to open inspired, and I think people are House of Commons administration. “We’re doing a fair amount of which followed demolition, began for use in September. Offi ce alloca- going to be very proud with what Public Services’ massive, multi- scanning of the existing building to late last year and includes creating tion will be based on party stand- they see,” he said. billion dollar plan to rehabilitate really try and get a good drawing new basement space, that the old ing in the House and determined [email protected] the Parliamentary Precinct is set basis, because it’s an old building. railway station did not have. by the respective party whips, The Hill Times

CELEBRATING CANADA’S HIGHEST HONOUR IN THE PERFORMING ARTS

CONGRATULATIONS, SUSAN AGLUKARK, 2016 GOVERNOR GENERAL’S PERFORMING ARTS AWARD LAUREATE

“I love the North, I love being an Inuk, I love that history. That’s what I write about.” - Susan Aglukark, singer-songwriter and humanitarian

TICKETS NOW ON SALE Enjoy the red carpet reception, rrr;QWTVKEMGVKPENWFGU the spectacular tribute show with ROCocktails and Canapés surprise performers, and the RO Gala Tribute Performance champagne after party! ROChampagne, Desserts, Dancing

NATIONAL ARTS CENTRE SATURDAY, JUNE 11

0#%$QZ1HƂEGQTPCEEPCECIICYCTFU @govgpaa #ggawards Photo: Denise Grant

PRESENTED BY PRODUCED BY IN PARTNERSHIP WITH WITH THE SUPPORT OF MAJOR SPONSOR ASSOCIATE SPONSORS MEDIA PARTNER THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 29 HILL LIFE & PEOPLE PARLIAMENT BUILDINGS

Continued from page 28 to have cost roughly $2.64-billion It’s 100 years old. There are no Asbestos abatement is also part starting with anyone displaced by to date by 2018. The department’s existing, really precise drawings of the overall work required on the work on the Centre Block. 2016-17 report on plans and priori- of the entire building,” said Thierry GCC, as well as seismic upgrades, Members of the House Govern- offi ce space, as per the original ties indicates $510.8-million will be Montpetit, a senior director with though Mr. Montpetit said some ment Operations and Estimates building design. spent on related work this fi scal the Parliamentary Precinct’s reno- heritage feature aspects of the Committee got a tour of the West The West Block hasn’t undergone year, with another $504.7-million vation management and delivery building, namely “the decorative Block and Wellington Building con- major renovations since the 1960s, in planned spending for 2017-18, section at Public Services. plaster” and columns, contain some struction sites on April 14, including and along with the other neo-Gothic and $106-million for 2018-19. All A new, underground visitor’s asbestos and will be left in place. going down into the 20-meter-deep buildings in the Parliamentary Pre- work remains “on time, on scope welcome centre is also being built in “In trying to keep the heritage pit excavated for the West Block cinct, was in dire need of work. and on budget,” according to Public three phases on the Hill, the fi rst of fi nishes we have to balance. It’s section of the new underground Along with seismic upgrades Services. which is being completed as part of very safely incased; there will be visitor’s welcome centre. and the abatement of asbestos Organized in domino-fashion, the West Block rehabilitation project. no exposure,” he said. “It was very interesting to see and other hazardous materials, each major step of the Hill’s reno- Excavation for this fi rst under- “[Once completed] you’ll be it,” said committee member NDP extensive masonry restoration vation depends on the completion ground phase, which started in 2015, able to walk through the north MP Erin Weir (Regina-Lewvan, work was done in the building, of a step before it. In order for the is almost complete, with concrete entrance [of the GCC], walk Sask.), adding a highlight for him including essentially taking it Centre Block to be emptied for pouring for the foundation and walls through the majestic stairs that was being able to see “the top of apart brick-by-brick, numbering renovations in 2018, work on the already “well underway,” according were there before, and see right the Peace Tower from the bottom those to be restored and re- West Block and the nearby Govern- to Public Services. The other two through to the Senate Chamber in of the pit that will be the new visi- turned, and ultimately replacing ment Conference Centre (GCC) at phases will be done in conjunction the background.” tor’s centre.” around 1.4-million bricks. 2 Rideau Street fi rst needs to fi nish. with rehabilitation of the Centre Next up for completion is Liberal MP Nick Whalen (St. Currently, mechanical and The West Block is slated for Block and East Block buildings. the Wellington Building, at the John’s East, N.L.) said it was “a electrical work is ongoing inside completion in 2017, while reha- Meanwhile, work on the GCC corner of Bank and Wellington very interesting walk through the the West Block, and once com- bilitation of the GCC, which will is well underway, including re- streets, which will also serve an West Block,” and seeing where the pleted, building occupants will house the interim Senate Cham- fi tting the old railway station’s important interim function when interim House Chamber will go. enjoy new technologies similar ber, will wrap up in time for the “concourse” space to accommo- renovations begin on the Centre He added that, as a new MP, he to other recently renovated Hill start of the 2018 parliamentary date the interim Senate Chamber. Block, providing 70 parliamentary was unfamiliar with the building, spaces, such as the Valour Build- session—at which point the inter- Structural supports are being offi ces, 10 committee rooms, and a which has been under construc- ing. Steel studs for partitions are im House and Senate Chambers prepared for installation as part new Library of Parliament branch, tion since 2011. also being installed, as are “all of will start being used. Centre Block of that work, including to help among other things. These Reno- From the “concrete slab of the the conduits and so on that are is expected to take about a decade support raised viewing galleries. vations are estimated to cost a fl oor of the Chamber,” he said it required to future-proof the build- to renovate, with work on the East “[In] the concourse, [people] total of $425.2-million, and include “looks like it’s going to be a very ing for IT and security and multi- Block building slated to follow. would embark on the train there, restoration of a unique, Byzantine- impressive, inspirational Chamber.” media,” said Mr. DiMillo. Asbestos Survey stickers are already so it was just a rough cement slab. style mosaic, which adorns the Mr. Whalen also lauded the abatement is “99 per cent done.” visible throughout the Centre We had to prepare that to bring lobby ceiling by the building’s work he saw done inside the Wel- A new Library of Parliament Block building as part of “heritage some conduits and some electrical Wellington Street entrance. lington Building, another space satellite branch is being added to the recording,” which has been ongo- feeds to support the [interim Sen- Public Services is set to hand new to him. “Those murals were West Block, which includes a caf- ing for months and will “con- ate] Chamber,” said Mr. Montpetit. over the building to the House just spectacular,” he said referring eteria. The “Hot Room,” the offi ce for tinue throughout the year,” to help He said “we’re going through of Commons administration this to the building’s lobby mosaic, press gallery members on the Hill, develop a 3-D model to plan the the material choices” for the month, with fi nal fi nishes, system which dates to the 1920s. will also go in the building, but Mr. building’s overall renovation, said interim Chamber with the Senate, tests and other “commissioning” “I think you want people, DiMillo said last week that the loca- Public Services. Some work, like but “something tells me that it work still to take place. Some offi c- when they come to government tion of that space is “being discussed on northern ventilation towers, is probably will be red.” es are already furnished inside the buildings in their capital, to be now” by Public Services and the already underway. Construction work on the GCC, building, which is expected to open inspired, and I think people are House of Commons administration. “We’re doing a fair amount of which followed demolition, began for use in September. Offi ce alloca- going to be very proud with what Public Services’ massive, multi- scanning of the existing building to late last year and includes creating tion will be based on party stand- they see,” he said. billion dollar plan to rehabilitate really try and get a good drawing new basement space, that the old ing in the House and determined [email protected] the Parliamentary Precinct is set basis, because it’s an old building. railway station did not have. by the respective party whips, The Hill Times

