Visual Impacts (Scenario 1) B PVSR 1.3 VSR 1.1 LEGEND Construction Operation Construction Operation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PVSR 1.3 VSR 1.1 LEGEND Construction Operation Construction Operation Substantial Substantial Insubstantial Insubstantial Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Unmitigated Project Site Boundary VSR 1.2 Moderate Insubstantial Mitigated Slight Adverse Mitigated Insubstantial Adverse (Year 10) (Year 10) VSR1.1 Construction Operation VSR 4.6 Substantial Substantial Visual Envelope Construction Operation Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Slight Slight Moderate Slight Adverse Unmitigated Mitigated Adverse Adverse VSR1.2 Adverse (Year 10) VSR1 Major Visually Sensitive Receiver Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial (VSR) and angle of main views (Year 10) VSR 4.5 VSR 1.4 Construction Operation Construction Operation A Slight Slight VSR4.6 H Slight Slight Photomontage Viewpoints Unmitigated +5.3mPD +83.3mPD Unmitigated Adverse Adverse A Adverse Adverse VSR 2.1 PVSR1.3 Footpath near Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial +17mPD Tycoon Place Mitigated Insubstantial Construction Operation (Year 10) (Year 10) Visually Sensitive Receivers G +37.2mPD +15.5mPD Substantial Substantial VSR 4.3 +6.2mPD B Unmitigated VSR1.4 Adverse Adverse Students and Staff of The Education Construction Operation Fortune Garden VSR 1.1 VSR 4.7 VSR4.5 I VSR2.1 Moderate Slight Adverse +9.8mPD (+42.2mPD) VSR2.2 Mitigated University of Hong Kong Slight Slight VSR4.7 Adverse (Year 10) Unmitigated Construction Operation VSR 2.2 Adverse Adverse VSR 1.2 Residents of low-rises along Lo Moderate Moderate Construction Operation Insubstantial C VSR2.3 Fai Road Mitigated Insubstantial Unmitigated Adverse Adverse The Project +7.1mPD (Year 10) Substantial Substantial Slight Insubstantial Tai Po Shuen Wan Typhoon Unmitigated Adverse Adverse PVSR 1.3 Residents of Planned low-rises Mitigated Site Adverse (Year 10) Industrial +15.4mPD Shelter Breakwater along Lo Fai Road Estate +9.95mPD Moderate Slight Adverse VSR 4.1 Mitigated (Year 10) +19.1mPD Adverse VSR 1.4 Pedestrians / Cyclists / Vehicular Construction Operation VSR4.4 +12.6mPD +9.95mPD VSR4.3 travellers along Ting Kok Road Slight Slight Tai Po VSR 2.3 Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Waterfront Park F VSR 2.1 Residents of Fortune Garden VSR4.8 +5.4mPD Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial VSR 2.2 Residents of The Beverly Hills (Year 10) E Slight Slight +10mPD VSR 4.4 Unmitigated Adverse Adverse VSR 2.3 Villagers at Sam Mun Tsai Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial VSR4.2 VSR4.1 VSR 4.8 (Year 10) VSR 3.1 Visitors to Ma On Shan Promenade Slight Slight and Ma On Shan Park Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Construction Operation VSR 3.2 Residents of high-rises along Ma Insubstantial Slight Slight VSR 3.5 VSR 4.2 Mitigated Insubstantial Unmitigated (Year 10) Adverse Adverse On Shan Promenade Construction Operation Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial VSR 3.3 Workers of Hong Kong Science Park (Year 10) Slight Slight Slight Slight Unmitigated Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Adverse Adverse VSR 3.4 Residents of Pak Shek Kok Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Promenade