Civil Society and Civil Discourse: Eloquence and Hope in The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CIVIL SOCIETY AND CIVIL DISCOURSE: ELOQUENCE AND HOPE IN THE COMMUNICATIONS OF PRESIDENTS ABRAHAM LINCOLN, FRANKLIN D. ROOSEVELT, AND BARACK OBAMA A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIRMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE TEXAS WOMAN’S UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH, SPEECH, AND FOREIGN LANGUAGES COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES BY MARSHA DECKER B.A., M.A. DENTON, TEXAS May 2020 Copyright © 2020 by Marsha Decker DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to my wonderful family. To my children, Kathrine and Tristan, who convinced me that it was never too late to go back to school. To my wonderful daughter-in-law, Qiong, who inspired me with her quiet grace as she completed her own Ph.D. And most of all, I would like to thank my amazing husband, Randy. Thank you for never losing faith in me and my abilities and for going above and beyond to help me make my dreams come true. Randy, you are my love, my rock, and my life, always and forever. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my dissertation chair, Dr. Brian Fehler, and my committee members, Dr. Phyllis Bridges and Dr. Graham Scott, for their guidance and support. Thank you, Dr. Fehler, for your enthusiasm for my topic and your never-ending patience with all of my emails. My deepest thanks to Tarleton State University’s Director of Composition, Dr. Kathleen Mollick for acting as my sounding board during all of our late afternoon coffee breaks. I could not have done this without your support. I would also like to thank Tarleton State University’s Dr. Mallory Young for encouraging me to pursue my doctorate. Thank you for believing in me even when I could not believe in myself. Thank you also to Dr. Jeanelle Barrett, the Department Head of English and Languages at Tarleton State University for your unwavering support and encouragement. I would also like to thank Dr. Julie Chappell and Mr. Hank Jones for your moral support and for encouraging my love of all things Literature. I am forever indebted to Dr. Ben Sword for the countless hours spent in your office discussing the doctorial experience. Your support and willingness to share your own experiences with your Ph.D. studies was often a shining beacon in a world of darkness. iii Special thanks go to Mr. Paul Juhasz who started me on this path when you encouraged me to reach for the stars. I am forever grateful for your never-ending support and faith in me as a student and as an individual. Walking into your Freshman English Composition class so long ago, literally changed my life for the better. Last but by no means least, thank you to my colleagues and friends at Tarleton State University, North Central Texas College, and Cayuga Community College for their patience and understanding during the long journey towards my Doctorate. iv ABSTRACT MARSHA DECKER CIVIL SOCIETY AND CIVIL DISCOURSE: ELOQUENCE AND HOPE IN THE COMMUNICATIONS OF PRESIDENTS ABRAHAM LINCOLN, FRANKLIN D. ROOSEVELT, AND BARACK OBAMA MAY 2020 During times of difficulty, Americans traditionally turn towards the President for guidance and leadership. The trope of hope is a critical part of achieving these goals. Hope is the attitude of mind that is based on the expectation that something positive can happen in relation to one’s life, community, or the world at large. During times of crisis, hope can unite the population, encourage new possibilities, and effect change. Through the decades, presidential speeches have tended to posit an epideictic ideal: eloquent expressions meant to bring a diverse citizenry an ideal, if not reality, of unity. The American presidents Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and Barack Obama each combined elements of taste, common sense, sympathy, propriety— and hope to posit an epideictic ideal: eloquent expressions meant to bring a diverse citizenry an ideal, if not reality, of unity. Each of these presidents’ style responded to the public values and political shifts of their time to encourage public trust and civil discourse. This study examines how civil discourse is essential to civil society and argues that a) United States presidents have practiced Stoic principles of rhetoric to unify the v American people, a practice that is understudied, and b) United States presidents have altered and extended those principles to allow room for appeals based on hope. The study situates presidential rhetoric within the larger context of classical rhetoric and Stoicism. This study analyzes several speeches from each of the selected presidents and draws upon PAC to show how these hopeful speeches have worked to evoke a sense of community and purpose for Americans. Lincoln, Roosevelt, and Obama combined the eloquence of clarity and coherence in speech, moral dignity in conduct of character and warmth of personality to advance their visions of civic unity during times of crisis. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page DEDICATION ............................................................................................................... ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................... iii ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................v TABLE OF CONTENTS .............................................................................................. vii Chapter I. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................1 Background ........................................................................................................1 The Problem .......................................................................................................3 Scope ...................................................................................................................4 Method and Literature Review .........................................................................5 Chapter Outline ............................................................................................... 16 II. THE GREAT EMANCIPATOR: ABRAHAM LINCOLN ........................................ 19 Lincoln the Orator ........................................................................................... 20 Lincoln’s Background ...................................................................................... 24 Young Abe ............................................................................................ 24 Lincoln’s Education .............................................................................. 25 Lincoln the Lawyer ............................................................................... 28 Lincoln’s Historical and Political Context ...................................................... 30 Entry into Politics ................................................................................. 30 A House Divided ................................................................................... 32 Rising Tide ............................................................................................ 35 Rhetorical Analysis of Lincoln’s Speeches ...................................................... 37 Cooper Union Address ......................................................................... 38 First Inaugural Address ....................................................................... 45 Gettysburg Address .............................................................................. 51 Second Inaugural Address ................................................................... 56 Conclusion ............................................................................................ 65 III. THE NEW DEALER: FRANKLIN DELANO ROOSEVELT ................................. 67 vii Roosevelt the Orator ........................................................................................ 69 Roosevelt’s Background................................................................................... 74 Childhood.............................................................................................. 74 Education .............................................................................................. 75 Roosevelt’s Historical and Political Context ................................................... 78 Entry into Political Life ........................................................................ 78 FDR and Polio ...................................................................................... 81 The Great Depression ........................................................................... 83 Rhetorical Analysis of Roosevelt’s Speeches ................................................... 84 First Inaugural Address ....................................................................... 85 The Four Freedoms Speech .................................................................. 91 The Day of Infamy Speech ................................................................... 97 Conclusion .......................................................................................... 101 IV. YES WE CAN: BARACK OBAMA ..................................................................... 103 Obama the Orator .......................................................................................... 104 Obama’s Background .................................................................................... 112 Childhood...........................................................................................