CELEBRATING CANADA’S HIGHEST HONOUR IN THE PERFORMING ARTS

CONGRATULATIONS, SUSAN AGLUKARK, 2016 GOVERNOR GENERAL’S PERFORMING ARTS AWARD LAUREATE

“I love the North, I love being an Inuk, I love that history. That’s what I write about.” - Susan Aglukark, singer-songwriter and humanitarian

TICKETS NOW ON SALE Enjoy the red carpet reception, rrr;QWTVKEMGVKPENWFGU the spectacular tribute show with ROCocktails and Canapés surprise performers, and the RO Gala Tribute Performance champagne after party! ROChampagne, Desserts, Dancing

NATIONAL ARTS CENTRE SATURDAY, JUNE 11

0#%$QZ1HƂEGQTPCEEPCECIICYCTFU @govgpaa #ggawards Photo: Denise Grant

PRESENTED BY PRODUCED BY IN PARTNERSHIP WITH WITH THE SUPPORT OF MAJOR SPONSOR ASSOCIATE SPONSORS MEDIA PARTNER THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 29 HILL LIFE & PEOPLE PARLIAMENT BUILDINGS

Continued from page 28 to have cost roughly $2.64-billion It’s 100 years old. There are no Asbestos abatement is also part starting with anyone displaced by to date by 2018. The department’s existing, really precise drawings of the overall work required on the work on the Centre Block. 2016-17 report on plans and priori- of the entire building,” said Thierry GCC, as well as seismic upgrades, Members of the House Govern- offi ce space, as per the original ties indicates $510.8-million will be Montpetit, a senior director with though Mr. Montpetit said some ment Operations and Estimates building design. spent on related work this fi scal the Parliamentary Precinct’s reno- heritage feature aspects of the Committee got a tour of the West The West Block hasn’t undergone year, with another $504.7-million vation management and delivery building, namely “the decorative Block and Wellington Building con- major renovations since the 1960s, in planned spending for 2017-18, section at Public Services. plaster” and columns, contain some struction sites on April 14, including and along with the other neo-Gothic and $106-million for 2018-19. All A new, underground visitor’s asbestos and will be left in place. going down into the 20-meter-deep buildings in the Parliamentary Pre- work remains “on time, on scope welcome centre is also being built in “In trying to keep the heritage pit excavated for the West Block cinct, was in dire need of work. and on budget,” according to Public three phases on the Hill, the fi rst of fi nishes we have to balance. It’s section of the new underground Along with seismic upgrades Services. which is being completed as part of very safely incased; there will be visitor’s welcome centre. and the abatement of asbestos Organized in domino-fashion, the West Block rehabilitation project. no exposure,” he said. “It was very interesting to see and other hazardous materials, each major step of the Hill’s reno- Excavation for this fi rst under- “[Once completed] you’ll be it,” said committee member NDP extensive masonry restoration vation depends on the completion ground phase, which started in 2015, able to walk through the north MP Erin Weir (Regina-Lewvan, work was done in the building, of a step before it. In order for the is almost complete, with concrete entrance [of the GCC], walk Sask.), adding a highlight for him including essentially taking it Centre Block to be emptied for pouring for the foundation and walls through the majestic stairs that was being able to see “the top of apart brick-by-brick, numbering renovations in 2018, work on the already “well underway,” according were there before, and see right the Peace Tower from the bottom those to be restored and re- West Block and the nearby Govern- to Public Services. The other two through to the Senate Chamber in of the pit that will be the new visi- turned, and ultimately replacing ment Conference Centre (GCC) at phases will be done in conjunction the background.” tor’s centre.” around 1.4-million bricks. 2 Rideau Street fi rst needs to fi nish. with rehabilitation of the Centre Next up for completion is Liberal MP Nick Whalen (St. Currently, mechanical and The West Block is slated for Block and East Block buildings. the Wellington Building, at the John’s East, N.L.) said it was “a electrical work is ongoing inside completion in 2017, while reha- Meanwhile, work on the GCC corner of Bank and Wellington very interesting walk through the the West Block, and once com- bilitation of the GCC, which will is well underway, including re- streets, which will also serve an West Block,” and seeing where the pleted, building occupants will house the interim Senate Cham- fi tting the old railway station’s important interim function when interim House Chamber will go. enjoy new technologies