DOCSLIB.ORG

Do No Harm in Nepal

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Do No Harm in Nepal DO NO HARM PROJECT Do No Harm in Nepal October 2006 Peter Bauman Winifred Fitzgerald This document was developed as part of a collaborative learning project directed by CDA. It is part of a collection of documents that should be considered initial and partial findings of the project. These documents are written to allow for the identification of cross-cutting issues and themes across a range of situations. Each case represents the views and perspectives of a variety of people at the time when it was written. These documents do not represent a final product of the project. While these documents may be cited, they remain working documents of a collaborative learning effort. Broad generalizations about the project’s findings cannot be made from a single case. CDA would like to acknowledge the generosity of the individuals and agencies involved in donating their time, experience and insights for these reports, and for their willingness to share their experiences. Not all the documents written for any project have been made public. When people in the area where a report has been done have asked us to protect their anonymity and security, in deference to them and communities involved, we keep those documents private 1 Table of Contents LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ......................................................................................................................2 1. INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................................1 2. METHODOLOGY ..............................................................................................................................1 3. CONFLICT IN NEPAL .........................................................................................................................2 4. THE HISTORY OF DNH IN NEPAL .......................................................................................................5 5. UNDERSTANDING, INTEGRATION, AND APPLICATION OF DNH IN NEPAL ........................................... 6 BUILDING CONFIDENCE ........................................................................................................................... 10 APPLYING THE TOOL ............................................................................................................................... 11 ADAPTING THE TOOL .............................................................................................................................. 13 GENERATING OPTIONS ............................................................................................................................ 14 FACTORS THAT ENHANCE OR INHIBIT THE UPTAKE AND APPLICATION OF DNH ................................................... 17 6. DNH TRAINING .............................................................................................................................. 20 CURRENT APPROACH TO TRAINING ........................................................................................................... 20 WORKSHOP PARTICIPANTS – DETERMINING WHO PARTICIPATES IN A DNH TRAINING ...................................... 21 DNH TRAINING METHODOLOGY............................................................................................................... 21 TRAINING CONTENT ................................................................................................................................ 22 MENTORING AND FOLLOW UP SUPPORT .................................................................................................... 24 RESOURCES ........................................................................................................................................... 24 MOTIVATION & INCENTIVE ...................................................................................................................... 24 7. POLITICAL RESISTANCE AND CONSTRAINTS TO DNH IN NEPAL ........................................................ 25 8. DO NO HARM AT THE MACRO LEVEL .............................................................................................. 26 9. RELEVANCE OF DNH IN THE “NEW NEPAL CONTEXT” ...................................................................... 29 APPENDIX A—CONFLICT IN THE TERAI ............................................................................................... 32 APPENDIX B—REFERENCES ................................................................................................................ 34 APPENDIX C—FRAMEWORK .............................................................................................................. 34 APPENDIX D—BASIC OPERATING GUIDELINES ................................................................................... 