Mitigated Insubstantial Tolo Highway (Year 10) (Year 10) VSR 3.5 Pedestrians / Cyclists along Tolo Tolo Harbour VSR 3.6 Harbour Tai Po Kau D VSR3.5 +5.7mPD Construction Operation VSR 3.6 Residents of low-rises along Yau Slight Slight King Lane Unmitigated Adverse Adverse VSR 3.7 Residents of low-rises along Yat Insubstantial VSR 3.4 VSR 3.1 Mitigated Insubstantial Yiu Avenue, Hung Lam Drive and (Year 10) Construction Operation Construction Operation VSR3.7 Tai Po Kau Slight Slight Slight Slight Unmitigated Unmitigated VSR 4.1 Visitors of Yuen Chau Tsai Park VSR3.4 Adverse Adverse Adverse Adverse VSR3.6 VSR 4.2 Residents of high-rises at Kwong Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial (Year 10) (Year 10) Fuk Estate and Wang Fuk Court VSR 4.3 Residents of high-rises at Fu VSR 3.3 Shin Estate, Ming Nga Court Construction Operation and Riviera Lodge Slight Slight VSR 4.4 Visitors of Tai Po Waterfront Park VSR 3.7 Pak Shek Kok Unmitigated VSR3.3 Adverse Adverse VSR3.1 Construction Operation Promenade VSR 4.5 Workers of Tai Po Industrial Estate Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Slight Slight (Year 10) VSR 4.6 Residents at Ha Hang Village Unmitigated Adverse Adverse and Casa Brava Insubstantial Ma On Shan Mitigated Insubstantial VSR 4.7 Workers of Tai Po Sewage (Year 10) VSR3.2 Treatment Works VSR 3.2 VSR 4.8 Visitors of Tai Po Waterfront Pier Construction Operation Slight Slight Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Landscape Impact Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial (Year 10) VSR Construction Operation Substantial Moderate Unmitigated Adverse Adverse 0 200 400 1000m Slight Insubstantial Mitigated Adverse (Year 10) SCALE As Shown DATE MAR 2019 ADI LIMITED LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, URBAN DESIGN AND MASTER PLANNING Shuen Wan Golf Course, Tai Po 10/F BANGKOK BANK BUILDING, 18 BONHAM STRAND WEST, HONG KONG CHECKED ELK DRAWN TEAM TELEPHONE 2131 8630 FACSIMILE 2131 8609 雅博奧頓國際設計有限公司 FIGURE NO. REV 國際環境管理, 城市規劃及設計, 園景建築顧問服務 香港上環文咸西街十八號盤谷銀行大廈十樓 Figure 12.10.1 電話 : (八 五 二 ) 二 一 三 一 八 六 三 零 傳真 : (八 五 二 ) 二 一 三 一 八 六 零 九 Visual Impacts (Scenario 1) B PVSR 1.3 VSR 1.1 LEGEND Construction Operation Construction Operation Substantial Substantial Insubstantial Insubstantial Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Unmitigated Project Site Boundary VSR 1.2 Moderate Insubstantial Mitigated Slight Adverse Mitigated Insubstantial Adverse (Year 10) (Year 10) VSR1.1 Construction Operation VSR 4.6 Substantial Substantial Visual Envelope Construction Operation Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Slight Slight Moderate Slight Adverse Unmitigated Mitigated Adverse Adverse VSR1.2 Adverse (Year 10) VSR1 Major Visually Sensitive Receiver Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial (VSR) and angle of main views (Year 10) VSR 4.5 VSR 1.4 Construction Operation Construction Operation A Slight Slight VSR4.6 H Slight Slight Photomontage Viewpoints Unmitigated +5.3mPD +83.3mPD Unmitigated Adverse Adverse A Adverse Adverse VSR 2.1 PVSR1.3 Footpath near Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial +17mPD Tycoon Place Mitigated Insubstantial Construction Operation (Year 10) (Year 10) Visually Sensitive Receivers G +37.2mPD +15.5mPD Substantial Substantial VSR 4.3 +6.2mPD B Unmitigated