similar ber, will wrap up in time for the “concourse” space to accommo- renovations begin on the Centre He added that, as a new MP, he to other recently renovated Hill start of the 2018 parliamentary date the interim Senate Chamber. Block, providing 70 parliamentary was unfamiliar with the building, spaces, such as the Valour Build- session—at which point the inter- Structural supports are being offi ces, 10 committee rooms, and a which has been under construc- ing. Steel studs for partitions are im House and Senate Chambers prepared for installation as part new Library of Parliament branch, tion since 2011. also being installed, as are “all of will start being used. Centre Block of that work, including to help among other things. These Reno- From the “concrete slab of the the conduits and so on that are is expected to take about a decade support raised viewing galleries. vations are estimated to cost a fl oor of the Chamber,” he said it required to future-proof the build- to renovate, with work on the East “[In] the concourse, [people] total of $425.2-million, and include “looks like it’s going to be a very ing for IT and security and multi- Block building slated to follow. would embark on the train there, restoration of a unique, Byzantine- impressive, inspirational Chamber.” media,” said Mr. DiMillo. Asbestos Survey stickers are already so it was just a rough cement slab. style mosaic, which adorns the Mr. Whalen also lauded the abatement is “99 per cent done.” visible throughout the Centre We had to prepare that to bring lobby ceiling by the building’s work he saw done inside the Wel- A new Library of Parliament Block building as part of “heritage some conduits and some electrical Wellington Street entrance. lington Building, another space satellite branch is being added to the recording,” which has been ongo- feeds to support the [interim Sen- Public Services is set to hand new to him. “Those murals were West Block, which includes a caf- ing for months and will “con- ate] Chamber,” said Mr. Montpetit. over the building to the House just spectacular,” he said referring eteria. The “Hot Room,” the offi ce for tinue throughout the year,” to help He said “we’re going through of Commons administration this to the building’s lobby mosaic, press gallery members on the Hill, develop a 3-D model to plan the the material choices” for the month, with fi nal fi nishes, system which dates to the 1920s. will also go in the building, but Mr. building’s overall renovation, said interim Chamber with the Senate, tests and other “commissioning” “I think you want people, DiMillo said last week that the loca- Public Services. Some work, like but “something tells me that it work still to take place. Some offi c- when they come to government tion of that space is “being discussed on northern ventilation towers, is probably will be red.” es are already furnished inside the buildings in their capital, to be now” by Public Services and the already underway. Construction work on the GCC, building, which is expected to open inspired, and I think people are House of Commons administration. “We’re doing a fair amount of which followed demolition, began for use in September. Offi ce alloca- going to be very proud with what Public Services’ massive, multi- scanning of the existing building to late last year and includes creating tion will be based on party stand- they see,” he said. billion dollar plan to rehabilitate really try and get a good drawing new basement space, that the old ing in the House and determined [email protected] the Parliamentary Precinct is set basis, because it’s an old building. railway station did not have. by the respective party whips, The Hill Times

CELEBRATING CANADA’S HIGHEST HONOUR IN THE PERFORMING ARTS

CONGRATULATIONS, SUSAN AGLUKARK, 2016 GOVERNOR GENERAL’S PERFORMING ARTS AWARD LAUREATE

“I love the North, I love being an Inuk, I love that history. That’s what I write about.” - Susan Aglukark, singer-songwriter and humanitarian

TICKETS NOW ON SALE Enjoy the red carpet reception, rrr;QWTVKEMGVKPENWFGU the spectacular tribute show with ROCocktails and Canapés surprise performers, and the RO Gala Tribute Performance champagne after party! ROChampagne, Desserts, Dancing

NATIONAL ARTS CENTRE SATURDAY, JUNE 11

0#%$QZ1HƂEGQTPCEEPCECIICYCTFU @govgpaa #ggawards Photo: Denise Grant

PRESENTED BY PRODUCED BY IN PARTNERSHIP WITH WITH THE SUPPORT OF MAJOR SPONSOR ASSOCIATE SPONSORS MEDIA PARTNER 32 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 THE SPIN DOCTORS By Laura Ryckewaert TUESDAY, MAY 17 NATIONAL ARTS CENTRE “Does Canada need a national pipeline strategy? Why or why not?”