38 1 List of Abbreviations ADRA Adventist Development and Releif Agency AIN Association for International NGOs BOGS Basic Operating Guidelines CBO Community-Based Organization CDA Collaborative Development Alternatives CECI Canadian Centre for International Studies and Cooperation CIDA Canadian International Development Agency CPA Comprehensive Peace Agreement CPN/M Communist Party of Nepal / Maoists DDC District Development Committee DLA District Line Agency DFID Department for International Development DNH Do No Harm GON Government of Nepal GTZ German Technical Organization HURDEC Human Resource Development Center IEM Implicit Ethical Message LCPP Local Capacities for Peace Project LDTA Local Development Training Academy NGO Non-Governmental Organization PPR Forum for Protection of People's Rights PVSE Poor, Vulnerable and Socially Excluded RBA Rights-Based Approach RMO Risk Management Office RNA Royal Nepal Army SCF Save the Children Foundation SDC Swiss Agency for Development and Corporation SPA Seven Party Alliance ToT Training of Trainer UN United Nations UNMIN United Nations Mission in Nepal UPF United People’s Front USAID United States Agency for International Development UG User Group VDC Village Development Committee YCL Young Communist League 2 1. Introduction The Do No Harm Project (DNH), originally called Local Capacities for Peace (LCP), began in the mid- 1990s. It was designed to help those involved in humanitarian and development work better understand their potential and actual impacts so they can avoid causing greater tension and can intervene in ways that complement local mechanisms for mitigating conflict. In 2006, the Do No Harm Project set out to determine how DNH was being used in the world and whether that use was leading to more effective programming decisions. A series of Reflective Case Studies was written in multiple countries to determine how practitioners in those places are learning, thinking about, using and spreading DNH. Some organizations are experienced and effective in applying Do No Harm principles and framework to their work, while others are struggling. This range of experience provides valuable lessons. Whether implementing Do No Harm in their daily work, in their program design and monitoring, or in shaping policies and organizational procedures, the cases look at where in their work people find it easy to use Do No Harm, where they find roadblocks, and how (or if) they overcame them. As part of this process, Peter Bauman and Winifred Fitzgerald, independent consultants commissioned by CDA, traveled to Nepal to complete the Nepal DNH case study. This report highlights the major themes and questions that emerged during these interviews and field visits. The paper is divided into several sequential parts beginning with an overview of the case study methodology followed by a brief analysis of the conflict in Nepal. The third section outlines the history of DNH in Nepal leading into a discourse regarding the understanding and application of DNH in Nepal. Section five examines DNH training and is followed by a description of different approaches to conflict sensitivity and adaptations of DNH. Section nine explores the relevance of DNH in the new context of Nepal and the final section provides recommendations and areas for further inquiry. 2. Methodology This case study was developed in three phases. The first, in September 2006, included interviews with individuals and organizations in Katmandu, provided the researchers with a macro-view. During the researchers’ second visit, conducted in November and December 2006, the researchers accompanied CARE Nepal to project sites in the field, providing a micro-view of CARE’s use, application and uptake of DNH.1 Last, Peter Bauman remained in Nepal to complete an impact assessment of the UJYALO project, a major USAID funded peacebuilding and development project being implemented by Save the Children, CARE, International Development Enterprises, Winrock International, and the Asia Foundation in thirteen conflict-affected districts in Western Nepal. This experience enabled the researchers to triangulate their findings from the first two phases, adding depth and insight to the case study. 1The complete findings of the second phase of this research are available in an additional case study, “A Review of CARE Nepal's Use of the Do No Harm Framework-Executive Summary” www.cdainc.com 1 To understand and categorize the level of understanding and application of DNH, the researchers developed a framework that provides categories and indicators ranging from awareness, conceptualization and application to mainstreaming and knowledge management.2 Our aim was to understand the differing depths and breadths of understanding and application of the DNH
Load more

Recommended publications
  • NRNA Nepal Promotion Committee Overview
    NRNA Nepal Promotion Committee Overview Nepal is a landlocked country in South Asia. It is located mainly in the Himalayas but also includes parts of the Indo-Gangetic Plain. With an estimated population of 29.4 million, it is 48th largest country by population and 93rd largest country by area.[2][14] It borders China in the north and India in the south, east, and west. Nepal has a diverse geography, including fertile plains, subalpine forested hills, and eight of the world's ten tallest mountains, including Mount Everest, the highest point on Earth. Kathmandu is the nation's capital and largest city. The name "Nepal" is first recorded in texts from the Vedic Age, the era in which Hinduism was founded, the predominant religion of the country. In the middle of the first millennium BCE, Gautama Buddha, the founder of Buddhism, was born in southern Nepal. Parts of northern Nepal were intertwined with the culture of Tibet. The centrally located Kathmandu Valley was the seat of the prosperous Newar confederacy known as Nepal Mandala. The Himalayan branch of the ancient Silk Road was dominated by the valley's traders. The cosmopolitan region developed distinct traditional art and architecture. By the 18th century, the Gorkha Kingdom achieved the unification of Nepal. The Shah dynasty established the Kingdom of Nepal and later formed an alliance with the British Empire, under its Rana dynasty of premiers. The country was never colonised but served as a buffer state between Imperial China and colonial India. Parliamentary democracy was introduced in 1951, but was twice suspended by Nepalese monarchs, in 1960 and 2005.