VSR1.4 Adverse Adverse Students and Staff of The Education Construction Operation Fortune Garden VSR 1.1 VSR 4.7 VSR4.5 I VSR2.1 Moderate Slight Adverse +9.8mPD (+42.2mPD) VSR2.2 Mitigated University of Hong Kong Slight Slight VSR4.7 Adverse (Year 10) Unmitigated Construction Operation VSR 2.2 Adverse Adverse VSR 1.2 Residents of low-rises along Lo Moderate Moderate Construction Operation Insubstantial C VSR2.3 Fai Road Mitigated Insubstantial Unmitigated Adverse Adverse The Project +7.1mPD (Year 10) Substantial Substantial Slight Insubstantial Tai Po Shuen Wan Typhoon Unmitigated Adverse Adverse PVSR 1.3 Residents of Planned low-rises Mitigated Site Adverse (Year 10) Industrial +15.4mPD Shelter Breakwater along Lo Fai Road Moderate Slight Adverse VSR 4.1 Estate +9.95mPD Mitigated +19.1mPD PVSR 3.8 Adverse (Year 10) Pedestrians / Cyclists / Vehicular Construction Operation VSR4.4 VSR 1.4 VSR4.3 +12.6mPD +9.95mPD Construction Operation PVSR3.8 travellers along Ting Kok Road Slight Slight Tai Po Not Moderate VSR 2.3 Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Waterfront Park Unmitigated F Applicable Adverse VSR 2.1 Residents of Fortune Garden VSR4.8 +5.4mPD Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Not Insubstantial VSR 2.2 Residents of The Beverly Hills (Year 10) E Mitigated Slight Slight +10mPD VSR 4.4 Applicable (Year 10) Unmitigated Adverse Adverse VSR 2.3 Villagers at Sam Mun Tsai Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial VSR4.2 VSR4.1 VSR 4.8 (Year 10) VSR 3.1 Visitors to Ma On Shan Promenade Slight Slight and Ma On Shan Park Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Construction Operation VSR 3.2 Residents of high-rises along Ma Insubstantial Slight Slight VSR 3.5 VSR 4.2 Mitigated Insubstantial Unmitigated (Year 10) Adverse Adverse On Shan Promenade Construction Operation Construction Operation Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial VSR 3.3 Workers of Hong Kong Science Park (Year 10) Slight Slight Slight Slight Unmitigated Unmitigated Adverse Adverse Adverse Adverse VSR 3.4 Residents of Pak Shek Kok Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Promenade Mitigated Insubstantial Tolo Highway (Year 10) (Year 10) VSR 3.5 Pedestrians / Cyclists along Tolo Tolo Harbour VSR 3.6 Harbour Tai Po Kau D VSR3.5 +5.7mPD Construction Operation VSR 3.6 Residents of low-rises along Yau Slight Slight King Lane Unmitigated Adverse Adverse VSR 3.7 Residents of low-rises along Yat Insubstantial VSR 3.4 VSR 3.1 Mitigated Insubstantial Yiu Avenue, Hung Lam Drive and (Year 10) Construction Operation Construction Operation VSR3.7 Tai Po Kau Slight Slight Slight Slight Unmitigated Unmitigated Staff at planned quarters / guests at VSR3.4 Adverse Adverse Adverse Adverse PVSR 3.8 VSR3.6 planned overnight accommodation Insubstantial Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial (Year 10) (Year 10) VSR 4.1 Visitors of Yuen Chau Tsai Park VSR 4.2 Residents of high-rises at Kwong VSR 3.3 Fuk Estate and Wang Fuk Court Construction Operation VSR 4.3 Residents of high-rises at Fu Slight Slight VSR 3.7 Pak Shek Kok Unmitigated Shin Estate, Ming Nga Court VSR3.3 Adverse Adverse VSR3.1 Construction Operation Promenade and Riviera Lodge Insubstantial Mitigated Insubstantial Slight Slight (Year 10) VSR 4.4 Visitors of Tai Po Waterfront Park Unmitigated