That is why we have committed to restore public trust in our environmental assess- TRAVERS ments and the National Energy Board. KATE We will better engage Canadians, conduct PURCHASE in-depth consultations with Indigenous Liberal strategist Peoples, and ensure decisions are based on DEBATES science, facts, and evidence. “To attract new investments, expand to

2016 “One of the fundamental responsibili- new markets, and receive fair value for our ties of any Canadian government is to get commodities, we must sustainably develop Canadian resources to market. In the 21st our energy sector. We will not follow the century, getting our resources to market lead of the previous government. We know means doing it sustainably and responsi- that the economy and environment go hand- bly, and in partnership with Indigenous in-hand. We will grow the economy—get our Peoples and impacted communities. resources to market—and increase our pros- Is democracy in trouble with “Without the trust of Canadians’, none of perity, while we protect the environment the decline of legacy media? these pipeline projects will move forward. and preserve our planet for posterity.” removing over-reliance on foreign oil. “The construction and maintenance of a pipeline means people are working, it Challenges facing traditional media in a digital world have CORY means they can provide for their families, HANN and it means contributing towards growing some fearing for the democratic process itself, worrying our economy. An ideological, anti-resource Conservative strategist agenda does not make Canada better, it that every newspaper or broadcasting layoff lessens the makes us worse off. If we can’t rely on the “Please, for the sake of everyone and prime minister to support Canadian jobs and foundation of an informed public. everything, let’s not encourage the Liberals support our economy, what can we rely on? to have another National Strategy on some- “His waffl ing on this has put the entire Bruce Anderson, Chairman, thing—especially one that relates to ‘energy.’ sector into chaos. Energy infrastructure “Here’s what Canada needs: We need a projects no longer fi nd it good enough to Abacus Data, and Ed Greenspon, Prime Minister and a government that is go through a rigorous process of fact-based going to stand up for the resource sector, assessments, approvals, and consultations. President of the Public Policy and see pipelines for what they are and Now they have to try to catch the prime min- what they provide to Canada—quality ister and his government feeling generous on Forum, will debate whether this jobs, getting our resources to market, and a good day, and hope for the best.”

is a valid concern, and whether overturn a ‘no’ recommendation from the NEB? cutting edge new media are What will climate impacts be measured against given the government has no targets—what’s changing the game in ways that RICCARDO a passing grade? What about the lack of cross examination in NEB hearings that have already the old media will not be missed. FILIPPONE happened—how will that be fi xed? Why is there NDP strategist no funding for general public participation? “For ten years we watched Stephen And join our fearless fun debate Harper—a prime minster repeatedly trying “What the Liberal government needs is to impose his views—and we have seen this teams as they tackle the a truly revamped pipeline review process. approach fail time and again. “The ‘new’ pipeline review process The Government needs a fair and question of House decorum. the Liberals brought in falls far short of thorough review process that addresses en- Scott Feschuk and Ruth Ellen what they committed to on the campaign vironmental concerns, allows for full public trail. Rather than scrapping the discredited participation, and looks at value-added jobs. Brosseau trade trenchant bon Conservative process—they simply layered That’s how you arrive at social license. their own on top of it—leaving us with more “The vague additions they tried to sub- mots with Katie Simpson and questions than answers. stitute for a genuinely new pipeline review “Are they keeping Cabinet’s ability to process just isn’t going to cut it.” Rodger Cuzner in arguing the “Canada must look to the future and invest pros and cons of the resolution in renewable energies. Unfortunately, the funds earmarked in the budget are not suffi cient “Heckling is a parliamentary to allow the government to create a real plan MATHIEU R. that will allow a realistic energy transition. A privilege and should be ST-AMAND number of provinces, including Quebec, have already begun this transition and need all the maintained.” Bloc Québécois strategist fi nancial resources possible to make this shift. “What Canada really needs is an en- Most of these resources are in Ottawa and are ergy transition plan. It is no longer time being used to support fossil fuels. It’s all in aid of raising funds for the R. James Travers to build pipelines and increase fossil fuel “In short, Canada must abandon the oil Foreign Corresponding Fellowship, created to honour production. However, if Canada decides to industry in favour of companies innovating continue to develop fossil fuels by means in the fi eld of renewable energy and energy the late Jim Travers. The last three Travers Debates have been of pipelines, this will simply demonstrate effi ciency. Even Saudi Arabia has realized once again that the economic interests of that the future lies in renewable energy; the sell-outs and tickets are selling quickly again for this year. Canada and Quebec are diametrically op- country recently announced a multi-billion posed. dollar plan to reduce its dependence on oil.” Don’t be disappointed — buy today! a ticking time bomb. Diluent mixed with bitumen literally cannot be cleaned up because both are threats, yet spills are PRESENTED BY CAMILLE unavoidable. The only question is whether MAY 17 LABCHUK they will be devastating or catastrophic. “But we can do better. We urgently need Green strategist NATIONAL ARTS CENTRE to calm the mania for shipping raw bitumen out of the oil sands. So why not keep the “We defi nitely need to get our act oil sands at current levels and process the Tickets are $125 and together when it comes to pipelines, and bitumen domestically before shipping it to more broadly the oil sands. It’s not just market? Refi ning it here at home will create available only at about the pipeline—it’s about what’s in the Canadian jobs instead of shipping them else- pipeline. We seem to fi nd ourselves in the where, and transporting a refi ned product traversdebates.ca midst of a mania for shipping raw bitumen is much less dangerous than transporting out of the oil sands. A pipeline containing bitumen. And if we transport it by rail, we’re dilbit—bitumen mixed with diluent—is decreasing the risk of a catastrophic spill.” THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 33 FEATURE EVENTS