    [Show full text]
  • The Abolition of Monarchy and Constitution Making in Nepal
    THE KING VERSUS THE PEOPLE（BHANDARI） Article THE KING VERSUS THE PEOPLE: THE ABOLITION OF MONARCHY AND CONSTITUTION MAKING IN NEPAL Surendra BHANDARI Abstract The abolition of the institution of monarchy on May 28, 2008 marks a turning point in the political and constitutional history of Nepal. This saga of constitutional development exemplifies the systemic conflict between people’s’ aspirations for democracy and kings’ ambitions for unlimited power. With the abolition of the monarchy, the process of making a new constitution for the Republic of Nepal has started under the auspices of the Constituent Assembly of Nepal. This paper primarily examines the reasons or causes behind the abolition of monarchy in Nepal. It analyzes the three main reasons for the abolition of monarchy. First, it argues that frequent slights and attacks to constitutionalism by the Nepalese kings had brought the institution of the monarchy to its end. The continuous failures of the early democratic government and the Supreme Court of Nepal in bringing the monarchy within the constitutional framework emphatically weakened the fledgling democracy, but these failures eventually became fatal to the monarchical institution itself. Second, it analyzes the indirect but crucial role of India in the abolition of monarchy. Third, it explains the ten-year-long Maoist insurgency and how the people’s movement culminated with its final blow to the monarchy. Furthermore, this paper also analyzes why the peace and constitution writing process has yet to take concrete shape or make significant process, despite the abolition of the monarchy. Finally, it concludes by recapitulating the main arguments of the paper.
    [Show full text]
  • Learning to Be Refugees: the Bhutanese in Nepal and Australia
    Learning to be Refugees: The Bhutanese in Nepal and Australia Alice Marie Neikirk December 2015 A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of The Australian National University. ii I hereby certify that this is a piece of original work, produced solely by the author. Alice Marie Neikirk 21 December 2015 iii iv Acknowledgements In memory of Cynthia Jane Neikirk This thesis would not have been possible without Dr Patrick Guinness’s steadfast guidance. His faith, not only that this thesis would be completed but his insistence that it could be improved, strengthened, and honed saw me through many dark days. He consistently challenged me to critically analyse many things that I would have been overlooked in my exuberance for fieldwork. Further, he patiently allowed a toddler to run wild in his office when I needed to meet but could not arrange childcare. Thank you for guiding me through the ethnographic process. The two members of my panel, Dr Francesca Merlan and Dr Sverre Molland, provided guidance at crucial junctures of the thesis. Francesca provided key feedback early in the writing process, reminding me that description is only one part of ethnographic writing. Sverre recommended a text that proved invaluable and fundamentally changed the direction of the thesis. Christina Alexander, Professor Emeritus, also deserves a special mention for introducing me to what would become my life’s passion: anthropology. Dr. Fiona McCormack further challenged me to focus that passion by critically engaging with anthropological theory. The people that shared their time, stories, and experiences with me both in Nepal and Australia are too numerous to list.
    [Show full text]
  • India Nepal Relations V India Nepal Relations Vis a Vis Madhesi Issue
    International Research Journal of Social Sciences___________________________________ ___ ISSN 2319–3565 Vol. 8(3), 50-53, July (2019) Int. Res. J. Social Sci. Short Review Paper India Nepal relations vis a vis Madhesi issue Lubina Sarwar University of Kashmir, India [email protected] Available online at: www.isca.in, www.isca.me Received 27 th November 2018, revised 25 th April 2019, accepted 29 th June 2019 Abstract India and Nepal share a unique relationship of friendship characterized by geographical contiguity, extensive socio - institutional relationships, along with it the common bond of a shared religion, common civilizational heritage, ethnic similarities and socio-cultural affinities have a great influence on bilateral relations. The ethnic similarity has been a cementing factor in bilateral relations, but post -2015 this is becoming a major irritant in relations. It is in this context that the study explores the Madhesi factor in India -Nepal relations and its impact on bilateral relations. Keywords : India, Madhesi, Ethnic, Nepal, blockade . Introduction Tharu (6.6%), Tamang (5.8%), Newar (5%) , Muslim (4.2%), Kami (4.8%), Yadav (4%) 6. They are all Indo -Aryan groups in India and Nepal are probably the closest neighbors in the world Nepal and are simultaneously found in east and south India. So who share huge similarities in terms of common civilizational Nepal’s predominant population is ethnically from the same heritage, geographical proximity, socio-cultural affinities, and group as Indian’s. 1 common bond of a shared religion making relationship unique . The open border between India and Nepal has facilitated Nepal a small landlocked Himalayan country sandwiched continuity and strengthened the ancient friendly bonds bet ween between India and China, surrounded by India to the east west the two countries.