Melanoma Mon- please contact Sara Thaw ([email protected]). day Skin Cancer The Canadian Dental Association’s (CDA) Days Parliamentary Screening Clinic on the Hill—May 10 and 11. CDA’s Days on the Hill and Reception— connects leaders from Canada’s 21,000 dentists with Calendar parliamentarians to discuss important issues pertaining House Speaker to oral health. The CDA is the national voice for dentistry Geoff Regan, left, in Canada and is dedicated to the promotion of optimal Liberal MP Bill oral health for Canadians. For further information, please Casey, and the Ca- contact Bonnie Kirkwood at [email protected] nadian Dermatolo- An Evening with the Canadian Dental Association gy Association will Tuesday May 10—The Canadian Dental Association (CDA) invites you to its annual Parliamentary reception for friends be hosting a skin of the dental profession, parliamentarians, and staff on cancer screening Tuesday May 10th at 5:30 p.m. at the Métropolitain clinic and recep- restaurant. Refreshments will be provided. To RSVP, please tion on Monday, contact Bonnie Kirkwood at [email protected] May 2, 3 p.m. to Launch of the Rio Tinto Award for Indigenous Stu- 6 p.m. in 216-N, dents—A reception co-hosted by Rio Tinto, Canada’s largest Centre Block. The mining and metals business, and Indspire, an indigenous-led Melanoma charity that invests in the education of indigenous people, Hill Times pho- celebrating the launch of the Rio Tinto Award for Indigenous Monday on the tographs by Jake Students. The reception is a chance for parliamentarians and Wright industry stakeholders to meet and mingle with indigenous fi nancial award recipients in order to learn their experiences Hill May 2 and celebrate indigenous education in Canada. Alfredo Barrios, chief executive of Rio Tinto Aluminum; Roberta Jamieson, president and CEO of Indspire; Indspire fi nancial award recipients; MPs and Senators; industry stakeholders, May 10, 5:30 p.m.-7:30 p.m. Drawing Room, Fairmont MONDAY, MAY 2 p.m., Daly’s Restaurant, The Westin Ottawa Hotel. Speakers include Peter Mantas, Dr. Youssef Youssef, David Chateau Laurier Hotel, 1 Rideau St. Ottawa. RSVP to Laura Seguin [email protected] or call 613- Kilgour, Allan Cutler, Cindy Blackstock, and Andy Bryce. WEDNESDAY, MAY 11 House Sitting— The House returns May 2 for 235-1400. For more information, call Allan Cutler at 613-293-4671. three weeks and will every weekday until May 20, it The Society of Composers, Authors and Music Pub- Liberal Caucus Meeting—The Liberals will meet in breaks for one week, and returns again on May 30. It’s lishers of Canada (SOCAN)—Invites all parliamentar- TUESDAY, MAY 10 Room 237-C Centre Block on Parliament Hill. For more scheduled to sit for four weeks until Thursday, June 23, ians and staff to come celebrate Canadian music talent Hill Times Event: Women in Finance—Small Business information, please call Liberal Party media relations at when it breaks for the summer. at a reception and special live performances by Karim and Tourism Minister Bardish Chagger will speak at this [email protected] or 613-627-2384. Reclaiming the Blue Helmet: Canada’s Role in Ouellet and Sam Roberts on May 3 in the Aboriginal event. 7:30 a.m.-9 a.m., Ottawa Marriott Hotel, 100 Kent Conservative Caucus Meeting—The Conservatives will Peacekeeping and UN Accountability—The Human Peoples Committee Room 160-S in Centre Block from St., Ottawa. Free for Hill Times subscribers and $20 for meet for their national caucus meeting. For more informa- Rights Research and Education Centre presents a dis- 5:30 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. The event will showcase music non-subscribers. Panellists include: Caroline Hubberstey, tion, contact Cory Hann, director of communications, tinguished panel (Stephen Lewis, Peggy Mason, Mario performances from English and French top-chart art- head of external relations at Acxsys Corporation/Interac Conservative Party of Canada at [email protected] Joseph & Beatrice Lindstrom) discussing account- ists. RSVP by April 29 to [email protected] Association; Caroline Riseboro, CEO Plan Canada Inter- NDP Caucus Meeting—The NDP caucus will meet ability and other challenges facing UN Peacekeeping Movie Night on the Hill—Heritage Minister Mélanie national; Victoria Lennox, co-founder and CEO Startup from 9:15 a.m.-11 a.m. in Room 112-N Centre Block, and how a re-engaged Canada can show leadership in Joly will host along with Telefi lm Canada, her fi rst Move Canada; and Sharon Connolly, vice-president Business on Wednesday. Please call the NDP Media Centre at addressing them. Opening remarks by Allan Rock. More Night on the Hill on May 3, the Canadian Screen and Development Bank of Canada. The discussion will be 613-222-2351 or [email protected] info: http://cdp-hrc.uottawa.ca/ Fauteux Hall, FTX147 Oscar Award winner, Room. 7 p.m., Canadian Museum moderated by Power & Infl uence editor Ally Foster. Canadian Rail Summit 2016—Canadian Rail Summit (University of Ottawa, 57 Louis Pasteur). May 2, 5 of History, 100 Laurier St., Gatineau, Que. CCSA Hosting Communications Services Recep- 2016, Canada’s leading rail event. Explore cutting-edge p.m.-7 p.m. Free. The Canadian Alliance on Mental Illness and Mental tion—The Canadian Cable Systems Alliance (CCSA), which products and services from 50 tradeshow exhibitors, and Electoral Reform in 2016—NDP MP Nathan Cullen Health—Celebrates the 14th annual Champions of Mental represents 120 independent and entrepreneurial cable, choose from a wide variety of technical and conference and Conservative MP Scott Reid will talk about electoral Health Awards recognizing individuals and organizations telephone and internet companies, is hosting a reception in sessions on key industry issues such as competitiveness, reform in 2016. Hear what the NDP and Conservative whose outstanding contributions have advanced the the Commonwealth Room in Centre Block, May 10, from 5 safety and emerging technologies. Register at www.railcan. critics have to say about keeping the Liberal govern- mental health agenda in Canada in the past year. The gala p.m.-7 p.m. All Senators, Members of Parliament and staff ca/crs2016 and for more information, contact Janet Greene ment accountable as their voting reform initiative goes takes place on May 3, at the Shaw Centre in Ottawa start- are invited to attend and better familiarize themselves with at 613-564-8109 [email protected] or Lynn Raby at 613- forward. Let’s build a politically legitimate reform that ing with a reception at 5:30 p.m. followed by dinner and our nation’s communications service providers. For more 237-3888 or [email protected] works for all parties and all Canadians. May 2, Fair Vote the awards ceremony at 6:30 p.m. The award recipients information or to RSVP, please contact Cynthia Waldmeier Fit for purpose? CSO Transformation for Agenda 2030— Canada local chapter AGM; open to public; free admis- include Status of Women Minister Patty Hajdu, Curtis at 613-233-8906 or [email protected]. The Canadian Council for International Co-operation (CCIC) sion. Tom Brown Arena, 141 Bayview Rd. Doors open Bishop, the Centre d’expertise Marie-Vincent, the Globe Canada at the World Humanitarian Summit: Opportu- is hosting its annual conference on May 11 and May 12 at 6:30 pm, AGM business 7 p.m.