    [Show full text]
  • India's Role in the Post-War Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal
    HIMALAYA, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies Volume 33 Number 1 Article 7 March 2014 Searching For Security: India’s Role in the Post-War Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal Liam D. Anderson Sciences Po, Paris, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/himalaya Recommended Citation Anderson, Liam D.. 2014. Searching For Security: India’s Role in the Post-War Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal. HIMALAYA 33(1). Available at: https://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/himalaya/vol33/iss1/7 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. This Research Article is brought to you for free and open access by the DigitalCommons@Macalester College at DigitalCommons@Macalester College. It has been accepted for inclusion in HIMALAYA, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Macalester College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Searching For Security: India’s Role in the Post-War Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal Acknowledgements I would like to express my thanks to Himalaya’s editors, anonymous reviewers, Dr Frederic Grare, and my family for their comments and help with writing this paper. This research article is available in HIMALAYA, the Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies: https://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/himalaya/vol33/iss1/7 Searching for Security: India’s Role in the Post-War Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal Liam Anderson This article aims to analyse New Delhi’s role In the post-war period Nepal faces many in post-war Nepal, understood as part of its challenges, chief among which are the ever search for security in its periphery.
    [Show full text]
  • View Article – Britain’S Gurkha War 64 Book Reviews 69 Obituaries 78 Useful Addresses 79 Notes on the Britain – Nepal Society 80 Officers and Committee of the Society
    G Birch Britain-Nepal Society Journal cover 2016 48396_Layout 1 05/10/2017 13:47 Page 1 THE BRITAIN-NEPAL SOCIETY J o u r n a l Number 40 2016 Printed by HARTS Design & Print T: 01799 510101 www.hartsdirect.co.uk G Birch Britain-Nepal Society 2016 48396_Layout 1 19/06/2017 13:40 Page 1 THE BRITAIN-NEPAL SOCIETY J o u r n a l Number 40 2016 CONTENTS 2 Editorial 4 The Society’s News 8 200 Years of UK – Nepal Relations 19 The Genealogies of the Shah, Rana and related Families 26 Social Mobility of Nepalis in the UK: A Case Study of Fairfax Road, Farnborough 32 ZSL Conservation & Biodiversity Symposium 26 Feb 16 38 The Golden Jubilee of Trekking in Nepal 42 The Gurkha Everest Expedition 45 MCC v Nepal at Lord’s Tuesday 19 July 47 Not Your Average Holiday – WaterAid in Nepal 53 From the Editor’s In-Tray 58 Review Article – Britain’s Gurkha War 64 Book Reviews 69 Obituaries 78 Useful addresses 79 Notes on the Britain – Nepal Society 80 Officers and Committee of the Society 1 G Birch Britain-Nepal Society 2016 48396_Layout 1 19/06/2017 13:40 Page 2 EDITORIAL Firstly I must apologise to members for the their team. The match was very well late publishing of this edition of the journal. supported by Nepalese living in London and close by, as some 5,000 were admitted. I have been more than usually dilatory and This is well above the support normally circumstances beyond my control have also afforded to such events.