-8 p.m.; speakers 8 p.m. and Mail’s Erin Anderssen, Queen’s University’s Heather nities for Leadership & Legacy—The Canadian Council for the Wabano Centre for Aboriginal Health. The 2016 CCIC CPAWS Talks: Nature Needs Half—An exciting Stuart, Ontario Shores Centre for Mental Health Sciences, International Co-operation (CCIC), the Canadian Associa- annual conference seeks to raise the profi le of the Canadian evening that blends science and art, featuring keynote and Bishop Ryan’s Celtic Circle Student Leadership Club. tion of International Development Professionals (CAIDP), international development and humanitarian assistance speaker international award-winning conservationist CTV’s Kevin Newman is the master of ceremonies. For and the School of International Development and Global sector and its important work. This landmark event brings and visionary Harvey Locke and nature rap artist Baba more information, please visit camimh.ca. Studies (SIDGS) are co-hosting a public event at the together stakeholders from international development and hu- Brinkman, as we explore the importance of large- WEDNESDAY, MAY 4 Library & Archives (395 Wellington St.), May 10, 5:30 manitarian civil society organizations (CSOs), key government landscape conservation and why Nature Needs Half. p.m.-9 p.m. The event includes a humanitarian expert offi cials, relevant policy makers and academics from Canada Monday, May 2, 7 p.m.– 9:30 p.m. at the Library and Liberal Caucus Meeting—The Liberals will meet in panel, a political response panel, networking reception, and abroad. ‘Fit for purpose: CSO transformation for Agenda Archives Canada Auditorium. The evening will also Room 237-C Centre Block on Parliament Hill. For more and a humanitarian fair. The event is free and open to 2030’ will examine the challenges and opportunities facing include local Ottawa/Gatineau artists, door prizes, and information, please call Liberal Party media relations at the public –register on Eventbrite. For more information CSOs in this new era of global development cooperation. For a silent auction! Come bid on an evening at Cirque du [email protected] or 613-627-2384. more info see: www.ccic.ca. Follow #intlcoopdays on Twitter. Soleil, outdoor gear from MEC, a night at the Wakefi eld Conservative Caucus Meeting—The Conservatives will Mill and so much more! Tickets: www.cpaws.org meet for their national caucus meeting. For more informa- TUESDAY, MAY 3 tion, contact Cory Hann, director of communications, Conservative Party of Canada at [email protected] Cabinet Meeting—Prime Minister Justin Trudeau NDP Caucus Meeting—The NDP caucus will meet is expected to hold a Cabinet meeting today in Ottawa. from 9:15 a.m.-11 a.m. in Room 112-N Centre Block, For more information, call the PMO Press Offi ce at on Wednesday. Please call the NDP Media Centre at 613-957-5555. 613-222-2351 or [email protected] Auditor General to Table Spring Reports—Audi- The Canadian International Council (CIC) National tor General Michael Ferguson will release the spring Capital Branch: An Evening with Lord David Owen on reports on May 3. The reports will cover: venture capital Why the UK Should Leave the European Union—David action plan; detecting and preventing fraud in the citi- Owen is one of the U.K.’s most distinguished political zenship program; the governor in council appointments fi gures and public intellectuals. He is a former U.K. process in administration tribunals; drug benefi ts and foreign secretary and EU peace negotiator in the former Veterans Affairs Canada; Canadian Army Reserve- Yugoslavia. It is a signifi cant development in the cur- National Defence; and a special examinations of PPP rent U.K. referendum campaign that he has decided Canada Inc. and Via Rail Canada Inc. There will be a his country should leave the EU. June 23 is the date media lockup 6 a.m.-9:45 a.m., Offi ce of the Auditor of the referendum, and Lord Owen has dramatically General of Canada, 240 Sparks St., followed by a news entered the debate with a new book Europe Restruc- conference at 11:30 a.m.-12:15 p.m. at the National tured, Vote to Leave. May 4, 5 p.m. (registration and Press Theatre, 150 Wellington St., Ottawa. cash bar); 6 p.m. (presentation begins), Rideau Room, Ovarian Cancer Canada Lobby Day—Ovarian Cancer Sheraton Hotel, 150 Albert Street, Ottawa, ottawa@ Canada will be in Ottawa on May 3 meeting with thecic.org or 613-903-4011 Members of Parliament to raise awareness of World The Ottawa-Orleans PC Association Reception—The Ovarian Cancer Day (May 8), and the need to do more Ottawa-Orleans PC Association is holding a recep- for women living with ovarian cancer and those that will tion featuring Conservative MPs Jason Kenney and be diagnosed in the future. In particular, the group will Tony Clement. The event will take place at the HMCS be asking politicians to support Bill S-201 (also known Bytown Naval Mess 78 Lisgar St., May 4, 6 p.m. For as the Genetic Non-Discrimination Act) fi rst tabled in tickets go to www.orleanspc.com. Contact: parkinsonda- the Senate by Senator James Cowan and expected to [email protected] for more information. be introduced in the House of Commons in early May. 18th Annual World Press Freedom Day Awards THURSDAY, MAY 5 Luncheon—At the Château Laurier Ballroom at 11:30 The Canadian Nurses Foundation—will host its an- a.m. Keynote speaker will be Suzanne Legault, Canada’s nual Nightingale Gala to celebrate Canada’s nurses and information commissioner. The CCWPF Press Freedom support indigenous nursing education and research on Award will go to a Canadian journalist who has made an May 5 at the Shaw Centre. The reception takes place at outstanding contribution to press freedom or freedom 5:30 p.m. followed by dinner at 7 p.m. Sophie Grégoire of expression, or suffered in their name in the past year. Trudeau is an honorary patron and will speak at the Celebrate the work of cartoonists from around the world gala. For more information please visit: http://cnf-fi ic. in the 16th Annual Editorial Cartoon Contest. Tickets are ca/2016-gala/ $65 or $120 for two, $480 for a table of eight. Nestlé Canada Parliamentary Reception—All parlia- SATURDAY, MAY 7 mentarians are invited to join Nestlé Canada’s business Second Annual Anti-Corruption Symposium—Orga- leaders from across the country to celebrate 150 years nized by the Canadians for Accountability, the symposium of Nestlé ‘Good Food, Good Life’. May 3, 5:30 p.m.-8 is free. The day starts at 9 a.m. and ends at 2:45 p.m. 34 THE HILL TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 2, 2016 FEATURE EVENTS