    [Show full text]
  • Transition of Nepal from Monarchy to Democracy
    IOSR Journal Of Humanities And Social Science (IOSR-JHSS) Volume 23, Issue 2, Ver. 12 (February. 2018) PP 22-27 e-ISSN: 2279-0837, p-ISSN: 2279-0845. www.iosrjournals.org Transition of Nepal From Monarchy To Democracy Harsimran Kaur Research Scholar, Department of Defence & Strategic Studies, Punjabi University Patiala Corresponding Author: Harsimran Kaur Abstract: Nepal is the mid-Himalayan country of South Asia and has its border with India on the South, East & West and China on the North. They are interrelated with each other by all measures, including geography, ethnicity, language, religion, and caste. The two countries not only share an open border and unhindered movement of people but they also have close bonds through marriages and familial ties, which is unique in Asia. They share a long standing, cordial and multi-faceted relationship based on mutual respect and understanding, characterised by open borders, deep-rooted people-to-people contacts and extensive cooperation. Both countries are bound by ancient history, geography, culture, religion and shared values. This present paper is a small effort towards analysing the transition of Nepal from the period of Kingdom to democracy. This paper is an attempt to understand the domestic political scenario that Nepal has experienced with major turmoil and transformation both in the nature of political system as well as in the character of the government. Keywords: Constitution, Democracy, Kingdom, Monarchy, Transition, South Asia. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------- Date of Submission: 14-02-2018 Date of acceptance: 01-03-2018 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------- I. INTRODUCTION Nepal is a mid-sized South Asian nation neighboring India and China. It is a greatly dissimilar to other countries by all its measures, including geography, ethnicity, language, religion, and caste.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal.Pdf 38 Cleanairnet.Org
    Table of Contents Geography ____________________________________________________________ 4 Introduction _______________________________________________________________ 4 Climate ___________________________________________________________________ 7 Rivers ____________________________________________________________________ 8 Cities _____________________________________________________________________ 9 Population 2001 ____________________________________________________________ 9 Environmental Concerns____________________________________________________ 12 Natural Hazards___________________________________________________________ 14 History ______________________________________________________________ 15 Introduction ______________________________________________________________ 15 Ancient History ___________________________________________________________ 15 The Medieval Period _______________________________________________________ 16 The Modern Period ________________________________________________________ 18 Recent Events _____________________________________________________________ 29 Economy_____________________________________________________________ 30 Introduction ______________________________________________________________ 30 Industry and Manufacturing ________________________________________________ 30 Agriculture _______________________________________________________________ 32 Banking and Currency _____________________________________________________ 33 Trade ____________________________________________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • Water Nepal: a Historical Perspective
    Water Nepal: A Historical Perspective GWP Nepal/ Jalsrot Vikas Sanstha (JVS) September, 2018 Water Nepal: A Historical Perspective, 2018 Disclaimer The findings, interpretations and conclusions expressed herein are those of the author (s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the institutions. Water Nepal: A Historical Perspective, 2018 Table of Contents Preface ............................................................................................................................................................... 8 CHAPTER-I ........................................................................................................................................................ 11 HISTORY OF DRINKING WATER SYSTEM: TRADITION, DEVELOPMENT AND PARTNERS IN PROGRESS ........... 11 Acronyms ......................................................................................................................................................... 12 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................ 15 Water: Socio-Economic Culture ................................................................................................................... 15 1. Drinking Water Harvesting and Management Tradition in Nepal ....................................................... 15 1.1 Kirat Period (200-800 B.C.) ............................................................................................................... 16 1.2 Lichhavi Period (300-800
    [Show full text]
  • Sikkim University