education author Jeff Selingo and ESDC deputy min- Parliamentary ister Ian Shugart. The conference will be held on May 12 and 13, 2016 at Humber College in Toronto, Ont. Calendar For more information visit polytechnicscanada.ca. Movie Night on Ottawa Branch Monarchist League of Canada the Hill—Heritage Celebrates Queen’s 90th Birthday—Senator Serge Joyal will deliver an address ‘Canada’s Constitutional Mon- Minister Mélanie archy: Honougin a Lifetime of Service by Her Majesty, Joly will host her Queen Elizabeth II, Queen of Canada. NAC director of fi rst Movie Night communications Rosemary Thompson will emcee. The on Hill along with event is sold out. Telefi lm Canada, TUESDAY, MAY 17 the Canadian Screen and Oscar Travers Debates—Maclean’s iconoclastic humourist Scott Feschuk, journalist Katie Simpson, and Liberal Award winner, MP Rodger Cuzner and NDP MP Ruth Ellen Brosseau Room. May 3, 7 are all going to be on the same stage May 17, at the p.m., Canadian It’s movie NAC. Register at www.traversdebates.ca Museum of History, Merit Canada Reception—Métropolitain Brasserie 100 Laurier St., & Restaurant, 700 Sussex Dr., May 17, 5 p.m.-8 p.m. Gatineau, Que. night on the RSVP to [email protected] The Hill Times The Forest Sector: Contributing to Climate Change Solutions—The Forest Products Association of Canada and photograph by Jake Hill May 3 FPInnovations will be holding a reception on Wednesday, Wright May 18 to showcase how the forest products industry is using clean tech and innovation to pave the way to a low- carbon economy. The event, which will include leaders from industry and government, will be held at the Rideau Club, 99 Bank St., Ottawa, between 5:30 p.m. and 7 p.m. For Continued from page 33 more information, please contact [email protected] THURSDAY, MAY 26, 2016 WEDNESDAY, MAY 11 Liberal Biennial Convention—The federal Liberals Talent for Innovation: Harnessing Canada’s Re- will hold their convention in Winnipeg, Man., Thursday, search Advantage—Join Mitacs and leaders from busi- May 26, to Sunday, May 29, 2016. ness, government, and academia to examine strategies Conservative Convention—The federal Conserva- to effectively engage and employ research innovators. tives will hold their convention in Vancouver, B.C., May Tuesday, May 11, National Arts Centre, Ottawa. Forum: 26 to May 29, 2016. 1 p.m.-4:30 p.m., and reception 4:30 p.m.-6 p.m. SATURDAY, JUNE 4 THURSDAY, MAY 12 Parliamentary Press Gallery Dinner—It’s the 150th Bacon & Eggheads Breakfast, Thursday May 12— Anniversary of the Press Gallery at its Annual Gallery PAGSE presents a bilingual talk ‘Keeping Food Avail- Dinner, Saturday, June 4, 5:30 p.m., Canadian Museum offi cials from the lead departments and agencies will or renew them in order to vote. For more information, able and Affordable: A 21st Century Challenge’ with of History, River View Salon. The dinner will be held in be at the networking reception. There will be exhibitors, contact Cory Hann, director of communications, Conser- Jean Caron, Université Laval. Thursday, May 12, the Grand Hall at 7 p.m. Dress: cocktail elegant (black subject matter experts representing both the public and vative Party of Canada, at 613-697-5614. 7:30 a.m. Parliamentary Dining Room, Centre Block. tie optional). For press gallery members and guests only. private sectors. Please contact CIPMM Secretariat at The Parliamentary Calendar is a free listing. Send No charge to MPs, Senators , and media. All others, [email protected] or at 613-725-0980. in your political, cultural, or governmental event in a $25. Pre-registration required by Monday, May 9 by TUESDAY, JUNE 7 MAY 2017 paragraph with all the relevant details under the sub- contacting Donna Boag, PAGSE [email protected] or Registration Now Open CIPMM’s 27th Annual Na- ject line ‘Parliamentary Calendar’ to news@hilltimes. call 613-991-6369. tional Workshop—June 7-8, 2016. The workshop fee is Conservative Party Leadership Convention—The Con- com by Wednesday at noon before the Monday paper. Polytechnics Canada Annual Policy Conference— $875 plus HST and includes access to all keynote and servatives will elect their next leader on May 27, 2017, Or fax it to 613-232-9055. We can’t guarantee inclu- This year’s conference theme is “Learning that Works: breakout sessions. More than 400 delegates from PW- Dan Nowlan, chair of the party’s leadership election sion of every event, but we will defi nitely do our best. Polytechnic Education.” Speakers include disruptive GSC, ESD, DND, HC, RCMP, CSEC, DFATD, DFO, TBS, organizing committee announced last week. The party is [email protected] innovation expert Michael Horn, best-selling higher NRCan, IC, AAND, CIC, and LAC. Senior government urging Conservative Party members to buy memberships The Hill Times

Canada at the World Humanitarian Summit: Opportunities for Leadership & Legacy

Join us for a dynamic and thought-provoking discussion on today's global humanitarian challenges! Panelists will unpack the humanitarian space, highlight key concerns and challenges, make humanitarian policy and practice recommendations for the Canadian Government, and provide guid- ance on the World Humanitarian Summit objectives.

May 10th, 2016 Introductory remarks by H.E. Selçuk Ünal, Turkish Ambassador to Canada Moderated by Susan Ormiston , Senior Correspondent | CBC 5:30-9:00PM

Humanitarian expert panel Susan Johnson: Vice President and Director General International Operations & Movement Relations | Canada Red Cross Dr. James Orbinksi:  ‡•‡ƒ” ŠŠƒ‹”Ƭ”‘ˆ‡••‘”‹ Ž‘„ƒŽ ‡ƒŽ–ŠȁƒŽ•‹ŽŽ‹‡ Š‘‘Ž‘ˆ –‡”ƒ–‹‘ƒŽơƒ‹”• Library & Archives Political response panel 395 Wellington St. ––ƒ™ƒǡ Pamela Goldsmith-Jones: ƒ”Ž‹ƒ‡–ƒ”›‡ ”‡–ƒ”›–‘–Š‡‹‹•–‡”‘ˆ ‘”‡‹‰ơƒ‹”•| Liberal Party of Canada Tony Clement: ”‹–‹ ˆ‘” ‘”‡‹‰ơƒ‹”•ȁ‘•‡”˜ƒ–‹˜‡ƒ”–›‘ˆƒƒ†ƒ Hélène Laverdière: ”‹–‹ ˆ‘” ‘”‡‹‰ơƒ‹”•ȁ‡™‡‘ ”ƒ–‹ ƒ”–›‘ˆƒƒ†ƒ Elizabeth May: Leader | Green Party of Canada FREE Public Event ϯ ϭ Ϯ Reception & Reception & Expert & Political Panels Humanitarian Fair Humanitarian Fair 5:30-6:30PM 6:30-8:00PM 8:00-9:00PM

REGISTER! Eventbrite: “Humanitarian Public Event” CANADA’S GLOBAL DEFENCE & SECURITY TRADE SHOW MAY 25-26, 2016 EY Centre, Ottawa

Parliamentarians reserve your CANSEC 2016 tour today: [email protected]

352'8&('%<

#CANSEC2016 Canadian Association of Defence and defenceandsecurity.ca Security Industries canseccanada.ca