    The Madheshi Question in Nepal: Implications for India-Nepal Relations A Dissertation Submitted To Sikkim University In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Philosophy By Rasik Rai Department of International Relations School of Social Sciences February 2017 Gangtok 737102 INDIA ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A note of gratitude to a number of people, whose genuine support and encouragements made this dissertation a successful work. The dissertation began and ended with the dedicated guidance and enormous help of my supervisor Mr. Ph. Newton Singh. Sir, without whom it would be almost impossible for the completion of the same. I would like to express my heartiest thankfulness and acknowledge him for the guidance and enduring support he bestowed upon me throughout. I also express my sincere thanks to the faculty members of my Department (International Relations), Dr. Manish, Dr. Teiborlang and Dr. Sebastian N. for their valuable suggestions. One of the major resources throughout the dissertation writing has been the library of Sikkim University and Central Library of Sikkim. Therefore, I am thankful to all the concerned authorities of these libraries who provided me access to the library and procure relevant materials during the course of my research. In the end, I extend my thanks to the entire family members especially papa, friends and relatives who believed on me. It was indeed their constant support, encouragement and patience which contributed at large in the process of this research. Rasik Rai Lists of Abbreviation
    [Show full text]
  • An Investigation Into the Gurkhas' Position in The
    THE WAY OF THE GURKHA: AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE GURKHAS’ POSITION IN THE BRITISH ARMY Thesis submitted to Kingston University in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Mulibir Rai Faculty of Arts and Social Science Kingston University 2018 1 2 CONTENTS The thesis contains: Documentary: The Way of the Gurkha Script/Director/Presenter/Editor/Cinematographer: Mulibir Rai Cast: Mulibir Rai, Karan Rai, Sarbada Rai, Deshu Rai, Shanta Maya Limbu, Kesharbahadur Rai, Yamkumar Rai, Dipendra Rai, Rastrakumar Rai, Bambahadur Thapa, Tiloksing Rai, Lt Col JNB Birch, Maj R Anderson, Gajendra K.C, Sophy Rai, Chandra Subba Gurung, Lt Col (retired) J. P. Cross, Major (retired) Tikendradal Dewan, Gyanraj Rai, Padam Gurung, D.B. Rai, Recruit intake 2012. Genre: Documentary Run time: 1:33:26 Medium: High definition Synopsis – The documentary is divided into two parts. In the first part, the researcher, in 2012 returned to his village of Chautara in Eastern Nepal where he was born, raised and educated for the first time in 13 years. He found many changes in the village - mainly in transport and information technology, but no improvement in the standard of English teaching which nowadays, unlike in the past, is one of the necessities required for joining the British Army. Hence, the hillboys pay a significant amount of money to the training academies in the cities to improve their English. In the end, only a few out of thousands of candidates achieve success. They fly to the UK and receive nine months training at Catterick Garrison Training Centre before joining their respective regiments as fully-fledged Gurkha soldiers.
    [Show full text]
  • Selective Exclusion: Foreigners, Foreign Goods, and Foreignness in Modern Nepali History
    SELECTIVE EXCLUSION: FOREIGNERS, FOREIGN GOODS, AND FOREIGNNESS IN MODERN NEPALI HISTORY Mark Liechty [B]efore now there were no European things in Nepal. Now, thanks to you, there are things and there are Padres. Since the Padres have given help to my subjects and made the people very happy, we are looking after the Padres as much as possible. In addition, send here for the things that you have not got there, and I will send there for the things that I have not got here. You must not have any anxiety about affairs here. You are my friend. I will do all I can. Also, there are no good doctors here. You must send me from there a good doctor and a good craftsman. - Ranjit Malla, King of Bhadgaon to Pope Benedict XIV, September 7, 1744 (Vannini 1977:55) Muglan [Mughal north India] is near. In that place there are singers and dancers. In rooms lined with paintings, they forget themselves in melodies woven on the drum and sitar. There is great pleasure in these melodies. But it drains your wealth. They take away the secrets of your country and deceive the poor… . Let no one open the mountain trails for these classes of people. - Prithvi Narayan Shah in his Dibya Upadesh, 1774 (Stiller 1968:46) How … will the English be able to penetrate into the hills? … [W]e will expel them… . [O]ur hills and fastnesses are impregnable. I, therefore, recommend hostilities. We can make peace afterwards on such terms as may suit our convenience. - Bhim Sen Thapa to his advisors on the eve of the Anglo-Nepali War, 1814 (Chaudhuri 1960:165) I am convinced that the prosperity of Nepal is bound up with the maintenance of British predominance in India, and I am determined that the sahib who is no sahib shall never enter Nepal, and weaken my people's belief that every Englishman is a gentleman.
    [Show full text]